In his Sidebar column, Adam Liptak offers a survey of predictions by Supreme Court justices, both majority and dissent, about the dire consequences of the other side’s improvident decisions. His point is that the Supremes are notoriously bad at predicting future consequences.
On Wednesday, for instance, it shut down plans to broadcast the same-sex marriage trial in San Francisco partly for fear that witnesses in the case would be harassed if their public testimony were made more public. That conclusion is known in the trade as speculation.
Consider first of all that we are talking about a trial held in open court and subject to intense press coverage. The witnesses are mostly paid experts whose views on the subject are already well known. “They’re not, after all, in the witness protection program testifying against Mafia bosses,” Eva Rodriguez wrote in The Washington Post.
Then add to the analysis that the additional coverage the court forbade was only closed-circuit transmissions to a few other federal courthouses around the country. (There had been talk of posting video on YouTube, but the idea was never approved and so was not before the Supreme Court.)
The people viewing the transmissions in the remote courthouses would have been barred from making recordings of the proceedings. Allowing the transmissions, Eugene Volokh wrote on The Volokh Conspiracy legal blog, was equivalent to “holding the trial in an extra large courtroom.”
“And most of the extra audience would be far from California,” Mr. Volokh added, “and therefore not especially likely to be able to effectively harass the witnesses in ways that turn on seeing the witness’s testimony.”
While his prescience versus precedent argument bears out, Liptak offers no insight as to why the Supremes are so god-awful at predicting how courts and lawyers will apply their muddled analyses. Allow me to fill the gap. There are nine people at One First Street who live such an insulated existence from the very world over which they preside that they have no clue of the wrestling in the gutter that comes of their decisions.
In the past, I’ve argued that the justices have rendered themselves irrelevant to the legal system. Not only do we, practicing lawyers, have no clue what their decisions are supposed to mean, but they, being particularly smart people, know as they write them that they are giving no guidance through their muddled language, deliberate ignorance of obvious and unanswered questions and apparent lack of concern for the multitude of people who will suffer for their failure to earn their living by providing clear, complete, comprehensible answers to burning questions.
Although the words appear nowhere in the column, what Liptak is talking about is the slippery slope. It’s a very appealing argument, though a logical fallacy, as it simultaneously enrages some while denigrating the opposing point of view. Since predicting the future is a fool’s game, and can be neither proven nor disproven at the time the prediction is made, it’s immune from facial challenge. It could happen, so therefore it’s a valid concern.
But Liptak’s comparison, precedent or prescience, fails to capture the full spectrum of options available to the Supremes. Missing from this choice is the real world comprehension of how its decision are applied, or not applied as was the case with Booker for far too long,
Ironically, Eugene Volokh (as it happens) posted about some new proposals to provide an increased level of reality in judicial duty, as opposed to the current cult of celebrity that surrounds our Supreme Court justices. One of the suggestions really strikes home:
Congress should require Justices to serve part of their time on lower federal courts, as they did for the first century of the republic’s existence. Restoring “circuit riding” would give the Justices some on-going experience with playing the role of a modest judge whose decisions are subject to appellate review and who is often required to interpret and apply muddled Supreme Court opinions.Maybe if they got out more, our Supreme Court justices would have both a better feel for predicting the future, as well as a sense of how much trouble they cause with their incomprehensible decisions. And I might add, it would be best if they rode the circuit on horseback, just to keep it real.

What was this potentially dangerous thingy? No clue. Why was it potentially dangerous? No clue. The key to the grocery clerk’s fear was the total absence of knowledge. So naturally, in came the Metro Arson Strike Team