Author Archives: SHG

Stories Untold

As a punk lawyer, I was fortunate to be in a suite of well known, experienced lawyers.  Like all punk lawyers, I wanted to be accepted.  And so I tried to tell my war stories like the big boys.  It was a learning experience.

In the blogosphere, many young lawyers make the same mistake that I did, but there’s no one there to pull them aside and tell them that their stories aren’t yet sufficiently interesting or unusual to make their telling worthwhile.  Constraints that had helped young lawyers to smooth their entry into the profession, to save them from their exuberance and desire to be accepted, have changed. 

Now that anyone can create a platform from which to speak, and often a megaphone from which to speak loudly, and since it’s very difficult to tell whether the speaker is someone who has attained credibility over time or manufactured his own through the adept use of social media, things are often said that would be best left unsaid.  Except, people no longer want to hear that they might be best to spend more time listening than talking.

There have been a few instances of criminal defense lawyers deciding that they delight in their ability to play raconteur of late that give rise to this post.  I offer it as a Dutch uncle might offer a few words of advice.  I can’t stop others from doing as they please, and wouldn’t.  I can, however, offer some suggestions, and I will.

Jamison Koehler pulled a quote from a post of mine and used it in one of his.

I don’t own my cases, and they aren’t mine to write about.  They belong to my clients, and my clients don’t want the worst experience of their lives strewn across the internet.  I respect that, so I don’t kiss and tell.

This referred to writing about my own cases.  I don’t do it.  There’s no need for it, aside from self-aggrandizement (even if that takes the form of self-deprecation).  Those who tout a win suggest to me that they must lose an awful lot, making that win such an unusual event that it’s newsworthy.  Those who take success in stride do so because they expect to succeed.  That’s why clients retain us, because we accomplish their goals more often than not.

While the quote that Jamison seizes upon is a good explanation of my reasoning, it only addresses one facet of the problem.

Confidences can be revealed directly, as when we write about a particular case or client.  Yet, we reveal something with everything we write.  We reveal something about ourselves, whether it’s our analytical ability, our emotional state, our sense of humor or our humanity (or lack thereof).  We reveal things we don’t intend to reveal.  It’s difficult, sometimes impossible, to realize how our thoughts appear through our words.  We reveal our impressions, biases, strategies, frustrations. 

Blawgers sometimes believe that they are adept at making their point while disclosing nothing.  Sometimes it’s true. Sometimes it’s not. The problem, unfortunately, is that our self-assessment of what we disclose through our writing isn’t necessarily accurate.  I speak only for myself here, but I do not trust my ability to know that I’ve given nothing away.  And I think I’m fairly good at it, as these things go.

To that end, we need to consider why we need to take the risk.  If we write for fun, then there is no comparison between our desire to enjoy blawging and a client’s dependence on our confidentiality and discretion.  Our fun is never worth the chance of doing harm to our client.  Even inadvertent harm.

For those who blawg for profit, the rationale is even less availing.  To use writing for mercenary purposes, running the risk that something we might write will inure to the detriment of our client, is inexcusable.  We can’t take comfort in accidental error, or even benign neglect.  The self-promoter is selling his confidences for the next fee.  There is no excuse for this.

An area of some concern to me relates to a group of social media users who defy the marketers’ spin, public defenders.  Clearly, they neither seek nor desire more “clients”, and hence neither blawg, nor twit, nor facebook, nor otherwise indulge in the permutations of social media for their own aggrandizement. Proof positive that no everyone online is there solely to make a buck.

Yet I often see PDs write about their cases, their experiences, with reckless abandon.  The other day, I came across a twit from someone who purports to be a PD who publicly twitted, “My evening project: formulating a plan to explain away 551kg of cocaine & 2700# of marijuana.”  Assuming, for the sake of argument, that it’s reasonably accurate, this twit leaves nothing to the imagination.  It’s tantamount to a confession.  While it may well be what all of us do regularly, trying to formulate a viable to defense to a charge, we do not state this publicly.  We do not inform the world that there is no legitimate, truthful, defense, for if there was, we would not be constrained to “formulate a plan to explain [it] away.” 

It may be that PDs, by the nature of their work or assignment process, lack the direct connection to the client that a retained lawyer has.  Diffusion of responsibility can alter one’s perspective about confidences.  On a PD blawg recently, there was a story about a trial of a sex offender that could have gone very wrong, but fortuitously ended up going right.  Did the PD consider that to those in the know, they would be able to identify the defendant, who was outed as guilty and acquitted only by dint of good fortune? 

And then there are the readers who complain, but I want to read your stories.  I want to be titillated.  I want to share the experience.  I want to live vicariously through them. Sorry, but your desire to play voyeur is no reason for my overstepping my ethical boundary.  Criminal defense lawyers often have sensational stories that will blow your socks off.  We sometimes know where the bodies are buried. Literally.  And we cannot tell you, no matter how cool and exciting that would be for you.  Your titillation plays no role in our disclosure.  So don’t ask.

