Author Archives: SHG

SCOTUS: Passenger has Standing to Challenge an Unlawful Stop

The United States Supreme Court just issued its unanimous opinion in Brendlin v. California, written by Justice Souter, reversing the Supreme Court of California and holding that a passenger has standing to challenge the baseless stop of a car as an unconstitutional seizure of his person.

While it has long been recognized that a traffic stop is a seizure of the driver of a vehicle, the Court has never directly addressed whether the same holds true for a passenger in the vehicle.  That question is now settled.  In this case, the State of California conceded that the police had no reasonable suspicion to stop the car (a separate problem that appears to have gone unnoticed by all), but argued that since the passenger does not submit to police authority when a car is stopped, he is not “seized” within the meaning of the Constitution.  Justice Souter said “nope”, finding that the passenger is just as stopped as the driver. 

Chambermaid: Just Read It

Chambermaid It’s summer, so read.  Order a copy of Saira Rao’s debut novel, Chambermaid.   Amazon says:



The devil holds a gavel in this wickedly entertaining debut novel about a young attorney’s eventful year clerking for a federal judge. Sheila Raj is a recent graduate of a top-ten law school with dreams of working for the ACLU, but law school did not prepare her for the power-hungry sociopath, Judge Helga Friedman, who greets her on her first day. While her beleaguered colleagues begin quitting their jobs, Sheila is assigned to a high-profile death penalty case and suddenly realizes that she has to survive the year as Friedman’s chambermaid — not just her sanity, but actual lives hang in the balance. With Chambermaid, debut novelist Saira Rao breaks the code of silence surrounding the clerkship and boldly takes us into the mysterious world of the third branch of US government, where the leaders are not elected and can never be fired. With its biting wit and laugh-out-loud humor, this novel will change everything you think you know about how great lawyers, and great judges, are made.

A Belated Thank You to Professor Myres McDougal

I was a student of Prof. Myres S. McDougal in law school.  He taught jurisprudence.  To this day, I think of Professor McDougal often.  Even though he is no longer with us, I want to say thank you.

Prof. McDougal was emeritus at Yale Law School, slumming when he taught my class.  On day 1, he made a short speech that I will never forget.  He told the class not to worry about their grades (something law students tend to obsess over); not to bother taking notes.  Just listen.  You won’t understand what I’m talking about for a few years, but if you pay attention, someday you will.  Most of the students took this as an opportunity to nap.  I can’t explain why, but I listened.  Prof. McDougal was quite brilliant.

What I learned was a holistic approach to jurisprudence and the law.  That we, as attorneys, must view what we do in the broadest context, including every aspect and influence in our approach to lawyering.  It’s not just about the facts and the law, but the judge and what he ate for breakfast that morning, and the shoes our clients wear to the trial, and the t-shirt worn by juror number 4.  Our arguments may be derived from natural law, or normative law, according to how we understand the decision-maker to be influenced, and that we should never lose sight of that point.  We need to notice everything, think about everything, and factor it all into a world-view of what we do.

While any particular influence may not ultimately prove to play a role in our efforts, it similarly may and we will never be able to identify what factors proved critical, or even influential.  But we have no reason to ignore any factor and do so at our own risk.  The very practical ultimate goal, the persuasion of the decision-maker to decide in our favor, is the culmination of a philosophy and approach that incorporates every tool and weapon at our disposal.  If we go into battle unarmed, we have no one to blame but ourselves.

In a sense, Prof. McDougal’s words sound obvious, and yet rarely heeded by lawyers.  It can be an enormous effort to remain forever vigilant.  Prof. McDougal’s words ring in my ears all the time, and I take great pains to follow his advice.  He was right; I didn’t have an appreciation of what he was trying to tell us so many years ago.  But over time, I came to fully appreciate the importance of his message.  Thank you Prof. McDougal.

Lessons from Nifong

Duke DA disgrace Mike Nifong has been disbarred.  For a painfully thorough discussion, see Durham-in-Wonderland by KC Johnson, ironically a Brooklyn College history professor.

