Author Archives: SHG

Schools Have Rules, Cub Scout Edition (Update)

Let’s call it what it is.  It’s a knife.  It is not, as has been widely reported, a “camping utensil.”  Sure, it has a fork and spoon, because that’s what’s connected to the knife. It’s like the beloved Swiss Army Knife, It may even have a toothpick and scissors for all I know. But it is, at its heart, a knife.  Just ask anybody who gets stabbed with it.

And so what?

Zachary Christie is only 6 years old, and he’s got a knife.  He was so excited about his new knife, part of his paraphernalia of membership in the paramilitary organization, Cub Scouts, that he wanted to show it off.  The Christina School District had a problem with this.  Do you blame them?  Does the fact that the knife happens to come with a fork and spoon make the knife less of a knife?  If your kid came home and told you that they want a really cool knife like Zach’s, would you be on the phone to the principal in about 12 seconds?  I would.

The New York Times has an editorial about this today, and they too refuse to call it what it is.


Consider the case of Zachary Christie, the 6-year-old Cub Scout from Newark, Del., who has been ordered to spend 45 days in a disciplinary school after bringing his nifty camping utensil to school to use to eat his lunch. The classic, foldable tool contains a fork and a spoon — and also a small knife, which violates the zero-tolerance weapons policy issued by the Christina public school system, Delaware’s largest.

“Nifty camping utensil?”  Have you ever read a story about a stabbing committed with a nifty camping utensil?  And notice how it’s just a “small knife,” as in the perfect length to accidentally pierce the heart of a 6 year old.  By playing word games, the Times trivializes two significant issues.

Problems abound with the telling of this story, as there is no question that Zachary’s mother should never have allowed him to bring a knife to school.  Never.  It’s stupid, It’s dangerous and it should be against the rules.  I can see cute little Zach whipping the blade around a bit to show it off to his friends, and somebody getting accidentally cut.  It’s just not much of stretch.  In fact, I wonder whether a 6 year old is ready for a camping knife at all.  I waited until 10 to give mine his first Swiss Army knife. The Buck knife came at 12.

The trivialization of what was wrong with Zachary’s, and his mother’s, choice undermines the real culprit in this story.  No, it’s not the school district per se, and their ridiculous punishment of 45 days in a disciplinary school.  It’s rather curious that they have disciplinary schools for 6 year olds.  Are these just for the really tough 6 year olds?

The problem here is our old buddy, zero tolerance policies.  What’s astounding is how many people absolutely love zero tolerance in the abstract, and hate it in actual application.  The same people who insist that by removing the arbitrariness of designing solutions based upon the specifics of the situation, by making intractable the certainty of harsh punishment, we can fix all problems, are the same people who demand to know what happened to common sense. 

Which is it people?  You demand mandatory minimums, three strikes, all the simplistic solutions that seem to be the silver bullet for society’s problems, and then can’t believe that anybody actually follows through with them. 


The district’s 80-page code of conduct is, of course, beyond the understanding of a 6-year-old. And wouldn’t everyone have been better off if someone at Zachary’s school had used the opportunity to explain to this child why he should leave his cool camping utensil at home from now on? Administrators said the local code of conduct left them no choice. But now he is holed up at home — his mother is teaching him while his family challenges the district’s ruling — worrying about how his friends will treat him once he returns to school.

The “code of conduct” is drafted by school boards at the insistence of the community, which expects it to address the various potential harms that could happen in a school.  Nobody wants another Columbine.  And sitting in a meeting, it certainly seems prudent to conclude that no weapon in school should be tolerated.  Had someone at the time suggested that the Zachary Christie scenario would arise, they would have been ridiculed.  And yet anomalous situations arise all the time.  That’s how life plays out.

What happened in the Christina School District should not be minimized by pretending a knife isn’t a knife.  It’s a knife, and if somebody was hurt, you can bet your bottom dollar that all hell would have broken loose.  So don’t chalk the problem up to a nifty camping utensil, when the problem here is the combination of a boneheaded decision by Zachary’s mother to allow him to bring this knife to school, coupled by an even more boneheaded decision to remove the authority to handle incidents with appropriate and relative discretion, and to craft ways to address the situation that are both useful and positive. 

But we are so taken by solutions that are clear, swift and absolute.  Is this what you had in mind?

Update:  In the face of apparent widespread public criticism, the School District has relented on the punishment, allowing Zachary to return to school, promising to rewrite the rules to exempt kindergartners and first graders from the harsh punishment.