My views on the subject of confidentiality are likely more harsh than those of your grievance committee or bar association.  But then, their concern is limited to whether you’ve gone over the line and committed a sanctionable violation of a disciplinary rule.  My point is that we, whether playing pundits on social media or just using social media to compensate for our lack of dear friends in the real world, have no excuse for going anywhere near that line. 

Neither our pleasure nor profit is a good reason to risk harm to our clients.  Not cause harm, but merely take the chance.  There are so many other things to write about, so very many interesting and fascinating things to engage our minds and words.  There is no reason why we do anything that might present a risk to a client.

Greetings From Astoria

Whether the self-assessment of your typical 3L as to the scope of his skills and quality of his work can be trusted is one thing.  That he believes himself to have so much to offer that, standing in a puddle of unemployment at a time when the potential of finding of work in a law office is slightly less likely than discovery cold fusion, he can make demands is quite another. 

Via Kash Hill at ATL, a law student from Astoria, Queens has issued the terms of his employment on Craigslist.

In order to be considered for this opening as my new boss, in addition to being willing to pay for my services, you must also meet all of the following criteria:

1. You must not be a lunatic.
2. You must not be a complete jerk.
3. You must not be a senile person who should have retired years ago.
4. You must not be disastrously disorganized.
5. You must actually show up to your legal practice on a regular basis.
6. You must not use screaming or condescension as your preferred method of communication.
7. You must actually know what is going on in your own cases.
8. You must actually be a boss, which means correcting me if I make a reasonable mistake and explaining how to do a new task.
9. You must be able to meet basic deadlines in your own case, which also entails knowing what these deadlines are.
10. You must not be a major alcoholic or drug addict.
11. You must not ask me to do unreasonable, personal tasks. I am a legal employee, not your babysitter.
12. You must not have unreasonable religious preferences, such as expecting me to wear your preferred religious garb while at work and proselytizing on the job.
13. You must not require me to lie to clients on a regular basis, or forge your signature, or do any other activities which could jeopardize me obtaining a legal license in the future.
14. You must not continually screw up your own cases, and then expect me to magically fix the problems or blame me when things go wrong as a result of your errors.
15. You must be financially stable in such a way that I am not continually worried about getting paid at the end of each pay period.
16. You must have basic, functioning office equipment, including an internet connection.
17. You must be capable of legal and logical reasoning skills that are more sophisticated than knee jerk reactions such as “that’s bullshit!” Sometimes something more complex is going on.
18. You must possess basic social skills.
19. You must be willing to pay me on a regular basis for my services (just a reminder). I do not accept food, liquor or drugs as payment. Payment must be made in valid, U.S. currency and must be a reasonable wage for a person of my skill set.
20. You must not be a crazy, obsessive-compulsive control freak.
21. You must not get off on degrading your employees.

And the advertisement offers a great deal on his side of the bargain as well, at least according to him:

I have a lot of experience drafting contracts, including very complex and lengthy contracts. I have substantial experience preparing various tax returns and forms. I am great with dealing with clients, even particularly difficult clients. I am talented at interviewing and screening potential clients. I have worked in outstanding, industry-leading law firms, where I worked on high impact cases and aided in representing major corporations, and these firms loved my work. I have a high work ethic, and I pride myself in doing outstanding work for both my employers and the clients they represent. I work well under pressure. I have good social skills, and I am a friendly person. I am the kind of employee who would hit the ground running at your firm, and do great work with minimal supervision and instruction.

I can do pretty much any work that an attorney would normally do.

Plus, he has access to Lexis and Westlaw via his educational password, which he will happily use provided nobody mention this to Lexis or Westlaw so he doesn’t get in trouble.

As one might expect, this third year law student has already been widely denigrated as King of the Slackoisie, from his [I’m assuming he’s male from the whiff of testosterone in the ad] over-estimate of his worth to his extreme sense of entitlement.  Being slightly contrarian, I’m going to take the point of view that we, lawyers of a certain age, can learn from this young man’s hubris.

This Astorian has provided a laundry list of how lawyers are perceived by the ruling class of 2035.  We are an ugly, nasty, lazy, stupid, crazy bunch, we are.  They may tolerate us to the extent we engage them on their terms, such as twitter or facebook, and even in blogs provided we don’t call them Slackoisie or any other name that makes them feel badly about themselves, but they will flip on us in the blink of an eye, the moment they see our true nature appear.

There is nothing to learn from us.  Our Astoria can “do pretty much any work that an attorney would normally do,” which may come as a surprise to some lawyers.  Lawyers in the first five years of practice may be more likely to believe this assertion, since they too tend to believe they have every skill, every competency, to do “any work that an attorney would normally do.”  From what I hear, the only thing experience does is make us increasingly lazy, greedy and senile. 

