Judge H. Lee Sarokin spent 17 years on the bench in the District of New Jersey and 3rd Circuit. He then retired, moved to California and wrote a post at HuffPo. Whenever a judge of his stature writes, it’s worth a read to understand better what’s happening in the mind behind the robe, and Judge Sarokin’s post offers much, and little.
The post appears to be motivated by the criticism of the courts for allowing John Gardner, accused of the rape and murder of Chelsea King, to go free. Why, comes the followers of John Walsh, do they let these animals out? After extolling the virtues of the presentence report provided federal judges, Judge Sarokin explains:
How does this happen? My experience has been solely in the federal courts, where few crimes involve acts of violence like murder and rape. But I suspect that most of the state courts operate in the same or similar fashion. First, let me assure you that it is nothing like the TV judges, who rap their gavel, impose sentence or render a decision in a flash and then say: “Next case.”
But sentencing is far from a science. One of the reasons sentencing guidelines were enacted was to reduce as much a possible the discrepancy based solely upon the predisposition of the sentencing judge — the tough sentencer v. the lenient sentencer. A sentence should not depend on which courtroom a defendant walks into. But the biography, the sentencing guidelines, the penalty standards based upon the crime committed, do not spew out a uniform sentence. A judge on sentencing day hears the arguments of counsel for and against incarceration and frequently statements of remorse from the defendant; sees the anger and hatred from the victim and/or the victim’s family; observes the parents, wife and children (many brought to the courtroom as infants) of the defendant, reads of the public’s cries for vengeance and punishment and the personal letters begging for leniency and attesting to the good character and good works of the defendant. We also think about rehabilitation and deterrence, although I understand that rehabilitation of sex offenders is unlikely, and we have no way of knowing whether the risk of punishment has any effect.
But what’s missing from the description is what distinguishes one human being from another, one sentence from another. Rather than offer insight, Judge Sarokin offers his apology.
We are not God, but we play God in these moments. The understandable public reaction in cases such as Chelsea King is to execute, forever incarcerate or medically disable persons who are likely to re-commit such terrible acts. Balancing the need to protect the public within the limits imposed by the law and the Constitution is an awesome task for a judge. We hope we get it right and avoid the horrific tragedy of families like those of Chelsea King, but sometimes we fail in that undertaking despite our best efforts or because of limits imposed by the law.It was the peculiar wording of this paragraph that caught my eyes, and caused some concern. On the one hand, there is “the need to protect the public.” On the other, “the limited imposed by law and the Constitution.” Is Judge Sarokin saying that they would do a much better job if it wasn’t for their hands being tied by law? Is protecting the public the predominant interest vindicated at sentence? Clearly, he makes no mention of any other factors set forth in 18 USC 3553(a). Does that mean that they are subsumed in his “limits of the law?”
What isn’t said here is how these “not God” creatures perform this “awesome task.” It remains every bit as mysterious after reading Judge Sarokin’s post as before. While noting “we hope we get it right” (us too) and “avoid the horrific tragedy of families like Chelsea King,” he neglects to mention the horrific tragedy of the families of the innocent, or those sentenced to draconian punishments because tough on crime is the tastiest flavor in Washington. While the post is clearly driven by the questions raised in the Chelsea King murder, and ignores the detail that John Gardner has yet to be convicted of anything, it leaves the impression that the only concern on a federal judge’s mind is how to put someone away for as long as the “limits of the law” will allow.
From the perspective of anyone involves in the criminal justice system, Judge Sarokin’s position, that’s not easy to determine an appropriate sentence, is hardly news. What is news is the depth of concern demonstrated when a sentenced prison re-offends, particularly when it’s a sex offender (who the judge specifically notes is unlikely to be rehabilitated). No one can argue that this is, and should be, a concern. But if that’s the only concern, and the only countervailing force is the limits of the law, Judge Sarokin reveals some very big problems in the mindset of the federal sentencing judge.

