Author Archives: SHG

Avvo’s Really Bad Answers

Here’s the moral right up front:  Don’t let incompetency or ethical challenges impair the desire for personal gain when it comes to a business model. 

Too strong?  Perhaps, but I’ll let you judge.

I’ve been critical of Avvo, my personal favorite lawyer website for providing the public with information about lawyers so that they can make a more intelligent decision about whom to retain (he writes with a sly smile on his face) from time to time, as well as complementary at others.  It’s got some legitimate benefits.  It’s also got some issues.  As much as I like the founders, Paul and Mark (though Mark rarely stops by here unless I post something really nice about Avvo, preferring to send Sam “the Hammer” instead), I try to keep my critique fair and balanced.  They probably aren’t going to like this post at all.

I never liked the concept of Avvo Answers, another ill-conceived effort to provide free legal advice online to consumers who want professional answers to their very serious questions without having to spend a dime.  But not until a skimmed through it the other day did I realize just how bad, how dangerous, Avvo Answers could be.

I happened onto a criminal law question posed by a Dallas mother concerned for her son.  Mothers tend to be that way.  She had a lawyer, but had doubts about his advice, and sought a second opinion.  Her post is long, so I’ll only excerpt the salient part:


My biggest question is, should I bond him out so he can get a job and do good while he is waiting on his trial? They say it could take 18-24 months. Or should he just sit in jail? He has a Court Appointed Lawyer, but I just don’t know, Why hasn’t he got the charges changed to not show BY FELON? The lawyer told my husband to leave him in there it looks better. I just don’t believe that. If he gets a job, does good, stays out of trouble, won’t that look better to a judge then sitting in jail? I feel like I should hire a lawyer, not just get a bail bondsman. I know I could just be throwing a lot of money away, but he told his wife this scared him so bad. He doesn’t want this life anymore.

If ever there was an appropriate question to ask on a freebie answer site, this is it.   She has a lawyer, but has doubts, and is looking for direction.  I don’t endorse the notion of asking questions in this fashion at all, but I understand completely why Dallas mom did so.

Then the ugliness of the concept rears its head.  The first lawyer to respond posts:


You need to get a new criminal attorney to replace the court-appointed attorney immediately.

Now this lawyer doesn’t practice criminal law.  But that didn’t stop her for an instant. And shockingly, she tells the poster to shed herself of this free lawyer and hire a new one immediately.  What could have influenced this advice.  Hmm.  Fortunately, there are paid advertisements for Texas criminal defense lawyers in a little box on the very same page!  How convenient!

Now, by way of explanation, by responding to questions, lawyers gain the benefit of increasing their “level” of contribution, which elevates their profile on Avvo and makes them appear to be more consumer friendly and helpful.  This is why a lawyer who practices “debt/’lending agreements” (whatever that means) with a rating of 6.3 would respond to a criminal law question.  But she’s a “level 7 contributor.”  Wow.

Then a second lawyer responds.  This lawyer, from Washington State practicing “family law” and “business law,” has this to add:

What is the likelihood that your son will get killed if he is out of jail? Seriously, are the people whom your son shot vengeful people who will harm your son if he is out of jail?

He’s a “level 8 contributor.”  That means he’s very, very lovable.

Finally, as it happens, the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, steps in to smack these absurd responses and provide some straight sound advice.

Here’s a suggestion: Non-criminal defense lawyers and non-Texas lawyers should not attempt to answer Texas criminal defense questions.

I generally believe that it’s better for an accused to be out pending trial. It makes the defense much easier for me, and allows him to show how well he can do.

But Ms. TreviƱo’s advice is terrible; possibly the worst advice I’ve ever seen in response to an Avvo question. You haven’t given nearly enough information for someone to advise you on changing lawyers.

If your son trusts his court-appointed lawyer, he should stick with him and follow his advice no matter how much it hurts. If your son does not trust his court-appointed lawyer, he needs to either find trust for him or change lawyers.

But what happens to these consumers who mistakenly believe that an answer from an attorney, lacking any qualifications, is reliable?  Avvo might respond that they have a disclaimer (though I didn’t see it on the page, but I bet it’s there somewhere) that no one should ever listen to anything any lawyer writes in response to their question. 

I wonder if Dallas mom read that disclaimer, or thought that an answer from a lawyer meant that it was an answer from a lawyer, the sort of thing from a professional that a person could rely upon?  I wonder if, upon reading the first response, she immediately fired her lawyer and found a new lawyer to retain?  I wonder what would have happened had Bennett not come across this question and straightened it out?

But hey, this isn’t about providing accurate response to people who need legal advice.  This is about business, about marketing, both for Avvo and for the “contributors” who are complicit in this travesty, ruining lives one by one.  At least Avvo makes no bones about being a business, and the business of business is business.  As for the lawyers, there’s no excuse.

And as for the consumers who believe that they can get a worthy, reliable and meaningful answer for free from Avvo lawyer contributors, you can’t rely on Bennett coming around to save you from every bad response. 

