Author Archives: SHG

Padilla, From the Sublime to the Ridiculous

Few cases generate as much heat amongst practicing lawyers than Padilla v. Kentucky, the Supreme Court decision requiring criminal defense lawyers to correctly advise non-citizen defendants who plead guilty of the immigration consequences of the plea, unless the consequences are unclear. 

Since my earlier discussion of the decision, and its flaws, some of the brethren have sought to provide some helpful information.  Gideon, at A Public Defender, offers this:

Never fear. Here’s a   practice advisory on Padilla, and more importantly, on pages 7-8, a list of deportable offenses and tips on how to approach a case with immigration consequences.

The advisory also points to several great resources on immigration consequences in criminal courts.

You can thank me later.

There’s nothing better than the simple life, where a handy “cheat sheet” gives a laundry list of everything you need to know.  Print it out. Carry it to court. Be brilliant.  Except…that’s not really the problem.  The problem is that the Padilla duty is largely a no brainer at the extremes, where the immigrant defendant pleads to possession of 457 kilos of cocaine with intent to sell (it’s a little large for personal use anyway), or doing 37 in a 35 mile per hour zone, with or without your windows excessively tinted.  The problem is toward the middle of the spectrum, where all this mushy information does little to inform.

What this means for the defense lawyer is clear, but even more interesting is what it means for the prosecutor who is concerned about making sure his guilty plea sticks.  Enter former TV star and Justin Bieber body double, Ken Lammers at CrimLaw to make the point.

It’s more than a little ridiculous to expect defense attorneys practicing in State courts to understand the intricacies of immigration law. How ridiculous? Well let’s look at the list of sources which Justice Stevens uses to back his claim that it is a normal standard of practice for defense attorneys to be fluent in and advise clients as to immigration law:

National Legal Aid and Defender Assn., Performance Guidelines for Criminal Representation §6.2 (1995); G. Herman, Plea Bargaining §3.03, pp. 20–21 (1997); Chin & Holmes, Effective Assistance of Counsel and the Consequences of Guilty Pleas, 87 Cornell L. Rev. 697, 713–718 (2002); A. Campbell, Law of Sentencing §13:23, pp. 555, 560 (3d ed. 2004); Dept. of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, 2 Compendium of Standards for Indigent Defense Systems, Standards for Attorney Performance, pp. D10, H8–H9, J8 (2000) (providing survey of guidelines across multiple jurisdictions); ABA Standards for Criminal Justice, Prosecution Function and Defense Function 4–5.1(a), p. 197 (3d ed. 1993); ABA Standards for Criminal Justice, Pleas of Guilty 14–3.2(f), p. 116 (3d ed. 1999).

Hard as it is to admit, Ken is right.  We don’t read hornbooks, law review articles or (gasp) the ABA standards (on anything whatsoever) in the regular course of our practice.  Court decisions, all the time.  The rest,

we have a widely disparate set of habeas-bait “standards” (invariably impossible to follow: see this post), never used procedural books (I’d even go so far as to say never heard of, but someone out there must have), ABA standards which laughed at by actual practitioners (actual criminal law attorneys don’t have time to waste with that organization), and a law review article (you’re kidding?!? tell me you’re kidding).

Ken used to be a criminal defense lawyer before he turned to the dark side.  He knows stuff.  And what this means is that the plea he worked out so carefully will be subject to all manner of challenge afterward for failure by the defense lawyer to either comply with Padilla, or be accurate.

So, getting back to reality as the Supreme Court has now defined it for us, what are the practical effects on the ground? Well, we know that a lot of attorneys aren’t going to pro-actively advise the possible immigration consequences of a conviction. We also know that even when they do there will be appeals and habeases in which the defendant claims that he wasn’t notified. Hopefully, judges will start adding the question to the plea colloquy, “Are you aware that if you are an immigrant a conviction may effect your immigration status?” Unfortunately, I can’t do anything to effect that change.

But that doesn’t mean that prosecutor Ken plans to take Padilla lying down, waiting for the defendant (and his immigration challenged lawyer) to spring the trap.

I can change the language in my plea agreements. Henceforth, all my plea agreements will contain the following language:

 

Immigration Consequences: The defendant understands that if he is an immigrant any conviction may effect his immigration status and that federal law allows deportation for drug convictions.

I suggest that any prosecutor out there develop similar language and insert it into their pleas until such time as the judges have changed their colloquies.

