Author Archives: SHG

The Vegan In The Well

Other than the truly sick people who find crush films to their liking, it’s hard to fathom why anyone would take pleasure from the infliction of needless harm and pain to animals.  But does the Stevens decision lead us to stop eating meat?  I was a little surprised to see that Marc Randazza  found the reasoning in Jon Katz’s argument  compelling:

I wish for Stevens to be an opportunity not only to celebrate and strengthen the First Amendment, but also for people to re-examine their relationship with and treatment of all animals, both of different species and their own species.

Violence begets violence, and that concept is not limited only to human-on-human violence. How desensitized do people become about harming other humans when they eat other mammals, who are not so unrelated biologically to humans? Of course, chickens and fish also bleed and feel pain and suffering from being slaughtered.

Randazza responds:

My food consumption is one of my admitted hypocrisies. While I agree with everything Katz has to say about this subject, I simply love eating animals. Even veal and foie gras. I don’t see changing that (but never say never). Nevertheless, I do think the argument is compelling. Believe it or not, I consciously try to be more compassionate every day. I think that Jon makes a very strong, if not indisputable, point.

This has the joint failing of conceding hypocrisy while adopting a straw argument.  Maybe all that San Diego sunshine has done something to Randazza?

I respect Jon’s choice to go vegan; it’s entirely up to him to be comfortable with his own conduct, and certainly there’s no harm in not eating meat.  But I don’t share the feeling.  While inflicting cruelty upon animals for kicks disgusts me, I am a carnivore.  Human beings are carnivores. It’s our nature.  That we raise, and kill, animals for food is consistent with out nature, and consistent with the natural world, even though we’ve altered it to satisfy the need to feed ourselves.

I’ve watched the National Geographic channel.  Wild animals are often unkind to their own, and even more unkind to those critters they eat.  There’s nothing pretty about one snatching the other in mid-air, or the bank of a river, or wherever they happen to find them.  It’s brutal. 

Does it cause pain?  I’ve no doubt it does, as I’ve no doubt the alpha rhino hurts the young bull hoping to catch the interest of a mate when it give it a piece of its horn.  This is still part of the natural process of the rhino’s life, and it’s unlikely that rhino matchmaking will find a place on cable.

Jon draws a connection between the desensitization that comes from eating meat and human on human violence.  I see no connection whatsoever.  There’s no explanation for the analogy, but merely a question of “how desensitized to people become.”  Not at all, I say.  Why would they?  One involves eating meat, as is our nature and maintains our existence, while the other has nothing whatsoever to do with that.  I can accept the parallel between crush films and harming other humans, but not eating.

There are people who cannot bear to eat meat knowing that an animal died to provide it.  There are people who cannot bear to eat meat knowing the conditions under which livestock is raised to supply us with meat, or knowing how the animals are slaughtered.  It’s understandable, and I do not begrudge anyone who feels this way from making whatever choice he or she feels necessary.

That doesn’t mean, however, that there is a sound basis to extrapolate the disgust we feel toward something as horrible as a crush film with our nature as carnivores.  There is simply no rational connection between the two, and the effort to draw one will tend to make it increasingly difficult to enforce the constitutional rights that underlie cases like Stevens by suggesting that they lead down the slippery slope to such outcomes as veganism. 

Preserving the First Amendment is not the gateway to becoming a vegan, or any other personal choices for which no rational connection exists.  Let’s not get crazy about this and provide ammunition to be used to shoot down sensible court decisions in guise of shooting down dinner.

Mind If I Take A Look?

Via John Wesley Hall at the Fourth Amendment Blog, courtesy of Liberty and Justice For Y’all, the 5th Circuit decision in United States v. Garcia  brings up an old shocker, when the consent search winds up with the cops dismantling a car on the side of the road.

The scope of a consensual search may be limited by the expressed object of the search. Jimeno, 500 U.S. at 251. But where, as here, an officer does not express the object of the search, the searched party, who knows the contents of the vehicle, has the responsibility explicitly to limit the scope of the search. Mendoza-Gonzalez, 318 F.3d at 667. Otherwise, an affirmative response to a general request is evidence of general consent to search. Id. Garcia did not qualify his consent to the officers, who therefore had general consent to search the truck.

General consent to search a vehicle does not, however, give an officer carte blanche over the vehicle. Id. at 669. A search must still be reasonable, given the totality of the circumstances. Id. The search here was reasonable. When the officers requested permission to search the truck after asking Garcia whether he was carrying “anything illegal,” it was natural to conclude that they might look for hidden compartments or containers.