What Do Some Cops Say About Drugs? LEAP

A press release went out yesterday from a group called LEAP, using the 75th Anniversary of the repeal of prohibition as a platform to promote their position that the War Against Drugs has failed, and it is time to put an end to it.  LEAP stands for Law Enforcement Against Prohibition.

The mission of LEAP is to reduce the multitude of unintended harmful consequences resulting from fighting the war on drugs and to lessen the incidence of death, disease, crime, and addiction by ultimately ending drug prohibition.
Not what many would expect to hear from those who have, or are, been at the frontlines of the war. 

When I received the PR from a fellow named Tom Angell, I responded by asking for some harder information to ascertain the legitimacy of this organization.  After all, it wouldn’t be too hard for a bunch of potheads to put a few dollars together, dummy up some website as if they were cops, and make a splash without anyone knowing that there wasn’t a legitimate voice in the bunch.  Tom’s response was to take a look at their speakers.  So I did.

As I scrolled down the page, I found something that a lot of others probably would have skimmed right over.  An old friend of mine, Jeff Kaufman.  Jeff was a cop, later an attorney at Police Legal where he handled asset forfeitures, and later still a defense lawyer.  But I knew Jeff differently.  We went to college together.  We went to law school together.  I knew Jeff as a person, not just a cop or lawyer.

Jeff was incredibly smart, which is why I made fun of him for becoming a cop.  But he was a believer, and loved being a cop.  He especially liked riding in an RMP with the lights and sirens on, particularly when the donuts were fresh.  He had no qualms, none, about doing his job.  He believed in being on the front line of protecting citizens against criminals, and he was a happy soldier in the war on crime.  I’m absolutely certain that he never lost a minute of sleep worrying about the consequences.

Something changed him.  Whatever that something was, it must have been far more powerful then anything I could have said, because I know that I never made a dent in his attitude.  Whatever it was, it caused him to turn into this person :


“If they caught the owner of the Empire State Building smoking a joint in the lobby, they could take the whole building.”

Jeff Kaufman began his criminal-justice career in 1980 as a beat cop for the NYPD just as the department was emerging from the budgetary crisis caused by the city’s near-bankruptcy in the mid ’70s. Says Jeff, “At the time, the force consisted of officers who were getting ready to retire and officers like me, young and motivated to ‘take back the streets’ from the ‘bad guys.'” He was assigned to the 75th Precinct in Brooklyn – one of the busiest in New York City. Within a year, he would be one of the responding officers to the “Palm Sunday Massacre” of 11 people, thus introducing him to the effect of drugs and the ‘War on Drugs’ on his community.

In his free time, Jeff attended law school. When he passed the bar, he was transferred to the NYPD’s Legal Bureau, where, among other duties, he brought cases against individuals for forfeiture of their property. Targets included both drug dealers and recreational users. But after Jeff attended the first National Conference on Asset Forfeiture in Washington, DC, he began to see just how wrong these policies were. “The conference organizers boasted that federal asset forfeiture was the only effective way to stop drugs. They claimed that if they caught the owner of the Empire State Building smoking a joint in the lobby, they could take the whole building! The [police] chiefs that accompanied me to the conference drooled with anticipation. Finally, an answer to their budget problems.” Shortly thereafter, Jeff left the police department and became a defense attorney for the indigent. “My caseload rapidly swelled with drug cases, and I saw from another vantage point how the ‘drug war’ was destroying us. More police were hired. New tactics were utilized, where large numbers of people were caught in police sweeps and arrested without regard to our basic constitutional principles. What affected me most were the number of young people who faced draconian sentencing guidelines. Lives snuffed out by our ‘drug war.'”

In the mid ’90s Jeff learned about the need for teachers at a high school in the precinct in which he’d once patrolled. Originally intending to return to criminal law, he was offered a teaching position on Rikers Island, where he developed relationships the nature of which he had been unable to do as either police officer or attorney. “I taught criminal law to adolescents facing life sentences for violent crimes and drug felonies. In class, we had the opportunity to fully explore the ramifications of the ‘drug war.'”

I lost track of Jeff about a decade ago, and wondered what became of him.  Now I know. 

If Jeff Kaufman can be turned around like this, then it’s something to be taken very seriously.

What If Plaxico Burress Played for Dallas? (Update)

No, this isn’t about the locker room brawl potential with Terrell Owens, but how Burress, wide receiver for the world champion New York Giants (currently 11-1 and first in the NFC East) has been universally vilified for carrying an unregistered handgun (Glock, I believe?) into the Latin Quarter nightclub in Manhattan, and put a neat hole in his thigh when he mistakenly pulled the trigger.

He was stupid.  He was wrong.  But folks, this doesn’t make him evil.

The inflammatory rhetoric about Plaxico’s conduct is out of control, with editorials, commentaries and even political cartoons vilifying Plax, as if he had pistol-whipped an 8 year old to steal their lollipop.  Time for a reality check about crime.

Possession of a weapon in New York is a crime.  New York has very restrictive laws regarding handguns, and it’s nearly impossible to obtain a permit to carry a weapon.  Short of being an ex-cop, the New York City Police Department approves carry permits to only a select few who have an absolutely clear and definitive need for a gun, and then only when the Pope writes a letter of recommendation.