While I think Ken’s on to something, I’m not convinced that his language is going to cut the mustard.  But if copies pages 7-8 of Gideon’s practice advisory, staples it to plea form, squints a bit and prays that nothing even remotely relating to the defendant’s charge or prior criminal history happened in another jurisdiction, he might be able to squeeze it through.

You can thank me later too.

Faith in Subpoenas

Amongst the many powers of the prosecutor is the power to compel disclosure of information needed in the investigation and prosecution of crimes.  Or maybe not quite crimes.  Or maybe, just something the prosecutor would like to know.  Or maybe something that a cop friend who belongs to a church who has an anonymous blogger would like to know so they can teach that anonymous blogger a darn good lesson. 

Fortunately, Middle District of Florida Judge Marcia Morales Howard wasn’t inclined to put her faith in church member/cop Robert HInson or prosecutor/subpoena issuer Stephen Siegel.  Normally, this is where I would insert a quote from the decision in Rich v. City of Jacksonville, but it’s one of those insufferable decisions that goes on ad naseum on every minute tangent under the sun without providing a clear point, sentence or paragraph, that would serve to inform.  Anybody wanna bet that the judge’s clerk was on law review?  So instead, here’s Eugene Volokh’s synopsis :

The most important part of the decision rests on the Free Speech Clause, but the court also concludes that if issuing the subpoena was motivated simply by a desire to “prosecut[e] an errand of the Church,” then that would also constitute a violation of the Establishment Clause. In such a situation, the court says, “the state actor [would have] lacked a ‘secular purpose’ for his actions,” and the action would have had “a primary effect of advancing religion” as well as “enmesh[ing] churches in the exercise of substantial governmental powers.” “Such ‘active involvement of the sovereign’ in the internal affairs of a church, namely a dispute between a congregant and his pastor on matters of church doctrine and administration, would violate the very essence of the First Amendment.”

Great news?  Well, not exactly.  The decision arises in the context of a §1983 action.  The blogger is long since outed, anonymity be damned, because Comcast and Google complied with the subpoenas.  Whether Assistant State Attorney Siegel was playing errand boy for the church wasn’t their business; they get a prosecution subpoena, they comply.

The issue here is whether the blogger’s complaint for damages and injunctive relief should be dismissed.  Ultimately, Judge Howard says no, at least at this stage, because Siegel’s prosecutorial qualified immunity fails for lack of any legitimate state interest in his issuance of the subpoena.  But the judge isn’t particularly encouraging about the plaintiff’s chances for recovery.

That Judge Howard held that the prosecutor cannot use the subpoena power for personal purposes seems almost too obvious for words.  That there is no remedy before the harm is done, however, reduces any after-the-fact jousting to an exercise in futility.  Here’s a tough question: How does a person prove harm/damage by having the veil of anonymity lifted?  Sure, we have a right to anonymous free speech, but what’s the dollar figure on the loss of that right?

Remember, where there’s no remedy, there’s no right.  There’s no reason to respect a right when there’s no downside to violating it.  A firmly worded “don’t do that ever again” usually evokes a foot shuffle and a head turned downward.  Not in contrition, but to conceal the sneer from the judge.  Want to slap my other hand, judge?

It’s axiomatic that the law can’t cure every wrong that man can devise.  It just seems to do a particularly ineffective job of preventing prosecutors and police from using their enormous powers in violation of constitutional rights, and all the nicely conceived decisions that labor to explain the vast complexities of immunity somehow neglect to note that, at the end of the day, no one was saved and no constitutional right was protected.

The argument against withholding immunity from prosecutors, primarily grounded in the fear that they will lack to fortitude to do their jobs if they are functioning under an ever-present concern of liability, seems hardly a match for cases like this where the abuse of authority is flagrant and far afield of any conceivable legitimate purpose.  Granted, the federal chastisement of the conduct isn’t going to win ASA Siegel any prosecutor of the year awards, but it similarly doesn’t do much to restore the plaintiff to his rightful place of anonymity.

You don’t have to like anonymity online to recognize that the government can’t abuse its authority to strip someone of it.  And as this case shows, there’s little to be done to stop it.  The best we can hope for is a tiny chance, afterward, of getting to court to say mean things about the prosecutor, even if there’s no real remedy to be had down the pike.

Three Hours Is All It Takes

In the never ending saga of bar associations trying desperately to put on a program that will attract the scarce free cash of lawyers in a poor economic climate, combined with the trend of idle hands believing that there’s money to be made by defending the devil, the New York City Bar Association is offering a three hour CLE for a mere $205 on a subject near and dear:

YOU DON’T PRACTICE CRIMINAL LAW &

YOU GET THAT MIDNIGHT PHONE CALL…

NEW YORK CRIMINAL PRACTICE 101

Who is this program for?

