Author Archives: SHG

If Only Half True

With all the wrong that appears from the surface of the American criminal justice system, the stuff that can be seen, occasionally appears on videotape so that the deniers can’t deny, none of it compares to the allegations of Craig Murray, the rector of the University of Dundee in Scotland and until 2004 the UK’s ambassador to Uzbekistan:



…the CIA not only relied on confessions gleaned through extreme torture, it sent terror war suspects to Uzbekistan as part of its extraordinary rendition program.


“I’m talking of people being raped with broken bottles,” he said at a lecture late last month that was re-broadcast by the Real News Network. “I’m talking of people having their children tortured in front of them until they sign a confession. I’m talking of people being boiled alive. And the intelligence from these torture sessions was being received by the CIA, and was being passed on.”


That this happens at all, anywhere, is beyond comprehension.  That our government knows it, contributes to it, participates in it and seeks to benefit from it, undermines any moral value in our existence.  This abhorrent conduct reflects an intersection between law and reality, where it’s “legal” to facilitate torture provided it doesn’t happen on our shores.  That way, the CIA can enjoy the benefits of torture without having to go through all those nasty hearings or ask John Yoo for permission.  Let the Uzkekis do it.



Suspects in Uzbekistan’s gulags “were being told to confess to membership in Al Qaeda. They were told to confess they’d been in training camps in Afghanistan. They were told to confess they had met Osama bin Laden in person. And the CIA intelligence constantly echoed these themes.”

“I was absolutely stunned — it changed my whole world view in an instant — to be told that London knew [the intelligence] coming from torture, that it was not illegal because our legal advisers had decided that under the United Nations convention against torture, it is not illegal to obtain or use intelligence gained from torture as long as we didn’t do the torture ourselves,” Murray said.
What’s particularly ironic, and disgusting, is that there is no information more unreliable than that obtained via torture.  Great for obtaining confessions; horrible for gaining information.  Who wouldn’t say anything the torturer wanted them to say in the face of this?  But more to the point, what kind of mind would engage in behaviors like this?  And what kind of nation would allow it?

For anyone who believes that it’s acceptable to do whatever we need to do to “win the war on terrorism,” does this strike you as worth it?  Does this make your chest swell with pride at being an American?

If this is only half true, that an arm of our government participated in any way in conduct of this stripe, whether by simply using the “information” gleaned or by actively using rendition to send people to the Uzbek’s for torture, it seems like a good time for a war crimes trial.  This nation cannot tolerate, no less participate, in such conduct. There is no leeway here.

Prosecutorial Indiscretion

Whether it’s by way of charging authority, as under the pre-Booker Sentencing Guidelines, or plea bargaining policy, prosecutors want more than to merely charge a defendant.  They want to impose their ideal of justice, leaving as little discretion to the judge to go all soft and mushy as possible.  It may not be merely a lack of faith in judges to exact a sufficient punishment, but an exertion of power to prove who’s really in charge.

Via Turley, Bedford County, Pennsylvania, District Attorney Bill Higgins decided a little pre-plea shaming was just the ticket for Evelyn Border, 55 and her daughter, Tina Griekspoor, 35, who were charged with stealing a gift card from a 9 year old girl at her birthday party.  Now that’s pretty low, even though it’s unlikely that the amount of the theft would have reached Bernie Madoff proportions.

Border apparently wanted a plea deal that avoided jail.  Higgins apparently saw his opportunity.  If not jail, what they could he do to exact his pound of flesh?  Hey, what about some public humiliation! DA Higgins came up with an idea.  If only Border and her daughter were to stand outside the courthouse with a sign, then he would recommend a sentence of probation.  And so they did.

Tina Griekspoor, left, and her mother Evelyn Border

Some will see the “punishment” as fitting, serving not only the purpose of personal but general deterrence, as any good public shaming should.  But this isn’t punishment, in the sense that it was a sentence imposed by a judge for the offense for which they stood accused.  Rather, this is a condition of the prosecutor, imposed by unilateral fiat, in order to receive a sentence of probation. 

While it wasn’t outside the realm of possibility that they could have told Higgins to go screw himself, and placed themselves in the hands of the judge for the imposition of sentence despite the prosecutor’s recommendation, Border and Griekspoor wanted as much of a guaranteed sentence as possible, and obviously weren’t too keen on going to jail.  (Hint Ladies: This is the sort of thing to think about before stealing.)

Would a judge have imposed a sentence of public shaming and probation?  It’s happened, and usually been subject to harsh criticism.  There’s a reason why we no longer have stocks in the village square.  But Higgins can deflect criticism by claiming that Border and Griekspoor voluntarily agreed to do this, a disingenuous argument for sure but one that might fly if he leaves out the part about jail as the alternative.

The problem here is that a prosecutor used his discretionary authority as a weapon to impose his own brand of justice, in this case public humiliation, in advance of a sentence imposed by a court,  It should not be within the prosecutor’s power to ignore the legislative sentencing scheme and superimpose his own brand of justice, outside the system.  There’s no appeal from this “sentence” of public humiliation.  There’s no choice made by those elected to do so as to whether shaming is the way to teach lessons. 

