A few of my fellow blawgers have posted “around the blawgosphere” posts this week, Windy. Lammers. Bennett. It’s a nice thing to do, both to share posts with readers that they might not otherwise see and to give a little link love to one’s friends in the ‘hood. Nothing wrong with being a good friend.
This is what’s been getting me in trouble with some of my friends, and others, in the blawgosphere lately. I’m something of a traitor. There are other blawgs around with whom I regularly interact, and with whom I share a great deal in common. They are my friends in the blawgosphere. I’ve grown to like them personally, respect their views, admire their efforts.
But sometimes, I disagree with something they write. For some of my friends, a healthy disagreement is no big deal. Bennett and I disagree about stuff all the time, and hash it out in public. It’s never affected our friendship, and it’s never taken personally. It’s our nature as trial lawyers, criminal defense lawyers, to take issue with ideas and duke it out.
Others, unfortunately, don’t see it that way. Not at all. It’s not that they can’t tolerate the fact that someone doesn’t agree with their every position, but that a post, a public writing taking issue with their public writing, is taken as a personal attack on them. Friends don’t attack friends. Yesterday we loved each other. Today, I hate you.
This scenario reflects a couple of fundamental flaws in the blawgosphere, and my hope is that by airing the problem, those who I’ve offended in the process will gain a better understanding of what I’m doing and why I’m doing it. Let me start by saying, just because I may not agree with something you’ve written doesn’t mean I think you’re a terrible human being, a blithering idiot or disgusting, ugly and a bad dancer. I just disagree with one of your positions. I think you’re wrong about something. So what? Maybe I’m the one who is wrong. You can disagree with me too, you know.
One such “issue” where I depart from the blawgosphere orthodoxy is work-life balance, a topic of particularly importance to a certain subsets of the blawgosphere. It’s likely that those who push the work-life balance are over-represented online, their being more attuned to technology and, frankly, having more time to promote a cause that suits their desires and comports with their lifestyle.
This creates an illusion of a groundswell of support for the cause. It’s an illusion because the other side is grossly under-represented online, yet predominant in the real world. Consequently, many begin to believe their own press releases, or support the cause that best suits their desires, even though it may be damaging to the profession and to them personally, when they get smacked in the face with the harsh reality that it’s a scam. Wanting to believe in something doesn’t make it so.
I’m asked regularly why I kick sand in the face of my friends in the blawgosphere on this subject. Why, oh why, can’t I just stick to criminal law subjects, stay within the bounds of my niche, and leave the work-life balance crowd alone. On one level, it’s because Simple Justice is a vehicle for things that interest me, whether within the criminal law arena or elsewhere. But on a deeper level, it’s because there is just too much deception going on in the blawgosphere, and few people want to confront it. Indeed, much of it is self-deception.
Someone has to tell the other side of the story. This is particularly true when people surround themselves with the chorus, like-minded wishers who keep pumping a pipe-dream because they really, really want it to come true.
Having been around the law long enough to remember when the challenge was whether lawyers should be allowed to advertise at all, I’ve watched as the professionalism of lawyers deteriorated. Law turned from profession to occupation, from practice to business. For many of my younger brethren at the bar, the concept of professionalism is foreign. Today, we are deluged with marketers and marketing, all whispering in our ear that everybody does it, that it’s the only way to survive, that we all market and that anyone who questions it is a liar or a fool.
The work-life balance agenda is inextricably tied to the marketing cabal, as the former is the feeder that supposedly feeds the coffers of part-time lawyers such that they no longer need to put the client first. I know, they insist that they do put the client first, but through their use of technology, planning, force of will, they somehow manage to do it all and do it better than old timers like me. This, according to the people who are selling their magic secrets, is how one can make millions being a lawyer while being home for dinner at 5. Horse hockey (h/t Jdog).
I’ve grown somewhat intolerant of those who would pursue an agenda that continues to diminish the professionalism of the law. We are not about making millions, though a good income will come from a learned profession as an outgrowth of excellence. We are not about kid lawyers with website touting their “expertise” when they’ve never tried a case. I see rampant lies across the internet, and none of this seems to sufficiently trouble the chorus to either change their evil ways or speak out against the liars.
But the dream of work-life balance, the one where there is no price to pay for leaving the office at 5 and kicking back to play video games in midday, presents as great, if not greater danger, to the professionalism of lawyers as it is primarily designed to appeal to those least capable of understanding the inherent dangers. So many young lawyers, coming out in a troubled economy and raised to believe that they are entitled to every shiny thing they see, willingly buy into this scheme.
These are the kids who put up sham websites to suck in clients who are in true need of help, but who buy the time of people utterly incapable of providing the representation they need, and utterly lacking the desire to fulfill the obligations that once characterized lawyers. The client suffers so the lawyer can make a buck. The lawyer loses his dignity and integrity, but no one in the movement speaks to those issues.
Travel around the blawgosphere and see what interests people, what agendas they are pursuing. It’s disheartening. A wealth of marketing. A dearth of competence. A lack of comprehension that you aren’t a brilliant lawyer because your marketing guru says so. Someone has to be the wet blanket at this beach party bingo, because Moondoggie is going back to his airline pilot job come September and Gidget is going to be left alone on the beach with no one to play with. I am so sorry to be the bearer of bad news. I wish you could all get your way. But this isn’t like your third grade soccer team, where everybody gets to play.
There are clients, real people who suffer real consequences, as a result of the delusions perpetrated on the internet. They come to lawyers believing them to be competent, even expert, and willing and capable of helping them, saving their lives sometimes. And the lawyer’s primary focus is to get paid and be home by dinner, with the client merely the conduit for the transfer of revenue and proof of the mastery of the secret to success. Is any of this getting through?
So I leave my niche in criminal law from time to time to be a voice in the wilderness, that we are not selling laundry detergent, but are lawyers, professionals, in whom p
eople repose their trust. I’ve seen their children cry when their lawyers fail to fulfill their duty. The need to enjoy a happy lawyer life will never wipe away their tears. I know that I’m being a pedantic old fool again as I write these words, but the truth is that, all the fun and sarcasm and humor aside, there is so much human pain belying what we do that this is no joke. It’s just not something to keep us busy between games of Mortal Kombat or junior’s soccer game.
For those whose toes I step on in the process, it’s not because I don’t like you or respect you. It’s just that I disagree with you on this subject, and I believe it to be important and serious. Sorry for the hard feelings I’ve caused, but it’s something that I believe needs to be done.
I hope we can be friends even if we disagree.
by andgarden on Fri Jul 17, 2009 at 12:23:42 AM EST