If you haven’t thought about criminal law since you were required to take it in law school,what can you expect to encounter when a client calls you in the middle of the night about a criminal matter? What questions do you ask? How do you counsel your client? What should you do—or not do? This program is a must for any attorney unfamiliar with the practice of criminal law.Find out everything you need to do to preserve the rights of your client (whether dealing with a minor problem or a serious matter) from the first minute your telephone rings.

Not ready to hand over your credit card yet?  Consider the expertise of the program chair:

Frank R.Dudis 
Deputy Bureau Chief
Kings County District Attorney’s Office
Investigations Bureau/Public Assistance Crimes Unit

Who better to teach how to defend an accused than a prosecutor? Talk about an insider, and as we all know, it’s all about being an insider, with the little wink and nod as the backroom deal is cut.

The program covers everything from the initial phone call through disposition.  Trial isn’t mentioned in the program, but collateral consequences are.  And there’s even a Q&A period before your three hours are up.  Imagine, a mere three hours of your life and you can then confidently represent individuals accused of crimes, who may spend many years, perhaps even their life, in prison should things not go well.  Is this a great program or what?

There is a perception amongst civil lawyers that criminal law is sexy, and compared with what they do, it is.  There’s a perception that criminals are worthless, so they have few qualms about trying to take every penny they can grab.  Heck, it’s almost a duty to redistribute money from the bad guys to the good, and they are most assuredly the good guys.  Remember, in the world of civil litigation, it’s only about money.  No one’s life is on the line, and the only question is how big a pie will provide their third.  With that in mind, and business slow, the notion of passing up the midnight phone call (perhaps with the knowledge that two-thirds of the pie remains in their escrow account) or handing it off so someone else can make a fee is just, well, ridiculous.

It’s one thing to disabuse civil litigators who think they can pretend to be criminal defense lawyers by feigning a swagger and a sneer, but it’s another altogether to have bar associations place their imprimatur on the idea.  Who came up with the idea that a three hour tour course makes someone competent to defend a human being accused of a crime?  Brilliant and idiotic at the same time.

As a public service, I will teach that course in seven seconds.  What to do if you don’t practice criminal law and you get that midnight phone call?

Immediately refer the case to a competent criminal defense lawyer, then go back to sleep.

That ought to be worth 1 CLE credit in ethics.

H/T Andrew Lavoott Bluestone at New York Attorney Malpractice Blog.

Prosecutor As Social Engineer

Via Radley Balko, a Wisconsin prosecutor has decided that he will wield his power to indict and prosecute teachers for teaching students about contraceptives.  His theory is that since children aren’t allowed to have sex under Wisconsin law, providing sex ed about contraceptives encourages students to break the law.

The problem is that teachers are required by law to teach students about contraceptives if they teach sex education at all.

The law doesn’t force any schools to teach the sex education classes, but it sets out strict guidelines on what should be taught in the schools that choose to do so. The law passed narrowly in the legislature and was the topic of a fierce battle between Republicans and Democrats: No Republicans voted for it, and it was signed by a Democratic governor.

The legislature passes a law, the governor signs it. The district attorney prosecutes for complying with it. 

Because the law requires teachers to instruct children not only about contraceptives but about how to use them, Juneau County District Attorney Scott Southworth said, schools are forced to encourage students to “engage in sexual behavior, whether as a victim or an offender.”

In his letter, Southworth said the law would convert sex education classes “into a radical program that sexualizes our children as early as kindergarten. This, in turn, will lead to more child sexual assaults.”

Putting aside, for the moment, the question of whether one agrees with the law or the teaching of contraceptive measure in sex education classes, an issue that may well be controversial for some, DA Southworth has, by his threats of prosecution, undermined the fundamental structure of government.  Forget those silly roles played by the legislative and executive branches; local district attorneys now posses the super-veto to quash compliance with a law with which they disagree.

This reflects a change in mindset in the scheme of criminal law.  Clearly, subjecting teachers to prosecution is, in itself, a substantial harm.  Where the law mandates it, then the prosecutor’s imposition of that harm is justified.  Where the law does not mandate it, then the prosecutor has gone rogue.  Where the law mandates the opposite, the prosecutor goes beyond rogue into the realm of threat to society. 

