Author Archives: SHG

So Sotomayor

Early this morning, I twitted that Obama tapped Sonia Sotomayor of the 2d Circuit for the Supreme Court.  I may have been the first to twit it. I may not.  It’s hard to say.  As I’ve not been told that I’ve won a prize by the twitter gods, I don’t care.

So now the usual suspects do the things that usual suspects do.

From Wendy Long at the National Reviews Bench Memos:


Judge Sotomayor is a liberal judicial activist of the first order who thinks her own personal political agenda is more important that the law as written.  She thinks that judges should dictate policy, and that one’s sex, race, and ethnicity ought to affect the decisions one renders from the bench.
There you have it.  Can we now go back to our regular show?  Judge Sotomayor will be confirmed, as she should be, and the rest of the chest-thumping will be quickly filed for use when the next nominee is named.  That’s the great part about fill-in-the-blanks opposition statements.  They’re reusable!

When You Say No, They Say . . .

Seth Godin has the ability to express things that the rest of us feel but can’t quite put into words.  One example is his recent post, entitled “Eternal September,” where he wrote:


The Internet has been stuck in September ever since. Every day, new people show up at your blog, on Facebook, everywhere. Every day it’s a whole new crop that need to figure out what RSS is and how to subscribe. Every day there are people who spam their address book because it feels like a fine thing to do, then learn their lesson and never do it again. There are new people who need to learn the proper etiquette for interacting on your site. Can you imagine if the real world worked this way? If people walking into your store had never been to a store before? If drivers on the highway had never driven on a highway before?

It’s going to be a long time before the medium stabilizes enough for the newbies to catch up, so the only alternative is to accept that it’s always September.


I tried to make this point, but was so inartful that Bobby Fredericks handed me a good whupping to remind me that my effort stunk.  This is why I pay close attention to Godin’s advice, where the philosophical underpinnings of dealing with humans traverses the pragmatic demands of defending them.  Much as I may not care for marketing, there is much to learn from those who truly understand people.

When Godin explained why it was important to have the guts to say “no”, it raised a red flag.


If you’ve got talent, people want more of you. They ask you for this or that or the other thing. They ask nicely. They will benefit from the insight you can give them.

The choice: You can dissipate your gift by making the people with the loudest requests temporarily happy, or you can change the world by saying ‘no’ often.


Not that I claim possession of any gift, but people ask a lot of me.  Emails, telephone calls, letters, comments on the blawg, people want things.  A culture of expectation of free legal advice has grown up around the internet, fostered by things like Avvo Answers, where self-promoting lawyers give inapplicable answers to stupid questions at no charge.  People need help, and have come to believe that it’s their right to get it.  Now.  From me.  Or you.  But from whoever they ask, they expect an answer. Now.

At first blush, Seth’s point seemed like a variation on the old saw, no one will buy the cow if you give the milk away for free.  But his point goes further, in that we have only so much time and energy available to do what we do, and do it well, and if we spend it being “nice guys,” it’s not there for us when we need it.  Time and energy are scare resources, not to be squandered.

Being a curmudgeon, I’m not inclined to accede to unsolicited demands.  Loud people don’t bother me much, and I have little fear of saying “no”.  But this does come at a price.  Now it should be pointed out that many of these demands come from people who are well outside my normal area of practice, whether geographically or substantively, such that I couldn’t help them even if I was so inclined.  Others are people who just have it in their heads that they deserve a free ride.  There are a lot of people who feel so entitled.

The demands often come accompanied by lengthy descriptions of their circumstances, whether in writing or verbally, without the slightest thought to the fact that they are giving a stranger an enormous amount of personal, often damaging, information, and expecting a stranger to spend the time to read and digest the story of their life.   Try to interrupt them on the phone and get the first whiff of their vehemence, as they inform you that you aren’t giving them the attention they are due.  Just shut up and listen, Mr. Lawyer, and I’ll get to my point when I’m damn good and ready.

It’s not the asking that surprises me in the least, but the reaction to hearing the “no” that I find so disturbing.  A fairly typical response to “I’m sorry, but I can’t help you,” is


You lawyers are all greedy scum, I hope you all die.
Or some variation of this theme.  It’s both curious and upsetting. 

