But what about the children? The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has overturned the convictions of about 6,500 kids who appeared before Ciavarella between 2003 and 2008. According to the Times-Leader :
The court based its ruling on allegations that Ciavarella and former judge Michael Conahan accepted millions of dollars from the owner and builder of two juvenile centers the county utilized. The court also found Ciavarella had repeatedly violated the constitutional rights of juveniles.
The decision means all convictions within that time frame will be vacated and the records of the juveniles expunged, or erased. Prosecutors also were barred from retrying any juveniles other than those that remain incarcerated or owe restitution or fines.
While that covers almost all of the children whose lives might otherwise have been irreversibly altered by this outrage, it doesn’t cover all of them. Those children who remain under court supervision will be subject to retrial, with the Luzerne Count District Attorney to notify Berks County Judge Arthur Grim which children should be subject to reprosecution, with Judge Grim then to determine whether to allow it. From the Philly Inquirer :
That leaves about 100 cases that may be reopened – serious offenses in which the defendant was represented by counsel, and is either still incarcerated or involved in the juvenile justice system through probation, treatment, or unpaid fines or restitution.
The Luzerne County District Attorney’s Office has 30 days to identify the defendants it wants to prosecute again. It must then submit the list to Grim, who will determine case by case which should go forward.
Musto Carroll agreed that the convictions in Ciavarella’s courtroom should be vacated, but she wanted to determine which ones to retry.
“We had argued all along that there were a certain class of cases so serious that we cannot just release those kids,” she said. “A lot of them are still in treatment. Also, we have concerns with the victims in these cases. We didn’t want [the accused] barred from being tried.”
Though it’s likely true that there were guilty amongst the abused innocent or trivial cases that resulted in incarceration, the District Attorney’s argument is disingenuous. Where was Carroll’s concern for justice when Ciavarella and Conahan were tossing kids in jail for staying out past curfew? Their scheme went on for five years right in front of the District Attorney’s nose, and no one gave a damn. Now they are true seekers of justice? Too little too late.
This situation also raises some very curious double jeopardy problems,
Musto Carroll’s recommendations could be contested on double-jeopardy grounds by the Juvenile Law Center, the Philadelphia group whose petition was the basis for Grim’s report. The center called the scheme “one of the largest and most serious violations of children’s rights in the history of the American legal system.”While the effort to retry these children doesn’t come after an acquittal, it does come after a “travesty of justice” dismissal and vacation of the convictions. That these scum judges crimes have reduced every case before them to a nullity, the children who remain under court supervision aren’t to blame for the fact that these judges were able to perpetrate their crimes for years without interference from the District Attorney.
For those inclined to be far more concerned with prosecuting crime than with a system even remotely resembling fairness, bear in mind that we are talking about juveniles here, children. These aren’t the ones treated as adults for their heinous crimes, but just kids with problems. Kids with even worse problems given that they were subjected to the scheme of Ciavarella and Conahan. Kids who received none of the protections that one would hope would come from a responsible District Attorney, whose responsibility is to do justice. Just kids.
District Attorney Musto Carroll voices concerns for the victims and for the children in need of treatment. Where was that concern when Ciavarella was shipping them off to jail over nothing? Where was that concern when Ciavarella was convicting them without a hearing? There was no one in a better position to recognize what was happening to 6,500 children in Luzerne County, Pennsylvania, than the District Attorney.
Carroll was responsible for protecting these 6,500 children, not just being complicit in the commission of these outrageous crimes by allowing it to happen to child after child right in front of his nose. He failed everyone, especially the children. Enough.

With DiPascali’s tearful wife, children, parents and FBI agents — including Manhattan securities-fraud chief Pat Carroll — looking on, Sullivan (pictured) told DiPascali’s lawyer Marc Mukasey that despite assurances his client wouldn’t flee, having his family pledge assets for bail, and offering to have him electronically monitored before his sentencing next year, the only thing that might lessen DiPascali’s incentive to flee was his cooperation with the government in future cases.