The power to prosecute is awesome.  It’s a power that can be easily abused, with devastating results.  But when it’s flagrantly abused, deliberately and purposefully to undermine the process of government, what little integrity the system maintains is lost.

While Southworth’s threats may be viewed as mere grand-standing shenanigans by some, it strikes me as ample demonstration that he’s incapable of handling the authority that comes with his position.  He is a threat to both law and order.  That he feels empowered to threaten prosecution based upon his political sensibilities, about what he thinks should not be taught to children, reflects a clear inability to be trusted with the authority to prosecute.

Rep. Kelda Helen Roys, a Democrat, told the Wisconsin State Journal that she believes there’s no problem with the law.

She said Southworth, a Republican, is a “zealot” who wrote the letter to try to scare people out of teaching the sexual education classes.

 

Whether accurate or not, this is a woefully inadequate response.  The question isn’t whether there’s “no problem with the law,” but whether the State of Wisconsin will be held captive by the Juneau County District Attorney.  Is it acceptable to this representative, to all the reps, to the Governor, that laws duly enacted meet with Southworth’s approval?  And what of the other prosecutors?  Must the laws meet with their approval as well?  Must the legislature and governor go begging for permission to pass laws in the State of Wisconsin.

That a prosecutor would be allowed to remain in power, while threatening prosecution of those who not only commit no crime, but comply with the law, reduces the state government to a farce.  This abuse of power cannot be tolerated, and this attempt to usurp the power of the state must be quickly and decisively brought to an end, lest we end up with prosecutors running the world and using their power to engineer society to their liking.

And The Online Lawyer Scam Continues

Bruce Carton twitted yesterday about this latest barrage from scam lawyer website BestAttorneysOnline..  You may recall that Bob Ambrogi called it out, as did I.  But it’s still out there, and still puliing stunts designed to mislead and deceive.  Hey, anything for a buck.  Isn’t that why the internet exists?

This time, the scam lawyer website announces the .  How did they arrive at this venerable list?

A research team reviews thousands of applicants, and performs an evaluation of each firm based on established criteria. A series of questions are posed, such as “Do they represent each client fairly providing the best possible defense and representation?” or “How extensive is the firm’s knowledge of case law when it comes to an individual’s rights?”.

Seriously, that’s what this scam site says.  I wouldn’t make this up.  I couldn’t.  And thus, the list:

The nation’s 10 best criminal attorneys for April 2010 are:

1. Kochhar & Co.
2. Marks, Golia & Finch, L.L.P.
3. Malaby & Bradley, LLC
4. Jackson Lewis LLP
5. Vogel Law firm
6. Garbarini & Scher
7. Ziegler, Metzger & Miller LLP
8. Schrader Byrd & Companion, PLLC
9. Sirkin Pinales & Schwartz LLP
10. Barrett Daffin Frappier Turner & Engel, LLP

Anybody want to take a wild guess what’s wrong with this list?

The deluge of crap that permeates the internet is never-ending and utterly shameless.  It’s out of control.  For any lawyer who tries to do right, there are a hundred, a thousand, maybe more, doing anything they can to lie and deceive. 

For those who appreciate lawyer marketing as a means of leveling the playing field, offering the small firm and solo lawyer the opportunity to get their name out to the public, this is the flip side of the argument, that the public is being scammed unmercifully by those inclined to do anything for a buck.  It’s tiring and tedious to deal with this day after day.  And it never seems to stop.

For those who argue that all this information helps consumers, what do you say about these scam websites?  What do you say about the lawyer websites that deceive?  Where does it stop?  And what are you doing to stop it?

Or are you too busy promoting yourself to bother?

The Marshall Chronicles: His 15 Minutes Are Up

The imbroglio started when a fellow named Jack Marshall, an unknown and inconsequential quantity in the blawgosphere, leveled an accusation against Eric Turkewitz, a well-known, highly-regarded New York personal injury lawyer and blawger.  It was a direct charge that Turk violated Rule 8.4. 

This wasn’t about discussing whether conduct was violative, but that a specific lawyer violated a specific rule with specific conduct that could result in sanctions ranging from suspension to disbarment.  It’s the lawyer equivalent of yelling rape.  And Jack Marshall was the yeller.  And the sole basis for accusation was that Marshall pronounced it to be so, because Marshall, per Marshall, was an ethics expert.

He was told he was wrong.  Over and over and a variety of ways by a variety of people over a period of days.  During that period, he had the time to write two additional posts, The April Fool Lawyer and His Defenders: Ethical Dodges on Display, and then, amazingly, decided that Jack Marshall was important enough to write the rules for everyone else, April Fool’s Day Ethics.  He called a lot of people names.  I was one for having stood up to his accusation against Turk, but the bloodletting went on for quite a while.