The problem, of course, is that the scope of the consent is whatever the cops say it is, and is based on a parsing of the language that far exceeds anything a reasonable person understands it to be.  When a cop asks a motorist if he can take a look in his car, does the motorist understand that to mean that he’s going to pull off the fenders in search of a secret compartment? 

During the 1980s, it became fairly commonplace for drug dealers to build secret compartments into their cars.  The Spanish word for this was clavo, the New York City police quickly became aware of the situation.  There was even an office in the 34th Precinct who took it upon himself to keep files on clavos in various types of cars, and was later called to testify as the Clavo Expert, with his notebook filled with his collected details about secret compartments in various types of cars. 

The problem was that the cop who made the car stop and obtained consent had to figure out where the clavo was and how to get into it.  They were often kept closed by substantial locks, triggered electrically, and secreted deep within the body structure of the car.  Based upon model, cars would have voids in different places, and the clavo was designed to fit the hole in the particular model.  Some cars, like the Nissan Maxima, were favorites, because they were fast and offered some great hiding places.

The solution became clear.  Not only were cops targeting Maximas, but after obtaining consent, physically dismantling the cars by pulling off body parts on the side of the road.  It was bad enough when they happened to stop a mule carrying drugs, but when they destroyed cars of innocent people in their search for the clavo, people were outraged.  Unfortunately, there was little to be done to stop it.  The courts ignored the issue of the search exceeding consent, the outrageous destruction of property in the never ending war on drugs. 

Notably, the second quoted paragraph above is the one that presents the problem.  The court held that general consent doesn’t give the police carte blanche, but that a search must still be reasonable under the totality of the circumstances.  The court then finds the search reasonable for no particular reason at all. 

When the war on drugs was at its most heated stage, it was hardly surprising that courts would empower the police to engage in routine dismantling of cars to search for secret compartments. Hey, that’s how the drugs were transported and that’s what was needed to find them.  Nobody was going to let a detail like excess or reasonableness stand in the way of the war on drugs.  So what if consent was obtained without any clue that it entailed the destruction of the car.  As the 5th Circuit says, it’s only “natural”.

But the war on drugs has wound down quite a bit since then.  The old crack days are largely past, and headlines no longer scream about the plague of drugs on the streets.  Courts can now take a more principled view of the old search at any price precedent when it came to drugs and automobiles, and rein in the harm done to the warrant clause when there was no search they didn’t approve. 

But the 5th Circuit instead stuck to the old drug war program and approve the search, engaging in the legal fiction that anyone giving consent would naturally understand that to mean approval of the cops dismantling the car, or any part of it, they wanted.  Isn’t that what we would all believe to be the case when we knowingly, voluntarily and intelligently consent to a quick look by the cops to see if there’s “anything illegal” in there?

And I’m sure that the defendant’s name, “Garcia”, didn’t have anything to do with it.

Voices From The Past, The Besmirched Marina Tylo

Things happen all the time, and so posts move forward to the new, leaving the old behind to fester for posterity.  Even an old post, however, can come back to life when someone “discovers” it and decides that it’s worthy of their attention despite the length of time that’s past.  It happens here from time to time.  It happened again yesterday.

The first thing I saw was a comment by a Brooklyn lawyer named Marina Tylo.

I had a misfortune of reading your blog about me. I wish I would be an anorexic chain smoking middle age broad on cheap wine.

I am plump; I do have a cig here and there, I do have a glass of Chablis on Saturday.

What the hell is your problem???

What do you gain by besmirching my reputation? Have we ever crossed our path?

I do happen to be one of the nice guys.
Just let me know what the fluff is up.

Please, reply. My potential clients are reading this and it does hurt my business.

Just tell me what I did to piss you off this much.

I couldn’t remember who this person was.  It was much like the bizarre call from Texas lawyer and publicity hound, Mimi Coffey.  Then there was the message from Tylo on my voice mail, telling me to call her back so we can keep this “friendly”.

Her comment doesn’t make a lot of sense to me, unless she’s got some weird hang-up about being weight, smoking and cheap wine, but I fully get the point of the rest of it.  Why can’t she do something wrong, then something stupid, then be left alone?  Why should any lawyer suffer the consequences of her actions?

