Via Seth Godin.
Taylor Mali didn’t teach at my school. But I had three teachers like him.
Taylor Mali didn’t teach at my daughter’s school. But she had two teachers like him.
Taylor Mali didn’t teach at my son’s school. And he’s never had a teacher like him.
Taylor Mali is wrong. What he’s talking about is what a teacher can make, what a teacher should make. It’s not what a teacher makes unless the teacher does what Mali says a teacher should do. There’s no guarantee that a teacher will make what Mali says a teacher makes. Most fail to live up to the ideal. Miserably.
Same for lawyers.
There’s no shame in being a teacher. There’s no shame in being a lawyer. Taylor Mali’s teacher is all about teaching students. If he was a lawyer, it would be all about representing clients. Excellence has become so old fashioned.
Author Archives: SHG
Ethics From ABA TechShow
There’s the keynote speaker, Ari Kaplan. Formerly an associate with McDermott Will & Emery, now a legal consultant, Kaplan wowed the crowd with the assertion that self-promotion isn’t about promoting yourself.
“People think self-promotion is about yourself,” Kaplan told the Tribune. “It has nothing to do with promoting yourself. It’s about promoting others and let that speak for your character. That’s my philosophy.”
But this is the ABA TechShow, right? If the ABA says this is the way lawyers should be, who am I to argue?
Then there’s the ABA’s marketing ethics panel, made up of “Will Hornsby, staff counsel for the ABA Standing Committee on the Delivery of Legal Services, and Matt Homann, founder of LexThink, an “innovation consultancy” for lawyers, [who] have the expertise on technology-based legal marketing.” Do they? Or are they both of the pro-marketing ilk, their presentation about pushing the marketing envelope to the edge of the ethical precipice, before it falls into the abyss.
“These are just guesses here,” Homann warned the audience at the start of the program, “because no one really knows what’s going on with all of this stuff.”
Sometimes those rules don’t fit well with technology-based business models that may be deemed impermissible referral services or permissible forms of group advertising, Hornsby added. Payment methods may challenge the notions of permissible flat fee payments or impermissible fee splits. Templates used by some social networking vehicles may violate specific terms prohibited under the rules, such as calling oneself an expert.
There are now computer programs lawyers can use that will scan the Internet for blog postings mentioning a particular subject, such as motorcycle accidents, leave a sympathetic comment on the blogger’s site and invite readers to click on that comment for more information, which takes the user to the lawyer’s own website, Hornsby said.
The love of “innovation” has become an end in itself to many. They so love anything “e” that the only question is how best to use it, not whether to use it. They see only the upside but not the down. What’s wrong with that? The focus is not on how tech can reduce our costs so that we can lower our fees and make access to excellent legal representation more accessible to the public. It’s not on how we can improve our research so we can deliver better representation to clients. Nope. The focus is on how we can make ourselves look more attractive in hotpants. And that’s the ABA TechShow. Hope you didn’t miss it.
Strip Searching By The Numbers
45,900 divided by 145,587 equals 33,000,000
EVENTUALLY, records showed that the city had bought 45,900 disposable gowns for the jails from July 2002 to August 2007, but many of them never left a central warehouse, said Elizabeth S. Saylor of Mr. Emery’s firm. During that time, 145,587 searches were done on people being held on misdemeanor charges. The city didn’t come close to having gowns for each and every one, as the jail officials had sworn. Shortly after turning over these records, the city conceded that there had been a “pattern and practice of strip-searches.”
Faced with a new lawsuit in summer 2002, officials in the administration of Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg settled that case for $5 million and promised that things would change. No longer would people sent to Rikers Island on charges like fare beating, pot smoking or shoplifting be automatically subject to public inspection of their rectums and vaginas.
“Perhaps naïvely,” the judge, Gerard E. Lynch, wrote five years later, “the court accepted D.O.C.’s representations that, whatever its past derelictions, there would be no future violations.”
“Practically every single person we deposed from the Department of Correction swore that they never have seen a strip-search,” said Richard Emery, whose firm, Emery Celli Brinckerhoff & Abady, brought the lawsuit. “They all said, ‘We give everyone gowns, they go into cubicles, and we search them like the Queen of England.’
