A Bad Day in Prairie Grove

Attorney Eric D. Puryear was just a passenger in a car passing through Prairie Grove, Illinois, when the pickup in which he and his family were traveling was stopped by Officer James G. Page. His day got worse.


In October 2012, my wife, our daughter, and I flew from Iowa to McHenry, IL, in order to attend a birthday party and spend time with my wife’s family. As we were headed back to the airport, we drove through Prairie Grove, IL. I was seated in the front passenger seat of my brother-in-law’s pickup truck, which he was driving. My wife was seated behind me, and our daughter was in a car seat behind my brother-in-law. A Prairie Grove, Illinois Police Officer named James G. Page, Badge Number 8227, stopped the vehicle and claimed that he saw me not wearing my seatbelt. I was most certainly wearing my seatbelt, as I always do when in a vehicle (I’m a very safety-conscious person).

After running my ID, Officer Page returned it to me and began walking back to his vehicle, ending the traffic stop. I politely asked Officer Page for his name and badge number, as I wished to address this improper stop with the Village of Prairie Grove. In response, Officer Page demanded my ID again, stated that he would write me a ticket with his name and badge number written on that ticket, and proceeded to do exactly that. Myself, my wife, and my brother-in-law all observed that I was wearing my seatbelt throughout the trip in my brother-in-law’s truck.
Puryear beat the rap, but had a heck of a time on the ride.


Through Freedom of Information Act requests, I eventually obtained video from Officer Page’s squad car, which revealed that he pulled over several Ford pickup trucks in a row, as if he were looking for someone in particular and using pretextual reasons like a supposed missing seatbelt as an excuse for the traffic stops. I say that I “eventually” obtained that video, as the Village of Prairie Grove initially tried to say that it was unavailable due to an “error,” and it took my submission of multiple Freedom of Information Act requests to finally obtain that video. In court and under oath, Officer Page later admitted that he wrote me the ticket as retaliation for my request for his name and badge number.
As Puryear believed this to be part of a larger problem with Page and the Prairie Grove police, he started a Facebook page about it:


Officer James Page has attempted to have Facebook remove the Prairie Grove Justice Facebook page that I created. This is one of many attempts that Officer Page has made to block my right to free speech and to attempt to stop my firm from providing free legal representation to those who he has wrongfully stopped. As expected, Facebook denied Officer Page’s meritless request. More information, including the emails between Officer Page and Facebook, can be seen here: http://www.pgjustice.com/facebook.html
And now, Puryear has decided to make this a cause.


At Puryear Law P.C. we have decided to handle Prairie Grove, IL matters (and Bull Valley, IL matters involving Officer James G. Page) on a pro bono (free) basis, in situations where a person has been wrongfully ticketed, charged, or had their civil rights violated. We cannot handle every case for free, and therefore select the cases where we believe our time is best spent to seek justice. Should your case be selected, Puryear Law P.C. will represent you without charging you legal fees for our services.

About five years ago, I wrote about how the same things that happen to other people  suddenly become real when they happen to you. Now that Eric Puryear has felt the sting of a false accusation, the smack of a cop who didn’t care for his failure to respect his authority, he has decided to do something about it. Good for him.

Some of the reactions to this have been less supportive.  After all, it was just a seat belt ticket, for crying out loud, not a killing or even a beating.  He didn’t spend days in jail, no less years in prison, for a lie.  And this is true, in the scheme of bad things that can happen at the hands of cops, this barely makes a ripple.

But as Amy Bach pointed out in Ordinary Injustice, it’s the little things, the millions of little injustices, that have made us “so accustomed to a pattern of lapses that they can no longer see their role in them.”  Maybe Puryear saw them before, but it’s different when it happens to you. The little thing wasn’t so little anymore.

Just as every prosecutor should spend some time in jail to appreciate what it means when she argues for the need to imprison someone, and every judge so she knows the suffering of the sentence, maybe every defense lawyer should be both the victim of a crime and the victim of police misconduct and lies, so we can know what our clients know. Eric Puryear now knows the feeling, and it has moved him to act.

Sure, this may not be the biggest instance of impropriety, or the worst pain inflicted by a cop on an undeserving person. But every bit of extra effort in the fight helps. By channeling his frustration into pro bono representation of people who had their rights violated in Prairie Grove, Eric Puryear is putting his anger and frustration to good use by helping others who might not otherwise have representation.

Every little bit helps, even if you never realize it until it happens to you.



Discover more from Simple Justice

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

10 thoughts on “A Bad Day in Prairie Grove

  1. Clifford Franklin

    His case wasn’t dismissed, and he didn’t beat the rap. He lost his motion to suppress. The judge watched the video and say articulate Probable cause for the traffic stop. Read the transcript.

  2. SHG

    My apologies if my info is wrong.

    Edit:  I see that you’re a big fan of Officer Page.

    Officer Page is a good man who teaches Sunday school in Crystal Lake and volunteers in the community. I realized that by asking you to wear a seat belt he was trying to keep your family together and your family from harm. But all you do is try to destr oy this man and his family. What kind of a man knowingly puts his child and wife in a car with a huge bumper sticker that says “Mother Fucker.” You did, its i the transcript. I support Officer Page and the Christians of McHenry County do also. All I needed to know about you came when I saw your photo on my facebook wall. This is the worst marketing I ever saw, Your just arrogant and I hope you find peace.

    How nice of you to roam the internet to protect your friend.

  3. Bruce Coulson

    Oddly enough, I believe this comes under the heading of bad police training; and it includes an area you might not think of. Now the first part (trying to retaliate because the officer ‘didn’t like someone’s attitude’) is pretty obvious. The second area is officer safety. Every time you engage with someone, in any manner, there is a risk, because you have no idea to whom you’re speaking…or what their capabilities might be…or what they might be willing to do. So, escalating a conflict when you lack knowledge of who you are dealing with increases your risk. As Office Page is finding out.

    He should have just rambled on…

  4. Frank

    Playing guitar? As in on the sidewalk hoping for spare change flung in the case?

    Because I wouldn’t trust this guy to make my fries right.

  5. Noah

    This about says it all:

    A. by Officer James G. Page [33-13]: Attitude means everything and Mr. Puryear — Mr. Puryear was not giving me the — was not respectful throughout this arrest, and if I’m going to take a complaint after giving him a favor by letting him go, then I’m going to write a citation for that.

  6. SHG

    Not only did Page do an exemplary job of explaining it, but that he admitted is quite remarkable. Idiotic, but honest and remarkable.

  7. bkm

    How can a cop see for sure if a seatbelt is or isnt on while a car drives by AND notice the obscene bumper sticker? Pretty sure it was the bumper sticker that got his attention & the seatbelt was an excuse to stop them. Police are in the career because they like the authority & when someone questions them they throw their weight around. They forget everyone is innocent until proven guilty & the person they are harassing is actually paying their salary, pension, & health insurance. As a nurse who has saved the lives of some ungrateful, messed up individuals while my taxes pay their bill, I remain neutral & am an advocate for them. Police are a vital necessity but need to remember they are a civil servant & not judge & jury!

  8. Kris Y.

    “Puryear was not giving me the — was not respectful throughout this arrest” holy hancock, being “not respectful” is not against the law you supposed law-upholding twit. How much more contempt do I have for this officer?

    A [expletive]-load.

Comments are closed.