Author Archives: SHG

How Much Is That Doggy On The Bench?

In the best of times, judicial elections are a goofy exercise of Jacksonian populism.  The concept of the popular vote fills the hearts of New Yorkers with pride, believing that they played some role in democracy.  The truth, of course, is that pulling a lever, or detaching a chad as the case may be, is only a small part of democracy.  The other, more difficult part is exercising the franchise intelligently. 

When it comes to electing judges, and aside from the handful of friends and relatives of any particular candidate, the tendency is to vote party line since few voters have the slightest clue who these candidates are or why they should want to vote for them.  A large part of the problem is the restriction on speech that deprives a judicial candidate of informing the electorate of what they would do with great power were theirs wield.  Of course, the limits are imposed to avoid candidates for the bench committing to positions prior to cases or arguments coming before them.  Judges really aren’t supposed to climb onto the bench with their minds already made up.

One of the most offensive aspects of judicial campaigns has been the need to go hat in hand for campaign donations, putting the arm on friends and lawyers likely to appear before them for some cash to appease the party leader.  Running for judge is a pay to play opportunity, and no party leader will endorse a candidate who can’t pay for his own telephone pole signs, unlawful though they may be.  Sitting judges running for re-election despise the need to ask for contributions.  New candidates rarely have anybody to ask, and even fewer willing to cough up some hard support.  It’s a nasty, demeaning business.

And along comes Citizen United.  Regardless of how one feels about the rights of corporations to “speak their minds” via their pocketbooks, it’s a particular game changer when it comes to judicial elections.  From Dorothy Samuels Editorial Notebook in the New York Times :


Thoughtful candidates known to look at the law on a case-by-case basis will be at a distinct disadvantage, forecasts Professor James Sample, a judicial elections expert at Hofstra Law School. The accelerated money war, he warns, will inevitably polarize the bench “because more moderate candidates are unlikely to be considered a bankable vote by any special interest group investing heavily in judicial campaigns.”


Judicial candidates have long use such amorphous language as “fair and just” in their campaign advertising, even though they regularly note their endorsements by a variety of police union groups (as if that’s not intended to send a message).  The path to election just became far smoother.  Consider the candidate who seeks the “endorsement” of the Strip Mall Builders Association of New York perhaps, and they’ll never have to bug their Uncle Joe for a dime again.

For the candidates who already own a robe, the easy path to avoiding the hat-in-hand route is to show your “value” to potential campaign contributors through your judicial philosophy, as evidenced by decisions.  It’s just too easy, and too obvious, to build a special interest following that can now channel more than adequate funding into your campaign warchest. 

This doesn’t mean that judges will openly sell themselves for campaign contributions.  For the most part, they will decide cases as they would regardless, reflecting their beliefs and deciding cases appropriately.  But there will be changes in the stridency, the details, the emphasis of their decisions so that their constituencies are clear who their friend is.  And for those whose friends happen to be broke, say people like criminal defendants, or have no trade association with a political slush fund to offer up to candidates for office, there will be few ways to help judicial candidates whose sensibilities are not antagonistic to their cause.

The point is that “moderate” candidates for judgeships, which means those who truly desire to be fair and open-minded, who don’t come to the bench to further a pre-conceived agenda, will find themselves odd-judge-out in the corporate funding race.  They can’t be trusted.  They aren’t bankable.  They aren’t a sure-bet.  Everyone wants reliable judges, including corporations.  We just have different definitions of reliable.

Tony Mauro, however, notes that others don’t buy into the notion that Citizens United will change much in judicial elections, despite former Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O’Connor’s contention that the case makes merit selection the only way to go.



But some commentators doubt that Citizens United will produce dramatic, opinion-shifting examples of corporate excess. Jan Baran, partner at Wiley Rein in Washington, said at the Georgetown conference that 26 states already have no limits on corporate spending in state campaigns — and their elections are not that different from those that restrict corporate participation. “There have been no stampedes [of special interest money] in those states’ elections,” Baran wrote in an op-ed column for The New York Times.

Supporters of the high court’s decision also caution that using nominating commissions to advise the governor on whom to appoint does not always remove politics from the process. Bradley Smith, a former Federal Election Commission chairman who is now a professor at Capital University Law School in Ohio, said nominating commissions should not be “dominated by elite interest groups on either side of the legal community, such as the trial bar or business groups.”
There’s much merit in the argument against merit selection, though there’s little promise to judicial elections aside from silly populist notions.  In other words, neither process is without its own ability to go horribly wrong.