I believe that most lawyers who practice criminal defense do so out of a desire to help people.  We feel empathy.  We understand how the system can destroy lives.  We appreciate how you feel.  But we cannot be the answer for everyone who asks.  It’s not just because some of us do this for a living, but there are far too many of you than there are of me.  Even if I was inclined to do so, I couldn’t.  Saying “no” is a necessity of self-preservation.

So while Seth Godin is absolutely correct in saying that it is imperative that we have the fortitude to say “no”, and appreciate why need to do so, it comes as a price.  For most of us, it hurts to have to turn away anyone in need.  We realize that there are many out there who truly need our help, who can’t find the help they need, and who do so not out of a misguided sense of entitlement but out of necessity of their own.  We want to help people.  It’s what we do.

But we can’t help everyone.  It would be great if those who called or wrote understood this, but it’s unlikely that many will care much about our feelings or circumstances.  They are too busy thinking about them to worry about us, and that’s understandable given the nature of the problems with which we deal.  But you’ve still got to do it.  And when you are attacked for it, you need to shrug it off and accept it as part of the job.

The Time To Speak (Update)

One of the most underappreciated skills necessary at trial is the objection.  There’s no “objection” class in law school, and as the test by fire of the Socratic method falls from favor, the emphasis is placed on a lawyer’s deeper, more deliberative process in lieu of the ability to jump up at just the right moment and forcefully state one of the most critical words in the lawyer lexicon: Objection.

An example of how critical this skill can be appeared before United States District Judge Kenneth Karas in the trial of Wayne Simoes, the Yonkers cop on trial for slam-dunking Irma Marquez.  From the Completely Legal Blog at LoHud, the Journal News, and with one of the more interesting titles, Simoesus Interruptus,

And Judge Kenneth Karas said he was expecting an objection from the prosecution when defense lawyer Andrew Quinn asked video expert Grant Fredericks if he thought Simoes threw or dropped Marquez. Fredericks said he dropped her. Prior to the trial, Karas had ruled that Fredericks wouldn’t be allowed to offer his interpretation of that, just what was happening in each of the 199 frames from the video of the incident .

But the prosecution didn’t object when Quinn asked Fredericks that question. Karas said after the jury left the room today that he expected an objection from the prosecution team of Anna Skotko, Cynthia Dunne, and Benjamin Torrance. But none came. Quinn said he asked because he felt the prosecution had opened the door with its cross-examination of Fredericks. The judge didn’t think so.

They should have seen this coming a mile away.  It was so painfully obvious, that there was no point to the defense putting an expert on the stand but for his opinion as to what the video of Simoes dropping Marquez showed.  Of course, this is precisely what an expert cannot provide, the ultimate conclusion of the jury.

“I don’t know why you didn’t object,” the judge said to [AUSA ] Skotko.

“It came out of left field,” Skotko said.

The United States Attorneys Office for the Southern District of New York is well regarded.  It’s supposed to be one of the best.  This is not a bright spot.  Let’s assume for the sake of argument that neither Skotko, nor the other two attorneys on her team, had any idea that the defense expert was there to tell the jury that the video showed the exact opposite of what their very own eyes saw when repeatedly watching the video of Simoes playing Hulk Hogan.  To do otherwise would be to suggest that the government would sabotage its own case against a police officer, and that could never happen.

The ability to know when to make an objection isn’t a function of preparedness or foresight.  The need often comes “from left field,” with either an unexpected line of questioning or a question formed in an unexpected manner.  On top of that comes the tactical considerations, such as whether the objection will appear to the jury to be disingenuous, a means of keeping evidence from the jury that is relevant.  Regular people believe that lawyers use such technicalities as the rules of evidence to prevent them from knowing the truth.  While we know that these “technicalities” have reason behind them, to prevent the jury from hearing unreliable evidence that may taint their understanding, their perceptions may differ.

In a split second, we are called upon to make the decision whether to stand up and object, or sit quietly and let the questioning continue uninterrupted.  This doesn’t fall in the “glib” abyss that makes lawprofs shun the Socratic Method, and yet demands a measure of speedy analytical decision-making that can produce a monumental shift in the direction of a trial.  Fail to make a critical objection and the evidence comes in, full speed and deadly.  There’s no second chance.  There’s no “unringing” the bell.  It’s in there.

I’ve addressed the tactical use of objections in the past, as well as the conflicts between presentation to a jury versus preservation for appeal.  It’s far more art than science, and comes from trial experience combined with a viable sense of how the entirety of the trial is playing before the jury.  These considerations, however, were absent from this glaring failure at the Simoes trial.  There was no conceivable purpose to not objecting to a witness, an expert whose purpose was suspect from the outset, telling the jury what they see in a videotape.  The jury has eyes; the rest is argument.

