She denied it. She lied about it when she denied it, and when she accused Mike Masnick of being a liar about it, because she is without shame or intellectual honesty. But this?
But for all it has given us, Section 230 of the CDA has also protected some of the worst parts of the internet. If a small-town factory pollutes the water supply, the company can be held legally responsible for the negative consequences of the factory. But on the internet, armed with the protection granted by the CDA, “you can reap all the rewards for whatever it is you’re producing, and you basically will be accountable for none of the negative things that you might also be producing,” says Franks. “So unlike a factory, people can’t sue you for the negative side effects your online product.”
Tim Cushing believes Mary Anne knows better, realizes that her factory analogy is utterly absurd. But then, if she is smart enough to realize that her analogy was ridiculously inapt, then Hanlon’s Razor would dictate that her words were born of malice rather than stupidity.
Then again, Slate Tech writer, April Glazer, who briefly worked for the Electronic Frontier Foundation, had no shame about repeating such idiocy. And how many Slate readers will care about Franks’ playing them for fools if it confirms their bias that the internet is full of awful people who must be silenced?
Discover more from Simple Justice
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Wow.
Last I checked, I have little if any control about the water I drink or (to extend the analogy) the air I breathe, but I have extensive choice as to when and whether and how I use the internet. And unless I am greatly mistaken, if a factory pollutes a water system, you cannot sue the maker of the pipes through which the water flows.
People like this make my head hurt. And they are bad allies for their cause.
The trick to a really good fallacious analogy is that you pause, if only for a split second, before realizing that it’s completely wrong. For most people, that’s enough to make them not think harder and move on. Mary Anne, who constantly relies on analogies to do the job she can’t otherwise accomplish for lack of any actual logical, legal or factual support, is quite adept at this trick.
Maybe she can tell me why the good people at HP put a “number lock” key on my keyboard. And directly above the number keypad at that.
One of the mysteries of life.
I am a small town factory, according to the paperwork I just filed.
( I mourn the math problem catchpas )
( also math is good )