When Nice Lawyers Get In Trouble
Things like this don't happen to lawyers like us, I was told.
And even if they thought it might, it's not like they or their companies would be willing to commit and any time, effort or, most importantly, money to preparation. They were in the business of making money, not spending it. It was bad enough that the GC wasn't a profit center; as if they could budget more money in anticipation of problems that nice lawyers never face. Ain't happening.
At Above the Law, David Mowry wrote a post abut Lauren Stevens, an in-house counsel at GlaxoSmithKline.
As one might expect, they trip all over themselves to curry favor with the government when they think it's someone else's butt on the line. It could never be theirs, because, well, they're the good guys. They help the government. And they never do anything that would turn their dear friends on them. Never.
Ms. Stevens was not the VP of legal affairs, she was one of many. Just like all those financial “VPs” on the prowl in Wall Street bars. She received a subpoena-like request from a department within the FDA that has no subpoena power. The request asked 15 broad questions, and GSK agreed to comply.
Now, in-house is a bit different than Biglaw in that we don’t immediately start to figure out how to fight or quash such requests. I receive subpoenas all the time, and it’s usually no big deal. We’ll do a risk analysis for the company, and most times the subpoena only tangentially involves us, and we’ll agree to comply. I will call up the AUSA, or other relevant contact, and ask how we can assist. Often, they want some documentation regarding a fraud investigation or illegal exportation practices by a third party. We have an interest in stopping such practices due to the implications for the company, so we readily agree to assist.
Lauren Stevens became a target. She was indicted. She was tried. To this day, she doesn't seem to have a firm grasp why. This video of her discussing the case, starting around 23:00, is painful. Things like this don't happen to nice, helpful lawyers.
So let’s review. She responded positively and diligently to the inquiry. She put together a crack team of attorneys and outside counsel to assist in responding. She maintained open lines of communication with the agency. And when mistakes were discovered, they were disclosed, rectified, and steps were taken to avoid the same mistakes occurring. What happened next is not only frightening, but wrong and unjust.
The naïveté is just brutal. In a WSJ Law Blog interview, Stevens called it the criminalization of the practice of law. We call it house counsel, used in the pejorative sense of a John Gotti and Bruce Cutler. When lawyers are working for the target company, doing the target's bidding, spouting the targets line, but believe that the lines of corporate liability don't spill onto their desk. They are not detached lawyers. They are house counsel for the target. But bad things never happen to nice lawyers.
Fortunately, Lauren Stevens was acquitted after trial, a fact she remarkably takes for granted as if there was never any question she would win because she, as she says, did nothing wrong. The judge didn't toss the indictment. There was no trial order of dismissal at the close of the prosecution's case. These things don't seem to find their way into her consciousness. She was acquitted when the judge refused to let the case go to the jury. Had it gone to the jury, she could have been convicted just as easily, though she shows no recognition of that possibility. Because bad things like that never happen to nice lawyers.
Lauren Stevens was utterly unprepared for what happened to her. David Mowry shows no clue of being prepared. My guess is none of the nice, in-house lawyers, or their corporate executive charges, have lifted a finger to be prepared. And I'm pretty sure that most still have their bestest friends, the U.S Attorney, on speed dial.
It's not like I didn't warn you. So are you going to mend your ways now? I didn't think so. Just complain about the unfairness of it all, like the rest of our clients.