There is no explanation for the failure to object called “it came out of left field.”  The targets of objections regularly come as a surprise.  If they didn’t, we would dispose of them in limine.  No need to wait until the jury is watching to have the car crash.  AUSA Skotka’s explanation falls flat; worse than flat, it is fundamentally unlawyerly.  What we do is object to things coming out of left field.  If you can’t handle the surprise question, then you have no business sitting at counsel table at trial.

Of course, mistakes happen.  No one is entitled to a perfect trial, mostly because there has never been a perfect trial.  There are just too many variables, the significance of which is unknown until after the jury returns its verdict.  If the verdict is favorable, you made the right decisions.  If not, you didn’t, ignoring the fact that even the best trial performance cannot guarantee an outcome.  It’s just the measure of sound judgment as viewed from the chair of appellate counsel or judge.

But the failure to object to the testimony of Simoes’ expert doesn’t fall into any tactical pigeonhole.  Nor can it be shrugged off as a reasonable mistake.  It was a demonstration of critical ineptitude, shocking incompetence.  The failure to object was inexcusable.

If we take Skotka’s explanation at face value, that she was surprised by this obvious question, does it reflect an individual prosecutor’s inability to handle a trial?  Does it reflect a fall from grace in the Southern District U.S. Attorney’s office?  Does it reflect young lawyers coming to the courthouse without having learned the basic skills necessary to try a case?

And if we refuse to believe that any lawyer couldn’t figure out that this was one of those unbelievably glaring moments to stand up and, in a stentorian voice, proclaim “objection”, then what does it reflect?

Update:  Via LoHud, apparently there was a pre-trial ruling precluding the defense expert from testifying that the video shows that Simoes did not throw Irma Marquez to the ground, and the government got a second bite at dealing with their screw up:

Yesterday, Judge Kenneth Karas instructed the jury to disregard defense expert Grant Fredericks’ conclusion about Simoes’ actions. Before the trial, Karas had ruled that Fredericks would not be allowed to offer such an opinion. Prosecutors asked the judge after testimony ended Friday to strike Fredericks’ statement from the record.

A special thanks to the Journal News for such a great reporting job.  Nothing like getting the details straight the day after.  Of course, it didn’t stop defense counsel from trying to push the envelope.

Andrew Quinn, Simoes’ lawyer, accused federal prosecutors of failing to properly investigate the case, building a prosecution solely on a video that wasn’t properly scrutinized by experts.

“We had to do what the government didn’t do in the first place,” he said.

Maybe tomorrow we’ll find out if there was an objection to this portion of the summation, after the judge struck the testimony.

H/T Reader George Cotz

Can 80 Million Slackoisie Be Wrong?

Stephanie West Allen at Idealawg posts about a group, calling themselves 80 Million Strong, with plans to seize control this summer. 


Without strong advocates, this generation will continue to be underserved by policy solutions. This cannot remain the status quo. The Student Association for Voter Empowerment (SAVE), Mobilize.org, and the Roosevelt Institution are convening a coalition and summit entitled 80 Million Strong for Young American Jobs, named for the 80 million members of our Millennial generation, each and every one of whom deserves a decent, quality job.


Whenever someone claims that they “deserve” something, it compels the question, why?  For all their bravado, it seems that the Slackoisie are terribly un- and underemployed, and they aren’t happy about it.  A “decent, quality job” is their birthright.  That’s why they deserve one.  Each and every one of them.

Stephanie asks a question in return:


And what does the workforce deserve from the Millennials? Am I hearing the one-sided, one-way entitlement demands from them again?
This past week has given us a wealth of insight into what our children have to say.  From the WSJ Law Blog to the ABA Journal to the mother-lode, What About Clients?, we have tried to help enlighten those of our youth who have failed to mature sufficiently to grasp why they, for better or worse, will most assuredly get what they “deserve”.  Unfortunately, most have reacted in a way that clearly proves the point to their elders, while believing that their responses are brilliant and presuasive.

Does the Slackoisie really believe that they have so much to offer that they are in a position to make demands?  Why yes, that’s exactly what they believe. 

Let me add my question to the mix:  Do we really need 80 million Barristas, each complaining that the tip wasn’t big enough?