Let’s put this in context.  What if Plaxico played for Dallas?  I’m going to fudge some details here, not only because of my lack of familiarity with Texas law but because I’m using Dallas mostly because they are also in the NFC East and all true New York Giants fans hate the Cowboys.

Had Plax played for Dallas, he would have lived in Texas instead of New Jersey, within a few miles of the center of Manhattan, and wouldn’t have been compelled to travel interstate to find cultural satisfaction.  Had Plax played for Dallas, he would have had a carry permit for the asking,  Had Plax played for Dallas, no one in Texas would have thought twice about the fact that he had a weapon on him, since guns are ubiquitous.  This is even more true in light of the murder of Sean Taylor, the gunpoint robbery of Steve Smith and the many other attacks on NFL football players.

Had Plax played for Dallas, the worst that would have been said of him is that he’s a lousy shot.  No one would have suggested that by mere possession of a gun, a malum prohibitum offense (meaning that it’s criminal only because a law says so, not because it reflects an inherent evil), he went from being a very tall receiver with great hands and a bad attitude to the personification of athletic malevolence.

The “fallen hero” political cartoons, repeated in commentaries by those who believe that the quirk of nature that gives one man the ability to catch an odd shaped ball requires him to similarly possess a degree of moral perfection somewhat inconsistent with the difficult upbringing of many professional athletes, is a sham.  Athletes compete based upon their skill in playing a game.  They are rewarded for their physical skills with a ton of money.  The teams know they aren’t necessarily fine human beings, and some aren’t the smartest fellows around (though others are).  But they aren’t one dimensional.  They are people, and they make mistakes.

In this case, Plaxico Burress made a particularly stupid mistake.  But his motives weren’t evil.  Is it evil to want to be protected from harm by some psycho who might be inclined to murder a football player for his diamond earing?  Would it be better if Plaxico Burress appeared in the headlines as a murder victim that Saturday morning, rather than a evil criminal gun possessor and bad shot?  The fans and team might think so, and the sports writers and cartoonists would have been singing his praises as his number was retired and he was hailed as a great humanitarian.  But for Plaxico, he would have been dead.  Not as good for him as for us.

So let’s cut through the nonsense that’s permeated the sports world, at least in New York, and painted Burress as one step below Jack the Ripper.  He’s a dope, but he’s not evil.  There is absolutely nothing about what he’s done to suggest any malevolent intent whatsoever.  If ever there has been a person possessing a hand gun in New York City for a defensive purpose, Plaxico is the one.  It’s time that the mouths shut their yapping about what a bad man he is, and recognize the wrong committed within a rational and reasonable context.  He broke the law,  He is being prosecuted for it.  That’s how it works.  But he is not evil.

And if he played for Dallas, my bet is that he’d be suited up in Pittsburgh this weekend and catching footballs, Achilles tendon permitting.

Update:  Via Doug Berman, Dave Kopel has an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal addressing the Heller angle on the Burress case.  What’s curious about his analysis, though not at all surprising, is that Dave doesn’t take Scalia to task for the fact that even under the full interpretation of 2d Amendment RKBA under  Heller, Burress would still not be permitted to carry a gun, since it’s limited to self-protection in the home.  When Dave contends that the law prohibiting possession of a weapon “is unjust and perhaps unconstitutional,” he’s jumping the gun (get it?).

And before some wag posts a comment about “it’s a start,” and compares it to Brown v. Board of Education, the Heller spin-off is getting old.  Scalia included the infamous exclusions paragraph, and until that changes, take it up with Nino.

Give GM a Fish

So November sales are down 41%, and the cash burn proceeds unabated, only waiting for the other shoe to fall when suppliers stop fronting product in the hope of payment.  So what does Detroit do?  It goes to Washington to play the “too big to fail” card.

What’s another $34 billion?  There are hundreds of thousand of lives on the line, from workers to suppliers to salespeople to mechanics, all of whom have suddenly discovered that the gravy train could stop abruptly.  And they’re scared, as well they should be.

Congress, on the other hand, thinks that it can play the car game better than Detroit.  After all, don’t we elect representatives based upon their combined knowledge of sound business practices and good taste in vehicles?  If the survival plan appeals to lawmakers, then the Big 3 will get their bailout.  Where’s Lee Iacocca when you need him?

The relative merit of saving the pain that will be felt throughout our economy, not to mention the one remaining holdout of the American industrial base, versus letting the tired, old, arrogant giants fall, has valid arguments on both sides, even if we ignore the United Auto Workers view that the $25 an hour its members get over non-union shops has nothing to do with the problem.

Few doubt that Congress will hand over the cash.  After all, it’s not like it’s their money, and it’s only $34 billion, after all.  In weighing the relative pain, the particularly hard feelings of those affected will far exceed the generic anger at yet another bailout of corporate America for what has been clear to most American’s for the past quarter century, that we don’t make cars that people want to buy.

It calls to mind the Chinese proverb, “Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime.” 

