Author Archives: SHG

Why We’ll Never Know

Police Officer Andrew P. Dunton will never be the same.  In an instant, a black man with a gun turned after Dunton yelled “police, drop the gun.”  Did he yell that?  Did Omar Edwards turn? Could Dunton have done something differently so that Police Officer Edwards wouldn’t be dead by his six shots? 

The story is everywhere, Whether the true story will ever be known is another matter.  The fact is that in a flash, two decisions were made on dark street in Harlem, one by each officer.  One of the decisions was wrong, but which one will depend on who you talk to.  Under the circumstances, the stories could all be true, as far as the witnesses to the event are concerned.  It’s almost impossible when shots ring out unexpectedly in the night to get the details straight.  The mind plays games to make sense out of situations that make no sense.

One television news report noted that the New York Police Department patrol guide has a policy to deal with this situation.  The police provides that the burden is on the off-duty officer to stand motionless and not turn when he hears the on-duty cop yell “police”.  It’s a policy that makes perfect sense, since the on-duty cop has no idea that the guy with the gun is a cop as well.  The problem is that it defies human nature. 

The off-duty cop, in this case Edwards, is pumped with adrenaline chasing the perp.  His focus is on getting the guy in front of him.  Suddenly, from behind him, he hears something that his brain tells him he ought to pay attention to.  But his mind wasn’t on the unanticipated shout from behind, but the guy in front.  It doesn’t quite register.  He hears it, but doesn’t really hear it.  It takes a moment to process.  So he turns . . .

Officer Dunton sees an unidentified man with gun running down a dark street.  He yells “police, drop your gun.”  What else can he yell (ignoring minor variations on the theme)?  The man with the gun turns toward him.  Maybe a full turn.  Maybe just a partial turn.  But any turn puts the aim of that gun closer to his heart.  He need not wait for the muzzle flash to decide what to do.  He fires six rounds at the gun pointed toward him.

It’s a conundrum.  We won’t know what Dunton actually yelled.  We won’t know what Edwards actually heard.  We won’t know what role, if any, the fact that Edwards was black played in Dunton’s decision.  At this point, everyone is playing catch-up, trying to piece things together in a way that causes the least exacerbation of the damage.  But none of it resolves the basic conundrum.  The policy sounds right, but doesn’t work.  Policy doesn’t supplant human experience.  Policy doesn’t trump human nature.

None of the post-hoc efforts to sort out this disaster strike me as credible.  The fix is always in when a disaster happens and it turns out that the dead body is a cop.  When it’s not a cop, they check his rap sheet so they can demean the dead man because of his priors.  That way, the public is informed that his death at the hand of a cop is no big deal.  He was a worthless criminal anyway.  That doesn’t work when the dead man is a cop.

But the needless death of a cop is no more, nor less, tragic than the death of any other human being.  And so we share in the grief of Officer Omar Edwards death as we do with any other person who was killed by mistake.  It’s unfortunate that the need to make it appear that no fault can be levied will cause us to gloss over the problems that gave rise to this tragic mistake.  It’s happened before and it will happen again, until someone figures out a better way to address a black man with a gun on the streets of Harlem.

Nino’s “Things That Rarely Happen”

In both the  Montejo and Ventris decisions, one of the substantive foundational explanations offered for overruling Michigan v. Jackson was, as Justice Antonin Scalia stated, that there would be “few if any” confessions resulting from post-appointment of counsel badgering by police.  Now I’m a fan of Nino’s as much as any criminal defense lawyer.  Heck, more than most.  But he doesn’t have a clue how life works on the street.

It didn’t take long for the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, to make the point, taking his cue from Dallas’ favorite son, Robert Guest.  From the Texas prosecutor website, some helpful internal ethics advice:

From Lisa Tanner:


So here is a question that’s come up among lawyers and officers from other states on a listserve I’m on.

Near as I can tell, it looks like SCOTUS has said that the police can initiate contact with and take a run at talking to a suspect/defendant, even if he is represented by counsel, so long as he clearly and unequivocally waives his right to silence and counsel. Right?