Memorial Day 2009

Over the weekend, a brief report was aired on the cable news station that just happened to be on television as I plopped down in my Parisian leather club chair to take a breather about four young Americans who died this week in Iraq.  Does anyone in America remember that there are young Americans dying in Iraq anymore? 

Our current wars seem like such old news, disinteresting and  passé.  We’ve elected a new president who wants us out, though we still have Americans on the ground in foreign lands waiting for a seat on the plane home.  Some have died.  More will die.  But we’ve moved on.

Last Memorial day, I wrote:


Before considering what to write, or whether to write at all, about Memorial Day, I took a look at my post from last year.  It was a brief post, but made its point:


The catch phrase today is that freedom is not free.  But what is this freedom that is worthy fighting, and dying, for?  To show our respect for those who gave their lives for freedom, those of us who remain should be willing to stand up for that freedom and defend it.  We don’t fight for a particular President.  We don’t fight for a political party.  We don’t fight for some transitory policy.  We fight for enduring freedom.  Don’t give up the fight.  Take a moment today to think about it.  Others have given their lives for it.  It’s not much to do.

A year has past, and nothing has changed.   Young people are still dying in Iraq, and we’re still listening to people whose lives are not at risk debate about whether and when they can be brought home.  We’ve paid the price, but are still watching freedom ebb away.


Is it not heartbreaking to know that another year has past, and yet we’ve accomplished so little?  If you have any feelings about the men and women who have suffered and died in the defense of our nation, then consider what we can do to give meaning to their loss.  Each of us has an opportunity every day to honor those whose sacrifice dwarfs our own.  To honor those who have died in the service of the United States of America, do something to protect and defend our freedom.  It won’t kill you.

If nothing else, think of someone other than yourself today. 

The Young and the Hapless

The morning after the story broke about how our government saved us from another fiendish terrorist plot, I just happened to be riding the train with a buddy who works as a reporter on TV.  We asked each other questions about the news, since we tend to share nagging doubts whenever our government announces how it’s done something wonderful. 

From the very outset, it appeared that this was a manufactured crime.  Four losers, who couldn’t manage to knock off a liquor store if their lives depended on it, and one prison rat were the players.  The rat planned the scheme, gave them the means, and pushed them forward.  That’s what it looked like to us.  My fear was that nobody, but nobody, would have the guts to call them on it.  My buddy had the same fear, with the 6 o’clock report parroting the government’s press release about how they saved us, again, from terrorism.

He was busily typing something into his Crackberrry to his producer, and I said to him, “It’s early.  We don’t really know much about this and it’s possible that it wasn’t a total scam.  Don’t get too crazy.”  After all, he’s mainstream media, but cares too much and thinks too hard to go with the flow.

News reports were gushing praise on the government.  Mayor Bloomberg took the lead in praising the arrests, with religious leaders of both stripes fawning over the fine work.  As the New York Times told it:


“This latest attempt to attack our freedoms shows that the homeland security threats against New York City are sadly all too real and underscores why we must remain vigilant in our efforts to prevent terrorism,” Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg said in a statement.

The charges against the four men represent some of the most significant allegations of domestic terrorism in some time, and come months into a new presidential administration, as President Obama grapples with the question of how to handle detainees at the Guantánamo Bay camp in Cuba.

Scary stuff.  Great work stopping it.  Or what?  More from the Times :


“It’s hard to envision a more chilling plot,” Assistant U.S. Atty. Eric Snyder said in court Thursday. He described all four suspects as “eager to bring death to Jews.”

Let’s try to imagine a more chilling plot, shall we.  How about one where the participants actually came up with the idea on their own, had the means and skills to execute it, didn’t depend on the government to provide it with absolutely everything needed to pull it off, and didn’t do every single act under the auspices of the government and its agent.  In other words, this plot was bogus from the word go, with a snitch trying to work off his prison sentence by finding the dumbest mutts around and manufacturing a terrorist plot that never was.  The opportunity for politicians to praise themselves was endless.  The appreciation of a fearful public was palpable.  They saved us again from this “chilling plot.”

Robert Dreyfuss of The Nation ripped the head off this pathetic plot in this post at Alternet.



[I]t’s hard to imagine a stupider, less competent, and less important plot. The four losers were ensnared by a creepy FBI agent who hung around the mosque in upstate New York until he found what he was looking for.


