Author Archives: SHG

Be Gone

It’s the stuff of fairytales, when the king would wave his arm and the knave would be forever banished from the kingdom.  Or the courts of the hinterlands.  From the Buffalo News :

Brian M. Renaud, who pleaded guilty Wednesday to his second marijuana felony in six years, is being kicked out of New York State as part of a plea bargain approved by Niagara County Judge Sara Sheldon Sperrazza.

Renaud, 31 . . . admitted to a reduced charge of attempted second-degree criminal possession of marijuana. Sperrazza agreed to place him on probation as long as he leaves the state forever.

“Banishment is not something I do lightly or often,” the judge said.

I bet.  Banish people too often and you can get tennis elbow.  Or banish shoulder.  Well, something bad can happen to a part of your arm, though it’s unclear whether a waving motion is required to effectuate banishment.  Judge Sperrazza, already renown  for approving the use of tasers to obtain a DNA swab, must have strong arms if it is.

As pot-sweeteners for probation go, banishment is quite an interesting one.  Many a time, prosecutors have told me that they were particularly displeased with the fact that a defendant committed a crime in “her town.”  Many a defendant would happily go elsewhere rather than sully the town yet further with his presence.  Particularly if his presence was in the local hoosegow.  Leave town?  Problem solved.

But then, it just moves the problem down the road a piece, unless probation is otherwise an appropriate sentence.

Banishment is the ultimate sentencing version of “out of sight, out of mind.”  It solves nothing with regard to the legitimate factors that the law imposes on a court in determining an appropriate sentence, other than general deterrence within the local sphere by dint of removing the defendant from the local sphere.  But it simultaneously injects the putative miscreant into someone else’s local sphere.  Everybody’s got to be somewhere.  If not here, then where?

Renaud apparently informed the court that he’s compelled by manifest necessity to go to California.  No doubt a fine choice for someone whose got a green thumb, at least when it comes to growing marijuana.  If, however, the police, prosecutors and judges on the left coast find Renaud’s activities troubling, the next sentence can always split the difference and banish him to Kansas.

Dare. Double Dare

Christopher Jorgenson labors under the worst of circumstances.  He lives in Des Moines, Iowa.  I’ve been to Des Moines. You’ve got to have a sense of humor.

Jorgenson is better known online as Jackass Letters , channeling Don Novello  (a/k/a Father Guido Sarducci), who assumed the persona of Lazlo Toth (of Pieta notoriety) as he wrote letters to celebrities, politicians and corporations to tweak them a bit and see how they responded.  He explains his schtick:

This site is a site dedicated to examining correspondence with real people and companies. It is part spoof, satire, parody and part criticism. New letters are generally published Mondays at 7:00 AM.

So….

Is my motivation greed? Am I just clamoring after free stuff? No. Free stuff is cool, but I also intend to enjoy the process. I fully expect to enjoy the responses more than any of the swag. Daily I make the trip to my mail box only to see it stuffed with junk mail and bills. I want to look forward to getting mail again.

Remember, he’s from Des Moines.  It doesn’t take much to amuse, if you get my drift.

So Jorgenson decided to put me to the test.  He sent me a letter, his FUQ’s (pronounced as would be expected from a guy from DM) notwithstanding, to which I responded by an email attachment, since I don’t have to live by his rules and I saved the price of stamp.  Would he have the ‘nads to publish it?  He then made a dare: He would publish my letter if I would post a drawing that he would send me.  He wanted me to put it on the fridge, which I would happily do if it wasn’t for the fact that I still use an icebox.  But that doesn’t stop me from showing you the picture anyway.

 

I dunno, but it’s a pretty good likeness if you ask me.

Your turn, Chris.

Bienvenido a Arizona

Don’t be surprised if police in Arizona seem particularly friendly.  And what’s wrong with that, bringing the police closer to the community and generating camaraderie and good will?  Happy police.  Happy public.  Everybody’s happy.  Especially anyone in Arizona with dark skin, who speaks Spanish or maybe just has an accent, who wears work boots and stands on a corner.  They may well be the special friends of cops.

When Governor Jan Brewer signed Arizona’s illegal alien bill into law, it was the dawn of a new age of friendliness.  Via Turley, this is the heart of the law.

