Author Archives: SHG

How Much Collateral Damage is Tolerable?

When Radley Balko posted at The Agitator about the death of Laquisha Turner, a 17-year-old quadriplegic woman from Richmond, California, it crystallized a very real question about the tipping point between the dual functions of police, public safety and law enforcement.  In particular, when cops are engaged primarily in one function, law enforcement, how concerned should they be about their other?

From ABC7 in San Francisco,



[W]hen FBI agents raided her house as part of a major gang sweep last month, West said Turner never recovered.


“When I opened the door I said, ‘I have a disabled daughter…you guys are going to scare her, you can come in and search, do whatever you have to do,’ but by this time they were coming in the side door shooting things,” West said. 


Laquisha Turner was the victim of a drive-by shooting, ironically as a result of gang violence, and was left a quad as a result, spending her days at home playing cards and watching television.  The police entered shooting flash-bang grenades, designed to stun and confuse occupants, and avoid harm to police and occupants.


“They kept telling her to get down on the ground and she kept telling them, ‘I can’t get down,'” West said.

Should the police have been aware, in advance, that there was a quadriplegic in the house they were about to raid?  Should they be expected to ascertain whether there will be special circumstances involved, or is this too much a burden on the police? 

It’s easy to default to the answer that cops should always be required to know what they are doing beforehand, though  there is something inherently contradictory about that reaction.  The fact is that we expect the police to do their job when it comes to law enforcement in order to fulfill their responsibility to protect us from people inclined to commit crimes.  In this case, Laquisha Turner, herself the victim of violent crime, is the example of why we can’t saddle the police with a constant stream of greater and more burdensome duties.  If you don’t want to get shot on the street, then don’t make it impossible for the cops to do their job.

On the other hand, there are certain aspects of an execution of a warrant that call into question how great a burden it would be to have some clue what you might be facing inside.  Initially, the police were not engaged in a street encounter with unknown people of dubious threat.  They made the decision to enter into someone’s home, a place that the law (and most rational people) endow with a special degree of protection from forced entry.  The police made the call to break into Laquisha Turner’s home, and she did nothing to cause it. 

Further, the warrant to enter the Turner home required police to express some degree of knowledge about why they should be entitled to do so.  The expectation that they show good cause to execute the warrant includes the belief that they have good basis to knock down a door and find the target inside.  They are thus expected to have a far greater degree of knowledge about what they are doing than they would have in a typical street encounter.  In other words, the increased burden of ascertaining whether there are likely to be children, innocent people, quadriplegics inside a home, shouldn’t be particularly great.

And finally, there is the larger question about the primacy of the police functions.  Which is more important, public safety or law enforcement?  The justification for law enforcement is public safety; Police don’t enforce laws because it’s fun to do or wins them medals to wear in court to prove their credibility.  Their authority to enforce laws stems from the public welfare, and the public welfare demands that they do not harm people in the process of enforcing laws.  They do not harm innocent people.  They do not harm less than innocent people, either, to the extent they can avoid doing so consistent with self-protection, a point missed by many.

While it’s true that the expectation that cops find out if there will be a Laquisha Turner, or a Tarika Wilson, killed while holding her baby almost a year ago in Lima, Ohio, inside the house they’re about to raid, it is more important that they not harm the innocent in the course of performing their law enforcement function.

To put it another way, just as it is a axiomatic that it is better that 10 guilty men go free than 1 innocent man be convicted, it is a fundamental precept that the police not harm the innocent in their zeal fo get their target.  The bad guys will still be there tomorrow, but there will be no tomorrow for Laquisha Turner or Tarika Wilson or the others who are the unfortunate collateral damage of law enforcement. 

The duty of the police must be to protect the public first, even if it means that they have to find another way to capture their target.  If this is not their first priority, then they have neither legal nor moral authority to perform the law enforcement function.

10 Blawging “Dos” and “Don’ts”

As of yesterday, I officially became knowledgeable about blawging.  No, I did not proclaim myself an expert.  No, I did not have an epiphany.  No, I did not learn the true meaning of “search engine optimization,” and I still have no clue what that means or how to actually do it.  For the nuts and bolts junk, you have to go elsewhere.  If that’s your purpose, you may want to stop reading immediately, as I offer no refund on wasted time. 