When the question comes long after something is posted, there’s a different sense about it then when first done.  At the time, their conduct is fresh and the need for transparency certain.  But later, the question arises whether they’ve “served their sentence.”  As the internet is forever, to the extent anything is forever anymore, it’s brand new whenever someone stumbles upon an old post about some incredibly stupid move, such as Tylo’s ridiculous $10 million suit  against Andy Bluestone for mentioning a malpractice case against her for her defective service of a summons.  But should this follow her forever?

Of course, the reason Tylo was immortalized online wasn’t because of her stupid, though relatively trivial, service of a defective summons, but her compounding the stupidity by suing a blawger for mentioning it.  This was a far more significant, and disturbing, act than her initial screw-up, and one that serves as a critical message to any lawyer who thinks they can sanitize their online reputation by threats or suits. 

Like so many lawyers whose grasp of the digital world is that it’s all about their right to market themselves without fear that their ugly side appear anywhere for potential clients to find, Tylo wants to know what she’s done to me personally to make me do something so harmful to her that I would harm her practice.  It’s all about her.  Why would I besmirch her reputation?

When a blawger is attacked by someone, even someone as empty as a Marina Tylo, it’s an attack on all of us.  This is important, even if her initial failing was relatively trivial.  The lesson is that suing to shut down a blawger will itself be the cause of negative consequences.  The message is necessary, and remains necessary.  Just ask Streisand.  Frivolous defamation suits are the bane of the blawgosphere, and the attempt to sanitize one’s oneline persona by threatening, or in fact suing, is an outrage and an attack on all of us.  It’s a message that needs to remain, and should be repeated as often as necessary to make sure the Marina Tylos of the world get slapped and remain slapped.

Maybe Marina Tylo will sue me too, since I’ve no plans to call her back and discuss anything with her to keep it friendly.  My bet is that if she doesn’t like her online reputation now, she’s going to really hate it if she compounds her stupidity by doing it again.  But every lawyer gets to make her own bed. 

There are consequences for such actions, and they will be online for as long as forever lasts these days.  The message is don’t do it.  It appears that Tylo still hasn’t gotten the message.

Promises, Promises (Update)

As the decision in Stevens  came out yesterday after I’d gotten down to work, and has since been announced and discussed everywhere in the blawgosphere, there’s no point in mentioning that the Supreme Court, in a case that presented (hopefully) the most extreme example of speech unworthy of protection, upheld the First Amendment anyway. 

Need proof that people can be truly sick?  Watch a “crush film” and know that there are people who get sexual gratification from it.

For non-lawyers, it’s hard to comprehend why the Supremes would, by 8 to Alito , find a law prohibiting, criminalizing, this to be unconstitutional.  Doug Berman  has plucked the sentence from the opinion that explains.

We would not uphold an unconstitutional statute merely because the Government promised to use it responsibly.

While the law would criminalize the wrong of these sick, disgusting films, its sweep covers expression that isn’t wrong.  Our government’s answer is “trust us, we would never use an overbroad law to go after people who didn’t deserve it.”  Even a Supreme Court that’s moved so far right as to make Justice John Paul Stevens the leading liberal couldn’t tolerate that justification.  This is why “plain English” laws can’t work, despite their superficial appeal to those who blame obfuscating lawyers for all that ails society.

But this line presents another interesting problem.  While the Supreme won’t tolerate a law that’s overbroad merely because the government says “trust us,” they willingly, no happily, tolerate, no enable, men and women with guns, batons, tasers, moving amongst us with no real check on their conduct beyond the promise to use their weapons, their authority to seize and imprison, their ability to make people do as they say upon pain of . . . pain, based solely on their promise to use it responsibly.

While we applaud the Stevens decision for upholding the First Amendment in the face of such sickness as crush films, we ignore a gap of monumental proportions that falls into the same category. 

What good is scrutinizing laws to this extent when the reality on the street, when, as commenter Alan  put it so clearly,

the police do what they need to do to get the job done. Right or wrong, the police sometimes need to circumvent the letter of the law an instead use the spirit of the law to get these scumbags off the street.

The legitimacy of our entire system of criminal law depends not on the decision of member of the Harvard or Yale Clubs, but on the decision of one cop to raise his weapon and bring it down on the head of a human being.  This is the real crush, and it happens every day across this country.  There are a thousand battles fought in the war of government responsibility, and the Supreme Court shuts its eyes to them, too trivial for their notice.