I, probably like everyone else on this board, get asked pretty regularly by officers to weigh in on whether they can take a run at interviewing a suspect/defendant. And if the guy is known to be represented, the standard answer is, of course, that he’s absolutely off limits (unless he should happen to initiate the contact himself, but that’s a whole ‘nuther issue). Now, under Jackson, it seems that the standard answer must change.

But, here’s where it seems to get tricky:

Disciplinary Rule 4.02 says that we cannot communicate or cause or encourage another to communicate with a person we know to be represented by counsel about the subject of that representation unless it is consented to by the representing lawyer or is “authorized by law”….

So how does that factor in? It seems to me that if we advise an officer that it’s now ok to take that run at that suspect that we know is represented, we might just be running afoul of 4.02, or does the “authorized by law” language kick in and permit it?

So if an officer approaches us for advise, would our safest bet just be to tell them that we cannot advise them what to do but direct them to Jackson?  Calling Chip, the Ethics Guru!


Back at ya:
















JB
Member
posted

05-29-09
  


With the change by SCOTUS, the contact is now authorized by law. The constitution and SCOTUS opions are certainly the law, even in Texas.


Posts: 5924  | From: Williamson County, Texas | Registered: 01-25-01





Lisa Tanner
Member
posted

05-29-09 



That was my thought too, but I figured I’d throw it out there — there’s a fairly high degree of concern about it amongst the other discussion group.


Posts: 244  | Registered: 10-24-02





JB
Member
posted

05-29-09 



Ahh, they are just disappointed.


Posts: 5924  | From: Williamson County, Texas | Registered: 01-25-01

The interpretation of Montejo amongst these prosecutors is that representation no longer plays a role in the determination of whether the cops can interrogate a defendant with a lawyer, whether requested, assigned, retained or otherwise.  Their read is that they can go back to the interrogation well at their leisure until a defendant clearly and unequivocably invokes the right to refuse to speak with cops without an attorney present. 

It took the cops what, maybe 30 seconds, to figure out how to make good use of Nino’s “few if any” opportunities?  Does this mean that Nino doesn’t get out enough, or Nino knows exactly what he’s doing by sending the message to the troops in the streets about how to get confessions when the going gets tough.  Who would be so cynical as to think that?

And as long as we’re talking about Nino’s cluelessness, the only fault that he sees is police “badgering” represented defendants into confessions.  What about lying to them?  What about using finely honed psychological techniques to deceive them into talking?  What about negotiating backroom deals with defendants who don’t realize that it can’t happen that way?  Do these things not happen in Nino’s world?  They surely happen in ours.

It must be nice to rule from the sanitized world of Washington, where bad things are never done by cops on a mission.  But while the Supremes prestend that this isn’t an issue, cops and prosecutors are busily figuring out how to game the situation under Nino’s new rules of engagement.  That didn’t take long.

Everyone Screwed Up, But Only McNair Is Executed

One of the most perversely bizarre stories I’ve seen, culminating in the execution of Willie McNair, this is an example of how the levels of failures resulted in the execution of one man.  It’s stories like this that make me disgusted by those whose biggest complaint about the law is that they don’t get enough “me” time. 

Willie McNair was executed last week after courts refused to review the trial judge’s decision to sentence him to death even though the jury decided he should be sentenced to life imprisonment without parole.

McNair was convicted after his first trial based on “illegal evidence, inflammatory comments, and name-calling,” bad enough that even an Alabama appeals court reversed the conviction and sent it back for retrial. 


At the second and final sentencing, the jury returned a verdict of life imprisonment without possibility of parole. The trial judge, without explanation, rejected the jury’s verdict and sentenced Mr. McNair to death.


Alabama, apparently, is the only state in the nation where a judge can reject the jury’s sentencing decision and order execution on his own. 


In 2004, the United States District Court for the Middle District of Alabama found that Mr. McNair’s death sentence was unconstitutional because his trial lawyers – who knew what had happened at the first trial – nonetheless failed at the second trial to present crucial information that would have explained the crime and persuaded the judge to follow the jury’s life verdict.

