Author Archives: SHG

$3 Million to the Target of Target

Via Turley, Rita Cantrell of Greenville, South Carolina found out how Target (or Targét as some would pretend) got its name.  From WYFF4 News,


Rita Cantrell of Greer went to two Target stores in the Greenville area in Feb. 2006, and both times employees accused her of using a counterfeit bill.  Cantrell tried to buy items at the store and pay with an older series $100 bill.

[A Target] store employee sent out an e-mail to dozens of other retailers and law enforcement agencies warning them that Cantrell was a shoplifter who tried to spend bogus cash. The e-mail also included Cantrell’s picture.

Two things followed, one fortuitous for Cantrell and one not-at-all-fortuitous for Target.  As it happened, Cantrell found out about the email because the place where she worked was on the list of recipients.  And second, the United States Secret Service determined that the $100 bills were perfectly legitimate. 

Cantrell sued Target and won a verdict of $100,000 compensatory damages and $3 million punitive.  Target is, of course, going to appeal, and the likelihood of the verdict being reduced seems pretty high.


Target spokeswoman Bethany Zucco said Friday the company will challenge the ruling.


“We are extremely disappointed by the magnitude of the compensatory and punitive damages awarded by the jury in this case,” Zucco said in a statement. “We sincerely regret any inconvenience incurred by the plaintiff.

Any inconvenience? You sent out a mass email, with her picture, telling the world that she’s a thief and forger, and you’re sorry for the inconvenience?  There’s an “apology” that demands some serious puni’s alone. 

The importance of this story is not merely its level of offensiveness, but in the actions taken by private players to smear people who are neither guilty of any wrongdoing nor provided an opportunity challenge accusations.  It was pure luck that Cantrell learned of the email, and had an opportunity to sue Target for its actions.  But the actions themselves are outrageous and, unfortunately, commonplace.

Search your memory.  Can you think of anyone you’ve ever met at a Target store who you would trust to play judge, jury and executioner?  What qualifications did this unnamed store employee have to send out an email, with a photo no less, smearing this woman across South Carolina?  What protections are in place at Target to stop some pimply-faced kid from destroying someone’s life because he didn’t know they made $100 bills before last week?

While theft is a plague for retail stores, fighting theft is not a job for amateurs, with inadequate training, procedures or accountability.  As sorry as it may be that there are people who shoplift or pass counterfeit bills at stores like Target, that does not create an entitlement to affirmatively harming innocent people.

While I suspect that the $3 million punitive damages award won’ be upheld in light of the actual damages in the case, I also suspect that whatever the exemplary damages turn out to be will be insufficient to teach a lesson to major retailers who see the destruction of people’s lives as a cost of doing business.

Law Crossing Can Get You a Job. As a Spammer

Amongst the many legal job search outfits out there is one called “Law Crossing,” which presents itself as a different sort of approach to finding a job as a lawyer.  Rather than charge those seeking to fill a position, it charges those looking for a job.  It’s the inverse of the Willie Sutton theory of bank robbery.

But as Cathy Gellis at Statements of Interest found out, that’s not the only function Law Crossing offers to the unemployed.  While she questioned whether Law Crossing was worth it, and concluded that it was not for a variety of reasons, she bought herself an entirely unanticipated bag of problems.  As I never knew how this worked before, Cathy’s explanation was an epiphany to me.


[M]y previous post is the third result on a Google-search for “Law Crossing.” It’s quite visible, and as some of the later comments on reflect, it apparently has been deterring people from doing business with Law Crossing.

What Law Crossing had done was to post a “hit” on Amazon’s mTurk service, offering to pay people for each testimonial they spammed my blog with. Services like mTurk are designed to broker piecework between willing workers with extra cycles and employers that have lots of small tasks needing doing.

While such a use of mTurk is a violation of Amazon’s policy, it doesn’t appear to have much impact on such use of mTurk, and while Amazon is against it and will deal with it once it becomes aware of it happening, that doesn’t help much when you’re the target of the spammers.

Check out mTurk is an interesting experience.  for a penny or two, “piece workers” are paid to spam (or perform such other trivial tasks that need to get done but aren’t worth hiring a real employee) on behalf of some business.  It’s not much, but if you spam enough, you can buy a burger off the dollar menu. 

When I’ve posted about certain businesses in a less than flattering way, I’ve experienced the joys of shills, magically appearing to spam me by either attacking me or supporting the business under scrutiny.  I wondered where these shills came from.  Now I know. 

Cathy castigates the practice as a reflection of corporate manipulation of thought and expression, paying to undermine legitimate assertions and challenges to business practices in order to create the fiction that a business is wonderful and anyone who challenges it is evil. 