The school board passed an amendment creating a separate category of rules for students in kindergarten and first grade.

If these students engage in what is known as a Level III offense for the first time, they will now face three to five days out-of-school suspension and referral to school-based counseling, rather than being sent to the local reform school, as is now the case.
While this addresses the issue for one child, the school board has clearly misinterpreted the message.  The problem isn’t that it’s punishment was too harsh, but that it’s zero tolerance rule was inherently absurd in its failure to recognize the particulars of the situation. But hey, who doesn’t love zero tolerance.  And it’s only a 3 to 5 days suspension for a kindergartner, right?  Now if only we can place them on the violent child predator registry.

A Little Dab Will Do Ya

In New York, it takes a so ordered subpoena and a good tasing to get a DNA swab.  Not so in Indiana, where the Court of Appeals in Garcia-Torres v. State, where the court demonstrated the ease with which they can remember the rubric and forget the rationale.  

Via Orin Kerr at Volokh :


After comparing cheek swabs with other searches requiring only reasonable suspicion, we conclude that the DNA sample collection technique at issue here, although minimally invasive, is also one of those limited searches that requires only reasonable suspicion and may therefore be conducted without a warrant. If anything, the cheek swab involves much less impact on the subject than some other searches that all agree may be conducted based on mere reasonable suspicion. As the United States Supreme Court has observed, “[e]ven a limited search of the outer clothing for weapons constitutes a severe, though brief, intrusion upon cherished personal security, and it must surely be an annoying, frightening, and perhaps humiliating experience.” Terry, 392 U.S. at 24-25. And yet, it is universally understood that such a pat-down may be conducted upon reasonable suspicion.
Notice anything missing from this analysis?  That’s right.  The pat down, or frisk, is permissible primarily because of the issue of safety for police officers,  Notice how the court forgot all about that part?  If the officers have a reasonable suspicion that a person may be armed, they are allowed a cursory pat down to make sure that there are no weapons because, in the balancing of rights and interests, the minimal intrusion is worth the protection a pat down offers cops.

But the Indiana Court of Appeals discarded the fundamental rationale for a pat down, and instead only remembered the minimal intrusion part.  This is a prime example of the slippery slope at work.

Taking a suspect’s DNA is not merely intrusive, without even getting into the deeper discussion of the amount of private information involved, but purely an evidentiary search.  There’s no exigency implicated, as it’s highly unlikely that the suspect’s DNA is going anywhere.  There’s no threat to the officer, aside from the potential that the suspect may spit at him, and taking DNA won’t stop a suspect inclined to do so.  The Indiana court simply decided to make it easier for police, at will, to seize DNA from a person without a warrant, or even probable cause.  It simply chose to make it easier.

There is no per se exception to the Fourth Amendment allowing searches that the court deems “minimally intrusive.”  Mind you, “minimally” is a relative term to begin with, such that it requires something like a frisk to compare it with in order to reach the conclusion that it’s not much worse.  That’s how the constitutional rights fall into the toilet, in baby steps.  Each new step is just minimally more intrusive than the one before it, pushing the envelope just a little bit further, a little bit more intrusive, until they’re allowed to shove a catheter up a man’s penis to collect evidence when the magic black box doesn’t give them what they seek.

Many argue that these “technicalities” make it too difficult, if not impossible, to gather the evidence necessary to ascertain and prosecute criminals.  Since crimes are bad, and they are, these rights unduly inhibit law enforcement from achieving their societally beneficial goal of protecting us from criminals.  Guys like me, harping on constitutional rights all the time as I do, are just obstructionists trying to make the police officers’ job too difficult.

All too true.  Adherence to the Constitution does indeed put a substantial burden on law enforcement to play by the rules.  It would be far easier to clean up crime if police would just be allowed to do whatever they please without the interference of having to obtain judicial approval before they search our bodies for evidence to be used against us.  Probable cause is a long way from basic suspicion, the measure that most cops use to justify a search (if they were being truthful about it) and assuming they weren’t doing it just to hassle the person or teach them who’s boss.

But this is a political choice.  If one prefers the authority of police to do their job, and wishes to facilitate the collection of evidence despite the limitations of the Constitution, that’s one thing. But it finds no justification in the caselaw, logic or the extension of the reasoning from a frisk to a DNA swab.  The Indiana Court of Appeals’ decision in Garcia-Torres is sheer nonsense, and merely serves to demonstrate why we need to be ever-vigilant of the rubric without the rationale.