No reason to rehash the story.  We all know it.  But the question remains, what does this mean for the rest of us?  I foresee two things:

1.  Sitting District Attorneys are no longer immune from scrutiny and can be held accountable for their conduct.
2.  Unless the impropriety by a sitting District Attorney makes headlines, it will be swept under the rug like it’s always been.

So while defense lawyers will be the perpetual target, particularly if you’re too good at what you do, the likelihood of a prosecutor being Nifonged remains slim.  And life goes on.

NY Criminal Defense Lawyers: Texan Says “We Got It Better”

We’ve got a throwdown.  Mark Bennett from Texas thinks that we’re a bunch of namby-pamby pretenders.  In response to my post that peripherally mentions Texas lawyers whining about “expunction” (some made-up Texas word that’s supposed to mean “expungement”), Mark provides a laundry list of why criminal defense is better in Texas than New York.

That’s right.  Better in Texas, where there are enough capital executions for a daily game show.  Where criminal defense lawyers can nap through trial with impunity.  Where the judges are more likely to pack heat than the defendants (actually, it’s probably a draw).  The State that gave us Tom Delay! 

Are you gonna let some yahoo in Gucci cowboy boots skewer New York criminal defense lawyers on a longhorn?  Let’s have your comments about why New York criminal defense lawyers have it better than Texans. 

One more thing, this Bennett guy writes:

There’s a barbecue restaurant here in Houston, Goode Co. Barbeque. They purvey some of the best Texas-style barbecue ( Wikipedia ) in the state. [talk about damning with faint praise!}  They make a pecan pie that’s second only to mine, and they will ship it anywhere; It’s not easy to read in the picture, but the inscription painted above their logo is “You might give some serious thought to thanking your lucky stars you’re in Texas.”

You think they mean that Texas jails are nicer than the Tombs or the Rock?  Extra points if you work in something about Texas “BBQ”.

The Other Drunk Driver

I was driving along yesterday when I noticed that the guy in the next lane, about 100 yards ahead of me, was driving eratically.  Speeding up, then slowing down.  Weaving over the lines, coming into my land then across the double yellow line into the oncoming traffic lane.  It was about 8:30 in the morning. 

“Oh crap,” I thought.  He’s drunk.  My son was in the car with me, and I pointed it out to him so he would recognize the danger as well as the impact of drinking and driving.

We came to a traffic signal, and I pulled alongside.  There was a middle aged man in the car.  He had a cellphone next to his head and was talking away.  He wasn’t drunk.  He was on the phone.

Society has become intolerant of drunk driving.  Whether this reaction is appropriate is a subject for another day.  But this same society views driving with a cellphone glued to a driver’s head, illegal in New York, as an inconsequential socially acceptable act. 

Three points need to be made, and made as clearly as possible. 

1.   Cellphone use while driving is as dangerous as driving drunk. 
2.  Death at the hands of a driver on a cellphone is every bit as dead as at the hands of a drunk driver.
3.  There is no one you need to speak with so desparately that you have the right to endanger the life of another person.

The same people who will rail with inflammatory rhetoric at the evils of driving drunk will happily cruise in their SUV while talking non-stop on a cellphone.  You may not think you’re driving poorly, but neither do most drunks.  The rest of us see it pretty clearly. 

Though illegal, it is so pervasive that one would think you get free airtime when you talk while driving.  I see it constantly, and I rarely see anyone stopped for it.  The cops take it no more seriously then anyone else, apparently.  But drunk driving is morally unacceptable, so it is the target of increasingly harsher laws and penalties.  If only we would come to grips with the fact that you can cause the death of an innocent person just as easily when driving while talking on a cellphone.  Get off the phone.  Whoever it is that wants to speak with you, or with whom you want to speak, you can call them later.  Let me get home alive.

Regional Differences (or Texas Whiners)

I was reading Jamie Spencer’s blog, Austin Criminal Defense Lawyer, where he writes about the importance of “expunction”.  Expunction?  What’s his beef?  In New York, we call expunction by a different name, expungement, and the significance of it is that we don’t have it. We would like it.  We think it would be the right thing to do.  But it doesn’t exist here. 

