Via Turley, Rita Cantrell of Greenville, South Carolina found out how Target (or Targét as some would pretend) got its name. From WYFF4 News,
Rita Cantrell of Greer went to two Target stores in the Greenville area in Feb. 2006, and both times employees accused her of using a counterfeit bill. Cantrell tried to buy items at the store and pay with an older series $100 bill.
[A Target] store employee sent out an e-mail to dozens of other retailers and law enforcement agencies warning them that Cantrell was a shoplifter who tried to spend bogus cash. The e-mail also included Cantrell’s picture.
Two things followed, one fortuitous for Cantrell and one not-at-all-fortuitous for Target. As it happened, Cantrell found out about the email because the place where she worked was on the list of recipients. And second, the United States Secret Service determined that the $100 bills were perfectly legitimate.
Cantrell sued Target and won a verdict of $100,000 compensatory damages and $3 million punitive. Target is, of course, going to appeal, and the likelihood of the verdict being reduced seems pretty high.
Target spokeswoman Bethany Zucco said Friday the company will challenge the ruling.
“We are extremely disappointed by the magnitude of the compensatory and punitive damages awarded by the jury in this case,” Zucco said in a statement. “We sincerely regret any inconvenience incurred by the plaintiff.
Any inconvenience? You sent out a mass email, with her picture, telling the world that she’s a thief and forger, and you’re sorry for the inconvenience? There’s an “apology” that demands some serious puni’s alone.
The importance of this story is not merely its level of offensiveness, but in the actions taken by private players to smear people who are neither guilty of any wrongdoing nor provided an opportunity challenge accusations. It was pure luck that Cantrell learned of the email, and had an opportunity to sue Target for its actions. But the actions themselves are outrageous and, unfortunately, commonplace.
Search your memory. Can you think of anyone you’ve ever met at a Target store who you would trust to play judge, jury and executioner? What qualifications did this unnamed store employee have to send out an email, with a photo no less, smearing this woman across South Carolina? What protections are in place at Target to stop some pimply-faced kid from destroying someone’s life because he didn’t know they made $100 bills before last week?
While theft is a plague for retail stores, fighting theft is not a job for amateurs, with inadequate training, procedures or accountability. As sorry as it may be that there are people who shoplift or pass counterfeit bills at stores like Target, that does not create an entitlement to affirmatively harming innocent people.
While I suspect that the $3 million punitive damages award won’ be upheld in light of the actual damages in the case, I also suspect that whatever the exemplary damages turn out to be will be insufficient to teach a lesson to major retailers who see the destruction of people’s lives as a cost of doing business.
