Thanksgiving Advice For Inclusive Lawyers

Ordinarily, my “advice” for Thanksgiving dinner is to never eat anything bigger than your head. No one listens to me, naturally, even though it’s good advice. But a friend sent me an email with more concrete advice from a group called the Center for Legal Inclusiveness, which says it is dedicated to advancing diversity in the legal profession.

Well, I’m all for diversity in the legal profession. Who isn’t? There should be prosecutors and defense lawyers, plaintiffs’ and defendants’ lawyers. There should be people of all colors and genders, religions and perspectives. Diversity is glorious. If someone wants to be a lawyer and has the chops to cut it, why not? So I read the note from the CEO Sara Scott.

Decide now. Who will you be on Thanksgiving Day? Will you hold true to your values of Allyship and/or Antiracism? Will you choose not to talk about politics and evade any questions of racial reckoning? Or will you dive-in, knowing that you have done the work to have a conversation about the impact of 2020 and systemic racism endured by Black, Indigenous, people of color (BIPOC) communities, and other marginalized groups. Before moving on to dinner table tips, however, I want to recognize that this CEO Note may seem geared toward white people. However, there are plenty of BIPOC individuals and those of other marginalized groups that can benefit from this reminder.

It wasn’t immediately clear to me what “Allyship” meant. Was it different from “allydom” or “allyhood,” Was there a pact with France and England to fight in the European Theater, which had now spread to my Thanksgiving table? Fortunately, Scott explained.

The definitions: in general Allies have a commitment to recognize their privileges and work with oppressed groups to end all forms of oppression, even those that may benefit the Ally. In general, an Antiracist, on a daily basis, studies the policies and practices that result in disparate impacts, examines the policies and procedures and will advocate greatly to destroy those that result in maintaining systemic racism.

Clearly, an ally has a duty to fight the battles everywhere and all the time, and search out and find those heretics passing the cranberry sauce and destroy them. But how to do so? Again, Scott has advice.

 Some Tips:

  • Remember that all Allies/Antiracists “have the back” of diverse communities when they are not in the room (i.e., get ready to defend if it becomes necessary);
  • As an Ally/Antiracist, you will come from a place of knowledge because you have properly educated yourself on the plight of the BIPOC people and other marginalized communities during recent months so do not be afraid to share what you have learned;
  • You can say that you personally celebrate all the different heritage months and give an example for what you have done to celebrate Native American Heritage Month;
  • Remind your friends and family that White Privilege is institutional, not individual, alleviating some of the the blame and shame they may feel;
  • Encourage them to educate themselves and have copies of Robin DiAngelo’s White Fragility with you and ready to give away;
  • Tell them to listen to podcasts such as: Code Switch, Pod Save the People, Intersectionality Matters, The Diversity Gap, and 1619;
  • Share your own journey of getting to the place where you are an Ally/Antiracist.

Whether Scott’s getting a kickback from the sale of DiAngelo’s White Fragility is unclear, although she should. How many people would show up for Thanksgiving dinner with extra copies to hand out but for her “advice”?

For most of us, this sort of “advice” would never find its way onto our radar. We might read a post or op-ed about how to talk Equity with your crazy uncle at Thanksgiving dinner, who will almost certainly appreciate being handed that free copy of DiAngelo’s book, but we don’t ordinarily come into contact with someone like Sara Scott, for whom a duty exists to steel allies for the Thanksgiving Dinner Massacre. Although, to be fair, her advice isn’t to turn the turkey reckoning into bloodshed.

Bottom-line: hold onto to your core values as it relates to who you are. Remember that this can be a conversation, not a fight. Show those who are hesitant to jump-in a little bit grace as you explain what it means to be an Ally/Antiracist. Decide today who you want to be on November 25, 2021, and stick to it.

Of course, it can’t be a conversation because a conversation involves give and take, an expression of diverse (there’s that word again) views, each of which is as worthy of respect as any other. But are they? Can an ally tolerate an opinion that wouldn’t receive a thumbs up from DiAngelo, from Scott, from a real ally? It’s one thing to urge “grace” when confronting those “who are hesitant to jump-in,” but what about those who disagree? What about those who think you have shit-for-brains, speak gibberish and are the real intolerant fascist at the table? Is there a “little bit [of ] grace” for them as well?

In light of what I learned from Sara Scott’s advice, I now expand my own with two additional thoughts. The first is for the adults at the table. Don’t blame little Timmy for coming home from his second year at Yale Law School with an armful of extra copies of Robin DiAngelo’s White Fragility. He believes he’s doing the “right” thing and his heart is in the right place, even if his mind has been molded into a misshapen morass of mush. He’s just seeking a sense of purpose and belonging, as children are wont to do.