This is one man’s personal vision of how best to teach a lesson, and regardless of how nasty it may be to steal from a 9 year old on her birthday, the choice doesn’t belong to DA Higgins. 


 

An Unsuccessful Conversion to the Cause

The office phone rings. Caller ID says “NRA”.  Nonetheless, I pick it up.




I’m calling from the NRA with a poll about how the United Nations wants to eliminate gun possession in the United States.  I have a message from NRA vice president Wayne LaPierre to explain the poll.

 

Do I need to hear a message from Wayne LaPierre to answer a poll question?

 

Well, I think he wants you to hear his message.

 

Well, I don’t think I want to hear his message.

 

Well, you don’t have to be rude about it, Sir.
In fairness, it’s unlikely that Wayne LaPierre’s message would have done much to influence my views.  I’m not a fan of guns, though I believe that if the Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms is a personal right, as Justice Scalia told me it is in Heller, then that means what it says no matter how I feel on the subject.

On the other hand, when an unsolicited call comes on from an advocacy group like the NRA, intruding on my time, the suggestion that I’m being rude because I’m disinclined to cooperate with what both a young woman with a midwestern accent and Wayne LaPierre want from me isn’t going to do much to persuade me to the cause.

And by the way, I can be rude to any unsolicited caller I want.  I can even say mean things to her and hang up the phone.  That’s my right as the recipient of an unsolicited call.  But in this case, I don’t believe I was rude.  Uncooperative, perhaps, but hardly rude.

There are a few things that a cold-caller can say to me that make me laugh more than telling me that I’m being rude.  Talk about chutzpah.  This is a young woman with a midwestern accent who shouldn’t be trusted with a gun.

Save the Connecticut 5?

Carolyn Elefant is pissed.  That doesn’t happen too often, so it’s certainly worthy of attention when it does.  At My Shingle, Carolyn asks why the blawgosphere hasn’t erupted in outrage at the persecution of the Connecticut 5.  The first reason is that most people have never heard about the Connecticut 5.  That’s easily remedied.


Yet the Connecticut Disciplinary Counsel, in its Order of Probable Cause and Complaint (H/T to Ben Glass of Great Legal Marketing for publicizing the order) against five innocent lawyers who participated in the Total Bankruptcy.com cooperative advertising website (one lawyer for just a scant two months) thinks otherwise – that John and Jane Consumers are really John and Jane Morons.  To the Connecticut Disciplinary Counsel, systems like TotalAttorneys subject consumers to “corrupt” and “abusive” practices (Order at 13), “capitalizes on the financially insecure consumer’s fear of debt, poor credit rating and shame” and “intrude on the “sacred territory between lawyers and their clients.” (Order at 14). 
Since I’m not a regular aficionado of marketing blogs, and most of them try to shut the door when they see me coming since I rarely have nice things to say about them, it’s no surprise that I hadn’t heard of the plight of these “five innocent lawyers.”  I had, however, been aware of the Connecticut Disciplinary Counsel’s investigation of Total Attorneys.

Carolyn has offered a paradigm of John and Jane Consumers enjoying the benefits of access to lawyers through Total Attorneys, and challenged the Disciplinary Counsel’s actions because no consumers were hurt in the making of this marketing strategy.  That’s one way to look at it.  Here’s another.


You’re a lawyer. You receive a telephone call from a for-profit company offering to feed you clients who visit the company’s web site seeking legal help. In exchange, you pay a fee for every consumer who contacts you. The company markets itself as a lawyer advertising site and claims the fee is used to cover operational costs and support services. But disciplinary officials, in Connecticut at least, think the agreement might be an example of paying for referrals, which is a felony offense in the state. The question of what constitutes ethical and legal Internet advertising of attorney services is back in the spotlight after local grievance panels recently found probable cause against two Connecticut attorneys who entered into business agreements with a Chicago-based company.

Of course, the focus is on Total Attorneys rather than the lawyers who put aside good judgment to become a party to this scheme.  I agree with Carolyn that the Connecticut 5 are being made the scapegoats for a much, much larger problem.  I don’t care for scapegoating, and don’t see how one can distinguish what these five lawyers have done from what is happening across the country with Total Attorneys and others, a whole industry that has arisen to feed cases to desperate lawyers under some variation of fee splitting. 

But the real problem is captured best in a comment to Carolyn’s post:


Tracy Thrower Conyers – November 3, 2009 4:49 PM


Why is nobody stepping up? Because lawyers don’t understand (and don’t want to understand) Internet marketing and PPC strategies. Combine that with the fact that too little has been written about the ethics of web 2.0, and that nobody seems to want to step up and translate outdated ethical considerations to modern day technology. It’s a heavy combination of sad events for our five hapless pioneers. Hats off to you, Caroline, for stepping into the chasm and shining a little light.


Forget about all those cannons of ethics,codes of professional responsibility.  That was so yesterday, so client-centric.  We’re now in the age of Web 2.0, and it’s all about how technology can be used for lawyers to hear the sound of cha-ching.  Our new ethos is profit, and our only discipline is doing whatever we have to do to get it.