Instead, I found myself quoted in a Law.com article by C.C. Holland entitled How to Build a Better Law Blog.  If I wasn’t knowledgeable, I wouldn’t be in there.  Walter Olson from Overlawyered was in there too, and for me to be in the same article as Walter is, well, flattering to say the least.  I mean, seriously, he started this whole blawging thing and I’m just a baby in comparison.  I hardly have the right to sit at his bended knee, so it must mean something that C.C. thought that anything I could say would have a place in the same article with Walter.

Now that my thoughts on blawging are worthy of open expression, I feel obliged to share them with others.  It’s a noblesse oblige thing that sweeps over us blawgers from time to time. After all, as C.C. writes:


Are you thinking about a foray into the world of law blogging? If so, you’re far from alone. According to the American Bar Association, there are over 2,000 law blogs now listed in the organization’s Blawg Directory, and the number is growing rapidly.

The benefits of blogging include better search-engine optimization, since frequent updates of attorney sites lead to more attention from Google and its ilk; an appearance of authority due to online punditry; and a combination of push and pull marketing. Blogs are less intrusive than e-mail newsletters and offer an opportunity for a conversation instead of a lecture. They may also showcase attorneys’ intellect or wit, thus personalizing them to potential clients.

Since they’re easy to start and cheap to run, it’s no wonder that so many new law blogs are sprouting. But don’t jump onto the bandwagon with a half-baked blog. If your blog is boring, banal or shamelessly self-promoting, it’ll do you little good and will likely die a slow death.

Did you know there were 2000 blawgs?  Do you care?  Chances are that if you’re reading this blawg, you read a few others.  But one point that’s missed by most blawgers is there are only so many free hours in a day, especially now that twitter has been proclaimed the coolest thing ever, and it soaks up time like nobody’s business.  So it’s critical that a new blawg find it’s way into that tiny niche of blawgs that make it onto peoples’ radar.  After all, why put in all that time if no one will either see or care about your blawg.  That’s just insulting.

That’s why it’s critical that you follow the 10 Blawging “Dos” and “Don’ts”.  Everybody in the blawgosphere loves a list.  Your blawg will be linked in every single existing blawg, for example, if you create a list of the 10 Best Blawgs of All Time.  It doesn’t matter if your blawg has zero content otherwise, Want proof?  This website, called “Criminal Justice Degrees Guide,” which pimps for places that offer instruction on how to become a paralegal, posted the Top 100 Law Blogs, and even the biggest, baddest blawgs, like Above the Law (with the highest demographics around in the age 3 to 7 range)  linked to it and announced how honored they were.  This list made them an overnight smash in the blawgosphere.  And you can too!

Of course, another reason why it’s critical to follow the 10 Blawging “Dos” and Don’ts” is that a spectacular entry into the blawgosphere does not guarantee that you will be able to hold an audience.  After all, even a clock that’s stopped is right twice a day, and huge success by following my rules will mean nothing if it’s not followed up by following more of my rules.  If I didn’t know stuff, would C.C. Holland have put me in the same article with Walter Olson?  Get real.


Walter Olson imagined that his Overlawyered blog would pull an audience of his friends and acquaintances and a cadre of legal policy wonks.

“But you don’t know who your audience really is until you start writing and find out,” he notes. “My readership has a large following among lawyers, but I’ve been surprised to find that a lot of doctors are reading it, as are a lot of people from other countries.”

Let’s face it, nobody knows how to blow money faster than doctors.  Why should they spill it only on Porsche 911 Turbo Carreras to make them look young and cool (as if) when they can be paying it over to you?  It’s just not fair.  If Walter can grab the docs, you can too.  There’s nothing they love more than a blawg whose purpose is to criticize lawyers, and there’s nothing easier to write about because you never run out of material.  It’s a perfect match!

I think I’ve made my point as clearly as humanly possible; If you want to be a smashing success in the blawgosphere (and who doesn’t?) and be able tell all your friends that you’ve optimized your search engine, just follow my 10 Blawging “Dos” and “Don’ts” to the letter and you too can be a Thought Leader and enjoy unbelievable financial success and gain the admiration of all! 

And isn’t that really what the blawgosphere is all about?

In the Marketplace of Ideas, Some are Bankrupt

My love of vapid platitudes aside, there are some that wreak greater havoc than others.  Two of my favorites are, “there are two sides to every story,” and “everybody is entitled to their own opinion.”  These are two of the greatest devises for comparing sound reasoning with whatever load of lunacy someone else can come up with.

