Author Archives: SHG

Gilbert Arenas’ Rush To Lose

When guns were pulled in the Washington Wizards locker room, it was hardly a big secret or a deniable event.  Gilbert Arenas must have figured out pretty quickly that he had a problem.  Fortunately for Arenas, he fit into that special category of potential defendants who had both the wherewithal and situation that lent itself to an issue yet to be resolved: Does Heller mean anything and Is there really a Second Amendment right in this country?

Before he stepped foot in a courtroom, Gilbert Arenas cut a deal.  He gave it up before he started to fight.  Addidas cut him loose immediately after his plea. Was that part of the plan?

Arenas isn’t the first celebrity to stand in those special, and quite large, shoes.  As Doug Berman wondered:


As regular readers know, I think that a Second Amendment with some real bite might provide some constitutional protection from the kind of criminal prosecution that Arenas is facing.  But like Plaxico Burress and Lil Wayne before him, it seems like Arenas just wants to cut a deal and try to move on rather than turn this matter into a Second Amendment test case.  I guess I just have to keep my fingers crossed that Delonte West will be the one rich and powerful celebrity willing to seek to assert his modern Second Amendment rights when charged with a gun possession crime.

There are, of course, legitimate reasons why a defendant, particularly a celebrity defendants, would hope to have criminal charges buried as quickly as possible.  There are also legitimate reasons why Gilbert Arenas might have decided to take a stand and challenge the charges against him.  Possession of a weapon in his place of business, the Wizards’ locker room, is but a tiny baby step from possession in the home.  As test cases go, this was a dream.

Jon Katz at Underdog raises the question that has to be raised in this case.


One is left to wonder what made Arenas choose his legal team. Instead of selecting among the many highly qualified local criminal defense veteran lawyers, he chose a recently-minted criminal defense lawyer who for years only knew prosecution and other government lawyer roles. His lawyer is Kenneth Wainstein — assisted by associate attorney Jeff Nestler — who has held such posts as United States Attorney for the District of Columbia, Assistant United States Attorney, and George Bush, II’s homeland security adviser. Granted, prior prosecution experience does not preclude one from becoming a great criminal defense lawyer. However, for such an alleged street crime defense as this, why did Arenas — who presumably has the funds to pay a lawyer, and likely is paying plenty to Wainstein, who is a partner at a big corporate law firm — not choose a lawyer with plenty of experience defending street crimes, including guns?

Wainstein is with the law firm of O’Melveny & Myers, Biglaw.  They have sterling prosecutorial credentials.  As defense lawyers, they are decidedly less illustrious.  They likely needed a sherpa to lead them to the criminal courthouse.  This is a typical way-station for prosecutors between official government gigs, where they pretend to be “white collar criminal defense lawyers” by flashing their prosecutor card at the door.

It appears that Wainstein has about an hour’s experience doing criminal defense, perfect for a partner at Biglaw.  His prosecution credentials, on the other hand, are quantifiable, with impressive titles that make the ignorant feel comforted.  It doesn’t mean the Wainstein isn’t a good lawyer. Even a great lawyer.  It also doesn’t mean that he has any competence to defend a person whatsoever.  But it seems to so many as if it should mean something important.

Somebody likely suggested that Gilbert Arenas get the best representation he could, and to people who don’t grasp how criminal law works, that means the one with the most marble in the waiting room and the most “resources”, meaning baby lawyers available for coffee fetching, around.  Big is a substitute for smart, just like tough is a substitute for smart, when you have no clue what you’re doing.  And so the Wizards point guard went to a lawyer who had a wealth of prosecutorial titles to his name to defend him from a gun charge.

It would be unfair to suggest that Wainstein’s advice to Arenas was less than sage.  I wasn’t in the room and have no idea what he had to say, or what Arenas asked of him.  Perhaps Wainstein told Gilbert that he wants to fight to the death and has a great opportunity to beat the case, make law, and turn him into an icon.  Perhaps Gilbert was crying and begging Wainstein to just rid him of this mess as quickly as possible.  Perhaps Gilbert was looking for a way out of his Addidas endorsement deal.  Maybe he preferred Converse.  Or Keds.