Orin suggests that this decision will be heading for the Supreme Court.  God help us.

The Meaning of Referral

The Texas Tornado, Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett, touched on a sore subject with me in his post about a referral.  Bennett was asked for a divorce referral out of town. He had no one in hand, so he reached out to a friend, who gave him another friend, etc.  He called the ultimate referral, who “passed the telephonic smell test.”  So he gave the name to the client.


The faraway lawyer dropped the ball. Hard. Not in a “things could have turned out better” way, but in a less forgivable “didn’t even show up” way. If I were a sports  fan, I would surely have some clever simile for how egregious his ball-dropping was. But I’m not a sports fan, so I’ll just say to say that if I dropped the ball that hard, I’d be giving the client the bulk of his fee back to make it up to him.
Maybe even more than the bulk?  Divorce is, in my opinion, the most difficult referral to make. Clients are constantly seeking referrals for divorce, primarily because so many need a divorced, and don’t know where to turn.  It’s a nasty business, and of the various practice areas, divorce law is possibly the one that inflicts the most damage on the litigants.  Just get one party riled up and it’s pretty much a lock that whatever assets they’re fighting over will end up in the lawyers’ pockets. Before you know it, the parties have run dry and the lawyers lose interest.

When I refer someone to a lawyer, it’s a personal endorsement.  I am saying to that person that I vouch for the competency and ethics of the person whose name I give them.  It means something to me, and I feel responsible.

Sure, I’m not my brother’s keeper and can’t do the other lawyer’s work myself.  Sometimes things to wrong. Sometimes things just don’t work out well, or the fit isn’t there.  But I cannot, and do not, send clients to just a name.  Names are easy to come by. I can get you a name pretty much anywhere, but getting a name means nothing. 

Contrary to my brethren who assert that cute and interesting twits are a fine basis for the construction of a referral network, I will never refer a matter to someone on the basis of their twits. I may like them very much, and enjoying twitting back and forth with them all day long, but they aren’t getting a case from me based on twits alone.  I would require far, far more to have the requisite faith to entrust them with a client. 

The flip side of the problem is that clients will react, when I respond to their request that I have no name to give, by asking me to just find someone since they have no one at all and desperately need legal help.  I hate it when they do this.  I will then make some calls to someone local who bears some reasonable facsimile of competence in their field for the names of a few lawyers who practice in the specific area needed.  I will not call a divorce lawyer, if that’s what I’m looking for, but maybe a PI lawyer, and ask about divorce lawyers. My purpose is to get information from someone who has no horse in the race, and hope that she will give me an honest appraisal of the local talent.  And hope that my PI lawyer isn’t some loser with a destitute cousin who does divorces.

My calling the lawyers, before having the client call, is usually a better way of initially vetting them.  There are questions I will ask, an impression I will get, that is usually more valid a predictor of competence than a client will receive.  More importantly, I can reach the lawyers swiftly, as they will take or return my call right away, when clients might get brushed off.  The lawyer’s communication, of course, is one of the critical aspects of my determining whether this is a lawyer to whom I would refer. 

I will then go back to the client and give him the names of the lawyers who are still in the running, with the caveat that I don’t really know them, can’t vouch for them, and have no idea whether they are great lawyers or just have good phone manners.  Talking a good game on the phone isn’t a substitute for competent lawyering, any more than giving good twits is demonstrative proof of being a lawyer to whom you should refer cases.

For those lawyers who I’ve come to know and trust, I will refer matters without hesitation.  I know that I’ve put my clients in good hands.  But going beyond trusted lawyers scares me to death, and I hate becoming embroiled in such referrals.  I try my best to keep out of the mix, even though clients will press me for someone.  It takes an inordinate amount of time to find a lawyer, and there’s usually nothing in it for me except the knowledge that I’ve tried to keep a client from crashing on the rocks.  For me, a referral is personal.  Don’t blow it.  Don’t embarrass me.  Don’t harm my client. 

Juror Duty

Up to now, stories of jurors Twitting, Facebooking or Googling tend to be about the process, the use of technology to do what they were never supposed to do.  This time was different.  From the Concord Monitor via Anne Reed :


The juror who derailed a sexual assault trial in March by telling jurors the defendant was a convicted child molester agreed yesterday to reimburse the court nearly $1,200 for his misconduct.

