One of the most curious rhetorical tricks these days is that when the woke refer to violence, it’s limited to acts done to the person, not a thing. Words can be violence. A Molotov cocktail thrown into an empty store is not violence, but property damage. Property can be replaced. Lives cannot. The law values life above property, which is certainly correct, and so there can never be a justification for use of force against the person when the person’s only offense is burning buildings or looting stores, property damage.

Destroying property, which can be replaced, is not violence. To use the same language to describe those two things is not moral.

—Nikole Hannah-Jones

As a laundry list of words have been untethered from any cognizable meaning over the last ten years, from rape to racism, so that they can be accused at random, it’s interesting that this one word, “violence,” has been tightened up in such facile fashion. Then again, there is a somewhat consistent rationale here, as all are defined by outcome rather than conduct. If a “victim” feels that she’s been raped, then it’s rape. If arson destroyed a business that somebody sunk their life into, but no one dies, then it’s just property damage. Continue reading →

No less a deep thinker than New York’s junior senator, Kirsten Gillibrand, told us.

Paid leave is infrastructure.
Child care is infrastructure.
Caregiving is infrastructure.

— Kirsten Gillibrand (@SenGillibrand) April 7, 2021

Is that it? Not necessarily. Continue reading →

Joe Biden’s 36-member commission to reimagine the Supreme Court is designed to do nothing and go nowhere, which makes it perfect for all its member from Yale Law School. Rep. Jerry “Weeble” Nadler, chair of the House Judiciary Committee isn’t going to let it go that easily, perhaps making good on the Democratic senators’ threat to SCOTUS, and so he along with Senator Edward Markey offered a DOA bill to expand the Supreme Court to 13 justices.

Continue reading →

I took up lock picking recently.

The idea came in a moment when I was cleaning out the kids’ toy room and came across a pick set I’d ordered a couple years ago but never really used. So I watched a couple of YouTube tutorials, read a manual, and started working on “bypassing pin tumblers.”

It was hard at first. Really, really hard. And because I’m a stubborn son of a bitch and won’t let something go until I get it, I kept a pick set and practice padlock with me all the time. Continue reading →

He was a 13-year-old seventh grader at Gary Elementary School. He was also a 13-year-old with a gun being chased by cops down a dark alley late at night. There’s an inexplicable compulsion to turn victims into saints these days. They’re not. They don’t have to be. Even kids who do bad things shouldn’t be needlessly killed. Adam Toledo was doing bad things, even though he was just a 13-year-old seventh grader. That shouldn’t have been the case, but it was. And he still shouldn’t have been shot and killed.

Adam Toledo complied. Continue reading →

John McWhorter calls them the “Elect.” Georgetown Palestinian-American feminist law prof Lama Abu Odeh called them the “Progressoriat.” Lacking both the intellectual bona fides of these academics and the identitarian cred, I’ve come up with no new names and have relied on a variety of terms that are invariably seen as pejorative when they come from an old, unwoke, white male liberal lawyer. But then, does the name really matter when someone goes as far out on a limb as Lama Abu Odeh?

Progressive liberals are blind to the fact that there is a regime take-over apace everywhere in academic institutions. A new ruling elite is taking over academic institutions by using its “minority status” to exercise a “soft” coup and is appealing to the minoritarianism of progressive ideology to legitimize its coup—or, if you like, to “manufacture consent.” I will call the adherents of this ideology the “progressoriat.”

Continue reading →

The killing of Daunte Wright is subsumed by the fact that he was an unarmed young black man who shouldn’t have been shot, shouldn’t have died. There can be no dispute about this. But that doesn’t mean that all other facts and circumstances cease to exist, unless the only thing that matters is that it happened. And to some, that’s certainly the case, Wright’s death coming during the Derek Chauvin trial, following almost immediately upon the stop of Lt. Caron Nazario, both within miles of each other.

Twenty-six year police officer Kimberly Potter has been charged with manslaughter 2 upon her claim that she thought she was firing her Taser when she fired her service weapon and killed Wright. There are arguments that cut both ways as to the veracity of her claim, though there is no reason why she would have wanted to kill him rather than prevent him from fleeing after being stopped for expired tags and having an open warrant in an armed robbery case. The man 2 charge tells us that its premised on the reckless mistake of shooting her gun rather than the Taser. And, indeed, if that’s what happened, it would seem quite likely that she was reckless. Continue reading →

If the option is kill or be killed, the choice is clear. But the option is rarely so clear. The probability of surviving an encounter with police is vastly improved by complying with their orders, no matter how wrong, confused, conflicting or distasteful they may be. No, no innocent, law-abiding person wants to be forced to lie in the dirt, and any cop who fails to grasp this is an idiot. But better to have to wash your clothes than have your loved ones lay out clothing for a funeral.

And before anyone else points out the obvious, no, compliance doesn’t guarantee survival or even that you make it through the encounter without physical injury. But it still greatly enhances the likelihood you will, and that’s about the best we can do until we come up with a better way to all survive. Continue reading →

She was fired from the Buffalo police department before she hit her 20 year mark, and finally was vindicated by a decision almost 15 years in the making that her termination was wrongful. So what did former Buffalo cop Cariol Horne do that was so bad that she was thrown off the force? She saved a life.*

On Nov. 1, 2006, a postal worker flagged down a patrol officer to report an argument between a man and a woman at a two-unit house on Walden Avenue. Among the Buffalo police officers responding was Horne. Continue reading →

The killing of Daunte Wright, on the heels of the needlessly aggressive actions of officers who stopped Lt. Caron Nazario, during the trial of Derek Chauvin for the murder of George Floyd, is a “perfect storm.” For what, however, varies wildly.

Is this the moment to revisit whether police should be involved in traffic stops at all? They are too easily abused as pretext stops. The legal justifications range from trivial nonsense that could be better handled by non-police, indeed, cameras, although they too have significant problems that seem to elude those arguing for alternatives. And drunk drivers, dangerous vehicles, harm others. There’s a long list of concerns which are serious when they’re on the front burner, and insignificant when another problem is front and center. Continue reading →