On his first appearance in court, Gilbert Arenas entered a plea of guilty on an information to carrying a pistol without a license, a lesser offense than he would have been charged had he not walked in with a deal in place but still a felony.  Prosecutors agreed not to seek a sentence of more than six months incarceration.  He will be sentenced in February, and the judge is free to impose a sentence outside the agreement, ranging from probation to five years imprisonment.

Arenas will be sentenced by Judge Robert Morin.  Jon Katz knows him from when the judge was a criminal defense lawyer, and thinks very well of him.  He encouraged Jon to become a criminal defense lawyer.


Judge Morin seems a walking example of pure modesty, whereas a very large percentage of criminal defense lawyers have huge egos; the modesty is a better approach, as long as that does not lead to lackluster and quiet performance in court. As a criminal defense lawyer, Judge Morin reached a great victory in reversing the Kirk Bloodsworth rape-murder conviction in the early 1990’s (see here, too) in Baltimore County, Maryland, when DNA was expensive and cumbersome to test. Through DNA testing he obtained Kirk Bloodsworth’s liberty. He did not even seem to toot his own horn over his earth-shaking Bloodsworth victory.

Almost all the stars were aligned in this case.  The only two stars out of place were Arenas and Wainstein.  And Arenas gave up without a fight.  We will never know whether he could have beat the case by challenging the law under Heller.  We will never know whether it was Wainstein or Arenas who made the decision, and whether it was a good choice or a bad choice.  It’s likely that Judge Morin is too good a judge to use the Arenas sentence to make an example of him rather than treat him like a human being, but we’ll never know whether Wainstein told Arenas how fortunate he was that, given a bad situation, he had the opportunity to fight. 

We will never know because Gilbert Arenas walked into court on day one to lose.  I hope, for his sake, that he made the right choice.

The New Sex Offender Registry: The Prison Guard Roster

There must be a different version of “swift and decisive” action in the government rulebook then in the one from which I call the plays.  When the Department of Justice Bureau of Justice Statistics  concludes that “more than 9,000 young people in custody and found that 12 percent reported being sexually abused one or more times, mainly by staff members,” swift and decisive action seems the least we can do.

It’s not that the report is really shocking.  It’s not like we weren’t aware that the problem existed, though some may quibble about the scope of the problem.  But now that the report is out, it’s on our radar, we know that prison staff are regularly sexually abusing children, there is no choice but to stop it.  So what’s the government answer?  According to the New York Times:

The commission said that corrections facilities must make it easier for victims to report abuse without fear of reprisal and promptly and thoroughly investigate all rape claims. It said that prison employees must be better screened before they are hired, and they must be better trained in how to deal with vulnerable young people.

The commission also called on state corrections agencies to develop written zero-tolerance rules for employees of adult and juvenile facilities — and write those rules into union contracts. Employees must be put on notice that they will be held accountable if they participate in sexual assaults or look the other way when they occur.

Not exactly earth-shattering.  Is there a amount of tolerance that prison guards today think is acceptable for raping children?  Are the Unions in favor of child-raping members?  Is it hard to figure out that the people charged with overseeing juveniles in prison should be screened for their sexual indulgences?

What part of this required a study?  What part of this presents difficulty?  How many raped children are acceptable in our prisons?

But it gets worse, when it becomes clear that the Times’ editorial isn’t decrying the fact that this sexual abuse has been happening forever under the noses of our fine government, or that Congress gave the government six years to figure out what to do about this well-known problem.  Nope, that’s not the concern at all.



The 2003 law gave the United States attorney general until June of this year to evaluate the commission’s findings and issue new rape-prevention standards. But juvenile justice advocates worry that the Justice Department will allow state corrections officials to water down those requirements, partly by arguing that they will be too expensive to implement. The department should not allow that to happen. If it does, Congress will have to strengthen the legislation. Zero tolerance for abuse in prisons or juvenile facilities must be the law of the land.
Let’s not concern ourselves with the kids being raped from 2003 to June of 2010, whilst the government studies the problem.    These things take time, you know.  After all, prison guards raping children is a very difficult problem to address, right? 

This is nuts.  Kids are being rapes by prison staff and our government wants another study to come up with brilliant ideas like the need to train staff that raping children isn’t acceptable behavior?