Whether Citizens United will mean a sudden influx of corporate cash in judicial elections in high population areas, or courts that tend to deal with cases that have a significant impact on business, has yet to be seen.  Whether judges, or judge wannabes, will be inclined to sell themselves for a decent contribution has yet to be seen. 

But regardless of whether corporations have a first amendment right to express their political views, and given a term of office of 14 years for New York’s Supreme Court justices, the impact on the judiciary could be devastating should there be some muscle flexing.  Maybe the best answer is to change the canons to allow judges to sell advertising space on their robes.  At least we will be able to easily identify a judge and his sponsor.

Book Review: Targets of Deception

Given that the books sent me for review generally range from the topics of false confessions to executions of the innocent, I was thrilled to receive a fiction book, a spy novel no less.  Jeffrey Stephens’ Targets of Deception, published by Variance did not disappoint. 

Why Jeffrey Stephens?  He’s one of us.  Jeffrey is a lawyer, a solo practitioner who, like to many of us, opened up shop in Manhattan without a client in his pocket back in the late 1970s, doing civil and criminal litigation.  Like so many of us, he made his bones case by case, standing in the well and doing what he had to do to make a name for himself and represent his clients.

But unlike us, Jeffrey did what most of us only dream about.  He took that need to write, that book inside him, and made it a reality.  And it turned out to be one heck of a good read.  I thoroughly enjoyed it, though it went so quickly that I wished there was more.

Targets of Deception
is about a former CIA agent, Jordon Sandor, in post-9/11 America, having “left” the Company after his team on a covert operation was hung out to dry.  Jeffrey avoids the obvious tendency to turn this into an exercise in jingoism, and instead employs a series of plot twists which ultimately shows both the muddling of patriotism and the absurdity of a simplistic view of the good guys and bad.

As you wind your way through the streets of New York, the quays of Miami and end up in the Italian fishing village of Portofino, you appreciate Jeffrey’s firm grasp of the technical mechanics behind his story line without getting bogged down by the literary equivalent of ordinance mechanics.  You feel that he’s done his research, knows his details and has provided everything necessary to believe that Sandor has the fire power to pull it off. 

Jeffrey’s writing style juxtaposes the complex with the simple, the Latin with the Saxon, moving the reader swiftly through the story with just enough to keep it interesting at every turn without becoming heavy or prolix.  One of the fascinating aspects is that he avoids the use of profanity, though I didn’t even realize it until it was pointed out to me afterward.  The dialogue never came across as stilted or unnatural, despite the absence of curse words, a testament to good writing that conveys the message without need to use cheap language for shock value,

The story isn’t totally flawless, the hero having a love who’s violently assault early on, horribly traumatized and left in the hospital, while Sandor moves on in his work, eventually hooking up (though tastefully amd, thankfully, without too flagrant a description) with another women.  Since Sandor is not only a Company man, but a gentleman in the old school sense, this caddish behavior was somewhat troubling.  This may be an example of why lawyers aren’t often asked for advice by the lovelorn.

Targets of Deception was a great read and the first in the coming series of books by Jeffrey Stephens about Jordon Sandor, right in the mix with the best of the genre.  And I’ve got to add that this isn’t just a matter of Jeffrey writing a terrific novel, but that Jeffrey Stephens success is one that every lawyer who loves to write and wishes he could sit down and let that book out of him should take pride in.  One of our own did it, and did it well.  There’s hope for us yet.

We all need a change of pace from the stories about the misery of the law and the injustice of the system.  Get Targets of Deception and both enjoy a great read and support a lawyer who has done what we only dream about. 

Cogito Ergo Blawg

Over at Mark Bennett’s Social Media Tyro blog, issue has been kinda joined when Jenni Buchanan, ghostblogger, responded to his challenge as to the ethics of a lawyer having someone create blog posts under their name.


Thank you for including my company in your blog post yesterday about the ethics of legal ghostblogging.  As a (relatively) new form of communication, blogging is still in many ways going through its growing pains, and as more and more professionals and businesses begin to see the value of blogging I know that there will be many more debates about various aspects of it, including continuing ethical debates.  Like you, I think these debates are important, and I look forward to seeing (and perhaps being a part of) how the field evolves.

Buchanan then asks Bennett to delink from her testimonials page, so as not to embarrass the lawyers who are busily scamming their potential client pool by concealing that they aren’t doing the writing attributed to them, and to take this “important” debate offline and pursue it in private emails.  Bennett, of course, does just the opposite.  He’s just not a very compliant sort of guy when it comes to concealing dubious conduct and protecting the guilty.

