Author Archives: SHG

Confusing Reports on Cellphone Searches

When J-dog told me about this Wisconsin case the other day, I planned on posting about it.  But after reading, and think, and reading again, I thought it was just so pathetically bad on every conceivable end to be worth the time it would take to make sense of it, particularly given that it was such an inconsequential decision. 

I was wrong.  Both the Wall Street Journal and the ABA Journal picked up on the subject.  And both send a confusing message, which means that somebody has to straighten things out.  The issue is whether a police officer can search a cellphone as part of a search incident to arrest. 

The mid-level appellate decision from Wisconsin’s 1st District Court of Appeals in the case of Jermichael James Carroll was just a botch all around.  The facts of the case show that Jermichael was a pathological narcissist who kept pictures on his cellphone of such diverse niceties as smoking a blunt, holding automatic weapons and surrounded by coke and cash. 

Then, Jermichael thought it smart to drive around 60 in a 25 mile zone to attract a little attention.  Then, Jermichael thought it smart to try to make a run for it when he stopped.  They Jermichael thought it smart to run with his phone on and open and in his hand, so that it could be confused with a weapon. Then Jermichael decided to drop it on the ground with the phone on and open, so his fabulous photos of himself would be readily visible.  So start with the fact that Jermichael’s a genius.

The decision goes on to note that his appellate lawyer made the strategic decision to ignore the prosecution’s argument on appeal that Detective Belsha, the arresting officer, answered a phone call asking in code for four and a half ounces of cocaine, which alone would serve to legitimize a search warrant for Jermichael’s cellphone. 

And the appellate court chose to reverse the hearing court’s suppression based on a theory that was never argued below, choosing instead to leave untouched the issue of whether a police officer can search a cellphone as a search incident to arrest.

The WSJ article discusses the concerns of law prof Adam Gershowitz:



Adam Gershowitz, a professor at the South Texas College of Law, argues law enforcement officials are flirting with a dangerous invasion of privacy under the “search incident to arrest” doctrine, which allows officers to search “containers” on the person of or within the reach of suspects without probable cause.


The doctrine is designed to protect police from a suspect who could reach for a hidden weapon and to prevent suspects from concealing or destroying evidence. Mr. Gershowitz argues that iPhones and other “smart” devices are, in the eyes of the law, now nothing but containers subject to warrantless search.


Welllll, kinda.  Sorta.  I’m sure that cops see cellphones as a great source of incriminating evidence and can’t even begin to imagine why they shouldn’t be allowed to wedge it into the search incident to arrest exception so that they can immediately check them out and enjoy whatever goodies are to be found.  Like very handsome pics of Jermichael smoking a blunt.

But that doesn’t mean that any court has ever agreed with, or upheld, the mangling of the search incident exception to allow for the search of a cellphone.  The WSJ even quotes one of my favorite lawprofs, Orin Kerr: 

“I don’t think I’ve seen yet a case where police stop someone and for no apparent reason start searching through their iPhone,” says Orin Kerr, a professor at George Washington University Law School.

Yes, Orin stuck that qualifier (“for no apparent reason”) in the middle of the quote, but that doesn’t change the fact that there are no decisions that allow a cellphone search as a search incident.

The search incident to arrest exception permits a police officer to search the “grabbable area” around a defendant to make sure that there are no weapons that could be used against him and no evidence that could be destroyed.  Granted, some courts have extended it to the point of absurdity, allowing searches of places where the defendant once was but no longer is, using one of my favorite judicial tricks, remembering the rubric while forgetting the rationale.

But as of now, no one has been able to articulate a theory that would make a cellphone a threat to the safety of an officer.  While the cops would be allowed to seize the cellphone itself, as it might be evidence should possession of a cellphone come into play (as it frequently does, since “cellphones are the tools of the drug trade”), the contents within are not at risk of being lost and are available, should there be probable cause, for search upon obtaining a warrant.

In fairness, Gershowitz has an agenda, seeking laws to protect the privacy of electronic devices from police, that is in itself both worthy and quite appropriate.  These devices are our modern day diaries, places where we keep information about ourselves and our lives that are intended for no eyes other than our own.  While there may be no decisions to date that would allow a cop to inspect our devices at will, there are plenty of judges out there who may be inclined to render decisions that would allow cops free access.

But this suggestion that this is the case at present, and that a search of a cellphone under the search incident exception has been judicially approved, is wrong.  To say otherwise is to suggest to both cops, who will seize upon this suggestion to search anything electronic device they can get their hands on, and some of our less-thoughtful judges, who think that if somebody else has already allowed it, they can allow it too, that this is a done deal.  It’s not.  It shouldn’t be.