FOR ANY LAWFUL CONTACT MADE BY A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICIAL OR AGENCY OF THIS STATE OR A COUNTY, CITY, TOWN OR OTHER POLITICAL SUBDIVISION OF THIS STATE WHERE REASONABLE SUSPICION EXISTS THAT THE PERSON IS AN ALIEN WHO IS UNLAWFULLY PRESENT IN THE UNITED STATES, A REASONABLE ATTEMPT SHALL BE MADE, WHEN PRACTICABLE, TO DETERMINE THE IMMIGRATION STATUS OF THE PERSON. THE PERSON’S IMMIGRATION STATUS SHALL BE VERIFIED WITH THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT PURSUANT TO 8 UNITED STATES CODE SECTION 1373(c).

It begins with “any lawful contact.”  There’s nothing unlawful about saying “good morning” to a dark skinned fellow in blue jeans walking down the street.  It’s just being friendly.  Certainly, cops can be friendly.  But now that lawful contact has been made, the response of “buenos dias” may take on new meaning.

The second prong is “where reasonable suspicion exists that the person is an alien who is unlawfully present in the United States.”  This gets a bit dodgy.  Does looking like a foreigner suffice for reasonable suspicion to believe the fellow is an illegal?  They don’t have scarlet letters on their foreheads, and it’s not clear what part of their appearance, speech or dress would distinguish a legal alien from an illegal.  Or even a citizen from an alien.  From my view, it’s going to be very hard to tell the illegals from others.  But there’s no harm in asking a question between friends.

But there’s nothing wrong with the police officer, after a friendly greeting, asking a fellow if he’s an illegal alien.  I mean, it’s just a question and there’s a common law right to inquire.  He can’t force the guy to answer.  But if he does answer, then the cop can ask for some proof, since the dark skin fellow asserted he’s here legally and the officer would be remiss if he didn’t followup.  On the other hand, if he runs from the officer rather than answer, well, that’s suspicion since a legal immigrant would never do that.  And it’s definitely suspicious if he refuses to answer.

If the Spanish speaking guy says he doesn’t have his proof of citizenship on him, then the officer will be required to determine his immigration status with the Feds.  That could take a while, of course.  A day or two.  The Feds are busy, you know, and can’t always answer the phone, or run the computer check, or care. 

My guess is that there won’t be a lot of Swedes becoming close friends with the Arizona police.  It’s unclear how grave a problem exists with illegal Swedish immigration, but word around Arizona is that they have a big problem with Mexicans coming across the border illegally and, if Senator McCain is to be trusted, purposefully crashing cars.  Nobody wants to be in a needless car crash.

The good people of Arizona don’t seem to like people from Mexico very much, even if the local police become really close friends with them.  I’ve been told in the past that those of us who live in other parts of the country don’t understand how illegal immigrants have overrun their state, causing crime, unemployment and, per the Senator, car crashes.  It’s not that I’m not unsympathetic about the problems endured by Arizonians.  I am.  I wouldn’t want to have my car crashed anymore than the next guy.  But that’s no reason not to get all buddy-buddy with the dark skinned, Spanish speaking guy in work boots on the corner.

And what’s wrong with having really friendly cops?

When There’s Nothing To Say

Since I discovered Tamar Weinberg , the self-proclaimed social media rock star, I use her as my bellwether for the unbearable lightness of marketing.  Following her post, 7 Truths About Social Media Marketing , a cat fight broke out in the comments when a commenter, going by the name “Fed Up,” wrote:

How many times can you write the same thing over and over again?

This led to flames.  Tamar adores being adored.  Tamar was not pleased at being told she was naked (excuse the image).  After a variety of nastiness, not the least of which was Tamar calling “Fed Up” a coward  for not using a real name (and one of the more brilliant commenters noting that this name was “obviously bogus.” I wonder what gave it away?).

The problem is Tamar’s post, which, per the majority of her commenters, ran the gamut from wonderful to genius, said nothing that any reasonably sentient being wouldn’t innately know.  It leads me to believe that social media marketing is either the last bastion of the pathologically stupid, or, more likely, simply a vapid endeavor where those lacking the skills to get a productive job congregate to lock arms and compliment each other for not drooling. 

Tamar ends the cat fight with this diatribe:

You want to give me constructive criticism? Give it to me. What you did was come out here with guns blazing and attacking my tactics.

“You insult the reader and say you’re not there to help them, and if they want real value they should hire you, closing with “bye”.”

