Author Archives: SHG

Jane, You Ignorant Slut

In a simpler time, many will remember Shana Alexander debating James J. Kilpatrick on 60 Minutes’ “Point-Counterpoint.”  And for those who don’t, there will always be Dan Aykroyd and Jane Curtin’s Saturday Night Live homage, immortalizing the opening salvo, “Jane, you ignorant slut.”  This is, of course, the bar by which all debates have since been measured.

A new website has been developed to host debate on subject of interest in the blawgosphere called Public Square.  It’s mission is:


PublicSquare.net is an independent, non-partisan webzine that aims to encourage stimulating debate on the political, legal, religious, and social issues of the day. We invite today’s leading experts to engage one another in thoughtful, intelligent discussion.
The “leading experts” language may be a bit hyperbolic, as I learned about this site when they invited me to participate in a debate next week.  Still, it alerted me to its existence and gave me cause to take a walk around.  The debate section is called Bloggerheads, and hosted a debate last week between Bridget Crawford of Feminist Law Professors and Darren Rosenblum, a professor at Pace Law School also listed as a feminist law professor.  The topic of debate was the criminalization of indoor prostitution. It fell somewhat short of lawprof mudwrestling.

There is also a forum section, which at the moment consists of a single post by the website administrator.  You have to register to post a comment in the forum.  It appears that they have not yet had a mad rush of people registering.

Starting tomorrow, Paul Lippe will be debating Florida State LawProf J.B. Ruhl on the subject of the future of law school.  I stuck my nose into the debate, which was the apparent source of their interest in my being a third wheel.  Unfortunately, my upcoming week is already booked, and the likelihood of my finding time to play in their sandbox on top of my own was slim. 

I love the idea of head to head debates.  While the mechanics of debating issues across blawgs works fairly well, and allows blawgers to engage each other on their own terms, putting it all in one place has the advantage of allowing readers to go straight throw the action, post by post, without having to switch blawgs.  Of course, it suffers from the awkward positioning problem, where the last post is atop its predecessor, requiring one to scroll down to find the initial post and reading down to up, but that’s the nature of the beast (though it doesn’t have to be if you don’t want it to be, Bloggerheads guys).

However, for this to be worth a second look, it’s got to offer a whole lot more debate than demonstrated in the Crawford/Rosenblum lovefest.  If this is going to turn out to be one of those brutally civil, bordering obtuse, highly-nuanced-type contests that lawprofs are so enamored of, then it should die a swift and painful death.  They aspire to be boring.  If bloggerheads is going to pit lawprof against lawprof, by and large, then I hope they rented the office furniture on a short term lease.

On the other hand, if this is to be a forum for vigorous debate, it may have a chance.  But that means that the participants will need to be willing to write clearly, express their disagreement and positions in forceful terms and, most importantly, reflect opposite point of view.  It means that they can’t blow kisses at one another and spend most of their time expressly their undying love and respect for their opponent.  If you want a debate, then have a debate. 

Whether Bloggerheads has any blogging legs has yet to be seen.  Certainly, the initial infatuation with lawprofs as “leading experts” bodes poorly for getting anyone other than fellow lawprofs to care, and they already have enough of their own blogs to blow kisses at each other. 

Ironically, Public Square announces that it has been set up as a not-for-profit.  I don’t think they have to worry about that, unless they are able to get some robust debate going.  And if they want to get any juices flowing, they would do better to take their lead from Dan Aykroyd.

Hate and Harm

The Senate passed the Matthew Shephard Hate Crimes Prevention Act, a sweeping extension of the 1968 hate crimes law that followed the assassination of Martin Luther King.  From the AP via Talkleft :


The legislation, backed by President Barack Obama, would extend federal protections granted under the 1968 hate crimes law to cover those physically attacked because of their gender, sexual orientation, gender identity or disability.

“This bill simply recognizes that there is a difference between assaulting someone to steal his money, or doing so because he is gay, or disabled, or Latino or Muslim,” Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid said.
This legislation is a barometer of liberal sacred cows, pitting beloved positions against each other and seeing which prevails.  First, there is the concern for the constitutional rights of defendants,  Of course, there is the concern for discrimination on the basis of immutable characteristics.  On top of that, there is the concern for free speech.  Of course, it also implicates concern for expansion of federal crimes.  And finally, there is the concern for the safeguard of alternative lifestyles. 

Over at Talkleft, Jeralyn Merritt has been a strong voice against hate crimes legislation, calling them unnecessary and ill-conceived, much to the consternation of many of her readers. 

I must firmly disagree with you on this, and (5.00 / 8) (#1)
by andgarden on Fri Jul 17, 2009 at 12:23:42 AM EST

celebrate the passage of this legislation. First, when a hate crime is committed, it is not just an attack on one person, it’s an attack on an entire group of people, always a minority. This amendment recognizes that. Second, we already care about what’s in the mind of a person accused of committing a crime, and will continue to do so unless we go to a strict liability system of criminal law (and I do not think we should).