So while a cop may be allowed to seize a perp’s IPhone, he’s still not permitted to search it without a warrant.  And let’s keep it that way.

Cops: Pick Your Favorite Amendment to Ignore

With too many great things to write about today, I’ve decided to combine a few under the heading of “which constitutional amendment should we ignore today.” A potpourri of law enforcement follies, but for the fact that this stuff really happens.  So the question posed is, do they simply have no clue what their job is, or are they just this stupid?  Or, from the police perspective, we’re heros just trying to protect law-abiding people despite those activist criminal-coddling judges who don’t realize that freedom isn’t free.  So, pick ’em.

First up is this gem from the little State of Delaware, known for its love of corporate protection and lack of a state income tax.


Delaware State Police stopped Alvina Vansickle from purchasing a .22-caliber pistol for self-defense because she was too old and a woman, said Superintendent Col. Thomas MacLeish.

The outrage that followed led to the revelation that Delaware State Police had been keeping lists of gun buyers for years; state law requires them to destroy these records after 60 days.


“To be very honest with you, we have a legal obligation under the law to do approvals,” MacLeish said. “We also have an obligation to make sure we’re safe, and paying due diligence.”

MacLeish said the initial call taker “was concerned this individual never purchased a weapon before. Age and gender caused her to take caution.”

I always enjoy when someone prefaces their comment with, “to be honest.”  So they’ve been lying through their teeth the rest of the time?  Now most police officers have heard a rumor about something called the Second Amendment, with its right to keep and bear arms.  Apparently, they fear that the arms of an old woman will be too feeble to bear arms.  How wonderfully concerned they are. 

Notice how seriously they take their “obligations”?  No, not the obligation to honor the Constitution.  Not the law to destroy records after 60 days.  But the obligation to make sure that they treat age and gender differently.

Next up, from the New York Law Journal, is a little insight into how our very own New York cops deal with Spanish speaking drivers when stopped for DWI.


At the 45th Precinct, Priolo testified that at about four a.m., Mr. Garcia-Cepero was shown a video tape in Spanish, by Officer Winchell, which was a verbatim Spanish interpretation of V.T.L. §1194(f). A viewing of the tape made during the procedure revealed that defendant responded to the final question on the tape of whether he consented or refused to take the breathalyser test, by stating “no drogas, no drogas” which means “no drugs, no drugs.” Officer Winchell and Priolo took this to mean that defendant refused the breathalyser test and thus, it is that alleged refusal which forms the basis for the prosecution’s request for the consciousness of guilt presumption.

Judge Caesar Cirigliano, formerly attorney in charge of The Legal Aid Society (but no softie as a judge), saw things a bit differently. 


However, it is this Court’s firm belief that the procedure employed by the Police Department creates a classification predicated upon a person’s ability to speak and understand the English language and therefore discriminates against non-English speaking individuals.

Obviously, when a person does not speak or understand English, extra efforts must be made to insure that person’s rights are protected, the same as English speaking defendants.

You mean even Spanish speaking people have to understand stuff before you can use it against them?  What’s next, interpreters?  Well, per Judge Cirigliano, yeah, if that’s what’s needed to make sure that the fellow you’ve got in custody has a clue what the cops are talking about.

And finally, from our neighboring state of New Jersey, known for its excellent drivers and particularly well-dressed citizens, comes this tidbit out of the beautiful city of Newark. 

In most jurisdictions, the police manage to get through the First Amendment before they lose interest (and none have ever made it all the way to the Fourth).  But not this cop in Newark.  There ain’t no First Amendment if he says there ain’t.  And don’t make him mad, because whatever he says you better do, Mr. Cameraman.



For the record, the anchor, Steve Bartelstein who used to do the morning news for WABC before getting canned and moving to WCBS, does wear pants, even though his legs are hidden behind the anchor desk.  I’ve sat next to him and I swear I never saw him wearing pajama bottoms.  Never.


Should a Juror be “Death Qualified?”

Anne Reed, whose appearances these days are as rare as hen’s teeth, has graced us with another thought provoking post at Deliberations about the Louisiana death penalty case of LaDerrick Campbell.  Campell has filed a petition for certiorari to address the issue:


Whether, under Wainwright v. Witt (1985), the trial judge improperly removed a juror despite a willingness to consider the death penalty in some circumstances while permitting a juror who reportedly had difficultly not imposing the death penalty.

