Short Take: NYPD’s 319 Secrets

It’s “secret” in the sense that it’s not public, but it’s hardly a secret in the sense that everybody involved in criminal law didn’t know about it. Section 50-a of the New York Civil Rights Law expressly says so.

All personnel records used to evaluate performance toward continued employment or promotion, under the control of any police agency…shall be considered confidential and not subject to inspection or review without the express written consent of such police officer, firefighter, firefighter/paramedic, correction officer or peace officer within the department of corrections and community supervision or probation department except as may be mandated by lawful court order.

There are ways to get a specific officer’s personnel records, but there is no means by which to get the personnel records of all cops who have been subject to discipline. Unless, of course, someone leaks them to you.

Secret files obtained by BuzzFeed News reveal that from 2011 to 2015 at least 319 New York Police Department employees who committed offenses serious enough to merit firing were allowed to keep their jobs.

From the BuzzFeed post, the outrage comes from the disposition of these instances of outrageous conduct, ranging from lying to drugs, beatings to sexual abuse. The sort of stuff that we would be put in prison for, but somehow isn’t worthy of discharge if you’re a cop.

In every instance, the police commissioner, who has final authority in disciplinary decisions, assigned these officers to “dismissal probation,” a penalty with few practical consequences. The officer continues to do their job at their usual salary. They may get less overtime and won’t be promoted during that period, which usually lasts a year. When the year is over, so is the probation.

In individual instances, we know that cops who did the dirty didn’t get fired, because they’re still on the job. In the aggregate, however, it was unclear. Until now.

Today many continue to patrol the streets, arrest people, put them in jail, and testify in criminal prosecutions. But the people they arrest have little way to find out about the officer’s record. So they are forced to make life-changing decisions — such as whether to fight their charges in court or take a guilty plea — without knowing, for example, if the officer who arrested them is a convicted liar, information that a jury might find directly relevant.

Of course there is a duty to disclose to the defense that a liar cop is a liar cop, but if they don’t, whether because a prosecutor isn’t aware of a cop’s history or decides to bury it, there’s often no way for the defense to find out. Yet there they are, on the job, busting defendants (in all sense of the word).

It’s hardly a secret that it’s up to the police commissioner to ultimately decide whether to fire a cop, and much as they proclaim their purity in public, few in the trenches are so naive as to believe this sputum. In fairness, the Commish gets feedback about the worthiness of cops from unreliable sources, like commanding officers, and has to face the post hoc arbitrator’s decision, which is notoriously pro-cop and means an award of reinstatement plus back pay. The PBA has its methods, you know.

While it gives a false impression to call these records “secret,” as the law requires them to be confidential and it’s not as if they are public records that the cops are hiding in the basement, it looks like BuzzFeed plans to put them online so that we can find out if a cop on a case is a bad dude, and perhaps drop some shame on the cops for keeping officers on the job who they insist would never be allowed to wear a badge. This could be huge.

18 comments on “Short Take: NYPD’s 319 Secrets

  1. B. McLeod

    Given that it is simply not possible a department the size of NYC’s would find it impracticable to replace 319 officers, I can only think this is a sign of the police union in operation there.

    1. SHG Post author

      It’s all union. In a force of @35,000, firing 319 dirty cops is no biggie, but dealing with the PBA is always aggravation. But hey, public sector union solidarity, baby!

      1. PseudonymousKid

        Cops brought to you by the Dodge RAM 1500 are the answer.

        319 dirty cops damned to push paper doesn’t seem as bad as putting them back on the streets and in courtrooms. Don’t be jealous of a union actually doing something, even if what they are doing here is a bit fucked.

  2. Wrongway

    …. Umm…. sputum ?!? … really ? .. the last time I saw that was Socrates, or was it Shakespeare ? who cares, but it’s awesome.. and yeah, pretty much sums it up quite nicely..

  3. Renfield

    In NYC, is it permissible for the defense to use this illegally obtained list (I assume Buzzfeed’s list was illegally obtained) to impeach the testimony of a cop? What is the standard for the defense using illegally obtained evidence in NYC?

    1. SHG Post author

      Ordinarily, it would require a Gissander motion to get to a cop’s personnel file. As for this “stolen” info, whether it can be used directly or used to obtain it lawfully per Gissander isn’t clear. It’s not as if this was available and ruled upon before.

          1. Renfield

            Sorry about not using the reply button. The issue, somehow, was my VPN. Without it running, no problem accessing that link.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments are subject to editing or deletion if I deem them inappropriate for any reason or no reason. Hyperlinks are not permitted in comments and will be deleted. References to Nazis/Hitler will not be tolerated. I allow anonymous comments, but will not tolerate attacks unless you use your real name. Anyone using the phrase "ad hominem" incorrectly will be ridiculed. If you use ALL CAPS for emphasis, I will assume you wear a tin foil hat and treat you accordingly. I expect civility from you, but that does not mean I will respond in kind. This is my home and I make the rules. If you don't like my rules, then don't comment. Spam is absolutely prohibited, and you will be permanently banned.