What makes little sense to me is why, given how awful the job is and we are, how it interferes with the preferred lifestyle which demands that work cease the minute they have something better, more fun, to do, and how terrible we are to work for, this Astorian wants to be a lawyer.  And that doesn’t just go for this 3L, but for all those paying huge sums of loaned money to learn worthless crap, knowing that they will either remain unemployed or be forced to work for psychotic, incompetent ogres. 

We are ogres, you know.  If we weren’t, we would see no issue with accommodating the very reasonable requests and expectations of law students like our Astorian.  Our inability to let go of the archaic notion that as experienced lawyers, not to mention the folks signing the paychecks, confers some amorphous right to expect to have a say over the terms of employment proves it. 

This Astorian isn’t going to take it. Frankly, he’s got plenty of company on that ground.  While others may not be as bold or forthright in nailing his 21 Theses to our virtual door, they agree wholeheartedly with him.  Like him, they see us as the festering remains of a legal profession gone wrong.  They can’t wait to put us on the sled, pull us out to the middle of the forest in winter and walk away.

This is the future of the legal profession, and it’s right there in black and white on Craigslist.

Flight of a Child

Bryce Bates was riding his bike to get the mail, just as his mother had asked, when he saw a police car coming toward him.  It must have been scary to see the speeding car, and in an exercise of a child’s sound judgment, the 10 year old 5th grader jumped off his bicycle and ran back toward his home.  That’s when the officer released the dog on him.  From the Gainesville Sun :

The 10-year-old, who is 5 feet tall and weighs 85 pounds, said he became scared, jumped off his bike and began running for home.

“I saw the police car, and he was speeding real fast. I thought he was going to hit me, so I jumped off my bike and ran,” Bryce said. “I heard the dog barking and looked behind and saw it running after me.”

The dog caught Bryce just as he reached his front door, biting the back of his left thigh. Bryce had one puncture wound that tore the flesh and several smaller bite wounds and scratches.

The officer was responding to a call about a burglary in progress.

Cpl. Tim Durst, with his dog Grady, responded and saw a youth on a bicycle in the area.

Police say Durst yelled for the boy to stop. The officer then released Grady, which bit the boy on the leg and caused minor injuries, Book said.

When an officer yells halt from a distance, is he talking to you?  Is he commanding a 10 year old boy to stop?   Since Bryce knew that he had done nothing more than follow his mother’s instructions to get the mail, and certainly that wasn’t a reason for the police to care much about him, the officer’s command couldn’t possibly be intended for him.  He was just a kid.  He was just going to get the mail,  He was getting out of the middle of something that had nothing to do with him.  Clearly, the officer must have been yelling stop at someone else, for it surely couldn’t have been Bryce.

As it turns out, the woman who called in the burglary in progress has “a mental health condition that causes her to see things or imagine things,” though that merely reduces what transpired to a deeper depth of futility.  It does not, however, alter the question of whether Durst had any reason to believe that 10 year old Bryce was a burglar.  Did he match the appearance of the alleged perpetrator?  Was he carrying a color TV under his 10 year old arm?  Apparently not, as there is no suggestion to the contrary.

Or could this have been a 10 year old boy, a child, who found himself in a scary situation having nothing to do with him, who ran to the comfort of his mother and his home?

It’s inadequate to chalk this up to an instance of bad judgment, or lack of the dreaded “common sense.”  Releasing the dog to hunt down a human being, about whom the officer knows absolutely nothing to suggest that he’s engaged in any criminal conduct, no less conduct that sufficiently threatens harm to another to mandate that he be mauled, viciously bitten by a dog trained to take down a human being with his teeth.

Bear in mind, when a police officer releases his dog, the intended outcome is not that the dog approach its target and bark commands to halt.  The dog is trained to attack, bite and subdue the person through violent means.  The dog cannot distinguish between a child and an adult, a criminal and an innocent.  He’s just a dog.  He will attack as commanded.

That Bryce Bates is a 10 year old boy only makes this attack more grievous, but this wouldn’t have been inconsequential had he been a 24 year old.  No one, child or adult, should be subject to an attack by a dog, bitten and subdued, in the absence of awfully good cause. 

The only arguable cause here is failure to heed a command, for there was nothing to suggest that Bryce was the putative burglar (albeit the non-existent burglary). or that Bryce had any idea that the command was meant for him.  

“It attacked him right in the doorway. I saw the dog just bear down on him and moving and tugging and constantly biting and biting,” [Bryce’s mother] Hampton-Bates said. “(Bryce) didn’t know the officer was telling him to stop. He was screaming my name the whole way here.”

An officer will describe Bryce’s running toward his mother as “flight”.  But an innocent person has the right to run to his mother’s arms, to take such action as a reasonable person would under the circumstances to protect himself from a threatening situation about which he knows nothing. 

Had this been an adult, flight alone would not have provided probable cause to believe that he was engaged in criminal conduct.  Human beings have a protective impulse, called fight or flight, that has served us well throughout our history.  It’s allowed our species to survive.  It’s in our nature.  It is not an excuse for the cops to release their attack dog.