Want some value? The original comment about building relationships was obviously missed by you, since you did no such thing. So guess what? These messages are being sent but not heeded to. That’s why I repeat it, because people like you don’t get the message.

If you’re a regular reader like you say you are, surely you should have gotten the memo by now.

“Second, I don’t know – I thought blogging was all about providing value to your readers”

I’m all about giving value to my readers, and like I said before, there are at least 20 commenters (and 321 people who have since retweeted this post) who thought so.

Don’t forget, time is money, and I am already giving you hours of my time for free. I don’t owe you a single thing more than what I’m already investing considerable time for — all for nothing.

There are many people who I appreciate; they’re incredibly thankful — that’s why I continue blogging (in generalities — oh, because I can). Then there’s you. You obviously need to demand more. Why do you think you’re entitled? Get over the sense of entitlement. Being rude and inconsiderate, which is exactly what you did from your first comment here, was wrong.

“Maybe it’s that easy for you, but some of us actually have to examine, apply, test and tweak any and every lesson learned and every advice received.”

Yup, and since going into specifics doesn’t belong in a blog post since it will ostracize 95% of my readers, I focus on generalities. Sorry to disappoint you, but again, I owe you absolutely nothing. Expecting otherwise speaks miles for your character, which is already undermined by the fact that you aren’t even [wo]man enough to use your real name. It’s actually my blog policy, which is why I ask for it. You have ignored the policy entirely.

If you want me to give you something of substance, ask for it. But just insulting my approach — which is EXACTLY what you did from your first comment — will absolutely get you to where you are with me right now, being defensive because this is MY blog and NOT yours.

Brevity is not Tamar’s strength.  She’s not much on clarity either.  And she’s a bit weak on logic.  But when it comes to being disingenuous, nobody beats Tamar.  And she’s got sycophants to prove it.

So the product of her outrage is that “Fed Up’s” complaint was right on the money, that Tamar repeats the same insipid, meaningless vagaries to the applause of some of the unemployables and concedes in her denial that she’s got nothing to offer.  There’s no substance to be had, and yet her fans adore her.  Does it occur to Tamar that she’s being applauded for saying nothing?  Does she consider what this says about social media marketing?  Having considered Tamar’s advice (most notably building relationships with those who bolster her fragile ego), I doubt she grasps the ironies.

Over the past week (actually for much longer, but it’s really hit home over the past week), I’ve watched lawyers trying to be like Tamar.  Some surrounding themselves with friendlies to build relationships upon which they can enjoy mutual self-promotion.  Others lighting a fire for noting the substantive errors in their self-promotional efforts.  Whether the flare-up was love or anger, it was embarrassing and disappointing.  

The shallowness of social media marketing is not Tamar’s fault.  Nor can we blame her for being angry about being called out.  If she could wield a hammer, she would build a house.  She can’t, so she spits out tired vagaries that appeal to others who can’t wield a hammer, and they all sing Kumbaya to feel better about themselves.  She can no more allow someone to reveal the obvious than fold up her tent and get a real job.  But then she wouldn’t be a social media rock star, which would make her cry.

We, on the other hand, are lawyers.  We have the ability to distinguish between substance and nonsense.  We also have the ability to distinguish between our brethren who provide substance and those who have taken to the internet to market their wares.  Those lawyers who buy into the need for social media marketing are fooling no one.  You’re just Tamar with a ticket.

Here’s my 1 truth of social media marketing.  If you want to build something worthwhile, it must start with respect for your own competency as a lawyer.  Any fool can toot his own horn.  Show that you know how to wield a hammer.  Or go hang out with Tamar and pretend that you have something to say.

It’s Not A Matter of Trust But Team

Radley Balko wrote about the travails of Steven Hatfill at The Agitator, using it as a window into how libertarianism happens.

Steven Hatfill, the government scientist whose life was turned upside down when he became a suspect in the 2001 anthrax attacks, is now talking about what happened to him. Hatfill was eventually cleared of any wrongdoing and given a settlement, but only after years of harassment and abuse at the hands of the federal government.

Hatfill was interviewed on the Today Show and in the Atlantic, and Radley includes quotes of Hatfill’s interviews via Firedoglake.

“I love my country,” Hatfill, 56, told Lauer. But, he added, “I learned a couple things. The government can do to you whatever they want. They can break the laws, federal laws, as they see fit … You can’t turn laws on and off as you deem fit. And the Privacy Act laws were put in place specifically to stop what happened to me. Whether we’re at war or have been attacked, the foundation of society is that you hold to the laws in place. I used to be somebody that trusted the government. Now I really don’t trust anything.”

