Last Wednesday, Edith Rodriguez was laying on the floor of the MLK-Harbor Hospital in a fetal position vomiting blood for 45 minutes. It might have been longer, but Los Angeles police determined that Ms. Rodriguez, apparently a potential parole violator, was ready for sentence. They executed her.
Other lawyers can discuss the fact that the hospital medical and nursing staff found her unworthy of assistance, or that the numerous calls to 911 brought about nothing more than the disdain of the very important operators, for whom Ms. Rodriguez’s extremis was hardly an emergency. But I’m going to stick with the cops.
How twisted has our hatred of the poor, of immigrants, of minorities, of potential parole violators, become that they should be intentionally left to die on the floor. They wouldn’t let this happen to a dog. But Ms. Rodriguez, apparently, was not nearly that important.
Some of the knee-jerk conservatives will bend over backwards to make excuses for the death of Ms. Rodriguez at the hands of police, snidely suggesting that she deserved it or brought it upon herself for some act of wrongdoing at some earlier moment in her life, and thereby relieving the cops of any responsibility. And in their disgusting logic, implicitly contend that she deserved the death penalty. That Ms. Rodriguez deserved to die on the floor because she was imperfect. To anyone who would even consider espousing such a view, I cannot find words strong enough to express how you sicken me.
Author Archives: SHG
America’s Funniest Home Blawgs
Following on the heels of Jamie Spencer’s excellent effort in putting together the Top Criminal Law Blogs (of which Simple Justice was honored to be included), Nicole Black has started a poll of the Top 10 Funniest Law Blogs at her very funny Legal Antics blog.
Let’s face facts, the law can be a hoot, and some lawyers take themselves waaaaaaay too seriously. If there’s a blawg that gives you a good laugh, or just brings a smile to your face, let Nicole know how you feel.
Return of the Flea (Or How I was John McNamara’d into Submission)
Most of us are painfully familiar with Dr. Flea, whose live blogging of his med-mal trial became the thing of which legends are made.
So where is he now? Well, it was understandable that he shut down his blog during trial, especially after his lawyer found out about it. But trial is now over, with the case settled and never to be heard from again. The Flea made the front page of the Boston Globe, which certainly was a shock to all, but that too has passed. People have short memories (gnats are jealous). It would be perfectly understandable that the Flea needed a break, and he got one. So shere is he?
Time to get back on that horse again, Flea. You were full of bluff and swagger when last we heard from you. Are you embarrassed? Ashamed? Are you a broken man, wallowing in self-pity? Well, snap out of it. Time to tell your story. Show us that you really are man enough to face the blogosphere.
You were a pretty good read before, and you had a lot of fans. Granted, some were pretty idiotic with their blind faith that the Flea could do no wrong. But that’s them. You know better. Get off your butt and back online. Put your blog back up and do some pediatric grand rounds. You most certainly have learned something about which subjects that are best left alone. On the other hand, there are some big open questions here and it’s hard to believe that you don’t want to fill in the blanks.
So come back, Flea. It was bad. It happened. You aren’t perfect, and that’s okay. Put it behind you and get back to work. The blogosphere isn’t the same without you.
You Paid How Much?
During dinner with a friend last night, the discussion eventually turned to a civil suit that he had brought against a neighbor for illegally cutting down trees. As he had shown me the papers during the pendency of the case, I had some familiarity with the subject.
With a relatively casual demeanor, my pal told me that legal fees for the action were “a little more than $75,000.” Trying my best to keep my composure, I repeated “$75,000?” “Yup,” he said, “it was a high-powered law firm.” They lost the case. They should not have lost the case. The work performed on my friend’s behalf was, at best, pedestrian and much of it pointless fluff that served no apparent purpose other than to grind out hours.
“Are you okay with that?” I asked, again with a casual air, as if it was no big deal to pay $75,000 over some trees and still end up the loser. “I guess they did everything they could,” he answered, leaving me to believe that he tosses that kind of money around on a regular basis.
