Leave The Supreme Court Alone

With the Iron Maiden canned, Trump has made “the odious Stephen Miller” his new chief of staff. The Democrats could not have asked for a better political gift, Miller being the architect and head cheerleader of the worst and most despised Trump initiatives, from the rounding up and removal to random countries of anyone with skin of a hue less white than his to the murder by the military of people in boats on the open seas.

The 41-year-old Miller embodies much of what America voted against, and Trump’s elevating him to COS, the position closest to Trump and most likely to be the last voice he hears before he indulges in his most unseemly whims, is a declaration of war against America.

At the same time, the question remains whether the Democrats, now in control of Congress as Americans rejected Doodad Donald, will do things to show that they can be trusted to hold power. The New York Times proffered eight “bold” ideas to fix America, each of which is deserving of far deeper consideration than given in its brief recitation. One, however, is particularly troubling, the proposal to “expand the Supreme Court” by Columbia lawprof Jamaal Greene.

The Supreme Court is broken. It has become overtly partisan and has lost touch with the country’s politics. It has used its shadow docket to issue consequential orders without explanation. The justices have no enforceable code of ethics, and reports have emerged of some members taking large gifts from political donors or people who could have business before the court. The usual fixes offered — term limits and partisan court packing — would almost certainly get vetoed by Mr. Trump.

There are, without a doubt, serious problems with the Court. Rule by Shadow Docket is a nightmare, although it’s largely a by-product of Trump’s persistently pushing his power beyond the law. Indeed, dealing with Trump has become the Supreme Court’s primary function over the past decade. It’s almost surprising that the Court finds time to handle anything other than Trump’s machinations du jour.

The question of an enforceable code of ethics is also a vexing problem, although one that eludes an easy fix since the Supreme Court is, by definition, supreme. Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? If the confirmation process were as rigorous as it should be, this might not be an issue. Unfortunately, it’s not rigorous and it is a problem. A solution, however, is hardly so easily found. Sometimes, there is no solution. This is likely such a time.

And while Trump will almost certainly veto any legislation affecting the Court, assuming it doesn’t require a constitutional amendment, which raises an entirely different universe of problems, that alone isn’t an argument not to try. After all, Trump’s blocking reform that Americans applaud might be the best they can do, and will inure to Trump’s detriment for preventing America from righting itself. Of course, this assumes that the Supreme Court is among the big problems that motivated people to vote blue. If exit polls are to be trusted, it was not.

But yes, the Supreme Court has disturbing issues, even if calling it “broken” might be too simplistic a view. So what?

There’s an easier way Congress can address these problems: by uncapping the court’s size and providing for a new justice every two years, indefinitely.

This change would introduce a fixed schedule of appointments unaffected by strategic retirements or a justice’s death. To get around a presidential veto, lawmakers could stipulate that the plan would go into effect only at the start of the next presidential term, giving it a fighting chance at presidential approval.

They’re going to need a bigger bench. And courtroom. And building. Granted, this avoids the overtly partisan calls to load the Supremes with reliable left-wing justices to counter the reliable right-wing justices, which can’t happen anyway since the president nominates justices and Trump is still the president, like it or not. But merely expanding the Court is extolling quantity over quality. What does it accomplish other than adding more people? It would appear that the thought underlying the concept is that after the current crop of justices die off or retire, it will normalize each presidential term getting two nominations. But that’s not all.

As important, a bigger Supreme Court could enable the justices to hear most cases in smaller panels rather than as a whole body. Not knowing who will decide their case would make litigants less aggressive in bringing extreme legal theories before the justices. Justices may be more willing to recuse themselves from cases for ethics concerns, since another justice could fill in. And a larger court could also have dedicated, rotating panels to resolve ethics complaints and hear cases that would otherwise be relegated to the shadow docket, allowing the justices to write reasoned opinions without taking away from the rest of the court’s business.

While it’s not remotely clear how this would work, is there anyone who really thinks it’s a wise idea for the nation to enable a three-justice panel to rule on the constitutionality of a law or act? What are the chances that a panel of Alito, Thomas and Kavanaugh will reach a different result than Kagan, Sotomayor and Jackson? If there is any justification for the Supreme Court to be final, it’s stability. For better or worse, the nation needs to know what is, and what is not, constitutional. Even bad decisions are better than no decisions, leaving us incapable of knowing what we can and cannot do without landing our butts on a prison cot.

But of utmost importance is that this proposal, one of a mere eight to guide the Democrats in their use of power given them by a disgruntled America, doesn’t make the cut to  begin with. Sure, prawfs and a few of us law-talking folks obsess over SCOTUS, but do farmers in Kansas? America has handed the Democrats the levers of Congressional power, and it’s now up to the Dems to show they get how America wants them to use it. Stop the killing and put food on the table and gas in the pickup. Leave the Supreme Court alone.


Discover more from Simple Justice

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

5 thoughts on “Leave The Supreme Court Alone”

    1. David

      Speaking (or listening to) words of wisdom was made a crime punishable by unpopularity and unelectability, so that won’t be the course taken.

      Reply ↓
  1. Advocate from India

    Somewhat surprised to see a professor of law recommending a polyvocal supreme court without any analysis of the weaknesses of such a system. If he wants a real life demonstration of the weaknesses of a polyvocal supreme court, he can look at the Supreme Court of India where smaller panels routinely disagree with each other, making bench-shopping a live concern. The current allocation of cases which lie at the absolute discretion of the CJ of India also allows for subtle manipulation of outcomes e.g. by allocating cases where the govt has an interest to a bench which is known to be pro-government.

    This is a cure worse than the disease.

    Reply ↓
  2. DS

    There needs to be an age limit for the bench (and all federal elected positions), but I’d otherwise agree. The ideas for tinkering with the size/composition of the court offered thus far are no better than the alternatives.

    Reply ↓

Leave a Reply