I find corporate tactics that run roughshod over consumers to be particularly despicable — no one should do business with any company that helps itself to money it’s not entitled to, which, according to so many accounts, is what Law Crossing routinely does. But to have used me and my site, my audience and my credibility, to further their unsavory business practices is beyond the pale. Their behavior forbids my silence, which is why I post now as I do, so the world can easily see just what kind of company Law Crossing is.

The same goes for any other business that spams to cover its bad acts and legitimate complaints about its business practices.  The more people who realize that this is happening, the less effective this practice becomes, and the practice itself becomes an indictment of the business.  As for Law Crossing, I defer to Cathy’s judgment since I know nothing about the business itself.  But it’s use of spammers to protect itself from criticism speaks volumes.

McCain’s Position on the Judiciary and DOJ (Update)

From Doug Berman, John McCain published his position on the future of the Department of Justice and the Federal Judiciary at the National Law Journal, entitled “Three priorities.”  The short take is this:


We face enormous challenges and you, the voters, deserve more than platitudes. I feel it is my duty as a candidate to tell you specifically how my presidency would improve our government and our country. In this column, I want to concentrate on what would be three important priorities in a McCain administration: keeping the Department of Justice politically neutral, focusing law enforcement programs on addressing important issues of the day and appointing strict constructionist judges.

It’s always interesting when someone denounces platitudes right before they lay a few down on the table.  Platitudes, of course, are the stock in trade of politicians, and both candidates have a whole closet full of them to pull out as needed.  Americans hate to think that all they’re getting is platitudes, even while getting fed a steady diet of them and “lovin’ it” (apologies to McDonalds).

Of the three priorities, the first one is inconsequential.  No one runs for office on a platform of politically corrupting a department of government, and no one expects John McCain to be the first.  What’s interesting is the first word of the priority, “keeping”.  This suggests that it is neutral now, and he plans for it to stay that way.  For this, McCain wins the first Monica Gooding Award.

The second priority is “focusing law enforcement programs on addressing important issues of the day,” which would at first appear to suggest that he’s planning on pulling them out of the bootleg whiskey and horse stealing operations.  Perhaps McCain remembers both well?  But he goes on to provide further explanation to provide a few particular areas where he would have law enforcement focus:


In particular, the FBI’s mortgage fraud task force is an important tool for keeping our markets clean. No matter who they are or where they hide, we must hold accountable those who would disregard the law, placing innocent citizens and investors in peril.

Preventing terrorist attacks would be a top priority of the McCain administration. As a number of observers have noted, our nation is safer than it was on Sept. 11, 2001, but not yet safe. Upon taking office, I would ensure we win the wars we are fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan. I will also review our counterterror operations to ensure their effectiveness.

Terrorists are not the only threat to public safety. Lax enforcement policies, judges who legislate from the bench and lack of support for law enforcement personnel all continue to force our innocent citizens behind the barred windows of their homes and allow criminals to roam free.

And now drugs are bringing waves of crime and organized gang activity to rural areas thought to be nearly immune from such problems. The federal government must both support state and local law enforcement and effectively enforce federal laws designed to root out violent crime, organized gangs and other interstate criminal activity.

Bearing in mind that this is a writing, produced after at least some thought and deliberation, did John McCain just compare the threat of terrorists to “judges who legislate from the bench?”  As for the rest of it, there’s little new.  This was the same rhetoric that was used in 1986.  Remember Rudy Giuliani raiding Wall Street brokers who ended up never getting indicted?  No need to discuss these “priorities”, unless you are one of those “innocent citizens behind the barred windows” while criminals “roam free.”  On some other planet named after Willie Horton.

Finally, we get to priority number 3:


None of these law enforcement efforts will succeed without a judiciary that understands its proper role and its proper mission. Senator Obama would appoint liberal activist judges and supply them with greater sentencing discretion. I will appoint judges who will strictly interpret our Constitution. Senator Obama’s judges would coddle criminals. I will appoint judges who will hold criminals accountable.

I was wondering when the “coddle criminals” prong would come into play.  While I have heard nothing from Obama to suggest that he’s prepared to show proper deference to the constitutional protections that have been emasculated over the years in favor of those “innocent citizens,” it was only natural that McCain would call him a criminal coddler and announce that he will appoint judges who nail them nasty criminals.  I wonder if that’s before or after trial?

Once again, I remind that this was a writing produced by the McCain campaign, if not Senator McCain himself, to express his vision of the future of law enforcement.  No mention of civil rights and liberties.  No mention of corruption and abuse.  The old, plain vanilla law and order agenda, with the criminal coddler slur thrown in for good measure.  I’m sure glad he didn’t just feed us platitudes.

What?  Were you hoping that John McCain, the Maverick, was going to show up?