Put in cameras everywhere.  Any staff member sexually abusing a child is prosecuted for the child rapist he/she is.  Any staff member that knows of it, allows it, turns his head the other way, is prosecuted for acting in concert.  Enhance the penalties for prison staff who sexually touch a child, and let them enjoy the cool breeze of the yard while informing the other inmates of their proclivities.  But allowing this to continue while it’s being studied is insane.  Suggestions that guards might not be aware that raping children is a bad thing is absurd.  Oh yes, and it would be nice to vet them in the hiring process to eliminate those who might be inclined to rape children.  That would seem wise, and it only took a six year study to come up with this brainstorm.

If there has to be a sex offender registry, let it be the roster of prison staff.  This must stop immediately.  This isn’t a money issue.  It’s hard enough to stop sexual abuse between juvenile inmates, but there can be no tolerance from the staff. And no excuses.

Debating The Obvious: Too Many Lawyers

When Mark Greenbaum’s Op-Ed in the L.A. Times appeared, arguing that law schools produce too many lawyers and, given the ABA’s conflicted interest and willingness to continue to allow new schools to open and produce far more lawyers than society either needs or can even absorb, I yawned.  It’s not that Greenbaum’s point wasn’t well taken. but that this is old news.

With 45,000 new lawyers emerging annually to fill 30,000 jobs, how much of an argument does it take to suggest that the numbers don’t work?  And that doesn’t even address whether those 30,000 jobs are really needed, or can be successfully absorbed into the market.  Bear in mind that we’re talking jobs, which means we’re ignoring the starving solo practitioners sitting by the phone waiting for it to ring.  Or brainstorming his next twit in the hope of scaring up a case.

The immediate reaction from those whose livelihoods depend on the constant influx of new children into the meat grinder was as anticipated: They don’t see a problem.  Paul Cassell at VC had this to say about too many law schools and too many law students:


Perhaps, as a law professor, I’m biased on this.  But I don’t see a general market failure requiring federal government action, although perhaps (as the author suggests) regulation of self-reported data on job placement should be considered.   The author also contends that the ABA has a conflict of interest in regulating law schools.  I agree — but not because (as the author maintains) the ABA is allowing too many law schools.  If there are too many law schools, prospective law students can surely figure that out.  The problem with ABA regulation is that it seems to get diverted from focusing on educational issues to extraneous, political issues. 

Odd for someone whose focus is on victim’s rights to blame the victim, but when it comes to self-interest, it’s hard for anyone to see clearly, even a former district court judge.  Ilya Somin at VC was less sympathetic:


Pity the poor lawyers whose wages are being “suppressed.”

Even if lawyers’ pay were to go down significantly, they would still be near the top of the income distribution, and would still be making more money than liberal arts graduates without science, engineering, or math skills could earn in most other fields. Obviously, the present recession has lowered wages and increased unemployment among lawyers. But the same can be said for virtually every other profession. The bottom line is that most lawyers are extremely well off, and don’t need any special government assistance to prop up their incomes.

At least Cassell admits his vision was clouded by self-interest up front, whereas Somin rejects the notion that flooding the monopolistic legal profession with warm bodies, after lightening his students to the tune of about $140,000, isn’t his problem.  Let them duke it out in the free market.

Meanwhile, Devan Desai over at Concurring Opinions argues that the education law schools are providing is wonderful, despite all the griping by lawyers that they’re not only turning out too many products, but lousy ones at that.


Law school doesn’t work. The model is broken. We need to train students to be ready to practice as full lawyers right out of law school. These are, of course, slightly hyperbolic reductions of some of the current claims and possible crises in legal education. Nonetheless, there has been discussion of whether the downturn means that law schools need to rethink what they are doing.

I have written before that I think law school offers a special skill better than other schools: critical thinking. None of which to say that legal education could not improve. But insofar as that drive to improve is a claim for more practical training, there is another reason to pause. Business schools and at least one business leader seem to say that what they want is someone with, wait for it, great critical thinking skills. What? Yes. Excellent critical thinking skills are requested. And it gets better. Business schools are under criticism for, wait for it, being too practical.
While Desai’s “the grass is always greener” argument is a defense of the status quo, his resort to extremist positions, false choices, reveals the desperation within the Academy. Since when does critical thinking skills preclude competency at the performance of some minimal level of practical lawyering?  Forget “full lawyers right out of law school,” and think any viability as lawyers at all.

