Tuesday Talk*: Who Will Protect The Voters?

There will almost certainly be accusations, if not legal battles, by Trump against election officials in various states and cities claiming that they violated the law by not denying putative citizens with names ending in vowels or swarthy complexions the right to vote. But there is a much more immediate concern that will arise next Tuesday, November 3rd, when the mass of Americans go to the polls to vote in the midterm elections.

The Trump administration said it would dispatch around 1,000 election monitors to polling places across the country. It’s important to remember that under the law, election monitors are entitled to observe polling places, but they cannot administer elections, determine voter eligibility or direct any election officials.

Former Knick and United States Senator from New Jersey Bill Bradley is almost right. They cannot legally do so, but that doesn’t mean they can’t physically try. What if a federal election observer directs a poll worker to check a person’s identification or not allow them to vote? What if that observer puts his hand on a putative voter’s arm and demands that he prove he’s a citizen? What if the observer pulls out his cellphone camera and takes a picture of the voter, informing him that he’s sending it to ICE agents for investigation?

State and local election officials may find themselves in a terrible bind. They are not supposed to take orders from the president or any federal agency. The law across all 50 states is clear that they must not obey illegal orders of any kind, including those issued by the federal government.

If they decide to comply with such illegal directions or instructions, election officials could face civil or criminal penalties. Under the law, they can be sued personally in civil court by anyone with standing and held responsible in court if they follow an improper order by the federal government about the administration of the election system, with sizable monetary damages as a possible result.

Poll workers tend to be older folks, some working as volunteers and others at minimum-wage temporary jobs where they feel that they’re trying to contribute to the system by working for free and fair elections. They don’t want to become a boldface name on the front page of the New York Times, a cause célèbre for boldly standing up to the threat, if not physical force, of a federal observer or agent. That’s not what they signed up for. That’s not what they were trained for.

But who will protect poll workers and voters from federal interference?

In an interview with Time magazine, Mr. Trump declined to rule out sending ICE agents to polling places. Three federal laws — including protections signed by Abraham Lincoln — prohibit federal troops and agents from interfering in elections. If Justice Department or ICE agents show up claiming emergency powers, election officials should say that none of their instructions will be obeyed without a court order signed by a judge. The “administrative warrants” issued by the Department of Homeland Security are not sufficient. Only an order with the John Hancock of a state or federal judge compels any action.

There are laws that prohibit the federal government from interfering in elections. Even if Attorney General Todd Blanche fails to grasp why ICE agents harassing, challenging, detaining and seizing people as they walk into the polling place might be a problem, citizens at risk of being stopped, detained, arrested, beaten or killed understand.

Of course, if a citizen who falls short of Trump’s preferred heritage refuses to comply with their command to drop to the ground, there will be trouble and it will be justified by claiming they resisted federal agents. Citizen or not, they could well end up in an African prison. But if the agents are present and issue orders, and the American citizen can’t do anything to defend himself, what recourse is there?

Will state and local officials call out their law enforcement to protect their citizens from illegal federal actions? Will the cops protect voters from observers and ICE agents? Will police use whatever force is necessary to repel the federal agents who would commit a crime by interfering with their state’s citizenry?

Will governors and mayors order them to do their job of protecting their citizens from crime, whether committed by criminals with or without a badge? If they do, will the police comply? And if the police comply, what will they do when a federal agent pulls his taser or gun and orders them to back away or else?

Senator Bradley is right that there are organizations ready, willing and able to address the legal proceeding that will come to the defense of election workers and voters. But that won’t fix the problem of citizens being denied their right to vote in the moment. Who will protect Americans on the ground one week from today from federal interference in the exercise of this fundamental right?

*Tuesday Talk rules apply.


Discover more from Simple Justice

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

11 thoughts on “Tuesday Talk*: Who Will Protect The Voters?”