Why did they continue when the Bloomberg administration promised that they would end? Has anyone in government been held accountable for not complying with the 2002 promises, or for denying under oath the plain truth of what was going on?They would never lie a second time. That would be wrong.
So far, there have been no answers to those questions — but the Law Department says the city really is doing much better now.
When The Twit Don’t Fit
Many people argue that twitter is an utterly worthless waste of time, premised on the prevalence of twits about what someone had for breakfast or whether they’re off to the grocery store followed by the dry cleaner. Some people really enjoy such twits. These are people who get vicarious thrills out of someone else’s chores, a sad bunch at best.
These twits, however, are not the sort that I, or the people with whom I engage on twitter, do. Not to blow my own horn, but I wouldn’t waste your time reading about the mundane aspects of my life. They bore me, and certainly would mean nothing to anyone else. Instead, twitter is used for some fooling around, dissemination of a bit of socially useful information, the occasional rallying of thoughtful and like-minded folks for an important cause such as #HankSkinner, and every once in a while, a substantive discussion of law.
Such a discussion was begun yesterday by Bryan Beel, with David Sugerman jumping in moments later, about whether a prosecutor has a duty under Brady to test all DNA evidence. A few twits in and Trace Rabern, a New Mexico criminal defense lawyer, who jumped in on the subject of whether the prosecution was under a duty to disclose the existence of DNA evidence and allow the defendant access to test it per Brady and Kyles v. Whitley. The problem, if it isn’t already clear, is that Trace and I went back and forth in an interesting discussion, but for the fact that we were twitting about entirely different things.
Twitter is fine, sometimes even great, for some things. Legal discussions are not one of them. I should have realized earlier that Trace had come into the discussion midway in, and having missed the intro, was working off some midway twits. Her view of what we were discussing was wholly appropriate, but the problem stems from the shorthand used on twitter that could make a twit appear to be discussing any one of a dozen subjects, or aspects of a subject, and lead one down the wrong path.
Since I was there from the outset, I should have realized earlier on that we were twitting at cross-purposes. My bad. Because it was twitter, I was jumping in and out while doing other things, as I expect was everyone else, and neglected to realized what should have been obvious. Trace apologized for jumping the shark. I apologize for being a bonehead. Jumping the shark sounds way cooler than being a bonehead.
This isn’t the first time that misunderstandings happen on twitter based upon somebody coming across a twit that strikes them a certain way. In fact, it happens all the time. It has the negatives of other forms of electronic communication, lack of expression, inflection, such that humor, sarcasm, irony, all the good stuff, is lost. The setup also serves to deny ready access to parts of conversations involving twits from others you aren’t following, leaving twitterers on the outside of a discussion without their knowledge.
Then there’s the big Kahuna problem, that not every idea is well expressed in 140 characters. But that’s twitter.
Most onliners are deeply enamored with the newest and grooviest forms of electronic communications. The gurus tell us about the joys and wonders, how they will connect us with our tribes so that we can be authentic and genuine (and ultimately get rich by tribe members sending us vasts sums of money which we, in turn, send back to them in a never ending tribe circle, until the chief of the tribe puts it all in his pocket and moves to parts unknown without WiFi access or gets a new screen name). It’s invariably positive, leading us down the garden path to digital Nirvana.
Sometimes, the new doesn’t always work as well as the gurus say, at least not for all purposes. I thought you should know.
Threat Level Orange
Nicola Fisher was a protester at the G20 summit. She was slight of stature, but strong in beliefs on animal rights. This led to her meeting Delroy Smellie at the end of an asp. From the BBC News,
Ms. Fisher was holding a carton of orange juice. Some people have a fear of orange juice. Others have a fear of the vitamin C in orange juice. Some people aren’t afraid of orange juice at all, and just say they are.The 47-year-old officer told the court he initially struck the animal rights activist across the face in a move which he described as a “clearance strike”.The court heard the senior territorial support group officer then struck Ms Fisher with it when she surged towards him again.