That Bryce Bates was only 10 years old, however, is what changes this from just another case of police excess, of incredibly bad judgment, to one that makes a point about police perspective,  Cpl. Durst was too ready to capture his perp, too ready to have a person attacked by a dog, despite the absence of any reason to believe that the target of his dog was a criminal.  He was just too ready to do harm in the name of order.

Bryce Bates was ten years old and a 5th grader.  He was also black.  And he did nothing wrong.

H/T Turley

Then There’s Some Other Stuff Worth Knowing

Too many worthwhile things around to write about.  Too little time.  So in the spirit of mashability, here’s the dump.

From the inimitable Frank Pasquale, Seton Hall law’s finest, over at Concurring Opinions, comes that shocking detail that, for all the raping and pillaging that banks have accomplished over the past two years, the top executives have somehow managed to survive.

For a bit of perspective on the resultant inequalities, check out the Institute for Policy Studies’ findings on bank employment and compensation since 2008:

Since the beginning of 2008 . . . the 20 U.S. banks that have received the most bailout dollars have laid off 160,000 workers. The 100 top executives at these 20 banks, in 2008 alone, collected a combined $791.5 million in personal compensation.

2009 was not a bad year for top bankers, either.

This is exceptionally good news for the caviar market.  It’s not so good for the sturgeon.

Mike at Crime & Federalism  notes that BP is still in charge of stopping the gush of oil into the Gulf, based upon the “you made the mess, you clean it up” theory of paternalism.  As the oil continues to spew, our hopes for the survival of our planet are based on the chances of BP hitting a spot the size of a dinner plate from two miles away.  But then, that assumes it will even work.

Independent experts warn that relief wells, like any well, are not without risk.“More oil could leak than before, because the field is being drilled into again,” says Fred Aminzadeh, a geophysicist at the University of Southern California. Ira Leifer, a geochemist at the University of California in Santa Barbara, voices similar concerns: “In the worst case, we would suddenly be dealing with two spills, and we’d have twice the problem.”

Of course, other experts feel confident that the relief well, after a few attempts (since everyone agrees that nailing it the first time would be like winning the lottery),  None, to my knowledge, has chosen to back up their confidence with a little wager.  It’s not like anyone voice this concern when top hat and top kill and top chef were going to save the day, but who could have possibly anticipated that there wouldn’t be another magic bullet solution to save America, yet again, from itself?

Addendum: Let’s assume, just for giggles, that they somehow plug the gusher before destroying life on this planet as we know it. Imagine how the bureaucracy of BP deals with the “legitimate” claims of fishing guys, when they demand “proof” of loss for this year’s (not to mention the next 10) catch.  I remember only too well law firms trying to get compensation for losses due to our offices being shut down after 9/11.  “So sir, you are required to prove by two independent sources how many criminal defendants would have retained your services during this period of time, in triplicate?”  Yup. Nothing to it.

Back at Concurring Opinions, Brandon Bartels brings us an interview of two academics, neither of whom is a lawyer, who explain why their “empirical study” of judicial elections leads them to conclude that their detractors, like that evil Sandra Day O’Connor, are poopyheads.

My favorite part of the Q&A is this:

2.  Your research is empirical—you analyze data from state supreme court elections to test claims put forth by judicial reform advocates (i.e., opponents to judicial elections). Judicial reform advocates have typically relied on normative arguments related to judicial independence and the need for judicial impartiality. Are these (and other) arguments grounded in reality?

BONNEAU: Based on all the evidence to date, the answer is no.  It is not only our work that highlights this, but also that of people like Jim Gibson and Eric Posner and his colleagues.  So, for example, one of the claims made by reformers is that voters don’t know what they are doing.  We find that, other thing being equal, voters are able to distinguish between challengers with prior judicial experience (“quality” challengers) and those who have no such experience.  That is, challengers to incumbents who have prior experience perform better, on average, than those that do not.  Another example:  reformers argue that nobody participates in these elections.  We find that voter participation is quite high, given a competitive election.  When voters are given a meaningful choice, they participate.  One final example:  reformers argue that these elections are exacting a toll on the legitimacy of the court system.  In a series of studies, Jim Gibson has shown that is just not true.

HALL:  This is an excellent question that goes directly to the disjuncture between political scientists and other scholars and practitioners concerned with judicial reform. The reform community, based almost entirely in the legal community, readily accepts normative accounts of judging as entirely apolitical and also assumes that any lifting of the purple curtain will attenuate judicial legitimacy. Similarly, the reform community casts the selection process simply as choosing competent technicians and has the tendency to rely on a normative ideal when evaluating the success or failure of judicial elections.

