Not that there hasn’t been enough about Phoenix lawyers around here lately, but when Nick Martin of
Heat City posted a video of a detention officer Adam Stoddard, during a sentence in Maricopa County Superior Court, rifle through defense lawyer Joanne Cuccia’s file behind her back, quietly lift a paper out of the file and hand it off to fellow officer Francisco Campillo, who then spirited the paper away, it can’t be ignored.
Radley Balko
opened the bidding first, asking
….so any attorneys want to explain to me what happened in this video? Is this as blatant, outrageous (and, I’d hope, illegal) as it looks? I mean, it is Maricopa County. But damn.
What happened is exactly what he thinks happened, as blatant, outrageous and yes, illegal, as it looks. But the problems run far deeper than the surface of this video, and the video presents the perfect opportunity to expose what went wrong, and what remains wrong, in Maricopa County.
Court officers
provide security for the courtroom. As such, they are entitled to check everything that comes in for any dangerous objects and contraband, and that includes a defense lawyer’s file. That means that they may properly scan the file to do their job, but reading the contents of papers within a file is entirely outside the scope of their authority. A staple may be considered a weapon. The words on paper is none of their business.
So, the officer violated confidentiality of the defense lawyer’s file, then stole a document from that file. The first is a constitutional violation. The second is a crime.
But these egregious wrongs are just the surface of what’s revealed by the video. What happened in this courtroom, both during and afterward, reflects a deeper problem. First, this happened in full view of the judge, Lisa Flores, who appears not to have noticed. Later, when confronted with what happened, her first reaction is that her court officers are entitled to “leeway.” Her second reaction is to seize upon a statement by Cuccia that this isn’t the time to deal with the situation. Her third is that she’s got a busy calender and this isn’t worthy of her scarce time.
None of this is particularly surprising, given that judges are typically protective of their officers. These are the people assigned to protect her, and with whom she works on a daily basis. A certain camaraderie develops, and the normal inclination to smooth over problems with friends is hardly surprising. The judge does so deftly. Had she not, an incident like this might well have caused enormous problems with her working relationships with detention officers, undermining her position in the courthouse and possibly putting her at personal risk. You can be that all the other detention officers will support their brother, and find her lack of support inexcusable.
On Cuccia’s side, she fails to notice, despite a few backward glances as the officer is touching her papers, that something is seriously awry. Once informed of the problem by her client, she asserts herself, but allows herself to be told to “calm down” by the judge, and follows instructions well. Rather than go nuts, inform the court that this is outrageous, far more significant than anything else she has to do that day, and demand that the court address it immediately, loudly and clearly, she demurely allows the matter to be put off to another day.
Whether Judge Flores’ conduct was guided by corruption, fear of repercussions from the officer’s Boss, Joe Arpaio, personal concern or gutlessnes is unclear. That she watched a crime committed in front of her in her courtroom and reacted as she did is unacceptable no matter what her motive.
Cuccia’s willingness to be cowed in the face of being both the victim of the crime and the protector of a client is sad. It’s understandable that she might be confused at how best to respond, or fear what might happen if she become overly agitated or aggressive. But if ever there was a moment in a criminal defense lawyer’s life to fly off the handle, to stare down a judge and court officer, to take an immediate and forceful stand, this was it. There are some things worth taking a risk for. This was such a thing.
Of course, the lack of bold reaction to the wrong doesn’t shift responsibility from Adam Stoddard to anyone else. Stoddard, and his cohort Campillo, broke the rules, and broke the law. For this, they are wholly responsible. The bigger picture, however, is how and why the staff of Sheriff Joe Arpaio are so emboldened to engage in such flagrant wrongs, as this is one of a constant stream of wrongs that emanates from that office for, what, decades?
A hearing was subsequently held before Judge Gary Donahoe on whether to hold Stoddard in contempt. Nick Martin of
Heat City was the only media outlet in attendance. He wrote:
Under state law, an officer can seize evidence or make an arrest if he sees a crime taking place. Essentially, that’s what Stoddard said he saw — or at least what he thought he saw — at the sentencing of Antonio Lozano on that day.
The detention officer, however, had a hard time sticking to his story.
At first, Stoddard testified that the document he yanked from the file — a handwritten letter — contained “keywords” that led him to believe Lozano was some sort of security risk. Later, however, the detention officer admitted the document had been reviewed by court or sheriff’s officials beforehand and was quite literally given a stamp of approval.
“I guess, yeah, he would be legally entitled to have whatever he had on him,” Stoddard said, adding that the letter had been “date stamped by a notoriety [sic notary] or the sheriff’s office.”
Stoddard’s testimony didn’t improve from there. No reason for Stoddard’s conduct could be discerned from the testimony, no less an acceptable justification. And the judge’s reaction? Outrage? Immediate incarceration? Condemnation? Not exactly.