Update:  Feeding off McCain’s article, comes Steven G. Calabresi, lawprof at Northwestern, who writes in this WSJ op-ed :

If Mr. Obama wins we could possibly see any or all of the following: a federal constitutional right to welfare; a federal constitutional mandate of affirmative action wherever there are racial disparities, without regard to proof of discriminatory intent; a right for government-financed abortions through the third trimester of pregnancy; the abolition of capital punishment and the mass freeing of criminal defendants;

Now this is the sort of professor I want to teach my children.  Calm, thoughtful, scholarly.  And totally insane.  Calabresi then goes on to conclude:

Nothing less than the very idea of liberty and the rule of law are at stake in this election. We should not let Mr. Obama replace justice with empathy in our nation’s courtrooms.

I never even realized that empathy was the opposite of justice.  And all these years I’ve been asking judges for justice together with empathy.  What was I thinking?

Thanks to Doug for the heads up, who notes:

I expect some hyperbolic tough-on-crime rhetoric coming from politicians like Senator McCain and former Mayor Rudy Giuliani (heard on recent robocalls).  But I am both sadded and very disappointed to see this kind of silly over-the-top rhetoric coming from law professors.  Though I know this is an exciting time legally and politically, I think everyone should just take a deep breath.

Uh huh.

Instapundit Says Palin was Kinda Right

In the blawgosphere, we call him Instapundit.  But he has a name, Glenn Harlan Reynolds, and he used it in an op-ed in the New York Times in support of the proposition that the Vice President is really a legislative office.

The op-ed was short, as Times op-eds go.  Maybe it was edited within an inch of its life, or maybe Glenn was as conservative in his use of words as he is in his view of the law.  Either way, he offered two major points in his view of the role of the Vice President.

Article I of the Constitution, which describes the authority of the legislative branch, says that “the vice president of the United States shall be president of the Senate, but shall have no vote, unless they be equally divided.” Aside from the job of replacing a president who dies or is unable to serve, the only vice presidential duties that are spelled out in the Constitution are legislative in character.

This position, while technically accurate, leaves one with the sense that there’s a glaring gap in reasoning.  What makes it accurate is the point that these two duties are all the Constitution “spelled out.” 

What makes it dubious is that historical experience is otherwise.  And, of course, the fact that the Senate established the office of permanent President Pro Tempore, as it is constitutionally entitled to do, renders the ceremonial position of the VP as Senate president meaningless.  As some wag commented, the Senate could, by rule, establish the duties of its president to be taking out the trash once a day, and that would be as much as the Vice President of the United States could do to fulfill his constitutional mandate, as long as the President survived.

So does this reduce the Vice Presidency to a legislative position, or more honestly, a position without function other than to wait around for the death of the President?  I don’t think the argument necessarily follows.  The Constitution does not mandate that the VP do nothing all day long.  It doesn’t forbid the VP from playing a role in the administration, or serving the presidency by delegating functions to the office in furtherance of the executive branch purposes. 

The constitutional mandate can just as easily be seen as an extension of authority rather than a limit, as Glenn would have it.  By denominating the position as “Vice President,” the Constitution implicitly acknowledges two things, that the office is secondary to the primary office, and that the primary office is that of the President.  To accept Glenn’s interpretation is to believe that the founding fathers either neglected to consider the name they gave to the position, or that they arbitrarily called it “Vice President” rather than President of the Senate and second in line to the Presidency.

Based upon his conclusion that the VP is a legislative office, Glenn then contends that the office holder should have no role in the executive branch, as it would constitute a separation of powers conflict, and that Congress should pass a law precluding the VP from acting in an executive branch capacity.  Talk about making a lousy job worse.  Aside from the practical issues this raises, such as a VP learning the role of the executive in preparation of taking over the job some day, it would leave the VP with essentially nothing to do. 

That’s exactly what Glenn proposes.


The most important function of a vice president is to serve as a spare president. Using the spare president in the ordinary course of business is as unwise as driving on one’s spare tire. Spares should be kept pristine, for when they are really needed.

Now that is one very cute analogy.  Wrong, but cute.  Unlike a spare tire, any person who ascends to the position of President should not be pristine, but road tested.   No one wants to pull out their spare, only to find it’s flat.  See, I can use analogies too.

But none of this discussion makes the claim made at the Vice Presidential debate by Sarah Palin accurate either.  She said that the vice president is “in charge of” the U.S. Senate and “can really get in there with the senators and make a lot of good policy changes.”  Even if Glenn is correct as to the legislative function, that function never goes beyond voting in case of a tie.  The Senate President position was displaced by the President pro tempore back in 1890, and the VP has never been “in charge of” the Senate by any stretch of the imagination.

On the other hand, Joe Biden flubbed the constitutional role of the Vice President in its entirety.  It’s hard to say which is more embarrassing, the fact that he’s been in the Senate long enough to know what’s up, or that he plays a constitutional law professor at Widener Law School? 

Under the circumstances, Glenn’s contention is beginning to sound better and better.  Let’s leave them in the trunk of the car and pray that we never have a flat.