It raises one of the most perplexing questions in jury selection imaginable.  Why is the prosecution in a capital case entitled to a jury consisting only of people who are willing to put people to death?  The name for such jurors is “death qualified.”


It’s the shorthand we use for the Supreme Court’s rulings, in Witherspoon v. Illinois and Wainwright v. Witt, that a juror can be struck for cause if his religious views on the death penalty “prevent or substantially impair the performance of his duties as a juror in accordance with his instructions and his oath.”  (The quote is from Wainwright.)

The proposition is that a juror who does not believe in imposing the death penalty would not be “qualified” to sit because he would be unable, as a result of his beliefs, to return a verdict of death, should the “circumstances warrant” such a punishment.  Put otherwise, the juror must be willing to impose execution to be capable of serving.

When it comes to something as controversial as the death penalty, people tend to have clear feelings.  Some are proponents while others oppose.  The problem is that opponents cannot be “death qualified,” while proponents can and are.  This results in a loaded jury, inherently inclined to believe in the death penalty.  It doesn’t mean that they are chomping at the bit to execute someone, but that they won’t lose sleep over it either.

On top of the jury beginning (or ending, as the case may be) with a predisposition toward death, people who are proponents of the death penalty carry with them some heavy additional baggage.  They tend to favor order and security over law and freedom.  They tend to believe that cops are more likely to be truthful, and will give them the benefit of the doubt.  They tend to align themselves more with the prosecution, saving good, law-abiding citizens from evil criminals.

This isn’t to say that, under the right circumstances, they can’t be shaken from their bias, but it’s an uphill climb.  After all, you’ve taken the people inclined toward more socially liberal views out of the mix, because they aren’t “death qualified.”

As Anne points out, “this lady goes home:”



… it’s against my religion. I don’t believe you should take a person’s life. I think they should be put up in a place where they can be rehabilitated or life in prison.  [I would] have to really pray about it and see the evidence before I could vote to take a man’s life or a woman’s life.


And she didn’t say that she could never vote for death.  Merely that it’s against her religion.  Does that mean people who believe in particular religions are definitionally excluded from being “death qualified?”  Yes, it does, leaving a particular religion (at least those who follow the tenets of the religion, and don’t juggle them to suit their personal politics) precluded from being on a death jury.

Naturally, I would take the entire issue further than most, believing that the jury, as a reflection of the conscience of the community, should consist of people who haven’t decided that execution is a good idea.  I cannot see a reasonable argument to limit participation to those inherently biased in favor of death, placing one side in an advantageous position over the other.  It’s the whole fair jury thing, and once jurors are subject to being “qualified” before being allowed to sit, the burden of arguing punishment is already shifted against the defense.  There’s nothing fair about it.

SCOTUSBlog calls the cert petition in Campbell “one to watch.”  My expectations are fairly low.  We’ve largely accepted the proposition that if you put somebody on the jury who does not believe in the death penalty, then they would never vote to execute anybody.  What’s wrong with that?

New York’s Sickest Are Back

Memories of Abner Louima, possibly the singular sickest act ever perpetrated by police officers of the city of New York, haven’t yet faded.  And the wound is about to be reopened.  Michael Mineo claimed that he, like Louima, was sodomized by a cop at the Prospect Park subway station on October 15th.  The police disputed the claim.  The New York Times reports:


About the only facts each side can agree on is that the man, Michael Mineo, 24, a body piercer from the Prospect-Lefferts Gardens neighborhood, ended up in a hospital after the police, believing he was smoking marijuana, chased him into a subway station, tackled him and, after finding no drugs, let him go with a summons for disorderly conduct.

Yet Mineo found himself at the hospital with a torn rectum and injuries consistent with anal penetration, which he claims was done by a police radio while other officers held him down.  The information was so sketchy, witness statements so inconsistent, that this was either another horrific assault on a citizen, or another bizarre lie.  The police department claimed that any injuries were “pre-existing” from Mineo’s volitional conduct, and he’s now using them to “get” the police.  The alleged facts differ wildly, according to whom one speaks. 

Now, it appears that all of this is about to change.  From Newsday,


The fifth officer, who works for the Transit Bureau, is considered a witness because he got to the platform as the other officers were subduing Mineo, sources say. However, he is weighing a deal with prosecutors out of concern the evidence may point toward his own culpability.

