Biden Defies Gravity

It’s normal for the media to give a new president a “honeymoon,” a chance to get his house in order and establish a plan of what he hopes to accomplish and how he plans to do it. Granted, Trump never got a honeymoon, but then, he never had a plan and was given what he gave. Biden, however, is different again. He’s whirling and spinning, massive plans at massive costs justified by massive claims of massive problems.

And nobody in the media seems to seriously question any of it.

Ten years ago, I would have been aghast at this leftward shift. But like everybody else, I’ve seen inequality widen, the social fabric decay, the racial wealth gap increase. Americans are rightly convinced that the country is broken and fear it is in decline. Like a lot of people, I’ve moved left on what I think of the role of government and income redistribution issues. We surely need to invest a lot more in infrastructure and children.

Did “inequality widen”? Did the “racial wealth gap increase”? Americans are concerned that the country is broken, but the primary reason for that is they are constantly told it’s broken, led to believe absurdly false claims like “inequality widened” and the “racial wealth gap increased” when neither is remotely true. Remember how people assumed thousands of unarmed black men were being slaughtered by the cops when the real number was 27? Yet here’s New York Times Columnist, David Brooks, citelessly spewing vapid crap as if his feelz are any more empirical than your basic college sophomore’s.

He may be right that we “feel” this way. That’s about our feelings, not about any facts to support them at a time when we are closer to eradicating some racism than ever before in our history. It has never been better and we have never been more sensitive to it. Some wags may even suggest we are bit oversensitive to it, if they don’t redefine racism to whatever serves their favorite race at any given moment.

But even Brooks, who picked a bad week to give up sniffing glue, can’t ignore the coming fall.

But I worry about this new economic philosophy that asserts you can have everything you want without trade-offs. This week I was reading a smart blog post from a progressive economist and I came across phrases that startled me: “Public debt doesn’t matter” and “Work incentives don’t matter.” Really? Have the laws of gravity been suspended, too?

Well, David, gravity does keep people down, you know.

I worry there’s a great historical amnesia going on — that we’re overlearning the lessons of the financial crisis and forgetting the lessons of all the other economic downturns. I worry we’re unwittingly committing ourselves to decades of higher taxes down the line that will sap American dynamism.

Biden’s first foray into the fun world of uncritical denial was the $1.9 trillion “America Rescue Plan,” which has a name that nobody could argue with so why look at the nuts and bolts and realize that it’s $900 million in COVID relief and $1 trillion in unrelated progressive pork. Next up is the $3 trillion “Infrastructure Plan.” As Richard Trumka, president of the AFL-CIO, who advised Biden on the bill, explained:

A big, bold infrastructure bill, he said, was “a racial justice bill, a Covid safety bill and the most important climate bill of all time, all in one.”

What? When you heard “infrastructure,” you were thinking this was about rebuilding failing bridges and highways?

After dinner the other evening, a friend of mine who comes out of corporate America told me that people were suffering and something had to be done. We all nodded, but then I asked, “but what?” He told me about the America Rescue Plan and I asked him what was in it beyond the $1400 payments.  He told me it would fund schools that needed the money and provide a “path to reopening.”

After explaining that schools not only didn’t need the money, but wouldn’t get the money for years, and that the money wasn’t tied to reopening any school, he gave me that quizzical look, the one with knitted eyebrows and doubt. That can’t be so, he explained, as everything he’s heard is that this was a glorious fix that we desperately needed. That’s what all the news folks were saying, and why would they lie?

Why would they lie? Or are they just giving President Biden a free pass on his empty rhetorical and carefully chosen names for his new laws? Or do they not know any better, think any harder, realize the issues that are being raised by these schemes that will comeback to bite us in the ass, both because they won’t work and because they are outrageously expensive. Nobody talks about “transfer payments” anymore. The phrase is as unacceptable as “illegal aliens.”

This is columnist heresy, but I’m going to take my time making up my mind on Biden’s $3 trillion spending package. But I do appreciate that this is a moment in which Americans are rethinking their fundamental values and the political-economic system that grew out of those values. This is necessary — and big.

