Let’s call it what it is. It’s a knife. It is not, as has been widely reported, a “camping utensil.” Sure, it has a fork and spoon, because that’s what’s connected to the knife. It’s like the beloved Swiss Army Knife, It may even have a toothpick and scissors for all I know. But it is, at its heart, a knife. Just ask anybody who gets stabbed with it.
And so what?
Zachary Christie is only 6 years old, and he’s got a knife. He was so excited about his new knife, part of his paraphernalia of membership in the paramilitary organization, Cub Scouts, that he wanted to show it off. The Christina School District had a problem with this. Do you blame them? Does the fact that the knife happens to come with a fork and spoon make the knife less of a knife? If your kid came home and told you that they want a really cool knife like Zach’s, would you be on the phone to the principal in about 12 seconds? I would.
The New York Times has an editorial about this today, and they too refuse to call it what it is.
Consider the case of Zachary Christie, the 6-year-old Cub Scout from Newark, Del., who has been ordered to spend 45 days in a disciplinary school after bringing his nifty camping utensil to school to use to eat his lunch. The classic, foldable tool contains a fork and a spoon — and also a small knife, which violates the zero-tolerance weapons policy issued by the Christina public school system, Delaware’s largest.
Problems abound with the telling of this story, as there is no question that Zachary’s mother should never have allowed him to bring a knife to school. Never. It’s stupid, It’s dangerous and it should be against the rules. I can see cute little Zach whipping the blade around a bit to show it off to his friends, and somebody getting accidentally cut. It’s just not much of stretch. In fact, I wonder whether a 6 year old is ready for a camping knife at all. I waited until 10 to give mine his first Swiss Army knife. The Buck knife came at 12.
The trivialization of what was wrong with Zachary’s, and his mother’s, choice undermines the real culprit in this story. No, it’s not the school district per se, and their ridiculous punishment of 45 days in a disciplinary school. It’s rather curious that they have disciplinary schools for 6 year olds. Are these just for the really tough 6 year olds?
The problem here is our old buddy, zero tolerance policies. What’s astounding is how many people absolutely love zero tolerance in the abstract, and hate it in actual application. The same people who insist that by removing the arbitrariness of designing solutions based upon the specifics of the situation, by making intractable the certainty of harsh punishment, we can fix all problems, are the same people who demand to know what happened to common sense.
Which is it people? You demand mandatory minimums, three strikes, all the simplistic solutions that seem to be the silver bullet for society’s problems, and then can’t believe that anybody actually follows through with them.
The district’s 80-page code of conduct is, of course, beyond the understanding of a 6-year-old. And wouldn’t everyone have been better off if someone at Zachary’s school had used the opportunity to explain to this child why he should leave his cool camping utensil at home from now on? Administrators said the local code of conduct left them no choice. But now he is holed up at home — his mother is teaching him while his family challenges the district’s ruling — worrying about how his friends will treat him once he returns to school.
What happened in the Christina School District should not be minimized by pretending a knife isn’t a knife. It’s a knife, and if somebody was hurt, you can bet your bottom dollar that all hell would have broken loose. So don’t chalk the problem up to a nifty camping utensil, when the problem here is the combination of a boneheaded decision by Zachary’s mother to allow him to bring this knife to school, coupled by an even more boneheaded decision to remove the authority to handle incidents with appropriate and relative discretion, and to craft ways to address the situation that are both useful and positive.
But we are so taken by solutions that are clear, swift and absolute. Is this what you had in mind?
Update: In the face of apparent widespread public criticism, the School District has relented on the punishment, allowing Zachary to return to school, promising to rewrite the rules to exempt kindergartners and first graders from the harsh punishment.
The school board passed an amendment creating a separate category of rules for students in kindergarten and first grade.While this addresses the issue for one child, the school board has clearly misinterpreted the message. The problem isn’t that it’s punishment was too harsh, but that it’s zero tolerance rule was inherently absurd in its failure to recognize the particulars of the situation. But hey, who doesn’t love zero tolerance. And it’s only a 3 to 5 days suspension for a kindergartner, right? Now if only we can place them on the violent child predator registry.
If these students engage in what is known as a Level III offense for the first time, they will now face three to five days out-of-school suspension and referral to school-based counseling, rather than being sent to the local reform school, as is now the case.