A grand jury has been convened to sort out the mess and, hopefully, ascertain what really happened.  With this turn of events, a police officer ready to break through the Blue Wall of Silence to reveal the truth, everything could change.

The story of Michael Mineo’s alleged sadistic attack has been floating around for more than a week now, but I’ve been reluctant to post about it given the hugely disparate stories and the fact that it is not beyond the pale that someone might concoct a story like this.  Of course, allegations that an officer sodomized someone while others held him down are so fundamental sick that they shouldn’t be repeated carelessly.  It now appears time to address this.

The Abner Louima case revealed two independent forms of conduct that were beyond shocking and outrageous.  First, that a police officer would sodomize Louima.  Second, that a precinct full of police officer, men and women sworn to protect us, who would hide behind the Blue Wall of Silence to protect a cop who would do this.  Both, in my view, are reprehensible.  The former was prosecuted.  The latter was ignored. 

There is nothing tolerable about police officer concealing this disgusting criminal conduct simply because the perpetrator wore a badge as well.  They did nothing to stop it.  They did nothing to prosecute it. 

The unnamed fifth officer, who may now reveal what the police did to Michael Mineo, isn’t at all a hero should he come forward.  If he was there when it happened, he should have done something to stop it.  He didn’t.  He should have come forward with the truth immediately.  He didn’t.  He should come forward now, without worrying more about the impact on him than on telling the truth.  He isn’t.  But at least he may come forward.  This is a start.

We hear from cops about how wonderful they are, all they do for us, how we don’t appreciate them, how nobody understands.  Bull.  Show me one cop who hasn’t seen a fellow cop commit a crime and kept his mouth shut.

But it’s different when the offense is stealing a donut, or “tuning up” a recalcitrant perp.  To hold someone down while he’s being sodomized is sick.  To watch and do nothing is sick.  To know about this and keep your mouth shut is sick.  We can’t trust cops to be honest in general, but when they are willing to conceal such an horrific act, they have hit bottom. 

Now we’ll see what officer five has to say, and whether New York’s Finest are really New York’s Sickest.

The November Surprise

No, the non-story, smear-by-innuendo claim about a six month old story about a five year old dinner with fellow Chicago professor, Rashid Khalidi, doesn’t have the traction.  It’s the focus of a campaign on the large group of older Jewish voters in Florida that’s curious. 

Clearly, this group is viewed as a pro-Israel voting block that can be easily manipulated by raising the specter of the “death of Israel.”  Where did we hear this “death of Israel” phrase used?  Oh yes, now I remember.


Do most elderly Jews look to Ohio plumbers as their closest allies?  Doctors and lawyers, sure.  Plumbers, not so much.  It’s an education thing.  Every Jew who lived through World War II believes that education is the only thing that they can’t take away from you, and demanded that their children be as well educated as possible.  By the way, Joe the Plumber has now earned whatever derision he receives.

So the surprise is how important the votes of Miami-Dade and Palm Beach Counties will be this year, just as they were in 2000.  At the moment, the push is raise questions and doubts, because there isn’t any actual basis for the Obama hates Israel claims.  Of course, the Obama is an Arab and a Muslim that was used throughout the campaign to mess with the minds of the weak and confused meshes nicely with this latest twist.

But the McCain campaign’s demands that the L.A. Times release a tape of the 5 year old dinner is disingenuous.  The LAT has stated that it obtained the tape on condition that it not be released, which means that Sarah Palin can rail all she wants without fear that the tape will in fact be released and smack her in the face.  And it has the added benefit of “proving” how the liberal elite media is out to get them, since they openly say that the LAT would release it if they had a tape of McCain meeting with neo-Nazis (McCain’s words, not mine). 

There’s a tape of McCain meeting with neo-Nazis?  No, there isn’t.  But that’s the sort of manipulative use of rhetoric that is being employed in Florida to scare the living daylights out of the old Jews. 

The November Surprise is that the best we can hope for in the waning hours of this presidential campaign is a lame attempt at smear by deception, rumor-mongering and rampant manipulation of those voters they consider intellectually at risk.  This is the gasp of desperation.

Knowing the altacaccas, to whom McCain and Palin direct their message, up close and personal, there are two things to bear in mind about them.  First, they aren’t as quick as they once were, having lost a bit from too any blue-plate specials.  But second, they really hate being treated like morons. 

This thrust, to play the Israel card as if Joe the Plumber is the guy they believe will be the savior of the Jews, treats the altacaccas like idiots.  This will be dinner talk across Palm Beach County, even though dinner will be at the Chinese restaurant at 5:00 p.m. sharp.  And it will dawn on someone, then spread like wild-fire, that they (as they did unwittingly in 2000) now control the fate of America.  This time they will know it.