So a creepy thug buttonholes people at a mosque, foaming at the mouth about violence and jihad? This is law enforcement? Just imagine if someone did this at a local church, or some synagogue. And the imam says the people “believed he was a government agent.”


Preying on these losers, none of whom were apparently actual Muslims, the “confidential informant” orchestrated the acquisition of a disabled Stinger missile to shoot down military planes and cooked up a wild scheme about attacking a Jewish center in the Bronx.

The 6 o’clock report on my buddy’s network played it straight, giving the government’s press release full play, falling into lockstep with the rest of the MSM in its reporting on how we foiled this “chilling” terrorist plot.  But my buddy wasn’t fooled for a moment.  How wonderful that our government is saving us from the terrorist plots it creates.  Which of our rights will be sacrificed next to protect us from these homegrown terrorists?


Troy Davis Tests Our Faith

The impending execution of Troy Davis tests our belief that, for better or worse, our criminal justice system has a soul.  We may soon find out that it doesn’t.

In the New York Times, Bob Herbert reminds us of what is at stake.


It’s bad enough that we still execute people in the United States. It’s absolutely chilling that we’re willing to do it when we’re not even sure we’ve got the right person in our clutches.

This case tests our love of formality over reality, process over substance.  It’s not that Troy Davis has been proven innocent, but that faith in his guilt has been shaken to the core.  He may not be guilty.  Had this been the case at his trial, one would be compelled to contend that he could not be convicted because guilt was not proven beyond a reasonable doubt. 

But as happens too often, the effort to challenge the allegations that Davis murdered Mark Allen MacPhail didn’t start in earnest until after the jury verdict was rendered.  At that point, the world turns around and the burden falls on the defendant to prove it wrong.  That’s our process, and frankly there’s good reason for the shift in burdens.  Jury verdicts must mean something or nothing will ever be resolved and concluded.  Closure, both for the benefit of the victim and society, is necessary.

What distinguishes this case isn’t that 7 of 9 witnesses have recanted their testimony that Troy Davis was the shooter.  There have been plenty of other cases where witnesses, after the fact, admitted that they lied.  Lying on the witness stand is a time-honored tradition on our criminal justice system, which is why we so studiously pretend it doesn’t happen.

The Troy Davis case is distinguished by the fact that, despite the doubt that has been shown, the State of Georgia, the 11th Circuit, the United States Supreme Court, will sit idly by and watch Troy Davis be put to death.

This isn’t just the hand-wringing of someone naturally inclined to give a defendant the benefit of the doubt.  There are some others who see things this way whose sympathies are beyond reproach.



An extraordinary group of 27 former judges and prosecutors joined in an amicus brief in support of the petition. Among those who signed on were William Sessions, the former director of the F.B.I.; Larry Thompson, a U.S. attorney general from 2001-2003; the former Congressman Bob Barr, who was the U.S. attorney for the Northern District of Georgia from 1986-1990; and Rudolph Gerber, who was an Arizona trial and court of appeals judge from 1979-2001.

This is one of those instances where a law enforcement or prosecutorial background is important, since a trench lawyer like me, and a liberal columnist like Herbert, are easily dismissed.  It’s hard to put William Sessions in the same pigeonhole.

The number of appeals is often raised as evidence that Troy Davis has received more than his share of due process, with each court rejecting his efforts.  It’s true that he can’t complain that they shut the courthouse doors on him, and that he’s had many opportunities to present his argument.  But this brings little comfort, as these hearings and arguments have fundamentally missed the heart of the issue in Davis.  Using time-honored tradition, the one that places the onus on Davis to prove his innocence, he will lose.  If he has 100 chances, he will lose 100 times.  Post-conviction proof of innocence, in the absence of DNA, is usually impossible, which is why this became a time-honored tradition.  

But no one is asking for the court to cut Davis loose, plus send him a letter of apology.  That isn’t the point at all.  The point is that Troy Davis, given all that is now known and trying our utmost not to entangle our soul in the line of precedent designed to prevent a conviction from being undone, should not be put to death.

Perhaps the thing that people hate most about the law and lawyers is our inflexibility in understanding when technical procedure, which may guide us well the vast majority of the time, fails under a peculiar set of circumstances.  People believe that our system of justice has the capacity, at its core, to be just.  Not that it happens, necessarily, but that it can happen.  Troy Davis takes this belief to its very edge, the logical extreme as we like to argue.