Finally, I think it’s really very important to point out that this is an expansion of existing law . In particular, it expands hate crimes protections to gays, lesbians, and transgendered people. Whether this amendment passes or not, the underlying hate crimes legislation will remain in effect. So I have to admit that I find yelling “stop” here, now, and making common cause with people like James Dobson (who opposes the amendment specifically because of who it is designed to protect) gives me a queasy feeling.  





Well said. As a gay man (5.00 / 11) (#16)
by kenosharick on Fri Jul 17, 2009 at 07:55:11 AM EST

who has had the crap kicked out of me, and then been laughed at by the police as I stood there bleeding in front of them, I think this is needed.  Not every hate crime ends in a horrific murder, such as in the Shephard case.  Every gay person I know has been assaulted in some way due to their sexual orientation.  I am sick of society tacitly (and not so tacitly) giving permission to the homophobes.  

Yessir! (5.00 / 1) (#104)
by ChiTownDenny on Fri Jul 17, 2009 at 05:33:10 PM EST


Hate crime legislation is necessary because it addresses crime perpetrated specifically because of one’s thought/disposition toward a class of people; it will act as a deterrent to keep those inclned to do so avoid acting upon their thoughts toward specific classes of people.  One may think what he chooses.  Acting upon one’s thought has consequences.  Acting upon one’s thoughts toward protected classes of people has/will have more severe consequences.  Those protected do/will experience safety from being associated with protected classes.


The desire to push aside reason for the desire to vindicate the special wrong done to people for the absolute ugliest, nastiest, stupidest of reasons, is understandable.  The resistance appears almost disingenuous; how can one not feel outrage at an attack on another human being because he’s gay or she’s lesbian?  That there walk amongst us people so blind and angry to do harm to others because of their blind hatred is a travesty.

And yet there need be no special law to “address” this travesty.  We have laws, though the spottiness of enforcement is an issue that need be kept in mind.  That police are often at the forefront of those who don’t care much for gays, or find themselves more attuned to those who would assault them, presents a secondary problem that requires redress.  Once enforced, life in prison for murder is as much of a deterrant as needed.  This is not a life plus cancer opportunity for thinking evil thoughts.

But more laws does nothing but vindicate an emotional disgust, no matter how understandable that disgust might be.  The damage to more fundamental rights, however, every time we want to ramp up our attack under the guise of a “special situation,” is what invariably comes back to haunt us, to damage us, to cause far more serious and permanent harm than can be offset by the euphoria that a group deserving of our concern received special treatment.

There will always be sacred cows, and once we get past this one (and we will), another will vying for our attention.  But over time, we must remember that it’s the fundamental rights that will serve to protect us all, and we really can’t let our focus, and ideological perspective, change with every new cow that wanders into the pasture.  I’m with Jeralyn,  This is bad law.

The Standard Walter Cronkite

The passing of Walter Cronkite is a milestone in the lives of today’s middle-aged men and women.  He was the voice of news in a more naive age, when we believed what we were told.  If Walter Cronkite said so, then it was true.

There are many excellent obits for this icon of news, and I have nothing to add worthy of another.  Instead, I mourn the death of innocence in the news in a time when Cronkite would be the target of attack and ridicule.  Whether denigratingly called the MSM or State Owned Media, as has lately come into fashion, Cronkite would have been as easy a target as any network anchor.

But things were different back then, when the news divisions weren’t underneath the entertainment divisions of networks.  Newsmen didn’t banter or do promos and teasers.  They held themselves above the wrestling, believing it to be a badge of honor to tell it straight. 

No one challenged Walter Cronkite’s integrity.  No one dared.  No one would have even considered trying, even if Cronkite’s broadcast was contrary to whatever political perspective they held.  We have people serving us news who similarly want to maintain the level of integrity and neutrality that characterized Walter Cronkite, but they are faced with different hurdles.

The broadcast networks are forced to present us with newscasts as an duty for the benefit of holding a slice of the public airwaves.  There was a time when they never questioned this duty, and embraced it as a responsibility of being a network.  But networks are businesses, and eventually the business minds realized that this was airtime to be used to create synergies with their more profitable endeavors. 

They mixed and matched, and forever changed the way news was delivered.  They dumbed it down and entertained it up.  It’s not that journalists necessary agree with this as the transition happened, but they quickly learned to serve the boss of find a new job at the local station in Duluth.  And so they learned to present news in a fashion consistent with entertainment, concerned with their demographics and public recognition.  All the time wanting to be more like Walter Cronkite as they became Buffalo Bob, trying desperately to cling to their ideals.