He said he feared objects in her hands could be used as weapons against him.
Asked how hard he hit Ms Fisher, Sgt Smellie replied he was aware she was “significantly smaller”.
“However it had to be enough to achieve the objective of negating the threat,” he added.
Fortunately for us, there’s a video of the incident.
Toward the end, Fisher asserts that Smellie could have just asked her politely to move. That makes her seem a bit smelly, not to mention silly and disingenuous. Fisher doesn’t appear particularly willing to respond to a polite request in the video. But her post-beating bit doesn’t alter the propriety of Smellie’s wallop, or of his claim at trial that this big, tough cop “felt threatened” by this small, young woman.
Curious, to the point of being humorous, is Smellie lapse into police jargon to overcome what happened on the street. This was a “clearance strike,” Smellie says. That sounds so much better than beating a small woman with a club for coming near him, yelling at him, not do what he tells her to do.
Then there’s “negating the threat.” Fear of OJ? Sure there was a large crowd of protesters, but he beat Fisher. He may well have had some fear of a crowd getting out of control, but his claim is that Fisher was the threat, and needed negating. You never know when she’s going to spray orange juice on his uniform, turning it into a sticky mess that resists spot removal.
There is always the argument that had Fisher just stayed home and baked cookies, she wouldn’t have put herself in the position of forcing Smellie to beat her. But then, everyone knows that cookies taste better with milk than orange juice. What was she left to do? And then there was the whole protest thing as well. If only protesters would be more orderly and compliant.
Sgt. Delroy Smellie is on trial before the City of Westminster Magistrates’ Court for common assault. Will the OJ defense work for him?
H/T Ed at Blawg Review via @NetLawMedia
Strategic Shunning
Amongst the issues swirling around the Hank Skinner case is that DNA tests now sought, which may or may not tend to exculpate him, could have been done before trial, but were not. His trial lawyer, Harold Comer, chose not to have additional DNA testing done. The ABA Journal writes:
Skinner’s lawyers want DNA tests that his trial lawyer shunned because of fears the results would be incriminating. Among the items that have not been tested are two knives, a bloody towel and a rape kit. Comer says he now backs DNA testing, but his trial strategy was justified, AP says. “I would make the same decision with the same circumstances again,” he said.From this side of the verdict, many have been highly critical of Comer’s decision not to test for DNA when the opportunity was available, making it a significant stumbling block now.
In retrospect, it’s easy to argue that Comer made the wrong decision, at least until the tests come back, should they end up showing Skinner’s DNA was there all along. One huge point that can’t be ignored at this stage is that testing isn’t so much to prove his innocence as to preclude the execution of a man who might be innocent. Should the tests come back with Skinner’s DNA all over the place, game over.
The view now, however, is based on an entirely different situation than the view Comer was looking at when he decided to “shun”, a ridiculous word choice, the testing before trial. We now look at the case with verdict and sentence in hand, guilty and death. Harold Comer had a trial to do on behalf of a presumed innocent defendant.
The last thing a trial lawyer wants to do is push for evidence that will seal his client’s fate. Comer was already faced with problematic, though not overwhelming evidence, against Skinner. Based on the evidence in hand, he had a chance of beating the case. How good a chance is easier to assess afterward. We now know that it wasn’t very good, but Comer didn’t know that at the time. Who knew how testimony would come off or the evidence would play out. Who knew what mistakes might happen.
To the general public, as well as lawyers who don’t try criminal cases, the multitude of unknowns at trial are staggering and incomprehensible. As clients love to say, “you’re the lawyer; you’re supposed to know this.” Unfortunately, not even criminal defense lawyers are endowed with the ability to see into the future. It’s one of our biggest faults.
While we don’t know, and will never know, what was said within the confines of privileged communications between Comer and Skinner, that might have influenced the decision, it is completely understandable that Comer made the decision not to seek additional DNA testing before trial for fear that it would seal Skinner’s fate. Neither side knew, for sure, what the testing would reveal. Comer had to make a decision, and he did. That it looks wrong, horribly wrong at the moment, is irrelevant. He wasn’t working with a case where his client was already convicted and sentenced to death. He was trying to win.