Apparently, You Can Go Back Again, When It’s Murder

Twenty-eight years ago, Ronald Rice copped a quick and dirty plea for having run down an 11 year old boy, Edwin Gulbransen, and hidden his body.


In 1980, after Edwin was found dead, Rice stood before a judge and said he couldn’t forgive himself for his role in what was believed then to be a hit-and-run.  Rice, who had turned himself in, then was sentenced to 6 months in jail for fleeing the scene of an accident and hiding the boy’s body.

Rice said all the right words at sentence, about how he couldn’t forgive himself and what a terrible thing he had done.  Had he kept his mouth shut, that might have been the end of it.  But he couldn’t.  And it wasn’t.


According to the prosecutors, Rice admitted to at least eight IDOC employees over the past decade that he killed the boy and told at least one of them he didn’t think he could be charged in the boy’s killing because he had pleaded guilty to the lesser charge.

In one instance, according to the prosecutors, he said, “I got away with murder because there was not enough evidence against me.”

The problem, amongst many, was that Rice spent most of the past 28 years in prison, having been convicted in 1984 of a sexual assault on a 12 year old boy.  He’s now scheduled for release in four years, after receiving a sentence of 60 years.  This happening in  California Illinois, I am clueless as to how a 60 year sentence would work this way.

So what happened back in 1980?

“We are very puzzled why there was a rush to judgment,” Dart said this morning, referring to the disposition of the 1980 case.  “We are absolutely convinced that this is the truth of what happened in 1980.”

Cook County Sheriff Tom Dart said investigators believe Rice (right), now 54, purposely struck 11- year-old Edwin Gulbransen as he was riding his bicycle that June day and then persuaded him to get into his car before driving a short distance to a forest preserve, where he sexually assaulted the boy.  Rice strangled Edwin, and then jumped up and down on his chest to make sure he was dead, the sheriff said.

The Cook County medical examiner’s office ruled the boy died from several broken cervical vertebrae.  After the case was reopened the office reviewed their findings and said the blunt force trauma was more consistent with being manually strangled and stomped than being run over by a car.

Certainly, the forensic evidence would seem to be a world apart, not to mention the questioning of the prosecutorial decisions made long ago.

Regardless, some problematic questions remain.  Even though there is no statute of limitations for murder, there remains the small hurdle of double jeopardy.  Despite the horrific allegations against Rice, and the potentially grave injustice done by a quickie plea and 6 month sentence after such a sick and brutal crime, the constitutional prohibition of being twice tried would seem to present a significant stumbling block to revisiting this crime now.

Of course, these are the types of horrific crimes that make judges want to jump through hoops to recraft the law to enable “justice”, but leave caselaw behind that wreaks havoc for everyone else.  This bears watching to see how the prosecution tries to jump this hurdle, and whether the court (which has already held Rice without bail) will allow it.

Cool Polygraph Tricks

By now, most have heard about the government’s War on the Mongols, the biker gang out in California that’s been accused of doing so many bad things that a federal judge has approved a pre-emptive strike on clothing bearing the word “Mongol.”  But have you wondered how the feds managed to nail 79 members of the motorcycle club?

Infiltration.  Apparently, four ATF agents were forced to drink, carouse and ride motorcycles for weeks (weeks?) to become “one of the gang.”  But it’s not that easy.  Not by a long shot, as the Mongols are a suspicious people by nature, plus they were burned before by “new members” turning out to be law enforcement.  So, the vetting process, according to this Daily Sentinel article, was “to test their “prospects,” including running background checks and having a private investigator administer the polygraph tests.”


The Mongols ratcheted up pressure by standing directly behind the agents while they were hooked up to the polygraph, Assistant U.S. Attorney Christopher Brunwin said.


“Is it scarier to see the threat that is facing you, or … taking a lie detector test while someone is standing behind you with a weapon?” the prosecutor said. “They could be getting ready to shoot.”


Each agent had been given all they needed to assume a new life — an apartment away from their family, a new Social Security number and a cover story. They had also been trained to pass the lie detector.


If it were me, just having a bunch of Mongols standing behind me with weapons would be enough to make my palms sweat, not to mention other parts of my anatomy damper than normal.  But then, I haven’t received the proper training.