There is a war being fought right in front of us.  On one side is a tidal wave of newly established lawyer marketing businesses, deluging us with the promise of clients, money and success.  On the other is the stodgy old world of hard work, competence and dignity.  The problem with the latter is that it offers no promise of making the practitioner’s telephone ring.  The marketers think they are very dignified, and take umbrage at the suggestion that their hair extensions are askew.  Given the range of miniskirts available to marketers, some certainly are far more dignified than others.  That’s feint praise.

The other side of equation is exemplified by my good buddy, Dan Hull at What About Clients?  Despite Dan’s having suffered horrendous disfigurement in an unfortunate kiln explosion as an undergrad, he’s never forgotten as a lawyer that his only justification for accepting a dime is to serve his clients.  And that dime can never be shared with any marketer, any business, for routing consumers his way.  They come to him because of his reputation for skilled lawyers and his dedication to client service. 

This battle has nothing to do with the five lawyers in Connecticut who have been placed in the town square to be used as examples of what will happen to you by succumbing to the lure of the marketers.  This is a huge battle, taking place everywhere and clouding the eyes of otherwise good, but hungry, lawyers who have been blinded to the meaning of professionalism by the nagging pain in their bellies. 

I cannot agree with Carolyn’s assessment that businesses like Total Attorneys are benign.  They are a cancer in the legal profession, and one that happily infects far too many lawyers who are desperate for business.  But I do agree that the five lawyers in Connecticut shouldn’t be flogged as the scapegoats for this much bigger problem.  We must deal with the disease, not the symptom.  Free the Connecticut 5!  Total Attorneys is another story.

Just Part of the Crowd

The Richmond Rape, in which a 15 year old girl was gang raped for more than two hours in front of crowd of fellow high school students, has received surprisingly little attention in the blawgosphere.  Not only did the crowd do nothing to stop the horrific crime, but they cheered it on.

The phenomenon has been explained as the “bystander effect,” the anonymity of the crowd, a reflection of the death of morality and responsibility of our youth. 


Although shocking, the “bystander effect” is a common social phenomenon that occurs when more than one person witnesses an emergency. People fail to act not because they lack empathy but because the presence of others can sometimes give us a false sense of security.

Perhaps the most shocking finding is that the more people that are around, the less likely any individual is to call for help. While the number of witnesses at Richmond High has made the story morally outrageous, it also, ironically, might explain why the horror went on for so long.

But the question for lawyers is whether those who not only stood by, but cheered the perpetrators of the rape, can be prosecuted.  This question was batted about between conspirators Eugene Volokh and Orin Kerr.  First Eugene:


Probably yes, on the grounds that the cheering tends to encourage the criminal and thus constitutes “abet[ing].” “An aider and abettor is one who acts with both knowledge of the perpetrator’s criminal purpose and the intent of encouraging or facilitating commission of the offense.” People v. Avila, 38 Cal. 4th 491, 564 (2006).

Orin responds:


I have a somewhat different take. I don’t know of any cases on this, but my sense has been that the answer is probably “no.” The reason is that an “aider and abettor” must aid and abet, not merely abet. A bystander who merely cheers on a criminal is not actually aiding the criminal, at least absent unusual circumstances. That is, he is not engaging in an act or omission that assists the crime. So I have tended to think that the bystander has not satisfied the act requirement of accomplice liability and therefore isn’t liable. 

It’s true that some courts say that “encouraging” the crime can satisfy the act requirement of accomplice liability. But when I’ve looked for cases that purport apply this, I encountered cases in which the encourager was actually helping the crime. It wasn’t just encouragement in the sense of an innocent bystander saying, “Run, OJ, run!,” but stuff more like co-conspirators giving the bad guy a pep talk to override his doubts and make sure he would go ahead with the crime. So my tentative sense of it is that the encouragement has to actually help the crime occur or the bad guys to escape.
The difference seems to be in how one distinguishes passive versus active involvement. Notably, In the immediate aftermath of the crime, the “former prosecutor” talking heads were unanimous in proclaiming that the bystanders couldn’t be prosecuted, no matter how morally offensive their behavior.  Though they sought to explain this as stemming from no duty to act when seeing a felony committed in front of them, the undertone was the they would never get a conviction anyway so it wasn’t worth the bother.  Probably true, but the discussion was less than illuminating.

The debate between Eugene and Orin, on the other hand, raises the more interesting definitional problem.  Had the crowd around the gang rape started screaming at the perpetrators to “stop it, we’re calling the cops,” it seems to me that the perpetrators would have stopped and headed for the hills.  But this crowd cheered the rape, and not only encouraged its continuance, but emboldened the rapists. 

I can’t help but wonder whether one or more of the rapists would not have committed the crime but for the crowd’s encouragement.  That there was a large gathering around them, cheering them on, prompting them to continue, pushing them forward, made any of the rapists who might otherwise have been reluctant to have acted for fear of having been viewed as afraid, unmanly perhaps, in front of their friends.  A screaming throng of bystanders will do that to a person.

The question to me, therefore, is how passive a role did the cheering play in this gang rape?  It strikes me as an integral part of the overall crime.  In New York, the archaic word “importune” is included in the definition of accomplice liability.  To “beset with insistent or repeated requests; entreat pressingly.”  It’s inclusion recognizes that a perpetrator of a crime can be influenced by those who push for it, beg for it, applaud it.  The angel sitting on his shoulder is no match for a crowd of devils cheering its commission onward.