These normative assumptions are contradicted by modern social science. In fact, judges often have significant discretion and rely on their own political preferences to make decisions. Also, voters have participated in partisan judicial elections for decades without any observable adverse consequences and consistently have shown an unwillingness to relinquish their power over the selection process to political elites. Finally, an apolitical selection process is fiction, just as judges are not mere technocrats. In fact, regardless of who chooses judges, these actors seek to forward their own agendas by placing like-minded people on the bench. The federal judicial appointment process illustrates this point well. Finally, when compared to a normative ideal, all American elections fail. State supreme court elections perform as well or better than elections to other major offices in the United States.

Voters are able to distinguish between candidates with prior judicial experience and those without, dispelling once and forever the myth that voters are wholly incapable of making simplistic yet critical decisions based upon wholly irrelevant yet discrete factors.  This bodes well for Judge Gregory Galler, who need not concern himself with that day in judge school he inadvertently slept through. since he is, without question, an experienced jurist.

While the entire post is worth a read, provided words like “normative” don’t make your head explode, but the best comes at page 18 of Melinda Gann Hall’s curriculum vitae, under the heading, OTHER EVIDENCE OF PROFESSIONAL IMPACT.  Hey, it’s better than the pages where she lists herself as “discussant” (as opposed, no doubt, to “conversant”, which carries all the obvious negative connotations).

And finally, I was informed that I was  because another blogger decided to use a post of mine to launch a post of his.  Now hear this: The plane is departing Fantasy Island.  It’s a big internet out there, and I can’t stop anyone from writing about me any more than the really important and smart blawgers can stop me from writing about them.  But one side does not a duel make. 

The worst part about this slide into lunacy is that the blogger, after manufacturing the duel, whines, “I’m inclined to call it tiresome and repetitive.”  Anti-hallucinogens will make you feel that way, you know.  You’re welcome to any delusions you like, but keep me out of it.  I’ve got my own.

And The Winner Is . . .

Awards make us feel appreciated and loved, as opposed to the slightly geeky bathrobed image that’s suggested by the unduly defensive media.  There are the Weblog Awards, which died an untimely death due to the morning coffee being spilled on the results.  There are the ABA Blawg 100 Awards, given out on behalf of Starbucks.  And then there are the Webbys.

The who? Ah, you’re obviously not keeping up with the underbelly of cult blogging.  The Webby Awards.

“An online institution for more than a decade.”

                                                                                               – CNN

“The Internet’s highest honor”

                                                                                               -The New York Times

“It’s a night designed to be as dynamic as the Internet itself.”

                                                                                               – Fox News

No, I’ve never heard of them either, but then, I’m usually the last to know about such things.  It came to my attention via twit yesterday by Kevin O’Keefe, who is invariably on the cutting edge of awards he doesn’t win, If it’s worth Kevin’s time, it’s worth mine, so I checked it out.

Much to my shock and amazement, there was a category for Law.  Given that this is the 14th Annual Webby Awards, and that it’s as dynamic as the internet itself (per Fox News, so it has to be true), which I suppose means that they keep moving it around like a floating craps game, it’s hard to imagine that I’ve never heard about this before.  I mean, how cool must it be to walk down a virtual red carpet being asked who designed your bathrobe?

So without further ado, here are the cream of the blawgosphereic crop in Law:

LAW

Webby Award WinnerAgency/Credited Organization
BITTER LAWYER BITTER LAWYER
http://www.bitterlawyer.com

 PUSH Offices
People’s Voice Winner
Institute for Justice Institute for Justice
http://www.ij.org
 Institute for Justice
Nominees
ABANow ABANow
http://www.ABANow.org
Manning Productions
BITTER LAWYER BITTER LAWYER
http://www.bitterlawyer.com
PUSH Offices
Hartsoe & Associates, P.C. Hartsoe & Associates, P.C.
http://www.hartsoelaw.com/
FindLaw
Immigration Advocates Network Immigration Advocates Network
http://www.immigrationadvocates.org
Pro Bono Net
Institute for Justice Institute for Justice
http://www.ij.org
Institute for Justice

Yes, like you, I was disappointed to not find The Volokh Conspiracy in the mix, but hey, this is the Webbys.  Only the really, really big guys that impact your daily existence are worthy.  Just thought you ought to know. 

And Now, A Message From Martindale-Hubbell

Years ago, when I was a puppy lawyer hoping to achieve some middling acknowledgement that I possessed the slightest degree of competency at my chosen profession, I hoped to somehow make it onto Martindale-Hubbell’s radar so that I could be rated.  There was no guarantee that a lawyer was even worthy of consideration, no less a rating.  But M-H was like the Oracle, looking down on mere mortal lawyers to decide whether they were worthy.

That was then.  Now, M-H has not only fallen from its perch on high, but is so low down that it needs to buy a few minutes of attention.  This is the email received yesterday:

Preeminent(TM) AV(R) Peer Review Rated
Dear Scott,

As an AV® rated attorney, I know you value your credential and want to share the distinction with as many potential new clients and peers as possible. That’s why I’m pleased to offer you a complimentary Martindale-Hubbell® AV Rated Attorney lapel pin for simply agreeing to a
5-minute phone conversation about our new Lawyers.comSM Enhanced Profiles.