All this makes those seeking DNA testing now appear disingenuous. He had his chance to get the DNA tested, and made his choice. Now he wants a second bite of the apple? Tough. If Skinner wants someone to blame, look to Harold Comer.
This argument is flawed. While it’s true that Comer could have decided to seek DNA testing pretrial, and Skinner’s post appellate position does seek a mulligan on DNA testing, the propriety of Comer’s decision cannot be judged based on post-trial circumstances. Trial lawyers make a million decisions before a verdict is returned. Some are bound to be wrong.
These only become problematic because of the systemic need for finality, but that equation changes when the sentence is death. While society may be prepared to accept that an innocent person goes to prison because his lawyer made the wrong choice, it’s not prepared to execute an innocent man, even when it can be partially blamed on strategic defense decision.
Harold Comer was constrained to make a decision on behalf of his client, Hank Skinner. He was flying blind, as is so often the case, but that’s the nature of the job. Whether it was the wrong decision remains unknown, but he didn’t have the benefit of having nothing left to lose. Today, we have the benefit. Test it all and let science give us the answer. Comer had a case to try. We have a man about to be executed. Finality doesn’t trump innocence.
Don’t blame Harold Comer for doing his job, even if it turns out that he made the wrong choice. That the ABA Journal described his decision as “shunned” is irresponsible; only someone who doesn’t grasp the nature and function of trial counsel would use that word to describe the choice facing the defense. Comer made his decision based on what was known at the time, and that’s all he could be asked to do. We now face a different situation, and that changes everything.
Fonts of Wisdom
It’s not for lack of concern or appreciation, but just lack of time. When I wrote of Blawgospheric Darwinism, I wasn’t being snippy, or arrogant, or self-important, but stating a harsh reality. We work for a living. We have real clients with real cases that require our time and attention. It’s not that the blawgosphere is just a game or diversion, but that it takes time to stay abreast and read all the things that it offers.
Still, it pains me that I haven’t properly acknowledged the fine efforts of many new, and not so new, comers. I was a newbie once, and others who were already here welcomed me to the blawgosphere. The least I can do is pay it forward. Some of the following blawgs have already been mentioned or discussed, some in a less than entirely favorable light because of a particular post or assertion, but they all offer substance and have their virtues. Some will appeal more than others to a particular audience, but that’s for the reader to decide.
Check these out and see if they are good fit for you.
Trial Theory
Not Guilty, No Way
Affirmative Links
Jamison Koehler’s Still Unnamed Blog
Liberty and Justice For Y’all
Public Defender Revolution
They aren’t all my cup of tea, and they may not be yours. But you’ll never know if you don’t check them out. Whatever you think, it would be a shame for fonts of wisdom to run dry merely because no one knew they were there. Take a look. It won’t kill you.
#HankSkinner: Maybe Nothing, But Something
The United States Supreme Court granted a stay of execution to Hank Skinner about an hour before the Texas death machinery had a chance to put on a show. The stay will terminate of its own accord should Skinner’s petition for a writ of certiorari be denied, meaning that it’s a baby step toward the goal of the only issue blocking his execution, DNA testing to either confirm his guilt or not.
Jeff Gamso has links to the relevant documents and an array of posts on Skinner. Mark Bennett provides the procedural history leading to this point, not to mention a bit of blawgospheric trickery to get those otherwise disinclined to care to become aware of the issue. Brian Tannebaum takes on the simple minds who are incapable of understanding why there’s any issue at all. And a broad group of lawyers online spent a good deal of time yesterday spreading the word as far and wide as they could.
We’re not so delusional as to believe that it was our twitter campaign that moved the Supremes to grant an 11th hour stay, or had Texas Governor Rick Perry cowering in the corner of his governor house hiding from the digital townspeople with their pitchforks and torches. But it showed that they cared enough about the right thing to act. If it played any role, even to merely encourage those engaged in the real fight to stop the possible execution of an innocent man, it served a purpose. If it played no role whatsoever, at least we didn’t turn our backs.
