Author Archives: SHG

Let There Be Liability

From Crime & Federalism :


Sandra Brown v. Rob Zarrett, etc. U.S. Court of Appeals Case No: 08-1640 U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota – Minneapolis [PUBLISHED] [Wollman, Author, with Riley and Shepherd, Circuit Judges]

Civil case – civil rights. Given the circumstances surrounding plaintiff’s Tasering and arrest, the district court did not err in concluding that defendant Zarrett’s use of force was not objectively reasonable as a matter of law;

the law was sufficiently clear to inform a reasonable police officer that it was unlawful to Taser a nonviolent, suspected misdemeanant who was not fleeing or resisting arrest, who posed little to no threat to anyone’s safety and whose only noncompliance with officer commands was to disobey orders to end her phone call to a 911 operator;

as a result, the district court did not err in denying the defendants’ motion for summary judgment based on qualified immunity; accepting plaintiff’s version of events, a jury could find defendant is not entitled to official immunity because he willfully violated plaintiff’s right to be free from excessive force.
Let this be spread around the blawgosphere far and wide.  It is henceforth to be known that the law is sufficiently clear to hold a police officer liable under 1983 for improper tasing.

Maybe there is hope?  It may have been too darn easy to just tase the noncompliant before, but at risk of liability?  This could shake up more than a few donut shops.

And all you civil rights lawyers, it’s time to welcome the victims of a darn good tasering.  Please make them feel at home.

Keeping Your Cool

Whether Atlanta lawyer Ella Hughes intended to make a point, or just let her feelings show, it clearly didn’t work out well for her.  Sure, the Georgie Court of Appeals reversed her contempt citation for the judge’s failure to give her the opportunity to purge the contempt before executing sentence, but that’s hardly vindication and the price, a $1000 fine and 10 days in jail, was steep. 

Hughes’ offense?   Looking at the judge with a sarcastic expression.

It doesn’t matter whether the judge, A.J. “Buddy” Welch Jr., handled the matter well.  It doesn’t matter whether Buddy deserved Hughes’ disdain.  It doesn’t matter whether Buddy deserved worse, as is often the case. 

Rule of thumb:  Offending the judge rarely* helps your client.  It often doesn’t do much for you either.

While I could hardly divine what really happened with Ella Hughes that day, or what she was thinking, I have seen a trend in young lawyers of allowing their displeasure with the judge’s rulings or actions show on their face, and sometimes in the words that come out of their mouths.  Do they not understand that their job is to persuade this person to do what is in their client’s best interest, not vent their personal spleen? 

There appears to be a mistaken understanding of the relative nature of the relationship in a courtroom.  The young lawyer is not the functional equal of the judge.  No matter what your professor taught you at Legal Theory Law School about due process, you are not entitled to express your personal feelings about the judge’s decision.  You exist in the well as an advocate.  The judge, for better or worse, sits as a decision-maker.  Pissing off the decision-maker is not the most effective way to advocate. 

As young lawyers may already be aware, not all judges are temperamentally or intellectually suited for the position.  Some are elected because they look remarkably like Judge Wapner.  Others for worse reasons.  But they still wear the robe and you don’t.  This is an important distinction, whether you want to acknowledge it or not.  You argue, they decide. 

A friend of mine tells a story about his arguing a point before a judge in Brooklyn Supreme Court.  After getting a little carried away with the judge’s inability to understand a nuanced point of law, he told the judge that the problem was the he, the judge, didn’t get it. 

The judge responded, “Counselor, are you looking to be held in contempt?”

The lawyer responded, “Not at this time, your Honor.” 

No client ever enjoyed a benefit from his lawyer being held in contempt.  Don’t forget why we’re there, and no matter how awful you think a judge’s decision or action might be, don’t get held in contempt.  Make your argument as firmly and clearly as possible, but know enough not to go over the line.  It helps no one.

*  There is one caveat: When the judge is about to something that will cause irreparable harm to your client, all bets are off.  Sometimes, taking a bad situation and making it worse will result in quicker and more effective review than allowing the normal course to play out.  Be very careful before going down this path, as it may be a path of no return.

Do It For the Children, Taser Edition

Another acorn from our friendly blind squirrel, Above the Law, from  Raw Story :


The Southern Thirty Adolescent Center near Mount Vernon, IL, filed the lawsuit on behalf of three children in its custody, who the lawsuit says were tasered by Jefferson County sheriff’s deputies who had been called to help subdue two misbehaving children, aged 11 and 12. Neither of those children were among those who were tasered during what one news service described as a police “rampage.”

One might wonder what sort of misbehaving these youngsters were doing to compel the Center to call the police, but then it’s likely that they, like so many others apparently, are somewhat confused about the variety of services offered by their local sheriff.  The menu is apparently limited.