The parallel profession of law professor is at stake here, and it’s lifeblood is students willing to risk their financial futures and three years of their lives to engage in a course of study that prepares them to do little more than take the bar examination, the reward for which is to enter a field that doesn’t have enough jobs for them and join a society that has no use for them.

Lest the starving lawyers say “right on,” bear in mind that you were the fodder in the law school machine a few minutes ago.  So now that you’ve got your ticket, shut the doors and stop the influx?  What makes you think that society needs you any more than it needs next year’s class?

All these spilled words ignore the obvious.  There are far too many lawyers, and the conflict is between an institution that exists to produce them and a society that can’t take any more.  But Dan Hull, whose love of small furry animals and desire to cuddle with saucy women allows a clearer vision than most, gets to the heart of the solution at What About Clients?



Or, “You Got Anyone On That Campus Who Can Chew Gum, Cite-Check, And Look You In The Eye At The Same Time?”. We note that practical skills are being mentioned more in writings about law school education. Bravo. Show us. We’re tired of wasting our money.* Last month we wrote about American law schools–and this time only a few people complained. More recently we noticed these: “ Problems in the law school ‘business plan’” at From Burke to Kirk and Beyond, which shares a few things in common, mostly good, with this blog, and “ The changing face of the early stages of law practice” at Libertas et Memoria, which comments on the recent ABA story about a possible new premium placed on practical skills that got us so excited we forgot to fire people last Friday.

Finally, an interesting excerpt from FBTK :

Law schools will be the last to abandon speculative debt as the means of financing themselves through their willing applicants, because a very large number of applicants are smarty-pants who couldn’t make it as scientists, engineers, bankers, financiers, etc. The applicant doesn’t realize how speculative his investment is until he is one to four years in.


*WAC? could care less about student debt. Your problem, Teacups. Don’t any of you have family money? Enrique, would you be good enough to decant the Port? Kindly leave the bottle as well.


Forget the ABA. Forget the lawprofs.  Forget the crippling debt that law students will carry with them as they pursue their careers in used car sales, enhanced by their critical thinking skills.  And forget the lawyers who sit waiting by the phone for someone to feed them a case so they won’t starve.  None will save the legal profession. 

Law school, and the legal profession, has become a crap shoot thanks to all of the above.  Few law students, just as few lawyers, belong in the profession.  It’s time to come to grips with the fact that we not only produce far too many lawyers, but far too many lawyers who either lack the ability to practice law, are too selfish or narcissistic to put in the effort demanded of an excellent (or even competent) lawyer or lack the mindset to be a professional whose responsibility is to serve their client. 

The future of the law is survival of the fittest.  Law schools will churn out as many lawyers as they can, no matter how unneeded, how ill-prepared or how ill-suited to the profession.  The ABA will continue to approve new schools as long as they can draw a picture on the back of a matchbook.  Lawprofs will continue to lecture on the theories behind Law and Television Sitcoms, while Biglaw collapses, solos sit by the phone and social media gurus craft websites to make dumber than dirt lawyers look like Learned Hand.

Our own inability, more precisely refusal, to recognize the obvious will bring this house of cards down around our heads.  So mommas, save your retirement funds for that new Cadillac, because throwing it at junior to make him a lawyer is a total waste of money.  But if you decide to do it anyway, you’re the one who will have to live with the bad bet.  I know it’s harsh, but Malthus had a point.  Not everybody can be Super Super Lawyers.

Got it, Teacups?

A Dissenting Voice In A Very Small Pond

When I was first asked if I would agree to provide information to a private business seeking to “teach” lawyers about social media, I responded with how much of their take they planned to donate to charity.  If none, then why would they expect my free services so that they could turn a profit?  My correspondent came back with a funny response, neither offended by my antagonistic response nor embarrassed by having been outed for her effort to free-ride. 

She showed moxie, and I like moxie.  So, against my better judgment, I agreed to answer a bunch of questions about lawyers and social media so that this for-profit entity could create a presentation to sell to lawyers as if it was CLE-worthy.  It was a few minutes of my time, and more importantly given the other lawyers who were being asked to contribute, I realized that I was likely the only voice that would have anything to say suggesting that social media was not the panacea of wealth, success and prominence.  The others were all social media cheerleaders, or made their living off of it.