In the comments to the post, Amy Derby, author of unwritten international best-seller, Chronic Bullshit Syndrome, offers some interesting observations.


While I agree with the integrity/ethical debate behind not outsourcing certain things, I am not convinced it always matters with blogging. Here’s why: Not all lawyers understand blogging well enough to know that it doesn’t need to be done.

I think the problem is that these types of folks shouldn’t be blogging in the first place, but they’ve been convinced by the hypesters that blogging will get them business. Similar to the way people who think flinging up SEO articles will get them business, and the way people think spamming blog comments will increase their page rank…. ugh! There are many many idiots doing a lot of things I don’t understand.

I’ve little doubt that Amy is right, that lawyers who have yet to spend 5 minutes of quality time in the blawgosphere are pumped up by the hype that blawging is the road to vast wealth and success, and succumb.  They may know squat about blawging, but when it comes to marketing, it’s only a check away. 

But ignorance isn’t a defense to unethical conduct.  To claim ownership of something that’s not yours is to lie.  It may be understandable that lawyers have fallen prey to the hype, particularly since legitimate bar associations are tripping over themselves to put on Marketing CLEs about it, staffed by presenters whose business model is selling crappy marketing blogs to dumb-as-dirt lawyers.  It’s pathetically sad that lawyers fall for this rather than do a little investigation to learn what the blawgosphere is all about, and more importantly, to learn that good blawging isn’t likely to change their fortunes, and bad blawging can destroy a reputation.

In another comment to Bennett’s post, Antonin Pribetic, better known as The Trial Warrior, makes a painful observation of his own:


I support professionalism and ethics, both of which are becoming vestigial tails wagging the legal marketing dog.  Having said that, I remember in my early days as an articling student ghostwriting for partners who sometimes didn’t give credit, or, if credit was given, it was never co-authorship but merely a footnote. Perhaps times have changed, but it is difficult to reconcile promoting a lawyer’s or law firm’s website to prospective clients, while using a third party ghostwriter to post blog content. It’s like getting a rectal exam at the doctor’s office and then finding out that the doctor was away that day.
A well-turned phrase and a vivid image, but then Antonin is Canadian and thinks curling is a sport.  That lawyer marketing has become the overarching purpose seems to trump all considerations of integrity when it comes to social media.  That lawyers have adopted the methods of used car salesmen to try to get warm bodies in the door, and can justify it as necessary to hop aboard the speeding marketing locomotive of blawging so they aren’t left in the dust, is simply goofy.  It’s hype, pure and simple.  Stop allowing yourself to be played for the fool, and don’t sell out your ethics in the process.

Granted, some guys like me have been harping on this nasty ethics and integrity thing for a long time, but the voices of those whose livelihoods depend on your buying into the lie that blogging is the magic bullet to success are loud, strident and unrelenting.  There is little reason for guys like Bennett, and me, to speak out as a counterbalance to the hypesters.  We aren’t invited to speak at the bar association CLEs or industry conferences to undo the damage the promoters and cheerleaders inflict.  We aren’t inclined to dig deep into our pockets to fly across the country to unsell you on the marketing juggernaut.  And we’re not making ourselves any more popular with those who desperately need your business, at the expense of your hiding your ethical thoughts in the sand, by being disagreeable.

But if nobody challenges the hypesters, the unethical, the marketing scammers, then the ignorant, the self-promoters, the ghostbloggers, the marketers, will overwhelm the blawgosphere and ruin it for all of us. 

But Kids Are So Much Easier To Push Around

The American Civil Liberties Union has filed suit against the New York City Police Department over the use of excessive force and wrongful arrests in city schools.  As in many cities, New York has used uniformed police to fill the position of school safety officers in an effort to protect students.  And as in many cities, the cops themselves have presented a significant threat to the safety and welfare of the students.


The landmark lawsuit challenges the conduct and behavior of police officers and school safety officers (SSOs) serving in the NYPD’s School Safety Division. It was filed on behalf of five middle school and high school students who were physically abused and wrongfully arrested at school by NYPD personnel.

Plaintiff Daija, 13, is an eighth-grade student at Lou Gehrig Middle School in the Bronx. On Oct. 7, 2009, Daija was unlawfully arrested by SSOs following a confrontation in front of her school initiated by two adult strangers who had threatened her. An SSO instructed Daija to go into the school with the strangers. Frightened, Daija told the SSO that she preferred to wait outside for her mother who was coming to pick her up.

In response, the SSO grabbed Daija by the arm, handcuffed her, forcefully threw her down and pinned her to the ground. Daija sat handcuffed at a desk until her mother managed to find her. No charges were filed against her. Daija required medical attention as a result of the assault.

