For the purpose of invoking rights under the Fourth Amendment, the definition of “seizure” is critical. Since Florida v. Bostick, 501 U.S. 429 (1991), seizure occurs when “a reasonable person would feel free” to leave, to disregard police, to turn their back and walk away. This, of course, is one of those ridiculous legal fictions that only a court could indulge.
Orin Kerr notes the decision by 10th Circuit Judge Michael McConnell in United States v. Thompson, wherein Judge McConnell let’s the cat out of the appellate bag by admitting that the test, repeated in every decision of its sort, is essentially meaningless.
According to formal legal doctrine, an encounter between an individual and the police is consensual when “a reasonable person would feel free ‘to disregard the police and go about his business.’” Florida v. Bostick, 501 U.S. 429, 434 (1991) (quoting California v. Hodari D., 499 U.S. 621, 628 (1991). In addressing this question, however, we must be guided by the Court’s decisions in similar cases rather than our own experience regarding how reasonable people actually respond to police investigations.[Fn1]
[FN1: It might bring greater clarity to this area of the law if the test were framed in terms of whether the officer’s behavior is coercive rather than whether, under the circumstances, the reasonable person would feel “free to disregard the police,” which we suspect is unrealistic.]
That this test continues to frame the discussion is a product of the slavish adherence to precedent, particularly when the Supreme Court comes up with a test it really likes regardless of whether it has any real-life validity.
Why is this test nonsense? Let’s turn to the two basic players in the scenario, the person stopped and the person doing the stopping. No one, but no one, thinks that a police officer’s utterance of the word “halt” is a friendly request. No one, innocent of any wrongdoing or not, can possibly know whether disregard of that word will result in a chase, a bullet in the back or nothing. Human experience suggests that an outcome of “nothing” rarely happens, if for no other reason then the fact that police officers really hate being ignored.
So does any reasonable person, even an innocent person, believe that he is free to ignore a police officer’s question, command, admonition, whatever? Never.
Let’s turn to the other half of the equation, the police officer. Perhaps you want to stop someone walking quietly down the street to ask where they got those really cool looking Nike sneakers, and say the word “Hey!” as they pass. They disregard your “hey” and keep on trucking. What happens next? The alarm goes off in your head that something is awry or the person would have stopped, turned, smiled and inquired, “Hello, officer. Can I help you?” Anything else suggests that you’ve stumbled onto something, and thus compels you to make further, more intrusive, inquiry. And I’m being kind by saying it this way.
Yet the law persists in testing whether a reasonable person is “seized” by virtue of this utterly ridiculous test, leaving both citizens and criminal defense lawyers in the awkward position of addressing street reality in the face of legal pseudo-reality. It might be helpful to consider that a person is seized when the gun is drawn and pointed, or when the police have a person firmly in their grasp and control, but even that doesn’t quite fit with the caselaw since Terry stops enjoy a degree of malleability that surpasses any ability to be limited by consistent doctrine.
Consider the cop who receives the radio call of a black man in jeans and a hoodie with a gun. He’s going to stop everyone fitting the description, which could well be 70% of the people on the street in a given neighborhood, by physical force and with gun drawn. Yet none are seized, under the law, since the seizure is somehow forgiven by the officer’s need to protect himself, which simply doesn’t fit in with the rest of the test. When that happens, we just pretend the test doesn’t exist and override it with police necessity. He isn’t seizing anyone, just safely inquiring.
This is where Judge McConnell’s footnote comes into play. Rather than pretend that there is any meaningful use of the reasonable person test, or that any court actually applies it, an objective test based upon the officer’s actions would seem a far better way to determine whether a seizure has occurred. It would still be far from perfect, since every command by a police officer is inherently coercive, and truth be told, most people feel that they must submit to the shield if they want to avoid a plethora of unpleasant risks.
My test wouldn’t work, of course, because it would require the application of 4th Amendment protections to almost all police/citizen encounters, and that would create an unwieldy situation for police who want to do their job without any constitutional-thingy interfering. It’s unfathomable that any court would apply the 4th Amendment so routinely; convicting people would become a nightmare.
Orin’s view is that the courts, as a matter of practice, spout the language of Hodari D., but engage in a more pragmatic approach by determining seizure via analogy to previously decided cases.
The Supreme Court has tried to address this problem a bit by clarifying that the standard is of a reasonable innocent person, apparently on the theory that a reasonable innocent person has no reason to fear the police. But again, that’s unrealistic: most people don’t feel free to walk away even if they feel they’re totally innocent. I end up advising my students along the lines of what Judge McConnell suggests: Apply the test based on analogy to decided cases applying it rather than by relying on the natural meaning of its words.
It’s unclear whether Orin thinks this is a good idea or just the way it works. I don’t think it’s a good idea at all. Initially, any rule dependent on analogy to other cases is subject to the facile descriptions of conduct by appellate courts. If they want to suppress, they describe the conduct in terms designed to make it appear clearly over the line of seizure. if not, they trivialize it. The problem is that it can be the exact same conduct, subject only to the rhetorical skills of the author relative to the desired outcome. We end up with a result-oriented jurisprudence that offers no guidance whatsoever. Just a lot of words that tell us nothing useful.
Further, the limitations of the written word, its ability to capture the feelings, sensations, timing and atmosphere of an interaction between police and citizens, make law by analogy inadequate. When you consider that our right to be left alone, to be free from search and compelled questioning, depends on how expressive, detailed or sympathetic a judge, the integrity of our constitutional protections hangs on a very thin thread.
So why are there so many issues surrounding a concept that most normal people would find easily answered? Why is it so difficult for such smart people as Supreme Court justices to come up with a test to determine when a person is seized that can be readily and realistically applied? Because doing so would mean that we would have to apply the full panoply of 4th Amendment rights to almost every interaction between citizens and police.
And wouldn’t that be horrible.