Then came the new wave of partisan punditry, to fill the confirmation bias gap generated by the release of news from fact.  Once people accepted the premise that sensibility need no longer be directly connected to reality, they were free to reinvent facts to suit their politics, and to attack those whose facts didn’t comport with their values.  The new genre attacked Walter Cronkite’s progeny, themselves weakened by their succumbing to the practicalities of commercial enterprise.  After all, how does one wear clown shoes or a red squishy nose, yet fend off challenges to their integrity?  Walter Cronkite never wore a red nose, but then no one ever asked him to or told him that he either wore it or found a new place to work.

We were better for believing in Walter Cronkite and allowing him the opportunity to tell us the news without challenge.  If he was to assume the anchor chair today, he might not be treated any differently than any other anchor on a broadcast network.  It’s impossible to say whether Walter Cronkite would have allowed himself to do commercials to promote his network or his newscast, to demean himself in the name of audience share.  I can’t imagine him engaging in mindless banter after telling the story of a tragic death or national crisis.  But then, that wasn’t the way it was done back then.

Today, both ends of the political spectrum attack Cronkite’s network media legacy, calling it names and proclaiming that it’s part of a conspiracy to delude the masses by feeding it biased news or hiding those parts of the story that don’t comport with the position of their bosses.  It’s all spin, or alleged spin.  Would Walter Cronkite have been treated any differently if he was working the anchor desk today?  Not likely. 

Walter Cronkite remains an untouchable icon, as he should.  We need heroes.  We need heroes in the news media, people who are above reproach by the extremist infotainment pundits who manipulate lesser minds.  We need to have a baseline of information that everyone will believe in and accept to be accurate.  We can still debate right and wrong, good and bad, but at least we can agree on the facts underlying our debate.  We haven’t had that agreement in a long time.

Walter Cronkite was the standard for discussion, argument, debate during a time of enormous upheaval in America.  Disagreement between young and old, war and peace, honesty and corruption, was rampant.  But unlike today, there was a factual baseline by which all disagreement could be weighed.  We have lost that standard for what constitutes fact, and are now left to create our own set of facts.  We denigrate the news media’s representations, and pick and chose what reality we wish to adopt.  We don’t really debate anymore, since we’re arguing alternate sets of facts rather than different value judgments based on an agreed-upon set of facts.

Without the standard, we have no common ground.  To improve the human condition, we require a standard.  It doesn’t seem possible that we will ever have another standard like Walter Cronkite to inform us nightly of the facts upon which we agree to rely.

What’s This In Reference To?

Many blawgers thrill when they hear the phone ring. New clients are the lifeblood of a small firm, and it all begins with a telephone call.  But when you answer the phone and the caller’s first words are, “I saw your blog and,” what follows is often a trip into a fantasy world beyond your wildest expectations.

I thought of this after a chat yesterday with What About Clients? blawger Dan Hull, who told me about a call he received from a woman who explained that she was betrothed to the Prince of Dubai and was having a tiff with Paris Hilton.  Ah, if I had a nickel for every caller who was having a tiff with Paris Hilton.

As the readership of Simple Justice grew, a different sort of person began to call my office.  People who believed they were kindred souls, who knew terrible secrets of law enforcement conspiracies to topple governments and subjugate the populus.  People who were having a tiff with Paris Hilton.

Nobody warns you about this in advance, so I feel obliged to do so.  There are a lot of crazy people out there, and now they all have access to your telephone number.  They are not shy about calling.  They have something very important to talk to you about, and if there’s one characteristic they share, they like to talk.  They have so very much to say, and you’re the only one who will listen.  You, they explain, will understand them when no one else does.

While there’s been much debate about whether blawging offers the Return on Investment that those in the business of making money off other people blawging suggest, few let on to this unintended consequence.  You see, this surprisingly large coterie of the disaffected go from lawyer to lawyer seeking the right one to handle their challenge to the government’s covert war against them, not to mention their tiff with Paris Hilton.  And they want a lawyer who is not only brave enough, bold enough, smart enough, but willing to take it on contingency.

As soon as the word “blog” comes out of the caller’s mouth, I feel an involuntary shudder.  This is the person who has been refused by lawyer after lawyer, thrown out of offices and threatened with arrest if he continues to call.  He is on a mission, a crusade, and he wants to find his legal soul mate to join him, a Sancho Panzo to his Don Quixote (with Paris Hilton as his Dulcinea).

There are times, when you’re not in the middle of work and perhaps in the mood for some distraction, that these calls can be quite amusing.  Of course, once you’ve taken some time with them, they are inclined to call back regularly in an effort to persuade you to sign on.  After all, you would be one of the only lawyers around to take his call, making you the closest thing possible to normal ear he’s got.

The hard part is that once in a while, the odd caller isn’t nearly as insane as he seems, and may in fact be correct in his beliefs and sincere in his need for your services.  After all, Paris Hilton does have a tendency to get into tiffs with others.

Just don’t take it on contingency.