The presentation was completed and it’s available to be seen.  It’s absolutely awful.  It’s a lie.  It’s nonsense.  It’s total and complete crap.  It includes one quote from me, a tepid offer of the benefits of social media:


You can become part of a community that will both add to your professional knowledge and expand your professional world.
Omitted is the preceding and subsequent thoughts that this is the only benefit, not wealth and success.  Just like talking to a reporter, they parsed out the tiny piece that supported the false premise and ignored the rest.   Whatever.  Any lawyer foolish enough to pay to see this presentation gets what they deserve.

But what I didn’t realize adequately until chatting with other lawyers during my time doing the ITAP program at Cardozo Law School was how little most lawyers understand about the internet, and how little they want to understand.  Guys like me, and other blawgers like Bennett and Tannebaum, are busy trying to warn the brothers and sisters to steer clear of the charlatans.  Guys like Turk and O’Keefe are disclosing the scams and spams of big-boy lawyercentric businesses like West’s Findlaw. 

Those of us who spend some time on line are well-aware of what’s happening to lawyer advertising and self-promotion.  The problem is that the vast majority (and based upon my anecdotal experience, the word “vast” fails to suffice to capture it) neither know nor care.  They pay the monthly bill and never look back.  They haven’t got the slightest clue what is being done in their name, and actively avoid learning anything about it.

It is nothing more than today’s version of the yellow page ad, as far as they’re concerned.  A salesman sells them on the concept, promises the world, and that’s the end of their involvement.  After that, it’s just another bill to pay.

Those of us paying attention use great phrases like “outsource marketing = outsource ethics.”  The problem is that the people who need the message aren’t listening.  They aren’t reading. They aren’t paying any attention.  Nothing.  They truly aren’t interested in what’s happening online, beyond the potential of getting some new cases and not missing out on the internet gravy train.

Which brings me back to the seminars touting social media for lawyers.  There’s one happening about this time out in Washington State by a well known company that derives all its income from social media.  They asked if I, along with a few others, would be interested in doing a contrarian panel, tentatively titled “Four Angry Men.”  The only draw back is that they wanted us to go out there on our own dime, the giveback being that we could attend their conference for free.  Yeah, and I enjoy having a needle thrust through my eye.

On the other side, the cheerleaders and hypsters would not only happily shell out for the flight and hotel, but would pay for the privilege of “presenting” to the attendees in the hope of the attendees paying for their social media guru services.  They promise this is the next coming of wealth for lawyers.  There will be no one there to disagree,  Why in the world would I be willing to pay the freight to “present”?  I’ve got no financial horse in the race.

Where are the bar associations in all this?  They are running CLEs replete with presenters who are  at best clueless about social media and at worst the same cheerleaders who clamor for the face time with potential customers.  I’ve yet to see a single bar association CLE that isn’t gushing about social media.  The bar associations are as clueless as the rest of the bar, when they could be the best source of legitimate information for lawyers.  They have failed miserably to inform, and instead use whatever juice they possess to promote ignorance.  The worst offender is the ABA, the foremost promoter of snake oil as a cure-all.

And so there’s a small pond of people who learn that the cheerleaders are selling snake oil, and a large group of people who outsource their marketing, and hence their ethics, because those are the loudest and most prevalent voices.  And the ocean of lawyers who are shelling out the bucks because they believe that’s the future of their practice neither know nor care.  They will never hear a dissenting voice.

Be Sure Your Donations Go To Haiti

We’re a better people than we sometimes give ourselves credit for, as shown by the depth of concern and level of support for victims of the Haitian earthquake.  But I can’t shake  a lesson learned after 9/11, when billions of dollars in donations poured into the American Red Cross. It was a scam.

We are ever-vigilant of scammers always at the ready to take advantage of anyone willing to open his wallet to help those in need.  But we fully expect that an institution like the American Red Cross can be trusted to use donation to help those in Haiti to go to that purpose.  Remember the name Bernadine Healy?  She was the Red Cross head at the time, oozing empathy and collecting the massive donations from a well-meaning public prepared to do everything they could to help.  She subsequently resigned in disgrace.

