Short Take: Disproportionately Yours

Squirreled away in the deepest bowels of New York siberia, the Metropolitan Detention Center-Brooklyn is a place you want to avoid on its best days. These are not its best days.

Locked away in dark and freezing cells with little heat for days, left to languish alone in the dead of winter — this is how the federal government of the United States thinks that it can treat the people in its care.

No, this isn’t some C.I.A. black site overseas. It is a federal detention center in Brooklyn, where inmates were being held in abominable conditions in America’s largest city.

The facility is run by the Bureau of Prisons, and while it denies that the facility is completely lacking heat and hot water, it’s at least substantially short of normal conditions. This distinction doesn’t save the conditions from being called “abominable,” as there is (or at least should be) no question but that they are required to provide these utter basics to inmates.

Whether storming the Bastille is an effective response to these conditions, that there is a severe problem that demands an immediate fix seems beyond question, even if District Judge Analisa Torres figures it can hold until Tuesday.

That something went particularly wrong at MDC, as opposed to the ordinary wrongs like, oh, rats, rape and beatings, has focused attention on federal detention facilities, prompting the New York Times to ponder why, particuarly given the freezing temperatures, such a problem was “allowed” to happen, and why it wasn’t immediately fixed.

The history of abuses in federal jails, prisons and detention centers, whose populations are disproportionately black and Hispanic, long predates the Trump administration — and rarely draws much attention. Maybe current officials thought they could treat people callously at the Metropolitan Detention Center because they were mostly poor, and black and brown.

It’s a matter of demographics that the population is disproportionately black and Hispanic, but just as reflected in the bizarrely misguided assumption that a reform of the system would serve “nice white boys” as opposed to everyone, harping on the distinction has contorted people’s understanding of who is in the can, who suffers, who is marginalized. Did this “calamity” at MDC happen because “they were mostly poor, and black and brown”? Let’s cut to the pie chart.

Because Hispanic is considered ethnicity rather than race, it’s carved out of the chart with Hispanic at 32.2% and non-Hispanic at 67.8%. So it’s clear, these percentages are definitly disproportionate to representation in the general population. But the impression that these jails are filled only with black and brown people simply isn’t true. It’s a Benneton ad, and it sucks for all of them.

Nor, as an aside, are they necessarily poor, as drug sellers and conspirators of any significance are presumptively detained. It’s not necessarily that they can’t make bail, but that their cash doesn’t help them.

While it’s fair and accurate to state that blacks and Hispanics are significantly overrepresented in the jail population, it’s inaccurate to convey the impression that there are no “nice white boys” in there as well. Well, maybe not all are nice, but that’s a different issue.

While trying to racialize every issue serves the thrust of advocates who pick the low-hanging fruit of racial disparities as a means of condemning the system, it ignores the reality that there are two very distinct problems: The system is deeply flawed for everyone, regardless of race or ethnicity. And there is racial discrimination.

If the heat is off at MDC, it is an inexcusable travesty. Rather than take tours or twit about it, maybe federal officials should be using their hold on the purse strings to compel the BOP to fix it immediately. Maybe a federal judge could hop in a cab and find out, immediately, whether inmates are freezing rather than schedule a hearing for the following week. Nobody in the custody of the United States should freeze, without regard to their race or ethnicity. And that includes the white inmates, who are in there freezing with everyone else.


Discover more from Simple Justice

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

17 thoughts on “Short Take: Disproportionately Yours

  1. wilbur

    Many are cold. Few are frozen.

    Seriously, as a 30+ year escapee from the frozen north, I know I’d rather be hungry than cold. It’s the worst.

    1. SHG Post author

      I’m generally of the view that if they want to keep them in cells, they have to feed them and keep them warm.

  2. Anonymous Coward

    To paraphrase Hanlon’s razor, avoid ascribing to racism that which can be explained by incompetence and callousness.

  3. Jake

    See, if the Kock brothers cared about criminal justice reform for all they could sponsor a bill called ‘the prisoner standards of care’ act which made it a criminal violation not to meet to be defined standards of care. This would have the dual effect of improving the lives of existing prisoners and raising the cost of prison to the point where society would be forced to make choices about what crimes are truly worthy of handing out life+cancer.

    1. SHG Post author

      You should write those Kock brothers and suggest it. You never know. They may put you in charge of their reform empire.

  4. Thrown_out_of_the_Kremlin_for_Singing

    I know someone who was charged with a Federal crime in New York City. The deal there is: while you await trial or resolution of your case, you are usually housed at Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan near the Financial District-Chinatown border. Then, when your case resolves (trial or plea) if you’re guilty you go to this place in Brooklyn for a few days (up to two weeks or so) while the Bureau of Prisons decides where to send you to do your time. Then, you go wherever that is.

    As I recall, the Brooklyn place is unusual in that it doesn’t have cells, just several huge open rooms with lots and lots of double-bunks in them. The few individual cells there are just for punishment (solitary) or safety (segregation). Without lights or heat, the place must be total chaos, unless I’m confused and the power-out prison is a different place.

    1. SHG Post author

      You’ve been misinformed. Maybe the guy who knows “someone” should let people who know hundreds speak from knowledge instead?

      1. Thrown_out_of_the_Kremlin_for_Singing

        As I said, I could be wrong about WHICH Brooklyn prison is suffering the power-outage. I most certainly am NOT misinformed about the [MCC-until-case-resolves, then Brooklyn-for-a-few-days, then real prison] trajectory.

        (I suppose things may have changed since the time the person I know went through it– it was between 2011 and 2014. But I doubt there’s been any change in the overall prisoner-trajectory.)

        1. SHG Post author

          Sadly, you’re wrong. Both MCC and MDC hold pre-trial detainees, as well as post conviction detainees awaiting designation. Remember, they need to keep snitches separate from the rest of their co-conspirators, and they just don’t have enough room at MCC to hold all the SDNY defendants.

  5. MonitorsMost

    I’m sure they were mass yelling, banging on the windows and protesting just to get a ride out of the media. A well-coordinated PR stunt after they heard a rumor that part of the building lost heat. Totally reasonable assumption. After all, they’re a bunch of lying cons.

Comments are closed.