It’s wonderful that the Court held that constitutionality can’t be left to the government’s promise to act responsibly.  It’s a shame that they do so anyway.  To any person who was stopped and frisked for no reason, or beaten, tased or shot because they comply with some cop’s demand, or sent to prison for lifetimes because a cop lied on the stand knowing that he can say anything, and as long as there’s no videotape to prove it, will get away with it and get a medal, this line from Stevens brings no comfort.

The government’s promise is only as good as the integrity of every cop on the street.  If only the Supreme Court realized this.

Update: Yesterday, a judge in Glendale did the California version of an ACD in the case of a woman , traveling with her 93 year old, wheel-chair bound mother, who tried to stop a TSA agent from seizing her cooler with applesauce so that her mother would have something that she could eat on a plane ride to a family wedding.  She was arrested, strip searched and prosecuted.  No word on what happened to the 93 year old mother left at the airport.

Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Fred Rotenberg said he would dismiss the case against Nadine Kay Hays only if the grandmother of six stays out of trouble for the next six months. Prosecutors had no objections during the hearing at a Glendale courthouse.

The case generated national attention, drawing the ire of talk-radio hosts who railed against the TSA agents and challenged how confiscating a disabled woman’s applesauce would improve national security.

A TSA supervisor told officers that Hays made a fist and struck her on the hand as they tugged at an ice chest containing the snacks, according to the arrest report.

Hays has denied hitting the agent, maintaining that she brought down her hand to keep agents from taking away her mother’s applesauce, cheese and milk.

This is being reported as a victory for sanity over an overbearing abuse of authority by the TSA.  How many government agents, prosecutors and a judge had an opportunity to exercise that promise to use its power responsibly?  And after a year, the best they could come up with is an ACD?  Yet this aspect of the promise of responsibility eludes our Justices.

A Selection That Can Never Be

Norm Pattis posts the news from Butner, North Carolina.

When the nominee stood to address the assembled press corps, there was an eerie silence. The man was on no short list of candidates. Indeed, he was a man few present had ever considered.

“I am flattered and humbled by this honor, Mr. President,” Gerry Darrow said. “In all my years at the bar, I never dreamed that I would be considered for such a post. I’ve represented folks at the margins of society for so long, I had begun to think of myself as an outcast.”

Thus began the improbable confirmation battle of a former plaintiffs’ lawyer turned mid-life public defender.

Court watchers and legal academics were stunned by the nomination.

Norm has captured something truly important in this post, and I implore you to read it in its entirety.  But the last sentence quoted above was the one that got me.  With all the punditry by “right in the center of the box” thinkers, Norm nailed it.  We look to the Lithwicks, the Liptaks, to tell us what we think.  That big pool of possibilities, consisting of federal appellate judges from Harvard or Yale, from which to choose.  Why?  Well, these are the people who know, and that’s what they say.  No one asked Norm what he thinks.

Years ago, Baskin-Robbins announced that it had 31 flavors.  Today, we have a choice of chocolate or vanilla, and both frankly taste the same.  We’ve become a nation of followers and cowards.  Presidents are cowards too.  Senators are cowards.  We are cowards for voting for cowards.  We are cowards for taking the path of least resistance, for indulging ourselves with rationalizations of the practical and predictable. 

“I promised hope when I asked for your trust during the last election. And you heard me. Together we transformed hope into a new and audacious reality. Today I redeem a part of my promise by naming a man who is no stranger to the suffering of ordinary Americans as the next Justice of the United States Supreme Court,” the president said.

It’s my turn to make a prediction.  We will never again have a president with the guts to make this statement.  We will never have a Senate that would consent to such a selection.  How many of you, dear readers, will think to yourselves that you’re satisfied with this future, that vanilla suits you just fine and, besides, it’s the easiest way to go, and, well, why bother since nothing ever changes.

Cowards.

Expect nothing and your expectations will always be met.

Only The Defense Lawyer Didn’t Get Schtupped.

The Supreme Court denied cert.  yesterday to Charles Dean Hood, the latest joke played by the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals.  You may remember it as the one where the judge, Verla Sue Holland , was deeply in love with the prosecutor, and, well, stercus accidit.

Scott Henson at Grits for Breakfast  spells out the details, so no need to do so again here.  It’s enough to know that the justices of the Supreme Court are romantics at heart, and not even an execution can stand in the way of true love. 