The ACLU press release provides the typical examples of children being arrested for such heinous crimes as writing on a desk or talking on a cellphone.  The SSOs aren’t subject to school supervision, and can exercise the full panoply of law enforcement powers without any school oversight.  And they do.


“When one of our clients was 11 years old, she was handcuffed and perp-walked into a police precinct for doing nothing more than doodling on a desk in erasable ink. Amazingly, no one in the police department or the school seemed to think there was anything wrong with that,” said Joshua Colangelo-Bryan, senior attorney at Dorsey & Whitney and co-counsel on the case. “It’s a sad day when you need to resort to a lawsuit to keep an 11-year-old from being arrested for drawing on her desk, but in this case it is clear there is no alternative.”
A few considerations that seem to elude city police departments that use their cops to maintain order within schools.  These are children, not perps.  The point isn’t to feed the school to prison pipeline, but to protect them so that they can be educated.  Still, kids are kids, and they tend to do kid things.  Dealing with children requires a modicum of thoughtfulness and patience, and a good deal of restraint.  Not things that cops, in general, deem important qualities.

And then there is the fact that school safety officer isn’t exactly a plum cop assignment.  There are very few opportunities to get a gold shield in the hallway of PS 126.  This is a dumping ground.  While there are no doubt cops who want to help students, there are far more who the police want to get out of their precincts because they are just lousy cops, or pissed off a superior, or create problems wherever they go.  Where better to bury them than in public schools?

It’s not that school administrators have demonstrated any great finesse at dealing with students and minor disciplinary issues, but at least they are generally disinclined to cuff them and throw them to the ground.  Does it fill the SSOs with pride that they beat up some kid for talking in the hallway?  Apparently so.

H/T Kathleen, our hinterlands correspondent (doing some slumming)

The Slackoisie Take The Lectern

That the seats in our law schools are filled with the Slackoisie is nothing new.  But do they own the lectern as well?  From Jeffrey Harrison’s description at MoneyLaw, so it would seem.


I analogized it to regulatory capture in the sense that faculty who were supposed to govern law schools for the benefit of shareholders — students, taxpayers, donors — actually governed to benefit themselves. The range of questionable activities ran from teaching specialized low enrollment courses because the topic was of interest to the teacher (but not to very many students) to foreign boondoggles, pushing ideology in the classroom, and hiring and tenure decisions based on social and political considerations rather than the merits of the candidates.

Harrison called lawprofs as “shirkers”, putting their responsibilities to others second, and making sure that they were taking care of number one.  He attributes it to an unbearable sense of entitlement.


After all, law faculties are largely populated by children of privilege. (I wonder what the record is for the most expensive education. I think we have it.) Many times their sense of entitlement is over the top. They deserve, therefore, to teach what they want to teach at the time they want to teach it, they deserve that new furniture or to vote yes on tenure for a pal because they have been told, since birth, that they are special. Some have a virtually infinite capacity to explain why they are deserving and why they are on the moral high road whether or not they are.

Does any of this sound familiar?  While Harrison’s focus is limited to his colleagues in academia, and hence his attribution of their ways to their “elite” educations, there’s little to distinguish these entitled lawprofs from the young Slackoisie lawyers that sat next to them in class and are now taking up office space in law firms around the country. 

Well, maybe two differences.  First, they may be a bit smarter than most, and thus more capable of manufacturing arguments to explain why their entitlement is more worthy than others.  Second, they exist in an environment where they can get away with putting self-interest ahead of all else.  The “shareholders” in law school aren’t in a position to be quite as demanding as clients.  Or quite as unforgiving.

Harrison struggles to clean up some loose ends about his belief that entitlement stems from attendance at our “elite” institutions of learning, noting that not every lawprof is a shirker, and that some who attended the less-elite schools seem even more entitled than those who went to the Big Time law schools. 


More importantly, not all those with an elite education seem to feel entitled. Far from it. Plus, some of those who do not have an elite education seem to feel an extreme sense of entitlement. Maybe all that can be said is those with the elite educations are more likely to have a sense of entitlement and more likely to justify their anti stakeholder activities than those without the same background.

With a few steps backward, I suspect Harrison will recognize that it’s not an elite law school issue at all, but the pervasive narcissism of the Slackoisie that has invaded his ivory tower.  The elites are simply better able to rationalize their narcissism, while the back-benchers have learned a lesson or two from getting kicked in the teeth on their way to work. 