John Torres, the ATF agent in charge in Los Angeles, declined to discuss how the three beat the polygraph, but said undercover agents generally compile cover stories that echo their own lives so they can tell them more believably.

“Our guys are highly trained and they were pretty much hand selected to do this mission and for their ability to think fast under pressure and beat the box,” Torres said, referring to the polygraph machine.

Thinking fast and beating the “box”, especially when your life hangs in the balance, seem like necessary characteristics of agents going undercover.  But going undercover has some risks/rewards of its own.



Torres said not all agents can handle undercover work. Those that do it feed off the thrill of maintaining a facade.


“It is the adrenaline, it’s being able to get one over on the bad guy,” Torres said.


Torres said the agents in the Mongols investigation never committed a crime during the investigation, he said, and were still subject to random drug tests.


Four women colleagues posed as girlfriends to help in the ruse, providing backup and an excuse that allowed the male agents to avoid having sex with women who hung out with Mongols, Brunwin said.


According to the indictment, the Mongols awarded each other special clothing patches, or “wings,” after they engaged in extreme sex acts, like having sex with a woman with a venereal disease.


This, of course, is the sanitized version, as Hunter Thompson fan will tell you.  There’s more to being an outlaw biker than riding a chopped hog.  But the point is that these federal agents passed the test of fire, did what they had to do to convince a paranoid group of bikers that they were one of them, and beat the box.

That a polygraph isn’t all its cracked up to be would seem rather clear.  That these agents could lie their way past any judge or juror, and likely any defense lawyer, without breaking a sweat seems obvious.  Being a very effective liar is a good trait for an undercover.  It’s a troubling trait for a law enforcement officer.  Our government is basically saying that they can lie their way past anything, and there isn’t a darn thing we can do about it.

But before we let go of this backstory to the Mongols indictment, there’s naturally a bit of irony to be had:

Though the ATF is able to train its agents to pass a polygraph test, the agency still uses lie detectors as part of its screening of potential new hires. ATF spokesman Mike Hoffman said the polygraph is just one of a slew of tests of a candidate’s background.

No need to wonder how they keep those violent, vicious, power-hungry sociopaths out of law enforcement anymore.  They use a “slew” plus the good old poly.  Now you can sleep better at night.

H/T to J-dog, who regularly monitors all outlaw biker gangs as part of his doctoral thesis project.

Another Reason to Have a Lawyer (or Leave Louisiana)

From Overlawyered, Radley Balko at Reason Hit and Run posts about one of the most fundamentally disturbing court scandals imaginable.

Since 1994, Chief Judge Edward Dufresne has been handling the appeals of indigent Louisiana convicts who had to file their own briefs.  Last year, the aid Dufresne had assigned to handle those appeals committed suicide.  According to his suicide note, Jarrold Peterson killed himself in part because of the guilt he faced over what he had been asked to do as part of his job. 

Peterson sent a posthumous letter to Louisiana’s Judiciary Commission with a damning allegation.  He said Dufresne had instructed him to deny every appeal not prepared by an attorney.  Peterson said he was instructed to write up and file the denials without every showing the appeals to the judges.  Peterson handled about 2,400 such cases in the 13 years he was in charge of them.

Radley writes that about 90% of all defendants in Louisiana are indigent, and lawyers are only provided to indigent defendants on appeal in death penalty cases.  How good are you feeling about the system at the moment?

One has to wonder how it is possible that nobody notice that this was happening?  Sure, most pro se appeals lose because defendants lack the ability to comprehend the legal issues, no less present and argue them persuasively.  But not a single pro se appeal survived? 

Sure, Judge Dufresne should spend some quality time hanging out in the cell with some of those whose lives he doomed in the name of “judicial economy” and Louisiana justice.  It will likely come shortly after they build a statue of him holding the ten commandments. 

But the idea that the entirety of this fell into the hands of an aid, and that one person could summarily undermine a state’s criminal justice system seems impossible.  Peterson, whose suicide is an act of cowardice, felt guilty?  Poor, poor Peterson.  How did he think the men and women who believed that there was some hope, little though it might be, that their appeal would be given some consideration feel?

As I’ve noted before, judges hate pro se litigants.  It’s a huge burden, a nightmare, trying to decipher their irrational rants and vehement yet unexplained demands for justice.  They are the very embodiment of the Dunning-Kruger effect, absolutely clueless as to how incomprehensible they are.  This is how the Times-Picayune described it:


It is not unknown for inmates to have a legitimate grievance and for jailhouse lawyers to advance cogent and well-researched arguments on their behalf. But most “pro se” briefs are probably frivolous and nonsensical, and it is only natural that judges should tend to look askance as they buckle down to the task of reading them.