This isn’t an epiphany, being thrust into the midst of libertarianism (or any other “ism” against one’s will.  In fact, Hatfill’s reaction largely misses the problem, and Radley’s vision of the birth of a libertarian may be premature.  Hatfill has suffered for sure, but not because he learned that the government is an omnipotent presence, one that can “turn laws on and off” at will.  Everyone who wants to know that knows that. 

We’re team players.  We pick a team and expect our team members to back us up.  Hatfill picked the government team, and had every reasonable expectation that they would be as loyal to him as he was to them, right or wrong.

“I used to be somebody that trusted the government. Now I really don’t trust anything.”

His team screwed him.  The team was disloyal. He got burned.  When you’re on the government team, you rationalize its conduct for the sake of others, while knowing (as does every cop) that it’s not a matter of believing that your team is more honest, more upstanding, more righteous than the other team.  You know that your team does things it shouldn’t from time to time, but you can turn a blind eye to it knowing that it’s your team.  Some people know that their team can be really, really bad, and still they remain in the batting order.  After all, it’s their team.

Sometimes you believe that your team is more right than wrong.  Sometimes you believe that your team has to beak a few rules or laws to accomplish the greater good.  Other times, you just slough it off when people on your team do wrong because, well, they’re your teammates and it’s your team.  Loyalty to the team is paramount, as you expect that loyalty in return.

Hatfill’s complaint is that his team was disloyal to him.  It turned on him and put him through the ringer that was only meant for the other team.  Would he have had the same epiphany had he been reading about the story happening to some other guy named Hatfill?  Has Hatfill’s travails caused a mass surge of libertarianism throughout the nation?  Of course not, because it didn’t happen to them. 

No matter what we know about the reality on the streets, the world we live in and the government that cares for us, we stick with our team.  Cops protect their own.  Criminal defense lawyers decry abuse.  Judges justify the imprisonment of the innocent based on precedent.  If we learned, or cared, we would all be of one mind.  We aren’t, and we refuse to understand why others see the world through different eyes.  These are the eyes of the team.

As long as the team continues to embrace us, we cheer for it.  We cheer for our schools, even though the other guy’s school is no better or worse.  It’s just not ours. We do the same for our country, our religion, our race.  No one has a monopoly on right and wrong, yet we stick together and back each other up.

The government team may be the best one going, since it allows you to be on the side of the powerful.  We all want to feel powerful, and by adopting the loves and hates of the government, our team wins almost every battle. Who doesn’t want to be on the winning team?  But when you’re not allowed on the winning team, or worse still, when the winning team throw you off, where do you go?

Some of us choose to be on another team.  We think we’re better than others for doing so, that we’ve chosen right over might.  We may just be naive, or perhaps a bit masochistic in picking struggle over ease.  There’s a certain smugness in being the underdog, but there’s also plenty of smugness to be on the winning team too.  No matter what team we’re on, we believe it’s the best team, not because it necessarily is but because we must believe it is. 

It’s hard to say what team Hatfill will join next, or what team will have him.  At this point, my guess is that Hatfill will be happy to be a part of any team that will protect him, but it will be hard for him to embrace any team after the members of his last team were disloyal.  The most important thing is that he’s accepted as part of the team.

NYPD to Bicycles: We Got You Now

The New York City Council has long struggled with the rampage of bicycles mowing down pedestrians in cold blood.  On the one hand, it involved neither salt, cigarettes nor polyunsaturated fats, evils long suspected to be the root of crack addiction and racial inequality.  On the other, debate has raged as to whether it’s bicycles who run down people, or riders.  A decision was needed. A decision was made.

042210bikes.jpg
Courtesy Anthony Rebholz/thisisfyf

It’s the bikes.

In related news, the NYPD determined that the possibility that a pipe bomb could be placed in a bicycle gave rise to the theft of hundreds along Houston Street in Manhattan, in anticipation of President Obama’s trip to Cooper Union last week in honor of Earth Day.  From This is FYF ,

Citing security concerns that bikes might be secret pipe bombs, NYPD officers clipped the locks of hundreds of bikes along Houston Street this morning in preparation for President Obama’s speech at Cooper Union.  The bikes  were unceremoniously put in the back of the truck.  There was no prior notification of the bikes needing to be cleared along the route by NYPD and onlookers were not given information as to what would become of the bikes.  Happy Earth Day!