Fade to black. Close-up of my subconscious: I could have done that case for a third of the cost, and won it. I represent people whose lives hang in the balance, and who think that a third of that is too high a price for their defense. “I’m in the wrong business,” I muttered under my breath.
My faux relaxed appearance must have belied my inner turmoil. “What’s the matter,” my good buddy asked. What am I supposed to say. Please don’t misunderstand; I have had many clients over the years whose lives have been worth many times that amount, and who have happily paid for the finest lawyering possible, with every bell and whistle that the profession can muster to provide as great an opportunity to prevail as possible. What I have difficulty with is that a civil litigator, whose work is mediocre and litigation experience clearly meager at best, can charge multiples of the value of yeoman legal services without raising the client’s cackles.
The vast majority of criminal cases do not involve well-heeled white collar defendants. There just aren’t that many Martha Stewart’s around. Most involve regular people, for whom the legal fee represents a significant portion of their net worth. And they are not inclined to give it up without a fight, which is understandable, but at the same time want to be represented by an OJ-like dream team. They just can’t, or won’t, pay for it. It’s worse with innocent clients, who argue that they shouldn’t have to pay because they didn’t do anything. As if the whole mess is the lawyer’s fault.
But that’s the criminal situation; Civil litigation, apparently, suffers from no similar issues, as they run up the bill more slowly, and suck it in dollar by dollar, knowing that they can be relieved whenever the bank runs dry. Criminal defense lawyers don’t just walk away when the client becomes a rock (you know, you can’t get blood from a rock?) The court won’t let us, but more importantly, we feel a different sense of duty toward our clients. For civil lawyers, it’s just money. For criminal lawyers, lives are at stake.
To express my feelings to my friend would only add insult to injury. It was bad enough the lawyer lost the case. He didn’t need to know that he overpaid as well. I let my friend pick up the tab for dinner.
Court of Appeals 2: Open for Business
Step right up and get yer justice here. Stomping for judicial pay raises, Court of Appeals Chief Judge Judy gave a speech to a group of businessfolk, as reported in the New York Law Journal and Judicial Reports. Well, this seemed a bit curious.
Other than playing on the businessfolk’s fear of reprisal, what could our Chief Judge, the one individual who more than any other in the State of New York represents Justice, Propriety and Fundamental Fairness for all, say to these corp-exec-types?
“We need it and deserve it for the protection and promotion of business interests in this financial and commercial capital of the world.”
Gulp. A new motto for the Court system, To Protect and Promote Business Interests. That old cliché, Equal Justice Under Law, was getting tired anyway.
NY Court of Appeals: So You Think You Can Dance?
In a June 12th decision, courtesy of New York Legal Update, the Court of Appeals upheld the conviction by plea in People v Parilla, 2007 NY Slip Op 05133. In this case involving a 1993 rape, a 1996 blood sample and a 2003 prosecution, the defendant brought a pro se motion to dismiss on statute of limitations grounds. The trial court rejected it because he was a represented defendant.
The judge then talked defense counsel out of adopting the motion, off the record, by telling her that it wouldn’t be granted. The defendant ultimately took a plea which included a waiver of appeal, and moved the next day via a 440.10 motion on ineffective assistance grounds. The defendant then appealed the whole enchilada.
The peculiar aspect of this case lies in the harsh description of the defendant’s purpose in appealing. The Court held:
Defendant attempts to sidestep the consequences of his plea by claiming ineffective assistance of counsel. Under the circumstances of this case, were we to consider defendant’s statute of limitations claim on the merits, we would be reviewing the very argument that defendant waived when he pleaded guilty and waived his right to appeal. [citations omitted, emphasis added.]
Sidestep the consequences? Is that not the point of essentially every appeal? Notice the judicial slight of hand by skipping over the ineffective assistance claim and going to the underlying statute of limitations argument, which, the Court held, was what was waived by the plea. Except for the fact that a waiver, to be effective, must be knowing and intentional, and the one thing that is clear throughout is that the defense attorney was bullied into submission by the trial judge.