  1. Jeff

    I wonder if the thought of potential House investigations will temper some of the worst impulses. Yes, he has promised pardons but those will go to the top people only. Perhaps a lowly branch chief will moderate the orders to the troops to prevent what you describe in the interest of their future. Hope springs eternal.

    1. Hal

      Actually, SCOTUS is scheduled to hear arguments in December on whether we, the people, can be “defanged”.

      As it’s Tuesday and the rules are relaxed, here’s a link to a Reason piece on Cook County arguing “Even if AR-15s are covered by the Second Amendment, …that doesn’t mean Americans have a right to own them.”;

      https://reason.com/2026/10/22/defending-its-ar-15-ban-cook-county-urges-scotus-to-ignore-the-rifles-popularity/

      And another in which Al Sayed acknowledges that the Bill of Rights was intended “to protect people from government tyranny”, but also claiming the Second Amendment protects only muskets;

      https://reason.com/2026/10/26/abdul-el-sayed-would-freeze-the-bill-of-rights-in-the-18th-century/

      Unfortunately, this abysmally low level of clarity and coherence and inherently contradictory reasoning is not limited to DSA candidates and Cook County’s attorneys. A surprisingly large number of, otherwise reasonable appearing, people see the AR-15 as “Schrodinger’s rifle”, at once a weapon of war that is too dangerous for mere civilians to own and yet too ineffective to prevent or deter tyranny.

      How SCOTUS will rule isn’t clear, but Bruen’s requiring an historically analogous law would seem to doom Cook County’s argument

      1. PK

        You have no right to resist unlawful arrest with an AR-15 or otherwise. The abrogation of the common law right only happened in the last century. Without the right, guns are a useful distraction, Hal, not the point. Like it or not but the concept of the “rugged individual” who defends his rights and property wholly by himself is naught but a myth, or an opiate, if you will.

        My guns don’t turn my bleating into a roar and neither do yours. A million or two of us lead by a lion, maybe, but good luck with that.

        1. Hal

          PK,

          I think you are “assuming facts not in evidence”, or perhaps attributing “thoughts and opinions not expressed” to me.

          So, to be clear, I do not support nor have I advocated any unlawful activity such as resisting arrest or armed insurrection.

          You said that we’ve been “defanged” and I pointed out that SCOTUS would soon be weighing the issue of our right to, metaphorical, “fangs” and how pathetic and disingenuous the arguments of those who’d unconstitutionally restrict the RKBA, that is “defang” the people, submitted to SCOTUS actually are.

          I most emphatically DO NOT want to see any flavor of civil war or armed insurrection in this nation. I don’t entertain any fantasies of being a modern day minute man.

          That said, the stakes are very high and I fear we’re closer to civil war than any time since ~ 1860. I can, all too easily, imagine a scenario where AR-15s and similar weapons are banned, in what would seem to me (and I’m certain would seem to many others) as an unconstitutional denial of a fundamental right.

          The 2026 National Firearms Survey suggests that twenty two million Americans own roughly forty million AR-15s and some millions of other “assault weapons”. I’ve no idea how many subscribe to the sentiment, “When tyranny becomes law, rebellion becomes duty” and would be prepared to take up arms against the government if their firearms were banned, but I’m certain some will be tempted to do so.

          If there were only ten million of these weapons in private hands and only one tenth of one percent (0.1%) of them were to be so enraged or incensed that that they decided violence was justified… that would be ten thousand people. If even one hundred of them decided to start ambushing police and assassinating politicians they’d create an appalling level of chaos. (Do you recall how Christopher Dorner nearly shut down LA in 2013? Imagine that happening, simultaneously, in a couple dozen cities, large and small across, the US.)

          Such attacks would be likely to both embolden others to commit similar assaults and to cause the government to implement harsh and unconstitutional measures in an effort to crack down/ curtail the violence. Maybe, just maybe, cooler heads would prevail and find some way to “put the toothpaste back in the tube”. I’m not sure that’s the way to bet.