One Last Week of Silliness and Delusion (Breaking News Update)

The nexus between law and politics really isn’t that hard to understand, but easily subject to manipulation.  The Drudge Report leads with a Youtube video to prove that Obama will usher in a new socialist society.  Some realize that this is just manipulation of those who don’t get it.  Others buy into it blindly, to the point of not comprehending the basic message.  We see what we want to see.

Regardless, as George Will opined yesterday on “This Week,” socialism has been a component of our economy for a long time.   What do we think sugar subsidies are all about?  It’s just a matter of who’s getting the benefit, businesses or regular folks.


95% of what the government does is redistribute the wealth. it operates on the principal of concentrated benefits & dispersed costs. case in point, we have sugar subsidies. costs the American people billions of dollars but they don’t notice it, it is in such small increments. but the sugar growers get very rich on this. now we have socialism for the strong, that is the well represented & organized in Washington, like sugar growers, but it is socialism none the less, and it is not new.

But who wants to listen to George Will when you’ve got Drudge whispering screaming in your ear?

It’s not like it really matters that much.  Minds are made up.  People who want to see evil will see evil.  What remains isn’t parsing economic policies, but the vilification of the presidency, because that is what turns the office holder from someone with whom you disagree into illegitimacy, and then there is nothing left but visceral hatred.

This is why a phone call from my mother-in-law, usually not the most interesting event of my day, struck me.  Having moved south to North Caccalacca, the in-laws experience a different reality than I enjoy in New York.  They are the targets of political outreach that has long been missing in the northeast, where our political leanings are a foregone conclusion.

A call came in from an unknown telephone number, so she let it go to the answering machine, monitoring the message.  It was from a McCain campaign worker (a live person) asking if she knew that the reason Obama went to Hawaii was to destroy records that would prove that he was not an American citizen.

Come on.  It can’t be this bad.  John McCain is worthier than this.  He is a better man, a better Senator, a better presidential candidate, then to be hyped by such ridiculous nonsense.  He has much more to offer and deserves to be shown greater respect by his own party, his own workers, then this.

In the final week of the 2008 Presidential Campaign, the two candidates seeking our vote could do more to harmonize the future of this nation then all their claims of inclusiveness together if they would put a lid on these desperate, stupid efforts to win at all costs.   I refuse to believe that John McCain wants to win by spreading lies like this.  It’s too late to put a stop to the innuendo of Ayers, which demeaned him before many conservatives or the gimmick of Sarah Palin that lost him some of the most significant conservative voices in America.

But lets have a final week of dignity.  If not for the two individuals running, for the office itself.  We have way too many problems to address to tolerate gutter politics.  If we have a brighter future, a concept that has yet to be proven but seems historically reasonable, let’s spend this last week discussing how to achieve it rather then lying to each other or hyping ridiculous videos designed to confuse and delude.

If we deserve better than this, we need to be better than this.

More on the Obama wasn’t born in Hawaii but is really a Kenyan contention at Court-o-Rama. 

BREAKING NEWS:  Via the AP, ATF has disrupted a plot by skinheads to assassinate Barack Obama and 102 other blacks.  And you still think that this campaign hasn’t gotten the fringe element all worked up?

Oh yeah, and Alaska’s Republican Senator Ted Stevens convicted of seven counts of making false statements on his disclosure forms. 

Why Eli Can’t Write (Like a Lawyer)

For those of you who attended the elite law schools or read Above the Law regularly, you probably already know this.  For me, this came as a shock.  Did you know that students at Yale and Penn law schools are taught legal writing by third year law students?

Rick Garnett at PrawfsBlawg let the cat out of the bag in his effort to dispute Jason Solomon’s point that this is a major failing for those schools in the USN&WR rankings.  Since I don’t give a hoot about the rankings, I didn’t pay attention.  Here’s the deal:

Over at MoneyLaw, Jason Solomon writes that the fact the first-year legal-writing program at Penn (as at Yale) is taught by 3-L’s “prevents Penn from having an ‘outstanding’ JD program”.  Why should this be true?  He elaborates:


So Penn, it’s time to spend some money on real legal writing professors. The people who head Penn and Yale’s programs may be terrific, but there’s only so much one person can do. The law student instructors may be doing a good job given what they know, but… they’re law students.

So the one thing, the single thing, we think law students should be able to do on Day 1, write like a lawyer, is the one thing that these Ivy League law schools believe to be beneath their doctrinal dignity.

They will have a tenured professor, sitting in a chair with somebody’s name on it, teaching Law and Post-Impressionist Painting, but they can’t be bothered having someone with any actual experience, any hands-on capability, teaching law students how to write?  Are they nuts?