Paul Christiansen of Danbury revealed Timothy Townsend’s prior conviction during the second day of deliberations on new child sexual assault charges, according to court records. He said afterward that he had no regrets because he believed jurors need to know about Townsend’s past.

The revelation forced a mistrial, and now the Merrimack County Attorney’s Office has to retry Townsend and again put the 9-year-old alleged victim on the stand.
No regrets.  Christiansen found out (as if it was hard to do) about the defendant’s prior, and he decided, Paul Christiansen decided, that the rest of the jury needed to know about it.  Not only does it tell what jurors think of propensity evidence, but that the entirety of the law is subject to the personal revision of one juror’s sensibilities.  Christiansen decided, and that was that.

The penalty was $1,200, to cover the cost for the jurors after the scuttled trial.  This neither beings to cover the cost, nor even recognizes that the cost of the jury stipend is the least of the price for his conduct.  There’s the testimony of a 9 year old, who is now forced to take the stand.  There is the trauma to the defendant, who has lost the rest of his seated jury as well as the toll of starting trial anew. The defense lawyer. The prosecutor. The judge and court staff. Everything lost, and not even considered worthy of inclusion in the penalty.

This was not an innocent juror.  Not only did he violate the instructions and go looking, but he decided, after he found what he felt was overwhelmingly important information of the defendant’s history, that it was up to him to spread the news.  It’s all up to him, everything else happening in that courtroom be damned.

Innocuous twits about the trial may make for interesting fodder for blog posts and technology lovers, but this was real.  And as information becomes increasingly available online, and as use of tech becomes increasingly ubiquitous (if it isn’t already), this is the future we have to deal with.  As jurors becomes this actively involved in the process, initiating investigations on their own and then acting upon their discovery, it compels the imposition of some sanction for the havoc they wreak. 

Nobody really wants to go after jurors. It’s hard enough to get normal people to come out and serve.  But if this is going to happen, then something needs to be done to stop it, and deter others from spending their evenings checking the sex offender registries, just for fun.  The $1,200 cost doesn’t appear to be adequate to have made Christiansen wish that he didn’t do it.  And certainly won’t compensate everyone else involved.

Anybody know how to stuff the genie back in the bottle?  Anybody know how to make jurors not decide to remake the law to suit whatever strikes them as a good idea?  And the next time a judge makes light of the significance of propensity evidence, remind her of this case, where the juror just couldn’t control himself given how critical the criminal history seemed to him.

Just a Matter of Trust

The stories of failings of experts are legion, but some are so ordinary, and thus pervasive, that they rock the foundation of criminal law.  Such is the story of Dee Wallace, via Paul Kennedy.


Dee Wallace, the disgraced breath test machine technical supervisor, who filed fake maintenance records on the Intoxilyzers under her watch, was sentenced to a year in prison yesterday. It is estimated that some 4,000 DWI convictions in Harris and Galveston counties could be affected by Ms. Wallace’s deceit.

While there may be some solace in the fact that Ms. Wallace is reaping her just rewards, those who were victimized by her lies must go through the process of filing writs and obtaining court orders to recover the money they spent on fines, court costs, probation fees and surcharges.
We take for granted some degree of baseline integrity in the legal system. Dee Wallace takes it away.  Nobody watches the watchers, the few who are entrusted to be responsible for the honest working of the backroom systems upon which everything else relies. Who would believe that this could happen.  It’s so basic.

It would be far too much to ask that the big time areas of expertise, ranging from autopsies to DNA, are handled by their respective professionals with the utmost integrity.  What of the little, taken-for-granted areas of expertise, like breathalyzers and drug testing?  What if the numbers were all a big scam, a big joke, and they were just making them up right and left?

No judge in his right mind would start from scratch on examining the true competencies of experts, straight down the line, or the actual validity of tests themselves, or the machines that magically convict on the government’s behalf.  That would take forever, and we all know that it’s accurate and valid.  The judge would be furious for our wasting his time, and wouldn’t let us do it anyway. We would be foolish to even suggest such lunacy.

Except for the fact that there is a Dee Wallace in the world.  And she isn’t the only one of her kind.

An isolated incident?  4,000 isolated incidents?  Part of a culture that takes such ordinary failings for granted, or worse still, thinks they are doing society a favor by making it easier to put bad guys in jail?  And yet, the experts will take the stand on Monday and testify with self-righteous certainty that we have no choice but to trust them.  And judges, and juries, will do exactly that. 

Say Who?