Saving Sonia

Having watched as much of the Senate Judiciary Committee’s confirmation hearing of Sonia Sotomayor as any relatively normal human being could, I’m left with a sense of dread.  Not because Senators are political animals, or use more than their share of allotted words.  Not even because Jeff Sessions is broadcast in living color, when it seems that he should come across in black and white.  But because Judge Sotomayor will be charged with safeguarding our civil rights and liberties.

Though it likely isn’t needed, some have tried to offer explanations for what Judge Sotomayor brings to the bench.  Forget the “wise Latina woman” nonsense that will come to be the phrase remembered from these hearings, but, as noted by Anthony S. Barkow, the executive director of the Center on the Administration of Criminal Law at NYU Law School, that she will be the court’s expert on the real world of criminal law.


If she is confirmed, she would be the only justice with experience as a local prosecutor. For five years, Sotomayor was an assistant district attorney in Manhattan. In that position, she interacted with some of the poorest, most troubled residents of New York and handled matters ranging from shoplifting, prostitution and petty drug offenses to robberies, child abuse and murders.

Sotomayor’s experience on the front lines in a big city’s fight against crime will bring a much-needed perspective to the court.  Only Justice Samuel Alito has any real background at all in criminal law. He was an assistant U.S. attorney and was later U.S. attorney in New Jersey.

What is striking about this assertion is that Barkow ignores that her experience is a bit lopsided.  Well, totally one-sided.  It’s not that this isn’t experience, but it’s a stacked deck no matter how hard Barkow tries to spin this.  Whether borne of ignorance or partisanship, there is no recognition that this “much-needed experience” is that of a person who enforced order against the people.



Sotomayor would bring a much-needed dose of reality when it comes to criminal law issues.  It is all too easy for someone who has not spent time working on these issues to caricature them.  For conservatives, the risk is assuming all crimes are a failure of personal responsibility that lead to serious breaches of public order and demand incarceration and a tough response. For liberals, the risk is seeing every defendant as a victim of poverty or society’s failures.

The reality, as Sotomayor knows well, is far more complicated. She has seen the human condition up close and personal. She knows the pain of victims and has looked into the eyes of defendants who have committed unspeakable acts with no remorse and are unredeemable. She has also seen defendants who need treatment and jobs, not prison.  Many of these individuals may have committed petty crimes, such as shoplifting or drug possession, to feed an addiction.

So the spectrum runs from guilty and unremorseful all the way to guilty and drug addicted.  Has she seen the police lie to her about their beating a defendant, or tailor testimony to make fools of judges who have provided a roadmap to subvert the law?  Has she seen the Youtube videos of our police caught engaging their “new professionalism?”  Has she looked into the eyes of a defendant imprisoned for decades for a crime he didn’t do because some zealous young prosecutor decided that the police and/or eyewitness could never be wrong?

That Judge Sotomayor’s career within criminal law kept her in the hallways of 1 Hogan Place, just long enough to make it out of criminal court to handle a few Supreme Court cases doesn’t mean that she didn’t come to realize that it’s a dirty, ugly business.  But if so, her time at Foley Square gave no indication of it.  She was unremarkable as a district court and circuit judge when it came to recognizing reality on the street, fitting in well with those who would never believe an agent to lie or do harm.  The “wise Latina” was one of the boys, her experience notwithstanding.

Barkow’s point is both important and horrible.  Judge Sonia Sotomayor may well become the Supreme Court’s reality check on criminal law cases.  At worst, she would be the ballast to Judge Alito’s perspective in the District of New Jersey.  Will she provide balance to Judge Alito, or will the ship list hard to starboard?

In the effort to soften the image that Jeff Sessions wishes to craft of Judge Sotomayor as some weird liberal activist, a characterization that’s as absurd as it is baseless, her supporters proffer the view that the forces of order need not fear her as, our Vice President proclaimed, she’s “got your back.”  Biden was just being honest.

Judge Sonia Sotomayor is the appointee of a Democratic President, a liberal if one believes the epithets,  It only gets worse from here.  I have no doubt that a well-qualified candidate with even harsher views toward criminal defendants could be found wandering the wilds of Alaska, but I hesitate to accept that our options are bad and worse.  Could Obama find no qualified candidate who embraces the Constitution? 

While she could have an epiphany on her walk up the stairs in front of the Supreme Court, that the future of personal freedom in the United States rests on her vote, neither friend nor foe has given any reason to believe that Sonia Sotomayor would be inclined to stand tough as rights and protections are whittled away.  Indeed, they don’t even recognize this as a worthy part of a judge’s experience.

The word “empathy” has been used with great frequency over the past few days.  No one has asked, empathy for whom?  I see no reason why the forces of order should fear her empathy.  There is grave reason, however, for the rest of us to be deeply concerned.