But this is about group dynamics, the impact of a crowd of people who can influence the commission of a crime.  It’s the action of the group, the crowd, in pushing the perpetration of the crime forward that importuned the ongoing rape.  The same influences that affect the rapists affect the individuals in the crowd, the dynamic of all the others cheering influences the individuals in the crowd who are offended or outraged by the rape, and they leave their own morality behind to be part of the group. 

It would take a very strong person to have spoken out against the cheering crowd, to have come forward and cry that this horrific crime must stop.  Few high school students have anywhere near this sense of inner strength and personal self-esteem that they can stare down their friends and classmates and oppose them.  After all, the thing most teenagers and young adults want more than anything is to be accepted by their peers, and they will do whatever they must to gain group acceptance. 

It seems unlikely that any individual in the cheering crowd bears criminal liability for the conduct of the group as a whole, despite my agreement with Eugene that the conduct of group, as a whole, did aid and abet the commission of this gang rape.  Other than the first person in the crowd, the one who decided that cheering the rapists onward rather than screaming for them to stop, who set the dynamic in motion to encourage this horrific crime rather than stop it, the individuals who ultimate comprise the group are unlikely to possess, or at least be proven to possess, the intent of encouraging the commission of the crime.  Rather, their intent was to be part of the group, as terribly sad as that may be.

That the reaction of the crowd to seeing a 15 year old girl gang raped was to cheer, rather than take the opposite tack and stop this crime from happening before their eyes, is different matter, one better explained by sociologists than lawyers.  Nothing here provides a moral justification for their conduct, and there is no moral justification.  The kids who cheered on this gang rape for hours will spend the rest of their lives knowing that they, as a group and individually, could have done something to stop this crime from happening and didn’t.  Worse still, they will know that they encouraged it, no matter that they will never be prosecuted.  Their failure to act is something that should haunt them for a very long time.

The Poisoned Water of Maricopa County (Update)

Not that there hasn’t been enough about Phoenix lawyers around here lately, but when Nick Martin of Heat City posted a video of a detention officer Adam Stoddard, during a sentence in Maricopa County Superior Court, rifle through defense lawyer Joanne Cuccia’s file behind her back, quietly lift a paper out of the file and hand it off to fellow officer Francisco Campillo, who then spirited the paper away, it can’t be ignored.

Radley Balko opened the bidding first, asking


….so any attorneys want to explain to me what happened in this video? Is this as blatant, outrageous (and, I’d hope, illegal) as it looks? I mean, it is Maricopa County. But damn.

What happened is exactly what he thinks happened, as blatant, outrageous and yes, illegal, as it looks.  But the problems run far deeper than the surface of this video, and the video presents the perfect opportunity to expose what went wrong, and what remains wrong, in Maricopa County.

Court officers provide security for the courtroom.  As such, they are entitled to check everything that comes in for any dangerous objects and contraband, and that includes a defense lawyer’s file.  That means that they may properly scan the file to do their job, but reading the contents of papers within a file is entirely outside the scope of their authority.  A staple may be considered a weapon. The words on paper is none of their business.

So, the officer violated confidentiality of the defense lawyer’s file, then stole a document from that file.  The first is a constitutional violation.  The second is a crime.

But these egregious wrongs are just the surface of what’s revealed by the video. What happened in this courtroom, both during and afterward, reflects a deeper problem.  First, this happened in full view of the judge, Lisa Flores, who appears not to have noticed.  Later, when confronted with what happened, her first reaction is that her court officers are entitled to “leeway.”  Her second reaction is to seize upon a statement by Cuccia that this isn’t the time to deal with the situation.  Her third is that she’s got a busy calender and this isn’t worthy of her scarce time.

None of this is particularly surprising, given that judges are typically protective of their officers.  These are the people assigned to protect her, and with whom she works on a daily basis.  A certain camaraderie develops, and the normal inclination to smooth over problems with friends is hardly surprising.  The judge does so deftly. Had she not, an incident like this might well have caused enormous problems with her working relationships with detention officers, undermining her position in the courthouse and possibly putting her at personal risk.  You can be that all the other detention officers will support their brother, and find her lack of support inexcusable.

On Cuccia’s side, she fails to notice, despite a few backward glances as the officer is touching her papers, that something is seriously awry.  Once informed of the problem by her client, she asserts herself, but allows herself to be told to “calm down” by the judge, and follows instructions well.  Rather than go nuts, inform the court that this is outrageous, far more significant than anything else she has to do that day, and demand that the court address it immediately, loudly and clearly, she demurely allows the matter to be put off to another day. 

Whether Judge Flores’ conduct was guided by corruption, fear of repercussions from the officer’s Boss, Joe Arpaio, personal concern or gutlessnes is unclear.  That she watched a crime committed in front of her in her courtroom and reacted as she did is unacceptable no matter what her motive. 

Cuccia’s willingness to be cowed in the face of being both the victim of the crime and the protector of a client is sad.  It’s understandable that she might be confused at how best to respond, or fear what might happen if she become overly agitated or aggressive.  But if ever there was a moment in a criminal defense lawyer’s life to fly off the handle, to stare down a judge and court officer, to take an immediate and forceful stand, this was it.  There are some things worth taking a risk for.  This was such a thing.