Say anything negative about Biden and a chorus of ten thousand college students and their profs will reply, “tRump.” That may be, but it doesn’t make Biden’s plans better or viable. Even if Brooks won’t commit the heresy of being factual about racism, he draws the line at defying gravity. He is, he says, “going to take my time making up my mind” about throwing $3 trillion more, atop the $1.9 trillion, atop the Trump payouts, atop the small business failures, the student debt fiasco and the myriad other problems facing America.

Biden held his first press conference, and he was heavily questioned about immigration and the filibuster, which he adored when the Republicans held the Senate and is now “systemic racism” when the Democrats hold a one-vote majority. The media is focused on the things that “really matter,” at least to them at the moment, and won’t have any clue how they could have missed it when everything flies off into space without gravity.


Discover more from Simple Justice

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

15 thoughts on “Biden Defies Gravity

  1. B. McLeod

    Except on jetway stairs, and only then because the evil stairs pull him down. Biden is their guy, and the Democratic party is their party. All Biden’s hacks and flunkies benefit. No matter what obviously false or unfounded statements they may make, the fantasies get a “pass.” Policy arguments get no examination either. As Biden lauds the two pending bills to extend the coverage and allowable periods for background checks, the media applies a “don’t ask, don’t tell” protocol on whether the Atlanta and Boulder gunmen each passed a background check for their purchases.

  2. Jake

    “Americans are concerned that the country is broken, but the primary reason for that is they are constantly told it’s broken, led to believe absurdly false claims like “inequality widened” and the “racial wealth gap increased” when neither is remotely true.”

    Did you fall over and bump your head last night? Why would you print something so clearly and demonstrably false? Are you trying to make a point by lying in a post about lazy journalism?

      1. Jake

        I don’t need to argue facts, Scott. I’d share a link to any of the many sources of data that disprove your counterfactual, but that’s not allowed.

          1. John Holden

            This chart is not very meaningful out of context. It’s percentage change in income, not actual change in income or wealth gained. I’d include those charts because the rise in inequality and the increasing racial wealth gap are extremely well documented, but you said no hyperlinks.

            1. SHG Post author

              There are two issues at play here, according to how one defines racial wealth gap. Are black people earning more than ever before relative to white people. Yes. Do white people still have the benefit of accumulated family wealth? Yes. Based on the former, black people are doing better than ever before. The latter is used to show that they’re doing poorly, as investments have increased which increased accumulated family wealth, even though they’re still earning more and potentially accumulating family wealth.

              The problem is that the latter is only useful to pretend that black people are doing worse today than ever when the data shows exactly the opposite. Unless you think all white people should be stripped of their accumulated family wealth (and some do, so you may think so) and give it black people as reparations, notwithstanding the great many problems involved, it’s an apples to oranges comparison. On an apples to apples comparison, it’s never been better for black people.

  3. KeyserSoze

    “Journalism is about covering important stories. With a pillow, until they stop moving.”

    David Burge aka IowaHawk

  4. Jay

    Ah yes, Greenfield making absurd claims WHILE attacking others for not providing citations, WHILE he provides no citations.

    You are truly awful Greenfield.

  5. L. Phillips

    Brooks might see “Americans . . . rethinking their fundamental values” but it feels to me like termites on a financial flood plain clambering up over the bodies of their fellows in a futile attempt to avoid the coming deluge – and name calling those they would push down to reach the top to boot.

  6. Andrew M Garland

    A technical correction. I’ve read, without supporting detail, that just 9% of Biden’s $1.9 trillion America Rescue Plan is aimed at direct covid relief. If true, that would be
    $171 billion for covid relief and $1,729 billion for other things.
    It’s an outrageous pork offering, called a “stimulus” as usual, with a bit of covid relief hung on as a decoration.

    Billions are hard to comprehend, and trillions are even harder.

    Here is a visual that I like
    [Ed. Note: Link deleted per rules.]

Comments are closed.