As someone who has blawged for a while, I get quite a few press releases about conferences being held around the country in the hope that I might mention, maybe even promote, the conference.  Sometimes, I’m invited to attend as a member of the media, and am provided with the promotional packet, replete with all the really critical information that makes one desperately want to be there.

My first interest in a conference, if there’s any interest at all, is to see who’s presenting.  Much like CLEs, the value, if any, is in the quality of the presenters, much more so than the topic at hand.  No matter how fascinating the subject of the conference, the speakers make it or break it.

More often than not, I end up laughing when I read the list of speakers.  It’s not that I don’t appreciate that the people who are speaking are busily trying to promote themselves or their agenda, actively seeking out speaking opportunities and willing to fly anywhere for forty minutes in front of an audience.  I applaud their pluck. It’s definitely in their self-interest to be on the podium rather than the audience if they want to create a higher profile for themselves and their interests.

But it’s goofy.  More often than not, the speakers have nothing to offer.  They are wannabes, devoid of substance and hiding behind crafted personas.  They don’t realize that they have nothing substantive to offer, six month experts as they are, and feel no shame in standing up before an audience of accomplished people as if they have knowledge to impart.  I doubt they realize that they just don’t know a whole lot. I bet they believe they do.

I do, however, fault the people who are putting these conferences together. Do they not give any thought to the people they ask/allow to speak?  Is it just that these are the people who are desperately seeking the podium?  That these are the people who will to show up for free, no travel costs required?

Here’s the question: What were you doing six months ago?  If you are appearing as an expert based upon your being a lawyer, did you ever practice law?  For, like, a year or more?

There was once a time when one would not agree to speak before a group of any substance because it would have the potential for personal humiliation.  One did not feign expertise in front of a group of people who would immediately recognize you to be unqualified to teach them anything.  This is no longer the case.  People are no longer concerned at all about being exposed as frauds, and will happily expose themselves to ridicule for the chance to stand onstage.

Since these self-promoting speakers will no longer show any self-control, it’s left to the conference promoter to put in minimal due diligence to determine whether the names on the list are worthy.  This isn’t happening much these days either.

As I initially wrote this post, I was going to name names, both of speakers and conferences.  One, out in California, was so facially laughable that I thought it was a spoof at first, and told the promoter’s flack as much. His response made clear that it was no joke.  After some reflection, I’ve decided not to do any damage to the people who have gotten the speaking gigs, though I do not believe they are close to having qualifications to take the stage or are appropriate representatives of lawyers, legal thought, legal ethics, and the variety of other subtopics that will be uttered during their presentation.  But my purpose here isn’t to hurt any particular person who is trying to create an existence as an “expert”.  If people are foolish enough to sign them up to speak, then they’ve gotten what they asked for. 

They may well be dangerous speaking, giving non-lawyers the horrible misimpression that they reflect what lawyers think and believe, and they don’t.  They wouldn’t have a clue what real lawyers think, but they will never admit this truth to the audience because it would reveal them as frauds.

This phenomenon, the unqualified speaker, has become increasingly pervasive, and increasingly problematic.  It’s not that it turns conferences into jokes, but that it misleads attendees into thinking that these speakers are what they purport to be.  If the speakers won’t recognize their limitations, and the conference promoters don’t care whether their speakers have any qualifications, and attendees still come to hear people that have nothing worthwhile to offer, then we will be left with worthless conferences selling meaningless crap to wastrel attendees.  A total waste all around.

A Million Reasonable Suspicions

It’s doesn’t take much. A suspicious glance. A furtive movement. Maybe nothing more than being a kid where a kid doesn’t seem to belong. And certainly being black where a black doesn’t belong. And they’re proud of it.

The broad statement is that over a million people are stopped by police.  Many are frisked. About 10% are arrested. That’s a failure rate of 90%, by almost any empirical metric a disaster of monumental proportions.  But cops don’t care about empiricism. They prefer the visceral route, that they are making us safer.



The New York Police Department is among the most vocal defenders of the practice. Commissioner Raymond Kelly said recently that officers may stop as many as 600,000 people this year. About 10 percent are arrested.

“This is a proven law enforcement tactic to fight and deter crime, one that is authorized by criminal procedure law,” he said.
Proven indeed.  Overshoot your authority by 900,000 people are you’re bound to catch a few criminals.  Isn’t it worth it?  Aren’t we prepared to sacrifice a few minutes of our time, and sneak peak into our personal possessions, if it catches even one heinous criminal?  After all, do we want another 9/11?