The problem here is that neither option seems to have much of chance of succeeding.  Certainly throwing money at carmakers whose cash burn rate, combined with its turnaround time for new products, suggests that it’s a singularly foolish idea.  On the other hand, the top management of Toyota and Nissan is unlikely to offer Detroit much instruction in how to manufacture cars that meet the needs and desires of Americans.  Does anybody really believe that Congress is up to the job?  Really?

Drew Jury Foreperson: “Well, I Always Read The TOS, You Lazy Scum

That this comes from the Lori Drew case is tangential, as it really aligns more closely with the interests of Anne Reed (ABA Blawg 100 star) at Deliberations in her never-ending battle to convince Philistines like me that there is some rational basis to approach the selection of jurors.  Or, in contrast with my views, it ain’t just voodoo.

From Orin Kerr at Volokh, who follows this trial with far greater attention then the WSJ Law Blog (which has just figured out that this case might involve some controversy), an interview from the  St. Louis Post Dispatch of jury foreperson, Valentina Kunasz.


Most jurors believed a felony conviction would send a message that Internet sites should be better regulated for fraud, the forewoman, Valentina Kunasz, said in a telephone interview.

“I would have liked to see this lady go to jail to change the way Internet sites are run,” said Kunasz, 25, a former hairdresser who lives in Los Angeles County.

Most messages from 25 year old former hairdressers involve changing appointments for a dye job, but Kunasz seems to have different agenda.  According to another interview by Kim Zetter of Wired (also via Orin):


Kunasz said despite all the debate outside the courtroom about the prosecution’s use of an anti-hacking statute to charge Drew for violating a website’s terms of service, jurors never considered whether the statute was appropriate. However, she said she agrees with the idea that users who violate a website’s terms of service should be prosecuted.

“The thing that really bothered me was that [Drew’s] attorney kept claiming that nobody reads the terms of service,” she said. “I always read the terms of service…. If you choose to be lazy and not go though that entire agreement or contract of agreement, then absolutely you should be held liable.”

And there’s the rub.  In this case, given its notoriety and attention, the effort to find fair-minded jurors, how did H. Dean Steward end up with the only person in the world who actually reads the terms of service?  Worse still, one who has such a chip on their shoulder that they believe anyone who does not read the TOS is lazy and should go to prison for it?

And note that Kunasz thought that “users who violate a website’s terms of service should be prosecuted,” so anyone I find to violate my one rule better hope that she’s not on your jury, because you don’t have a chance with her.

One of the great joys of an investigative press is that we get to hear from jurors who enjoy their 15 minutes post-trial explaining their views on life, hairdressing and the internet.  We are left to wonder, however, how these nice folks, performing their civic duty by sitting on a jury, harbor the secret thoughts in their heads that lead them to say things like this. 

One would expect, at minimum, that the foreperson of the Lori Drew jury would not be the only living person who never neglects to read a websites TOS, and who is of the view that anyone less diligent than she deserves to be locked away.  Wouldn’t something like this be, oh, of interest on voir dire? It certainly strikes me as the sort of thing that everybody would want to know.

So if jury selection, the process in all its art and science, fulfills its purported purpose, how could this have happened?  Or is it all just voodoo?

Unconstitutional Confusion: An Explanation for Children and Others

One of the conversations that criminal defense lawyers have with some regularity, falling far behind the “how can you represent those people” one and the “do you represent anyone famous” one, is the one where a thoughtful person with a single malt Scotch in hand inquires, “but if it’s not constitutional, how can they do it?”

Georgia Con Law Professor Sonja West posts at PrawfsBlawg about how she deals with this issue with her students.


Student after student tells me that they went to a public high school (usually in the South) and they had a minister lead a prayer at their graduation or they had a school-sponsored baccalaureate with sermons and prayers. Just as many of them had prayers before school football games. The students are confused. They want to know how their school could do this after the Supreme Court found such actions to be unconstitutional.

I can think of no other topic where my answers are so direct and unqualified. “That was very likely unconstitutional,” I tell them, and your school officials are simply waiting for someone to formally complain or even to sue before changing their ways.

The story of the power struggle between the states and the federal government during desegregation is riveting, and we’re all familiar with the incredible show of force that was ultimately necessary to maintain the integrity of the Court’s role as final interpreter of the Constitution. Today, however, there are repeated acts of defiance quietly going on in public schools all across the country when it comes to these school prayer cases.

Much of the conflict between those who believe that “democracy”, in the form of a legislative enactment or executive fiat, trumps the Constitution, stems from the reality that governments large and small make the active choice of ignoring the laws, courts and Constitution.  Don’t try this at home, as the government isn’t nearly as tolerant of you doing it as it is of itself.

This problem arose twice over the last month in the Simple Justice household, where my daughter got all twisted over California’s Prop 8, a referendum by the People (with a little help from the Mormon Church) to alter the Constitution to permit discrimination against gays and lesbians, while my son learned about Kentucky’s latest stroke of genius, a law requiring the state Homeland Security office to credit God with their safety.


The law that organized the Homeland Security office first lists Homeland Security’s duty to recognize that government itself can’t secure the state without God. 