It was a day of gross juxtaposition, however. While some blawged, some twitted, some did both, in the name of keeping Hank Skinner alive long enough to make sure he was guilty before killing him, other lawyers were occupied with doing the things most important to them. They had no time to notice the impending execution of Hank Skinner. They were busy with more important things.
There was marketing to do. There were ten tips on how to best use social media to connect with your tribe to be told. There was a delicious luncheon to describe. And somewhere, there was a conference being held on how to make lawyers more money.
Self-promotion depends on making others like you, think you’re fun and interesting, want to engage with you. Nobody wants to love you when you’re busy being a downer, harping on some unpleasantness like the execution of some guy in Texas. It’s not like the guy is a member of the family. Or even a friend. Hey, people die every day. What’s one more? It’s not like life doesn’t go on, you know.
Life does go on. No one expected any lawyer anywhere to go on a hunger strike yesterday to protest the impending execution of Hank Skinner. Enjoy that delicious luncheon. It would be terrible shame to waste fine food. But going about your life doesn’t exclude your ability to be aware of, care about, do something about, a pretty big issue happening within your sphere of concern as a lawyer. Even if it’s only to join in the chorus, one more voice makes the hosanna louder.
It made me proud that I could be a part of the group of lawyers who raised a hand, maybe only a finger, to be part of the solution. It may have meant absolutely nothing to the grant of a stay or the transitory extension of Hank Skinner’s life, but it’s better to try than not. In contrast, the swell of lawyers who were too busy going about their daily lives online, eying themselves in the mirror to see if their hotpants made their butt look fat, may have found a new client while we were trying to save a life.
These are the choices that lawyers have to make in this digital age. Social media can be put to good use, but it’s up to each of us to decide what a good use is, and whether trivial, self-serving interests are sufficient to make you feel that you’re day wasn’t wasted.
Merge or Start-Up, We’re Doomed
If there’s one thing that’s clear, it’s that lots of colleges and universities covet a law school. The reasons vary. For research universities, a law school serves to complete a portfolio. For smaller schools, it can place them on the map. And finally, there are a few schools that are simply built to make money. At the moment an institution decides to start down the law school path, it has to face a crucial choice: start-up or merger. For-profits and smaller non-profit schools usually have little choice but to start fresh; few existing law school see a benefit from linking up with these smaller fish. I want to focus a bit on bigger institutions: private research universities and state universities. They can choose to build or merge.
It would seem that the numbers speak loudly. American law schools are producing warm bodies at the rate of 45,000 per year, when there are only 30,000 jobs. Of course, that doesn’t include those who fly solo or use their degree for something more productive, But it also doesn’t account for all those solos and small firm lawyers staring at the telephone, praying it comes to life with something that can make it past Rule 11 sanctions. Or the small army of Biglaw partner wannabes who are told to turn in their Oxfords for flip-flops.
Dan Filler’s attempt at compare and contrast in his post offers even more insight into the faculty mindset:
The biggest advantage to a start-up is faculty quality.
Another big plus for a start-up is the ability to create both an agenda and a culture.
Nowhere in this discussion does a consideration appear about swamping the nation with yet more lawyers to serve in the devil’s workshop. Of course, if universities in desperate need of a law school were to merge with existing schools, at least we would be saved from yet more deeply indebted, grossly unneeded, men and women being sent out into the legal world primarily due to their inability to stomach the sight of blood (in which case they would have gone to medical school) if they just merged with an existing factory. What does Filler find to be the main virtues of merger?
Why might a school choose to merge? The first obvious answer is lower front-end transaction costs. You already have an administration. Starting a new law school is incredibly time consuming for both faculty and administrators, and inevitably involves driving through a lot of potholes. You also already have a faculty, which means you don’t need to spend five years in endless job talks.Lower transaction costs and no new jobs. Talk about making merger look sexy. Who doesn’t have a soft spot for lower transaction costs, especially when compared to the ability to “create both an agenda and a culture?” Plus, they would have to come up with a mascot, and everyone knows what a minefield that can be.