The other day, David Giacalone of f/k/a wrote me to express his disgust at the lawyer’s argument at sentence for Schenectady’s former Chief of Police and drug dealer, Gregory Kaczmarek (affectionately known as “Kaz”)


Please stop insulting our intelligence by telling us — as your mouthpiece Tom O’Hearn did over and over — that taking the plea “ultimately . . . was a pretty stand up thing for him to do,” because it allowed his wife, against whom there was more-compelling evidence, to avoid going to the penitentiary.  O’Hearn says he’d prefer his client take his chances with a jury. 

I tried to calm David down by reminding him that this is what criminal defense lawyers are required to do, provide the best possible argument they can on behalf of their clients.  Sometimes there is a good argument, well founded in fact and law.  Sometimes, we do the best we can with what we have.  It’s our job.  He understood.  He didn’t like it, but he understood.

On the other hand, that same rationale doesn’t apply everywhere or to everything.  There are assuredly times when reasonable people may differ, when there are policy choices to be made, or mere preferences in the weighing of relevant factors.  Sometimes things fall under the heading of “acceptance decisions,”  Some people love chocolate.  I don’t particularly care for it.  It’s not a right or wrong, but just a personal preference.

Personal preference, however, does not apply to reason.  When it comes to the application of reason, there aren’t always two sides of equal or equivalent value.  Sometimes, the arguments proffered are just irrational or illogical, and do not deserve the deference their makers demand.

Worse still, opinions without basis in fact are worthless.  If people want to fabricate a fiction to justify their arguments, then they lose any right to expect anyone to take them seriously.  You can’t just make things up, then argue your point based upon fiction. 

Now, to bring this home.  There has been an epidemic here of late of people commenting based upon pure, unadulterated, baseless assumption, and then wrapping it up in a logical fallacy.  The content shows that they have no idea that they are relying upon assumption, as they take their views very seriously and can’t begin to comprehend why everyone else doesn’t assume as they do.  In other words, a world exists within their heads, and they believe this world to be real for everyone as it is for them. 

When others fail to back up their view of the world through baseless assumption, they get all huffy.  They insist they’re right.  They demand they’re right.  They stamp their feet and make the same argument over and over, because obviously no one else grasps their brilliance if they don’t see the same world as they do. 

Then they get angry about it.  This stems from the belief that their position is entitled to respect, deference even.  It’s not.  Sure, people (especially me) could be kinder about disagreeing, but no one is entitled to have their ill-conceived notions treated with hid gloves.  No one is entitled to have someone else explain to them, calmly, nicely and usually ad naseum, why their assumptions are wrong.  If they lay an egg, they should expect it to get scrambled.  If they don’t want to be challenged, then keep it to yourself.

At sentence, a defendant has a right to be heard.  Here, there is no such right.  A judge has a responsibility employ appropriate judicial temperament, meaning that he’s generally ill-advised to call a lawyer a moron.  This is no courtroom, and I’m no judge. 

I’m not telling anyone not to speak their mind.  I am, however, telling you that your opinion may not be worthy of admiration and respect, and may well subject you to widespread ridicule.  If it makes you feel any better, there are plenty of people who feel the same about my opinions, laid out for the world to see whenever I post something on Simple Justice. 

I put my credibility on the line every time I put my thoughts in writing and press the little button that makes it appear on my blawg. I take my risks. You take yours.  So don’t whine about it if it turns out that you don’t have a right to your opinion.  I’ve had my butt handed to me from time to time.  Maybe today is your turn.  Get over it. 

If you can’t live with this, go post on the marketing blogs, where they will kiss every butt that comes along lest they miss a potential sale.  There you get kindness, no matter how ridiculous your opinions may be.  Here, you take your chances.

But Really, Aren’t We All Victims?

There he goes again, but this time he’s trying to stretch the rhetoric so that it will eventually include pretty much everybody on the face of the earth.  Who?  My favorite victims rights advocate, Paul Cassell, who posts at VC about his latest foray into spreading the victimhood in the case of mortgage banker mutt, Phillip Coon.

Coon, a vice-president at Coast Bank, came up with a scheme to split one point of a mortgage origination fee between himself and the mortgage broker who sold the residential real estate loans.  Former District Court Judge turned Utah Lawprof Cassell argues that the homeowners who paid the point are victims, and therefore entitled to a seat at the table.

The borrowers’ petition arises out of a plan by Coon to “skim points” off of residential mortgage loans in Florida from 2004–07. On November 5, 2008, Coon pled guilty to the scheme in U.S. District Court in Tampa. A group of 112 borrowers of these loans then filed a motion with Judge Kovachevich to be recognized as “victims” of his crime of conspiracy because they had to pay extra on their mortgages because of the crime. Judge Kovachevich denied the motion because the government’s charges only specifically listed Coast Bank, Coon’s employer, as the victim of the crime.