Of course, the lack of bold reaction to the wrong doesn’t shift responsibility from Adam Stoddard to anyone else.  Stoddard, and his cohort Campillo, broke the rules, and broke the law.  For this, they are wholly responsible.  The bigger picture, however, is how and why the staff of Sheriff Joe Arpaio are so emboldened to engage in such flagrant wrongs, as this is one of a constant stream of wrongs that emanates from that office for, what, decades?

A hearing was subsequently held before Judge Gary Donahoe on whether to hold Stoddard in contempt.  Nick Martin of Heat City was the only media outlet in attendance.  He wrote:


Under state law, an officer can seize evidence or make an arrest if he sees a crime taking place. Essentially, that’s what Stoddard said he saw — or at least what he thought he saw — at the sentencing of Antonio Lozano on that day.

The detention officer, however, had a hard time sticking to his story.


At first, Stoddard testified that the document he yanked from the file — a handwritten letter — contained “keywords” that led him to believe Lozano was some sort of security risk. Later, however, the detention officer admitted the document had been reviewed by court or sheriff’s officials beforehand and was quite literally given a stamp of approval.

“I guess, yeah, he would be legally entitled to have whatever he had on him,” Stoddard said, adding that the letter had been “date stamped by a notoriety [sic notary] or the sheriff’s office.”


Stoddard’s testimony didn’t improve from there.  No reason for Stoddard’s conduct could be discerned from the testimony, no less an acceptable justification.  And the judge’s reaction?  Outrage? Immediate incarceration? Condemnation?  Not exactly.


One of the complication’s of the hearing was Donahoe’s decision that the handwritten letter falls under attorney-client privilege. Because of that, no one was allowed to talk about the contents of the letter, including the supposed “keywords” that possibly provoked the seizure.

This, Donahoe said, made it impossible for Stoddard or Campillo to mount a defense against a possible contempt of court charge. Donahoe said he would not even consider holding the sheriff’s employees in contempt for the seizure unless Lozano waived his attorney-client privilege.

“Unless you’re going to let these gentlemen fully defend against it, I’m not going to hold them in contempt,” Donahoe said.

This is utter nonsense.  The content of the document is wholly irrelevant to what Stoddard and Campillo did.  Whether it was a full confession or the lyrics to Inagodadavita matters not a whit.  That it was in Cuccia’s file, that it was observed, that it was stolen, is all that matters. 

What reaction came from the attorneys representing Cuccia and her client at this hearing, Craig Mehrens and Maricopa County legal defender Maria Schaffer? 


Mehrens and Schaffer discussed it, but did not come to a decision. The waiver appeared unlikely.

No mention of forceful, perhaps even angry argument at Judge Donahue’s ridiculous statement.  Instead, they considered the unthinkable, acquiescing in this absurd challenge that the choice was limited to waiver of confidentiality or just forgetting about the whole thing.  It may be that Nick Martin omitted a vigorous challenge by the lawyers to Judge Donahue, and certainly he wasn’t privy to their private discussion.  One can only hope that if no challenge was mounted, then they were discussing appellate opportunities or the applicability of Section 1983.

So, in response to Radley Balko’s question, this is every bit as outrageous as it appears, and more.  That Sheriff Joe Arpaio’s people are out of control shocks no one. That’s how things are in Maricopa County, and have been for a long time.  But what’s being done about it?  Where are the civil rights suits in federal court?  Where is the outrage by the criminal defense bar? Who are these gutless judges who skirt fact and law to avoid whatever they fear will happen to them for doing their job?

Cops, and sheriff’s detention officers, get out of control.  There are others involved in this system to serve as a check on out of control cops.  It doesn’t excuse the officers for doing wrong, but who is there to stand up and stop them?

Something is very, very wrong down there in Maricopa County, and it appears that everyone in the criminal justice system has a part in it.  It appears that the primary motivation for all the players who aren’t on the sheriff’s payroll is fear.  Fear of prosecution. Fear of retaliation. Fear of Sheriff Joe Arpaio.  As if Arpaio poisoned the water of Maricopa County. 

It won’t stop until people stop drinking the water, arrive at an effective strategy to address the stream of outrages perpetrated by this one man constitutional wrecking crew and decide to take the risk of taking a stand.   Former U.S. Attorney for the District of New Mexico, David Iglesias, had this to say :


“I’ve been in and around law enforcement for about 20 years — state, local and federal level (and) even some military prosecution work. I’ve never seen anything like this,” Iglesias said after he looked through 5 Investigates’ research and did some on his own [about Sheriff Joe Arpaio’s conduct].

If he were handling the case, Iglesias said, “I would work very closely with the civil rights division in Washington, D.C., and based on the information I have, I would seek an indictment.”
Does this not give anyone any ideas?  Yes, being a judge or a criminal defense lawyer can be very difficult, sometimes risky.  But do something about it.  As much as I would like to stroke you, make you feel better, offer sympathy for your awful situation, I just can’t.  When criminal defense lawyers are faced with a challenge, with injustice, there is only one response.  Deal with it.  That’s what we do.