While the fine academics who sit alongside Dan Filler in the Faculty Lounge drinking sherry from leaded crystal stemware are certainly brilliant people and scholars, the disconnect between their self-interest and the nasty reality of too many lawyers is hard to comprehend. Do they concern themselves with how many lawyers per capita we have? Will they be satisfied when there’s a lawyer for every man, woman and child in America? Will it end when a law degree becomes de rigueur for every public sector job, from sanitation worker to traffic cop?
Not as long as there are jobs to be created and agendas and cultures to create, as would be the position of any self-respecting guild.
Is It Always Just About Money?
Oral argument was held yesterday before the Court of Appeals in Hurrell-Harring v. State of New York, where the NYCLU seeks reinstatement of its action on behalf of 20 plaintiffs to hold that “the current system for representing poor defendants creates an unacceptably high chance that defendants’ constitutional right to adequate legal counsel will be violated.”
Under persistent questioning by Judge Robert S. Smith, New York Civil Liberties Union attorney Corey Stoughton conceded that lawyers for plaintiffs in the case do not know how much it would cost to significantly improve the effectiveness of counsel assigned to indigent defendants.
“That’s absolutely true, I have no idea,” Ms. Stoughton replied.
“Isn’t that a problem with systemic failure questions?” Judge Smith persisted. “What you’re really doing…by upholding the complaint, you’ve signed a blank check that someone is going to have to fill in later?”
That’s all it is? Money?
From the standpoint of Gideon, my favorite public defender, yes, money is the answer. Not an answer. Not part of the answer. The answer. “We’re only as good as our funding.” I know it’s meant with the best of intentions, but money is a false god.
There is no public agency/service that doesn’t say it could do better with more money. That should be engraved over the door of every government building. I’ve no doubt that it’s true, particularly when it comes to indigent defense, where lack of funding has been a perpetual problem. But there’s another view of the big picture that can’t be ignored.
The NYCLU is seeking class action status for the plaintiffs, who contended their counsels did not appear in court, failed to keep them apprised of the status of their cases, did not properly investigate their cases or otherwise provided inadequate representation.
In the case of lead plaintiff, Kimberly Hurrell-Harring, her lawyer had her plead guilty to a felony, when it should have been a misdeamnor. How much money would it cost to correct that incompetence? Her public defender was informed by a lawyer from NYSDA in advance of sentence of the problem. He still didn’t bother to raise the issue. How much money for that?
It’s not to say that adequate funding isn’t critical to the functioning of indigent defense. It most assuredly is. But funding a broken system doesn’t fix the system. It just makes it a more costly broken system.
The Chief Judge, Jonathon Lippman, asked an incisive question of New York’s Solicitor General, Barbara Underwood:
“Do we have a particular role to play here, given that this is about the justice system, the court system—that it works?” he asked at one point. “Or can we take just a hands-off approach and say, ‘Listen, there is no real controversy here, just have the individual cases go through to completion [and correct mistakes post-trial]. It doesn’t matter that this is about the justice system, about the courts.’ Should it matter to us?”
There’s no way to answer that the courts shouldn’t have a role to play in making certain that the court system works. And Underwood acknowledged that, but added that concern alone doesn’t make a claim justiciable. While Judge Lippman pressed on whether the only thing the court could do is correct mistakes afterward, Lippman argued that there was no assurance that allowing this case to proceed would prospectively produce effective assistance of counsel for anyone.
In tacit acknowledgement, the NYCLU told the court that it would drop the suit if the state forms a “statewide independent indigent defense commission.” This is what’s really needed, together with funding. And it’s something the court can’t order. There must be money available to pay the cost of indigent defense. There must be a system that assures that the money spent will result in an indigent defense system that serves poor defendants by providing effective representation. It’s not just money.
It’s heresy within the criminal defense community to question any action that would produce more funding for indigent defense, and to the extent this suit will do so, and I’ve no doubt that increased funding will help to provide effective assistance of counsel, it’s hard not to support it. But if the goal is true effective assistance for indigent defendants, then the system for delivering effective representation must be improved, and neither this case, nor even a blank check, will fix a broken system.