According to the legal filing, quoted in the Mount Vernon Register, one deputy “physically pushed R.E. towards his bunk and shocked him repeatedly with a taser. … R.E. was tased multiple times to multiple locations on his person, including, but not limited to, his neck. Deputy Bowers shouted to B.B. to lie down in his bunk and physically forced him to lie down.

“Without physical provocation and/or physical gestures from B.B., Deputy Bowers held B.B. down on his bed and shocked him repeatedly with a taser. While he was tasing B.B., Deputy David Bowers threatened to sodomize B.B. As a result of this repeated and excessive tasing, B.B. urinated and defecated himself. Deputy David Bowers was aware that B.B. urinated himself after the tasing.”

The filing goes on to say that a 17-year-old female visitor to the center, who had pleaded with police to stop the attack, was grabbed by an officer, choked, and locked in a closet.
I wonder what made Deputy Bowers feel better about himself, having a child defecate on himself or locking a visitor in a closet.

We hear with regularity about how we need more laws, harsher laws, to protect the children.  No need to repeat it again here, as the refrain has been sung far too many times and we can all sing it by heart.  We’re left to believe that as bad a police may sometimes behave with evil adult perps, they have a “soft spot” for the children.  Would that be the soft spot where they apply the Taser?

Of course, none of the children were arrested or charged with any offense.  Whether it’s because none was committed or the deputies felt that they had adequately handled the situation without the need for further intervention is unknown. 

What is known is that there are far too many people who should have neither shield nor Taser, and that adults charged with the care of children but lacking the ability to handle them had better find another way to deal with their issues than calling the police. 

And, of course, “the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office says the deputies ‘acted appropriately’.”  “Appropriately” has now been officially redefined to mean, “whatever cops do, no matter what.” 

If You’re Really, Really Desperate, Meet Law Guru

In the course of trying to get some background information on a local lawyer I’d never heard of recently, I stumbled on a website called Law Guru.  I hated it from the outset because of the name, but that’s just me and is no reason for anyone else to think ill of it.  An email sent out by Law Guru, on the other hand, provides a really good reason.


Dear Member Attorneys:

It has always been our mission to improve and increase the public’s access to affordable and reliable legal information and resources. In early February we wrote that we were developing a new system that in addition to allowing users to continue to submit free questions like they always have, would also allow our users to choose to pay a small fee to have access to additional features for their legal question (e.g. expedited answers, privacy options, enhanced communication with the attorney, etc.). Participation in this new paid system by our member attorneys would be purely optional and would have the potential to provide them with a nice additional revenue stream.

We received a significant response to this announcement. Most loved the idea, but others expressed concerns regarding such ethical issues as fee-splitting and attorney-client relationships. Because LawGuru has always been about our community of lawyers, we listened and took the concerns very seriously. Over the last four months, we hired some of the nation’s leading ethics attorneys and with their help, reexamined and redesigned the system to address these concerns.

Today we are happy to announce the introduction of LawGuru Answers! The key difference between this process and the process described in our February message is that now the users submitting paid questions and the answering attorney will be entering into a limited representation agreement which will create an attorney-client relationship which is limited in both scope (only involves the answer to the question) and duration (ends when the answer is delivered to and accepted by the user). Although a recent phenomenon, these types of agreements (also known as unbundled services) are gaining popularity and believed to be an integral part of the future of legal representation.

And I thought Avvo Answers had problems.  I wouldn’t even imagine anyone coming up with this.  Not in my wildest dreams.  The founder of Law Guru, Bahman Eslamboly, apparently has a different vision than I do.  This may well be his wildest dream.

So the deal is that users submit legal questions on a website, pay the fee (which is no longer fee splitting, because they now take one fee and split into two), and await an answer. On the other side of a computer, it gets sent to a lawyer who indicates that he wants to answer these questions for a fee, and he’s got 2 hours to do so.  If he isn’t around, the question gets kicked to another lawyer of a similar level of hunger and desperation.

Are the lawyers appropriate, competent, interested?  I dunno.  I’m sure Law Guru will explain that they are highly qualified.  I bet if they were highly qualified they wouldn’t be answering questions on Law Guru.  How much do they charge per question?  How much goes to the lawyer?  What’s required in return?  Research?  A cogent answer?  A correct answer?

And what of the questions?  We’ve all seen the type and quantum of information that non-lawyers provide when the want an answer to a very important question.  It’s never adequate, and often only partially accurate. 

And when the lawyer responds and things don’t work out, whether because the lawyer is an incompetent buffoon or the question omitted salient facts? 

The social media folks keep telling me that law is going to be different in the 21st Century, though none has ever explained what the heck they are talking about.  Is this what they are referring?  If this is the future. I pass. 