What’s fascinating is how the argument relies on a twist of the facts to create victimhood.  You see, the borrowers agreed to pay two points on their loans, paid their points (either up front or by inclusion within the loan) and got their check.  Paul argues that had there been no scheme, the borrowers would have paid one point less.  And so he filed a petition for mandamus in the 11th Circuit.


In the petition filed yesterday, I explain that the borrowers suffered financial harms because they became legally obligated to pay the point that Coon skimmed off the loan and had to pay interest on the point. The petition cites documents showing that Coon received more than $1.1 million from his crime, which he used to buy overseas vacations, fine wine, expensive jewelry, a $20,000 piano, and other luxury items. The petition states that “while Coon was enjoying the high life on his ill-gotten gains, the borrowers were all paying interest on the money financing it.” The petition seeks restitution for the borrowers.

What Coon did with his ill-gotten gains has zero bearing on who the victim is, and its inclusion in his argument is an obvious effort to whip up hard feelings.  It’s not that Coon doesn’t deserve hard feelings, but that there remains no logical connection between the hard feelings and Paul’s argument.  But when it comes to victims, logic apparently plays no role.  It’s all about the sympathy factor.

Coon should pay restitution, but to the appropriate victim of his crime, Coast Bank.  It was Coast’s half point that he stole, not the borrowers.  They received the deal they agreed to, and suffered no loss from their expectations.  Coast Bank, on the other hand, was entitled to his honest service, and was denied it (not to mention their half point). 

The danger of this argument is its implications for the future, given the rosy future for mortgage-related prosecutions going forward.


This could be a nationally significant case that will set the precedent for whether people who harmed by financial crimes have rights in the process. In my view, the borrowers here lost real money as a result of Coon’s crime – they should have their rights as crime victims respected.

If the borrowers are allowed to assume the status of victims, given the political happy meal offered by the CVRA as well as the new Rule 60 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, there will be no stopping borrowers from involvement in essentially every mortgage related case, even when they received everything they agreed to.

Applying a theoretical model, where everything that happens with regard to a mortgage ultimately is paid for by a borrower somewhere, there is no conceptual ledge to prevent borrowers (and consider the number we’re talking about) from intervening in a prosecution.  But by the same theoretical extension, we are all “borrowers” and all victims.  After all, the APR of residential mortgages moved in lockstep from bank to bank, meaning that one bank’s increase in points allowed others to do the same, meaning that all borrowers paid more than they theoretically should/could have but for the crime.  Do we all get a piece of the pie?

However, “but for” arguments such as this are purely speculative.  Banks increase points because they can, and because they are in the business of obtaining the best return on their investment.  As Coast Bank could get another point on their loans from otherwise satisfied borrowers, then there was no harm.  Similarly, if the borrowers were unhappy with the terms of the loan, they could have called the next bank on the list.  And if the next bank on the list also bumped the points up one because Coast Bank did, then ever borrower from every bank suffered the same theoretical consequence of the crime.  So either we’re all victims, or none.

One thing remains unclear to me, which is that Doug Berman at Sentencing Law & Policy also posted about this matter, and offered this:


I am pleased to see from this post at The Volokh Conspiracy that Professor Paul Cassell is continuing his important efforts to get district and circuit courts to give serious effect to the federal Crime Victims’ Rights Act.

Given Doug’s concern for doctrinal purity in sentencing, I can’t understand why, when it comes to the “victims’ rights” issue and CVRA, sympathy for the victims, even when they aren’t actually victims, should undermine the basic structure of the adversary process of the criminal justice system and the rights of defendants.  I’ve discussed many times and many ways why victims have no place in the well in the criminal justice system.  Yes, they’re sympathetic.  No, they don’t get to have a third table in the courtroom. 

I would sincerely like to understand how Doug rationalizes his views on fair and appropriate sentencing in general with his support of victims’ rights, which seems so antithetical to his concerns about the lack of fairness and proportionality in sentencing.  There is no insular group whose involvement would serve no purpose beyond a blatant appeal to visceral vengeance than victims.  I don’t get it. 