That it’s claimed to be authorized by law is both a truth and a lie.  The law requires mere “reasonable suspicion,” a phrase so fundamentally convenient and meaningless as to make it sound, to the ordinary citizen, perfectly “reasonable” while handing police a free hand in stopping anyone they want at will.  Resort to such amorphous phrases is a judicial cop out, a failure to come up with a rule that can be both uniformly applied and generally understood.  But this also assumes that the courts really care to come up with such a rule, since it is always in their power to reject such meaningless phrases if they so decide. They don’t.

And then there’s the 90% problem.  Courts never deal with the 90% who aren’t arrested, the people who gave a cop a dirty look, or maybe no look at all, and were stopped and frisked anyway.  If nothing was found, and the cop was in a sufficiently good mood that he elected not to arrest for such offenses as obstruction of governmental administration, the stop simply disappears as if it never happened.  Sure, it’s included in the statistics, but there’s no person complaining to a court about being forced to succumb to police will for no good reason.  Or for being the type or color of person that cops just tend to stop.

There’s no club for them to join.  There’s no lawsuit to be had, to gain vast riches from the police having baselessly seized them for nothing.  Their stories are never told.  Judges, filled with the importance of getting criminals off the streets, embolden the police use of these tactics by nodding and winking at the silliest of explanations for street stops.  The same excuses appear over and over, even using the same unusual words like “furtive”, and judges always believe that it must be true.  Why would cops just stop an innocent citizen walking down the street if he didn’t have a good reason to do so?  That would never happen.  Never.

It’s an epidemic.  Yet no one is trying to find a cure, or even a vaccine. 

From the police perspective, there is nothing wrong with these numbers. You have to break a few eggs to make an omelet, which is fine unless you either happen to be one of those eggs or care about how many eggs are broken for nothing.  By that theory, of course, our police would be remarkably effective if they could just stop and frisk anyone they want to at will, without even the pretense of having to mouth the words of “reasonable suspicion.” Better still, who knows what they would find if they could just search whenever they felt the need.  Imagine how safe we would be, from everybody except the cops.

H/T Rick “Write What I Want You To Write, Dammit” Horowitz

Schools Have Rules, Learning Disabled Edition

Interactions between learning disabled children and the police have proven terribly problematic, largely due to the fact that police lack the training to identify an LD child as well as how to address a situation involving an LD child.  The police resort to their standard operating procedure, with stupid and often tragic results.  The same is often true of others with disabilities, but this post addresses the specifics of the learning disabled child, the most vulnerable victim.

But to the limited extent it’s understandable when an officer from the outside comes in to deal with the LD child, there is absolutely no excuse when it happens in a school for learning disabled children by a police officer assigned to work within that school, as happened in Dolton, Illinois.


The purported cause for this violent assault was that the student had his shirt tail out, a violation of school rules.  It’s unfathomable that this violation, perhaps real despite its trivial nature, was the cause of this attack.  Rather, it appears to be the far more mundane, and commonplace, failure to immediately respect the cop’s authority that enraged the officer.  Still, the school must be cognizant of the noxious mixture of its rules and a violent cop in its hallway.

Why it was necessary to have a police officer in the hallway of this school is unexplained.  Was he there to prevent violence between students?  Protect the staff from children with behavioral issues?  Was there a drug or theft problem that compelled his presence?  It’s unclear.  But what is brutally clear is that the officer, this particular cop, should never have been allowed anywhere near this school and these children.  His conduct was criminal, and his victim was someone he knew to be a learning disabled child.  This was nothing more than a vicious attack.

In looking back at my own posts on the subject of special needs kids being harmed, arrested, assaulted, not to mention others with disabilities, it becomes extremely clear that they are particularly vulnerable to harm at the hands of police.  What distinguished this incident is that the cop wasn’t random, but was assigned to work within a school for learning disabled children.  He was chosen to be there. 

While all police officers need training in the identification and handling of people with disabilities, it is inexcusable that an officer selected to work within an LD school was specially screened for this service and then given extensive training in dealing with LD children.  It’s unfathomable that they would pluck a cop off the street, with the authority and control issues that tend to characterize bad cops, and place him in a situation where he could do such great harm.  It would be even worse if they selected this officer because he possessed the characteristics they believe appropriate to serve at this school.

While it goes without saying that no one, no child, no disabled person, no one should be the victim of this type of brutal attack, it is inconceivable that our most vulnerable children are the victims.  There is no excuse for this happening.  Ever.