And yet, there’s Jamie, and Mark Bennett commenting about the unfairness of it all, complaining about expunction.

 

Personally, I think its a bit bizarre when Texas law is a step ahead of New York when it comes to something like expungement.  Remember, this is the state that puts defendants to death when their lawyer is fast asleep at trial. 

But the point of this post is that there are significant differences in the law and practice from place to place.  Having tried cases as far away as Anchorage, Alaska, I’ve come to realize and appreciate that understanding local practice matters.  I had a “My Cousin Vinny” moment when I traveled down to Bowling Green, Kentucky to do a case.  I opened to the jury with, “You probably can’t tell, but I’m not from around here.”  Got a good laugh out of them, which is always important.  Happy juries have a harder time convicting. 

Obviously, local differences abound and it would be impossible to mention, or even recognize, all of them.  But what is important is the recognition that they exist and they matter.  While I naturally believe that I am the best trial lawyer since Clarence Darrow, and there’s no successful trial lawyer who can believe otherwise, I always work with local counsel when I go to some foreign venue who can show me the local ropes, help me with local customs and even tell me what’s funny there and what’s not.  Humor in New York isn’t always funny in Galveston. 

This is true in both state and federal courts.  Even though federal law is (theoretically) the same across the country, the practical differences are often staggering and assumptions that life the Southern District of Florida is the same as the Southern District of New York can lead to some foolish mistakes.  The jurisprudence of criminal defense demands that we understand where we fit into the bigger picture.  I don’t bet my clients’ lives on assumptions, and they tend to be appreciate it.

So as you travel through the blawgosphere and read about how things are done in one place or another, never confuse the good life in Texas (with this expunction issue) with the hard life in New York (where your lawyer is required to be awake throughout the entire trial).  Take the information with a grain of salt (Lawyerus Emptor) and bear in mind that not everything on the internet will apply to you.

And Now, A Word From Bob

6/15/2007 8:51 PM Bob wrote:
Why not point fingers at the fat parole violator. Maybe she should take better care of her fat self and her fat family. Did you see those fatties on TV?


This comment was left by somebody who gave only the name “Bob” in reaction to my story of the execution of Edith Rodriguez.  My first reaction was to delete the comment.  Since this is my blawg, I can do that.  But that smelled of censorship, and that cuts against my grain.  My next thought was to respond to it.  But what exactly is the right response to a comment like this?  Do I ridicule Bob for the suggestion that fat people are unworthy of living?  Do I tell him what a truly sick person he is?

I decided to sleep on it and take another look in the morning.  So here it is, morning, and the comment is as ugly and ignorant as it was last night.  Ah, there’s nothing like the anonymity of the internet to let the true ugliness come out.

And then it came to me.  This comment is important.  It is important that people who read this blawg know that there are people out there who actually think this way.  That there are people who would actually put something like this in writing.  Because we know nothing more about “Bob”, no one will ever be able to tell who, exactly, this Bob is, and he will never be held accountable for this comment.  The anonymity of the internet is the most potent truth serum there is.  Bob has let out his deepest, darkest prejudice and hatred, something I doubt he would do if he was standing face to face with another person.  But online, he can say it straight out and chuckle about it afterward.  “Ha!  I sure told them fatties!”

I post Bob’s comment here as demonstrable evidence that people like Bob exist.  There is no voir dire question that will elicit this response, showing the depth of his anger and ignorance and prejudice.  But fair minded people, even those who tend to disagree politically, have trouble believing that people like this really exist.  Well friends, Bob exists and he’s walking amongst us right now.  Never forget it.

Execution Update

I received an email castigating me for calling the death of Edith Rodriguez an “execution”.  While the writer neglected to mention his/her background, I was accused of deceit and being unamerican.  It also implied that I’m short, fat and incredibly ugly, suggesting that it’s someone who knows me. 

So in an effort to be as precise as possible, I want to update my comment to make things absolutely clear:  Edith Rodriguez was executed at the hands of LA County Public Safety Police. 