A second theme that comes across loud and clear is that the defendant, having been in prison for an extended period before this plea (yes, the defendant was not a fine upstanding citizen), became a jail house lawyer. He was the poster boy for the phrase, “a little knowledge is dangerous.” Of course, since his lawyer failed him, this may not have been the worst thing.
The old formulation for ineffective assistance was a “mockery of justice,” a somewhat subjective standard. But in this case, it was met. This plea smells of a farce and sham, where the defense lawyer was pushed into not pursuing the statute of limitations defense in order to avoid annoying the judge. The fact that the judge had told her the motion would fail is ridiculous. Since when is that the measure of whether to move for dismissal?
And so, while few can feel a great deal of sympathy for this defendant, the precedent of this decision, combined with the harshness of its language, is quite disturbing. The Court of Appeals did a quick step around the real issue, knowing full well that the defendant was denied effective assistance of counsel, and upheld an unintended and unknowing waiver, to avoid allowing the defendant to fox trot his way to freedom. Another bad case making bad law.
Watch the Watch
Keep your eye on the left wrist.
Anybody need a slightly used Timex?
Customer Complaints
Thrice this week I was chastised by others for my blawg defying easy pigeonholing.
“Yutz,” I was called (by someone obviously misinformed that yutz was a Yiddish term of endearment).
“Don’t you know that you can’t market yourself through your blog unless you keep it consistent!”
Why yes, I’ve heard that. But then my blog was not created as an exercise in marketing. Shocking but true. It’s not that I do not appreciate the inquiries from people who have happened upon my work and sought me out, but that’s not why I write. Cogito ergo sum. And I write because I think.
I could limit my blawg to New York criminal law issues, or criminal law issues in general. But my interests are not so limited. Some of my work is deadly serious, while I include many humorous elements in my blawg. For me, there’s room for both. And if your gestalt needs compel you to demand an explanation, jurisprudence is the product of all influences of society, whether popular, political, legal or historical. Why stop at one when you can have them all?
So read what you want. If you like it, read more. If you hate it, tell me why. I don’t mind being told I’m wrong. My best thoughts come from being challenged, and I am proud to say that I’ve learned as a result. But don’t bitch because I my world tends to expand in unpredictable ways. If I had the time, I would write about 100 things a day, likely more. There is so much of interest happening around us that I cannot fathom how any thinking person could do less.
UPDATE: I just found out that Jamie Spencer in his Austin Criminal Defense Lawyer blog has just posted the results of his highly scientific poll of favorite criminal defense blawgs of all time, and this blog has made the top 10 (actually, 11, but we’re lawyers, not accountants, so who’s counting). I am, of course, humbled by this honor. So who’s the yutz now!
Slavery on the North Shore
Newsday has been running a series of articles about a Muttontown couple accused of enslaving 2 Indonesian women. You don’t get too many slavery cases these days, though some might argue that its purely a matter of poor enforcement.
Today, Newsday reports that US District Court Judge Thomas Platt has given up on releasing the couple on any bail conditions. Despite their offer to put up $3.5 Million in cash, and pay $15,000 a day to turn their home into a prison, prosecutors have not agreed to the terms. According to the article, significant doubts have arisen from the couple’s possibly deceptive information about their financial resources, particularly those held outside the country. This suggests, of course, that the couple would flee and live quite nicely elsewhere.
What today’s story doesn’t mention is that the couple’s attorneys today, Stephen Scaring and Jeffrey Hoffman, were not their lawyers yesterday. And their lawyers yesterday were different from the ones the day before. 
Flavor of the Day: Defense Attorneys Scaring and Hoffman
It’s impossible to point the finger of blame at any attorney involved in this case, even though an earlier one apparently got into a bit of a pissing contest with Judge Platt, causing the judge to publicly shut him down. Not generally considered to be a wise move given that Judge Platt gets to make the decision. But what emits an unpleasant odor about this situation is that the “wealthy Muttontown couple,” as they are invariably referred to, have dug themselves into a legal hole (aside from any issue of guilt or innocence) from which they will never emerge.