Rick questions whether this is really a big deal, big enough to be worthy of a ranking problem for these schools.  Bear in mind that lawprofs and law schools live and die on these rankings, as if the education obtained is affected rather than just cash-flow.  Rick asks a litany of questions to challenge the assumptions that 3L students can’t be as good teaching legal writing as “real professors.”   The phrase “the blind leading the blind” comes to mind. 

As with all attempts to justify bad concepts via absolutism, there are probably some 3L students who can do a minimally acceptable job passing along whatever they learned to be legal writing to the next generation.  But this completely misses the point of both legal writing and law school.  The best they could hope for is an accurate mechanical transmission of what these kids are told is legal writing.  They don’t know legal writing because they’ve never done legal writing. 

If Rick thinks that it’s that mechanical to write successfully as a lawyer, then he needs to get back to the trenches.  Good legal writing is hard.  Successful legal writing is very hard.  Most lawyers can’t do it well.  Why would one take the huge risk that a third year law student who has zero experience with bad legal writing can teach others to be competent at it?

But the bigger picture is that legal writing is one of the few skills that budding lawyers need.  The ability to write for legal purposes is basic; it’s what lawyers are expected to do.   Whether it’s a Biglaw partner or a client, the day that kid becomes a lawyer and has to write something, he’s expected to be able to do it.  This is one of, if not the, primary skills one needs to practice law.   And you’re sending him away from law school without it? 

Jim Chen at MoneyLaw (edit: via Larry Rosenthal) has recapped the points:


  1. Legal writing is an awfully important skill. It is probably the only skill that employers will expect recent graduates to have . . . .

  2. Successful legal writing is a difficult skill to learn. I spent many years supervising young lawyers in a rather sophisticated appellate practice. Rarely did a recent graduate display much competence until after at least a year of work. . . .

  3. It is extremely unlikely that someone who cannot write well will be [a] successful teacher of legal writing. Yet, substantial experience is generally a necessary if not sufficient condition for being able to write well. . . .

  4. The typical 3L has very little writing experience — the 1L [legal research and writing] curriculum, maybe a law review note, and a few memos produced at a summer job that probably were not very good.

  5. A law school that hires individuals with enough experience to have a high level of briefwriting skills and the ability to teach them will confer on its students a substantial advantage in the job market.

  6. That last point, it bears remembering, goes to the heart of why law students burn a thousand days and often incur more than $100,000 in undischargeable debt: to get jobs.


For crying out loud, teach the students how to write.  Give them something useful for their money.  And put the rest of us out of our misery trying to clean up the crap they produce.

And let me add one thing to Jim’s list.  Maybe law schools ought to be awfully careful even when they have lawprofs teach legal writing.  Maybe, just maybe, some of them lack the “substantial experience” in the trenches that distinguishes a “successful” teacher of legal writing from a teacher of what an academic thinks is good legal writing?  There can be a difference.  Just think about it. 

From Laptops to Letters, Beware the Border Search

When Homeland Security Czar Michael Chertoff explained the need to search laptop computers to preserve the safety and security of the union, it appeared to reflect the government’s venture into hi-tech snooping by capitalizing on the antiquated rationale for unlimited border searches.   But based upon a 10-1 decision out of the 9th Circuit in its en banc rehearing of its decision to uphold the search, the problems runs deeper.

From the San Francisco Chronicle, the court held that agents could read personal letters during a border search without any basis or evidence of wrongdoing. 


The court majority noted that an international airport is considered the equivalent of a national border and said airport officers need no evidence of wrongdoing before conducting searches, as long as they are not “unreasonably intrusive.”

In upholding the initial search, the court noted that inspectors were entitled to conduct random searches of the packages and said they were not obliged to “disregard evidence of other unlawful activity.”

This is yet another example of the remembering the rubric while forgetting the rationale.  The reason that border searches were denied any protection was not because constitutional rights were no longer inherently worthy, but because there was a need to prevent avoidance of untaxed goods from entering the country and disease-ridden things (whether people, animals or plants) from infesting our great plains.

But this rationale came at an earlier, more simple age.  The border search was not intended as a general crime search substitute, simply because of the lack of expectation of privacy.  Yet that’s where it’s gone.  And now we’re coming full circle, from the hidden porn on laptops to the content of personal letters.  Certainly, there is no border protection purpose to be found in private letters, lest someone attempt to attack another by threat of a paper cut.

Only one judge stood up against this holding, Chief Judge Alex Kozinski. 


In dissent, Chief Judge Alex Kozinski said the court’s rationale was dangerous, even though Seljan got what he deserved. By allowing agents to read the letter without a warrant or evidence of wrongdoing, he said, the ruling gives them “a green light … to go on fishing expeditions through all private papers and electronic documents that are sent or carried across our national borders.”