None of this need be tolerated.  Lawprofs have a job to do, just like everyone else.  But it requires someone to cut them down to size, burst their bubble and give them a good smack in the face.  Teach the darn students, and forget about twirling around in your ermine stole.  Lawprofs exist to teach law students.  Law students don’t exist to fund lawprofs’ flights of fancy.

Worse still, if the lawprofs are so self-absorbed that they can’t see their own sense of entitlement undermining the very purpose of their existence, how will they be able to grow law students beyond their own Slackoisie narcissism?  Who will teach them that being a lawyer is about serving clients rather than feeling good about yourself or making happy hour at the tavern?  As we criticize the young lawyers coming out for their lack of dedication to clients, their inability to comprehend the notion of hard or disagreeable work, their entitlement, we can’t forget about the group of men and women, the last vanguard, who stand between the students and the lawyers.  They are supposed to teach them how to be lawyers, provided they aren’t too busy indulging their own self-important fantasies to notice the room full of students in front of them.

Not every law student will get a trophy.  Yet, every lawprof thinks they deserve one, and their fellow lawprofs are only too happy to oblige.  After all, they’re entitled.  They’re the Slackoisie.

Just Stuff Around the Blawgosphere

Bob Ambrogi has announced that he’s completed his sentence at Legal Blog Watch.  Bob’s been sharing the writing duties there since before I started, making him the blawger who ignored Simple Justice’s existence longer than any other.  Following so soon on the heels of Carolyn Elefant’s “retirement”, I can only speculate that the burden of keeping up with the energy and humor of Bruce Carton, Carolyn’s replacement, was more than Bob could bear.  Or it could be keeping up with the hundreds of new blawgs coming on the scene daily.

But over the four years I’ve been doing this, the blogosphere that we set out to cover has exploded like a supernova. When I started, the number of blogs to track was manageable. Now, it could easily be a full-time effort to keep up. My RSS reader shows some 500 feeds I try to follow.

Beyond the sheer number of blogs is the ever-higher bar they set. So many legal blogs produce so much high quality content that it is difficult to know where to begin and where to end in reading them. As the overall content of blogs has improved, so has the competitiveness among bloggers to be first out of the gate on a story — us included. With all this, legal blogging could be a full-time occupation — and in fact it now is for some.

Seriously, while I haven’t always seen eye to eye with Bob, I can well appreciate the burden of trying to keep track of the blawgosphere.  There’s a huge difference between writing for fun, which means I can write or not at will, and writing for money, which means Bob had to write upon command.  The product may be similar, but the pressure is entirely different.

While Bob will continue to write at his own blogs, Lawsites and Media Law, where Bob really let’s his hair down and sheds the formality that characterized his “official” posts, his years of doing yeoman duty as the Legal Blog Watcher are very much appreciated.  After all, without Bob’s help, I might have missed the blawgs that used my posts to come up with their own, which would catch Bob’s eye.

Orin Kerr at Volokh Conspiracy does a rare introspective post about dealing with commenters.  After deleting a politically conservative comment, Orin received the anticipated screaming email, but with a twist.  This one challenged him for trying to be “too fair” with liberals by being too harsh on conservatives.


First, I think this is the first time a commenter has criticized my comment moderating on the ground that I am trying to be fair. Normally, those who find their uncivil comment deleted claim that I harbor a bias against the commenter and I am afraid to recognize the deep truth of their message. So this is a bit new, and I appreciate that. 

Second, moderating comments can make you feel many things, but one thing it cannot make you feel is deeply loved. The kinds of people who write uncivil comments are the kinds of people who get furious when their comments are deleted. They often write in with very angry responses filled with an unusual number of four-letter words, usually indicating their belief that you have some deep-seated insecurity that is making you not realize how right they are. If you need to feel loved, you don’t generally volunteer to spend your time interacting with that sort of person. 

This is a new twist on the rather bizarre experience and “relationship” a blawger has with commenters.  While regular readers/commenters form a sort of community at a blawg, day-trippers have this inexplicable disinhibition where they believe that it’s them against the blawger, each having equal “rights” in the exchange.  The commenters believe not only that their thoughts, often expressed in a way intended to directly insult the blawger, are as worthy, if not more so, as the blawger’s.

While I can’t say for sure how many readers Orin typically has for a given post, I know it’s far more than I do, and that he will get many more comments at VC than I do here.  Yet the single day-tripper truly believes that it’s all about him.  Worse still, the day-tripper somehow superimposes his (invariably brilliant) supposition of the blawger’s motives over the situation, thus challenging the blawger’s purposes, ranging from abject stupidity to utter gutlessness, in silencing his critics.