Update:  Radley Balko linked back to this post, and got a few comments over at The Agitator.  While it’s heartwarming to read how so many non-lawyers are inclined to invent excuses for the defense lawyer’s “reaction”, they fail to comprehend that dealing with surprises, shocking conduct, outrages, is what criminal defense lawyers do for a living. 

It’s not an easy job, and it isn’t supposed to be.  It’s not a job for someone who wants to get along with everybody and make lots of friends.  It’s a job for someone who is capable of dealing with unknown, effectively and immediately, even if it means going toe to toe with the judge.  That happens to any good defense lawyer from time to time, for far less cause than this.

More significantly, excuses help no one and nothing.  As kind as it may be to rationalize Cuccia’s reaction, she is a criminal defense lawyer.  Dealing with shocking situations like this, no matter how unusual, is her job, as it is for every defense lawyer. This is what we do. No excuses.

A Naked Boulder Rolls Downhill (And A Related Twit)

Via Radley Balko, the good people of Boulder, Colorado, can sleep well on Halloween, secure in the knowledge that human genitalia will not be flailing about, demeaning the sensibilities of those without any.



For nearly a decade, naked pumpkin runners did their thing unmolested, stampeding through the frigid dark past crowds of admirers who hooted, hollered and tossed candy. But last year the run attracted more than 150 participants, and Police Chief Mark Beckner fears things are getting out of hand. “It’s a free-for-all,” he says.

So he intends to stop it.

He will station more than 40 officers on the traditional four-block route tonight, with two SWAT teams patrolling nearby. All have orders to arrest gourd-topped streakers as sex offenders.
Naked Halloween shenanigans is the gateway to heroin, or something like that.  No matter, we can’t have it.  There can be no more foolishness that distinguishes those inclined toward harmless foolishness from those who sit in front of their televisions and tsk at these miscreants who disrupt their orderly lives.

Chances are good that, had I been a resident of Boulder, I would not have elected to put a gourd on my head and run wild in the streets.  I’m far too much a fan of warmth, and far too little a fan of what gravity has meant for my physique.  Still, there’s a certain appreciation of those who want to break away from the norm, engage in a little harmless tomfoolery and prove that humans are still capable of careless abandon.  After all, it gets awfully cold in Boulder this time of year, and shrinkage is always a problem.  I have to admire those willing to, and capable of, braving the weather.

Given the consequences, the SWAT teams won.


The costumed crowd on the Pearl Street Mall was large and boisterous Saturday night, but with bars closing and the crowd dispersing at 2 a.m. Sunday, there had been just one arrest and no significant problems.

Forty police officers patrolled the Mall in pairs, and another 60 were spread out around the city.

“I’ve heard people say, ‘It’s just not worth it. Let’s not go down there,'” he said. “Obviously there will always be people who come down to the Mall and that’s fine. And as long as everyone obeys the law, we won’t have any problems.”


Photo by Will Morgan

The heavy police presence appeared to deter full participation in the annual Naked Pumpkin Run, where people streak down the Mall wearing nothing but carved-out pumpkins on their heads.

Little by little, the quirks that make life different, worth living, will be eliminated from our universe to secure the overarching mandate of order.  It’s not just the Boulder police chief who has killed the spirit and vibrancy of his city, but officials in every school, every statehouse, even every courthouse, who seek to homogenize every experience to protect us from ourselves. 

It’s the quirks, the peculiar, maybe even ridiculous, acts of craziness that allow the human spirit to soar.  It’s fun.  It’s crazy and wild.  No one ever suffered because a bunch of naked runners streaked the mall in Boulder.  Oddly, it may not even be illegal.  But getting up close and personal with the local SWAT team isn’t worth finding out.

The residents of Boulder can be assured that there will be no Naked Pumpkin runners sullying up their streets.  They need have no fear as they sit on their couch and watch reruns of Family Guy, where only cartoon figures engage in shenanigans that humans once enjoyed. 

Lest you think that there is no one out there bold enough to fight the forces of safety, order and homogenization, social media guru Adrian Dayton has taken up arms and stood as a bulwark of boldness, letting the wild animal that still exists within mankind shine through.  For Halloween, Adrian was a twit.

img_7505

Welcome to our wild and crazy future.  I wonder if the bird on the fedora has eaten recently?

Addendum:  In response to various emails, no bird was harmed in the taking of this photo.  However, several laws of nature were violated, but no SWAT teams were involved.

Sullivan & Cromwell Gets a Seat At The Execution

Imagine how fortunate a death row inmate must feel when he learns that his cause will be taken up by the best and brightest lawyers at one of the most prestigious big law firms in the nation, Sullivan & Cromwell.  Hallelujah!  After all, these are the whizkids, the ones with all the resources.  Their staff has staff.  A thousand laboring oars, all to save one man from execution.

Cory Maples must have thought he hit the lottery when he found out.  From Above the Law :

More than a decade ago, Cory Maples of Alabama murdered two people. After an evening of heavy drinking, playing pool, and riding around in a friend’s car, Maples killed two friends, shooting them execution-style.

According to court documents, he signed a confession, “stating that he: (1) shot both victims around midnight; (2) had drunk six or seven beers by about 8 p.m., but ‘didn’t feel very drunk’; and (3) did not know why he decided to kill the two men. Faced with this confession, Maples’s trial attorneys argued that Maples was guilty of murder, but not capital murder.”