The judges weren’t looking askance over at the state Court of Appeal in Gretna, however, because they weren’t looking at all. For 13 years, the court ignored the lucubrations of all convicts who appealed on their own account.

But, these indigent defendants have no choice.  They are given no counsel, and they are poor.  These aren’t the wiseguys who know better than anyone else, but those who are left without an option but to do the best they can. 

Many would lose in any event.  Most, even.  But some would have a viable argument for reversal, and may in fact be innocent.  Judge Dufresne decided that this group, however small, was not worth the effort.  And so he decided to sacrifice them to make his job easier and more convenient.

What kind of rats nest exists in Louisiana, that this went on for 13 years and nobody noticed?  Every criminal writ application was supposed to be reviewed by three judges.  Didn’t the other judges on the court notice that they had never seen a pro se application in 13 years?

And if anyone needed an explanation as to why it is critical to provide counsel to the indigent on appeal, look no further. 

And what is the Louisiana Supreme Court going to do to “cure” this problem? 


So the state Supreme Court, after receiving petitions from hundreds of appellants spurned by an idle and unprincipled Fifth Circuit, has stepped in. Kinda.

The solution, the Supreme Court has decided, can safely be entrusted to the idle and unprincipled Fifth Circuit, which kindly volunteered to take a belated look at the appeals once Peterson had blown the whistle.

Is it now clear why no lawyer outside the State of Louisiana considers anything coming out of that court system meaningful?

Law Review: Blame the Defense Lawyers?

While scanning the law reviews over at CoOp for something that might keep me interested long enough to finish my lunch, I stumbled across a note by William & Mary 3L David C. Holman entitled Death by a Thousand Cases: After Booker, Rita, and Gall, the Guidelines Still Violate the Sixth Amendment.  The first part of the title seemed intriguing, sufficiently so to make me ignore the second part.  I decided to read.

For the most part, the note described what anyone in the trenches has long understood to be the case, that while the Supreme Court has tried to nudge the judiciary away from the Federal Sentencing Guidelines, they remain largely as entrenched as ever.  Of course, Holman is far too young to remember how judge after judge, circuit after circuit, rejected the guidelines through 1989 as an unconstitutional usurpation of their authority and responsibility, the Supreme Court held otherwise. 

Since then, a generation of federal judges have come to wrap themselves in the guidelines like a cape of invincibility.  Sentence within the Guidelines and you are protected from harm.  Remember that few federal judges come to the bench with any criminal law experience, or any particular sense of understanding about their role in the criminal justice system.  They may be extraordinarily smart and experienced in their area of practice before hand, but criminal law is an entirely different field from others.  The totality of their exposure to criminal law was learned on the bench under the Guidelines.  Other than that, they were probably like most people, unsympathetic toward those accused of crimes and strong believers that law enforcement was bulwark of society, to be respected and given the benefit of the doubt.

The idea behind the Guidelines was simple, creating uniformity across the nation to “fix” the problem of purported wild sentencing disparities from shore to shore.  It promoted a notion of sentencing fairness by sentencing everybody to the worst possible sentence and refusing to permit judges to consider the legitimate sentencing factors of 18 U.S.C. §3553.

David Holman argues that for all the effort of Booker, Rita and Gall, little has changed.  He complains that the trilogy was too ambiguous to serve their purpose of letting the circuits know that advisory means advisory.  While I might substitute the word “subtle” for ambiguous, the trilogy failed to give the necessary smack across the face that sent the clear message that the era of the Guidelines was over.  They remain a port in a storm.

But more importantly, Holman correctly notes that the Department of Justice remains wedded to the Guidelines.  Prosecutors have always loved them, as their wonderfully harsh penalties have served the government well as a wedge to turn defendants into snitches and scare them away from the exercise of the right to trial.  The risk can be so great that “rolling the dice” is truly a crapshoot.  As much as our executive branch loves the Constitution, the last thing it wants us to do is use it, which would make them have to work really, really hard.  Anything that allows them to tout freedom while rendering its exercise too grave a risk receives our government’s support.

Holman, however, takes his argument to a different place when he blames three groups for allowing the “unconstitutional” use of the Guidelines to continue:  the Probation Officer, the prosecutor and the defense lawyer.  While he is absolutely correct about the first two, he completely misses the point as to defense lawyers.