Yesterday, Carolyn Elefant posted at My Shingle about lawyers getting referrals from a business named Foreclosure Solutions, one of those companies that purports to help consumers avoid foreclosure run by non-lawyers.  The gig involved signing and filing pleadings while the company tried to renegotiate mortgage loans.  It landed the lawyers in hot water.


File this story under “What were they thinking?”  That was my first reaction when I read this disciplinary decision, Cincinnati Bar Association v. Mullaney, in which three lawyers were sanctioned  for partnering up with Foreclosure Solutions, a non-lawyer company which referred the lawyers foreclosure cases (yes, that’s right – cases where folks were about to lose their homes!) for $125, then $150 a matter. 

Would you sell your ticket for $125?  While the Law Guru letter doesn’t state how much they are paying per answer, I can’t imagine it would be more than that.  Likely less.  Maybe even much less.  Just how desperate can one get to be willing to take the risk, and do the harm, for a few bucks?

Edit:  We now know exactly how much LawGuru will spend to buy it’s lawyers’ souls:


Cost. The cost of a paid question will be initially set at $29 for all legal areas. This will include the venue fee of $11 to LawGuru.com and a $18 fee to the attorney who answers the question. The attorney fees will be paid monthly via check or PayPal.

Suddenly, $125 to sign and file pleadings sounds pretty good.  Although, they probably require the attorney signing pleadings to spell his name correctly.  LawGuru imposes no similar burdens.  

Even  if you are one of those lawyers who can’t manage to get a client, even though you’ve carefully followed the 13 steps to legal success via twitter and twinkies, and see this as your last chance to pay for dinner, try to maintain some dignity please.  This is as humiliating as it gets, for all and to all.  A new low for what used to be known as the legal profession.

Just so we’re clear, these non-lawyer schemes cannot survive without the aid and cooperation of lawyers.  If we refuse to become complicit in these schemes, they die and go away.  Only through our complicity can they exist.  We can stop these things from happening by refusing to be party to it.  We can stop them.

Today, I Wear Short Shorts

Becky was indeed a bit off the deep end at times, but she was incredibly irreverent, bold and, more often than not, right.  Becky had a blog called Just a Girl in Short Shorts Talking About Whatever.  When you click the link, you will be taken to a page that warns of objectionable content.  It’s dangerous content indeed, and clearly objectionable to the enemies of ideas.

Becky describes herself as:


Mom, recovering attorney, post-modern neo-feminist, disrespectful dyke, unlikely punk, nice Catholic girl, passionate freedom-loving libertarian, thinking conservative, sappy romantic, spiritual redneck, softball enthusiast, shopaholic and unrepentant flirt.

Don’t let that fool you.  She is a razor.  A razor that will make you laugh as she cuts your nuts off.  But don’t look forward to her next post or her incisive comments on the future of society, because there won’t be one.  She’s closing up shop. 


I  had a blast, not only sharing my annoying opinions, but interacting with, and irritating all of you—perhaps sometimes being entertaining as well–and not taking any of it too seriously.

But those days are gone. Some readers complained to Google, and the “objectionable content” splash page was inserted, no doubt by the click of some rather low-level Google employee—tyranny of the constable is often much more oppressive than the King’s tyranny.

The blog, which had remarkably high page rankings on a number of topics, is disappearing from the search engines by the minute–when an entry is not totally scrubbed it is replaced with an Objectionable Content Warning. Besides I am not going to maintain a blog which is publicly identified as objectionable.
If ever there was an awfully good reason to have a blog, it’s to irritate as many people as possible.  It means that she had a point and made it very well.  I bet that the wealth of (small “l”) libertarian bloggers will be on this outrage today like flies on feces.  I can’t wait to hear their voices ring out against this travesty.  If I was half as worthy as Becky, someone would put an objectionable content warning on Simple Justice.  That you can access it without warning is a testament to my unworthiness.

But don’t cry for Becky.  I’m sure that ten new lawyer blogs will spring up in place of Short Shorts to promote their availability to represent the victims of airplane crashes, or to guide lawyers to financial freedom while maintaining a relaxed lifestyle.  You know, the really important stuff.

H/T Our hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen.

A Lesser Evil

Which is worse, a man’s sexual attack of a woman, or drunk driving?  These “clash of the titans” cases create a dilemma for advocates, all of whom promote their most hated offense as the worst thing that could ever happen.  Fortunately for 48-year-old Donna Powell, the attack trumped drunk driving, resulting in her acquittal.

From Newsday :

Powell, who admitted driving last October with more than twice the legal limit of alcohol in her system, said she was forced to get behind the wheel drunk after a man she had left a bar with took her to a remote area and attacked her.

The man,Long Island Jewish Medical Center executive director John Steel, denied in court that he had attacked Powell, though he admitted that he is addicted to crack, and said he took Powell to buy and then smoke the drug.