H/T Berman

Consumer Beware

One of the gravest benefits claimed online is its resource to consumers.  It offers some wonderful advice and information, but it similar offers some of the worst, most ignorant and potentially dangerous consumer “advice” as well.  The problem, of course, is that the consumer seeking information is incapable of discerning which is which.

An example of the bad stuff was found by Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett, when he came across a post at what purports to be a consumer guide website, and about how to select a lawyer for a white collar criminal case.  Who, in the great wide world of possible people to author such advice, is the anointed expert on such matters?


Robert Rava is a dude who aged in herringbone jacket at Yale, galloped around French West Africa in the Peace Corps, and later worked as a screenwriter and story editor in Angel City, Australia, Iceland, and Russia. Two years ago, with the encouragement of Mary Ellen Mark, he began photographing.

Yes, he is a dude.  For the record, the word “dude”, when self-attributed, is a primary indicator of stunted adolescence.  That aside, Rava lacks any qualifications to assist consumers.  That, however, doesn’t stop him from writing, or the website from publishing, his ignorant screed.  All for the benefit of consumers.

This is what Rava offers to educate the public:


Any short list of high-end white-collar defense attorneys should be composed of former government prosecutors. That is, lawyers who’ve “flipped,” as they say in the under-worldly language of criminal law. It’s these highly skilled attorneys who understand the prosecutorial mindset, and can anticipate the cunning strategies they’ll employ against you.

As much as you might resent these well-dressed law enforcement officials, with their farrago of lies and defamations, you nevertheless want a defense attorney who has a friendly relationship with them. Government prosecutors and agents automatically give more credibility to defense attorneys who’ve forged their legal skills as prosecutorial attack dogs.

This makes perfect sense, provided you are a clueless simpleton.  Bennett, because he can’t control himself when he sees a windmill in need of tilting, sought to “clarify” Rava’s expert advice.


Sure, if you want to race down to the U.S. Attorney’s Office, spill your guts, plead guilty and hope for a reduced sentence, a former prosecutor is perfect.

But if you want to fight your case, hire a lawyer who has made a career out of keeping people out of prison, rather than putting them in; who has always been on the side of the underdog; and who understands the prosecutorial mindset not because he’s a (“former”) prosecutor but because he’s spent years fighting the government and seen and countered the worst they can throw at him.

One might expect Bennett’s enormously sound advice to generate a chorus of appreciation, but no one thanks Don Quixote.  Instead, he became the target of the swarm, a cavalcade of uber-marketing eyeballs dedicated to the promotion of crap and the attack of anyone urging sanity. 

How do we know it’s not just some legitimate, random thoughts by others seeking to provide aid to the consumer?  It was made clear almost immediately, with this piece of promotional stupidity, pushing some former Bronx ADA kid whose sole claim to fame is that he is the single biggest internet self-promoter in New York City.  I’ve called him out in the past, not for his competence (about which I know nothing) but for his chutzpah, deceit and marketing tactics.  This is my personal ever:


He personally obtained hundreds of victories in criminal court before even completing law school— while working under the District Attorney’s Office. 
Now there’s a legitimate confidence booster, right?  While the kid may actually be capable of defending someone, even if only a speeding ticket, his integrity will never overcome this bit of garbage. 

And this is what infiltrates the internet, the consumer help sites which purport to guide people seeking sound and meaningful advice, and those who use such sites to spread their marketing message.  Marketers will tell you that this is what you should do, how you should protect your turf and spread your brand. 

And this is what becomes of a lawyer who tries to counter the deception with a little honesty.

Mind you, Mark never said that former prosecutors cannot be good, even great, defense lawyers.  No one would say that, and it isn’t true.  The arguments of the swarm rely on the logical fallacy of the strawman, the fabrication of a false position and the attribution of that false position to the adversary, so that it can be easily knocked down.  Unfortunately, most people are unaware of logical fallacies, and find them naggingly persuasive.  It’s another of those “common sense” type things, where it appeals to people who get a headache when asked to think.

It reminds me of the Sy Syms motto, “an educated consumer is our best customer.”  They may claim to be there to help consumers, but the last thing the marketers want is an educated consumer.  Or to have Mark Bennett stumble on their website.


The Lawyer Letter Commandeth

Jon Katz at Underdog,a zealous defender of the first amendment, was given a letter that is just too funny to pass up.


Late last month, Los Angeles lawyer Martin Singer sent a threat letter to the San Diego Reader warning of exposure to “potentially astronomical [financial] damages” through a defamation suit if the newspaper “proceed[s] to recklessly and falsely publish a Story which falsely states, either directly or by implication, that my client [Platinum Equity, LLC] engaged in wrongdoing…” Singer’s letter states at the beginning and end that it is confidential and not to be republished.

Jon’s description doesn’t do it justice.  Don Bauder of the San Diego Reader, one of the targets of the threat letter, did a story on the letter itself.