The problem here was that McNair’s indigent defenders were limited to $1,000 for out-of-court work, and claimed they couldn’t manage to do the work needed within the budget.  This is clearly a two-part failure, from the state’s ridiculous low limit for out-of-court work in a death case to the defense lawyers absolute failure to provide effective assistance, compensation notwithstanding.  So the criminal defense lawyers were prepared to let a man die because they weren’t paid enough?  Don’t get me started.



People who had known Willie McNair his whole life testified that such behavior was highly out of character for him and that he was held in extremely high esteem in his community. Expert witnesses explained that this offense would not have happened but for Mr. McNair’s tragic and severe substance addiction.


The federal court found that Mr. McNair’s lawyers failed to fulfill their constitutional duty to represent him effectively, and vacated his death sentence.

One of the primary mitigating factors in a death case is aberrant behavior.  But of course, if you don’t present the mitigating factors, then it doesn’t exist.  Well done, fellows.  Are you proud of yourselves?

But the district court’s decision was reversed on appeal, not because it was inherently wrong, but based upon the procedural flaw of presenting evidence at the hearing that was neither new nor unavailable at the trial.  It’s unclear why this wasn’t permitted as evidence of ineffective assistance, rather than in mitigation of the sentence, but it was rejected nonetheless.


That ruling was reversed by a federal appeals court on procedural grounds. The appeals court did not disagree with the findings about the poor quality of Mr. McNair’s legal representation, but held that the federal trial court should not have allowed additional evidence to be presented in federal court.
McNair sought leave to appeal to both the Alabama Supreme Court and the United States Supreme Court.  Both turned him away.  On May 14, 2009, Willie McNair was put to death by lethal injection.

And this is really the best system there is?  Tell it to Willie McNair.

H/T Lee Stonum

Officer Simoes Never Meant to Hurt Her (Update)

Having followed the trial of Yonkers Police Officer Wayne Simoes in the Southern District of New York, it would be wrong to leave you hanging.  The jury returned.  Was justice done?

Interest was peaked in the case when Simoes, accused of body slamming Irma Marquez after a bar fight involving her niece, ended up on the wrong side of the thin blue line.  The trial started with fellow officer John Liberatore testifying that, contrary to Simoes claim that he accidentally dropped Marquez, body slammed her to the group, causing her substantial injury.

Of course, it didn’t help that Liberatore didn’t find religion until the video tape of the conduct came out.  Before that, he saw nothing.

Then, the defense called an expert to deconstruct the video via a frame by frame parsing which, in the opinion of the expert, proved that Simoes didn’t body slam her on the ground, as it clearly appeared in the video, but merely dropped her when he slipped.  Unintentionally, of course.

The defense’s videotape expert had been precluded, after an in limine motion, from answering the ultimate question for the jury, but the question was asked anyway.  And the prosecution neglected to object.  “It came out of the blue,” the prosecutor explained.  The judge nonetheless struck the testimony afterward, and no doubt the jury forgot all about it since the jury does whatever the judge says.  Always. 

As all trials do, this one came to an end.  From LoHud, the outcome:



The jury of eight men and four women deliberated for a little more than five hours yesterday in U.S. District Court in White Plains before finding Simoes not guilty yesterday of the lone charge against him, violating the civil rights of Marquez.

“We watched the video and we watched the frame-by-frame,” Jhonna Van Dunk said, “and we could not determine that he intended to hurt her.”
While an acquittal is usually a cause for celebration, showing that not every arrest demands a conclusion of guilt, and that our system of trial by jury remains vital, I again find myself posting about an acquittal involving a cop.  Not merely the acquittal of a cop, but one where there was a videotape showing, as conclusively as one could dream possible, what happened.  And still, the officer was acquitted.