One of the complication’s of the hearing was Donahoe’s decision that the handwritten letter falls under attorney-client privilege. Because of that, no one was allowed to talk about the contents of the letter, including the supposed “keywords” that possibly provoked the seizure.
This, Donahoe said, made it impossible for Stoddard or Campillo to mount a defense against a possible contempt of court charge. Donahoe said he would not even consider holding the sheriff’s employees in contempt for the seizure unless Lozano waived his attorney-client privilege.
“Unless you’re going to let these gentlemen fully defend against it, I’m not going to hold them in contempt,” Donahoe said.
This is utter nonsense. The content of the document is wholly irrelevant to what Stoddard and Campillo did. Whether it was a full confession or the lyrics to Inagodadavita matters not a whit. That it was in Cuccia’s file, that it was observed, that it was stolen, is all that matters.
What reaction came from the attorneys representing Cuccia and her client at this hearing, Craig Mehrens and Maricopa County legal defender Maria Schaffer?
Mehrens and Schaffer discussed it, but did not come to a decision. The waiver appeared unlikely.
No mention of forceful, perhaps even angry argument at Judge Donahue’s ridiculous statement. Instead, they considered the unthinkable, acquiescing in this absurd challenge that the choice was limited to waiver of confidentiality or just forgetting about the whole thing. It may be that Nick Martin omitted a vigorous challenge by the lawyers to Judge Donahue, and certainly he wasn’t privy to their private discussion. One can only hope that if no challenge was mounted, then they were discussing appellate opportunities or the applicability of Section 1983.
So, in response to Radley Balko’s question, this is every bit as outrageous as it appears, and more. That Sheriff Joe Arpaio’s people are out of control shocks no one. That’s how things are in Maricopa County, and have been for a long time. But what’s being done about it? Where are the civil rights suits in federal court? Where is the outrage by the criminal defense bar? Who are these gutless judges who skirt fact and law to avoid whatever they fear will happen to them for doing their job?
Cops, and sheriff’s detention officers, get out of control. There are others involved in this system to serve as a check on out of control cops. It doesn’t excuse the officers for doing wrong, but who is there to stand up and stop them?
Something is very, very wrong down there in Maricopa County, and it appears that everyone in the criminal justice system has a part in it. It appears that the primary motivation for all the players who aren’t on the sheriff’s payroll is fear. Fear of prosecution. Fear of retaliation. Fear of Sheriff Joe Arpaio. As if Arpaio poisoned the water of Maricopa County.
It won’t stop until people stop drinking the water, arrive at an effective strategy to address the stream of outrages perpetrated by this one man constitutional wrecking crew and decide to take the risk of taking a stand. Former U.S. Attorney for the District of New Mexico, David Iglesias, had
this to say :
“I’ve been in and around law enforcement for about 20 years — state, local and federal level (and) even some military prosecution work. I’ve never seen anything like this,” Iglesias said after he looked through 5 Investigates’ research and did some on his own [about Sheriff Joe Arpaio’s conduct].
If he were handling the case, Iglesias said, “I would work very closely with the civil rights division in Washington, D.C., and based on the information I have, I would seek an indictment.”
Does this not give anyone any ideas? Yes, being a judge or a criminal defense lawyer can be very difficult, sometimes risky. But do something about it. As much as I would like to stroke you, make you feel better, offer sympathy for your awful situation, I just can’t. When criminal defense lawyers are faced with a challenge, with injustice, there is only one response. Deal with it. That’s what we do.
Update: Radley Balko linked back to this post, and got a few comments over at
The Agitator. While it’s heartwarming to read how so many non-lawyers are inclined to invent excuses for the defense lawyer’s “reaction”, they fail to comprehend that dealing with surprises, shocking conduct, outrages, is what criminal defense lawyers do for a living.
It’s not an easy job, and it isn’t supposed to be. It’s not a job for someone who wants to get along with everybody and make lots of friends. It’s a job for someone who is capable of dealing with unknown, effectively and immediately, even if it means going toe to toe with the judge. That happens to any good defense lawyer from time to time, for far less cause than this.
More significantly, excuses help no one and nothing. As kind as it may be to rationalize Cuccia’s reaction, she is a criminal defense lawyer. Dealing with shocking situations like this, no matter how unusual, is her job, as it is for every defense lawyer. This is what we do. No excuses.
Why is nobody stepping up? Because lawyers don’t understand (and don’t want to understand) Internet marketing and PPC strategies. Combine that with the fact that too little has been written about the ethics of web 2.0, and that nobody seems to want to step up and translate outdated ethical considerations to modern day technology. It’s a heavy combination of sad events for our five hapless pioneers. Hats off to you, Caroline, for stepping into the chasm and shining a little light.