For crying out loud, you don’t know squat, and you haven’t a clue where your brilliant and biting comment fits into the scheme of things.  If you think your opinion is the most important one in the world, then start your own blawg and write down every thought that enters your head.  If you’re as smart as you think, you’ll be the most influential blawger in the world.  But when it comes to someone else’s blawg, don’t be a jerk.  Your approval really isn’t the most important thing in a blawger’s world.

Mark Bennett, at his Social Media Tyro blog, explains for the hard-of-thinking why ghostblogging might be a less than honest way to promote yourself.  Would you take credit for another lawyer’s court victories?  What about putting up a photo of a good looking lawyer instead of your own?


Since you’re still reading this, odds are that you didn’t graduate from a Tier-One law school. You know that it doesn’t make any difference to the results you get (or lease, through GhostWins.com), but some paying clients might be more likely to hire you if your resume were a little more impressive. GhostResume.com can fix that problem. On the same model as GhostWins.com and GhostMug.com, GhostResume.com allows you to contract out your credentials. For a nominal fee, you get to use the guaranteed-to-impress bona fides of an actual lawyer in your marketing materials. Your clients will never know the difference.

There is no end to the opportunities to lie about oneself in the scheme of self-promotion.  And hey, if it’s all about making money, and you couldn’t care less what you have to do to score the next case, then why not?  Because it would be wrong to claim another lawyer’s victories, or use his photo, or resume.



So how is it okay for a lawyer to hire a ghostwriter to write his blog?

Legal Ghost Blogger, the subject of Bennett’s invective, is an enterprising concept.


LegalGhostBlogger.com will provide you with a steady stream of content for your estate planning blog. Created by an experienced writer and estate planning paralegal, your content can be a mix of syndicated or original posts, with new material appearing on your blog at the intervals you choose. It’s easy and affordable, but above all, it’s highly professional…

The fingers behind the post;


Jenni Buchanan is a writer who has worked in the legal arena since 2002, including the past several years as a paralegal with a prominent estate planning law firm in Southern California. As a writer, Jenni has been published in both the professional and literary fields, and coached others in improving their own writing skills. As a paralegal she has met with clients, drafted trusts and estate plans, and organized seminars. Jenni graduated with a B.A. in English in 1997.
I can’t blame Buchanan for trying to make a go of it.  She wants to write, and prefers to be paid for it.  Who doesn’t?  But if you’re inclined to have Jenni write your blog for you, at least use her photo as well.  After all, you wouldn’t want to be a total fraud, would you?

Who Needs A PSR When There’s Facebook

Social media has its ups.  And its downs.  And its downs can do a lot of damage.  Via Doug Berman, a tragic story from the  Buffalo News shows yet another great opportunity for young defendants to keep their head low when using social media.


Ashley M. Sullivan is in Niagara County Jail, and Facebook may be to blame as much as the car crash that killed a Niagara Falls man.

Sullivan, 17, of Linden Avenue, North Tonawanda, was sentenced Wednesday afternoon to six months in the County Jail and five years’ probation for crashing her car while drunk and killing her boyfriend May 30 on Sweeney Street in North Tonawanda.  She pleaded guilty Nov. 18 to criminally negligent homicide and misdemeanor driving while intoxicated.

Certainly a 17 year old drunk driver, whose conduct resulted in the death of her boyfriend, is tragic for all involved.  One might suspect that it would have a lasting impact on Ashley Sullivan, one that would guide her conduct for, oh, at least as long as it took for her to be sentenced.  Perhaps it did.


The Buffalo News has learned that Sullivan went to Florida a month after the crash and posted a photo on her Facebook Web page captioned, “Drunk in Florida.”

Can you count the number of things that are wrong in the one sentence?  The judge could.


“I’m troubled by your conduct since the crash,” County Judge Matthew J. Murphy III told Sullivan, “and that’s the reason for the jail sentence.”  Murphy also refused to grant Sullivan youthful offender status for the same reason.  “I don’t believe the defendant has earned it,” the judge said.

Murphy, in reading the terms of probation, went out of his way to emphasize to Sullivan that she isn’t allowed to drink for the next five years.  “You’re 17 years old. You’re not old enough to drink,” Murphy said.

Even though Sullivan was only 17, one might expect the death of her boyfriend as a result of her drunk driving to have a sobering affect.  Granted, teens lack maturity, but this demonstrates an utter lack of comprehension of the significance of her conduct.  And where were her parents?  Was this really the best time for your kid to go on vacation to Florida?  On her own, at 17 and obviously inclined to enjoy forbidden beverages? 