The plea for donations by the American Red Cross for the victims of the earthquake is patent on its website, smeared with images evoking the need for help.  But your donation will go wherever the American Red Cross wants it to go, such as the more than $450,000 a year salary paid Red Cross CEO Healy when 9/11 was the cause, if they have their way.

Note the carefully worded solicitation by the Red Cross.







International Response Fund



You can help the victims of countless crises, like the recent earthquake in Haiti, around the world each year by making a financial gift to the American Red Cross International Response Fund, which will provide immediate relief and long-term support through supplies, technical assistance and other support to help those in need. The American Red Cross honors donor intent. If you wish to designate your donation to a specific disaster, please do so at the time of your donation by mailing your donation with the designation to the American Red Cross…


The first sentence suggests that donations to the International Response Fund will help Haiti, but obviously its use of the word “like” qualifies it to be an example, not a promise.  Buried in the paragraph is the need to specifically designate the donation to a “specific disaster,” a reform that followed Healy’s 9/11 scam. 

The expectation that few will read beyond the first sentence, or note that the solicitation qualifies the use of the money, creating the expectation that it will go to Haiti without any assurance that it will.  And no, the American Red Cross has no qualms about using the money in whatever way it deems best, your intentions notwithstanding.  And if you click on the International Response Fund, the next page will ask for a wealth of information to facilitate your donation, but nowhere does it have a space to designate it for any specific disaster. 

Sadly, this is the first fund recommended by Consumer Reports for Haitian donations, primarily because of the institutional nature of the American Red Cross.  Big is easy.  It’s not necessarily accurate.  While well-intended blawgers urge caution against scammers by donating to “reputable charities,” it’s not that easy.

Please donate to help the victims of the Haitian earthquake.  Just make sure that your donation goes where you intend it to go.

Don’t Quote Me

The past two days were spent on the faculty of Cardozo Law School’s Intensive Trial Advocacy Program (ITAP).  If your law school doesn’t have a similar program, ask why.  If they aren’t interested, transfer. Forget law review or whatever tier your school claims.  This is what lawyers do, and if your school isn’t doing it, then you lose.

This program, taught primarily by practicing lawyers and judges, including some of the best around who fly in across the country to be a part of the gang and offer their experience, provides an experience to law students that has the potential to actually enable them to walk into a courtroom and act like a lawyer.  Professors Ellen Yaroshefsky and Barry Scheck (who is phasing himself out of running the program) have a great thing going.

For the lawyers and judges, the most fun is the opportunity to hang out, listen to the war stories and see friends that we haven’t run across in the past year.  We tend to spend some intense time with other lawyers when we work with them on a case, and then lose track as we move on to other cases with other lawyers.  They become part of the coterie of old friends, people we like, respect and wish we could speak with more often.  Of course, life makes that difficult.

The most curious aspect of this year’s ITAP experience was how many people had stories to tell me, about their cases, lawyers, experience, whatever, and at the end of the conversation, would say to me, “that’s off the record, right?”  It appears that my blawging precedes me, and it makes even old, trusted friends a little wary about what they say to me.

I’ve got my doubts about this lawyer/journalist concept, about whether what I do here qualifies me to claim amateur reporter status.  While I have, on occasion, “broken” news, and I do pass stories of interest around from time to time, most of my effort is better defined as commentary than reporting.  The ABA Journal calls my posts “rants”, but that’s only because they hate me.

However, my sense was that blawging has changed things.  Not to the extent that old friends aren’t still friends, but that they want to be sure that they are talking to Greenfield the lawyer, not Greenfield the blawger.  Their words, thoughts, complaints, interests aren’t for publication, but for talk amongst their own. 

Let there be no doubt that I’m lawyer first and blawger second.  These men and women are not my “sources”, but my friends and peers.  I’m not a mole, taking notes on every nasty word spoken or beef between the brothers.  I’m just another lawyer hanging out with my own.

Don’t worry guys. I won’t quote you. 

But I will tell one funny story.  Fifth Circuit Judge Ed Prado was in my group, along with Arizona lawprof Zelda Harris, who was our team leader.  Judge Prado (yes, I still call judges judge, even in this friendly, informal setting) was having some fun during downtime telling the law students stories about life as a federal circuit judge, and he’s quite the raconteur.  Zelda kept trying to shut him down, as his stories were more interesting than hers, and he would feign being a scolded child whenever Zelda gave him the evil eye. 