          Far better, I think, to respect the founders’ intentions and the rights of millions of Americans who own AR-15s and are unlikely to ever use them to engage in violence than to effectively dare them to do so.

        1. Hal

          davep,

          I’m not sure if the above was directed to me or PK.

          If the former, both pcs linked to were from Reason, and it’s not clear which you were referring to.

          If you’d care to elaborate, I’m happy to discuss whatever it is you think I missed.

          TIA

  2. B Ambrose

    It’s far from clear exactly who the Administration thinks it can dispatch. Polling sites are strictly regulated. There are guard-rails in place to prevent misconduct by election monitors, at least in Florida where I have served as a poll worker in two counties over the last ten years. Yep, I’m one of those old retired volunteers. Law enforcement officers of any agency are allowed inside the polling station only to vote, not to observe. Monitors are called “Poll Watchers” here, they must be registered in advance with and approved by the County Supervisor of Elections. They are provided written guidance on their participation. A person cannot walk in off the street to observe. In my experience they are permitted to watch from a clearly marked off area in the polling room (usually a corner of the room away from the registration desk and the rows of voting booths) and are not allowed to wander around the room, stroll by voting booths, or interact with voters or any poll worker except for the Poll Clerk (the person in charge). I do not think any Poll Watcher here would get anywhere trying to tell a Poll Worker or the Poll Clerk to check someone’s ID. The worker would raise their hand to call the Poll Clerk over to intercede, and the Poll Clerks I’ve worked with have been “no-nonsense” people, in part, no doubt because they’ve understood they have exposure to legal liabilities for malfeasance and misfeasance. The required classroom training for Poll Workers and Poll Clerks every election includes the restrictions on Poll Watchers. All the poll workers and clerks with whom I’ve served have been seriously committed to a fair process and they would not have hesitated to cry “foul!” The Poll Clerk has the authority to have them removed by the Sheriff, and while I’ve seen a Poll Clerk rein in a zealous Watcher who was not observing the boundaries I’ve never seen a need for a Sheriff’s Deputy to get involved. In addition, the County Elections offfice assigns poll workers to a precinct based in part on their party affiliation with the goal of achieving an even balance between Democrat and Republican workers, and unaffiliated voters (like me) are thrown in to the mix as well. Finally, the only Federal monitor who is not a registered Poll Watcher” that I can envision would be an AUSA and they typically sit in their offices waiting for a call, they don’t have authority to intervene. Besides, having been an AUSA I know there aren’t enough of them to go around. None of this means there won’t be shenanigans somewhere by the overzealous of either party, but I believe that poll workers, clerks and voters alike are especially tuned in this election to such a degree that I hope the fears raised here turn out to be insignificant. My two cents from the sandbox.

    1. Skink

      The administration and its agencies don’t care about the law or policies. When it comes to them, the past isn’t a bee’s shit predictor of current action.

      But there’s a bigger problem for the Swamp if these “monitors” are actually agents or otherwise act unlawfully: the proximity of deputies. Last year, a part of Florida’s concealed-carry law was found unconstitutional. I don’t have time to make a full explanation of what happened, but it left a hole in the law–open carry of a long gun isn’t illegal in a non-governmental polling place, like a church. Like I said, I don’t have time for the explanation, but you can take it to the bank.

      Nearly every election official has arranged for deputies to be in those parking lots, if not in the buildings. I’ve done work for 20 Swamp sheriff’s offices. Deputies have a universal opinion of feds: they come in, assume jurisdiction and fuck-up the case. They are unwanted and disliked.

      Should the “monitors” act unlawfully, especially in the instance of a nitwit voting while wearing an AK, real trouble could happen.

  3. Knotta Lawyer

    Journalist Andrew Gumbel wrote, “But the law clearly prevents him from deploying troops or law enforcement at polling stations, and any attempt to do so is likely to be short-circuited by a swift injunction from the nearest court…” I am not sure that he is correct.

Comments are closed.