Don’t blame Wayne Simoes for the acquittal.  No one, cop included, wants to be convicted, and no one can blame a defendant for fighting the charges.  Certainly his lawyer, Andrew Quinn, did his job well.  But if you want someone to blame, blame ourselves.  Blame the fact that we can see a video of a cop body slamming a woman to the ground and still give the cop the benefit of the doubt. 

In New York, the jury is instructed that a person intends the natural consequences of his act.  Slam a woman to the ground and one intends to cause her harm.  If not, then don’t body slam her.  It’s not a difficult instruction, nor conclusion to reach.  Except when the slammer is a cop. 

Wayne Simoes is not guilty of the charges against him.  That’s how the system works.  But if you’re not a cop, I wouldn’t try to copy Simoes, because it doesn’t seem the system works the same for others.  And it will continue that way for as long as we can’t seem to get it into our heads that police officers, like anyone else, sometimes do harm.  And when they do, they should be subject to the same “benefit of the doubt” as anyone else, for better or worse.

Update:  In case you were wondering what an accident by Wayne Simoes looks like, here a photo of Irma Marquez, courtesy of BlackListedNews via Karl Mansour. 

Imagine what she would have look like if he meant to hurt here.

Oh, That Memo

I’ve been meaning to post about this since Jdog first twitted about it, but there was a hole in my racket, the sun was in my eyes, the dog ate my homework.  Okay, I just didn’t get around to it.  But it’s too important to ignore, so I’m back to it now.

From the Northern Muckraker via Boing Boing, somebody let slip an internal police memo from the New York Police Department.  For those who may not know, New York City has a police force with more officers than most cities have residents.  They have a cute nickname, New York’s Finest.  They considered calling themselves New York’s Brightest, but were unable to find anyone amongst that very large group of officers who would go along. 

Just to be clear, there are many police officers who are well educated, smart and dedicated, in the service of the City of New York.  There are a whole lot more, however, who make rocks look brilliant.  The standards have slipped a bit over the years, much to the consternation of the more intelligent officers, who are now forced to do send out things like this :



We await next month’s Memo, Investigation of Individuals Engaged in Suspicious Winking.  I know, it makes me proud to be a New Yorker too.

Anyone Can; Everyone Shouldn’t

I was never much of a fan of inspirational posters.  I can remember that ubiquitous poster of a kitty cat hanging on a tree limb, with the words, “Hang in there, baby.  Friday’s coming,” in almost every woman’s dorm room at college.  I was also never much of a fan of cats. 

While the old poster is a cheesy reminder of the past, inspirational posts live on.  A particularly inspiring one comes from Susan Cartier Leibel, at her recently moved blog, http://buildasolopractice.solopracticeuniversity.com/2009/05/26/stop-telling-me-what-i-cant-do/.



As new lawyers, we are told over and over again that “we can’t” open our own practice right out of law school. Like my fourth grade teacher, these naysayers in the form of professors, career counselors, other lawyers, judges and family members are just projecting their fears upon you, maybe the very same fears that stopped them from venturing out on their own and pursuing their dreams. Find out why they are so fearful of you, so you can address the obstacles to the success they perceive to be insurmountable, one hurdle at a time.

You can open your own legal practice. Some perceived hurdles might present challenges you’re not willing to take on. That, however, is very different than saying, “I can’t.” If you’re just not willing to make those hard choices, that’s perfectly alright. But you absolutely can open your own law practice if you want to.
She’s right.  You can.  Anyone can open their own solo practice right out of law school.  While there are a number of things you might want, there are really very few things you absolutely need.  A telephone and a computer will largely cover it, provided you aren’t living out of a car.  Maybe a pen, but you can usually find one lying around the courtroom and nab it when no one is looking.

There is one more thing you’re going to need.  Clients.  You will need to find people who are willing to pay you for your services.  It’s not the easiest thing to do, but it too can be done.  There are plenty of people happy to show you, the newly-minted lawyer, how to sell yourself as the best thing since sliced bread to the public.  For a small fee.  If they can get a few people with cash to call your telephone number, then you’re in business.