Let us consider the nitty gritty:  Ms. Rodriguez, at the time she first appeared in the ER, was alive.  Ms. Rodriguez, was still alive as she lay on the floor vomiting blood.  Vomiting blood whilst lying on the floor in the fetal position is a universal sign that something is wrong.  Very wrong.  The Public Safety Cops appear and observe this scene, carefully noting every detail because they are highly trained observers.

Human beings can engage in conduct in one of two ways.  They can either perform an act, and thereby actively engage.  Or they can fail to perform an act, and thereby passively engage.  Both involve choices.  Edith Rodriguez, as a direct consequence of the choice made here, is dead.  She is every bit as dead as if a bullet was shot into her head.  Although, it is arguably more cruel to simply stand there and allow the life to painfully ebb out of her body than to end her life quickly.  Not that I am advocating for the latter.

And so Edith Rodriguez was executed.  For anyone who still separates the nature of human volitional acts from the responsibility for the consequences of those acts, or whose blind love of police enables them to overlook the harsh reality of what happened to Edith Rodriguez, there are plenty of neo-con websites out there who will support and applaud your position that either cops can do no wrong or that hispanic surnamed individuals with warrants should be left to die.  But not here.

Suppression: Opportunity Lost

Of all the weapons available to the defense, few are more potent than suppression of evidence.  When I do an appeal, or come into a case after pre-trial motions are completed, I am often astounded at how one of the biggest guns in the defense arsenal is neglected or wasted through the use of pro forma motions, lacking any semblance of thought or strategy.

Sure, the client is impressed that you cranked out a 20 page omnibus motion, but who do you think you’re kidding?  You didn’t even bother to change the name of the defendant all the way through when you churned out your standard motion papers.  This 5 second solution comes at an extraordinary price.  One size does not fit all.  Every defendant you represent deserves an omnibus motion thoughtfully crafted for the specific case.  No excuses.  If you can’t be bothered, go become a civil lawyer.  You’ll probably make more money anyway.

I’ve lectured at CLEs about the power of a strong, fully-conceived, thoroughly researched and clearly-written suppression motion.  I beg lawyers to do this.  Often, to no avail.  Is it too much work?  Is it beyond your ability?  Have you just become too complacent to care?  The excuses may have varied but the results did not.  Denied.

Suppression motions, and the hearings that invariably follow a good suppression motion, have been an exceptional opportunity for me.  I prevail with great frequency, and even if I can’t get every piece of evidence, every spoken word, every identification suppressed, I almost always walk away with some victory.  No, this is not luck or weak opposition.  It’s effort.  Police routinely fudge the details surrounding an arrest, or the procedures for identification, or . . . something.  It’s my responsibility to have such a thorough knowledge of the law, and command of the facts, that I can find that crack and exploit it. 

At the very least, you get a preview of the witnesses against you and can get a ton of information about the case.  I push the envelope as far as the judge will let me, going as deep into the facts as possible.  Why? Two really good reasons: First, to get the details that I will never get from discovery. Second, to nail down the witness’ testimony for use at trial, when he “improves” upon it after being told by the prosecutor what he did wrong.  How can any competent lawyer ignore this opportunity?

For those of you non-criminal lawyers who think, “Aha another lawyer trying to manipulate the truth to deny justice,” you miss the point.  In criminal law, we work with the information as viewed through the eyes of the police and prosecutors.  Sometimes we’re lied to, but almost always we’re fed a relative truth that’s been twisted to meet their desire to convict.  Rarely does anyone in criminal law possess “truth”, but merely stories from our respective points of view. 

Moreover, at least in NY, disclosure is largely non-existent.  Civil litigators have the opportunity to find out essentially everything about their adversaries position in advance. Criminal defense lawyers often go to trial blind.  Most people can’t conceive of how this could be, since civil cases involve only money, while criminal involves the lives of real people.  And yet, this is how it is, and how our Legislature intends it to be. 

So I reiterate my plea to any lawyer who happens upon this rant.  Take suppression seriously.  Think about it.  Develop a strategy, well grounded in the law and facts, and then make it happen.  Research the law. Then research it again.  Don’t just do it for your client, but do it for me.  I may be taking over the case and I don’t want to be saddled with anyone’s garbage lawyering.