“My client failed to consider the consequences, the tragic consequences,” [defense lawyer Glenn] Murray said.  “This offender understands the tragedy she is responsible for.  She will never forgive herself.”  He said Sullivan had decided not to speak, although when Murphy asked her, Sullivan managed to say, “I’m very sorry,” before breaking down in tears.

Talk about words ringing hollow.  Maybe Murray could have said something to his client, even if her family thought a week at a drunken bacchanalia in Florida was the perfect thing to soothe their 17 year old darling?  Something like don’t get drunk, but if you do, don’t let the whole world know about it?

And all other things aside, that Ashley Sullivan was sufficiently pleased with herself to broadcast her conduct on Facebook is as strong a reminder as can be that teens can be total idiots, in addition to being teens.  It’s bad enough that Sullivan demonstrated no appreciation of the harm she had done, or the wrongfulness of her conduct, but that she chose to make this her image to the world is one of the saddest reflections of our time.

Facebook is fun.  Facebook is a place for kids to show off to their friends and be really cool.  Facebook is a great way to make sure that your judge knows that you couldn’t care less that you just killed your boyfriend and still think that getting drunk in the midst of the prosecution, especially when you’re only 17, is the image you want to project to the world.  Who needs a presentence report when the court need only check your Facebook page?

Miranda Meets The Underpants Bomber

The meme of 9/11 changed everything remains in full force in the hallways of the Washington Post, where an editorial ripped the handling of Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab, whom they call the Christmas Day Bomber due to an excess of propriety and lack of a sense of humor. 

The background is that after 50 minutes of questioning, the bomber who had sewn explosives into his underpants was given Miranda warning and, accordingly, clammed up.  No, the bastion of first amendment testosterone wasn’t bothered by the 50 minutes before Miranda.  Quite the contrary.


UMAR FAROUK Abdulmutallab was nabbed in Detroit on board Northwest Flight 253 after trying unsuccessfully to ignite explosives sewn into his underwear. The Obama administration had three options: It could charge him in federal court. It could detain him as an enemy belligerent. Or it could hold him for prolonged questioning and later indict him, ensuring that nothing Mr. Abdulmutallab said during questioning was used against him in court.

It is now clear that the administration did not give serious thought to anything but Door No. 1. This was myopic, irresponsible and potentially dangerous.

Harsh words indeed, but not nearly harsh enough to sate former federal prosecutor Bill Otis at Crime and Consequences, who then rips the WP for not realizing that this isn’t a one-time screw-up, but a systemic failure.


What the Post still fails to understand is that the administration’s “myopic, irresponsible and potentially dangerous” blunder in this case was less a result of one bureaucratic miscommunication than of the inherent confusion at the base of its thinking about terrorism and the law.  As long as there is indecision about whether violent jihadists should be treated as standard criminals or as the illegal combatants they are, blunders like this are inevitable.

Sadly, Utah lawprof and former federal judge, Paul Cassell, is on board with Otis in this post at the Volokh Conspiracy.



The analysis seems spot on to me.  I can’t for the life of me figure out why as a society we would want to give Miranda warnings to such a high-value suspect like Abdulmutallab.  While there is debate about the extent to which Miranda warnings reduce the overall confession rate (I think it is significant, while others disagree), surely we can all agree that in the context of Abdulmutallab’s interrogation such warning were not going to be helpful in obtaining information about, for example, where he trained and what other attacks might be planned.
Whether Miranda warnings change the game or not (and given how many suspects vomit inculpatory statements despite the warnings, the efficacy of the warnings is very much in question), there’s little doubt that it would be far easier for law enforcement to obtain information without them.  Of course, it would be far easier for law enforcement to obtain evidence if they could just break into homes at will.  In fact, they might be really, really effective if there were no limits on law enforcement at all. Does anyone doubt this?

But here we have a man attempting to blow up a plane filled with Americans, in American airspace, over American soil, seized by American law enforcement.  And the views of a newspaper, a former federal prosecutor and a former federal judge is that the FBI blew it, and blew it huge, by adhering somewhat to American law.  Mind you, nobody’s even mentioning the first 50 minutes of pre-Miranda custodial interrogation.

While it’s a fair question whether any reasonable person would expect a guy prepared to blow up his underpants to know which cave Osama bin Laden calls home, it’s shocking that these views so completely and utterly reject the basic rule of law, a fundamental law enforcement practice, the giving of Miranda warnings, at will. 

The justification, of course, is that the underparts bomber might have had information.  It’s possible, though not likely, that he had much of value to offer.  But since when does that provide the measure of ignoring American law? 