It lists the office’s initial duty as “stressing the dependence on Almighty God as being vital to the security of the Commonwealth.”

I sometimes marvel at the ability of Kentucky legislators to provide teaching moments. 

So the refrain, how could this be, was echoed throughout the house.  Of course, schools around here continue to offer a prayer before official events, just as they do in deepest, darkest Kentucky, so who am I to point fingers? 

While Sonja’s explanation is both clear and accurate, it raises some troubling questions.  For all the lip service we pay to the Constitution, why does government get to simply ignore it at will until somebody, some regular person who put his pants on one leg at a time, forces change?  Isn’t there some entity out there in the mist that goes around from town to village making sure that they behave themselves in accordance with the Constitution?  And if the government gets to ignore the law at will, how can it put regular people into prison for doing the same?

Ah, kids and Scotch drinkers.  They are so naive, so beautifully unaffected by cognitive dissonance.  The problem of course is that the questions are awfully darned good, and the answers are generally cynical.  While some in the law prefer to hide their heads in platitudes designed to pacify the weak-minded, pretending that none of this really happens, or covering it up in a cloud of dignified denial, neither children, Scotch drinkers nor criminal defense lawyers have that pleasure. 

The plain fact is that the inconvenient aspects of  the Constitution are routinely ignored, and it’s so common and pervasive that most of us take it for granted.  Sure, we lawyers know the caselaw, and know that our schools shouldn’t be offering a prayer to their inchoate graduates, but who wants to throw a skunk onstage right before their kid gets the sheepskin?  It’s unbecoming. 

So the second part of Sonja’s explanation is that there is a perpetual tension between the forces that favor the Constitution and the forces that believe that this old piece of paper protects their right to enforce the will of the people, no matter how contrary the two might be.  

As Edmund Burke said,  “All that is required for evil to prevail is for good men to do nothing.”   Bravo to Sonja for breaking the silence, and to my two kids for caring.

Cheney Indictment Tossed, But Nobody Looks Very Pretty

It was an astounding act of chutzpah when Willacy County DA Juan Angel Guerra, in the waning hours of his term as District Attorney, indicted the Vice President of the United States of America.  It was less than astounding when Judge Manuel Banales tossed the indictment.  But that doesn’t mean that Guerra wasn’t right.

By all accounts, including mine, this was a bizarre case from the outset.  Some believed it was a hatchet job by Guerra, as a way to get back for the 18 months he spent under indictment before the very same judge.  Others believe that, Guerra’s baggage aside, he had an indictment and it’s no different when it’s the VP than anyone else.  It ceased to matter when Banales tossed the indictment since Guerra’s term of office ends at the end of the month, and after that he won’t have the ability to indict anyone.

According to the AP Report,


“I suggest on behalf of the law that you not present any cases to the grand jury involving these defendants,” Administrative Judge Manuel Banales said in court while ruling that eight indictments against Cheney, Gonzales and others were invalid.

Why would Judge Banales take such a position? 


Even in defeat, Guerra saw the outcome as confirmation of the very conspiracy he had pursued. “I expected it,” he said. “The system is going to protect itself.”

Even the court’s order contributed to the circus.


Banales withheld judgment on whether probable cause existed for the Cheney and Gonzales indictments because they were not represented in court and did not present any argument.

It isn’t often when an indicted defendant gets the option to not appear.  I suspect many defendants would prefer that choice to the one where they are shipped off to jail on bail they can’t make, made to face the indictment and put on trial.  From now on, the “Cheney Option” may be favored by accused felons in Willacy County, Texas.

But as Grits for Breakfast points out in his review of the Brownsville Herald, despite all the nasty issues swirling around DA Guerra, opening him to ridicule and allegations of using his office for a personal vendetta, it doesn’t mean that the indictments weren’t legitimate.  Hey, even paranoids have enemies.


[Nueces County retired District Judge Michael J.] Westergren told The Brownsville Herald Wednesday that Guerra is the only one who has had the “gumption” to investigate privately owned and managed prisons and their lack of oversight.

“I certainly think it is a serious matter. It’s not frivolous by any means,” Westergren said, referring to Guerra’s case relating to private prison firms. He said there is “substantial support” to the allegations.

Opining that investigations into activities within the private prison system had been suppressed, Westergren said, “That’s not good.”

“It’s a nationwide problem,” said Westergren, adding that the incidence of death in private prisons is estimated to be substantially higher than at other facilities. “That’s pretty bad,” he said.

So Guerra is a nut, in a County that is more zoo than body politic, before a Judge who may be every bit as biased against Guerra as Guerra is against him.  That doesn’t make Cheney’s indictment wrong.  It doesn’t make him guilty either.  The question still remains whether former Attorney General Alberto Gonzalez covered up the death of an inmate, De La Rosa, to protect Cheney’s financial interest in Vanguard and it’s subsidiary private prison interests.  Is this just the tip of an iceberg of rampant conspiratorial abuse in private prisons?  Bear in mind, Cheney may be the headlines, but many others were indicted as well and all enjoyed the benefit of Judge Banales’ subjective decision to overrule the grand jury (not that there’s anything wrong with that).