If you go to the website of the Los Angeles law firm of Lavely & Singer and click the bio of cofounder Martin Singer, you find a Los Angeles Magazine article in which Singer is described as a “pit bull” who has “rabid” tactics and the nickname “Mad Dog.” The article quotes a journalist saying, “I’ll make one call to a publicist to check out a tip, and pretty soon I get a hand-delivered letter from Singer threatening all sorts of disasters and financial damages.”

So what does this “pitbull” write to scare the pants off his targets?


Warning of “immense monetary damages,” Singer’s letter admonished, “You proceed at your peril.” At the top of the letter were these words: “CONFIDENTIAL LEGAL NOTICE. NOT FOR PUBLICATION OR OTHER USE.” In a number of instances, the Reader has found, Singer’s threatening letters have been published despite his warning of a possible copyright violation. The letters we have seen contained the same language — words such as “malicious,” “defamatory,” and “violation of Copyright Act,” for example — that Singer uses in his letter to the Reader.

Now if you received a letter like this, and didn’t know better, there’s a pretty good chance that it would shake you up.  Whether he has any basis to assert that the underlying claim would have a potentially meritorious libel claim is one thing, but the part that is just too ridiculous for words is this Confidential Notice.  It’s utterly goofy.

Naturally, Bauder not only provides a link to the letter, but publishes it in full.  God bless him.  After the ominous sentence, “you proceed at your peril,” (peril is a great word, isn’t it?), Singer concludes with this warning:


This letter is a confidential legal communication and is not for publication. Any publication, dissemination or broadcast of any portion of this letter will constitute a breach of such confidence and a violation of the Copyright Act, and you are not authorized to publish this letter in whole or part absent our express written authorization.
Wrongo, dogbreath.  Pit bull just turned into a chihuahua. 

Lest anyone shake unnecessarily, here’s the deal.  Singer is full of it.  Absent an agreement, meaning that both sides agree, to hold a document, such as a letter or email or any other writing, in confidence, you can do any darn thing you please with it.  You can publish it, post it on the internet or use it for toilet paper.  Singer can’t tell you not to publish it.  Once it’s put into your hands, whether literally or figuratively, it’s yours to do with as you please.

Now Singer includes a copyright notice at the end of the letter.  Letters are as entitled to copyright protection as any other writing.  They are also subject to the “fair use” exceptions to copyright.  This means that Bauder, if he was a lawyer, couldn’t copy over Singer’s nastygram onto his own letterhead and send it out to the next fellow.  But it doesn’t stop Bauder from publishing the letter to show what a joke Singer is. 

If all this sounds familiar, it is.  It harkens to another puffy wannabe bully, John Dozier, who tried to scare people into not publishing his nastygrams.  It made Dozier the joke of the internet, and it should do the same for this mutt, Singer.  Understand, guys like this include these stern commands because non-lawyers get shaken up, prefer not to challenge the command “just in case,” and allow these guys to get away with it.  Their lawyer letters remain hidden from sight rather than tempt fate.

But not this one.  And whenever someone gets a letter from self-proclaimed doggie, Martin Singer, commanding them not to disclose it, perhaps now they will laugh rather than shake with fear.  Got that, Marty? 

And the pit bulls want an apology.  You’ve diminished their economic opportunity.

Hope Steffey Settles With County

You may remember the disgusting videos of a young woman, strip searched by Stark County, Ohio police, and left naked in a cell, all under the watchful eye of male police officers.  If you don’t remember, please go back and take a look.  It’s a video you won’t soon forget, particularly if you have a mother, wife or daughter.

Via Carlos Miller, some good news.

U.S. District Court Judge David Dowd said in a court order that the plaintiffs, including Sheriff Tim Swanson and the Stark County Board of Commissioners, “have entered into a resolution of the plaintiffs’ case against those defendants, reserving only a determination by the Court as to the amount of attorney fees and costs.”

The amount of the settlement, however, is undisclosed, a rather strange thing given that it would appear that the cost of the police abuse of Hope Steffey (which had earlier been spelled “Steffi” based on news reports, but is different in this report) will be born by the taxpayers.  Don’t they have a right to know just how much their police have cost them?  Since when does government impropriety get to be swept under the rug so that the citizens, for whom the cops exists, are left to wonder?

When asked if the settlement is an admission of guilt, Sheriff Swanson told The Investigator Tom Meyer, “No reaction, Tom” and he hung up.

Other county officials had no reaction either.

Of course, it’s great to hear that Hope Steffey received a settlement for the harm done in this egregious case, though disappointing that the local sheriff would still hide from what happened.   I can’t blame her attorneys for settling, as their duty is to Hope, not us.  But it’s a shame that the full panoply of what went horribly wrong here won’t be aired publicly as a message to police everywhere.  And it’s a shame that the individual cops involved won’t have to pay personally for what they did to this young woman.