At Met News, there is a lengthier description of the dissent:


Kozinski argued in dissent that the search violated the Fourth Amendment’s guarantee of the “right of the people to be secure in their…papers.” While the court’s “reluctance to step between Mr. Seljan and his well-merited punishment is understandable,” the chief judge wrote, “this result comes at a high price.”

The majority, he said, was turning what the court has previously described as a “narrow” Fourth Amendment exception into “a gaping hole” that would allow “every e-mail, every diary, every laptop that crosses the border” to be inspected and read “without a warrant or even founded suspicion.”

Kozinski cited the infamous “Wilkes affair,” in which private papers were seized under general warrant in 1760s England in order to build a case of seditious libel against a leader of the political opposition. The actions led to a series of decisions holding that English common law did not permit such seizures.

“We sell this birthright very cheaply today,” the jurist wrote.

Perhaps Judge Kozinski has a greater appreciation of the privacy of one’s papers and effects, having been on the receiving end of disclosure of some personal photographs.  There’s nothing like public disclosure of highly personal things to enlighten one to the finer points of privacy.

Regardless of how Judge Kozinski came to this conclusion, his lone voice in dissent is worthy of heed.  We’ve sold off many of our birthrights lately, and it’s going to be awfully hard to get them back.

Lesson For Lawyers From Roseville

My recent post about the dilemma presented by Charles Etchison, who moved to Roseville, California after his release from prison post-murder, post-child molestation, post-sexual assault, resulted in some disturbing commentary.  Not so much by the residents of Roseville, who understandably approach their situation with raw emotion and no interest in putting their children at risk in the name of reasonableness. 

Few parents would consider taking a needless risk when it comes to their family, and fewer still when the opposite side of the equation is someone like Charles Etchison.  While Etchison claims to have found God, and that he is no longer a threat, it’s hard, perhaps even impossible, to care much about Etchison’s claims.  Aside from being merely alive and now free, Etchison offers nothing positive to society.  Nothing in his life suggests that he’s worthy of anyone’s concern, or capable of redemption.  Certainly, Etchison’s “rights” are hardly worthy of risk to children.

And as expected, parents of Roseville have vehemently expressed their anger and frustration about Etchison’s presence in their community.  It was a self-defeating expression, since it solves none of their problems, but I grant that the dilemma has no easy solution and they are unwilling to consider any possibility that includes adapting to Etchison’s presence.  While I found the comments of parents blind, emotional and irrational, they were wholly understandable.

But the comments of lawyers, unrelated to Roseville, cannot be understood as the product of raw emotion overcoming reason.  These comments are quite disturbing, as it is our responsibility to see the bigger picture and consider the policy implications of letting the mob with their pitchforks and torches seize control.  Defenestration is not a rational response from a lawyer.

This disturbs me because I do not want Simple Justice to become a locus for ignorance, prejudice or hatred, whether for non-lawyers surfing the web to find digital comfort or a place to rant, or for lawyers who lack the capacity to comprehend fallacious reasoning or support pandering to hatred.  If that’s where Simple Justice is heading, then I don’t care to maintain it anymore.

Blogs are not a democracy.  This is my home, and anyone who stops by is a guest.  You are here at my sufferance, and have no right to express yourself.  A number of readers have chosen not to become embroiled in what they see as a no-win argument with the commenting lawyers, preferring instead to email me with their thoughts.  Their thoughts are that the lawyer comments are bizarre and fail to reflect the reasoning ability that one would expect from another lawyer.  But they don’t want to get into a pissing match with irrational lawyers.

The product is that the conversation is monopolized by those who have taken a leap off the bridge of reason.  This is no acceptable.  That other readers have felt that they would prefer not to comment rather than become embroiled in an argument with irrational commenters means that the irrational commenters have hijacked my post, and my blawg.  I won’t allow this to happen, and I truly don’t care if it pleases others or not. 

I have no doubt that the lawyers who have commented believe that their thoughts are reasonable, correct and appropriate, and that they are merely arguing their position in their best, lawyerly fashion.  I disagree, and since this is not a democracy, my vote is the only that counts here.  You don’t have to like it.  You don’t have to agree with me.  And if you find this unacceptable, you are absolutely free to never come here again.

But I will not allow the comments from lawyers to a post to devolve to the point where a couple of irrational people scare off others.  Agree or not, that’s the deal.  I’ve banned lawyers who mistakenly believe that they have a right to be irrational or offensive from commenting here before, and I’ll do it again.  This is my home, not yours.  If I’m left here in a room by myself, so be it.

Returning to Roseville and Charles Etchison, no one would contend that he’s a desirable addition to the neighborhood.  But the subject of sexual predators is generally inflammatory. Short of acquiescing in the general public belief that they should all be put to death so that they never return to harm anyone, a position that some may espouse, it’s one of the most intractable problems facing society.  While I won’t represent child molesters and their ilk, I similarly have the capacity to understand the problem and attempt to address it rationally.