The Downside of Gall; Using “Local Conditions” to Enhance a Sentence

From Doug Berman, the Second Circuit’s en banc decision in U.S. v. Cavera arrived the other day, reversing the original panel’s ruling that EDNY Judge Charles Sifton’s use of “local conditions” to increase a sentence above the guidelines is permissible.  Ironically, the explanation for this reversal is none other than the intervening Supreme Court decisions in Gall and Kimbrough.

Cavera was in his 70s when he decided to embark on a career as a gun dealer, You know how those wild septuagenarians in Florida will do anything to keep busy and make a buck.  So Cavera found selling guns to be brought up to New York a good way to keep his idle hands busy, and it made good use of the training from his army career.

After a plea of guilty. Cavera faced a guidelines range of 12 to 18 months, but advised that he was considering an above-guidelines sentence because of “local conditions.”  What this meant was that bringing guns into New York City was an offense of a different calibre than, say, Sherman Oaks, California.  Judge Sifton concluded that the guidelines failed to adequately address the need for deterrence of gun trafficking in large metropolitan areas.  With higher homicide rates and the plethora of problems cause by weapons possession in cities, the guidelines could not properly homogenize the nation as it was intended to do when it came to guns.

On the initial appeal, the Circuit reversed, with the government agreeing that the sentence could not stand, holding that it was improper for Judge Sifton to impose a broad-based policy decision on the sentence of this individual.  The District Court could only take into account particularized arguments relative to the defendant before it, and went beyond his authority to determine, as a matter of policy, that the guidelines failed to provide adequate deterrence for major metropolitan areas.

But that was then.  This is now.

As a product of Booker, Gall and Kimbrough, the Circuit held that their review was limited to an abuse of discretion, and that the “very wide latitude” afforded a sentencing judge  allows him to take into account the “nature of the offense” as well as that of the defendant.  The double-edge sword of Gall and Kimbrough is here.

As Judge Sifton properly considered the guidelines as well as the factors set forth in 3553(a), he satisfied his procedural duty and left the Circuit to consider only substantive review, subject to the “unreasonableness” standard of highly deferential review.  The Circuit held that it was not to substitute its judgment for that of the sentencing judge.  The Court expressly rejected the presumption of reasonableness of a within guidelines sentence, as well as the presumption of unreasonableness of an outside guidelines sentence.

But all this doesn’t mean that sentences only depart in one direction, a point that many forget when they held parties after the Gall and Kimbrough decisions.

In this case, the Circuit held that the sentencing court was authorized to impose a sentence higher than the guidelines would require based upon a broad policy position, provided that the sentencing judge applies the considerations of 3553(a).  In this case, Judge Sifton used the general deterrence prong, certainly a legitimate and proper consideration for sentence, to justify his imposition of a higher than guidelines sentence on Cavera.

On the down side, the expectation that judges would use Gall and Kimbrough as a means of reducing the ridiculously harsh sentences mandated by the guidelines has been proven wrong.  While available for that purpose, it’s similarly available to increase a sentence, despite the fact that many believe that the guidelines are far too harsh to begin with.

On the up side, this decision clarifies many of the issues of review and latitude given district court judges, including the use of policy arguments with regard to crimes, most notably the crack guidelines.  As for Cavera, the enhanced sentence added a mere 6 months to the top end of the guidelines, which for most people wouldn’t be all that painful, though for a man in his 70s is like adding 10 years to the back end.

If you do federal defense in the 2nd Circuit, this is a must read decision, and offers much for argument regardless of which way you want the sentence to go.

Cops and Lawprofs Should Take a Pregnant Pause

For anyone who has either been pregnant, or been next to someone who has been pregnant for the full gestation period, there is no doubt that it’s a condition requiring a very high degree of understanding.  No one can argue with hormones.  But even more, it’s an event that remains miraculous  each and every time, even though it’s happened as many times as there are people on the face of the earth.  You’ve got to admit, that’s pretty special.

Yet not everyone seems to have a soft spot for pregnancy.  First, we have Massachusetts State Trooper Michael Galluccio (of the Brighton barracks, in case you were wondering).  According to the Boston Globe, Michael doesn’t have much of a soft spot.

Jennifer Davis was stuck in bumper-to-bumper traffic on Nov. 18, her contractions just 3 minutes apart. Her husband, John, was trying to appear calm for his wife’s sake, driving in the breakdown lane of Route 2. They pulled up behind a state trooper to ask whether they could continue using the lane to reach the next exit, near Alewife Station.

Not only did the trooper say no, he gave them a $100 citation for driving in the breakdown lane, made them wait for their citation while he finished writing someone else’s ticket, and even seemed to ask for proof of pregnancy, Jennifer Davis said.

