Is the job of a cabinet member to advise a president on the propriety and lawfulness of a policy or course of action, or to be fawning sycophant who does whatever he’s told to do without regard to whether it’s unlawful, dangerous or counterproductive? In another time, the answer would obviously be the former. But during their confirmation hearings, neither Todd Blanche nor Jay Clayton, nominated to be the Director of National Intelligence where the stunningly unqualified Bill Pulte sits in the chair, made clear that their duty is to do as they’re told no matter what.
PADILLA: Do you personally believe that someone who forcibly entered the Capitol and assaulted law enforcement should be rewarded with taxpayer money?
BLANCHE: I can’t answer yes or no pic.twitter.com/Gdo8LWa00P
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) July 15, 2026
Given the question, there can be no other answer than no. But then, Blanche was the person who “settled” a specious Trump suit by approving a slush fund for the January 6th insurrectionists. As he openly conceded during questioning, he is Trump’s lawyer and he will do whatever Trump tells him to do.
HIRONO: Do you believe it is the president’s right and duty to order the investigation or prosecution of his perceived enemies, yes or no?
BLANCHE: I can’t answer that yes or no. Under Article 2, he’s in charge of the DOJ. My answer reflects that idea. pic.twitter.com/eJ9H6htyL3
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) July 15, 2026
Like Trump’s nominees before him, including those appointed to the federal bench, Jay Clayton gave the stock answers as to who won the 2020 election by stating that Biden was “certified” by Congress. In this way, they could “admit” that Biden was, in fact, president, without conceding that Biden won the election.
KELLY: Can you tell me why Joe Biden was certified as the winner of the 2020 election?
CLAYTON: … I really … Uhm … I don’t want to continue to debate about this, but I believe he had the most electoral votes
KELLY: So he won the election?
CLAYTON: … hahehe
KELLY:… pic.twitter.com/vHh4X76ZXJ
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) July 15, 2026
When pushed by some very pointed questioning by Senator Jon Ossoff, it got worse.
OMGGGGG — Clayton is reduced to sitting in silence instead of acknowledging Joe Biden won the 2020 election
OSSOFF: Who won the 2020 election?
CLAYTON: Uhm, you know, I’m not going to do this with you
OSSOFF: This is a job interview. You have an obligation to be honest with… pic.twitter.com/vk0m6EYnl0
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) July 15, 2026
It’s entirely understandable why both Blanche and Clayton answered as they did. Anything else would have made Trump furious. They may have been nominated already, but there is nothing to stop Trump from pulling their nominations if they fail to toe the line and give the answers they’re told to give.
Unlike other Trump nominees, like Ka$h Patel, Pete Hegseth or RFJ Jr., neither Blanche nor Clayton are stupid or professionally unqualified. Granted, Clayton lacks the experience required for the position of DNI, as his background in intelligence is severely limited, but at least he has some experience stemming from his time as the United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York. Blanche, of course, had been an AUSA in that same office before going to Biglaw, then leaving to be Trump’s personal lawyer.
While most confirmation hearings are pure circus these days, their hearings actually provided some insight as to how they would serve in their respective positions. The insight, pathetically, showed that they lack the courage to disagree with Trump, to fulfill the role of adviser and subject matter expert, by telling the president when he’s wrong.
In Blanche’s case, it was even worse, in that he told Senator Cory Booker during the Senate Judiciary Committee that he’s not legally permitted to meet with the Epstein survivors, a blatantly false claim. But Clayton wasn’t far behind, saying that he supported the January 6th slush fund.
Clayton on the weaponization fund: “I stand by what I said. If people have been inappropriately and intentionally subject to prosecution, they should have recourse” pic.twitter.com/2q8Bd6NWxb
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) July 15, 2026
As Trump has regurgitated many times over, he knows more about everything than anyone. No need to surround himself with people who are smarter than him, because no one is smarter than him. No need to nominate subject matter experts to advise him on the merits or legality of an idea that pops into his head as he’s sitting in one of his ubiquitous oval officer pressers, as there can be no one more expert than him. In their place,
Trump wants only those people who are so unquestionably loyal to him that their only answer is “Yessir, you are right and the bestest president ever!” He’s accomplished that with his nominations of Todd Blanche and Jay Clayton, neither of whom has or will ever have the guts to tell Trump that “no, you can’t just shoot people in the legs for protesting” or that Biden won the election.
Discover more from Simple Justice
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
