The Office of National Drug Control Policy is not a subtle bunch. Its latest foray into scaring kids to stay away from marijuana is over the top, a modern day Reefer Madness effort designed to suggest that smoking some reefer will be the end of any chance they might have to lead a successful life. The motto is, “Hey, not trying to be your mom, but there aren’t many jobs out there for potheads.”
Clearly, the ONDCP is pushing the envelope. But why, I wonder, are so many pushing back?
There are many people who argue that marijuana should be decriminalized. That the suggestion that smoking marijuana places a young person on the road to heroin addiction is absurd. This is certainly and worthy debate, and one that becomes clearer when you consider that there are jail cells filled with young people who have done nothing different than people we have elected to high office from both parties. Indeed, this has to strike anyone who thinks on occasion as an absurdity.
But there is a flip side to consider. As much as the heavy-handed efforts by the ONDCP provide the source of some hearty laughter, what do we gain by promoting pot use?
Think about it this way. If you are a parent, do you tell your teenage child to go try some pot? See if you like it? Find out whether it’s your version of the martini? Want to join Mommy and Daddy in a blunt? Come on. This isn’t cool.
This is why I found Radley Balko’s reaction to the government’s silliness disturbing. In contrast to the advertising campaign that pot smokers are losers, Radley proffers a list of successful people who have smoked pot:
Barack Obama, president-elect. Bill Clinton, 42nd president of the U.S. John Kerry, U.S. Senator and 2004 Democratic nominee for president. John Edwards, multi-millionaire, former U.S. Senator, and 2004 Democratic nominee for vice president. Sarah Palin, governor of Alaska, 2008 Republican nominee for vice president. British Home Secretary Jacqui Smith, Transport Secretary Ruth Kelly, and Chancellor Alistair Darling. Josh Howard, NBA all-star. New York Governor David Paterson. Former Vice President, Nobel Peace Prize winner, and Oscar winner Al Gore. Former Sen. Bill Bradley, who smoked while playing professional basketball. Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas, former Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich, and former New York Governor George Pataki. Billionaire and New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg.
The list, of course, is decidedly underinclusive. It certainly shows the fallacy of the government’s campaign to suggest that all pot smokers turn out to be losers. Of course the campaign was absurd and silly, and obviously there are plenty of people who have smoked pot and turned out to be great successes. So what?
Many others have linked to, and joined with, Radley Balko’s endeavor, including some blawgers who I respect and admire greatly. But I suggest that they have confused two issues. At least, I hope they have. No, marijuana does not inevitably lead to heroin addiction and failure in life. But does that mean that it’s a good idea to suggest that people should smoke pot and be like Barack Obama or Michael Bloomberg?
Smoking pot is something that almost everyone of a certain age has done. Some did it more than others. Some grew out of it. Some did not. Not every person who smoked pot became a billionaire or president. Some became a waste product. Some would have become billionaires anyway. Some would have become waste products anyway.
Automobile accidents happen because drivers are high, just like they do when drivers are drunk. I don’t extol the virtues of getting drunk. I don’t condemn someone because they smoked pot. But it’s not something I promote either.
Let’s not lose our heads on the subject of marijuana. It’s hard to blame the government for using an advertising campaign to promote sobriety. Not smoking marijuana isn’t a bad thing. While the campaign itself may be a worthy topic of debate, even ridicule, its underlying purpose isn’t really controversial at all. The national policy against the use of marijuana is pretty standard stuff.
And this does not implicate the medical marijuana issue, any more than arguing that vic-o-din (deliberately broken up so search engines won’t recognize it), great for relieving severe pain, is the perfect “pick-me-up” pill for anyone driving race cars.
No one on the list of marijuana smokers achieved success because they smoked marijuana. It’s questionable whether anyone on the list smoked pot as they climbed the ladder of success, or was a regular pot smoker beyond their younger years. I haven’t seen anyone on the list become part of an advertising campaign to “Smoke Pot, Be Like Me!”
So let’s not get crazy about this. It’s perfectly reasonable to challenge the criminalization, and certainly the punishment, of marijuana users. It’s fair game to ridicule the ONDCP’s anti-marijuana campaign, described by Radley as “an incredibly lame campaign, [that] reeks of stodgy wonks making a desperate attempt to look hip.”
But it’s similarly foolish to turn the government’s inept effort into an opportunity to suggest that pot smoking is the road to success and wealth. It’s not.
Update: Radley has just added this video, created by John Holowach. I think this strikes a very good balance, and makes its point effectively.