The theft and trashing of hundreds of bicycles might, under other circumstances, be considered scandalous, if not mind-bogglingly stupid, but an NYPD spokesman stated that many of the seized culprits have a prior criminal history of attacking innocent pedestrians, leaving babies fatherless.  In addition, some were believed to be congregating on the sidewalk and observed smoking marijuana.  When ordered to leave by a police officer, they just stood there, defiant, until one bicycle made a furtive gesture, forcing the officer to taser the bike.  Rumors that the bikes were part of the Gambino crime family were dismissed after thorough investigation.

The officer was injured in the melee and has retired on full pension.  The PBA will be running a sale on cut bicycle chains this weekend, with all proceeds going to purchase new bullet-proof Sam Browns for the incoming class at the Academy.

New York City is now safe for presidents and pedestrians.

 

Judging Us, The Business Opportunity

My favorite marketing philosopher, Seth Godin, asks who judges your work.

We let anyone, just anyone, judge our work (and by extension, judge us.)

Sue, the airheaded but long-legged girl in Spanish class gets the right to judge our appearance.

Bill, the bitter former-poet English teacher gets the power to tell us if we’re good at writing.

And on and on.

An email arrived yesterday announcing a contest for the worst lawyer ads on the internet.  Well, that seemed like a funny enough contest to pique my interest. There were a host of categories, from worst acting to most ethically challenged.  And who was running this funny contest?  A website I’d never heard of before called .

With reckless abandon, I clicked.  “Helping Regular People and Businesses Choose and Manage Their Lawyers.”

From what I can tell, this is the brainchild of Nat Colley, a former marketer for Thomson Reuters, the folks who bring you Westlaw and Findlaw, who has created a website to find lawyers, for a fee, for those in need.  His basic service provides the names of three lawyers for $250.  His rationale for why someone should pay him is all over his site.  It makes sense, though it leaves more questions open than it answers, most notably, “why him?”  Ironic, since a person who can’t find a lawyer for lack of the ability to discern quality, would pay an unknown person to do it for him.  Go figure.

Looking around the website, I was unable to find Nat Colley’s name anywhere.  That’s a red flag to me, a sign that someone’s trying to hide something.  It’s easy to hide on the internet.  While providing his background as a former Thomson marketer, though without any details of worth, he doesn’t say who he is.  Another disbarred lawyer, perhaps?  A former lawyer, but it’s a blank from there. Maybe he’s great at what he does and provides a wonderful service. But there’s nothing to distinguish him from the mass of make-believe people online with something to sell.  And what he sells is judging lawyers.

Scanning the blawgosphere, I saw a fascinating exchange over at Affirmative Links  in the comments section of a post that riffed off the discussion here between Orin Kerr and me.  It involved efforts to make one commenter, Andrew MacKie-Mason, agree with the idea that the exceptions to the Warrant Clause have swallowed the rule.  The commenter wasn’t buying and wanted it proven to him.  What made this remarkable is that anyone cared.

A few clicks and it appeared that Andrew MacKie-Mason is a law student of no particular account.  To his credit, lawyers spent their time attempting to educate him, to no avail as it appears.  The student has a blog of his own, where he expresses his opinions.  It too is of no account.  That doesn’t mean that Andrew doesn’t sincerely believe that his opinion matters, or that he is owed an explanation to his satisfaction upon demand.  Every one of the 135,000 current law students believes, with all his heart and soul, that the world revolves around him or her, and that every lawyer in the country is obliged to indulge them. 

Somebody unfollowed me on twitter yesterday, which in itself is nothing worth mentioning.  But this person unfollowed me because I didn’t follow him back.  I don’t know who he is, or why I would possibly want to follow him.  For some reason, he thought that by following me, he made himself someone I would want to follow.  I didn’t.  I don’t.

Seth Godin’s post reminds us that the need for approval by people we don’t know, who frankly don’t exist, can be overwhelming.  There are invisible people selling their judgment of us to people too foolish to consider why they’re invisible and what they have to hide.  There are people who have done nothing in their lives to merit our attention, but who not only demand it, but receive it from people who inexplicably can’t bear the idea of someone not agreeing with them.  There are people who think they are owed our attention just because they give us theirs.