Each year, thousands of sexual predators will be released from prison.  Not the ones who never belonged on the registry, but the real ones, hard core.  No one, particularly me, can guarantee that they won’t commit crimes.  No community, no parent, wants them anywhere near them.  They have no political clout or public supporters.  That human beings engage in this type of behavior at all is beyond the comprehension of most of us.  We are fundamentally disgusted and outrage by it, but we also know that it is far more pervasive then anyone wants to admit.

There are two untenable solutions.  Keep all sexual predators in prison for life, or put them to death.  Aside from the cost of these solutions, penal theory informs that either solution will result in greater harm to the victims by imposing the most severe punishments.  What we do not want is sexual predators murdering children to eliminate witnesses to their vile conduct. 

So we are left with thousands of people who have served their prison sentence and are returning to society, but without a place to go.  They are universally unwelcomed. They cannot find employment.  They are intentionally stigmatized.  They are held up to ostracism.  Even if they want to lead law-abiding lives, they aren’t given a way to do so. 

It would be marvelous if we, criminal defense lawyers, could apply our minds and our appreciation of humanity to finding a viable way of addressing this facially untenable situation.  How can these ex-cons rejoin a society that wants nothing to do with them?  What do we do with convicted sexual predators after they’ve served their sentence?

An Honest Man in Albany

I spent a couple of hours yesterday watching the debates between Long Island candidates for the New York State Senate on News 12.  It was, for the most part, a painful exercise.  The incumbents were somewhat polished in their comments.  The challengers, not so much.

For the most part, the challengers were sacrificial lambs.  Some came dressed in what appeared to be their Halloween costumes.  Others repeated a catchphrase, without regard to its lack of applicability to the question, seemingly in lieu of any knowledge or appreciation of the issues. 

The incumbents looked the part, and demonstrated a facial working knowledge of the issues.  They offered no solutions to any problems during my listening period, but generally responded that they had to “work on” this and “fix” that.  Why they hadn’t done so in their last 12 terms went unquestioned and unexplained.  It really wasn’t much of a debate, a word used to describe the situation in only the loosest possible way.  For the most part, all of the candidates agreed with each other on what was needed, “more services, lower taxes, smarter, more efficient, less corrupt, less abuse, more transparent” government. 

Only once did a candidate take a direct swipe at another, that being Barbara Donno against Democratic incumbent Craig Johnson.  Johnson’s seat is considered “at risk,” and Donno is going for blood.  He got his first county lege seat when his mother died.  Mrs. Simple Justice was friends with Craig’s mother, who was an incredible woman.  Donno came off as a serious candidate, but pointless and nasty.  She claimed residents complained that Craig “didn’t represent them” in Albany, without further explanation. 

Then, a debate began that rocked me to my core.  Two men vying for the 3rd Senate District, comprised of Islip, Smithtown and Brookhaven, took the stage.  There he was, an honest man.

No, it wasn’t challenger Brian Foley, Brookhaven Supervisor who was elected when all available Republican politicians were exhausted through indictment and imprisonment after the name change from Crookhaven.

It was 82 year old State Senator Caesar Trunzo.  Physically, he stands just over three feet tall, with a wattle the size of the Pine Barrens, but politically the man is a giant.  His argument for why he should be re-elected was clear and direct:  I’ve been there a long time,. I bring lots of cash to my district because of seniority.  The system works great.  Vote for the other guy and he’ll be at the bottom of the cash list.  He won’t bring in the cash.  I bring the money.

No nonsense.  No malarkey about lowering taxes and protecting the environment.  He’s got the loot and he’s bringing it home.  You want the loot, elect him.  Caesar Trunzo is perfect.

And he’s right about the cash.  Brian Foley will be at the bottom of the list, with the other rookies.  He won’t get the member money doled out by the Republican Senate.   Nothing has ever been said that more truly reflects the New York State Legislature than Trunzo’s pitch.  It’s a cash and carry legislature, and everything else is just fluff to appease the masses.

This is the real question for voters.  Do they want to maintain a cash and carry legislature, one where seniority gets the cash and votes are bought and sold.  Of course, if Trunzo brings home cash, it has to come from somewhere, meaning that some other district isn’t getting the cash it may need and deserve.  But “need and deserve” have no place in Albany.  Trunzo made that clear. 

Of course, if you happen to be on the receiving end of Trunzo’s payout, he’s a great Senator.  But remember that the money comes from one pocket to end in another, and just as someone in Schenectady may be paying for Caesar’s gifts, you can end up footing the bill for that downtown Rochester revival.  People get stupid when it comes to connecting taxes with services, forgetting that somebody has to pay every shiny new toy.  The trick is getting more than you pay for, which means someone else gets less.  That’s the Albany way.

Newsday has taken a stand on the 3rd Senatorial district.


