Brian Tannebaum discusses one of the most curious questions confronting a lawyer at My Law License. Raised by Lee Rosen at Divorce Discourse, he asks why crappy lawyers have happy clients.
I know one personally. She’s a terrible lawyer. She can’t read and understand a court opinion. She misreads statutes. She’s an embarrassment in court. Her pleadings are poorly drafted. Her correspondence is filled with errors. She says things in chambers that make her look like an idiot. Her objections are overruled. Her court appearances are dominated by illogical arguments.
She’s a really crappy lawyer.
Her clients, however, love her. They refer business to her like crazy. She spends nearly nothing on marketing and is making a freaking fortune. She can’t see a new client for weeks because she is solidly booked.
How many lawyers can say that they are booked solid for weeks? How many lawyers can say that clients love them? How many lawyers suck? Tannebaum breaks it out:
We all know that clients hire lawyers for the strangest reasons. Something, one thing the lawyer says or does can determine the client’s happiness with the lawyer. In the criminal practice we all experience the difference in the client who barely shakes your hand when you win his case, and the client who hugs you after you lose his case and before he’s shipped off to jail.
From a client’s perspective, the definition of a “crappy” lawyer is completely different from that “within” the profession.
“Likability,” says Scott, “bears no connection to the lawyer’s skillset.” I disagree. Likability bears a great connection to the lawyer’s skillset — criminal defense trial lawyering is about communication, and better communication skills make a person more likable. If all else is equal, an accused is going to do better in a jury trial with a lawyer that the jury likes than with one that the jury doesn’t like.
While likability doesn’t invariably mean that a lawyer isn’t competent, or great for that matter, wrapping it up in a ribbon by calling it all part of communications is way too facile for my taste. Chatting up a client in an initial evaluation doesn’t translate to being great in front of a jury. Nor is being great in front of a jury enough of a skill to define a competent lawyer, no less a great one. More importantly, what makes clients love their lawyers goes well beyond the initial evaluation, and into providing the client with what the client perceives to be important, even if it’s actually horribly counterproductive to the legal interests.
Lee explains the virtues of his crappy lawyer:
Here’s the deal. She does things that make it clear that she cares about her clients. She rants and raves in court, like a maniac, on behalf of her clients. She crosses over every line and gets personally involved with her clients. She laughs with her clients, she cries with her clients. She returns calls, she calls at night, she stays on the phone forever. She loves her clients and it shows. She knows it and her clients know it. She’d do anything to help them. They are her friends.
Her clients love her. They love her when she wins, they love her when she loses. They know she’s committed to their cause. They know she did her best, even when her best isn’t good enough.
It all makes me wonder whether she’s really a crappy lawyer or whether I have ideas about what’s important that might be irrelevant. Who sets the standard for crappy? Lawyers or clients? Maybe my idea of crappy doesn’t really matter?
There is, however, an alternative way to view this. While there will always be lawyers whose business is built solely on their likability, despite their either being incompetent or engaging in conduct that pleases the client but destroys their professional credibility, there are also practices built on outcome and effort. Granted, it requires a better, more knowledgeable clientèle to appreciate skill over empathy and long telephone calls, but they are out there and have more mature expectations of counsel.
Moreover, rather than do your utmost to appeal to the lowest common denominator, lawyers can make the effort to educate the public as to what they should be looking for in a lawyer, as Tannebaum has done in his free eBook, The Truth About Hiring A Criminal Defense Lawyer. No one is arguing that lawyers should be dislikable, but the willingness to sit on the phone for hours on end listening to the client vent isn’t exactly what most of us would call our best feature. Nor are we paid to become our clients’ best friend, especially when it masks the fact that the lawyer is crappy.
It’s up to each of us to decide what type of lawyer we want to be. The question seems to come down to whether it’s more important to get the clients’ money by meeting the clients’ likability needs or to provide the client with great legal service. The irony is the client may well love us more if we’re better friends and worse lawyers.
Update: While non-lawyers may appreciate the way the way Lee’s “crappy lawyer” makes her clients feel, Mike at Crime & Federalism has tapped into the other side of the equation:
Most clients want to feel the love. They want validation. They expect you to answer their calls to discuss the same issues over and over again. They expect you to file every motion their reading of USA Today has told them is relevant.Feeling the love yet? Is this really what you want to pay for?
Most lawyers resent this. “Didn’t we discuss this already?” “That motion won’t work.” “No, I’m not going to tell the judge he’s biased. I have a reputation to uphold.” “How dare these clients tell me how to do my job?!”
Yet tapping into a client’s need for constant validation is profitable. Why do you think family lawyers make so much money?