Will we allow a man whose guilt has been placed in doubt to be put to death?  Our soul depends on the answer.

Seeing It Through The Cops’ Eyes, Part 2

In an effort to appreciate the “new professionalism” that guides our police, as noted by Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia whenever he explains why the old sanctions to prevent cops from beating people are no longer needed, it’s critical that we keep on top of new law enforcement tactics.  From Packratt at his new blog,  Injustice Everywhere, I learned of a new one:  Distraction.

Richard Rodriguez fled in a car from El Monte police, who followed in high speed pursuit.  He abandoned the car and ran, and they continued to follow.  Eventually, the chase came to an end, with Rodriguez giving up by lying supine on the ground, spread eagle.  He was very wrong to flee as he did.  And apparently quite unfamiliar with the tactics of new professionalism.


Officer George Fierro was the first to run up to Rodriguez and, in mid stride, kicked him square in the face while he laid prone waiting to be arrested. A lawyer for the police union in El Monte claims that this kick is a “Distraction Technique” that all officers are trained to perform and are justified to use by departmental policy… apparently so is the tactic of repeatedly hitting a prone suspect in the back with a flashlight and instructing one’s K9 unit to bite his legs as two other officers proceeded to do when they arrived shortly after Fierro.

While the description is fine, the “impact” of the “impact” is better made visually.  To save you some time, the first 5:25 is video of the high speed chase.  If you’re a fan of chases, enjoy, but otherwise jump ahead.



As the high fives and back pats suggest, the El Monte police officers were quite pleased with themselves.  They caught the guy, and this time it was the guy they were trying to catch.  It’s fair cause for celebration, as it happens so infrequently.  But more to the point, they have effectively employed the “new professionalism” tactic of the “Distraction Technique.”

In an interview shortly after video of the arrest made the rounds in the media, the El Monte police chief appeared to agree with this assessment by saying that a spread-eagle suspected is a threat worthy of this “distraction technique” if that suspect moves his head to see where the footsteps rapidly approaching him are headed… which was right towards his face.

From the cop’s perspective, Rodriguez (who by all accounts is about as unsympathetic a fellow as you will find) could have been “playing possum,” lying there awaiting the officers’ approach, and then attacking.  When this was posted at Carols Miller’s Photography is Not a Crime, a commenter, LEO (that’s an abbreviation for Law Enforcement Officer, for those who might confuse it with an astrological adherent), explained :



It’s called “playing dead” folks. Jason is 100% correct. It may appear to an untrained civilian that this man surrendered, but he can easily turn on the officers. Every officer knows this and many have personally witnessed “surrendered” suspects who turn out to have done anything but. This was a clean bust and what the officer did was both right and necessary.

This isn’t Snow White here the officers captured. This is a vicious criminal who already demonstrated his callous disregard for human life in his dangerous pursuit. That told the officers this man is highly dangerous.
Another commenter, 10-18 (police code for an urgent assignment), offered this explanation :



This is a terrific example of civilians who don’t understand lawful, necessary police tactics commenting on something they don’t understand.

Once the suspect was cuffed, he walked to the police cruiser on his own two feet. He has no head injuries. A dangerous suspect must be subdued as soon as possible. You don’t wait around to make things all warm and cuddly for violent felons. You move as fast as you can, just like if you found a cobra in your baby’s crib. LEO is absolutely right.

The kick was completely justified.
The gist of our new professionals is clear.  We, meaning those of us who do not put our life on the line everyday to protect people from the forces of evil,  don’t get it.  They do.  As with Part 1, I don’t doubt the sincerity of the cops’ belief that this was an appropriate, perhaps even necessary, use force.  Rather, it is the disconnect between what us “civilians” see and what cops see.

To the extent that we chose to believe that we are all on the same page in our understanding of what is happening on the streets with those to whom we entrust a shield and gun, the evidence is otherwise.  We do not see the same thing.  We do not share a common sense of where the line is drawn between legitimate use of police force and excess.  We do not see the same images and see the same thing.

It’s one thing for criminals, those who we condemn for the harm they do to others, to deserve our moral condemnation for their actions.  It’s another when those actions are performed by our police.  Criminals are not the measure of legitimacy, and yet our police believe with all their heart that we, who they call “civilians”, are the ones who don’t get it.  If this reflects the social compact, then we do not have a meeting of the minds.