But it looks like we’ll never know, unless some other District Attorney decides to pick up the ball and carry it toward the end zone.  Any takers?

Another Year, Another Beauty Pageant, ABA Blawg 100

Like wildfire, word of the ABA Blawg 100 spread across the blawgosphere.  I learned of it as I entered the subway on my way back from court yesterday, when the person in the glass booth, formerly known as the token clerk, smiled at me and waved me through without having to swipe my Metrocard.  “No need,” he bellowed, “because you made the ABA Blawg 100!” 

It’s an honor to be recognized, and for that I appreciate being on the list for a second year.  And I certainly don’t want to be ungracious about it.  But the discomfort I felt last year persists, plus this year’s list presents some new issues that should be aired.  Does this make me unappreciative?  Perhaps, but the truth is that I still had to swipe my Metrocard to get on the subway, my honor notwithstanding. I received no free ride.  When this latest hoopla dies out, I will still be a party of the same blawgosphere, with the same folks as before, and aside from another badge on my sidebar indicating that I was an also-ran,

The list is structured very differently this year then last.  Rather than being broken up into practice areas that make some degree of sense, it’s broken into strange and amorphous categories that don’t have any cognizable connection to one another.  “Crime,” the category that Simple Justice is in, is the closest to last year, but this year contains only 5 names.  Worse yet, of the five, one isn’t a blog at all, and another seems to be in the wrong category, since there is a separate category for law professors where all the other lawprofs were placed.

Eric Turkewitz, the most glaring omission from last year’s list (along with the fact that it failed to include a single blog that discussed personal injury law), is now part of the 100, as well he should be after yesterday’s epic Blawg Review, a shoo in to win BR of the Year. But he’s in a category called “regional”.  Huh?  It’s like somebody read the blog title but never read the content, which is anything but regional.

But wholly missing from the list is any blawg by a Public Defender.  There are quite a few of them, and they are exceptionally good.  And they are entirely unworthy of mention, as far as the ABA Journal is concerned.  They include a website, an extremely good and fascinating website that I’ve posted about because I thought it was so terrific, but doesn’t happen to be a blog at all.  But they found no room for a PD blawg in the Crime category.  Not one.  Oddly, Blonde Justice is on the list, but this time was shunted off into the “Quirky” category.  What is meant by “quirky” is anybody’s guess, but Blonde apparently is more quirky than criminal.

This seems to be the new thing at the ABA Blawg 100.  It’s no longer about blawgs.  Not that there aren’t plenty of blawgs, written by lawyers, written for lawyers, thoughtful, interesting, funny, whatever.  There are.  And each reflects some lawyer somewhere giving his time and effort to provide posts for others who don’t put in that time and effort a place to go and explain why they are smarter then the blawger.  It’s a wonderful world in here, But the ABA Blawg 100 doesn’t see these blawgs. 

The point is driven home more clearly with the inclusion in the “podcasts” category (I kid you not, they have a podcasts category) of FBI: Gotcha, which is discussed more thoroughly here.  Not only is it not a blawg, but it’s open and notorious government propaganda.  And they have no room for a public defender blawg?

It is, without a doubt, nice to be back on the list, if only because one catches more than enough grief for doing this and a little appreciation from time to time makes me feel a little warm and fuzzy.  I still can’t shake the feeling that whoever created the list doesn’t really have much of a clue about the scope, breadth and nature of the blawgosphere, and inadvertently creates hard feelings within the ranks by the omission of great blawgs, far (by miles) of inclusion over others, or the insult of including non-blogs to those who work awfully hard to put out brilliant content.  I think some of the categories are silly, and that some of the blawg included within the categories don’t make any sense.  I’m not even going to touch the inclusion of Gerry Spence’s blog.

The ABA has gone a step further by providing blurbs about each of their selections.  I’ve read some of them, and think they are just awful.  I assume that they reflect someone’s concept of the blawg or non-blog website chosen, but certainly not mine.  As for the blurb written about Simple Justice, which attempts to be cute, it reflects at best a myopic and simplistic view of what I do here.  If that’s why they put me on the list, then it’s likely a mistake and they should remove me immediately and put a more worthy blawg in there.

The second stage of the ABA Blawg 100 process is to solicit votes, or the Beauty Pageant stage.  This is the part that I will not be involved in, as it’s demeaning and ridiculous.  Imagine, grown lawyers acting all humble while secretly begging for readers to “vote for me!”  The lawprofs are deep into this, as many posted about their inclusion within second of the list coming out, and seem to care deeply, very deeply, that they are on it.  Perhaps they get so little recognition otherwise that this matters.  Maybe it counts toward tenure.  I don’t know why they care, but they sure do. 

Plenty of other blawgs will be posting about this today, asking (begging) for your vote.  I am thrilled to pimp (h/t Randazza) for the blawgs that I believe do a great job, to the extent they appear on the list, and urge you to go to the Beauty Pageant and vote for them.  To do so, click on the category name or on this badge to go to the main page.


