The New York Times reports that Mary Peltola, the Democratic candidate for Senator from Alaska, pulled a dirty trick. Her campaign sought out a person with the same name as the incumbent Republican Senator, convinced him to run as a Republican, supported his candidacy, and, most importantly, lied about it.
The Peltola campaign has repeatedly denied any involvement in his candidacy. But The Times has found, based on interviews and text messages, along with documents prepared for a potential lawsuit against the campaign, that not only did Ms. Peltola’s team work with people trying to recruit Mr. Sullivan to run for Senate, but the effort was much broader. The group worked to coax other would-be spoilers into the race, to dilute the incumbent’s support and help catapult the Democrat to victory.
Unsurprisingly, Trump demanded she resign from the race and called for her to be criminally prosecuted, not that he could point to any crime committed. Thus far, no one has pointed to any plausible crime, but it certainly falls within the dirty trick ambit. As Vance is fond of saying, politics is dirty business, but then, since when is Vance the arbiter of propriety?
Democrats immediately pointed to the myriad dirty tricks and lies, which have happened with both far greater frequency, and far worse, than this. “Whataboutism” is no less fallacious when done by Democrats than Republicans. As for the Republicans, the pearl clutching was stunning. The rank hypocrisy of embracing Trump’s lies and dirty tricks while condemning Peltola’s broke the irony meter.
But that doesn’t make Peltola’s conduct either the end of the world or acceptable. If she did what she’s accused of doing, and it certainly appears that she was well aware that her campaign introduced a spoiler to siphon votes away from the incumbent and then she lied about it, its wrongfulness stands alone and warrants scrutiny. In the grand scheme of this election, it doesn’t mean Senator Dan Sullivan is the better choice. After all, he remains part of the MAGA machine, backing Trump’s pathological lying, corruption and violations of the Constitution. Sullivan doesn’t come to this election clean.
The Democrats, nonetheless, have to squarely face the reality that their one and only claim to take the Congress is that they are not Trump. You cannot simultaneously wrap yourself in virtue to distinguish yourself from the most venal and corrupt person to ever darken the Oval Office and engage in dirty tricks, then lie about it. No, it was not the dirtiest of tricks. No, it was not the worst of lies, paling in comparison to Trump’s routine stump speech content. But it was still a lie.
There is a cohort in the Democratic Party that applauds Peltola’s action. They argue that the Reps have played dirty, very dirty, for years, and so it’s time that the Dems play dirty as well. We teach children that two wrongs don’t make a right, and yet they share the Trumpian view that anything that achieves their desired end is justified. The ends do not justify the means. The means are what distinguishes good and decent people from their adversaries. Peltola did not honor that distinction.
Politics can be a very ugly business, trying to promote a candidate whose accomplishments, abilities or intentions fall far short of what they want the voters to believe, and denigrate their adversaries for things that are twisted beyond truth to turn supporters away. There are a lot of lies. There are a great many distortions. There is rampant dishonesty. It is not for the faint-hearted.
None of this excuses what happened here. Yes, it pales in comparison to what the Republicans have done, both in terms of awful but not illegal dirty tricks and lies. Mary Peltola has now been branded a liar. This changes the question of whether to vote for the virtuous candidate or the MAGA sycophant, with all that implies, to whether to vote for the lying trickster or the MAGA sycophant.
The shame of it all is that Peltola didn’t need to engage in this ploy to have a real chance of prevailing, given the unpopularity of Trump and the consequences of his vast array of failures. But here we are.
Discover more from Simple Justice
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Hopefully not too far off topic but perhaps unsurprisingly Trump is blowing the Rs political advantage on this one by going full on asshole and calling for her to be criminally prosecuted. By doing what he does he risks turning Sullivan from a victim of sorts to the unsightly aggressor. I agree it doesnt change Peltola’s underlying conduct but Trump may very well blunt the public perception of it by being an even bigger asshole about it.
Skulduggery was a major staple of Imperial Rome. Ambitus, electoral bribery, led to massive borrowing to rig elections. It led to the civil war between Pompey and Caesar. Res Repetundae, provincial plundering, was rampant (think if Cicero’s defense of Verres the corrupt governor of Sicily). Donativum, Imperial extortion, transitioned Republicans Rome to the Empire. Am I the only one to notice the eerie similarity between Donativum and Donald? Yes, we have transitioned from a Republic to Empire. We now have to expect the skulduggery on a more frequent basis. Frankly, running another Sullivan is a somewhat puerile form of skulduggery. Of course we have recently transitioned. Our Augustus while publicly outraged and calling for Peltola’s withdrawal from the race, is probably laughing privately at the amateurish efforts by Alaskan Democrats. It lacks sophistication. Worse, it lacks style. We are living in a new Golden Age. We know that because Our Augustus keeps telling us so. The new White House ballroom will be covered in gold, like the Oval Office is now (to impress the foreign barbarians who come to pay tribute). Now that is skulduggery with style. How can these rustic Democrats possibly compete with Caesar?
I’m going to walk into my voting station and hold my nose while I cast my ballot. I feel like I’m going to be walking into a cesspool. I’ll need to take an acid shower afterwards.
There is no lessor of two evils.
I’ve followed the national news and Arizona is just as bad if not worse. Both sides are doing it and the slander, family attacks and out of context quotes are horrific. Attack websites are rampant.
No wonder decent people don’t want to run.
A plague on all their houses.
“…and violations of the Constitution.”
Where has any court ruled Trump violated the Constitution?
“…to whether to vote for the lying trickster or the MAGA sycophant.”
Is not the answer obvious? “Better the devil you know than the devil you don’t.” A liar can be a MAGA sycophant or worse.
If you were either a lawyer or a regular reader here, you wouldn’t ask such an asinine question. If you want an answer, read the past two years worth of posts.
Attributed to Tullius Cicero.
Non nocebit suffragatores admonere quanti scelerati sint tui adversarii et eos quavis data occasione maculare.
“It wouldn’t hurt to remind the voters of what scoundrels your opponents are and to smear them at every opportunity….”
Democrats should have learned 10 years ago to stay the hell out of Republican primaries. I guess that’s too much to ask
I don’t see how this is any different than the AI generated ads of Josh Shapiro that the Garrity campaign is running here in PA. It past time for Democrats to get dirty. You gotta get in the mud to wrestle a pig.
The Alaska ballot is pretty clear on which Dan Sullivan is which. If GOP voters can’t figure it out, perhaps they are too stupid to vote.
61 years ago I joined Martin Luther King’s march from Selma to Montgomery to get Congress to pass the 1965 Voting Rights Act to outlaw literacy requirements because we believed no one was too stupid to vote.
Was the failure to report contributions to the phony Dan Sullivan campaign as contributions to Perolta a violation of FECA? If the violation was wilful it may have been a criminal offense. Kinda like Trump’s failure to report his hush money to Stormy Daniels as a campaign contribution.
Edwin Edwards’ Bumper Sticker in 1991 Louisiana Gubernatorial Race Against David Duke: “Vote For The Crook. It’s Important!”