While Karyann Parkinson’s appeal of her criminal conviction for a parenting decision not to bubble wrap her child remains pending, her application for admission to the bar was approved.
Parkinson was convicted of contributing to the delinquency of a minor, a first-degree misdemeanor in Virginia, because the authorities thought her child was too young to take a walk. The judge sentenced her to six-months in jail, but suspended the sentence. An appeal is pending.
As a consequence of her conviction, Parkinson was added to Virginia’s Child Abuse and Neglect Registry, where she will be listed for the next seven years. Parkinson also feared that the conviction could prevent her from practicing law.
What did Parkinson do that was so bad that it compelled her prosecution?
On a sunny day in June, Karyann Parkinson made a fateful choice that could affect her life for years to come: She let her 5-year-old son, Sam, walk alone to a neighborhood pond to collect goose feathers.
Nothing happened to Sam, at least not physically. But for her choice, Parkinson was charged with contributing to the delinquency of a minor, a first-degree misdemeanor in Virginia. In August, she was convicted by a local judge after a bench trial in the Williamsburg Juvenile & Domestic Relations District Court and given a six-month suspended jail sentence.
Was five too young? Some will believe that it was up to her to exercise parental discretion, knowing both her child and the circumstances well enough to make the right decision. Others will disagree. Others included the Williamsburg Commonwealth Attorney and the district court, which decided that it was bad enough to prosecute and convict her. Notably, she was a law student at the time and has since sought admission to the bar.
Prosecutors brought the charges against Parkinson while she was preparing to take the Virginia Bar exam, and her conviction came while her character and fitness application was under review. It is common to place character and fitness evaluations on hold pending the outcome of legal or disciplinary proceedings, and Parkinson initially received a communication to that effect.
Upon review of the details of Parkinson’s case, however, the Virginia Board of Bar Examiners concluded that nothing alleged against Parkinson cast doubt on her character and fitness to practice law in the Commonwealth of Virginia, and her application was approved. The Williamsburg Commonwealth Attorney should take note.
The situation presents an irreconcilable conflict. Here was an applicant to the bar, subject to character and fitness review, who was convicted of a crime and, pending the outcome of the appeal, a registered child abuser. Should Parkinson prevail on appeal, that conflict goes away, but until that happens, the conviction exists.
Jon Adler calls for the prosecution to “take note,” which is just as true now as it was when it made the fateful decision to prosecute a mother for making a debatable decision in allowing her child some freedom in the first place. But once the prosecution proceeded, and resulted in a bench trial conviction, should the Virginia bar have taken note and respected the fact of conviction?
There has long been a debate over whether applicants for the bar who had been convicted of crimes and completed their sentence should be allowed to practice law. For the most part, it’s been addressed on a case-by-case basis, cognizant of the facts of the case and the nature of the applicant. For the most part, state bars have accepted the premise that a youthful indiscretion shouldn’t preclude someone from being a lawyer forever, and that once they’ve paid their “debt to society” by serving their sentence, they should be allowed to pursue a career as a lawyer.
But here, the case was still pending appeal and Parkinson was still under a cloud due to her being placed on the child abuse registry. Should it have been up to the bar to shrug it off and decide that her conduct wasn’t sufficiently criminal that they need not delay, or disapprove, her admission? Does the bar get to decide what is prosecution worthy, or worse, conviction worthy?
On the other hand, Parkinson’s “crime” smells more like an ideological determination by the proponents of bubble-wrapping kids. It was not so much a crime of child neglect as a crime against the sensibilities of overly protective nosy neighbors and government officials, who believe it’s their duty to impose their sensibilities upon parents’ child-rearing decisions.
Parents understandably agonize over such choices, acutely aware of the consequence of a wrong decision. This is enough for them to worry about. They should not have to worry about government officials second-guessing their choices or threatening criminal charges if a given cop or prosecutor determines a given choice was too permissive. One can conclude Parkinson was too permissive with Sam without thinking her decision was criminal.
Yet, it was prosecuted and resulted in a conviction. Should the Virginia bar simply ignore the conviction, or did they impose their sensibilities on the Commonwealth attorney and convicting judge? The clash happened, but which side should give way?
*Tuesday Talk rules apply.
Discover more from Simple Justice
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

IMHO the bar should focus on crimes that impact the ability to practice law which would generally be crimes of dishonesty.