Well, that wasn’t very nice.  True, the Davis’ use of the shoulder to circumvent bumper to bumper traffic was the potential first step toward anarchy, there being important laws prohibiting driving in the “breakdown lane” for the protection of society.  On the other hand, police frequently exercise a bit of discretion when circumstances, like pregnant women in labor, suggest it’s appropriate.  Had Jennifer been a pregnant police officer, perhaps she would have obtained more help from Trooper Galluccio.

But the story of Jennifer and Michael the Trooper doesn’t end with a $100 citation.  Oh no.  It seems that this tale has caused deep-seated antagonism toward those pregnant women with a sense of entitlement to bubble to the surface.  And surprisingly, not from the angry mobs of barren hermaphrodites, but from the legal academy.  Go figure.

David Bernstein at Volokh Conspiracy took this tale of inchoate anarcho-syndicalism and ran with it:


What a cruel, heartless cop, right? That’s the way the story is written.

But wait. If you read the story carefully, when the cop pulled the husband over, he was attending to a car in the breakdown lane, where the husband was driving illegally (albeit allegedly with the permission of cops he encountered previously). In other words, the husband was endangering the cop’s life. And the couple turned down the officer’s offer of an ambulance. Why? Well, when you get to the last paragraph, you find out that the baby wasn’t born until five hours later. If it’s a true emergency, call 911 and meet the ambulance at the next exit!

As I’ve pointed out before, the fact that a woman is in labor is no excuse for unsafe driving.

That’s just heartless.  Worse still, it’s factually wrong.  Nowhere does the story suggest that a cop’s life was endangered.  Not even close.  Not even from as biased a starting point as David’s post suggests.  The attempt to justify this animus toward pregnant women, that she didn’t in fact deliver for another five hours, is shocking.  Does David think that pregnant women know how long labor is going to take.  As a professor, an academic, a scholar, this is just incredibly foolish stuff.

What drives this sort of hostility toward pregnant women?  That’s for a well-paid therapist to discover after many years of appointments, but it’s wrong to suggest that Trooper Michael Galluccio, in his zeal to protect the breakdown lane from heinous pregnant women, is the last man standing between order and pregnant chaos.

Had the Trooper and the lawprof taken a deep breadth, thought about their mothers under the same conditions, and considered that the excessive desire for order and compliance has to occasionally give way, perhaps the miracle of child birth would be cause for joy rather than a $100 citation. 

Is It Just Too Hard to Follow Instructions?

While the vast majority of the work needed to effect the strategy of winning a criminal case falls on the criminal defense lawyer, there are certain things that a defendant or his family are required to do.  Gathering information, for example, or obtaining paperwork from past enterprises. 

The list changes with every case and every charge, but these are simply not things that the attorney can do for the client.  We need a little cooperation from our own guy, and it would hardly seem too much to ask, considering that it’s his life on the line.  Yet, this can prove to be the one of the most difficult aspect of a defense to perform, particularly when the case is complex and requires tactics that have multiple steps.  Indeed, a sophisticated defense can implode when it entails reliance on the client.

Why?  Because clients frequently find it impossible to follow simple instructions.  Tell them to take 5 steps forward, then turn to the right, and they end up 16 blocks away.  There’s some bone in people’s head that compels them to ignore the advice of the person to whom they have paid a substantial amount of money and in whose hands they have entrusted their life.  Strange.

While having a lawyer to represent you may be the first step toward achieving your desired goal of prevailing against criminal accusations, it’s not the last.  In difficult cases, and particularly in white collar cases, a fully-conceived defense requires that all the players on the defense side contribute to the goal.  This means that paying the fee isn’t enough, but making oneself available to do the handful of things asked of you, and then doing them properly, is part of the deal.

And this is where things go astray.  It’s my practice to provide explicit instructions on how something is to be done, based upon my experience of how best to accomplish a particular task, the potential pitfalls of performing the task in other ways and the risk of failure should the task not be adequately or properly performed.  Very detailed.  Very explicit. Very precise.

Yet clients take my instructions and decide that they have a better idea, usually an easier, less burdensome way (for them) to perform the task.  Without further discussion, they go full throttle into performing the task and wreak havoc. 

Afterward, when the damage is done, the task having failed and the sheepish client staring blankly at me, muttering, “but you’re the lawyer…can’t you fix it?” I’m left to bang my head against the conference table.  Of course I’m the lawyer.  I was also the lawyer last week, when we discussed how to perform this small but critical task, and I explained in painful detail why it had to be done a particular way. 