The complaint about probation is that its Presentence Report is a recitation of the applicable Guidelines, and though they would deny it, based solely upon the government view of the facts.  If you’ve never seen a PSR, it can be a sickening report, where every word uttered by an agent appears to be undisputed gospel.  Probation is supposed to be neutral.  Probation believes itself to be neutral. It’s not. Not even close.  And they will never understand why.

As for prosecutors, they are under orders from Washington to rely on the Guidelines.  In fact, any variance below needs special permission from Washington.  And frankly, why should they bother?  They’ve got the Guidelines.  It makes their life easy and simple.  Why complicate life?

But defense lawyers have no say in the process.  Holman says that defense lawyers haggle over pleas based on the Guidelines, and are therefore enablers of the process.  It’s not because they choose to, but the options for pleas are presented by the Government.  Looking in from the outside, it’s understandable that Holman doesn’t understand the dynamics of plea negotiations.  The defense doesn’t drive negotiations; the prosecution does. 

A defendant has three options when indicted for a federal offense.  Plea, snitch or go to trial.  Should the defendant decide to “cooperate”, he’s subject to doing whatever the prosecution demands upon pain of losing his 5K1.1 letter, which would render his cooperation useless.  If the defendant goes to trial, the guidelines are irrelevant unless and until there’s a conviction, at which point the defense will fight the Guidelines tooth and nail.

But if a defendant is interested in the possibility of a plea, the power shifts to the government.  It is the government that offers the plea, notwithstanding any arguments that the defense may make.  And the plea offer will come in terms of the Guidelines.  It has to, from the government’s standpoint, because that’s their rules.  The defense can disagree all its wants, stamp its feet, demand otherwise, but then there will be no plea.  The parties may haggle over dollar amounts, quantities, time frames, but ultimately the outcome will be squeezed into the Guidelines.  Take it or leave it, buddy.

The best one can expect is plea agreement that stipulates as to the proper application of the Guidelines, but leaves the defense free to argue for a non-Guidelines sentence.  My experience is that the prosecution is becoming less resistant to this approach, and certainly the defense wants as much latitude as possible to argue for a sentence below the Guidelines.  Of course, plea cases such as this aren’t the fodder of much appellate review, and therefore don’t find their way into the research for law review notes such as Holman’s.

Holman’s note presents some great research and some interesting arguments and proposals, something that would be worthy of remembering when preparing to argue why a sentence is unconstitutional.  But don’t blame the victim for having no choice in being the victim.  No defense lawyer chooses the Guidelines as the basis for haggling over a sentence.  They are rammed down our throats. 

The better question is why one arm of government, represented by the DOJ and the U.S. Attorneys, chooses to ignore another branch of government, represented by the Supreme Court, and demand that the Guidelines remain the rule?  The answer, as far as I can tell, is that until the third branch, Congress, finally does away with the Guidelines or enacts a law that forbids the DOJ from relying upon the Guidelines, they will continue to demand that all plea negotiations utilize the Federal Sentencing Guidelines as the basis.  The option for the defense is take it or leave it.

And there’s nothing the Supreme Court can do about it.

Solo Practice University Professor Number 1

When Susan Cartier Liebel asked if I would teach at Solo Practice University, she gave me a long and persuasive list of reasons to do it, ranging from the extravagant salary I’ll be paid to the vast prestige I’ll enjoy at A-list events.  Yet, I was unmoved.

There was only one reason for my interest in helping with Susan’s love-child (SPU, of course).  That’s to provide whatever help I can to others in their quest to establish a solo practice in criminal defense.  There are 17,849 mistakes to be made along the road.  I know because I kept count.  Over 25 years, I’ve seen things change and stay the same, but I’ve learned from all of it.  Maybe my learning experience can help others to smooth the learning curve.

This should prove to be a very interesting experience for all of us.  I expect that I will remain as low-tech in my approach as a computer will allow, despite SPUs pushing us toward increasingly sophisticated online pedagogical methodologies.  I promise I will never use the word pedagogical again in connection with SPU.  And due to my aversion to new technology, my acceptance of Susan’s advances (in technology, of course) will be slow.  But I’ll try to do whatever I can to convey what I’ve learned, and I generally find that it’s the message that counts.

So my decision to accept Susan’s generous proposal (to teach, of course) was a done deal.  I hope that I can offer some worthwhile advice on how to navigate your way into a successful criminal defense practice, and dodge a few of the larger missiles that will come your way.  And so, I am Solo Practice University’s Professor Number 1.