I watched in morbid fascination as the comments came in, trying nicely, angrily, sweetly, attackingly, to tell Marshall he was wrong.  He attacked in response.  He was right.  He was absolutely certain he was right.  He was the expert and everyone else was a fool, an idiot, all manner of stupid, because he was right. More than 100 comments at his blog (note spelling).

Then suddenly, he wasn’t.  Jack Marshall announced I was wrong, you were right.

He apologized to Turk, which Turk gracefully accepted.  Others praised his willingness to admit he was wrong and apologize.  The “hoary” (to borrow a word) chestnut that it takes a big man to apologize was floated.  Kumbaya was heard in the distant background.  The train stopped wrecking itself, over and over, and we could all return to our normal blogospheric viewing.  Who cared that some idiot named Marshall flung a false accusation, raised a ruckus against a respected lawyer, smeared many of the most respected members of the blawgosphere, then skunked off with his tail between his legs, admittedly wrong?

Despite watching for the past two days, mostly laughing at the antics of one of the most pompous, narcissistic ignoramuses I’ve yet to see online, I’m not satisfied with this conclusion.  Marshall proceeds to “explain” the error of his ways.

I’m not going to spin this. My conviction that the web hoax engineered by trial lawyer/blogger Eric Turkewitz violated the legal ethics rules was the product of a toxic mix of factors, prime among then being that I didn’t review my own files.

Yet spin is all it is.  Even this opening sentence, claiming that his fault was not reviewing his own files, is a outrageous lie.  Does he have files that inform him not to accuse others falsely of wrongdoing first, then think later?  What file does he need to tell him not to falsely accuse someone?  What a load of crap.

I had been wallowing in obscure clues from other jurisdictions–Tennessee, for example, which has the ABA wording but an odd Comment that begins…

[4] Paragraph (c) prohibits lawyers from engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation. Such conduct reflects adversely on the lawyer’s fitness to practice law…

This could be taken to mean that all such conduct reflects adversely on fitness. The problem is, I don’t believe that, and I don’t believe that Tennessee means that.

Spare me.  The old “obscure Tennessee caveat” defense?  At no time did Marshall “reveal” his argument that he was relying on the Tennessee interpretation.  In fact, at no time did Marshall say he was relying on any obscure state rule.  In fact, he disavowed, numerous times, that there was a need to rely on any interpretation, caselaw or otherwise, smacking those who tried to tell him otherwise that they were wrong.  They were idiots who didn’t get it like he did, because he was the expert and they were morons.  It wasn’t that Marshall just got it wrong, but that he viciously attacked back at every chance.

Run through the list of adjectives used by Marshall in this post and his response to comments.  Anybody see a reference to an obscure Tennessee interpretation?  But now there’s no spin? 

I picked Eric’s hoax, moreover, for another bad reason: I was rubbed the wrong way by his post criticizing the New York Times for falling for it. But that’s not ethics, that’s style. I let it warp my judgment.

Notice that it’s still a hoax rather than an April Fools Day joke or prank?  Notice that he’s still justifying his reaction, despite the backdoor concession?  It may not have been an ethical violation, Marshall now says, though Turk was still wrong for criticizing the Times, which is what compelled me to do it.  He’s wrong, but not blameworthy.

So, with incomplete disregard for my accumulated research and my prior positions, I wrote that Eric’s fiction was an ethics Rules violation. Then I compounded the blunder by focusing on the counter-arguments initially chosen by Eric, Carolyn Elephant, and Scott Greenfield, which were more emotional and abusive than analytical, rather than considering whether they had something to be emotional and abusive about. It was a good platform to write about how lawyers and others resort to rationalizations, and I took the bait…

And the “counter-arguments” (which by definition elevate Marshall’s original attack from false accusation to argument) were “emotional and abusive.”  Marshall still doesn’t grasp that his false accusation was utterly baseless, the narcissists dream of alleging a wrong because Marshall, the center of his own universe, says so.  This malicious, self-aggrandizing narcissist still doesn’t get that the responses were geared to his baseless, ignorant, false accusation.  The false accuser whines that those who called him out were “abusive”?  Do you think that the “abusive” attacks against you might have something to do with the fact that you began this mess by falsely and baselessly accusing Turk of unethical conduct?  Does that detail not enter into your warped psyche?