Before delving further into the fascinating legal issues, it’s impossible to move beyond some of the more scintillating details of the individuals involved.  John Steel, the accused attacker, is the director of LIJ Medical Center, and his explanation for his conduct is that he’s addicted to crack?  There’s an advertisement hidden in here somewhere for St. Francis Hospital.

And Ms. Powell, whose occupation is left to the imagination, left a bar with Steel, having imbibed sufficiently to double the legal limit of alcohol, and was so shocked by Steel’s advances that she needed to escape?  I envision her as a nuclear physicist, or perhaps a charm school instructor.  I hate it when they give enough details to spark one’s interest, but not enough to close the loop.

The bench trial, before Judge George Peck, had Powell testify that Steel attacked her.  Even though she was drunk as a skunk, she had no choice but to jump into the car and speed away.  That’s what she said in court, anyway.

Powell did not tell police that Steel had attacked her when she was arrested, a fact that prosecutors said was a major hole in her story. Powell’s lawyer, James Pascarella of Huntington, said it is common for sexual assault victims to delay reporting attacks.

Happens all the time.  All the time.  Judge Beck found Powell credible, and that there was some external evidence to support her allegations.  He also found Steel less credible.  Crack addicts are often found to be less credible, and one should bear that in mind when considering their drug of choice.  Once Powell sufficiently established that the attack happened, the burden shifted to the prosecution to prove it didn’t.  Upon failure to do so, the justification defense prevailed

Use of a justification defense in a drunk driving case is truly brilliant.  It’s not easy to claim that someone simply had to drive drunk lest a greater crime occur.  While the facts of this case are unlikely to fall into the mainstream of drunk driving prosecutions, lending themselves to a potential justification argument, it does open up a number of possibilities that may not have occurred to lawyers before.

The prosecutor, Maureen McCormack (no, not Marsha, Marsha, Marsha), not only felt the sting of a loss when the case should have been a slam dunk, but the future of drunk driving prosecutions in a County where the campaigning District Attorney is demanding reinstitution of the death penalty for the heinous crime.

Prosecutor Maureen McCormack said she was deeply disappointed.

“If she [Powell] can make this unsubstantiated claim and get off, it makes you concerned about what other claims will be made by other defendants in the future,” she said. “They would have every reason to be emboldened by this decision.”

I know exactly what she means.  Imagine a society where people can be convicted of crimes and sent to prison for decades based solely on the unsubstantiated claim of police officer, with absolutely no hard evidence whatsoever.  They would have every reason to be emboldened by such a decision.

H/T The Blind Guy.

Racism or the American Experience? (Update)

When the feces began to rain down on the Cambridge Police Department, and particularly on the head of Sgt. James Crowley, it was unclear what it all meant.  The details in the Boston Globe’s report were fuzzy, making it uncertain whether an officer was simply doing his best to make sure that a house wasn’t being robbed, a man over-reacted, a black man believed himself to be unfairly targeted and lost his cool. 

The police report offered a clear version of an officer just trying to protect and serve.  Police reports always provide a clear version.

But since the black man was Henry Louis Gates, director of Harvard’s W.E.B. Du Bois Institute for African and African American Research, further scrutiny was inevitable.  As the picture came into focus, reports firmed up the details of Gates’ encounter with Sgt. Crowley.

There is no question that a call was made by a white woman who observed two black men appearing to force a door to a house open, and the police responded to the call.  When they arrived at Gates’ home, he was inside. 


According to his lawyer, Professor Gates told the sergeant that he lived there and showed his Massachusetts driver’s license and his Harvard identification card, but Sergeant Crowley still did not seem to believe that Professor Gates lived in the home, a few blocks from Harvard Square. At that point, his lawyer said, Professor Gates grew frustrated and asked for the officer’s name and badge number.

According to the police report, Professor Gates initially refused to show identification.

Some will say that a homeowner, whether it be Henry Gates or you or me, could have easily avoided all the unpleasantness by simply cooperating with Sgt. Crowley, whose only offense was to investigate a possible break in and protect the homeowner, whether it be Gates or you or me.  There is certainly merit to the point, as full acquiescence to the demands of a cop tends to avoid invoking their wrath.

Others, of comparable virtue, will argue that it was Henry Gates’ home, his castle, and no one, not even a cop, has the power to tell a man what to do in his castle.  Indeed, they might suggest that he come out firing, the defense of one’s castle being a primary duty of a homeowner.

Had a white man opened the door to Sgt. Crowley’s knock, it was likely that he would have been assumed to be the owner of the small white house on Ware Street.  Of course, the report was that it was two black men who were pushing against the door, so the inconsistency may have played some role in Crowley’s assumption. 