During a break, Judge Prado was talking about cowboy boots, being from San Antoine, and explained how he admired his Luccheses.  This stopped the students cold, and they stared at him in wonderment.  The judge had no idea what happened, why the students were suddenly looking at him like he was nuts.

I chimed in at that moment (cautiously, as I didn’t want to be scolded by Zelda), and said, “Judge, in New York, the name Luchese has a different meaning than it does in San Antoine.  Everybody broke up, except Zelda who admonished us to get back to work.

If you get a chance to attend ITAP, whether as student or faculty, I urge you to go for it.  It’s a great experience.

Stupid Is As Stupid Does

From Grits for Breakfast, Dr. George Denkowski was the prosecutor’s favorite forensic psychologist down Texas way, given that the Supreme Court’s Atkins decision precluded executing defendants who were mentally retarded.  From Renee Feltz at the Texas Observer :


After the Atkins decision in 2002, Denkowski became the first choice for Texas prosecutors. He would ultimately testify in 29 cases—nearly two-thirds of such appeals in Texas to date. …

In 29 cases, Denkowski has found defendants retarded only eight times. By 2006, when he tested Plata, Denkowski had garnered an “almost Dr. Death status” among defense lawyers, according to attorney Robert Morrow. Morrow represented Alfred DeWayne Brown during his 2004 trial for killing a clerk and a security guard at a Houston check-cashing store. Morrow said “Denkowski pretty much thought that if you had engaged in criminal behavior you were not retarded,” Morrow says. Brown remains on Death Row.

Like most things scientific, it’s assumed that intelligence testing is inherently accurate and reliable.  To the contrary, it’s particularly susceptible to the will of the person administering the test, and Denkowski was just the man for the job if you wanted to make sure a defendant was executable.

That is, until the case of Daniel Plata, on death row for 12 years before “a federal judge found that Denkowski had improperly inflated IQ scores and all of his testimony ‘must be disregarded due to fatal errors.’ ”  This exposed Denkowski’s massive and systemic deception to his peers.



After the judge rejected Denkowski’s findings in the Plata case, Brown enlisted Jack Fletcher and a Florida-based psychologist named Tom Oakland to jointly file a complaint against Denkowski. Oakland co-authored the adaptive-behavior test. Their complaint cited the Richard case, as well as those of Plata and DeWayne Brown.


Last February, the state Board of Examiners of Psychologists upheld the complaint, finding that Denkowski had made “administration, scoring and mathematical errors” in all three cases. The board sent the complaint to the State Office of Administrative Hearings. Denkowski will have a chance to defend himself in a hearing scheduled for Feb. 16 in Austin. He could lose his license.


The broader psychological community has also rejected Denkowski’s methods. He is mentioned by name in the 2010 edition of the American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities’ diagnostic manual. In a section about how cultural or economic factors should impact scores on adaptive behavior tests, the authors “strongly caution against practices such as those recommended by Denkowski.”


And who, you ask, was the attorney who both saved Daniel Plata from execution and exposed Denkowski as a fraud?


Daniel Plata’s lawyer, Kathryn Kase, [who] argues that all of the appeals on which Denkowski worked should be re-heard. “When you have junk science in a case, it’s like pouring poison into a punch bowl,” she says. “You aren’t going to get the poison out. So you have to pour out the punch, clean the bowl, and start all over again.”
Our very own ginger-girl, formerly of Albany, New York, and possibly the best president the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers ever had, Kathryn Kase.  Doesn’t it figure that it would be some transplanted New York lawyer who would go down to Texas and ruin all their fun executing mentally retarded defendants whose intelligence was falsely inflated just to make sure that they could be put to death?

Congratulations, Kathryn.  Great work.

If Jdog Argued Before The Supremes

As a reader and commenter at Simple Justice, Joel Rosenberg, better known as Jdog, brought many things, amongst which was the regular use of the word “orthogonally” to describe his often curious take an the relative worth of a tangential view.  It appears that the spirit of Jdog flowed through University of Michigan law professor Richard Friedman yesterday, as he argued in Briscoe v, Virginia.


