Nature v. Nutjob

In the comments to a post at SJ, a deeply passionate ally did his utmost to “dismantle” my frat bro “Klan circle jerk” to protect the honor of fragile womanhood. It was, to be kind, an interesting exchange.

More breaking news! A frat boy condoning non consensual sex-shocking!! You’re a mysogynist…sure you can have problems with the article, but you condone rape here and need to be called for it by other men. pink panty dropper drink…gee whatever do You mean?? im sure you felt Brock Turner should’ve gotten off too…you are the problem-not the author and not the drinking…you and your beliefs and actions…look back decades later with fondness LOL-tell that to the scores of women being raped by your bros. I’m sure You won’t publish this-bros hate to be challengers or have to think deeply about anything…but at least you should read that other men are ashamed of you and your beliefs

Nothing says “take me seriously” more than “LOL.”  But Jonny had plenty more to explain to this “mysogynist.” Seriously, go read the comments. While it’s easy to enjoy this irrational ranting of a cartoon character who thought himself (sorry, still not sure of his/her/Xir’s preferred pronouns) overwhelmingly persuasive, that’s because we don’t have to endure it. We can x out anytime we want.

Not so for the twin boys of Jody Allard.

“Oh boy,” my son said, rolling his eyes. “Not rape culture again.”

We were sitting around the dinner table talking about the news. As soon as I mentioned the Stanford sexual assault case, my sons looked at each other. They knew what was coming. They’ve been listening to me talk about consent, misogyny and rape culture since they were tweens. They listened to me then, but they are 16 and 18 now and they roll their eyes and argue when I talk to them about sexism and misogyny.

There was no father there. Allard has been thrice divorced, never her fault, so that she is the only adult in these boys’ lives.

She has been married and divorced three timesher exes, of course, were the problem; her biological father abandoned her; she has “divorced” her mother, who she says is “incapable of mothering anyone; and she’s a victim of sexual abuse. Oh, and she was born with one hand, not two;and her adopted sister, who liked to kill animals, tried to kill her. The list goes on.

That places a heavy burden on a mother to raise good boys. Allard’s answer was all about Allard.

I’m a survivor of rape and sexual abuse. My sons know this like they know I was once a reporter and I love curries and coffee. But they have never been sexually abused, and they can’t fathom what it’s like to stand in a scalding hot shower trying to burn away the touch of a stranger’s hands. I’ve told them why dismantling rape culture is so important to me, but they will never truly understand how survivors feel.

And despite being suffocated by Allard’s narcissistic indoctrination, her twin sons were unmoved.

Men who tell me I’m being too sensitive or that I don’t understand what teenage boys are like. “You don’t speak out about this stuff, mom,” they tell me with a sigh. “It’s just not what teenagers do.”

My sons are right about that much. Teenage boys, by and large, don’t speak out about slut-shaming or rape culture. They don’t call each other out when they make sexist jokes or objectify women. It’s too uncomfortable to separate themselves from the pack so they continue to at least dip their toes into toxic masculinity. In their discomfort with action, they remain passive, and their passivity perpetuates the same broken system that sentenced Brock Turner to only six months in jail.

What Allard sought to do is to use her children to vent the angst of her personal misery. Even her 16-year-old’s suicidal ideation was fodder for her own agenda.

But to publicly shame one’s children for dipping “their toes into toxic masculinity” goes beyond any acceptable realm of parenting.

No matter how often my sons remind me that they are good men, they don’t understand that being “good” is an action. You don’t earn the honor by simply shaking your head when you hear about Turner and other rapists being given lenient sentences. You earn it by acting to end rape culture, and by doing it even when it’s awkward and uncomfortable as hell.

Allard’s sons are indeed good men. That’s because they have refused to become party to their mother’s insanity.  Jody Allard is a sick and twisted woman, and that any two children should be left in the care of such a person is a terrible shame. That her two sons aren’t emotional and psychological cripples is a testament to nature versus nuture, though her suicidal son suggests at least one struggles to overcome his mother’s sickness.

But that this homage to child abuse in the name of feminism appeared on the pages of the Washington Post, and was later reprinted at the Chicago TribuneThe Denver Post, Bangor Daily News, and at the Charlotte Observer, is a reminder that there may be a great many Jonny’s, irrational and incomprehensible, but true believers in the gibberish of social justice. That won’t be funny.

Some young men will overcome their nutjob mother’s abuse.  Some, perhaps most, will not. When media like the Washington Post normalizes such insanity as “toxic masculinity,” because little boys should grow up to be a flaming nutjob like Jody Allard, it will be nearly impossible for these boys’ nature to overcome indoctrination.  And abusive mothers, like Allard, will believe themselves empowered to impose their insanity on their children.  This is a recipe for disaster.

28 thoughts on “Nature v. Nutjob

  1. Beth

    “It’s too uncomfortable to separate themselves from the pack” – It’s been a long time since I was a teenager, but ‘uncomfortable’ is not accurate. They don’t want to become targets of the pack. I remember what that was like; I don’t blame them.

    1. SHG Post author

      Allard’s vision of the world, and her children, is through her twisted lens. Adjectives are limited to those that rationalize her views, no matter how mangled her fantasy. This is the only way she can explain why her boys aren’t her tools.

  2. Noxx

    My son is not quite a month old, I’m already trying to figure out a way to tell him that vast swaths of humanity are going to be batshit insane, and not worth troubling with. Thanks to your tireless research I’m not in any danger of running out of examples.

    1. SHG Post author

      That’s an excellent question. For most of us, the alt to being “religious” isn’t toxic angosticism, where we’re deluged daily about how we’re athiest apologists. Then again, there are some (think the movie Carrie), which can be similarly abusive.

      1. Derek Ramsey

        It is the job of a parent to tell their children how to behave and what to believe. Sure some religious (and non-religious) indoctrination is harmful but not all. Allard is putting her son’s life at increased risk. She has her best interests at heart, not her kids. I’ve literally gone to the other side of the world for my kids. ANY good parent would do the same if required. I also raise them in a religious home and teach them how to think for themselves. Good parenting is orthogonal to religion.

  3. Edward Adamsky

    When women are criticized for expressing their sexuality, others attack the critics for “slut-shaming.” This concept can be applied those who criticize men for normal expressions of male sexuality. I suggest we call this “creep-shaming” (as some women call men “creepy” or “creeps” when they do anything remotely sexual – like look at them). We need to speak out against those who engage in behavior that is detrimental to the normal and healthy sexuality of males.

    1. SHG Post author

      It’s my general preference is not to use either the language or metric of the unduly passionate to gauge the efficacy of my actions. But that’s just me. YMMV.

  4. FF

    This is why men flock to Men Going Their Own Way [Ed. Note: Link deleted per rules.] or marry sex dolls. Women like Allard are toxic. Instead of teaching their sons to fight against the alleged rape culture, how about teaching them how to be gentlemen?

  5. spumoni101

    Last year Ms. Allard identified her oldest son as a rape apologist for saying that the man whom Emma Sulkowicz accused was innocent until proven guilty.

Comments are closed.