On the other hand, Henry Louis Gates doesn’t exactly give the appearance of a gangbanger.  With his cane in hand, he was a distinguished looking man.  Even in his mug shot, courtesy of HuffPo, he appears distinguished, if disgruntled.  But more to the point, when a cop knocks on the door to question whether a break in has occurred, the robber doesn’t usually answer.  These factors alone should have given Sgt. Crowley some sense that he was not staring a bad guy in the eyes.

There are some things we should not be compelled to do in our own home.  Be directed to step outside to speak with a police officer is one of them.  Prove to the officer’s satisfaction who we are is another.  While answering the door with a shotgun is not a sound approach, the Castle Doctrine does have a role to play here.  Henry Gates was within his sanctuary.  Sgt. Crowley had very good reason to believe that the homeowner answered his knock.  A calm conversation as to why he was there might have ended in Gates thanking the sergeant for his efforts in protecting his home from possible invasion, and the encounter would have ended without incident.  Instead, it ended with Gates’ arrest.

Was the tenor of Sgt. Crowley’s approach to Gates the result of racist assumptions, that the distinguished man who answered the door was black rather than white?  This can only be answered in a meaningful way if there was a basis for comparison.  It could well be the case.  Or, it could equally be the case that Sgt. Crowley would have done the same thing no matter what color the skin of the man who came to the door. 

The problem is that the American experience with police has achieved a certain degree of racial equality, in that police can be just as wrong in dealing with a white man as a black man.  The stories are legend of police officers demanding compliance from people of all colors except blue.  Be obsequious and survive.  Be defiant and suffer the consequences.  Black or white, defiance to the command of a police officer will not be tolerated.  It doesn’t matter whether the officer has the authority, or the propriety, to make demands; it only matters that he is a police officer.  Compliance is the only acceptable response.

Once Henry Gates showed Sgt. Crowley his drivers license and Harvard identification, an act of compliance that some will believe already exceeded any obligation on the part of a man standing inside his own home, the sergeant had everything he could possibly want to confirm, as if confirmation was necessary, that this distinguished man was within the walls of his castle.  The reports emphasize that Gates at first resisted Crowley’s demand for identification, but then complied. 

While the implication of the initial refusal is that Gates had his cockles raised to begin with, it’s important to bear in mind that he was being asked to prove to a cop’s satisfaction his right to be inside his own home.  Many, including a few hardened officers of the court, might well have refused the officer’s demand, that bone in their head requiring them to be passive and compliant having long been excised.  That Gates ultimately complied by providing identification is an act of cooperation above anything required of him as a man in his own castle.

Even if we were to credit Sgt. Crowley with a excess of zeal, but a well-intended purpose of making absolutely certain that no intruder had entered this lovely Ware Street home, he used up all his chits after checking Henry Gates’ identification.  That would have been a good moment to apologize for challenging a man within his castle and disturbing his tranquility.  An awkward smile, head slightly bent, and Sgt. Crowley might well have been offered some small degree of appreciation for his thoroughness, even if it exceeded what a thoughtful officer might have done.

Instead, Sgt. Crowley remained firm in his resolve that Henry Gates, the man unquestionably within his own home, acknowledge the sergeant’s supremacy of authority.  Gates, for his part, demanded the same of the sergeant.  Gates believed the officer’s conduct to be the product of racist excess, and he said so in no uncertain terms.  Some will find Gates to have rushed to an unwarranted conclusion, a hyper-racial sensitivity perhaps.  Those who do are likely white, and never lived the life of Henry Louis Gates.  Even if Gates was mistaken in his accusation that Sgt. Crowley was racially motivated, Gates is as entitled to believe in his view of events as anyone else.  We find it far easy to be critical of the conclusions of others, whose life experiences differ from our own, though we are absolutely certain of our own conclusions.  Ours are always justified.  Theirs may not be.

It doesn’t matter whether we interpret events the same as Henry Louis Gates.  Whether he was right or wrong is not for us to judge.  It is his interpretation of events that forms his reality, and it’s not as though it was an absurd leap into the abyss.  There is some very good reason to suspect that this would never have happened had this been the home of Alan Dershowitz.  Indeed, not even Sgt. Crowley would likely to have a sufficient metacognitive appreciation to explain why, at critical moments, he acted and reacted as he did.  Racial assumptions are often too deep below the surface to be facially appreciated.

But there is similarly a possibility, based upon a larger experience by those who follow the conduct of police officers, that this was unrelated to Henry Louis Gates’ race.  This encounter could have, and has, happened to whites as well as black, to Hispanics as well as Asians.  To old women and young men. 