Stop worrying about being loved, respected and admired by people who don’t exist.  Just do whatever it is you do to the best of your ability and tell the rest of them to go jump in a lake.  You will never achieve universal love and popularity, respect and admiration.  There will always be some cheerleader who says you aren’t popular enough.  Who cares.

Whether it’s Nat Colley, Andrew MacKie-Mason, @LawandBaseball, do they matter in your world?  So why bother?  On the other hand, the idea of giving people the names of three lawyers for $250 is very attractive.

For A Good Time, Call Little Lupe

Mike at Crime & Federalism  broke the story.  In August, 2009, a guy named Carlos Alfredo Simon-Timmerman bought a porn video while in Venezuela, and had it in his possession when he entered the United States through Puerto Rico.  The video, “Little Lupe the Innocent; Don’t Be Fooled By Her Baby Face,” starred Lupe Fuentes, born in 1987.  The customs decided she was a child.

Simon-Timmerman spent two months in jail prior to the court case because a Special Agent of Immigration and Customs Enforcement had testified that Fuentes was “definitely” under the age of 18 in the video, as well as testimony from a pediatrician that had deemed her 100% underage; both of which Fuentes proved wrong when she showed up in court.

There are a host of ways in which this matter could have been resolved in minutes, maybe hours on a busy day. 

Under 18 U.S.C. Section 2257, all porn producers are required to verify the age of a porn actress.  Every porn production company is required to have a custodian of records.  Under the law, these records must be made available for law enforcement to inspect.

And there’s always Googling, where it would have been immediately learned:

Two months before the innocent man was arrested, Teravision signed Fuentes.  An article that appeared on AVN on June 10, 2009:

VAN NUYS, Calif. — Teravision today announced the signing of Spanish internet sensation Lupe Fuentes to an exclusive performing contract.

Previously known as “Little Lupe,” Fuentes made herself a teen model sensation and gained international stardom online. Now, she is ready to parlay that into an even brighter career in the adult video arena.

In the alternative, one would easily ascertain that Lupe won the 2006 FICEB Ninfa Prize nominee (Best New Spanish Actress – Posesión) at the Barcelona Erotic Film Festival.  It’s all there online, should anyone care.

But Simon-Timmerman was being held, lest he flee from the federales and buy another porn video, in the face of stinging evidence against him.  The prosecutrix, AUSA Jenifer Yois Hernandez-Vega, like so many young, powerful prosecutors, knew when she had an evil kiddie porn video buyer in her clutches.  She had no need to waste her time on Google, or perhaps even contacting someone to actually ascertain facts.  Not when she had “experts“.

Alek Pacheco, who works for U.S. Customs, claimed that he was an expert on child pornography.  According to Special Agent Alek Pacheco, Lupe Fuentes was between 13-14 years of age.  (See Affidavit.)

AUSA Jenifer Yois Hernandez-Vega also enlisted the help of Dr. Pedro R. Jaunarena:

Based on his numerous years of experience and training in treating children, Dr. Jaunarena will provide expert testimony regarding, but not limited to, the age of the minors depicted in the images in the labels of the DVDs and in the video images found in the DVDs seized in relation to this case.

The defense lawyer, to his enormous credit, located Lupe’s Myspace Page, tracked her down in Venezuela and got her to fly from Venezuela to Puerto Rico to prove her age.  She had to physically appear, as Prosecutor Jen would accept no less in the face of overwhelming evidence.  The judge then dismissed.

Those who love order over all else will point to Carlos’ travails as proof that all’s well that ends well.  After all, the innocent man walked.  He wasn’t executed this time, so what’s the beef?  The problem is that this case reflects a host of errors, ranging from the customs agent at the airport to the government’s experts, to the twinkie prosecutrix to the judge who allowed it to happen in front of him.  Consider this predicate to everything that happened to Carlos Alfredo Simon-Timmerman: Where it the evidence of a crime?

The entirety of this arrest and prosecution was based on one dope’s mistaken assumption, bolstered by a government in the hands of a twinkie with power far in excess of her grasp, and a system prepared to squint hard enough to allow order to prevail over reason.  When Simon-Timmerman arrived at Customs with the video, and presumably the Customs agent felt empowered to watch it, just to be sure that no evil porn watching American was bringing anything nasty back, somebody in a uniform decided, without basis whatsoever, that Lupe was a kid. 