News: Vote for How Appealing, because Howard Bashman does more to help the blawgosphere than anyone else, and deserves to get some love.

Crime:  Vote for Defending People.  If I need to explain this, then you probably shouldn’t be reading Simple Justice.

Professors:  Vote for Volokh Conspiracy.  Oops, wait, VC isn’t in that category.  They put it in News instead.  Well then, second choice is Concurring Opinions, which is in a very tight race with a couple of others, like PrawfsBlawg and Turley.  I give the edge to Dan and Dave for depth, and especially because they have Frank Pasquale on their team.

Niche:  This is a tough category because they’ve mixed together blawgs that have absolutely nothing to do with one another.  Even so, the vote goes to Deliberations by Anne Reed.  Sorry Walter.

Technology:  Not my favorite category, but I’ll throw my vote to Kevin at Real Lawyers Have Blogs just because he works so darned hard at it.  Of course, he gets paid for it too, so don’t cry too hard for him.

Quirky:  As much as like Blonde Justice (and I do) and as much as I dislike (and I do), vote for Quizlaw.

Careers:  While Law21 is a great new blog, and Carolyn Elefant’s My Shingle is the only marketing blawg that keeps things honest, vote for What About Clients? because Dan Hull has got the biggest pair in the blawgosphere, and never shies away from saying what needs to be said.

Students:  I can’t help you on this one, as I’ve never read any of the blawgs.  You’re on your own.

Podcasts:  The only thing I can suggest here is don’t vote for FBI:Gotcha, a disgraceful inclusion. Talk about lipstick on a pig.  Aside from that, who cares.

Regional:   Another mix of apples and oranges that makes it silly to have to chose, but chose we must, and I chose Eric Turkewitz’s New York Personal Injury Law Blog, because Turk is one of the best, funniest and most astute inhabitants of the blawgosphere.

And so it goes.

New Federal Rule 60: What’s With That Third Table?

Yesterday was the effective date of new Rule 60 of the amended Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure. I remind you of this not because it’s cause for a party, but to prevent any potential embarrassment when you ask the judge to exclude the most significant witness against the defendant from the courtroom so that their testimony won’t be tainted by the other government witnesses. 

Historically, the “victim”, by whatever name he or she was known, was not permitted to sit in the courtroom and listen to the parade of government agents on the stand testify about the case.  This was to make sure that the victim didn’t alter his testimony to conform with that of the witnesses who preceded him.  After all, there is no one in the courtroom with a greater desire to convict then the victim, and most victims, absolutely certain that the defendant is the man who “did it to him,” will do anything to assure a conviction.

The parade of agents notwithstanding, it is the victim’s testimony that closes the deal.  The victim identifies the defendant as the one who did it, with sufficient drama and certainty that no one could doubt.   The victim describes in chilling detail the defendant’s cruelty, avarice, or malice, so that the jury learns to hate the defendant as much as the victim does.  The other witnesses are the appetizer.  The victim is the main course.

For this reason, we isolate the victim from the other witnesses, preventing the victim from listening to their testimony and then altering his own to match it.  The victim’s untainted testimony, free from modification, is what provides the integrity of the testimonial and adversarial process; it either stands up on its own or falls.  But this quaint notion, I’m afraid, is now an anachronism.

Rule 60 provides:

(2) Attending the Proceeding. 

The court must not exclude a victim from a public court proceeding involving the crime, unless the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that the victim’s testimony would be materially altered if the victim heard other testimony at that proceeding. In determining whether to exclude a victim, the court must make every effort to permit the fullest attendance possible by the victim and must consider reasonable alternatives to exclusion. The reasons for any exclusion must be clearly stated on the record.

The generic rationale for excluding victims in every trial will no longer suffice, and the new test, that the defense must prove by “clear and convincing evidence  that the victim’s testimony would be materially altered if the victim heard other testimony at that proceeding,” is essentially impossible to meet.  There is little possible basis to contend that one particular victim would be specifically inclined to alter the testimony.  How can you prove that someone else would almost assuredly lie?

The proponents of victims’ rights, like Judge/Professor Paul Cassell who testified in favor of these changes, has carefully crafted the reasoning to evoke a tear.  This has been a topic of discussion here numerous times before.


Crime victims are absent from the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure. Yet this is not because victims lack vital interests in criminal cases. As the CVRA recognizes, victims have vital concerns throughout the criminal process. This section recounts the absence of victims from the federal criminal rules, then contrasts that absence with the aims of the victims’ rights movement. The movement has argued successfully before state legislatures and Congress for the recognition of crime victims’ rights-with these efforts culminating in the passage of the CVRA, protecting crime victims’ rights in the federal system.

It sounds so kind and thoughtful to demonstrate concern for the victims, those “forgotten” people in the criminal justice system.  But the argument is wrong.  The victims are very much included, as the witnesses who provide the critical testimony against the defendant.  They are the central focus of the trial.  They are at the epicenter of the system.  The problem is, to victims rights advocates, that they aren’t there on equal footing as the other two players in the adversary system.

