A telltale of the Trump Department of Justice was who would be willing to sign off, to appear in court, to assert and argue some of the most specious and absurd positions taken by the Trump administration to circumvent the law and make Trump’s wildest dreams come true. One such guy was senior adviser to the Attorney General, Henry Whitaker.
Back in November 2025, in an effort to resuscitate the failed prosecutions of James Comey and Letitia James, Whitaker told Judge Cameron McGowan Currie that Comey and James were trying to “elevate what is at best a paperwork error,” when they flagged the fact that they were being prosecuted by a random insurance lawyer with a MAGA hat. At the time, he called it “fanciful” to suggest that the DOJ sought to evade Senate confirmation by continuing to treat Lindsey Halligan as the U.S. Attorney. Currie tossed both indictments anyway.
As no dead horse goes unbeaten by this administration, Whitaker took the matter to the Fourth Circuit, opening his September argument thusly:
That decision is wrong on its merits and in no event would dismissal of the indictments be an appropriate remedy for what can be at best described as an error in the title that Ms. Halligan used when she presented before the grand juries and signed the indictments.
The “error in the title” here was Halligan saying she held all the authority of a U.S. Attorney, when she meant to say she had no authority whatsoever. Chief Judge Albert Diaz asked whether Whitaker’s reading of the law would allow a president to constantly reappoint interim appointees forever, thereby cutting both the courts and the Senate out of the process. Whitaker said the administration had “no incentive.” Judge Diaz pushed back:
No, no, no. See, that’s not responsive. You’re saying you have no incentive. But under your reading of the statute, a nefarious, ne’er-do-well executive could do exactly that, right?
Whitaker replied:
Well, in theory, Your Honor, well, in theory or not, Your Honor, yes.
Like other rats fleeing the sinking ship, Whitaker resigned last Friday. But don’t cry for poor Henry, as he will be sitting in a corner office at Biglaw firm Dechert come Monday.
“Henry is an elite litigator who understands how legal and policy decisions take shape within government and what those decisions can mean for businesses,” said Michael McGinley, co-chair of Dechert’s securities and complex litigation practice. “His experience serving at the highest levels of the U.S. and Florida governments, combined with nearly two decades of appellate advocacy arguing before the U.S. Supreme Court, nearly every federal circuit court and in courts throughout Florida, brings a valuable perspective to our practice.
Henry chose to serve Trump, alongside such legal luminaries as Pam Bondi and Todd Blanche, not to mention Lindsey Halligan and Alina Habba (who was just fired from her $50 million gig for “failure to perform [her] duties” after Trump was furious that she didn’t give him his cut.
Obviously, Dechert saw value in hiring Whitaker, raising that question of what should become of lawyers who made the decision to sell their ethics and souls to Trump.
Lawyers advocate for their clients, and Whitaker can say he only advanced the administration’s position. But lawyers make a business decision to choose who they represent and how they do it. He didn’t have to be senior counselor to the Attorney General — the scoreboard shows that he had the experience to go to Biglaw. Whitaker, a FedSoc guy with a Clarence Thomas clerkship, chose to give the administration a boost in its quest to have an illegal appointment turn in an indictment the grand jury didn’t even sign, in order to put Jim Comey in jail over taking pictures of seashells.
While it is true that lawyers are often constrained to argue positions with which they personally disagree, the fact that lawyers have voluntarily placed themselves in positions where they knew they would be put in a position where they would be forced to defend outrageous, unethical and flagrantly deceitful actions does not absolve them of responsibility. No one forced Whitaker to work for Trump’s justice department. No one forced Whitaker to make such laughably absurd claims as Halligan made a boo-boo when using the United States Attorney title.
It may well be true that there was no way to serve under Trump without spewing the nonsense he demanded, meaning that one either did Trump’s bidding or got canned. But when the demand was to engage in unethical conduct, ignoring court orders or lying to the court, there really is no choice for a lawyer. Even though Trump is not the DoJ’s client, despite Blanche’s insistence otherwise, its hardly unusual for lawyers to be told to push specious arguments, lie to judges and behave unethically. Clients do so all the time. Lawyers refuse. That’s what an honorable lawyer does, and if it means losing the gig, so be it.
What does it say about Dechert that it grabbed up Whitaker? One might hope that even Biglaw has some modicum of honor and that there are lines below which it won’t go. Whitaker didn’t end up in service to Trump by accident. He made his choice. So too did Dechert. To the extent one might think that forfeiting ethics to serve in the Trump administration would make you a legal pariah, the message is clear. Not at Dechert.
Discover more from Simple Justice
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