Or maybe Lupe looked a little young after the agent watched the video for the third time (just to be sure), and Simon-Timmerman pissed him off just a little bit with his ‘tude.  Busted.

When the case landed on the prosecutrix’s desk, she could have spent the five minutes to ascertain whether there was a crime here.  She chose not to.  Instead, she turned to “experts”.  One of the secret plagues of the criminal justice system is the use of agents as “experts”, which is remarkable given how reluctant courts are to allow the defense to call someone with a few doctoral degrees, a dozen scholarly, peer reviewed studies and leading books and articles.  But if they have a shield, they are warmly embraced as experts in fields they’ve never studied or practiced.  You wouldn’t believe the expertise agents possess when it comes to drugs; they know everything there is about drug dealing, and invariably can explain why the mere possession of a beeper conclusively proves that a defendant is a major drug dealer.  Apparently, they can also discern a persons age from watching a film, so conclusively as to imprison a person.  At least to the satisfaction of a prosecutrix and a judge.

That the AUSA could have spent five minutes on Google, or made a phone call, and actually obtained information, seems to have bypassed the reasoning process here.  Why exert all that effort when one can make assure the results with the help of a friend.  Oh yes, and a doctor, since they would never say anything that was certain to a reasonable degree of medical certainty.  Just ask any personal injury lawyer, who for $500 can get a doctor to swear to anything.

But all of this comes down to the gatekeeper of the jail house.  The judge.  When presented with the allegations of possession of kiddie porn, one might wonder why a judge didn’t inquire, “have you contacted the producer of this film to ascertain the age of the actress?”  It seems to obvious, in retrospect.

It’s not only astounding how little it takes for a person’s life to be undone in the hands of the highly trained personnel of the government, from agent to all-powerful prosecutrix, but how the stop-gap, the judge, joins in the presumption of guilt.  Not only did the case proceed, but Carlos spent two months in custody until he was bonded out, without the government having an iota of evidence that a crime had occurred. 

The judge is more likely to be considered for a seat on the Supreme Court than I am.  AUSA Jenifer Yois Hernandez-Vega may leave the office and open up shop as a criminal defense lawyer, trading her claim of  insider knowledge and prosecutorial expertise for cash.  The agents will continue to watch porn videos while on duty to protect the United States from harm.

Lupe Fuentes was kind enough to travel from Venezuela to Puerto Rico to appear in court, prove her age and set an innocent man free.  She’s definitely got a good heart to be willing to put herself out to that extent.  The entirety of the United States government wasn’t worthy of the kindness of a porn star.

A Victim Twice

Samantha Geimer’s name isn’t nearly as well as known as Roman Polanksi’s, but it’s known enough.  She’s his “victim”, when she was a child of 13 back in 1977.  But now, she’s had enough .

Geimer’s attorney petitioned the court on March 23 to dismiss the case against Polanski, arguing recent changes to California’s constitution gave her more rights as a victim to influence the case.

“She is a person who is harmed by the maintenance of the prosecution and she wants it to end,” Geimer’s attorney wrote in the petition for dismissal. “She has not been treated fairly.”

Just as the prosecution for a crime is not, contrary to the mindset of victims rights advocates, a proxy for the vindication of individual rights, giving rise to the victim becoming a player in the proceedings, the termination of a prosecution isn’t up to a victim either.  Crimes are against society, though individuals may do the bulk of the suffering when there’s a victim to be had. 

The prosecution argued against Geimer, as one would expect and, perhaps, demand.  After all these years, it would be absurd to have the case die with a whimper.  Plus, there is the added concern that Polanski not be rewarded for fleeing the country rather than returning to court, particularly since lower air fares would make this an option for almost any defendant who can make bail.

Geimer’s petition was denied by the California Second District Court of Appeal without explanation.  It really didn’t need any, as the Victim’s Bill of Rights passed in California was nothing more than a political ploy to pander to those who thought it sounded really cool to make people think that victims had rights.  Another political subterfuge revealed as an empty gesture.

The question remains, however, why those who champion the rights of victims have been silent.  Do you not love Samantha, Paul Cassell?  Is she not worthy too?

It would be disingenuous of me to raise this if it involved some obscure victim, plucked out of some backwater news story that no one ever heard of.  But the Polanski case is pretty big.  Certainly big enough to make it onto the birthers victims rights advocates radar.  It seems reasonable to believe that Professor Cassell heard about it.  Even in Utah.

