HBR: Call In Black

If you can’t turn to Harvard Business Review for “management wisdom,” where else can a CEO turn? And HBR delivers, even if the message may not turn out the way the brilliant minds there assume it will. First, the corporate dilemma.

Black employees are exhausted. Over the past year, their cognitive, emotional, and physical resources have been disproportionally depleted due to two deadly and intertwined pandemics: Covid-19 and structural racism. Black people are more likely to lose their jobs and be hospitalized or die from Covid-19, while still facing disproportionate threats of brutalization and death from policing compared to white people.

Additional factors exacerbate these experiences. First, assaults against Black people were major news stories in 2020, broadcasted regularly across all types of media. This is what’s known as a racial mega-threat — a negative, large-scale, race-related event that receives significant media attention — which heightens racial trauma. Research shows that this type of ongoing experience creates psychological racial battle fatigue — a natural depletion response to commonplace, consistent experiences of heightened distress due to racism.

But that’s not all.

Second, Black employees and leaders are also often asked to educate non-Black individuals about racism and, in many cases, to lead the antiracism charge in their organizations. Responding to such requests and/or fulfilling them requires both physical and emotional labor, which can heighten existing fatigue. All of this is being added to the weight of ongoing disparities in the workplace, including pay inequality and lack of representation in leadership.

Who wouldn’t be exhausted? Now the HBR solutions.

It may seem counterintuitive to rest when there is so much work needed for meaningful change. Yet, consistently disengaging from work can facilitate recovery, as rest is critical for resilience to adversity. This includes taking time off from work when needed to prioritize mental health and well-being. For example, we theorize that employees may need to “call in Black” instead of showing up to work when racially traumatic events occur, especially for those who work in organizations lacking resources to support their coping process. Employers can offer paid time off in a way that is specifically intended to support Black employees.

Quality sleep is critical for recovery, too. Several individuals, groups, and organizations such as The Nap Ministry are exploring how people can experience rest as resistance to and liberation from systemic racism. Naps also help to boost moodalertness, and performance. Thus, rest is a useful tool for organizations to offer and support for Black employees’ recovery.

There are other fixes, such as entitling black employees to “just say no” when they don’t want to shoulder the exhausting burdens of blackness in the workplace. They also urge employers to create black healing spaces, segregated from other races, and promoting “comfort and esteem for Black identities” so black people aren’t expected, no required, to behave like white folks.

Over the past year, many organizations have stated that they value Black lives. One important way of showing this is to value Black recovery and tangibly support Black resilience.

If this were true, that black employees are so weak, emotionally stunted and sleepy that they are incapable of functioning as employees at all, no less viable employees, why would anyone hire a black person? Neither people nor businesses value black people because they’re less able to perform their job than white, Hispanic, Asian or Aleut employees, but because they are just as good, if not better, than any other employee. Advice like this is the last thing black people need to achieve success in the workplace.

Fortunately, it’s not true and this is the most ridiculous, offensive and racist advice possible. Yet, there it is, in Harvard Business Review.

 


Discover more from Simple Justice

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

18 thoughts on “HBR: Call In Black

  1. Miles

    My initial reaction was the soft racism of low expectations, but then I realize that there was nothing soft about the racism of claiming that black people are so pathetic that they are incapable of functioning.

    What surprises me is that the solution wasn’t “hire black people and just send them paychecks and let them stay home.” This is the racist twilight zone.

    1. SHG Post author

      I’m a big fan of naps, but falling asleep during trial is not consistent with zealous advocacy. Yes, it’s hard to stay awake. Yes, there are excuses for why I might be sleepy and bored. Yet, that’s the job.

  2. Paleo

    Assaults against blacks have been all over the media lately?

    It seems as if most of the racial violence I’ve seen make national stories recently are blacks beating Asians and jews and patrons at outdoor restaurants.

    The politically zealous, both Trumpian and progressive, live in a completely separate reality than us normies. Filled with fantasies that justify their hate and anger.

    1. SHG Post author

      The media has perpetuated, if not created, the impression that cops are constantly slaughtering black people in the street. Most people, including (particularly) black people, know this isn’t real because they live their lives and somehow haven’t gotten slaughtered even though the media reliably assures them they will any second. But that may not include people in academia who are unfamiliar with much of anything actually happening in the streets.

      1. RTM

        Are you sure you got the publication’s name right? It reads more like something found in the Harvard Lampoon rather than the HBR. Calling in Black was the tip off. Everyone knows it’s called a mental health day.

  3. Guitardave

    If you stop listening to the ideological stupid amplifier ( formerly referred to as ‘news’ ) and look around, you will see whats true, and what needs to be done.
    With articles like this I’m thinking de-funding Harvard would be a good start.

      1. Guitardave

        You’re very welcome, Andy…. and Drew, and Mark, last week.
        (Don’t worry Admiral, be it slings and arrows or tummy rubs, I can handle it…and thank you, too.)

  4. John Barleycorn

    You really need to start rethinking the publications you are reading esteemed one, especially when it comes to business advice.

    null

    P.S. How come nobody writes about all the cool things, people, and math-s you can learn about at horse-track anymore?

  5. B. McLeod

    They left out the Roxane Gay solution of “stop watching cable news.” She must be losing her following. And it can’t be because they can’t see her.

  6. Bryan Burroughs

    Benefits and policies based explicitly on the race of the employee? How could that possibly go wrong?

Comments are closed.