The next chair of the House Oversight Committee, Rep. Robert Garcia, sent out letters that thrilled the hearts of every host on MSNOW.
Rep. Robert Garcia, who is expected to be the next chair of the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, sent letters to [sons Donald Trump Jr. and Eric Trump to chief of staff Stephen Miller, former chief Susie Wiles and Vice President JD Vance inter alia] Wednesday morning, indicating they will be subjects of interest to the panel next year as he prepares to make good on his promise to probe Trump family business ties, ICE’s mass deportation campaign, the administration’s handling of the Epstein files and more.
There’s only one problem. and White House counsel Will Scharf was only too happy to point it out.
“Your demands do not reflect a request of the House, Senate, or a committee to which that body’s oversight authority has been delegated,” White House counsel Will Scharf wrote in a letter to Democratic lawmakers dated Wednesday and obtained by POLITICO.
“As a result, Ranking Member requests in the 119th Congress do not trigger any obligation to ‘accommodate … the needs of the conflicting branches,’” the letter said. “Although some of you may (or may not) become a Chair in the 120th Congress, that does not mean that requests from the 119th Congress carry over,” he added.
As if the point needed to be driven home, Scharf added “This should not be surprising to you given the Biden Administration took the same position.” Ouch.
The letters requested that the targets retain documents, as opposed to burn them on John Mitchell’s backyard barbecue, so that the evidence will exist when the 120th Congress takes its seats come January 3, It’s not only a reasonable request, but one of some grave significance given rumors that the Trump administration was destroying papers that they would prefer not be revealed. Spoliation is a terrible thing. Much as it would seem wrong for government officials to destroy documents that would reveal malfeasance, if not crimes, there is no law that says they can’t.
There is, of course, the Presidential Records Act of 1978, born out of Nixon’s attempt to conceal his wrongdoing, but the Trump DoJ Office of Legal Counsel opined that it was unconstitutional. There is also the Federal Records Act, but its scope is limited and more addressed to process than substance, and leaves the ultimate determination of whether a record must be retained to the discretion of the Archivist of the United States, currently Trump appointee Bradford Wilson.
Painful as it may be to acknowledge that Will Scharf is right, he’s right. The requests by Garcia are of no legal consequence as he’s merely the ranking member until such time as the majority in Congress flips and he speaks for the committee. That doesn’t mean, however, that come January 3rd, the administration will suddenly become cooperative.
Scharf said Democrats will be able to issue oversight requests come January, and the administration is “committed to working with future Chairs consistent with the Executive Branch’s constitutional and statutory obligations and applicable limits on the oversight authority of Congress,” including requests made with a “legitimate legislative purpose.” But he added that the White House’s commitment to this is “colored” and “qualified” by the “‘pettiness’ promised by one potential incoming chair” — a reference to remarks Garcia made earlier this month.
While Congress, once considered first among equals when it comes to oversight of the functions of our tripartite government, is charged with oversight with the power and process to investigate the workings of the Trump administration, its authority is limited to matters in furtherance of “a legitimate legislative purpose.” Unsurprisingly, Scharf characterized the ranking members’ requests as vindictive.
But Scharf also slammed the intent of Democrats’ letters, saying they “drip with an animus or pettiness” reflective of an intent to “harass and aggrandize” instead of conduct legitimate oversight.
Rep. Jamie Rankin, former constitutional lawprof and soon-to-be chair of the House Judiciary Committee, disagreed.
“As the Supreme Court has repeatedly found, Congress has a broad constitutional responsibility and power to conduct oversight in order to legislate,” Raskin said in a statement. “We strongly suggest tuning out any third-party ‘advice’ to obstruct and defy Congress on the basis of specious legal theories.”
There is a strong argument that the matters raised by the Garcia letters have a clear relation to legitimate legislative concerns, as the rampant violation of laws and norms by the executive give rise to both the need to stop the bleeding and enact laws to prevent such executive actions in the future. There is also a strong argument that there is a great deal of well-earned animus toward Trump and his minions who have enabled, and engaged in, impropriety.
From now until the next Congress, Republican chairs are placed in a precarious position of either supporting their soon-to-be majority brethren or backing Trump. Whatever happens over the next month plus will come back to bite them in the butt when the tables have turned, just as the Biden administration’s refusal to cooperate with Republican minority requests do now.
Even so, it’s already quite clear that the Trump administration is prepared to go to war with Congress to stymie oversight and tie it up in court for as long as possible, with the hope of a compliant Supreme Court decision ultimately saving it from itself. Should Republican chairs choose to protect Trump, it will add another complication to the War Over Oversight that they will likely regret in time.
Discover more from Simple Justice
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