It’s not everything one could want in a settlement, but it’s better than nothing.  Better this than giving these sick, disgraceful cops medals.

The Valid Court Order (Update)

There is a supposition on the part of the public that courts, even when wrong, wouldn’t do anything completely nuts.  After all, there are appellate courts, more appellate courts, and certainly lawyers, watching them closely, and any judge who does something completely bonkers would be called out immediately.  Right?

Of course, that didn’t help Hillary Transue, but there are always exceptions.

Meet Frank Hatley.  He’s an exception too.  From AJC :



Frank Hatley has languished in a South Georgia jail for more than a year.


The reason? He failed to reimburse the state for all the public assistance his “son” received over the past two decades.


The problem? Hatley is not the biological father — and a special assistant state attorney general and a judge knew it but jailed Hatley anyway.

It’s not like Hatley didn’t try.  He did.  He tried really hard.


Even after learning he was not the father, Hatley paid thousands of dollars the state said he owed for support. After losing his job and becoming homeless, he still made payments out of his unemployment benefits.

His new lawyer says that “Hatley had paid a total of $9,524.05 in support since April 1995.”  Not good enough, apparently.  You see, Hatley was a “deadbeat dad” at the time it was determined that he wasn’t the dad at all.  While the court relieved him from future child support payments, he remained obligated to pay past due support.


The Aug. 21, 2001 order, signed by Cook County Superior Court Judge Dane Perkins, acknowledges that Hatley was not Travon’s father.

After that, Hatley paid almost $6,000. But last year he was laid off from his job unloading charcoal grills from shipping containers. He became homeless and lived in his car. Still, Hatley made some child support payments using his unemployment benefits.

By May 2008, he apparently had not paid enough. In another order prepared by Reddick and signed by Perkins, Hatley was found in contempt and jailed. When he is released, the order said, Hatley must continue making payments to the state at a rate of $250 a month.

Did anyone mention to Judge Perkins that he’s got the authority to vacate a facially erroneous order nunc pro tunc?  Or perhaps there was no point in making the suggestion, since someone has to pay the freight and better it’s Hatley than, say, the real father?

So what’s to be done about this facial fiasco?


It may be difficult for Hatley to get out from under the court order, said Atlanta family lawyer Randall Kessler, who is not associated with the case. “It’s definitely unfair,” Kessler said. “But at the same time, he’s dealing with a valid court order.”

That’s right.  It’s a valid court order.  And isn’t that all that really matter? 

Update:  Frank Hatley was released from jail by Judge Dane Perkins.



Superior Court Judge Dane Perkins ruled that Hatley was indigent and should not be jailed for not being able to make child support payments. Perkins postponed a decision on whether Hatley should have to make any more back payments on child-support for a child who is not his.
Of course, this was all true and known at the time Perkins put Hatley in jail for contempt for failure to pay child support.  There’s nothing like religion and a job well done by attorney Sarah Geraghty of the Southern Center for Human Rights.

‘Cause You Got To Have Friends

A few of my fellow blawgers have posted “around the blawgosphere” posts this week,  Windy.  Lammers.  Bennett.  It’s a nice thing to do, both to share posts with readers that they might not otherwise see and to give a little link love to one’s friends in the ‘hood.  Nothing wrong with being a good friend.

This is what’s been getting me in trouble with some of my friends, and others, in the blawgosphere lately.  I’m something of a traitor.  There are other blawgs around with whom I regularly interact, and with whom I share a great deal in common.  They are my friends in the blawgosphere.  I’ve grown to like them personally, respect their views, admire their efforts. 

But sometimes, I disagree with something they write.  For some of my friends, a healthy disagreement is no big deal.  Bennett and I disagree about stuff all the time, and hash it out in public.  It’s never affected our friendship, and it’s never taken personally.  It’s our nature as trial lawyers, criminal defense lawyers, to take issue with ideas and duke it out. 

Others, unfortunately, don’t see it that way.  Not at all.  It’s not that they can’t tolerate the fact that someone doesn’t agree with their every position, but that a post, a public writing taking issue with their public writing, is taken as a personal attack on them.  Friends don’t attack friends.  Yesterday we loved each other.  Today, I hate you.

This scenario reflects a couple of fundamental flaws in the blawgosphere, and my hope is that by airing the problem, those who I’ve offended in the process will gain a better understanding of what I’m doing and why I’m doing it.  Let me start by saying, just because I may not agree with something you’ve written doesn’t mean I think you’re a terrible human being, a blithering idiot or disgusting, ugly and a bad dancer.  I just disagree with one of your positions.  I think you’re wrong about something.  So what?  Maybe I’m the one who is wrong.  You can disagree with me too, you know.

One such “issue” where I depart from the blawgosphere orthodoxy is work-life balance, a topic of particularly importance to a certain subsets of the blawgosphere.  It’s likely that those who push the work-life balance are over-represented online, their being more attuned to technology and, frankly, having more time to promote a cause that suits their desires and comports with their lifestyle. 