The good news is that Hood will get a new trial, purportedly because of erroneous instructions.  The bad news is that there’s no impropriety if the judge is screwing the prosecutor in an entirely different way than everyone else.  It’s almost like  they’re librarians .

Ain’t love grand?

Tech Neutralilty Meets The Supremes (Update)

The Supreme Court heard oral argument in City of Ontario v. Quon, providing the perfect opportunity for criminal defense lawyers to get a bird’s eye view of the folks into whose hands the future of the Fourth Amendment is placed, should Orin Kerr’s tech neutral  approach become the format for future of search and seizure law.

The point isn’t the Quon case per se, which is about the Stored Communications Act, a boring yet unconstitutional law that circumvents the Fourth Amendment because Congress says so, but about how tech neutrality plays out.  The notion is that the myriad of issues raised by developing technology and the digital world under the Fourth Amendment should be addressed by applying the rules developed over the past century for brick and mortar searches and seizures to electrons by analogy.  Orin explains it in his article, Applying the Fourth Amendment to the Internet: A General Approach, 62 Stan. L. Rev. 1005 (2010), but that’s my shorthand version.

Just in the nick of time comes this post from Ashby Jones at the WSJ Law Blog .  Meet the tech savvy justices who will be deciding which analogy to use to deprive you of your constitutional rights.

According to the story, the first sign of trouble came was about midway through the argument, when Chief Justice John Roberts asked what the difference was “between email and a pager?” (Cue sound of hard slap against forehead.)

At another point, Justice Anthony Kennedy asked what would happen if a text message was sent to an officer at the same time he was sending one to someone else.

“Does it say: ‘Your call is important to us, and we will get back to you?’” Kennedy asked. (Cue sound of louder slap against forehead.)

Justice Antonin Scalia stumbled getting his arms around with the idea of a service provider.

“You mean (the text) doesn’t go right to me?” he asked.

Then he asked whether they can be printed out in hard copy.

“Could Quon print these spicy little conversations and send them to his buddies?” Scalia asked.

No doubt this will make you feel a whole lot more comfortable putting the future of our freedom from unreasonable searches and seizures into their hands, appreciating their firm grasp of technology and the ability to discern which exceptions to the Fourth Amendment to apply by analogy under any given circumstances.

I bet you’re shocked to find out that Supreme Court Justices probably didn’t pre-order the iPad, desperate to be on the cutting edge of cool.  And yet, let’s place our faith in personal freedom in the ability of Luddites to apply horse and buggy rules to the digital world.  It would be a shame to waste a century of exceptions, right?

H/T Orin Kerr , who loves irony as much as I do.

Update:  And here’s some more exchange  via Orin:

CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS: Do any of these other people know about Arch Wireless? Don’t they just assume that once they send something to Quon, it’s going to Quon?

MR. DAMMEIER: That’s — that is true. I mean, they expect –

CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS: Well, then they can’t have a reasonable expectation of privacy based on the fact that their communication is routed through a communications company.

MR. DAMMEIER: Well, they — they expect that some company, I’m sure, is going to have to be processing the delivery of this message. And –

CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS: Well, I didn’t — I wouldn’t think that. I thought, you know, you push a button; it goes right to the other thing.

And that, tech neutral types, is how the law and tech intersect.

 

His First Arrest

There’s nothing unusual about a defendant being on trial for his first arrest.  What is unusual is when that he’s the person who made the arrest, and it was his first as a police officer.  The trial of Patrick Pogan  for his assault on bicyclist Christopher Long during the Critical Mass rally in Manhattan has opened, which I like to call the “Big Shove.”

As it turns out, Pogan, who has since resigned from the force, was a mere baby cop when he become a video star of the internet.  According to his lawyer, Stuart London, Pogan was just following orders.

But Mr. London said during his opening statement that Mr. Pogan, who had been on the force for just 11 days when the confrontation happened, was naïve and simply following the orders of his superiors. At a briefing earlier that evening, a captain told Mr. Pogan and other young officers that they needed to issue summonses, Mr. London said.

“How do we stop them?” an officer asked, according to Mr. London.

“Do what you have to do to get them off their bikes,” the captain responded, according to Mr. London.

So Pogan ran over to Long and slammed him off his bike as Long tried to pass.  A bit literal, but it did serve to get Long off the bike.  Still, this fails to explain why Pogan decided that Long would be the person to be debiked.  London explains that too in his opening.

Mr. Pogan’s lawyer vigorously attacked Mr. Long, 31, as a reckless, pot-smoking miscreant who was the provocateur that night.