The second piece of advice is for the unduly passionate who believe it their duty to fulfill their role as ally by informing their family that they’re white privileged fascists enabling systemic racism by eating a dinner to celebrate genocide and colonialism: Be thankful to have a family that is so very tolerant as to have you at their Thanksgiving dinner despite how unpleasant you’ve become. And don’t waste your money buying extra copies of a book no one wants to read.

29 thoughts on “Thanksgiving Advice For Inclusive Lawyers

  1. Guitardave

    “…even if his mind has been molded into a misshapen morass of mush.” NICE!

    As to the last bit of advice…not so fast. I get a couple of hundred pages of high quality paper kindling to light the fireplace, all for the price of one off ‘color’ joke.
    and, of course, it could be worse…

    Reply
      1. LocoYokel

        Book burning is wrong when mandated and enforced by any branch of the state or forced on a person by others. I reserve the absolute right to burn any book or other material that makes its way unwanted into my house. Plus I need kindling for the wood fire-pit out back.

        Reply
  2. Skink

    I picture this at the Irish Thanksgiving table of my youth, but in today-time. Whiskey has been had. Gripes about the quarterback and goalie have been made. Butts have been grabbed. Some faces are stern; others just flushed. Then this, between the salad with marshmallows and burnt bird:

    Ally: Pops, you know you wouldn’t have all this stuff if you weren’t white and your relatives didn’t steal it all from the original peoples.
    Pops: Huh?
    Ally: Right. So* everything belongs to the aboriginal peoples. You know who they are, right?
    Pops: Canucks?
    Ally: No! The Indian peoples! Everything belongs to them. Columbus did it. Then there were settlers. Now it’s you! You took all their stuff. You didn’t earn any of this. You only have stuff because it was taken.
    Pops: Are you talking about the money I make working in the factory?
    Ally: Yes. you didn’t earn it.
    Pops: I guess I didn’t earn the money for your school and car, right?
    Ally: Correct! You’re getting it! It’s all right here in this book.
    Pops: You brought a book to the dinner table?
    Ally: Oh no, I have three dozen, enough for everyone.
    Pops: Put the car keys right here; next to the basket of rolls. Then go sit at the little table with the children. No, the garage is good for you. Your mother will bring you leftovers from the other plates.

    *Because there must always be a random “so.”

    Reply
    1. Jeff

      More than anything, I’m curious to hear you elaborate on the necessity of the random “so”. There seems to be a great deal of weight attached to that asterisk. Pet peeve?

      Reply
  3. Jake

    Not to worry. In the name of a peaceful holiday meal, I shall mix drinks for that racist boomer uncle so he goes to sleep on the couch before the turkey is even served.

    Reply
  4. Elpey P.

    Because what Thanksgiving Dinner always needs is more self-centered scolds saying cluelessly racist things as they foist their latest multi-level marketing religion on us.

    Reply
  5. Josh

    Anyone who recommends DiAngelo as serious (instead of just providing a summary of leftist thinking in this area) isn’t an intellectually serious person, in my opinion.

    Reply
      1. B. McLeod

        Dear Mr. Kotter:

        Please excuse Robin for missing school last Friday. Due to excessive THC consumption, she was mesmerized in rapt contemplation of her boombox, looping “Whiter Shade of Pale.”

        /s/ DiAngelo’s Mother

        Reply
  6. Dan J

    >You can say that you personally celebrate all the different heritage months and give an example for what you have done to celebrate Native American Heritage Month

    Was she hoping no one would notice this joke stuck in the middle?

    >Encourage them to educate themselves and have copies of Robin DiAngelo’s White Fragility with you and ready to give away;

    I bet she has a lot of lonely Thanksgivings.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments are subject to editing or deletion if I deem them inappropriate for any reason or no reason. Hyperlinks are not permitted in comments and will be deleted. References to Nazis/Hitler will not be tolerated. I allow anonymous comments, but will not tolerate attacks unless you use your real name. Anyone using the phrase "ad hominem" incorrectly will be ridiculed. If you use ALL CAPS for emphasis, I will assume you wear a tin foil hat and treat you accordingly. I expect civility from you, but that does not mean I will respond in kind. This is my home and I make the rules. If you don't like my rules, then don't comment. Spam is absolutely prohibited, and you will be permanently banned.