Almost.  There is still one dilemma.  What do you know about actually representing a client?  Maybe you can find your way to the courthouse with Mapquest, but do you know what to do once you get there?  Some of you may have an idea, having either clerked your way to prosperity or paid attention in a law school clinic.  It’s a start.  Others wouldn’t know a notice of motion if it bit them on the butt.  Of course, this doesn’t stop you from putting up a fetching website extolling your virtues, but it does present a dilemma when it comes to earning the money that those nice people want to throw at you.

There is a gap in Susan’s otherwise very inspiration post.  It’s only focus is on your will to take a chance.  But the chance you are really taking is with some other person’s life.  There’s nothing in there about the damage you could do to someone if you take on a case that you’re not yet equipped to handle.  You get paid.  They get screwed.  Is that okay with you?

Not to nitpick, but there is one “threat” posed by Susan with which I take issue.  The naysayers aren’t fearful of you.  As full of yourselves as you may be, you don’t pose a threat to us.  We are, however, fearful of the potential for harm you can do to others and to the profession.  Once you’ve got your ticket, you are a lawyer.  You are entitled to hold yourself out as a lawyer, to offer your services as a lawyer, to stand up in court as a lawyer.  But you are also expected to recognize your limitations as a lawyer.  This is why there are a bunch of ethical considerations and disciplinary rules that apply to what you do going forward. 

For the worst arguers in the bunch, the retort is that there are lawyers who have practiced for years who are utterly incompetent.  Very true.  Very unfortunate.  Very problematic.  Perhaps even more so than you going into private practice when you haven’t a clue.  But two wrongs don’t make a right.  You are responsible for yourself, and the fact that some other lawyer is an incompetent fool doesn’t make you a competent lawyer.

In tough times for those beginning their legal career, the lure of hanging out a shingle may well prove to color the vision of young lawyers to the extent that they care only about their own circumstances.  Loans to pay off.  Mouths to feed.  Years of lost opportunity to catch up on. Business school friends making fun of your clothing.  Maybe a BMW.  Whatever.  It’s hard to turn down the opportunity when a few hours and a cheesy website can turn you into the greatest lawyer ever.

But you need to ask yourselves whether you, if you were in trouble, would want you to be the person standing beside you.  Somebody cares about that client who called, and they will entrust you with their loved one.  Are you really prepared to take on that trust?  Are you really?

Some will be able to represent clients right out of the box, at least with a little help and support.  Most will not.  With a little experience and a lot of effort, most will be capable of fulfilling their role as lawyer and performing adequately to take on the representation of human beings.  There’s no shame in falling into the latter category; indeed, there’s honor in respecting the solemnity of your duty to be competent. 

Don’t feel badly if you’re not one of the very few who should open your own practice on day one.  Hang in there, baby.  Competency’s coming.



If Unpopular Rights Can Be Undone

The California Supreme Court’s decision in Strauss v. Horton upheld the referendum to amend the state Constitution to do away with the court’s own decision holding that denial of marriage to gay couples was unconstitutional in In Re Marriage Cases. Aside from it being a silly exercise in futility that will ultimately prove embarrassing to California, as other states pass laws entitling gay couples to marry, it raises an uglier question.

It is axiomatic that the Constitution, whether state or federal, protects the minority from the tyranny of the majority.  Granted, most people don’t realize this concept, being schooled in the idea that the will of the majority should always prevail and often confused when courts don’t seem to rule the way that the masses think it should.  But for those familiar with the concept, and those who have the capacity to understand it once explained, the idea that there are basic rights guaranteed by the Constitution to all, and these cannot be taken away because the majority doesn’t like the minority, it seems an awfully important protection.

What if the majority of this country, perceiving itself to be good, law-abiding folk, decides that it’s had enough of coddling criminals, appreciates the fine work done by law enforcement in protecting us, and concludes that it’s a terrible waste of time and effort to handcuff the police in doing their job when it comes to career criminals. 