“Christopher Long is a bike rider that conned Pogan in this whole situation,” Stuart London, Mr. Pogan’s lawyer, said in his opening statement. “Christopher Long is a bike rider who knew exactly what he was doing.”

So it was the crafty criminal mastermind, bicyclist Long, who played agent provocateur to naïve rookie Pogan, compelling the officer to run toward Long and body slam him to the ground as part of his scheme as a reckless, pot-smoking miscreant.  This wasn’t immediately clear from the video  that’s been around since the incident, or apparently a second video taken by a cyclist behind Long.

(Addendum: At the request of readers too lazy to click on the link to see the video, here’s a reprise)

Now that London cleared that up, what of the criminal complaint  filed by Pogan alleging that Long attacked him (and it should be noted that police officers, in the heat of performing their stressful work, sometimes confuse who attacked whom.  No seriously, it can happen).

The arrest was Mr. Pogan’s first, Mr. London said, and his sergeant was the one who filled out the report. Mr. Pogan merely signed off on it, and was not trying to cover anything up, Mr. London said.

There you have it.  Pogan wasn’t being evil, but just didn’t read the complaint when he swore it was truthful.  I mean, does anybody serious buy into that whole swearing to tell the truth thing?

There is a monumental schism between the defense of a cop and the defense of anyone else in America.  When defending a cop, as London regularly does on behalf of the PBA, you can make outrageous claims and allegations that would be absurd when defending anyone else.  This is because people want to believe that the police are here to protect and serve, are really the good guys, would never do what is clearly shown on the video.  People struggle to find excuses, no matter how far-fetched, for their wrongdoing.  They need to believe.

London’s allegations about Christopher Long are ridiculous.  That doesn’t mean that they won’t fly, although this particular case presents one of the longest stretches to reach for a not guilty verdict we’re likely to see.  Whether it flies will be told when the verdict is returned.

Until then, it’s worth bearing in mind that had there been no video of the Big Shove, it would have been Christopher Long on trial for assaulting rookie cop Jason Pogan.  And the verdict would have likely been a foregone conclusion.

I Have Failed The Fourth

Orin Kerr announces  that his latest law review article, Applying the Fourth Amendment to the Internet: A General Approach, 62 Stan. L. Rev. 1005 (2010), is now online.  This is the abstract.

This Article offers a general framework for applying the Fourth Amendment to the Internet. It assumes that courts will seek a technology-neutral translation of Fourth Amendment principles from physical space to cyberspace, and it considers what new distinctions in the online setting can reflect the function of Fourth Amendment protections designed for the physical world. It reaches two major conclusions. First, the traditional physical distinction between inside and outside should be replaced with the online distinction between content and non-content information. Second, courts should require a search warrant that is particularized to individuals rather than Internet accounts to collect the contents of protected Internet communications. These two principles point the way to a technology-neutral translation of the Fourth Amendment from physical space to cyberspace.

My eyes burn as they absorb each word.  Oh, the horror. 

As courts, invariably reaching to grasp a way to deal with the intersection of technology and the Fourth Amendment, look to a credible source for guidance, Orin has emerged as one of the foremost thinkers.  His works are regularly cited, and serve to provide a foundation for consideration of the constitutionality of search and seizure law as applied to the digital world.  He’s a player.

It’s been clear for some time that Orin’s “net neutrality” approach, the application of existing “brick and mortar” Fourth Amendment precedent to evolving technologies and the digital world by analogy meant that we are doomed.  Same black letter law.  Same 17 million exceptions to cover every search.  Same judges using the “file cabinet” analogy to explain why suppression is denied. 

Don’t believe me?  Then do what every cautious lawyer does on Sunday night.  Watch the Celebrity Apprentice, Rod Blagojevich  edition.  He’s turning a laptop computer upside down, looking for a pencil perhaps.   Granted, Blago was a governor, not a judge, but neither post has a test for computer literacy.  Do you really think judges are inherently more savvy than Blago.

Ultimately, the technology neutral approach leaves it up to the only person in the room who can’t distinguish a text message from twitter to decide which inapplicable analogy strikes him as most appealing.  At least when we went from Conestoga to Packards, you could see that one had chrome and the other didn’t.

Since Orin first floated his tech neutral approach, I’ve tried to persuade him that it was the wrong way to go.  I’ve failed.  Now that his latest law review article is out there for all to see, it’s too late to undo the damage that Orin Kerr has done to the future of the Fourth Amendment.