Trunzo, 82, has kept being re-elected because he delivers for his district. But his nearly four decades in Albany have given him a jaded perspective on what it’s possible to accomplish there. More than once during a joint appearance by Trunzo and Foley before this board, Trunzo responded to an idea of Foley’s by referring to it as a dream. Ouch!

So the choice is between an incumbent who sees getting things done in Albany as a lost cause – the sad thing is, too often he’s probably right – and a challenger with a lot of ideas – some of them insufficiently detailed – but an inflated estimate of what a single senator can do.

In the end, it comes down to this: On balance, we think a GOP-controlled Senate will probably be better able to protect Long Island interests in this current fiscal crisis. So we endorse Trunzo.

Standing atop his pile of member money, Trunzo looks very tall indeed.  Who wants to take a chance on “dreams” when there’s cash to be had.  Newsday, in fact, endorsed every single incumbent for the Senate, though no other was as honest as Trunzo.  Others pretended to care about something other than their own re-election, when all they really want is to be Caesar Trunzo.

Long Islanders pay extraordinarily high taxes, but then we demand an awful lot of services.  As long as cash is thrown at the things we like, predominantly schools, we close our eyes to foolishness, graft and corruption.  It would be far too much effort to figure things out, and we are all much too important to waste our time becoming part of the solution.  So the true electoral mission is to continue our profligate ways, but at the expense of those dumb hicks upstate and those unworthy minorities in the City. 

The one true goal of politics on Long Island is to take other people’s money and spend it here, so we don’t have to spend our own or deal with our mess.  If this suits you, then Caesar Trunzo is your perfect politician, and the one honest man in Albany.  He brings home the loot and he’s not afraid to tell you.  But if you elect Caesar Trunzo, stop your griping.  You got what you wanted.

Troy Davis, Stay Number 3

Having reported on the yoyo status of the Troy Davis execution, another shocker came yesterday when the 11th Circuit issued yet another stay of execution, scheduled for this coming Monday.  According to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution :


On Wednesday, Davis asked the 11th Circuit for permission to pursue a new federal habeas corpus petition in which an inmate claims he is unlawfully incarcerated. The Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1996 requires a federal appeals court to approve such a request before such a new lawsuit can be filed.


“Upon our thorough review of the record, we conclude that Davis has met the burden for a stay of execution,” the court said in an order issued by Judges Joel Dubina, Rosemary Barkett and Stanley Marcus.


The judges called the stay “conditional” and said they want to hear more from Davis’ lawyers and state attorneys.


What is so surprising about this stay is that it comes on the heels of the United States Supreme Court’s rejection of Davis’ petition for cert, raising the obvious question of what the Circuit saw that the Supremes did not.  while there is no available opinion as yet, the newspaper reports that:



Davis must clear two difficult legal hurdles to win a new round of appeals.


First, he must show that his lawyers could not have previously found the new evidence supporting his innocence no matter how diligently they looked for it. And he must show that the new testimony, viewed in light of all the evidence, is enough to prove “by clear and convincing evidence that…no reasonable fact finder would have found [him] guilty.”


The 11th Circuit added a twist. It asked the parties to address whether Davis can still be executed if he can establish innocence under the second standard but cannot satisfy his burden under the first, due-diligence question.


The last paragraph is the one that is most shocking, and most offensive, about existing federal law.  One would think that proof of innocence, with nothing more, would be an awfully good reason not to execute someone.  The very notion of putting an innocent person to death is reprehensible.  The very notion of putting someone who may well be innocent, even if not quite proven, is reprehensible.  But not in America.

The second prong, diligence, is the bureaucratic kicker.  It is our legal system’s elevation of process over substance. 

There is an interest in finality of legal determinations.  Cases can’t go on forever, with nothing ever being finally resolved.  As a general rule, I take no issue with this.  But like all legal truisms, there are circumstances that trump the need for finality.  Innocence is one such circumstance. 

I would be inclined to ask who amongst us is in favor of executing an innocent person, but I already know the answer:  much of our federal judiciary.  The idea that a belated claim of innocence should be ignored because it didn’t fall within arbitrary time frames, or that a defendant should die because of any number of structural defense issues that delayed learning about, or presenting, new evidence, is just offensive.  While appellate decisions clean up the mess of practical litigation reality, to stake a person’s life on the fiction of expected diligence is just plain wrong.

But this latest twist, the 11th Circuit’s post-cert-denial grant of a stay, suggests that there are judges on the court who are indeed concerned about the possibility of putting an innocent man to death.  Bravo. 

But it begs one very serious question:  What if the Circuit concludes that there is evidence to prove that Troy Davis did not murder Police Officer Mark Allen MacPhail, but that his attorney failed to act with sufficient diligence.  Are they prepared to put an innocent man to death for a procedural flaw?  Is America prepared for this? Stay tuned.