MR. FRIEDMAN: I think that issue is entirely orthogonal to the issue here because the Commonwealth is acknowledging –
CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS: I’m sorry. Entirely what?
MR. FRIEDMAN: Orthogonal. Right angle. Unrelated. Irrelevant.
CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS: Oh.
JUSTICE SCALIA: What was that adjective? I liked that.
MR. FRIEDMAN: Orthogonal.
CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS: Orthogonal.
MR. FRIEDMAN: Right, right.
JUSTICE SCALIA: Orthogonal, ooh.
(Laughter.)
JUSTICE KENNEDY: I knew this case presented us a problem.
(Laughter.)
MR. FRIEDMAN: I should have — I probably should have said –
JUSTICE SCALIA: I think we should use that in the opinion.
(Laughter.)
MR. FRIEDMAN: I thought — I thought I had seen it before.
JUSTICE SCALIA: Or the dissent.
(Laughter.)
MR. FRIEDMAN: That is a bit of professorship creeping in, I suppose.
Professorship?  Feh. More likely the running theme of lawprofs unable to give credit where it’s due.

Eugene Volokh, while applauding a word he has long admired, raises the downside of this lighthearted exchange surrounding the use of a word that was unfamiliar to the justices:

[A]s the lawyer in the story … described learned, to his cost. (It sounds like the Justices weren’t much upset with the lawyer, and they did figure out what the word means; but it was a distraction from the lawyer’s point, and took up time that could have been used for substantive argument.)

Did it distract from his point? Sure, though the point that the argument he was challenging was tangential was hardly a difficult to follow.  Did it eat up time?  Obviously, though not much. Did it break the tension, allow Friedman to relax as he moved forward and create an endearing moment that will enhance Friedman’s likability and hence credibility to all wings of the court.  You bet. 

And Friedman will go home with a story about his oral argument before the Supreme Court that he will enjoy telling for the rest of his life.  The case won’t be won or lost in those few seconds, but that experience will last forever.  You can’t buy something like this.  The only bad news is that orthogonal has now been used.  Of course, Slackoisie is still available.

Taser Wants To Be Its Own Watchdog

Taser is one of those remarkable things that owns it’s generic product name, like scotch tape and fridge.  You would think that they would be happy selling stun guns to 14,000 out of 18,000 police agencies, but no, they want more.  They also want to be their own overseer, according to this article in the Economist via  Alternet.


Taser has already begun piloting AXON, a “tactical on-officer network computer” that beams video footage to a secure Web site available only to a select few. According to Big Brother Rick Smith, Taser’s boss, this site is like a “secure YouTube of global law enforcement.” He claims it will serve a dual function: Create incentives for police to behave themselves, and vindicate them when they face accusations of misuse.

While we may be suspicious of Taser’s motives, aside from having a new product to sell, what does Taser have to say about it? From their Q & A :


Why is Taser International Developing such a complex device?
The answer:


First and foremost, having transparent accountability is of utmost concern to TASER International. When you combine our built-in accountability features with the TASER other accountability features of the TASER® X26 or the ADVANCED TASER® M26 electronic control devices you have a win-win combination. We back that claim up in light of the November 2006 IACP report that showed statistical data indicates that 96.2 percent of the time, the recording of the event exonerated the officer of the allegation or complaint. By adding the TASER AXON capability you now can capture 90 percent of law enforcement action that is missed by the in-car cameras.


Byard Duncan at Alternet isn’t buying.  He suspects that footage of abusive use of Tasers will suddenly disappear.  Computers do have glitches, you know.  But I doubt it.  I don’t think Taser finds it much a problem that 3.8% of the time, the officer will be proven to have use the Taser to abuse someone, as judged by the fine people at Taser. Of course, their idea of officer exoneration and mine might differ from time to time, and given the huge number of times Tasers are used as the weapon of first resort, even the small percentage amounts to an enormous number of cops gone bad and people harmed.

And that fact that it opens Taser to a new billion dollar product doesn’t hurt either.

But if Taser’s new AXON doesn’t record instances of police misconduct and abuse, or just plain laziness, there’s always cellphones and Youtube.  Just like now.

H/T Ed at Blawg Review