Seeing It Through The Cops’ Eyes, Part 1

Most of us assume that when we see an act played out in front of us, we’re all seeing the same thing.  Of course, we know intellectually that there are some variations in perspective, but we generally believe that no reasonable person can see the same thing we do yet arrive at a diametrically opposed conclusion.  Wrongo.

Via Injustice Everywhere, Packratt’s new blog, what happened to Christopher Harris in Seattle is both a horror story and a cautionary tale.  From the Seattle Times :



The deputies, who are assigned to Metro Transit, were working the graveyard shift patrolling downtown bus routes and shelters. They were searching for a suspect in connection with the beating and stabbing of a man at a convenience store, but detectives later determined Harris was wrongly identified by a witness and wasn’t involved in the assault.


Seattle lawyer Sim Osborn, who has been retained by Christopher Harris’ family, said both deputies wore black uniforms and yelled to Harris from a half-block away in a darkened alley. He said one witness reported the two deputies didn’t identify themselves as law-enforcement officers until after Harris began running down the alley sometime after 1 a.m. Sunday. Osborn said Harris stopped running a few blocks away, apparently after realizing the two men chasing him were deputies.


“He was blindsided,” Osborn said of Harris. “It was not a tackle but an absolute, bone-crushing hit.” Harris’ head struck a concrete wall. Since then, he’s been in a coma and on life support at Harborview Medical Center.
There’s a dispute as to whether the cops identified themselves in the first place, or left Harris to think at the outset that he was being chased by black-clothed attackers.  If he knew they were cops, then he shouldn’t have run.  But once he stopped running and posed no threat, the running officer continued toward him, slamming him so that his head struck the wall behind him causing him grave injury.



At this point we stop and take account.  Excessive force?  Needless violence?  An officer who went one giant step too far?  Bear in mind, Harris wasn’t the man they were seeking.  He was mistakenly identified and had nothing to do with any assault.  Except as the recipient of a blow that will change, if not end, his life.  We can all agree that the officer should not have delivered the final blow, right?

Not right.  Not even close, as demonstrated in comment after comment by a group of men who, like this officer, consider the people on the street a crash dummy to sacrifice to the God of their own safety.  If the pain of watching Harris isn’t bad enough, consider these comments from that safe-haven forum for our boys in blue, OfficerOne.com :


























Posted by lmpd2050 on Saturday, May 23, 2009 11:31 AM Pacific  Report Abuse
Great job Deputy! That suspect FLED on foot and turned toward you. What were his intentions when he turned, fight, weapon, surrender? We may never know but you did right and will be vindicated! I wonder what kind of criminal record this “innocent” person that fled uniformed Police has?











Posted by pdsmr726 on Saturday, May 23, 2009 11:01 AM Pacific  Report Abuse
I see nothing wrong with the Deputy’s actions. Of course the family and money hungry attorney are going to say the video doesn’t show everything. Of course it does, the suspect ran and the deputy caught him and handcuffed him. Theres nothing more to it. I would of done the same thing. A reminder to suspects who run from the police, when you get caught, you should only go to jail tired and hurt. Good job deputy.











Posted by ltfrazier146 on Saturday, May 23, 2009 09:40 AM Pacific  Report Abuse
I saw nothing wrong. The good guys did it right. As soon as the knucklehead was down, they moved in and cuffed the suspect, done deal. Bad guy goes to jail and the good guys live on to fight another day. One day people will learn that stop means stop. Unfortunate the guy got hurt, but he made the decision to run from the law. I really wonder what is was the guy threw down just before he was apprehended?











Posted by bmoc_57 on Saturday, May 23, 2009 04:37 AM Pacific  Report Abuse
Screw that money hungry lawyer. If we are justified in hitting someone, then we are justified in hitting someone with 110 of all we have. Good job Officer!











Posted by Lanco on Saturday, May 23, 2009 04:01 AM Pacific  Report Abuse
DEFINITELY throws something. I agree…looks like a bag of dope. I will be following this as closely as possible. GOOD JOB Deputy.