Henry Louis Gates was arrested for engaging in “tumultuous” behavior.  Only in Cambridge would the complaint use the word “tumultuous”.  But many a man forced from his castle upon the command of a police officer who refused to accept that he was at home would have been outraged.  Tumult seems an appropriate way to act.  The crime was Gates’ hurling words at Sgt. Crowley at a time when the sergeant commanded him to be obsequious and compliant.  Gates would not calm down.  There is no law that requires him to be calm because a police officer ordered him to do so.  Other than the expectation that we do what an officer tells us to do, no matter what.

It may well be that what happened to Henry Louis Gates reflects, as he is accused of screaming at Sgt. Crowley, “what happens to a black man in America.”  Because the black man happens to be the director of the W.E.B. Du Bois Institute for African and African American Research at Harvard, perhaps the pre-eminent black scholar, it will open a discussion that we still need to have, black president notwithstanding. 

It is also possible, however, that what happened to Henry Louis Gates is the outgrowth of the conflict between law and order, order represented by police who have been empowered, in our p
ost 9/11 age, to believe that their every command is the law, that our blind obedience is mandatory.  Other than a few old-timers on the Supreme Court who live in a fantasy world where ordinary people can assert their rights and refuse to comply with the command of a police officer with impunity, this encounter between a distinguished scholar, within his own home, and a police sergeant who believes that his command is sufficient to create the divide between citizen and criminal, may offer the chance to question who commands whom in our society.

Perhaps Henry Louis Gates suffered the experience of a black man in America.  Perhaps he suffered the experience of all men in America.  The conversation needs to include both possibilities, as neither one is acceptable.

Update:  The AP reports that charges against Gates have been dropped.


The city of Cambridge issued a statement saying the arrest “was regrettable and unfortunate” and police and Gates agreed that dropping the charge was a just resolution.

“This incident should not be viewed as one that demeans the character and reputation of professor Gates or the character of the Cambridge Police Department,” the statement said.
Is this the end of the issue?  I don’t think it’s going to be quite that easy.

A Bum on a Stoop

Shem Walker was a good son.  He would visit his mother, Lydia, every weekend and keep an eye on a property she owned in Clinton Hill, Brooklyn.  When he came across a bum on the stoop, he told him to get lost.  Then he was shot twice in the chest and died.

Sometimes, undercover officers dress like bums.  Sometimes, they position themselves on private property, such as stoops, where they can have a comfortable seat with a good line of sight at their target.  But never do they want someone bothering them in the middle of a buy and bust.

The official police response was the undercover identified himself to Walker, but Walker chose to struggle with the officer. 


NEW YORK (AP) — New York City police say a man who told an undercover officer to get off his family’s stoop punched the officer and got into a struggle over the officer’s gun before being shot dead.

Police say Shem Walker grabbed the officer’s gun Saturday night after hitting him on the head.

Police spokesman Paul Browne says other officers heard the undercover officer or a plainclothes colleague identify themselves.

We all know how people who are uninvolved in criminal conduct are more inclined to pick a fight with a police officer and challenge them for their weapon rather than back away.  It happens all the time, right?  It so much more productive to fight with an armed cop than let him sit on the stoop.

Others found the cops’ story dubious.  Questionable even.  But then Shem Walker gave them the solution to their veracity issues.  He was a convicted felon, a drug dealer.  As detailed by Jim Dwyer.


It quickly emerged that Mr. Walker had been convicted of making drug sales in Wilkes-Barre, Pa., and was released from prison in 2007. There is, inevitably, more.

Walker served in the army from 1983 to 1990.  He then floated, married, worked, had children.


In 1999, when the family was living in Wilkes-Barre, Mr. Walker was selling drugs. A mailman introduced him to a buyer who turned out to be an undercover investigator, and Mr. Walker sold him cocaine and marijuana.

The case was still unresolved in the fall of 2001. “Shem became enraged by what happened on 9/11,” said Mr. Collins, a nurse in Harrisburg. “He decided to re-enlist with the Pennsylvania National Guard.”

The 1999 drug case, delayed by Mr. Walker’s military service, remained open until 2004, when he was convicted. At sentencing, he reminded the judge that the offense had occurred five years earlier. “I’m a changed person,” he said, according to The Times Leader of Wilkes-Barre. The judge was quoted as saying: “I don’t care if it happened 100 years ago. It makes no difference to me.”

So Shem Walker was, indeed, a convicted drug dealer.  We could argue whether the judge who sentenced him was harsh and uncaring, but that wouldn’t alter his rap sheet.  Dwyer sums up the point nicely:


Not knowing the real identity of an undercover cost Mr. Walker three years in prison. Not knowing the identity of another on a stoop in Brooklyn probably cost him his life.
A good father.  A good son.  A good soldier.  He might have been a hero in another story.  In this one, he’s dead.