Somebody offers an amendment to the Constitution that any person who has been previously convicted of a serious violent crime will not be entitled to due process thereafter, but if determined by a police officer to have committed a second serious crime may be summarily punished according to law.  Don’t quibble about  the details of the amendment, as they aren’t important.  What’s important is that a majority could amend the Constitution to deprive an unpopular citizen of what was previously considered a fundamental right.  Sure, it would be wrong to upend due process, but recidivist serious criminals have few friends, and they do take a toll on society.

Why not?  If the fine people of California can decide that gays don’t deserve equal protection, why can’t criminals not deserve due process?  We can go down the list of groups we don’t like and identify which of our fundamental rights should be denied them.  I bet the 4th Amendment would be gone in a flash; after all, law-abiding folks have nothing to fear from the cops.  And the 6th is just a full-employment for lawyers amendment, and nobody likes lawyers. 

The California Supreme Court’s Strauss decision dealt with a technical issue, whether Proposition 8 was an amendment or a revision.  Typical of the limited focus of lawyers and courts, it didn’t deal with the heart of the problem.  Is our constitutional democracy so fragile that a well-financed group that is able to muster a majority of votes, that disapproves of rights being given a discrete and unpopular group, can change a Constitution so as to deprive that unpopular group of a fundamental right?

Apparently so, as I’ve seen no one consider that if gays are not entitled to equal protection in marriage, then they can be denied equal protection as to any other right by dint of majority vote.  If the tyranny of the majority is constitutionally permissible, what group is next on the agenda?  I’m probably a member of a few groups that might not fair well.

According to who you talk to, there’s a long list of minority groups in this nation who are looked at askance by the majority.  Can an angry majority decide to eliminate the basic rights to people we don’t like?  Are due process and equal protection that fragile?

Merely Having A Lawyer Isn’t Enough Anymore

The Supreme Court’s decision in Montejo v. Louisiana, piggybacked on its recent decision in Kanas v. Ventris*, makes one point abundantly clear for anyone accused of a crime:  The first thing out of your mouth is “I want to speak with my lawyer.”  Then shut up.

The Supremes have chosen to go down a strange path, separating the minor detail that a defendant has a lawyer from the invocation of the right to counsel.  Jesse Montejo has already appeared before a judge, who properly assigned a lawyer to represent him.  Before the lawyer had the chance to meet with his new client, the police swooped in for a chat of their own.  As it happens, Jesse spilled his guts.

The rationale for deciding that this was a perfectly fine way for police to interrogate a defendant was spelled out:


Even without Jackson, few badger-ing-induced waivers, if any, would be admitted at trial because the Court has taken substantial other, overlapping measures to exclude them. Under Miranda, any suspect subject to custodial interrogation must be advised of his right to have a lawyer present. 384 U. S., at 474. Under Edwards, once such a defendant “has invoked his [Miranda] right,” interrogation must stop. 451 U. S., at 484. And under Minnick v. Mississippi, 498 U. S. 146, no subsequent interrogation may take place until counsel is present. Id., at 153. These three layers of prophylaxis are sufficient. On the other side of the equation, the principal cost of applying Jackson’s rule is that crimes can go unsolved and criminals unpunished when uncoerced confessions are excluded and when officers are deterred from even trying to obtain confessions. The Court concludes that the Jackson rule does not “pay its way,” United States v. Leon, 468 U. S. 897, 907–908, n. 6, and thus the case should be overruled. Pp. 13–18.
In other words, the right to counsel now falls under the “pay to play” rule, comparing the benefit in the eyes of some robed guys in Washington to defendants with the effectiveness of police getting the bad guy.  The Court ruled that defendants have enough rights already, and don’t need this one as well.  As with Edwards, one of the worst reasoned decisions ever, the Court baselessly concludes that it’s not a big deal for defendants.

Nothing is a big deal for defendants, unless you happen to be the defendant under interrogation.  You can quote me on this.