Lawyers.com is the most visited site for consumers seeking an attorney, with more than 20 million visitors a year.* While you’re listed in Lawyers.com, your current profile has limited information and could be working much harder for you: Click to view your profile

Act now to take advantage of Lawyers.com Enhanced Profiles, a new inexpensive listing option available only to select attorneys. For a minimal investment, you can enhance your profile by adding:

  • Your phone number and e-mail
  • Your AV® Preeminent™ rating
  • A direct link to your website and law firm video
  • Biographic information, including professional accomplishments and Areas of Practice
  • Direct links to your Facebook®, LinkedIn® and Twitter® pages
  • Plus we will promote your Lawyers.com profile in Google™ Web searches

Please let me know when you would have five minutes to talk, so I can validate your credentials and mailing address to send your lapel pin, while supplies last.

While supplies last?  Do they anticipate a mad rush to get those “AV” lapel pins? I mean, hot dang, strutting my stuff through the courthouse, an “AV” on my lapel, fighting off all those Big Money clients clawing at my preeminent heels. And all this for only giving the M-H salesperson five minutes of my life, which I will never, ever, get back.

As much as I, like any other red-blooded American lawyer, crave an “AV” lapel pin, the notion of spending five minutes of what’s left of my life with a M-H salesman falls slightly below sticking a needle in my eye.  I wonder if the back of the lapel pin would serve that purpose?

But then, Martindale-Hubbell is offering to “validate my credentials.”  Are my credentials currently unvalidated?  Isn’t validation what we all seek.  Especially from Martindale-Hubbell?  I was nothing until M-H sent me a lapel pin.  Now I’m a preeminent lawyer.  Something tells me, however, that there will be an additional cash payment on my part before I’m as “validated” as I could be.

It’s just pathetic that M-H has been reduced to sending out solicitations like this.  Gone are the days when M-H was best known for its very large, very heavy, very brown books, and looked awfully darn good behind your head when the ambush interview aired.  Gone are the days when a young lawyer prayed that some old guy in a pinstripe suit and white shirt from M-H would peer over his spectacles and whisper, you’re worthy.  I can still remember the crashing anguish of a lawyer down the hall who received a BV rating, sending him into a tailspin that didn’t stop until he was found in the gutter on skid row.

Was it a joke then, but we didn’t know any better?  It’s not clear, but its certainly a joke now.  An AV rating and a metrocard gets you a ride on the subway.  What it won’t get you is a client.  What it won’t get you is the respect of your fellow lawyers or judges.  Not even if you show up for your next court appearance sporting a shiny new “AV” lapel pin.

One question, however, continues to pound at my brain.  If you were one of the lucky few to get an “AV” lapel pin, while supplies last, would you actually wear it?

Impugning Integrity, Whenever Possible

In the category of people who slept through judge school, and consequently confuse the best practice in placing their head in a warm, moist, dark location, comes this story from the Minneapolis-St. Paul Star Tribune  about Washington County District Judge Gregory Galler.

But in Washington County earlier this month, District Judge Gregory Galler decided that defense attorney David McCormick went too far when his questions suggested an officer was being less than truthful.

Galler ordered McCormick to write an apology to the officer for “impugning the officer’s integrity,” according to court documents.

Judge Galler was outraged, apparently, by McCormick’s “suggestion” that the officer was being less than truthful. I, on the other hand, am outraged that McCormick didn’t make the officer cry on the stand, admitting wholesale fabrication and complicity in the kidnapping of the Lindbergh baby.  It’s a perspective thing.

One might suspect that Galler, whether in his experience as a lawyer before being measured for the robe, or perhaps during luncheon discussions with other jurists over the virtue of sobriety, was made aware of both the purpose of cross-examination, as well as the duty of a defense lawyer.  Both would suggest that challenging the credibility of a police officer is, well, kinda what we do.

Was the officer lying?  Who knows.  It’s certainly not beyond the pale for McCormick, who for some odd reason may be more inclined to believe his client’s view of events rather than the officer’s, to question the officer’s veracity.  Even if he didn’t believe in the innocence of his client, McCormick’s job requires (yes, requires) him to seek to undermine the officer’s credibility if possible.  That’s what we do.  We test the veracity of the police under withering cross-examination, should that be strategically advisable.

Galler ordered McCormick to write an apology with a deadline of last Tuesday, upon pain of contempt.

McCormick refused, missing Galler’s original deadline, which passed Tuesday. On Wednesday, Galler indefinitely extended the deadline and notified McCormick through his lawyer, John Brink, whom McCormick hired in case the judge held him in contempt of court.

There’s nothing like an indefinite extension to put some teeth in an inane order. Hah!  You write that apology, and it better be done before hell freezes over or else.  That will show him, right, Judge?