Whether it’s preservation of evidence, or preservation of privilege, or completeness (a perpetual problem, where clients want you to see all the stuff that’s great for him but none of the stuff that’s going to blow the defense out of the water), there are sound reasons why specific instructions are given.  There really are, I swear. 

White collar defendants, in particular, are notoriously bad about following instructions.  The problem, I’ve found, is that they are smart and worldy.  They functioned for much of their life autonomously as best, and in a supervisory position at worst, where they gave directions.  They didn’t take them.  Their personal accomplishment derived from their coming up with a “better way,” and they’ve come to believe that whatever notion pops into their heads is, by definition, a good one.  It’s a perfectly understandable affectation.  It’s also quite a problem. 

Sometimes, problems can be fixed, at least adequately to continue to pursue the desired strategy.  Other times, it’s back the drawing board.  When the failure to follow instructions results in the unfixable problem, a defendant may blow the only viable avenue of defense available.  The consequences are crushing, potentially meaning that a defendant who started with at least a theoretically successful strategy is left without recourse.  This is not a good reason to lose a case.

Understand that at the end of the case, the lawyer goes home either way.  It’s the defendant and his family that pays the price.  But any good criminal defense lawyer wants to win the case, both for himself and for his client.  It matters that we’ve done everything possible to help, explored every possible opportunity and performed every task successfully.  We take no comfort in the fact that it’s the client who screwed it up; it isn’t about blame, but about success.  We want to provide clients with the best possible success.  It’s what makes us get out of bed in the morning.

Help us to do this.  If we give you instructions, follow them.  Even if you think you know better, have a better idea or there’s a hole in your racket, have enough trust in our competence and experience to perform the task the way we tell you.  Let there be no doubt that it’s in your best interest, and that your best interest is paramount.  Please?

When confronted with the problem, the reaction is usually that they meant well.  Ah, “the road to hell” axiom rears its ugly head.  What is misunderstood is that your lawyer isn’t flexing his muscles for fun, or to elevate himself over you.  This isn’t a competition.  This is a duty to defend you as successfully as the law allows, whether you get it or not. 

Cash & Carry Law Enforcement

From Turley comes an idea that will put a serious dent in overwhelming taxes.  You know how they have all that great equipment on the shiny red firetrucks?  Well, they just got a new toy to add to the mix, a credit card machine. 


The tough economic times are producing some highly questionable revenue measures by cities and states. One of the most problematic is the growing trend for towns, cities, and counties to charge citizens to use of police or fire services in emergencies. At least 24 states have such laws on the books and private contractors are pushing for every state to allow them to collect from crime and fire victims.

“Yes, Ma’am.  We see that you’re pinned under your car.  Will that be Visa or Mastercard?”


Part of this movement is being pushed by private contractors who want a percentage of the take from collecting reimbursement from victims. They generally demand 10% of the cut. While Georgia, Indiana, Missouri, Pennsylvania and Tennessee have banned “crash taxes,” other states have proven ripe for this sale’s pitch and citizens are being hit with demands for payment for assistance that was historically viewed as an essential government service. Indeed, the whole principle of taxes was to fund common necessities like schools, police, fire, and other basic services.

Now I realize that many will find this concept horrible, a disgrace.  If we can’t expect government services to be there for us in times of need, then why would we want government at all?  But that’s such a short-sighted view.  Think customer service.


“Up against the wall…”

“I’m sorry, Officer, but I don’t care for the way you’ve addressed me and have no intention of paying for this arrest.  From now on, I’m afraid that I will have to insist that another officer handle all my arrests.”

“Uh, I apologize.  Is there anything else I can do for you today?  Thank you for using the Metropolitan Police Department. Have a nice day.  Would you mind filling out this survey…”

The possibilities are endless.  Just consider the fun you’ll have contesting your credit card bill at the end of the month.  They charge you and you charge them right back.  How cool would that be?

Seriously, this is what comes of capitalism run amok.  From certain perspectives, the idea that spreading the cost of common necessities, whether police, fire or education, presents fairness issues.  People without children still pay school taxes.  People in quiet peaceful suburbs pay for the police who patrol inner cities.  People in ranch houses pay for ladder trucks.  Why should I pay, some ask, when it doesn’t help ME?

