Other than the truly sick people who find crush films to their liking, it’s hard to fathom why anyone would take pleasure from the infliction of needless harm and pain to animals. But does the Stevens decision lead us to stop eating meat? I was a little surprised to see that Marc Randazza found the reasoning in Jon Katz’s argument compelling:
I wish for Stevens to be an opportunity not only to celebrate and strengthen the First Amendment, but also for people to re-examine their relationship with and treatment of all animals, both of different species and their own species.
Violence begets violence, and that concept is not limited only to human-on-human violence. How desensitized do people become about harming other humans when they eat other mammals, who are not so unrelated biologically to humans? Of course, chickens and fish also bleed and feel pain and suffering from being slaughtered.
Randazza responds:
My food consumption is one of my admitted hypocrisies. While I agree with everything Katz has to say about this subject, I simply love eating animals. Even veal and foie gras. I don’t see changing that (but never say never). Nevertheless, I do think the argument is compelling. Believe it or not, I consciously try to be more compassionate every day. I think that Jon makes a very strong, if not indisputable, point.
This has the joint failing of conceding hypocrisy while adopting a straw argument. Maybe all that San Diego sunshine has done something to Randazza?
I respect Jon’s choice to go vegan; it’s entirely up to him to be comfortable with his own conduct, and certainly there’s no harm in not eating meat. But I don’t share the feeling. While inflicting cruelty upon animals for kicks disgusts me, I am a carnivore. Human beings are carnivores. It’s our nature. That we raise, and kill, animals for food is consistent with out nature, and consistent with the natural world, even though we’ve altered it to satisfy the need to feed ourselves.
I’ve watched the National Geographic channel. Wild animals are often unkind to their own, and even more unkind to those critters they eat. There’s nothing pretty about one snatching the other in mid-air, or the bank of a river, or wherever they happen to find them. It’s brutal.
Does it cause pain? I’ve no doubt it does, as I’ve no doubt the alpha rhino hurts the young bull hoping to catch the interest of a mate when it give it a piece of its horn. This is still part of the natural process of the rhino’s life, and it’s unlikely that rhino matchmaking will find a place on cable.
Jon draws a connection between the desensitization that comes from eating meat and human on human violence. I see no connection whatsoever. There’s no explanation for the analogy, but merely a question of “how desensitized to people become.” Not at all, I say. Why would they? One involves eating meat, as is our nature and maintains our existence, while the other has nothing whatsoever to do with that. I can accept the parallel between crush films and harming other humans, but not eating.
There are people who cannot bear to eat meat knowing that an animal died to provide it. There are people who cannot bear to eat meat knowing the conditions under which livestock is raised to supply us with meat, or knowing how the animals are slaughtered. It’s understandable, and I do not begrudge anyone who feels this way from making whatever choice he or she feels necessary.
That doesn’t mean, however, that there is a sound basis to extrapolate the disgust we feel toward something as horrible as a crush film with our nature as carnivores. There is simply no rational connection between the two, and the effort to draw one will tend to make it increasingly difficult to enforce the constitutional rights that underlie cases like Stevens by suggesting that they lead down the slippery slope to such outcomes as veganism.
Preserving the First Amendment is not the gateway to becoming a vegan, or any other personal choices for which no rational connection exists. Let’s not get crazy about this and provide ammunition to be used to shoot down sensible court decisions in guise of shooting down dinner.