Because It’s A Cross II

If it’s wrong to have a large cross on Sunrise Rock in the Mojave National Preserve, then it must similarly be wrong for a prosecutor to wear a cross, proportionately smaller, around her neck while trying a case before a jury.  Not necessarily.  Via Eugene Volokh, the issue arose in a California case, People v. Morris, where the defendant challenged a small silver cross worn by the prosecutor as crossing the line.


Morris claims the trial court deprived him of a fair trial by allowing the prosecutor to wear the cross. Although in a hypothetical case the constitutional issues could be grave, we conclude that on the record before us Morris’s right to a fair trial has not been compromised. Nor do we find on these facts a violation of the establishment clause of the United States Constitution….

The court quickly distinguished the clerical collar cases, noting that it was the conferral of authority and ascription of credibility that came with the collar that made it improper.  On the other side, the court distinguished cases involving public employees in not prosecutorial roles, where their free speech rights weren’t balanced against a defendant’s right to a fair trial.


We agree with defendant that the Constitution preserves the religious neutrality of the courtroom and it may be necessary to restrict some exercise of the First Amendment to avoid violating the establishment clause. We also believe that because the prosecutor is, in the eyes of the jurors, the personification of the state, we must be particularly sensitive to a defendant’s claim that any religious adornments have the potential to cross the fuzzy line between the free exercise and establishment clauses of the First Amendment.

To its credit, the court recognized that the claim warranted constitutional scrutiny.  It could easily have just sloughed off the argument as frivolous, or simply ignored it as unworthy of the court’s attention.  It didn’t.  But the court ruled:



[The trial judge] found that the cross was small in size and barely noticeable. She believed any message the cross might convey was ambiguous, as the slender silver cross could be construed equally as a fashion statement or as a religious symbol. Morris does not contest the factual findings of the trial court.

As a result, we do not believe the prosecutor’s small cross compromised the fairness of the trial in this case, and we are unwilling to restrict a lawyer’s First Amendment right to wear a small piece of jewelry the trial judge barely noticed and found unlikely to influence anyone who might have seen it….
The upshot is that the propriety of the prosecutor wearing a cross was dependent upon it being “small in size and barely noticeable,” suggesting that a larger cross, or a gaudier one, would have cause a different result, and that its message was ambiguous, that it could have been construed as a fashion statement.  Rather than draw a doctrinal distinction between an individual wearing a symbol of personal faith, the court chose to nibble at the edges.

A subtle but hugely significant distinction in the application of the Establishment Clause is that a line can be drawn between actions attributable to the government, as a secular institution, and the individuals who make up the government, whether by election to office or employment in a governmental function.  By dint of serving the government, no one is expected to abdicate their faith, virtue and personal morality. Indeed, these are the qualities that draw us to many of the people we elect, for better or worse. 

We understand that the religious faith of each individual person who fulfills a governmental function is a personal reflection, however, and not one ascribed to the government.  We have people of all faiths, and no faith, working in governmental roles, and we recognize that there is no religious litmus test for service to a governmental entity.  To the extent they wear a cross, or a star, or any other religious symbol, it’s a personal reflection and nothing more.

The people who make up our government, as opposed to the government itself as a secular institution, retain their personal right to believe as they wish, and express their personal belief to the extent is doesn’t alter or impact the performance of their secular responsibility.  The question, then, becomes whether by wearing a cross, does a prosecutor convey a message to a jury that her faith would preclude her from prosecuting an individual who was not guilty, thus putting the weight of her religious beliefs behind her prosecutorial stance, and give the jury a religious reason to side with the prosecution.  If so, then this expression of faith interferes with her ability to perform her governmental function.

So is a cross just a piece of jewelry, of ambiguous significance?  That’s ridiculous. Granted, some people wear a cross as a fashion statement of sorts, but to leap to the Madonna Louise Ciccone exception strains reason.  The vast majority of cross wearers do so for the plain and obvious reason: to signify that they are Christian.  It’s nonsensical to rule based on the particularly small tail than the very large dog.  And it’s because the dog is so large that it’s also unnecessary.

Many individuals wear symbols of their religion or faith around their neck.  We see it all the time, interacting with these people, dealing with these people, relying on these people. We know these people.  And we know that the mere fact that they have a religious symbol hanging around their neck doesn’t mean that they are any more Godly than anyone else. 