They shouldn’t be.  The prosecution does not represent victims, and it shouldn’t.  The defendant should not have two independent adversaries, and he shouldn’t.  The existence and deployment of criminal laws is not to vindicate personal rights of any individual victim, but to reflect society’s hedge against criminal conduct. 

But Congress, dear Congress, in passing the Scott Campbell, Stephanie Roper, Wendy Preston, Louarna Gillis, and Nila Lynn Crime Victims’ Rights Act (yes, that’s the complete name of the CVRA), could not help itself from enjoying the political gain from appealing to the needs of victims.  Who could say “no” to victims?  This was a political slam dunk.

The only problem is that new Rule 60 creates a new victim, one that no one was concerned about at the time.  The integrity of the criminal justice system.

So when you rise to argue to the jury that the testimony of the victim has been irreparably tainted by him sitting in the courtroom, listening intently to the testimony preceding him, and tailoring his testimony to match up perfectly with that of earlier witnesses, anticipate the objection.  Expect the “sustained”, or at least the cautionary instruction that the victim is permitted as a matter of law to be present for the testimony.  After all, why concern yourself with the legitimacy of the victim’s testimony when there are emotions to be played? 

So don’t be surprised when you see the victim sitting in the front row throughout the trial.  It’s his right.  That it comes at the expense of the defendant’s right to a fair trial is old news, as of yesterday.

The Newest Second Amendment Hero, Plaxico Burress

As a die-hard New York Giants fan, it’s hard to take off my blue helmet and put on my lawyer hat to rationally discuss wide receiver Plaxico Burress.  This is even more true when he retained Ben Brafman, who successfully defended Puffy Daddy, to make his problems to away.  But with the Giants 11-1 after beating the pants off the Washington Redskins, it’s time to admit the truth.  Burress is a big, tall bone-head who’s going to jail.  Here’s the prediction: He’s taking a bullet for shooting a bullet.  You heard it here first.

Special treatment?  He’s already getting it.  You didn’t see a special news alert in the middle of the game to show SWAT teams busting into Burress’ New Jersey mansion, did you?  Most shooters don’t get a gentle knock on the door, and a request for permission to speak with the perp. 

The “why’s” behind the street-cred stupidity things are obvious.  Plax is a street guy who happens to play ball, and carried a gun to “protect” himself from the other street guys who might be inclined to prove that they are as tough as him.  No, it’s not a very good reason, but Burress didn’t ask for our advice.  That he had an itchy trigger finger and was safety-challenged is a matter for the J-dog to address; apparently Burress didn’t take a decent gun safety class.  Of course, a lot of people carrying illegal weapons don’t,  But the newspapers reported that he did, at one time, possess a legal Florida carry permit, so it’s possible that he should have known better.

New York State has some very tight gun laws.  Falling well within the gaping hole of Heller, Burress took his gun on the road, so the potential safe haven of home defense isn’t readily available to him.  I wouldn’t put it past Ben to fashion an excellent argument that this was still a defensive possession, even though in a bar in Manhattan, but that would create an untenable situation for the thousands of other gun possessors who similarly claim that they only carry for safety.  Every defendant says that.

There used to be a loophole in the gun law so that a defendant could receive a sentence of probation on a first offense.  That was closed when the Lege realized that they stood to be embarrassed when some kid on probation shot up a bodega, and then mandated jail time for a weapon.  He could even do prison time.  It could happen.

Granted, Burress has yet to be charged or arrested, though Brafman says he will surrender today.  Maybe there’s a great story behind this accidental self-shooting.  Maybe Ben will find a spin that makes some inkling of sense.  He’s a very imaginative fellow, not to be underestimated.  But it seems like there’s too much water under the bridge already to change the story now. 

The most curious side story to this is that Cornell Medical Center failed to alert police to a gun shot wound when Burress showed up for treatment Friday night.  A Giants fan in the ER perhaps?  A phone call from the Maras?  Most people find hospitals rather unwilling to risk problems with their patients, but apparently the hospital bearing Sandy Weil’s name is the place to go for gun shot wounds from now on.  It could be a new marketing strategy, since hospitals are competing for patients with good insurance.

Plaxico Burress is being roundly condemned for being a malcontent, a bad boy and an idiot.  Why?  He’s a wide receiver.  There’s no ethic tests for being a wide out.  He’s expected to catch footballs, and he does that awfully well.  People continually overlay a duty on sports figures to be better, nicer, smarter then they are.  He was known to be street when they signed him up, and it’s not like they forced him to take classes in being a better person.  Sure, there’s a morals clause in the contract, but nobody can read the contract while they are counting up the signing bonus. 

In the grand scheme of things, Burress was stupid, but not a whole lot more stupid than plenty of others.  He wasn’t venal, like Michael Vick.  He didn’t pull out the gun to shoot someone.  This is a malum prohibitum offense, and not a crime of moral turpitude, unless stupidity implicates morality on the back end. The only person harmed by his itchy finger was himself.

And my beloved Giants.  While they can still win without him, it would be better if he was with them on the field catching the fade into the corner of the end zone.