A jury found Maples guilty and sentenced him to death.

Maples appealed his capital murder conviction with the help of attorneys at Sullivan & Cromwell.

So they filed a Rule 32 petition alleging ineffective assistance of counsel.  And they lost.  Stercus accidit.  But what happened after that, well, doesn’t just happen.

Basically, Sullivan & Cromwell forgot to file a notice of appeal for a death row inmate, causing him to procedurally default all his ineffective-assistance claims. Oops!

It seems that between the time that the petition was filed and the decision, the young lawyers assigned to save Cory Maples life moved on to greener pastures.  New lawyers were assigned, but they were busy trying to figure out how to achieve work/life balance.  Nobody noticed that the adverse decision arrived and the 42 days to file the notice of appeal began to run.  And ran.  And ran out.

Having screwed up once, the quickie solution was to get the Court to play ball with S&C and give them an outlet to save face.

Thereafter, Maples’s mother contacted Sullivan & Cromwell. On Maples’s behalf, new attorneys from the Sullivan & Cromwell firm requested that the Alabama trial court re-issue its Rule 32 Order so that he might file a timely appeal. The trial court refused, stating in an order that it was “unwilling to enter into subterfuge in order to gloss over mistakes made by counsel for [Maples].”

Plan B was to make an end run around their screw up via a habeas corpus petition.

The district court concluded that: (1) Maples’s ineffective-assistance claims were procedurally defaulted because Maples did not timely file an appeal of the dismissal of his Rule 32 petition; (2) even if Maples’s default were the result of his three post-conviction counsel’s failing to file a Rule 32 appeal, such ineffectiveness could not establish cause for the default because there is no constitutional right to post-conviction counsel; and (3) the Alabama appellate courts’ decisions that Maples was not entitled to a sua sponte jury instruction on manslaughter due to voluntary intoxication was not contrary to, or an unreasonable application of, clearly established federal law.

The 11th Circuit affirmed in a per curiam opinion.

Cory Maples remains on death row.

Biglaw has made some significant contributions to the cause of death row defendants, taking their cases pro bono, both as a public service as well as a training exercise for their associates.  Better that they should practice on death row inmates than major (paying) corporations.  Mistakes on paying clients had dire consequences.  Mistakes on death row inmates, not so much. Even if their motives were suspect, at least they filled a void of representation, and often did some great work and won some major victories.

But Cory Maples remains on death row because Sullivan & Cromwell blew a deadline.  I wonder how many partners and associates will turn out to watch as he’s put to death.  The execution chamber isn’t big enough for a law firm of Sullivan & Cromwell’s stature.

A Very Long Island Without a Newpaper

Newsday was the hometown paper for those of us living on Long Island.  No, it was no New York Times, but a Daily News, maybe.  Better than a New York Post, except for page 6.  I’ve linked to it for stories. Written op-eds for it. Read the hard copy with morning coffee and on the train ride into Manhattan.

Those were the good old days, when Newsday was a real newspaper.  Those days are gone.

When Newsday was purchased by the Dolans, of Cablevision infamy, we knew the end was near.  The ax swung broadly around the newsroom and through the hearts of the editorial staff.  Most of the stories are now AP or purchased from elsewhere.  The op-eds are largely gone.  Some local news remains, written by actual reporters, but are spread too thin and cover too little.  The idea of investigating a story is farcical; the few remaining are lucky to make deadline on the daily fluff.  It’s not the fault of the remaining staff, as much as the simple fact of life for a few people doing the job of many.

This was all anticipated.  The Dolans weren’t newspaper people.  Chuck Dolan was once a cable television visionary.  His son Jim, who hold the reins of Newsday, only knows how the turn the crank on a cash machine.  As their vision of Newsday came into focus, it became clear that there was no desire to own a newspaper, but rather to create a value added benefit to Cablevision subscribers, a wedge to fight the telephone company’s intrusion into their domain and an excuse to raise cable prices.  As if they ever needed an excuse before.

Newsday has now become a captive of Cablevision.  It’s closed its doors to non-cable subscribers, unless you want to pay a fee.  No one will pay the fee, as it would be plain nuts.  This change was serious enough to cause long-time business columnist, Saul Friedman, one of the few who still had the password to a computer terminal, to hang up his keyboard.



Mr. Friedman, who had written a column for Newsday since 1996, quit last week over the paper’s decision to require some readers to pay for access to its Web site.

That did not sit well with Mr. Friedman, a freelancer who wrote Gray Matters, a weekly column on aging. He explained his departure in a note to Jim Romenesko’s media blog. In an interview, Mr. Friedman said, “My column has been popular around the country, but now it was really going to be impossible for people outside Long Island to read it.” That includes him; living outside Washington, he is not a subscriber to Newsday or Cablevision.
And that includes readers here, who don’t carry a subscription to Newsday.  This creates quite a quandary, since any link to a Newsday story will leave others unable to read it, to see the source material upon which I’ve relied.  But then, there’s no alternative news source for Long Island.  But then, is Newsday even a news source anymore, or the house organ for Cablevision?

