There’s a phenomenon among the sick and pathetic randos of both the right and left that they not only take measures to damage their hated targets of cancel culture, but that they take matters a step too far. It’s one thing to blame the person who did whatever it is that outrages the rando mob, but it’s quite another to inflict harm on their employers, businesses, family and friends. In Couture v. Noshirvan, Middle District of Florida Judge Kyle Dudek found that it crossed the line.
[T]he story begins with a viral video of a parking-lot argument. Convinced that one of the women [Couture] had broken the law, Noshirvan set out to uncover her identity. He deployed a “sock puppet” social media account, posing as a concerned bystander to gain her trust. The ruse worked, and Couture unwittingly confirmed her involvement. Armed with that info, Noshirvan published a TikTok video broadcasting both Couture’s name and her employer—Garramone Plastic Surgery.
Noshirvan’s followers quickly took to the comments with ideas for how to retaliate. One suggested to “schedule appointments and not show up[.]” Another pitched calling Garramone Plastic Surgery to ask about Couture. And two users went so far as to agree that “we are now working on reviews for his business[.]” Just as the comments suggested, Garramone Plastic Surgery received emails, voicemails, and fictitious reviews….
Many of us engaged in online commentary have experienced this phenomenon. I’ve been both the target of social media ire and dealt with commenters attempting to use SJ as a means of perpetuating their attack by trying to post information about employers, home addresses and telephone numbers, and even providing names of children and their schools. The purpose of such extreme doxxing is clear: to push for secondary retaliation against their enemies. They care nothing about the damage done to innocent businesses or family members, as long as it exacts revenge on the target of their hatred.
Noshirvan didn’t exactly tell his mob to destroy Couture’s employer’s business, but by revealing the name of the employer and imploring his followers to call Garramone Plastic Surgery “to ask about Couture,” the message was clear. And when his followers came up with ways of damaging the business, Noshirvan made no effort to prevent it from happening.
There is no shortage of evidence showing both protected business relationships and Noshirvan’s knowledge of them. Garramone Plastic Surgery’s testimony highlights interference with its existing patients and with Dr. Allison Yee, an associate physician who left the practice amid the fallout. Florida law does not require Noshirvan to know these individuals by name. He merely had to know the business relationships existed. The targeted nature of the online attack—especially the bogus reviews planted on the Yelp and Google pages—is more than enough for a jury to infer that Noshirvan knew he was interfering with the practice’s clientele.
Further, there is evidence of competent damages. Garramone Plastic Surgery testified that it lost about $900,000 in non-surgical procedures and $130,000 in surgical procedures. Then there are the costs Garramone Plastic Surgery incurred for security personnel and a security surveillance system.
Should that give rise to liability for Noshirvan under tortious interference with business? The court held that was a question for the jury.
What is not clear though, is whether there was intentional, unjustified interference…. But Noshirvan’s intent in making his posts is best left for the jury. A reasonable jury could conclude Noshirvan’s intent was to harass and target Garramone Plastic Surgery. [Plaintiff’s theory is that] {Noshirvan incited his followers to flood Garramone Plastic Surgery with false reviews, calls, and emails.} … A reasonable jury could also conclude, however, that Noshirvan’s intent was just to harass and target Couture.
The judge’s distinction, that the specific intent to do harm was directed at Couture rather than Garramone Plastic Surgery, seems rather weak and conflicted. That Noshirvan sought to incite his followers to do harm to Couture by secondary means of damaging Garramone to compel Garramone to take adverse action against Couture is a distinction without a difference. The employer was damaged regardless, and was swept into the scheme of attacking Couture so as to make Noshirvan’s intentions to do damage the overarching purpose. It wasn’t that Noshirvan and his followers had any particular grievance with Garramone Plastic Surgery beyond the fact that it employed Couture, but that it specifically intended to harm Garramone in furtherance of its intent to destroy Couture.
For those of us online who might be critical of what an individual says or does, the object of our criticism is the person or court that did the dirty deed. We neither advocate for, or enable by providing information, that will inflict damage on others even if the harm will ultimately inure to the detriment of the target of our criticism Indeed, we consciously prevent the online crazies from doing so by deleting comments that provide home addresses, telephone numbers or employer information.
Noshirvan not only went out of his way to surreptitiously obtain that information, but to broadcast it to his followers for the obvious purpose of inciting action against both his target and her employer. Much as it may be hard to imagine that there are sick, pathetic people who have nothing better to do than spend their time attacking and trying to harm people and businesses their “thought leaders” tell them to attack, they exist and they are all too happy to cause harm to others.
Anyone inciting such conduct should be liable for their actions, and that liability should not depend on too fine of a point of who they specifically intend to harm. When they incite others to cause harm, they know what they’re doing and to whom it will be done. Liability for tortious interference should follow.
Discover more from Simple Justice
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

In which we learn again that “eye for an eye” was never about allowing maximal punishment, but limiting the human desire to punish to something proportional to the offense.
The people who engage in these behaviors believe they enjoy the anonymity of the mob, and that they are free to do any amount of harm without ever being held accountable. Some examples of reality may prove useful in correcting their erroneous assumptions.
Full disclosure: I know Dudek as a DJ, MJ and lawyer. He has a baby face and a very sturdy brain.
“Anyone inciting such conduct should be liable for their actions, and that liability should not depend on too fine of a point of who they specifically intend to harm.”
Then they’ll need a different claim. TI requires this specific showing, and not just in the Swamp.
But the case is a hoot. So is the companion case mentioned in the order. It was brought by Noshirvan on similar claims. There are about a billion lawyers involved, so most of the claims were virtual non-starters–they could survive dismissal, but had no real factual basis. Since the facts were about as concrete as a Reddit post, lawyers were sanctioned. There’s a long-lived rule in the Swamp: Miami lawyers should stay there.
Isn’t the point that while Norshivan desired that the ultimate harm come to Couture, he specifically intended, by definition, to harm Garramone in the process of achieving that ultimate harm? He might not have had anything against Garramone, per se, but deliberately incited the outrage mob to attack Garramone in order to get Couture?
It’s a no collateral damage tort.