There is, however, a side argument to be considered.  Miranda is a rule of admissibility.  They could have questioned Abdulmutallab till the cows came home without warnings of any sort, provided that the statements gained were not used against him at trial.  While still a constitutional violation, the practical remedy would have been meaningless.  Of course, this would entail a deliberate determination on the part of the FBI to violate our Constitution in the process.  Does this matter if there’s no effective downside?

It’s disconcerting that voices who have, in their former lives, sworn fealty to the Constitution, and a newspaper whose ability to express its views depends on it, are so quick to scream that law enforcement blew it when they comport themselves (somewhat) with the rules.  If they’re so quick to toss out the Constitution when it comes to interrogation, can it be much of a surprise that a little torture doesn’t bother them?

It might be different if there was some hard information that the underpants bomber knew of a dirty bomb about to be detonated in Times Square, where the lives of thousands depended on immediate information.  Maybe dire need, though conceptually problematic, might render this widespread disdain for what makes us us understandable.  But there was nothing like that involved here; he was a “terrorist” and that was all it took for these fine Americans to declare their desire to shred the Constitution.  It’s that simple.

Jimmy Dolan’s Magic Touch

If you run a fabulously successful business, one that essentially prints money at will, that must mean you’re a genius, right?  But what if you run it only because daddy owned it?  Not so genius-y?  What if it prints money, but could print a whole lot more money if he hadn’t botched a myriad of decisions, angering its customers to the point where they were willing to pay the phone company competition, an entity hated almost as much, more for the same product?

The Dolan family will never go hungry because Chuck Dolan was a visionary.  And Cablevision will continue to pump television through little wires to lots of homes, even as it is reviled monthly for its antipathy, always-increasing charges at will and mediocre service.  We can’t live without cable, with or without Food Network. 

But when it comes to the death of Newsday, the house organ of Cablevision, the throw-away paper offered as a value-added benefit to Cablevision subscribers, it was done right.  They put up a pay wall, and showed us that publisher Jimmy Dolan, Chuck’s son, was a business titan.  From the Consumerist :


Newsday is a Long Island newspaper. Some people bought it for $650 million and put it behind a pay wall. Three months later, they’ve got 35 subscribers. Yes, 35.

The web site redesign and relaunch cost the Dolans $4 million, according to Mr. Jimenez. With those 35 people, they’ve grossed about $9,000.
Thirty five subscribers.  Who would have thought that Dolan would have been that successful?  By the way, the new website sucks.  I mean, really, really sucks. 

But there isn’t much of a story in what these lucky 35 mean for Newsday.  As described by a reporter, it’s now “freebie newsletter that comes with your HBO.”  And really, that’s all the Dolan’s wanted for their $650 million.  It’s good to be able to print money.

The real question is whether the Sulzberger family is paying attention.  Of course, the New York Times is a much more important newspaper than Newsday.  It could get 100 paid subscribers. Maybe more.  I’m sure that Punch’s touch is more magical than Jimmy’s.

H/T Turk

Think Angry Thoughts, But Don’t File Them

Dan Hull at What About Clients? thinks a lot of angry thoughts.  I know because he tells me about some of them.  But he knows that when it comes to representing a client, there’s no place for personal vitriol.  It’s pure self-indulgence.  Unlike the Slackoisie, who are of the view that their thoughts, clear or angry, demand an airing, real men know better. 

Sure, there are times when anger can be effectively use to register the depth of a problem, or to shock a judge out of complacency, but that’s the strategic use of anger.  As with anything, anger can be part of an arsenal of weapons available to the lawyer, but of all the bullets in our gun, it’s the one that must be aimed with the greatest precision.  Few can do so effectively, and a miss can be devastating.

For this reason, Dan adopted the exceptionally sound advise to “always draft angry briefs, but never file them.”  Feel that anger swell up inside you when the other side is particularly idiotic?  We all do.  Let it out.  The catharsis will do you good.  Deep breath.  Now get down to the work that your client needs of you, persuading he decision-maker to reach the right decision.  That’s not about your anger, but about your client’s needs.

From whence does Dan glean this pithy advice?  None other than Max Kennerly at his blog,  Litigation and Trial.


But a brief is no place to question the intellect or motives of opposing counsel. Get mad, then get over it.

As James Fallows puts it:  Always write angry letters to your enemies. Never mail them.

Always draft angry briefs. Never file them.

Yup, that would be the same Max Kennerly whose vitriolic comments here have caused me to ban him.  Maybe this is where Max gets his catharsis so he’s not so angry elsewhere.  Interesting, no?