I’ll miss Newsday.  The old Newsday, that was a leading paper with hard-hitting investigative journalism and top-notch columnists.  The less old Newsday that adequately covered Long Island local news, unafraid to out abuse and misconduct.  The new Newsday is a monument to the death of journalism and the elevation of collateral business acumen over a vital free press.  Business has won.

From Great Neck to Montauk, there will no longer be any news. Will the last one out please shut off the lights.  Electricity costs money, you know.

The Sturm and Drang of Blathering

In an unfortunately heated, yet dismissive comment, a criminal defense lawyer of some substantial experience and accomplishment wrote of her true thoughts about blawgs:


I think blogs are ridiculous and extraordinarily egocentric blatherings of people who apparently don’t get enough attention in their day to day lives.

It wasn’t unfortunate because it revealed her true feelings about blawgs; feelings which are no doubt shared by many others who think that any fool with a keyboard can set themselves up to be a pundit of some worth.  It was unfortunate because it was gratuitous, wholly unrelated to her purpose for commenting, and fundamentally misguided.  I reacted to the comment with some disdain, having grown tired of the responsibility to explain life in the blawgosphere to everyone who doesn’t understand it but won’t let their ignorance stand in the way of expressing their opinion.

This post, however, isn’t directed at the individual, which is why I don’t link back to the comment or identify its author.  She’s been duly chastised, and will no doubt dismiss my response as still more blathering.  That’s the beauty of being dismissive, as it alleviates one from any responsibility for being wrong or learning what’s right.

That said, the comment serves well as a launching pad for a better understanding of what blawgs are, and can be.  Better to light a candle than curse the darkness.

There are blogs that meet the commenter’s expectation.  But we rarely see them, because they offer nothing of value.  For some reason, people unfamiliar with the blawgosphere are apt to believe that every blog, no matter how vapid or fascinating, is read by millions of people.  To their mind, there is some vast group of disconnected people (none of whom they know) that spends their days and nights fussing with the digital world.


It is becoming increasingly obvious that there is little to be gained from disagreeing with what someone says in a blog, especially when they know very little about what they write. It also shows the sadly impersonal communication that we have become used to because of computers, e-mail, texting, instant messaging, etc.
The obverse is the lonely old woman, surrounded by only the few people with whom she interacts and agrees, deciding that everything electronic is evil, and that the hordes of people who have forsaken real human contact for a technology driven life portend the death of intelligence.  These are both caricatures.  Few people spend their days and nights tapping away at keyboards, though there are certainly some and they tend to be as dislikable online as they are in real life.  On the other hand, only a fool is so totally dismissive of the future, of the tools that enable us to do things that we could only dream about a generation ago.

Blawgs are very much a by-product of the confluence of technological advancement and good, old fashioned community.  There are no hordes of avid blog readers out there consuming everything written by every fool with a computer.  As any blawger will tell you, readers are both fickle and hard to come by.  The vast majority of blawgers have very few readers, some consisting of no more than immediate family and the occasional Googler who has yet to figure out how to frame a decent search.  When their trees fall in the forest, there’s no one to hear.

There are thousand of blawgs, but only a handful that have any significant readership.  The blawgosphere can be quite harsh, with peer rejection requiring nothing more than the click of a mouse button.  Nasty comment are better than no comments.  At least someone is reading.  But most have the deafening sound of an empty room.  For a variety of reasons, readers have decided that their time is better spent elsewhere.  The blawg will fail of its own accord.

Then there are blawgs of remarkable content, thought and substance.  The Volokh Conspiracy comes immediately to mind, reflecting the best of what the blawgosphere has to offer.  Invariably thought-provoking, informative and challenging, it’s unlikely that any conversation the commenter might have with cronies might approach the value of reading VC for a day or two.  And not surprisingly, that explains why Volokh has tens of thousand of daily readers, most of whom have real lives just like my commenter and still choose to spend a few minutes of their day with a blawg.  Lawyers, just like my commenter but who have chosen not to dismiss an entire genre of communication, see great value in reading a blawg.  They are not all fools.

The facile combination of dismissing the substantive value of the blawgosphere as worthless, the individuals as egocentric blathering idiots crying for attention and the views with which she disagrees as inherently wrong, allows the commenter to smugly wallow in ignorance, confident that she’s not only missing nothing of value, but that her thoughts stand above the fray.  The world is passing her by, and she takes satisfaction in holding firm in her belief that nothing worthwhile has happened since LBJ left office.

Being something of an old codger to many of the young whippersnappers who frequent the blawgosphere, I understand the resistance to change, the reluctance to hop aboard the bandwagon with every new-fangled fad or gizmo.  I’m still uncomfortable with Lexis, believing that researching with a stack of books in front of me means that I’m likely to miss something important.  But it’s just foolish to ignore change, to dismiss it out of sheer ignorance.  I refuse to accept every new development that teeny-boppers find alluring, but I similarly refuse to just ignore it and justify my ignorance by calling it all stupid. 

An old fool is worse than a young fool.  Better not to be a fool at all.  There will always be people who reject that the world around them is changing, and that some of the change is useful, valuable and for the better.  They don’t have to agree with all of it, or like any of it, but to deny it is just plain foolish.