This trend might be worth a decent parsing if it didn’t sound like a broken record.  I’ve explained the problem already when the Court decided Edwards, and the rationale didn’t get any better in the past month.  Like it or not (and I don’t), the point is now absolutely, totally, 100% crystal clear:  Each and every defendant must personally, individually, loudly and clearly invoke the right to counsel at the first, and every subsequent, opportunity.  It doesn’t matter whether this seems wrong when you already have an attorney assigned to represent you.  Do it anyway.  Just do it.

Officer:  We’d like to ask you a few questions.

Defendant:  I would like to speak with my attorney.

Officer:  It’s no big deal, just a couple of questions to straighten out a few details.

Defendant:  I would like to speak with my attorney.

Officer:  Look, this will only take a few seconds, and it might even help to clear you so you can go home.

Defendant: I would like to speak with my attorney.

Officer:  Sigh.

Just do it.  You will thank me later.

* In my original post, I used the case of Edward v. Arizona where Ventris should have been.  It was entirely my mistake, and it’s now corrected.  Please forgive my brain fart.  It happens at my age.

Falwell’s Liberty University Tosses Young Democrats as “Unchristian”

Having already espoused the idea that a religious school has the authority to dictate the conduct of its students to comport with its religious doctrine, no matter how absurd that seems to those who do not share the faith, Jerry Falwell’s Liberty U has taken it to the next level.  From Mark Hine, VP of Student Affairs at Liberty U:


I must inform you that the College democrats’ club is no longer going to be recognized as a Liberty University club. We are unable to lend support to a club whose parent organization stands against the moral principles held by  Liberty University. I expressed these concerns when we met, earlier in the spring semester.

The Liberty Way states, “It is the duty of every student to respect Liberty’s Statement of Doctrine and Purpose. They may not engage in any activity on or off campus that would compromise the testimony or reputation of the University or cause disruption to Liberty’s Christian learning environment.”

How, you ask, does being a Democrat disrupt the school’s Christian learning environment?



Even though this club may not support the more radical planks of the democratic party, the democratic party is still the parent organization of the club on campus. The Democratic Party Platform is contrary to the mission of LU and to Christian doctrine (supports abortion, federal funding of abortion, advocates repeal of the federal Defense of Marriage Act, promotes the “LGBT” agenda, Hate Crimes, which include sexual orientation and gender identity, socialism, etc). The candidates this club supports uphold the Platform and implement it. The candidates supported are directly contrary to the mission of LU. By using LU or  Liberty University and Democrat in the name, the two are associated and the goals of both run in opposite directions.
Well, at least it’s not because they listen to rock & roll music and think it’s acceptable for boys and girls to hold hands.

Now it’s one thing for a religious school to dictate the conduct of its students, but another to dictate their political thought. In a strange way, I can understand why Liberty U has problems with a club within its midst overtly supporting such Falwell travesties as abortion and the “LGBT” agenda.  Stuff like that just gives Falwell the heebie-jeebies.  But to ban a political club because the parent party supports radical ideas that are contrary to Falwell’s version of life?  Has this not gone well beyond any cognizable religious belief and deeply into the realm of political thought, regardless of religion? 

The message seems clear: LU isn’t satisfied with controlling the conduct of its students.  It wants to own their thoughts, to raise a student body of one political belief, confusing religion with politics and controlling both.

On the other hand, why would anybody who shares any belief similar to those of the Democratic Party chose to go to Liberty University?  I mean, could you have made a more bizarre choice of schools?.

So the question ultimately comes down to whether a religiously-premised university should dictate the political beliefs of its students as well as their actions.  The answer seems to be that when you buy Jerry Falwell, you get Jerry Falwell.  And when it comes to Liberty University, you can either see things his way or get the boot.  For anyone who might argue that LU is a legitimate university, this pretty much kills that notion.

Is it wrong for a school to demand that students share an institution’s political beliefs?  You betcha.  But when you signed up for Jerry Falwell’s Liberty U, didn’t you realize what you were doing? 