Consultant Nation

Even though it was below the fold, it still made the front page of the New York Times.  And even though it was about college admissions, the details were eerily familiar.  The story opened with a fashion show about what kids should wear to their college admissions interview.



“I burst out laughing,” she said.

That quote was from a college admissions dean who was shown photographs of the outfits proposed.  Yet independent consultants, a new-angled unregulated industry, charge big money, from $14,000 to $50,000.

“When you say things like, ‘We know the secrets of getting in,’ it kind of implies that it’s not the student’s ability,” said Mark H. Sklarow, executive director of the association, in Fairfax, Va. “It suggests that there’s some kind of underground code.”

Consultant charge big money to teach you the “secrets”, the “underground code,” a recurring theme.  And who are these consultant who know the secrets to success?

It is not uncommon for other counselors to exaggerate their backgrounds. Ivy Success, in Garden City, N.Y., which charges some clients nearly $30,000, says on its Web site that its counselors have “years of experience as admissions officers to help you gain an edge in this competitive and uncertain process.”

Victoria Hsiao, a partner in Ivy Success, said in an interview that she had worked as an admissions officer at Cornell for several years in “the late 1990s.” But Jason Locke, the director of undergraduate admissions at the university, said there was no record, or memory, of Ms. Hsiao doing such work. (Mr. Locke did confirm that she graduated from Cornell in 1996.)


On further questioning, it turns out that Hsiao did some alumna interviews, better known as a sales chat with prospective students.


[Hsiao] also said a partner, Robert Shaw, had been an admissions officer at the University of Pennsylvania. Asked about this in an e-mail message, Mr. Shaw said he had been only “an assistant,” from 1987 to 1988.


“Don’t remember all the details,” he said, adding, “We really don’t want to be a part of your article as we’re not a service for the masses.”

So it doesn’t become truthier if someone else promotes a slight exaggeration of qualifications?  I supposed not.  And what do real college admissions folks think of these consultants who are selling the secrets?


Regardless, colleges say parents should be wary of any counselor’s claim of being able to lobby for a candidate’s admission. While noting that there are “genuinely rational and knowledgeable folks out there doing this work,” Bruce Poch, the dean of admissions at Pomona College, adds, “Some of the independents leave me looking for the nearest emergency shower.”
We have become a nation of people trying to get a leg up on everyone else by paying someone, a person about whom we know nothing more than the “new, improved” on the label, to teach us the magic secret to success.  Whether it’s how to get into college, or law school perhaps, or how to start a million dollar law practice overnight via twitter. 

Young lawyers don’t believe that they could be taken in by snake oil salesmen.  They’re far smarter than that.  Far too savvy to be suckered and played like fools.  After all, they aren’t high schoolers hoping to get into the Ivies.  Or their desperate parents.  They would never suspect all judgment and blindly accept the idea that someone out there, for a fee, can tell them how to make millions while enjoying the wondrous lifestyle they desire and deserve.

Of course, it doesn’t strike these skeptical and bright legal minds as odd that these consultants, who claim to know the secret, aren’t using that secret to make themselves millions in successful law practices.  They charge plenty to consult, so it’s not for love, yet they left behind millions to share their secret?  Why would any rational person do that? 

We doubt ourselves and believe that there is a rainbow around the corner, if only we knew which corner it was.  We happily pay anyone who claims to know in the hope that it will solve our problems and bring us to Nirvana.  It dices. It slices. 

But why would I bother to draw the analogy from the Times story to young lawyers looking for the secret to success?  Surely, you’ve fully vetted the backgrounds of the wealth of consultant available on the internet to show you how to maximize your secret potential, to establish a million dollar law practice and be home for dinner with the kids every night. 

You would never fall for a scam like these silly college kids and their desperate parents.  Never.

Serving Corporate Masters

During the discussion about the pending investigation of the actions of corporate officers and high level executives, my potential client informed me that the corporation would indemnify him for his legal fees.  The alarm went off.  While this is great for the client, who won’t be required to foot the cost of what would be an expensive, drawn out matter, it puts the lawyer into an awkward and unpleasant situation: corporate cog.

Many corporations have the means of circumventing the normal corporate process when it comes to professional services rendered to its officers and executives.  Some don’t.  The issues isn’t who we represent, and it’s made clear from the outset that we are personal counsel to the individual client, but that we thrust into the corporate world of vendor.  Be prepared to have to deal in the world of back office clerks, each with their own checklist of corporate requirements, none of whom care a whit about the fact that their entire world could implode at any moment.  It won’t move them an inch.

Three weeks and quite a few hours of my time were lost to playing footsie with clerks of varying intelligence and suffering from massive delusions.  An affirmative statement on Monday that everything was done and a check would be overnighted for receipt the next morning turned into a definitive assertion the next day that they only required 3 more forms to be filled out and they would assure that payment would be sent a week from Tuesday.  It’s as if nothing they said the day before ever happened.  And call them on it and they cover their butts like nobody’s business.  You can’t win an argument of reason with a clerk.  We don’t share the same reality.