Our experience allows us to not be blinded by the wearing of a cross to jump to the assumption that they adhere to the tenets of their religion any more or less than anyone else.  Indeed, defendants commonly wear crosses, and carry bibles, when they are on trial, and yet they still get convicted.  We know that the mere wearing of a cross isn’t a substitute for conducting ones life in accordance with religious teachings or tenets.  We know better.

Whether the cross is large or small, simple or showing, is more a fashion statement than a indicia of the depth of belief or the noticeability of its significance.  I’ve seen many a religious symbol on an alleged drug dealer that can been seen from half a mile away, and it has yet to demonstrate their salvation to the jury’s satisfaction.  If anything, it’s proof that they have far more money than taste, and is rarely a good thing for someone accused of drug dealing.

By wearing a cross, the prosecutor in Morris did nothing more than express her personal connection of some greater or lesser degree to a religion.  It offered no suggestion that her performance of her prosecutorial function was endorsed by God or imbued her with some priest-like adherence to the tenets of her religion.  Ironically, because of the number of Christian faiths, it might well have served to prejudice her in the eyes of other Christians, who ascribe the wearing of a cross to Roman Catholicism, for those who find certain Christian faiths troubling because of conflicts with their own Christian beliefs.

The doctrinal line between establishment by the government and individual expression shouldn’t be based on such spurious factors as size and gaudiness.  While the Morris court was correct in its result, it took the path of least resistance to get there. rather than confront the larger issue of where to draw the Establishment Clause line.

Creepy Indeed

David Letterman’s sex life is something I wish not to think about.  It isn’t fascinating to me. It’s not even mildly interesting. It is, as he said himself, creepy.

Gerald Shargel’s public defense of Robert (Joe) Halderman by taking to the airwaves, on the other hand, is mildly interesting.  From the Los Angeles Times :


Shargel declined to go into details about his client’s actions, saying he was still gathering information about the case, but said it did not make sense that Halderman would try to pull off such a crime. He noted repeatedly that he had never heard of an extortion attempt in which someone asks for a check.

“Joe Halderman was at CBS for 27 years,” he told Roberts. “Here’s a guy who was an investigative journalist for so many years. He knows all about cops and wiretaps. And to suggest that he was trapped in an extortion plot is sort of preposterous.”

“I’m not saying he didn’t take the check,” Shargel told Maggie Rodriguez on CBS’ “The Early Show.” “But the question at the end of the day is, what was his intent? One of the things that the prosecution has to prove beyond a reasonable doubt, one of the elements of the offense, is that Joe Halderman had specific criminal intent. And I say to you and to the public that we shouldn’t rush to judgment, because I think, at the end of the day, when the case is tried and after the cross-examination of David Letterman and the full story comes out, I’m confident that a jury will not find that specific criminal intent.”
Shargel did all the morning shows, and there’s a ton of video around saying pretty much the same thing.  Why would he do this?  Clearly, Halderman was getting skewered in the media, but that’s bound to happen when you get a $2 million check from Letterman to keep his sex life under wraps.  But if Shargel is going to do the talking head circuit, then he’s got to have something to say that’s going to deflect guilt, or at least change the discussion somewhat to his client’s benefit.  Arguing that his client lacked “specific intent” just doesn’t play well.

Aside from the vague and meaningless suggestion that there is evidence that will come out later, and that he can’t wait to cross-examine Letterman (who could?), the only substantive argument offered is that Halderman, as an “investigative journalist,” would never let himself be trapped in an extortion plot.  It’s “sort of preposterous.”  Got any specific examples, there, Gerry?

This is no argument at all.  Politicians do it all the time. Cops do it in front of dash cams. Journalists are too smart to get caught committing a crime?  Who are you kidding?

It’s not like Shargel did the circuit because he wanted to see his balding pate on the tube.  He does more high profile criminal defenses than any other lawyer in New York.  He could get his face on television whenever he wants.  That being clear, his decision to talk to the cameras must have been in reaction to the overwhelming attention given Letterman and the presumed guilt of his client. But if so, and I can’t imagine any other reason for his flurry of appearances, then he really should have had something better to say.  This was lame, and did nothing to make Halderman look any less guilty.

Perhaps there will be more to the defense when time for trial arises.  But my biggest fear is that this case will actually go to trial, that David Letterman will take the stand and be cross-examined by Gerald Shargel.  Shargel will then cross-examine Letterman about his sex life in excruciating detail.  I don’t think I could stand it.