Short and sweet: Don’t change lawyers more often than socks. Recently, I wrote about getting it right the first time, and the impact of half-baked initial choices as to defense counsel. Of course I realize that it isn’t easy to select the best quality defense lawyer available, but knee-jerk resort to some guy “who used to be a DA” as referred by your real estate lawyer just doesn’t cut it. Quick and easy, just foolishly wrong.
And so the couple, with their first set of lawyers in hand, provide financial disclosure that has permanently tainted the efforts of their current set of lawyers. That was a mistake. And the fact that a new lawyer shows up every time the case comes before Judge Platt creates a sense of, oh what to call this, instability? That was a mistake. This couple hasn’t figured out yet that they are walking into court as criminal defendants, no matter how important they are in their own minds (an inherent North Shore curse). No doubt they know better than any lawyer, and as they are absolutely entitled to get whatever they want (another inherent North Shore curse), the failure to secure release means that the lawyer must suck. It certainly couldn’t have anything to do with the couple’s choices.
What will be interesting after today’s ruling by Judge Platt, shutting down efforts to turn their home into a fortress, will be what happens to the couple’s current lawyers. Certainly the couple has better lawyers now then they deserve. But will there be new lawyers defending them tomorrow? I bet that will impress the judge. Given this history of compounding one stupid move with another, I have but one piece of advice for lawyers in the game. Get a big retainer up front, because the chances of actually seeing this case through to its conclusion seem mighty slim. As for the “wealthy Muttontown couple,” Varsha Mahender Sabhnani, 45, and her husband, Mahender Murlidhar Sabhnani, 51, bear in mind that America is the land of opportunity for everyone. Not just you.
What’s in a Name
New York Legal Update asks Who’s Acronym Is It Anyway? In Matter of Fireman’s Assn. of State of New York v French Am. School of N. Y., 2007 NY Slip Op 04745, the FASNY firefighters duke it out with the FASNY French School. FASNY. Man, what a catchy acronym. No wonder they are all over each other.
What took me by surprise was this bit of info about the volunteer fireman’s FASNY:
It has a membership of 43,000 volunteer firefighters and an annual operating budget of $11,000,000.
Excuse me? These are the vollys that are so desperate that they need pensions for retention, race cars for fun, and have a piece of fire apparatus for every member (okay, I’m exaggerating on the last one, but if you’ve ever been to a parade, it certainly looks that way.) And they have an association with an annual operating budge of $11 Mil! Who’s paying for this, and what do they do that they need $11 Mil that isn’t already being done with my tax dollars the first time around? Holy Smoke! Volunteers cost a bundle!
Apparently, part of that $11 Mil is needed for legal fees to keep those French students from glomming their good name. When I first saw the decision, I thought to myself, this is a tempest in a teapot. But now I realize, if only 10% of that $11 Mil gets mistakenly shuffled over to the French FASNY instead of the fireman’s FASNY, that could cost them 3 Las Vegas conventions. This is serious business.
Turning now to my other reason for taking note of this nonsense, the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, or NYSACDL as its called by almost every New Yorker, was looking for a new name. The problem was that the name was too long for the media, such that its was either left out entirely or routinely butchered into some shortened version. So, we tried to come up with a new, more media friendly name.
One of the choices was Defense Attorneys of New York, or DANY. Catchy, right? Except for one tiny hitch. DANY is used by the District Attorney of New York County, Bob Morgenthau’s gang. Potential for confusion? Perhaps, but think of the fun we would have litigating the issue. I wanted to go for it. Others, less inclined to tussle with the DA when not being paid to do so, thought it ill-advised. Still others thought that the original name was so deeply etched in the public’s consciousness that a change would be unwise.
What about the Feisty Attorneys of the State of New York. Catchy, right?
