There has been much discussion about priorities as the next Congress formulates its investigative agenda. Now that the Democrats hold majorities in both houses, they have the ability to subpoena both witnesses and records as they choose, ranging from the war in Iran to the donors to the Trump ballroom. Whether their priorities will garner public support is another matter, given the internal conflict within the Democratic Party as to how their newfound power should be used.
But what hasn’t been discussed as much is whether their efforts, regardless of priorities, will bear fruit or be the next battleground. Trump’s pitbull, Stephen Miller, is determined to make sure that the Dems get nothing.
“If you’re not ready for these fights, you’re going to be in a whole lot of trouble legally and politically,” said Hogan Gidley, a White House deputy press secretary in the first Trump administration. “They have a really good plan and have a good leader at the top in Stephen Miller. He is primed and ready for this fight, like no one else would be.”
While clashes between lawmakers and the White House over congressional investigations are not unusual, the escalating threats could result in a remarkable battle that reshapes the balance of power between the two branches of government. Legal experts have said the White House’s contention that congressional investigations “may cross the line into blatant criminality” pushes the bounds of the law, but much remains unclear about how the courts might handle the coming fights.
Quietly, the Department of Justice Office of Legal Counsel issued an opinion stating that communications with the president by people outside government are still protected by presidential privilege.
The Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel over the summer quietly published an opinion asserting that even communications by those outside government could be covered by executive privilege if they concerned Mr. Trump and his top aides.
While OLC opinions aren’t laws, but merely internal guidance for the government, they provide the foundation for potential witnesses to refuse to answer based on executive privilege. The congressional committees could, of course, reject this assertion and demand answers upon pain of contempt. Then comes the next problem.
“Although the Democrats control the Congress, the administration still controls the Department of Justice, and so to the extent that people get referred for contempt under the criminal statute, I don’t expect that to go anywhere,” he said.
The chance that Blanche’s DoJ will take action for Congress by pursuing contempt prosecution is essentially nonexistent. While the sergeant-at-arms could be directed to arrest a witness under the “inherent contempt” authority, it’s a “dormant” power. Congress may well have the theoretical power, but without an executive branch willing to back it up, it’s toothless.
But the administration isn’t satisfied with merely playing defense.
On Saturday, the president posted on social media: “Threatening letters have been sent to many people, all innocent, from Democrat Political Leaders. By copy of this statement, I am ordering the Department of Justice to look into this criminal act, immediately!”
Top lawyers across the federal government snapped into action.
White House counsel Will Scharf sent notice to Rep. Robert Garcia, incoming chair of the House Oversight Committee, that his oversight could be investigated as a crime, the Speech and Debate Clause notwithstanding. Southern District of Texas (?) United States Attorney Aaron Reitz threatened Senator Richard Blumenthal with “significant legal consequences” if he investigates the donors to Trump’s ballroom.
Blanche joined the chorus as well.
At a news conference, Mr. Blanche said there were “no ongoing criminal investigations” into statements made by incoming members of Congress. Nevertheless, he said, Justice Department officials were concerned about some of the statements made after the election.
“There can come a point when a criticism becomes a threat,” Mr. Blanche said, adding, “There are threats, which can be allowed as well, but at some point it does become a crime.”
While the threatened Dems have stated that they will not be intimidated by the administration’s threats of criminal prosecution, and there is essentially no question that these threats will ultimately be found specious, it does not mean that legal maneuvering won’t manage to tie up the committees and their members in court for long enough to make these efforts fruitless. When the executive branch of government refuses to do its job when it’s the target of congressional investigations, there is little it can do to enforce its demands.
To make matters worse, after the Supreme Court’s decision in United States v. Trump, it’s unclear what the courts will do when witnesses asked about corruption by Trump and his minions refuse to answer based on executive privilege. It may well turn out that the ruling not only immunizes Trump from prosecution for crimes, but prevents any oversight into the president’s corruption itself.
The Dems may well have ambitious plans to reveal how the levers of government have been used illegally, but the question of whether their plans are the right ones will only be answered after it’s determined that they can make oversight happen at all. With an Attorney General who sees his mandate as doing whatever Trump tells him to do, the notion of investigating Trump’s corruption seems aspirational at best. Even if Congress ultimately wins this battle, it will almost certainly result in sufficient delay to blunt any effectiveness in addressing executive branch corruption.
Discover more from Simple Justice
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Anyone with two functional brain cells will see this as nothing but political theater.
Besides, Trump will pardon everyone so nothing happens except a waste of time.
“Congress may well have the theoretical [contempt] power, but without an executive branch willing to back it up, it’s toothless.”
If an unwilling executive isn’t what a special prosecutor is for, then all it takes for that to become what it’s for is for Congress to stand up and say it long enough with a straight face. Or at least so Trump seems to believe.
While they all screw around, interest rates and inflation chart their own course. Nobody can indict the bond market, though perhaps I shouldn’t give anyone ideas.