Without question, it’s better that this worthless, pontificating, ignoramus finally conceded that he was wrong, even if he does so in a vain attempt to salvage what remains of his reputation only after the universal condemnation of the blawgosphere.  We tend to be a fairly forgiving bunch, and the amount of energy put into dealing with this otherwise inconsequential self-promoter far exceeded his worth.  But I don’t buy his apology.  Not in the slightest. 

I believe the apology is wholly disingenuous, replete with spin at every turn.  I believe that Marshall is trying to resurrect himself, only because he now realizes that he committed marketing suicide with the universal condemnation.  His apology is nothing more than a carefully crafted rationalization of his misconduct.  His apology continues his attack, merely from another angle.  Even wrong, he’s still right.

Since Marshall never offered an apology to me, I have nothing to accept or reject.  If he had done so, I wouldn’t have bothered with it.  He’s unworthy of my concern either way.  But Turk is.  Carolyn is.  The myriad blawgers who tried to straighten this jerk out are, and this post is for them, and me. 

You do not falsely accuse someone of wrongdoing first, then figure out whether you’ve got any basis later.

You do not justify your accusations by claiming to be a false prophet of ethics, while attacking others as ignorant fools.

You do not spend days viciously attacking those who are telling you that you’re wrong, when you’re wrong, then claim that you were only wrong because you didn’t have the time to “review your files.”  There is no justification, none, for your attacking first then thinking later. I can’t imagine a more pathetic, disingenuous, claim.

You do not get to apologize after having done all of this and then expect to get a trophy for being a big enough man to admit your error.  The best you get is minor mitigation for your many wrongs.  And they were many.  But even the minor mitigation is undermined by your attempt at self-aggrandizement and rationalization in the apology. You net out zero.

Jack Marshall, the owner of ProEthics, a company that sells CLE courses, has destroyed his credibility.  Jack Marshall, blogger at Ethics Alarm, has engaged in rampant unethical conduct, based upon his own claims of what constitutes ethical conduct.  Jack Marshall cannot pretend it was just a big, silly mistake and expect to be welcomed back into the fold as an ethics expert.   Anyone who listen to Marshall is a bigger fool than he is. 

This fight has come to a conclusion.  Eric Turketwitz has done nothing, repeat, nothing unethical.  The baseless accusation against him was false.  And false accuser Jack Marshall’s 15 minutes are over, and he should never be heard from again.

If others forgive him, that’s their choice.  Some may think that he deserves a second chance.  That too is their choice. I believe he’s a danger to ethics.  He can have a second chance being a dog catcher, not an ethicist (if he ever was one except in his own mind).  I have deliberately used a wealth of ad hominem attacks on Marshall because I believe he should be attacked for what he’s done and how he’s done it. I am deliberately harsh.  That’s what Marshall deserves.  It’s unfathomable to me that anyone would pay heed to this worthless twerp on any subject, no less ethics.

Stumped By The First Question

When I received the email announcing a study of plea bargaining by a doctoral candidate at John Jay College of Criminal Justice, a part of the City University of New York, and seeking participants, there was no hesitation.  Not only did I want to participate, but I wanted very much to see more about the study.  I emailed immediately.

Within minutes, I received the information and was ready to jump in.  It began with some basic case/investigation information and then launched into questions.  I won’t provide any background on the information, as some readers will also participate in the study and, to the extent it’s to have any validity, disclosure here would spoil it.  I won’t do that.

The first question to be answered in the study was:

1. If you were the defense attorney in this case, would you recommend that the defendant accept a plea bargain if one is offered by the prosecutor?

                  NO                YES

Oh my God.  It was only question number one and already I was stumped.  There was no possibility of answering a question like this question.  Stymied, I called the number provided for any questions about the study.  No answer, so I left a message. 

Could this be a trick?  Maybe a test for tolerance for ambiguity?  Maybe the legal version of Stanley Milgram?  Was there some secret hidden meaning in this being the first question, a test perhaps of whether defense lawyers were so incompetent, thoughtless, uncaring, that they would respond without any of the hundreds, no thousand, maybe more, bits of information on the variable factors that go into such a complex decision as to whether to recommend that a defendant accept a plea bargain.

I quickly decided that anyone who answered this question should be disbarred.  Possibly tarred and feathered after being disbarred. First maybe.  Whatever, it was an absurd question.  After waiting a few minutes, and having other things to do, I decided that it was a trick and answered “no”, my reasoning being that I could absolutely not recommend a plea bargain without having all the reason to aligned to do otherwise.  “No” was my default. 