The answer is too obvious for lengthy discussion.  The fundamental concept of the common good means that we, as a society, sacrifice a little for the benefit of the whole.  An educated society helps everyone, so we all pay for it.  There just isn’t need to explain this much further.  But then, how do we explain those states that enable private contractors to perform public functions at a direct charge to the users?

It would appear that our elected officials, with their vast knowledge of civic responsibility, have latched on to an idea that panders to those who put dollars ahead of people.  When one’s focus is limited to the electoral process, and one’s constituents have no greater understanding of government than does their favorite candidate, laws like these with superficial appeal tend to make candidates very popular.

Until your house catches on fire.  Sorry, sir, but we don’t take American Express.

But What Would Spitzer Do?

There used to be an appropriate interval after the death of a spouse before one started dating again.  The same was true for the death of dignity, but Eliot Spitzer, after leaving his office in disgrace, is coming back on the market, courtesy of Slate. From Professor Bainbridge, courtesy of Overlawyered, the word is out that Spitzer’s first column appears today!

With a post entitled Too Big Not to Fail, Spitzer has jumped back into the public light with both feet.  Sure, I could make cheap jokes about the title of his post, relating to his personal hubris to believe that he, Avenging Angel of Government and Client 9, thought himself too big not to fail, but that would be beneath me.  And too easy.  So I won’t.

Bainbridge is incensed by Spitzer’s failure to make even a half-hearted effort at letting the water flow under the bridge before trying to get back in the game.


How far we have come in dumbing down our response to public figures behaving badly. Now we don’t even require them to wait a decent interval before rejoining society.

He posts a bunch of Leno and Letterman jokes, which remain funny today, an wonders how long it will be before Michael Vick will be writing a column on dog training.  This was a good one:


“Do you ever notice politics is the only profession when a guy gets caught with a hooker, the wife has to stand by his side. You know, if this guy was a plumber and he got caught with a prostitute, he’d have his wife’s SUV tire tracks over his head.” –Jay Leno

But, indecent interval aside, there’s one thing that Spitzer brings to his column that few others can.  Having been at the center of the onion, and being now in a position where he has absolutely no future political potential for himself, and owes no fealty to any other player since he’s a pariah, Spitzer is absolutely free to write honestly.  As Kris Kristofferson wrote, “freedom is just another word for nothing left to lose.”  Spitzer is very, very free.

Whether Eliot will use his power well (or write in a more interesting way than he spoke) has yet to be seen.  For now, he’s offering gems like:


This long-term change frames the question we should be asking ourselves: What are we getting for the trillions of dollars in rescue funds? If we are merely extending a fatally flawed status quo, we should invest those dollars elsewhere. Nobody disputes that radical action was needed to forestall total collapse. But we are creating the significant systemic risk not just of rewarding imprudent behavior by private actors but of preventing, through bailouts and subsidies, the process of creative destruction that capitalism depends on.

Yeah, he sounds like a 5th year associate writing a legal brief, without a working knowledge of dangling participles (not that there’s anything wrong with that). 

Indecent interval aside, there is one notable risk for a fellow like Eliot Spitzer to jump atop the bully pulpit, pull up his fly and speak his mind.  It’s quite apparent in his conclusion:


It is time we permitted the market to work: This means true competition with winners and losers; companies that disappear; shareholders and CEOs who can lose as well as win; and government investment in the long-range competitiveness of our nation, not in a failed business model of financial concentration and failed risk management that holds nobody accountable.

Let’s think, holding nobody accountable…why does that phrase strike one as disingenuous?  Hey, did you expect Spitzer to suddenly have a decency epiphany?  Get real.

While it would have certainly been nicer if Eliot’s public return followed an act of redemption, particularly given how many lives were unnecessarily destroyed by this single individual in his zeal to elevate his image to the most vengeful prosecutor in the world (after Giuliani gave up the title), and his efforts at contrition were sorely disappointing.  But he still has thoughts to offer that may prove worthwhile, if he uses his newfound freedom wisely.

And if he stops writing like a lawyer.

Vote For “Defending People” Already

Mark Bennett’s blog, Defending People, has collapsed under the weight of interested readers, leaving him dangling in the wind for most of the day.  In the meantime, the voting for Defending People in the ABA Blawg 100 has been pathetic.  Anemic.  Slow. Totally unacceptable.  I realize all this voting may seem silling, but it will take only a few second of your time and will make me, and maybe even Bennett, the Texas Tornado, happy.  Is that too much to ask?

Here’s the link . 

Take a second and go vote for Defending People.  Do it now.  All the other posts will still be here when you get back.  GO!