I would expect “we” would want lawyers to have enough regard for the law not to break them. (That is, the interest wouldn’t be limited to just “dishonesty”).
Disbar the prosecutor.
And get rid of prosecutorial immunity.
So how old does a child have to be to take a walk by him or herself? I can see, at most, letting her know that’s it’s not recommended. The bar did right to approve her application.
Great question. I’ll take the side of formalism because my heart wants to pull for Parkinson over the literal nanny state and I feel the need to disagree with my inclinations. It’s not the bar’s place to be questioning judgments of courts. They should have done what was reported as common place and put her character and fitness application on hold before looking into the facts underlying her conviction. Then, once finally determined, the bar can continue with its processes either admitting her or not to practice. Fair is fair.
Contrary to the bar’s conclusion, if she can’t monitor her child without the state convicting her of negligence, then it sure as shit impacts her fitness to practice law. That is, if we look at the situation agnostically, as the bar should have. Flip the script and hypothetically put a parent who physically beats her child as punishment claiming traditional values and parental rights in Parkinson’s shoes. Now have the bar look the other way because it agrees with those values even though the beating led to conviction pending appeal. Sure not apples to apples with violence involved but corporal punishment only recently went out of fashion. How does that feel?
From what I recall of the situation or at least reading between the lines, she didn’t show sufficient obsequiousness to the authorities involved when confronted. Show some skill, law student, and defuse the situation. Apologize when you don’t mean it and serve your vengeance later. Sure you don’t have to do so, but then you pay the price of having to deal with bullshit sometimes. Flies, honey, vinegar. But that’s very Midwestern of me, I’m told. I won’t judge anyone totally for standing their ground, and yet.
All this said, I’m glad this fell in her favor because I hate the nanny state and disagree with what happened to Parkinson and her family. At the same time, I can be annoyed with how the bar behaved because I love formal process.
How often do such “ambiguous” situations like this arise? Might it generally make more sense to wait until the case is settled (when all the “facts” have come out.
Maybe leaving things as they are is fine even it isn’t perfect. (Nothing is perfect.)
I cheer the bar’s decision. It gives me some hope that the entire legal profession hasn’t lost its collective mind. I suspect that if a jury had been involved, the verdict would have been different. In fact, I wonder if the case would have been brought at all if it had been scheduled to be heard in front of a jury.
In New York a prior conviction is a factor the character committee considers, not an automatic disqualification. One of my friends in law school in the 1980’s served 3 and a half years for armed robbery and applied to law school while he was still behind bars. He was admitted first try in 1988 and was an excellent lawyer and a role model to other offenders before he passed away too soon. I don’t know the rules in Virginia, but in New York Ms. Parkinson would have to do some explaining and the character committee would make its decision. The character committee’s obligation is to consider a pending criminal proceeding and any prior conviction and make an appropriate decision under the circumstances of each case.
As for the underlying merits, the prosecutor should be sanctioned. I grew up in a public housing project in the Bronx in the fifties. On my fifth or sixth birthday my parents told me I was a big boy now and gave me four pennies to take across the street all by myself to the candy store to buy a Daily Mirror for my parents. It was my first rite of passage. Now I suspect my father may have been watching me out of sight., But I looked both ways and crossed Burke Avenue all by myself and did my first chore with a smile on my face and pride in my heart.
The Virginia bar made the right decision.
The BAR used common sense, which I applaud.
CPS on the other hand, is filled with idiots. They should have determined that the neglect was unfounded.
However, they like to throw their power around.
From personal experience dealing with the foster system and adoption I three types that work for DCS.
The lawyers that work for DCS are there because they can’t do anything else. BTDT and dealt with them.
None of them use common sense. The cops defaulted to DCS because that’s their guidance. The security guard is a low IQ doing what he’s told with a chip on his shoulder.
I hope she gets her appeal.
As a resident I will say this with all due fervor “FUCK VIRGINIA!!” Remember this is also the state that elected a man who fantasizes about committing murder as the state AG. And it’s the state that just wrote the legalized the murder of children up to and during childbirth into the state constitution. So much for them “Caring about the welfare of children”.
I hate this state and am trying hard to convince my wife to move out of this shithole. However, I do support the bars decision in this one matter.