A few minutes later, I received a call back.  After niceties, I explained that I called because I was stumped by the first question.  She was concerned.  This wasn’t a trick question.  It was just a question, one that she thought would be rather straightforward.

I explained to the doctoral candidate that it was an impossible question and gave her about a dozen variables that would have to be answered, at absolute minimum, to formulate an opinion.  She had not thought about the variables; she was very much interested in studying plea bargaining, an area she informed me that was terribly understudied, but wasn’t familiar with legal processes.  Instead, her study sought to isolate particular factors in plea bargaining, such as a weakness in a specific aspect of evidence, and its impact on the willingness to take a plea. 

It was a fine idea, but without isolating the element she sought to study, rendered her study kinda, well, goofy and pointless.  It wasn’t easy to do, I recognized, and it was extremely unlikely that her study was going to accomplish much.

John Jay isn’t a law school, but one dedicated to the study of criminal justice.  I’ve never been entirely clear what that means, but I expect it turns out a lot more cops and corrections types then, say, criminal defense non-lawyer occupational-types.  There are likely many who are involved with criminal justice on both sides of the fence, as well as neutrals, but not many who could offer the perspective of a criminal defense lawyer to a doctoral candidate. 

That nobody suggested that the decision to accept a plea bargain required, at minimum, a fact (like what the deal might be) is pretty surprising.  That somebody is trying to get a doctorate without knowing this is, well, surprising.  That the committee that approved this study didn’t find this troubling is, well, surprising.  Interdisciplinary is one the buzzwords throughout academia these days, and while the study was being done under the auspices of the forensic psychology department, there had to be a lawyer or two they could have asked to take a look at it.  I know they have some lawyers working the adjunct side of the street, and Jeremy Travis, the President of John Jay, used to be an aide at the Legal Aid lawyer before he went all official.  They could have asked somebody.

The blawgosphere often discusses the results of studies that bear upon what we do.  This scares me.  While I was never so naive before as to believe that any study should be taken as gospel, I could easily push aside the nasty details of construction to get to the bottom line, anticipating that smart people had gone over the structure of the study to make sure that it had some validity from inception. 

But this study passed through the normal rigors, and still it began with a question that couldn’t be answered.  At least not by me.

Saving For Appeal

Over at Crime & Federalism, Mike urges defendants to put it all on the table at trial because of the futility of criminal appeals.  He supports his position by pointing to  the odds of winning, together with the egregious decision in People v. Milosavljevic, 
affirming a conviction despite the appellate court finding the victim’s story

may seem highly unusual, if not improbable, to many people, we cannot conclude her testimony was inherently improbable or unbelievable.

While I agree wholeheartedly with Mike’s primary position, that the best chance of prevailing is at trial, and that’s where every defendant needs to focus all his energy, not to mention financial resources, his reasoning troubles me.  As to the Milosavilievic decision, it’s one example of a bad, no make that horrible, rationale that exposes an unfortunate tendency amongst appellate courts to render result-oriented decisions. 

This is often what comes of cases with bad facts and worse evidence, where the proof may suck but the panel feels that the bad guy got what he deserved, and so the court stretches to sustain the verdict.  When the decisions are fact based, it’s of no precedential value and does nothing more than skim over the law to reach the desired result.  But it’s one case, and that’s not enough to prove much of anything.

More significant are the odds of winning an appeal: 

Ruggero Aldisert, author of Winning on Appeal and one of the finest federal appellate judge, offers these sobering statistics :

United States Court of Appeals—National Average of Reversals
[for 2002]

 

 

 

ALL APPEALS……………………. 9.5%
Criminal…………………………………5.6
U.S. Prisoner Petitions…………..9.5
Other U.S. Civil Cases…………..11.0
Private Prisoner Petitions……….9.9
Other Private Civil Cases……….12.2

From this, we conclude that the reversal rates from 1998 to 2002 for all appeals averaged 9.54 percent. Expressed otherwise, here are your odds of reversing the district court:

  • All appeals: 1 in 10
  • Criminal cases: 1 in 18
  • Private civil actions: 1 in 9

These numbers reflect federal appeals, which are a harder win than state appeals in most jurisdictions.  They also reflect all criminal appeals, meaning those that have little or no chance of winning, but are filed pro forma because people have the right to appeal even when they lack any grounds.  Some are Anders briefs (which state that there are no non-frivolous issues on appeal) and others are just mailed in, sounds without fury.   Still, this isn’t to say that the chances of winning on appeal are decent, or even reasonable.

