When Charles Lane beat up on 7th Circuit  Judge Richard Posner for talking out of school, his complaint fell flat.

Yet, respect comes from the knowledge that our judges aren’t gaming the system to get to results they prefer. Respect comes from honesty and sincerity, and that comes from being truthful, both to oneself and the public.  Judge Posner told the truth. That’s cause to rejoice, not complain.

But Judge Posner, apparently smarting from Lane’s spanking, couldn’t leave well enough alone.

But in the latest twist, Judge Posner now says he never disavowed the 2007 opinion he wrote for the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Crawford v. Marion County Elections Board. Writing in the New Republic, he says: Continue reading →

In one of the most outrageous and bizarre stories to come out of the dark and ugly annals of the Drug Enforcement Administration protecting us from the plague, Craig Patty was left hanging high and dry after the DEA decided that his life, his family’s life and his business were their toys.

Patty, the owner of a small trucking company in Houston, was never asked if he wanted to become a cog in the DEA’s sting of the Zetas Cartel.  He was never asked if it was cool with him to have his truck, his driver, become part of their covert operation. The DEA didn’t care what Patty thought. Continue reading →

Whenever a story about an inadvertent discharge of a weapon by a police officer appears, people knowledgeable about gun safety will explain how it violated every basic safety rule around.  The point is that the problem isn’t with guns, but improper gun handling. Had the police merely employed proper precautions, it wouldn’t have happened.

While this may be true, it fails to take into account one perpetual problem with the use of weapons by police. They don’t give a damn about firearm safety when it conflicts with the First Rule of Policing.

Continue reading →

Within hours after the Citizens United decision issued, people started asking how big money would fundamentally alter judicial elections. I had my doubts, since buying judges’ loyalties never struck me as a good use of money, and if someone was dying to throw their money away, there were better places to waste it.  And indeed, aside from some high profile purchases, the influence of big outside money didn’t appear to be nearly as serious a problem as initially thought.

From this report by the Center for American Progress, however, it appears that cash for judges may have a more insidious effect than most realize.

As state supreme court campaigns become more expensive and more partisan, the fear of being portrayed as “soft on crime” is leading courts to rule more often for prosecutors and against criminal defendants. Continue reading →

When XKCD first published this comic, everyone who saw it realized how painfully true it was:

A lot of people get very passionate about winning arguments on the internet.  No one “wins” arguments on the internet. Continue reading →

The New York Times editorial applauds the incipient “smart on crime” solutions that are starting to undo the damage of decades of “tough on crime” politics.

The mandatory sentencing movement that swept the United States beginning in the 1970s drove the state prison population up from less than 200,000 to about 1.4 million today and made corrections the second-fastest-growing state expense after Medicaid. But bipartisan sentencing reforms in a growing number of states are starting to reverse that trend — causing the prison population to decline by about 3.8 percent since 2009.

It credits empirical analysis as a better means of determining recidivism: Continue reading →

As a half-snarky response to Tim Cushing’s update to this post about the harm done to students by police educating them on active shooter preparedness, I twitted:

Any more kids harmed today?

And Tim half-snarkily replied:

Day’s still young.

This post at PoliceOne makes me regret my lame attempt at humor.

Police policy was not followed leading up to a school assembly where a student pulled the trigger of an assault rifle mounted on a police motorcycle and three children were injured by bullet fragments, authorities said. Continue reading →

At the New York Times, Tim Kreider complains of how the word “content” went from satisfied to freebie.

NOT long ago, I received, in a single week, three (3) invitations to write an original piece for publication or give a prepared speech in exchange for no ($0.00) money. As with stinkbugs, it’s not any one instance of this request but their sheer number and relentlessness that make them so tiresome. It also makes composing a polite response a heroic exercise in restraint.

People who would consider it a bizarre breach of conduct to expect anyone to give them a haircut or a can of soda at no cost will ask you, with a straight face and a clear conscience, Continue reading →

In a scathing post at The Atlantic, Andrew Cohen wrote of the travesty inflicted on Terrence Miller, both at trial and appeal.

In State v. Terrence Miller, four justices of the state supreme court—over a lone dissent—affirmed the conviction of a man indicted on drug charges who met his lawyer for the first time for a few minutes in a stairwell at the courthouse on the morning of trial. The lawyer had not tried a criminal case in seven years and had been appointed to Miller’s case only four days before trial. He never spoke to any witnesses, or to Miller’s former attorney, or to investigators in the public defender’s office. He didn’t know what his client would say on the witness stand. Continue reading →

I recall the drills in grade school where we were shuffled into the hallway and instructed to crouch down and put our head between our knees.  If an atomic bomb went off, we were ready. Of course, there was a joke about the drill, but nobody told us grade-schoolers about it.

Today, schools are engaging in active shooter drills. Trying to impute the best of faith to those who came up with the idea, it’s because this is perceived as the most likely tragedy that a school can face.  It may not be likely, but it does happen. So why not be prepared?

IF you missed last week’s “mad gunman terrorizes American schoolchildren” news story, Continue reading →