Obviously, the direction this is heading is down the old one-way street, where victims rights advocates are there whenever a victim wants compensation, or to veto a plea bargain, or to demand a table of her own in the well during trial, lest the prosecution not ask the questions to which the victim demands answers.  The table pounding, where is the justice, reverberates through the courtroom. 

And yet, Samantha Geimer, as far as victims go, has not only failed to achieve “closure”, that goal so often raised in the victims rights list of demands, but has spent a lifetime living, and reliving, an existence of a prop in a high profile battle that may well have made it impossible for her to exist as anything other than the 13 year old girl given champagne and a Quaalude at Jack Nicholson’s house before being raped by the boyish Roman.  Maybe she’s a real person, who wants to have a life apart of being Polanski’s victim before she dies of old age?

It’s not that this petition was any more worthy of being granted than that of victims demanding that the court ignore the terms of a plea bargain and sentence a defendant to five or six thousand years.  The decision was clearly correct, and Greimer has no right to demand dismissal, even though it means that she will continue to be the victim against her will.

The legitimacy of the victims rights movement, and the integrity of its advocates, however, is suspect when they only appear to chant “death to defendants.”  If there’s no gain to be had by supporting this victim, one who seeks the dismissal of charges rather than ever harsher punishment, then the movement  goes silent and its advocates hope that no one notices that they hid under their rocks.  Well, I noticed.

H/T Doug Berman

WWWT?

On CNN, the Republican Senator from Alabama, Jeff Sessions, was asked by John King about Arizona’s new birther law, requiring candidates for President of the United States to show their birth certificate before being placed on the ballot.  His response  was, “What’s wrong with that?”

Sessions , a former United States Attorney, Attorney General of Alabama and failed appointee for a federal judgeship, is the senior minority party member of the Senate Judiciary Committee, the same committee that blocked his judgeship.  He’s the fellow  who tried to insert a amendment in patent reform at the behest of the banking industry to deny DataTreasury of its ability to recover for infringement.  He’ll lead the charge against the nominee to replace Justice Stevens on the Supreme Court. 

Of course, the birth certificate requirement embraced by the Arizona legislature is in response to the birthers, those who believe that President Barack Obama wasn’t really born in Hawaii, and isn’t really qualified under the Constitution to serve as President.  Some may believe that he’s a sleeper agent of the terrorists, while others just hate him so much that they will seize on any reason to run him out of office on a rail.  WWWT?

King asked Sessions if it might present a problem to have each individual state come up with its own special demands for candidates before getting on the ballot.  Sessions’ response was, after a sly chuckle, to wonder whether it was constitutional.  He asks a lot of questions.  He has few answers. 

Being the helpful sort of guy that I am, and somehow having not been invited to join the King interview, it only seems right to offer some assistance to Senator Sessions by explaining WWWT.  Jeff (if I may be so bold), the problem is that if states are allowed to superimpose their individual political demands on candidates for national office, like, oh, president, we might end up with a system where candidates are held captive to impossible, embarrassing, demeaning demands designed to make it impossible for them to run. 

We could end up with courts deciding they meet the eligibility requirements, but states deciding they don’t.  We could end up with some screwy state, Alabama perhaps, enacting a law requiring candidates to recite the alphabet backwards while hopping on their left foot.  Ridiculous? Sure, but just a few baby steps beyond Arizona saying that a presidential candidate needs to meet their approval as to proof of birth.

The notion of states introducing their own requirements on candidates for national office opens a door to a new, heretofore unused, opportunity to make politics uglier than ever before.  And you thought Glen Beck was a bit too fruity?  I lack the imagination to conceive of all the potential requirements states might develop to block a potential candidate, maybe one of the party other than in control of the state.  But it’s not at all clear that states lack the power to do so.  As they are in control of their ballot, states may very well have the authority to impose conditions upon candidates.  Moreover, it’s not entirely clear that they need to be conditions that reflect specific requirements of the Constitution, such as being a natural born citizen.

Open this door and the ugliness that characterizes the state of American politics will reach a new low.  If it’s difficult now to find a candidate that anyone actually wants to vote for, imagine what we’ll be left with should another layer of political craziness be imposed.

On the other hand, there is one requirement to get on the ballot that I could get behind.  Why not make every candidate for office, and I mean every office, take the Advanced Placement exam for United States History and have to get a 5 to make the cut?  WWWT?