There are a host of reasons why otherwise good cases fail on appeal.  Some, like Milosavilievic, may reflect a results-oriented failure.  Others fail for lack of preservation by trial counsel, where a great appellate issue might exist but for the trial lawyer’s having dropped the ball and failed to object, or having made a strategic choice to go for the acquittal at the risk of losing an appellate issue.  It may also reflect a artful trial judge who sanitizes the record to cover any potentially reversible issue.  There are lots of tricks available that will frustrate an appeal.

Another problem stems from the defendant’s inability to understand the concept of an appeal.  Defendants often think that an appeal is a new trial, a do-over if you will, where they get to present new evidence, argue the opposite of what was argued at the first trial, or at least some variation on a theme.  When they learn that an appeal is based solely on the trial record, that there will be no new testimony or evidence, and particularly that they won’t be brought into court, shackles or not, to sit beside their lawyer, anger and frustration ensues.  It doesn’t matter that they’ve been told all of this already, as clearly and emphatically as possible.  Somewhere in their head is a bone that blocks out the noise emanating from a lawyer’s mouth and hears only those sounds that comports with their deepest desires.

Despite all these reasons why appeals should fail, they don’t.  At least not always, and not when there is the combination of good appellate issues, advocacy and effort.  There’s a fighting chance.  It’s neither a joke nor a waste of time.  Reversals of convictions happen, and the only better feeling than reading that the indictment is dismissed is to hear the jury foreman utter the words “not guilty.”

The point is that the first, and best, opportunity to win is at trial, and no effort or expense should be spared if you’re putting your life on the line before a jury.  Try a case to win, and nothing else.  Of course a lawyer should preserve appellate issues, as it’s just a part of good lawyering, but unless you’ve reached the point in trial where you are certain that the verdict is going to be guilty, decisions must be made to win at trial rather than to create the best appellate record ever.

But if the trial goes south, and the verdict is guilty, that doesn’t mean all hope is lost.  Your appeal may not be a winner for many reasons, and most won’t be for lack of legal basis, no matter how badly the defendant wants to win.  But there are winners, and they are often the product of excellent appellate lawyering.  Don’t save for them, but should appeal be the only avenue remaining, don’t despair either.  There is a good fight to be had, and it is worth the effort.

Reality Marketing: If Lawyers Did It, Then

It’s a new trend.  It’s funny, at least the first few times you see it, but does revealing the reality behind the fantasy make you want to buy?

Or this one?

And what would a criminal defense lawyer have to say that would make someone want to retain her?

Would it be true?  Would it distinguish her from everyone else? 

Then what would she have to say to make the client want to retain her rather than any of a hundred others while still being honest and truthful?

If you recall the TV commercials by Trolman, Glaser & Lichtman, which were quite cutting edge, where do we go from here?

Some Days, There’s Just No Show

I’ve been called prolific, with good reason.  I don’t care for it, but that doesn’t make it inaccurate.  But today, nothing moved me enough to formulate an opinion or compel me to write.  It happens.

Whenever I don’t post something, readers send emails asking why, what happened.  Nothing happened. I just had nothing that I felt like writing about, so rather than write for the sake of keeping the reader occupied, I took a pass.  I was up late last night watching the end of the Butler/Duke game (and I’m not a basketball fan at all).  I slept late this morning. 

I’m still spending a lot of time every day cleaning up the spam comments, which have continued unabated while becoming increasingly more worthless and spammy.  You would think that the spammers would figure out that their comments don’t make it to the screen and would take their game somewhere else.  But these aren’t the brightest folks online, and come back night after night by the hundreds to post about how they agree with me and (coincidentally) have the cure for toenail fungus or best man speeches.  The crap they sell is unbelievable.  There’s a hypster for every problem.

I started to write a post about Gideon’s latest at A Public Defender, Guilty of being poor, but a few minutes into it realized that I had nothing particularly worthwhile to add.  Like Shakespeare, I don’t always know what I think until I see what I write.  Sometimes, I learn that I don’t think much of anything, which is usually a good reason to stop writing.

And for anyone who happens to notice, this post is all about me.  Norm would chastise me for navel gazing.  Mike would make sure I realized that I was a pathologic narcissist.  I don’t mind.  It’s just an explanation for the void, with far too many “I’s” for comfort.  That’s what happens when you navel gaze.

This may all change later today, should something strike me as worthy of writing.  Or maybe tomorrow. Or maybe not.  Either way, have a nice day.