When asked about his adverse reaction to McCormick’s impugning the integrity of the officer, Judge Galler showed his shy, reticent side.

Reached in his Stillwater chambers, Galler confirmed that he “might have” ordered the apology and asked, “How has that become a story?” When told the demand seemed unusual, Galler said, “Not really.” He declined to comment further.

They say Stillwater runs deep.  Or not.  After all, don’t judges issue lots of threats to hold lawyers in contempt for questioning the honesty of a cop on cross?  Wouldn’t it be hard to remember all of them?  Not so, according to other local lawyers.

Other judges, defense lawyers and prosecutors say the demand was highly unusual.

Joe Friedberg, a criminal defense lawyer for 45 years, said, “If a judge ordered me to do that, I would tell him to go have intercourse with himself.”

It’s suggestions like Friedberg’s that make me wonder what’s become of the criminal defense bar.  It would likely be the most fun Judge Galler’s had in a very long time.

H/T Injustice Everywhere

Ohio Supreme Court Upholds the Magic Powers of Police

It’s not bad enough that there are some significant issues with the accuracy of radar used to clock speeders, or trees moving at 70 miles per hour.  Hey, technology isn’t perfect.  But that’s no longer an issue in Ohio, now that the Supreme Court has upheld  the old school method of nailing speeders. 

In Barberton v. Jenney, the 5-1 court held that a police officers “unaided visual estimation of a vehicle’s speed” is sufficient for conviction.

“Independent verification of the vehicle’s speed is not necessary to support a conviction for speeding,” assuming the officer has been trained and certified by the Ohio Peace Officer Training Academy or similar organization, Justice Maureen O’Connor wrote for the court’s majority.

Obviously, as Justice O’Connor’s holding suggests, my assertion that it’s magic is mere snark.   It’s not just magic, but magic by an officer trained and certified by the Ohio satellite school of Hogwarts.  If cop training school says a cop is certified in magic, then he must be. 

The ability to stand in a spot, eyeball a vehicle for a split second and opine, beyond a reasonable doubt, that it was traveling 87 miles per hour is quite remarkable.  Indeed, a skill to be envied.  Even though I’ve been driving for more than 30 years, I still have to look at my speedometer to know how fast I’m going.  I’m such a muggle.

We have a long history of attributing magical skills to police officers.  They can smell a miscreant a mile away, which is why they are entitled to search black and Hispanic youths at will for drugs or guns.  It’s a sixth sense, having nothing whatsoever to do with racial profiling.  They know who is lying and who is telling the truth, just by squinting their eyes and lifting a brow.  It’s uncanny how every perp they drag to lockup is the guilty one.  They just know it.

Over time, however, courts have been increasingly denying what the public and police have long accepted, that some people are just capable of discerning bad from good, wrong from right, by mere sensation.  The hunch.  The scent.  The vibrational manifestation.  How they do it is beyond a lawyer like me, but the cops just have the gift.

Now the Ohio Supreme Court, rejecting the slavish reliance on technology and evidence, has embraced the magic that keeps our streets safe by acknowledging that police do, indeed, enjoy the ability to perform magic.  They can’t quite phrase it that way, as that would make them look stupid, so it’s incumbent upon the court to wrap it up in a bow by providing that only self-certified magic is acceptable magic.  Anything less would be, well, ridiculous.

This ruling will, no doubt, present a problem for those drivers who deny that they were speeding, and disagree with the police officer’s “unaided” (hah! As if magic isn’t an aid.) assessment of his excessive speed.  There’s no arguing with magic.  The officer says so, and so it hereby is.

We could, of course, create some difficult hypothetical, say with the Pope driving the Popemobile from Youngstown to Cincinnati in order to get to a prayer breakfast, when the Pope slept late and nobody woke him (who wants to be the one who wakes the Pope?).  While driving at the top end of the speed limit, the Pope was very careful to never exceed it.  That would be wrong. Suddenly, flashing red lights behind the Popemobile and he’s pulled over by an agnostic for doing 76 in a 70 mile zone.  The Pope denies all wrongdoing.  Who wins?

The Ohio Supreme Court has now answered the question.  Do you believe in magic?

Touching A Nerve

George Washington Lawprof Jonathon Turley, well-known for his brief posts on legal oddities and ironies, provides a longer, more substantive offering in this USA Today op-ed, which questions whether laws matter.  Given that we have so many, and spend so much time discussing them, it seems an awfully good question.

After running through a series of diverse and facially disconnected legal issues that are or have recently been on the front burner, Turley writes:

An arbitrary system

The message across these areas is troubling. To paraphrase Animal Farm, all people are equal, but some people are more equal than others.

A legal system cannot demand the faith and fealty of the governed when rules are seen as arbitrary and deceptive. Our leaders have led us not to an economic crisis or an immigration crisis or an environmental crisis or a civil liberties crisis. They have led us to a crisis of faith where citizens no longer believe that laws have any determinant meaning. It is politics, not the law, that appears to drive outcomes — a self-destructive trend for a nation supposedly defined by the rule of law.