Posted by jscrivner on Friday, May 22, 2009 10:43 PM Pacific  Report Abuse
No apology necessary. Clean hit and good takedown. So sorry that this idiot got hurt, but if he would have just followed the reasonable commands of the guys with the badges and guns, it never would have happened. I love the attorney suggesting that the deputies could have Tased the idiot. Of course in all the Taser related lawsuits, the bottom feeders claim that it would have been less forceful if the LEO had used unarmed tactics to take dirtbag down. CanРІР‚в„ўt have it both ways, guys. Bottom line, this was a justified and appropriate use of force. Of course, Seattle (and by extension, King County) is so full of cop-hating liberals, in both the population and government, that this cop is going to come under a lot of pressure. LetРІР‚в„ўs all hope that he doesnРІР‚в„ўt become another victim of anti-law enforcement hysteria.
The comments go on in the same vein for quite a while, without a dissenting voice in the bunch.  A clean hit.  A deserving perp.  And of course, he deserved it because (a) he ran, (b) he tossed something, (c) he probably has a criminal record, the big three reasons why cops feel entitled to take action to subdue.  The fourth reason, of course, is so obvious as to be unworthy of mention:  Because any circumstances where there is any potential for a cop to be hurt justifes hurting the citizen first.  The first rule of policing: Get home alive.

It’s unclear whether Harris’ flight was appropriate, there being a dispute whether the officers yelled out “police” before chasing him.  But even giving the officers the benefit of the doubt on this one, the absence of humanity on the back end should cause any viewer to feel both deeply saddened by the cops reactions as well as deeply afraid.  It is a resoundingly clear view that our lives, the lives of those they are paid to protect and serve, are subject to sacrifice with the full support of the brotherhood. 

As the comments make clear, there is a depth of loathing by officers toward citizens (not to mention lawyers, but they are on firmer ground there) that makes them view this video and see a world that eludes the rest of us.   We cannot improve our condition until we understand and appreciate that a primary difference exists between what cops see and what seems obvious to everyone else.  I don’t think the commenters at PoliceOne are being disingenuous; I believe that they have enunciated exactly what they see on this video.  I believe that their vision places us in a state of perpetual fear that our most vicious assault will come from those we believe are there to protect us, and that afterward, they will applaud themselves for the harm they have done.

A few commenters at least felt badly that Harris was so badly injured, though he still deserved it, as opposed to those who called Harris “dirtbag”.  Is this the best we can hope for?  Will we ever share the same image?

H/T Karl Mansour at Blue Must Be True.

A Fair Trade?

Doug Berman at Sentencing Law and Policy has posted one of the great questions in criminal law.


“Is 500 serious crimes worth the freedom of 50,000 offenders?”

In many respects, the answer to this question is at the root of much of our policy decisions with the criminal justice system.  Recognizing that a question of this magnitude requires some fleshing out, Doug notes:


My students know that I say that the right answer to every good question is “it depends,” and I think that this is the right answer to [the questioner’s] great question.  First, of course, we need some sense of what “serious” crimes are hypothetically being prevented by denying freedom 50,000 offenders. 

[W]e also have the fundamental question of whether this hypo sets up a false choice because of the other costs of denying freedom to 50,000 offenders.  Specifically, at current rates, it could cost well over $2,000,000,000 deny this freedom for just one year.  I would think spending that $2 billion on additional cops (or better health care and schooling) could prevent even more serious crimes.  Plus, of course, there is the (abstract?) cost to freedom and liberty for the 49,500 offenders (and all who know them) from being locked up to prevent others from committing crimes.
Many would answer the question by quibbling with the details, which of course blinds us from the bottom line.  If we limit the definition of serious crimes to the basic malum in se stuff, murder, rape, assault, where do we draw the line.  If we were able to reduce the cost of incarceration, what “price” would be a fair trade for 500 serious crimes?  If $2 billion is too expensive, would $100 million be acceptable?

Then, of course, there is the head game that flows from how personally we take the question: If we, or our loved one, were the victim of one of these serious crime, there would be no cost too high to stop it.  But if the victim is someone we don’t know, part of that amorphous group of people who are the victims of crime currently, would we think differently?

This is not only an amazing difficult question to answer, and answer honestly, but the type of question that lawmakers and voters must ponder to arrive at the tipping point where “tough on crime” has gotten tough enough, or too tough.

In a perfect world, there would be no crime.  Of course, in that same perfect world, we would have no reason to incarcerate anyone since no one would do anything worthy of incarceration.  But it’s an imperfect world, and people do harm others with regularity.  As the debate rages about whether mass imprisonment, at monumental expense, is the right solution, there comes a point when we need to decide when enough is enough.

Not so easy, is it?