Next Up, The Body Odor Registry

It’s less than two miles from where I sit and type. Suffolk County, New York.  Doug Berman calls it prominent, which is likely do to the fact that it sticks out into the Atlantic Ocean.  Oh, and did I mention they’ve slid down the slippery slope of stupid?  It’s an odd feeling to be in such close proximity, raising fears that there’s something in the water and it’s drifting my way.

Suffolk County is the first in the nation (the very FIRST!) to come up with an Animal Abuse Registry.  That’s right, forget abused children or mass murderers, and go straight to Fluffy and Spot.  Via Newsday :

Under the measure passed Tuesday, a Suffolk resident older than 18 who is convicted of animal abuse would be required to file their name, address and photo with the registry and stay on the list for five years. It will be administered without cost to the county by the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. It will be publicly available.

Those convicted of animal abuse crimes would also stay on the list for an additional five years for any subsequent conviction. The registry would only cover those convicted of abuse crimes. Those on the list would also have to pay a $50 annual fee to help fund the cost of maintaining the registry.

It’s not enough to prosecute anyone engaged in abuse, convict them and sentence them.  We need to add the scarlet letter, yet even that isn’t enough.  We need to make them pay for their own branding.  No, if they fail to pay their $50 annual fee, they aren’t punished by having their name removed from the list.  Those who fail to register and pay face a $1000 “charge” or jail.  Not criminal, of course, for that would be an unlawful sentence.  You know, civil jail and a civil “charge.”

According to aides, Democrat Republican gubernatorial quitter to Lobbyist Rich Lazio, who lost to Carl “I’m Angry, Argh” Paladino, Steve Levy, will sign the bill into law.  Why?

“There are sick individuals out there who are preying on innocent animals,” said Legis. Jon Cooper (D-Lloyd Harbor), sponsor of the bill.

Well, yeah.  That’s why it’s a crime, Jon.

Roy Gross, who heads the Suffolk County Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, said his group, which deals with over 2,000 animal abuse cases in the county per year,  believes the animal abuse registry will help to save animals.

“Most serial killers began as animal abusers,” he said. “It’s a known fact: people who hurt animals hurt people too.”

It’s always better to state those known facts than the unknown ones.  But is there a looming disaster of serial killing in Suffolk County that needs to be stopped?  Does the logical fallacy of post hoc ergo propter hoc cease at the Nassau County line?

I abhor people who abuse animals.  And that includes police officers, by the way.  But disgust at an evil act is a reason to prohibit it and punish it, not continue downstream to compound the damage of sex offenders registries by pursuing new registries.  How long will it be before there’s a registry for each of us?  You know that we all do something that someone else thinks is wrong.

Ironically, a substantial number of the animal abuse cases that arise aren’t a result of sick people who hate animals, but sick people who love them too much.  You know, the person who takes in 100 feral cats, which she can’t afford to feed.  Then animals do what nature compels of them, and we hear of the travesty of a suburban home smelling so badly of urine and feces that men in hazmat suits are called in.  Are these our future serial killers?

This trend toward registries was bad to begin with and will only get worse.  That people who are otherwise capable of walking upright are making political points off this latest bit of insanity is not merely sad, but a matter to be feared.  As otherwise normal people applaud the creation of another registry, let them consider what it means when they, their kids, their friends, find their unsmiling face online as an animal abuser.

What?  It could never happen to you?  Ever swat a fly? Step on ants?  Eat meat?  Did you think they cuddle the cute little baby lamb before they slaughter it?


Discover more from Simple Justice

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

7 thoughts on “Next Up, The Body Odor Registry

  1. Gritsforbreakfast

    The FBI already has an odor registry, or at least the beginnings of one. I’d provide a link if it didn’t violate house policy, but here’s an excerpt from a 2009 news story about it:

    “The FBI is using new technology at crime scenes that can literally bottle up a person’s distinct odor.

    “The STU 100 Portable Vacuum Collection Unit has been in service in FBI offices for the past two years.

    “The unit collects scents ‘in such a way that can store that scent for later use,’ FBI Special Agent Darrin Jones told KRQE News 13.”

    The FBI used the unit to collect the odor of Joseph Burgess, better known as ‘the Cookie Bandit,’ who died in a shootout in the Jemez Mountains that also killed a Sandoval County sheriff’s sergeant. According to the New Mexico Police Report on the shootout, the FBI had Burgess’ clothing processed to maintain his distinctive scent.

    “The unit vacuums the odor onto sterile scent pads. The scent pads are then stored inside a sealed tube for later use.”

  2. AlliG

    “Most serial killers began as animal abusers,” he said. “It’s a known fact: people who hurt animals hurt people too.”
    ————–

    Thanks, Roy. You should win the Nobel Peace Prize for this groundbreaking research and the steps you’ve taken to eradicate “hurting people” from our society. But why stop at a registry? Why not resurrect internment camps?

    I just have one question–does forcing your dog to skateboard for YouTube fame count?

  3. Stephen

    That’s slightly worrying. The Stasi had a scent database too. The idea was that they would have something to give to tracker dogs.

  4. Stephen

    Well, given it’s an animals rights charity that’s behind the idea of a registry they might even believe that not being a vegetarian is animal cruelty (it’s not an unusual animal rights belief).

  5. Letsgetreal

    “The slippery Slope of Stupid.” Exactly!

    I couldn’t agree more. All these registries in the public view is exactly that.

    Law makers and the public have totally ignored the RESEARCH when it comes to making sex offender laws and the result is insane. Knee jerk laws for feel good results have utterly failed to “prevent and protect. They have caused “More Harm than Good at an enormous cost of BILLIONS to the tax payer.

    [Edit Note: Link to commenter’s website deleted as violation of no links in comments rule.]

Comments are closed.