H/T Lee

My Website Is Worse Than Your Website

Eric Turkewitz at New York Personal Injury Law posts that he hates his website.  Turk is one of the guys who gets it.  If you’re a PI lawyer, or frankly a civil litigator of any stripe, Turk would be the guy you want to emulate, because he reflects the combination of zealous representation and deep ethical concern that characterizes how a civil litigator attorney should be.  And that’s his problem.


It isn’t the style or functionality of my website that I hate, it’s my writing. The site is my electronic brochure and it’s designed so that folks in need of a personal injury attorney can find it and consider retaining my firm. But creating such a website is a real problem. . .

And that’s the hard part, impressing the potential client. Because most of us were not brought up to brag. We’re taught as kids to be modest. Yet on the website we must do the opposite by showing past results and clucking about ourselves, and this does not come naturally.

Turk explains the nuances involved, the conflicting issues confronted, in greater detail.  But the bottom line is that our static websites exist to show that we exist.  Like Turk, I have one.  Like Turk, I absolutely hate mine.  Just like Turk.

I don’t think I’ve gone back to look at my website more than twice since it was put up.  It embarrasses me.  I am ashamed of its blatant self-promotion, and it pains me whenever anybody reminds me of what is said there.  I refuse to play the search engine optimization game, the inclusion of language designed to trick search engines into putting my website at the top of the list so that it will be front and center when someone types in “criminal defense lawyer.”  I neither seek that sort of clientèle, nor wish to ever be in competition with that crowd of lawyers. 

But even without SEO, my website stinks of braggadocio.  I tried to think of a way to express my approach toward my work, and fell horribly short.  It all sounds so empty and meaningless to me.  Every lawyer claims to “really care” about his clients.  Every lawyer claims to fight for their rights.  I sound no different than everyone else.  You couldn’t tell me from the most incompetent fool based on website.  Maybe I am the most incompetent fool,  You would have no way of knowing.


We live in an era where we occasionally see wretched lawyer ads — and now solicitation by website or blogs. While such lawyers are few and far between, their antics may get broadcast widely in the electronic age, and it sends a powerfully negative message to the public. Those horrid ads, as well as the occasional loopy lawsuit that finds its way to Overlawyered or the local papers where they are often justifiably skewered, helps to create and feed a deep cynicism when it comes to attorneys.
Because of my frequent criticism of lawyer marketing and those who promise wealth and fame if only you pay them to market for you, I’ve intentionally made myself a target for criticism by virtue of having a website myself.  While there’s a link on my blawg to it, it is not, as some have argued, to use the blawg for self-promotion, but rather to provide access to some information about the guy who deigns to put his views in writing for others to read.  If you don’t know who I am, you have no reason to think that anything I write is worthy of consideration.  But I understand how easy it is to jump to the wrong conclusion.  My website is a nightmare.

Turk hasn’t figured out a way to exist on the internet while maintaining a comfortable level of dignity.  I’ve looked at literally thousands of lawyer websites and have yet to see one that doesn’t make me wince.  Most are more professionally done than mine, with far better design and text.  If I had an idea of how I would like it to be, perhaps I would pay sufficient attention to have it done more professionally.  As of now, I can’t bear to think about it.  I haven’t figured out what I could possibly say or write that wouldn’t make me sound like a self-promoting, disingenuous bag of slime.  There is no way to explain what I do, and who I am, that rings true and sincere.

Every lawyer needs clients to stay in business.  While the types of clients I typically represent don’t come from Google searches, I’ve heard from many other criminal defense lawyers that they do get calls from their websites, and that these calls are how they keep busy and feed their families.  I don’t begrudge them a practice and a living.  Their websites don’t have to please me.  My only concern is my own existence on the internet, and my critical view of my own effort is that it is absolutely awful and an embarrassment.

I’m particularly thankful that Turk takes such an introspective view of his website, because if anybody will figure out how to do this without appearing deceptive, or bragging, or disingenuous, it’s Turk.  And when he does, I will learn from him. 

Until then, it’s unlikely that I’ll do much of anything to change my website as I just can’t bear to look at it.  It’s not me.  And yet it unfortunately is.  And I am ashamed of it.