There is, however, one saving grace.  No one who would use his misbegotten theory to justify suppression can find it, because they don’t know how to turn on the computer, and even if they did, would never be capable of formulating a viable Google search.  Now, if only we can rid them of their law clerks, there may still be hope.

Getting What You Paid For

When Dwight David Eisenhower appointed Earl Warren to be the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States in 1953, it was the “biggest damn fool mistake [he] ever made.”  The Warren Court did not perform the way President Eisenhower expected, and he wanted his money back.

Adam Liptak explains that recently retired Associate Justice David Souter was the last of the stealth appointees.

When liberal groups analyzed Justice Souter’s record as New Hampshire’s attorney general and as a justice on the state’s Supreme Court, they concluded that he was a hard-core conservative.

It didn’t quite turn out that way, though some may question whether it was Justice Souter who shifted a little to the left, or the court that shifted a lot to the right.  Since then, we’ve had no big surprises:

But 1990 probably marked a turning point in the confirmation process. The six justices appointed in the two decades since have performed largely as expected, probably thanks to increased scrutiny of more robust paper trails and less ideological drift.

The contemporary nominee’s résumé yields so much valuable information, legal scholars say, that unexpected judicial decisions are much less likely now. Nominees’ backgrounds these days often include work for the executive branch in Washington and substantial service on a federal appeals court.

The reason for the accuracy is that candidates are drawn from one of two places, either federal appellate courts where they have long records of written decisions demonstrating their views, or service in the executive branch, where formal and informal discussion clarifies their true leanings, at least to others in the executive branch.

The talk that the only criteria for appointment is competence is sheer and utter nonsense.  That’s not to say that anyone suggests that appointees are not competent, but competence alone will get you a seat in the gallery, provided you wait on line.  It’s competence plus agenda, the clear and demonstrable showing of adherence to a political and philosophical view upon which a president, and senate, can depend. 

This means that the pool of candidates for the Supremes won’t include a trench lawyer.  Not for Republicans, and not for Democrats either.  Not now, and now in the future.  Never again.  And if you lawprofs think that’s funny, you aren’t in the pool either, unless you are able to get a gig on the circuit bench.  Of course, there’s a far better chance for a lawprof to wind up in a robe than your typical trench lawyer, so maybe you get a chuckle or two.

The problem is that the pool of potential appointees is so small, and so insular, that our third branch of government is comprised of an elite within an elite.  For anyone who believes that the Supremes are, by virtue of their job, detached from the reality of society in general, and even the practice of law in the trenches, consider that the desire to make absolutely certain that no one gets the nod without having an absolute lock on their views means that the broadest segment of the legal profession, no less society, will never again be represented on the Court.  That’s an awful lot of experience to be ignored.

Given that Supreme Court appointments are for life, in order to immunize the court from transitory political whims and empower justices to make bold decisions without fear of impact, the limitation of future appointees to be drawn from this incredibly narrow pool of federal appellate judges and top executive branch staff is frightening.  These are the people who make the rules by which the rest of us live, and few of them, if any, have every actually lived life on the streets like the poor schnooks who have to abide their rulings.  Their decisions describe a view of reality from on high, like the “new professionalism” of cops, or the incentives/disincentives for alleged criminals.  As if they have a clue.

The irony is that presidents, who are elected based upon transitory political whims, get to name folks to the court who will sit in their seats for decades after the presidents are turned out of office.  While the appointments may reflect the public’s will at the time of their appointment, that doesn’t mean that their political and legal agendas are still suited to the good of the Republic decades later, and that leaves one branch of government with potentially poor choices for a generation to come. 

Of course, this cuts both ways, and whether one sees the court as too liberal or too conservative, it’s political foundation is firm and predictable.  Considering how many 5-4 decisions have come from the Supremes since Justice Souter took the bench, how tenuous the basic law of the land has become with a single vote sufficient to change the rule of law 180 degrees, the Supreme Court has become little more than a proxy for political hardball based on the guy naming names.

What the American people won’t be getting is a court comprised of men and women who bear any resemblance to them, or have much more of a feel for their lives, and hence the impact of their decisions, beyond the way it looks from the heights of an appellate bench.  No matter how brilliant or well-intended, there may never be another Supreme Court Justice who knows anything about life on the street again.  And that won’t stop them from telling us what it’s all about.