As top executives sent emails demanding, then begging, that we get off the dime and commence cooperating with the various internal and external investigations, the clerks dragged their feet.  Do not set a fee based upon the work needed to represent the client; set a fee based upon the time wasted in dealing with clerks, or they will suck you dry.  For those criminal defense lawyers who have never billed hourly, and for those who proclaim the hourly fee is dead, this is time that bears no causal connection with any service required nor can be avoided.  As the corporate clerks demand your obedience, then only be exacting an hourly tribute can you survive. 

As I continued to receive emails from corporate executives and counsel requesting that I make myself available to them and stop delaying the progress of their efforts, I would calmly respond that no movement would happen until they, the Corporation, covered the retainer.  They would then shoot off emails down the food chain, demanding that they get things rolling.  Toward the bottom of the ladder, supervisors would respond that they were doing everything possible, shifting blame in every direction but their own.  It serves no purpose to question whether they were unmitigated liars, incompetents or psychopaths.  They weren’t going to lift a finger until they put a check mark next to every line on their grocery list, and each mark came only after the screwed up once or twice per line. 

Then again, I wasn’t going to lift a finger until the check arrived.  No, I don’t love the corporation.  No, I don’t care at all about their needs or procedures.  No, I don’t “trust” them.  If the powers in the corporation want to play pass the buck while the corporation burns, it’s no skin off my nose.  They are merely the entity funding the representation of my client.  As I succinctly explained to the grocery clerks, when told what I “must” do, I don’t work for the corporation. I don’t have to do anything, and they still have to indemnify my client because their Board of Directors said so. 

Of course, this was of no consequence when they insisted that a form had to be signed in red crayon instead of blue, even though they told you blue yesterday.  Yes, this was the nature of their very important demands.  That, for criminal defense lawyers unused to life in corporations, is the sort of stuff that is critically important to grocery clerks.

What makes all this most amusing is the angst and damage the corporation ultimately does to its own interests.  After three weeks of waiting, the check came in about midday on a Friday, at which point I immediately set to work and contacted all the various interested folks to advise them that I was now retained.  One such interested fellow was from a law firm conducting an internal investigation on behalf of the Board of Directors.  The same Board that ultimately oversaw the fine work of the lowliest clerk at accounts payable.

The lawyer, relieved that I finally called, emphatically explained to me that he absolutely had to meet with me the following Monday, as his mandate from the Board was to complete his initial investigation within a set time frame.  “Bummer,” I responded.  You see, I had plenty of time over the course of the past three weeks to set up meetings, perform my necessary background work, ramp up my representation, so that everything needed could be performed in a timely, even leisurely, fashion.  Except that his client’s clerks just couldn’t manage to send out the retainer check.  And so all that time was lost.

“But it HAS to be Monday,” he told me again.  “It just HAS to be Monday.” 

“Sorry”, I said, “but I can’t do it.  I have to be in court on Monday to start hearings.”

“Court!”  What do you mean ‘court’?” 

It’s that big granite building with the pillars in front.  No, my purpose wasn’t to insult him.  I understood his problem, but I really had to be in court and making his meeting just wasn’t in the cards.  I explained that I had been available to meet with him for weeks.  Weeks!  But that there were a couple of people deep within the bowels of his client who decided that the urgency of my representation and his investigation were secondary to their making marks next to lines on their grocery list, even though I explained to them that there were a bunch of lawyers and corporate officers waiting for me. 

The clerks didn’t care.  But that didn’t make their delay my emergency.  And it was awfully nervy for the lawyer to expect me to be readily available to suit his need, as if I’ve got nothing to do but be there at his beck and call.  I didn’t relish the idea of making the other lawyer’s life miserable, and would have accommodated him if possible.  But it’s not like they didn’t have three weeks to get it done and make everyone happy. 

Whether this will ultimately matter to the corporation is questionable.  Certainly it’s in my client’s best interest for me to be fully prepared before jumping into meetings to suit the time constraints of others.  But to the extent that this inconveniences everyone else engaged in the investigation and makes their work more difficult and problematic, it was entirely within the corporation’s power to deal with the delay of their own people.

I represent my client, no matter who is paying the bill.  Just remember when you take on a case where the legal fee is being paid via the , no matter how urgent the situation or how problematic the effect of delay, nothing moves any faster than the lowliest clerk with a checklist. 

If this displeases the corporation or its lawyers, then they really ought to have a talk with their own people.  And if they want to allow this ridiculous waste of time and effort to satisfy the grocery clerk gods, that’s their problem, not mine.