This creates an illusion of a groundswell of support for the cause.  It’s an illusion because the other side is grossly under-represented online, yet predominant in the real world.  Consequently, many begin to believe their own press releases, or support the cause that best suits their desires, even though it may be damaging to the profession and to them personally, when they get smacked in the face with the harsh reality that it’s a scam.  Wanting to believe in something doesn’t make it so. 

I’m asked regularly why I kick sand in the face of my friends in the blawgosphere on this subject.  Why, oh why, can’t I just stick to criminal law subjects, stay within the bounds of my niche, and leave the work-life balance crowd alone.  On one level, it’s because Simple Justice is a vehicle for things that interest me, whether within the criminal law arena or elsewhere.  But on a deeper level, it’s because there is just too much deception going on in the blawgosphere, and few people want to confront it. Indeed, much of it is self-deception.

Someone has to tell the other side of the story.  This is particularly true when people surround themselves with the chorus, like-minded wishers who keep pumping a pipe-dream because they really, really want it to come true.

Having been around the law long enough to remember when the challenge was whether lawyers should be allowed to advertise at all, I’ve watched as the professionalism of lawyers deteriorated.  Law turned from profession to occupation, from practice to business.  For many of my younger brethren at the bar, the concept of professionalism is foreign.  Today, we are deluged with marketers and marketing, all whispering in our ear that everybody does it, that it’s the only way to survive, that we all market and that anyone who questions it is a liar or a fool.

The work-life balance agenda is inextricably tied to the marketing cabal, as the former is the feeder that supposedly feeds the coffers of part-time lawyers such that they no longer need to put the client first.  I know, they insist that they do put the client first, but through their use of technology, planning, force of will, they somehow manage to do it all and do it better than old timers like me.  This, according to the people who are selling their magic secrets, is how one can make millions being a lawyer while being home for dinner at 5.  Horse hockey (h/t Jdog).

I’ve grown somewhat intolerant of those who would pursue an agenda that continues to diminish the professionalism of the law.  We are not about making millions, though a good income will come from a learned profession as an outgrowth of excellence.  We are not about kid lawyers with website touting their “expertise” when they’ve never tried a case.  I see rampant lies across the internet, and none of this seems to sufficiently trouble the chorus to either change their evil ways or speak out against the liars.

But the dream of work-life balance, the one where there is no price to pay for leaving the office at 5 and kicking back to play video games in midday, presents as great, if not greater danger, to the professionalism of lawyers as it is primarily designed to appeal to those least capable of understanding the inherent dangers.  So many young lawyers, coming out in a troubled economy and raised to believe that they are entitled to every shiny thing they see, willingly buy into this scheme. 

These are the kids who put up sham websites to suck in clients who are in true need of help, but who buy the time of people utterly incapable of providing the representation they need, and utterly lacking the desire to fulfill the obligations that once characterized lawyers.  The client suffers so the lawyer can make a buck.  The lawyer loses his dignity and integrity, but no one in the movement speaks to those issues.

Travel around the blawgosphere and see what interests people, what agendas they are pursuing.  It’s disheartening.  A wealth of marketing.  A dearth of competence.  A lack of comprehension that you aren’t a brilliant lawyer because your marketing guru says so.  Someone has to be the wet blanket at this beach party bingo, because Moondoggie is going back to his airline pilot job come September and Gidget is going to be left alone on the beach with no one to play with.  I am so sorry to be the bearer of bad news.  I wish you could all get your way.  But this isn’t like your third grade soccer team, where everybody gets to play.

There are clients, real people who suffer real consequences, as a result of the delusions perpetrated on the internet.  They come to lawyers believing them to be competent, even expert, and willing and capable of helping them, saving their lives sometimes. And the lawyer’s primary focus is to get paid and be home by dinner, with the client merely the conduit for the transfer of revenue and proof of the mastery of the secret to success.  Is any of this getting through?

So I leave my niche in criminal law from time to time to be a voice in the wilderness, that we are not selling laundry detergent, but are lawyers, professionals, in whom p
eople repose their trust.  I’ve seen their children cry when their lawyers fail to fulfill their duty.  The need to enjoy a happy lawyer life will never wipe away their tears.  I know that I’m being a pedantic old fool again as I write these words, but the truth is that, all the fun and sarcasm and humor aside, there is so much human pain belying what we do that this is no joke.  It’s just not something to keep us busy between games of Mortal Kombat or junior’s soccer game.

For those whose toes I step on in the process, it’s not because I don’t like you or respect you.  It’s just that I disagree with you on this subject, and I believe it to be important and serious.  Sorry for the hard feelings I’ve caused, but it’s something that I believe needs to be done.

I hope we can be friends even if we disagree.