The manner in which Turley has framed his conclusion makes it adoptable by anyone and everyone, as becomes clear in the comments to his post.  It feeds the mass paranoia, whether liberal or conservative, Democrat or Republican.  Everyone with a position believes that they are getting screwed and the other guy is getting a free ride.  The mixed chorus is singing hosanna, though the altos are blaming the baritones who are blaming the sopranos.

The reason Turley’s assertion is universally embraced is that we have lost faith in the integrity of the law, and the legal system.  John Adams wrote that we are “a nation of laws, not men.”  It’s a fine platitude, repeated mostly by elementary school students and Supreme Court justices.  But as long as people administer the law, it’s subject to human foibles.

It’s not all that hard to tap into frustration.  Most of us are angry about those who manage to wield petty power in a way that we feel is wrong or dishonorable.  Each of us, provided we are reasonably normal, believes that we are reasonable, honest and appropriate in our view of life.  We see right and wrong, and when things happen that don’t comport with our vision, and happen again and again, we lose faith.  Those of us outside government see it as a monolith, a sort of insider conspiracy bent on subjugation of the good people (that would be us).  Even people within government see other branches, divisions, this way, while knowing that they are hampered by well-intended rules gone astray.

Society is in a current state where the passage of laws, those named after dead children being a good example, are used for  political  exploitation, which is odd in that we blame bad laws for so many of our problems, yet embrace new laws as if they will magically cure all the bad ones that came before it.

What makes Turley’s conclusion so universally acceptable is that nothing seems to work right anymore, and yet the talking political heads continue to spew as if doing more of the same will produce a different, better, result.  We’ve heard that song too many times.  We’ve suffered the outcomes failing to meet the promise.  We then hear the excuses and rationalizations that, we mumble to ourselves, ring hollow or foolish.  We won’t be fooled again.

The expectation that government will fix things for us is at the heart of our loss of faith.  Sure, government tells us it can and will, but it can’t and won’t.  Don’t argue that this is a liberal concept, as conservatives are merely “differently liberal” when it comes to the passage of laws that are supposed to make things better.  Governments make laws.  It’s what it does.  Like the proverbial nail to the guy with a hammer, laws are the only answer that government has to offer.  And so they pass them, and pass them again, and watch as they fail to improve our condition.

What we have lost faith in isn’t merely government, but our ability to reach a consensus of what we want for our society.  The other day, no less a scoundrel than former New York governor and patron of the arts, Eliot Spitzer, wrote for Slate that “Americans have lost their commitment to shared sacrifice.”  No, he wasn’t referring to group sex, but to Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address.

The problems—from energy to educational achievement to financial reform to environmental degradation—that could be resolved with just a modicum of shared sacrifice are remarkable. Surely, as we enter a period of negative-sum decision-making, not positive-sum giveaways, we must understand—as President Lincoln beseeched us—that shared sacrifice, the shared shouldering of burdens, is the key to resolving our critical problems.

The problem, aside from the unseemliness of being lectured by Client Number 9, is that we continue to believe that there is some vast core of ideals that normal people share about what we want to accomplish and how best to do so.  Some people love to characterize this as “common sense,” the last bastion of the myopic.  If we think it’s the sensible thing to do, then all other people of good will and intelligence must, by definition, agree.  And yet they never do, as they wonder why we’re too stupid or malevolent as to not agree with their common sense.  After all, if we call it common, then common it must be.

Turley has tapped into a lode of frustration and disgust that has simmered below the surface for a long time, and has bubbled to the top recently, as demonstrated by elections based on the theme of change and tea parties of internally conflicted purposes.  Everybody wants better and is certain that their way will accomplish it.  And anyone who disagrees is just wrong and evil.

Laws that fail to meet our personal expectations of outcome are derided as a root source of our problems.  But laws are just a manifestation of human frailty, both in their creation and application.  Our problem isn’t with the laws, but with ourselves.  Until we get it out of our heads that law, one more or less, will produce Nirvana, and come to the hard realization that laws are no better than the people paid to deal with them, we will continue to cast blame in the wrong direction.

As for our loss of faith in the people who comprise government, create the laws, apply the laws, decide the laws, it’s unclear that we will ever find someone of sufficiently accepted sincerity that we can all agree to trust him or her.  Then again, it’s not unclear that we ever did before.  Yet we’ve survived this far.

The tension between the government and the governed is likely the most powerful force to prevent our subjugation.  Our distrust and frustration may prevent us from reaching national consensus, but it also prevents us from blindly following our government off a cliff.  While loss of faith may not be what anyone wants out of government, it may be the best we’re ever going to get, and a whole lot better than the alternative of trusting a government that’s every bit as flawed as the people who comprise it, but without the scrutiny of the paranoids or us regular folks who just don’t think it’s doing a swell job.