When I started practicing law, I was taught it was a profession. That meant that we, the members of the profession, carried certain responsibilities that transcended the basic fee for service model. People trusted us to exercise a level of thoughtfulness, effort and insight on their behalf that had no direct connection to the fact that we were paid for our services.
So where did everything go awry? When a new client comes to me, I begin with the assumption that I’m there to achieve the results the client desires. This doesn’t mean that it may not ultimately be possible, but I’m damn well going to try. It would never occur to me to assume, from day 1, that it’s a quick plea. So I’m part of the club that anticipates working for his client. It’s a very lonely club these days.
Many criminal defense lawyers take cases (note cases, not clients) under the assumption that (1) they will never go to trial, (2) they will be pleading guilty, and (3) the only work involved on the lawyer’s part is a negotiation to determine how many years the defendant will spend in prison. Hey, defendants out there, did your lawyer tell you this when you decided to retain him/her? Did you realize that you hired a lawyer for the purpose of losing your case?
The answer, unfortunately, is that the lawyer DID tell you, though not in so many words. When you retain counsel on a serious felony for $2500, exactly how much time did you think the lawyer intended to spend on you? It’s a math question, and nothing more. The lawyer is saying to you that he has no intention of putting time and effort into your defense, and that you (and your case) are going down so fast it will make your head spin.
Let’s assume that the lawyer is charging $250 per hour, a rate that is not inappropriate for a relatively rookie lawyer. That’s 10 hours of work for $2500. Figure 2 hours per court appearance, and maybe 2 hours of office time (meeting with you) and 2 hours of research and writing (more likely just copying over an old set of motion papers with the name changed) for an attorney to handle your case. You’re left with a total of 3 court appearances, just enough for a plea and sentence. Did you think you were going to trial for that amount?
“But he promised me he was going to take care of me!” you exclaim. And so he did, though not in the way you expected. Let’s face some cold, hard facts. You, the client, couldn’t distinguish a competent lawyer from a banana if your life depended on it. You, the client, chose a lawyer because you like him or her, or because he told you what you wanted to hear, or because he comes recommended by someone who had a good outcome. But having a warm and fuzzy personality, or intentionally deceiving a client, has nothing to do with being a good lawyer. The hard work that top quality lawyers do happens outside the view of clients for the most part, but becomes readily apparent on the back side when and if you go to court. See your lawyer on trial and you will either see someone command the courtroom or look like a blithering idiot. Believe me, it can be painful to watch some lawyers on trial.
The best method is by recommendation, but that has extreme pitfalls as well. Most look to the outcome achieved by the person who made the recommendation, under the assumption that if one person beat the case, you will beat the case as well. The problem here, of course, is that no two cases are alike and outcome in one case means nothing as to outcome in another. Further, there are a variety of factors that result in any given outcome, many of which have nothing to do with the lawyer. You would need to know a lot about how the outcome was achieved in order to make any meaningful determination of whether it applies to you.
The real question when considering a recommendation is whether the lawyer demonstrated the skills and determination necessary to achieve the outcome, regardless of the particular facts and circumstances of the other case. What you want is the lawyer capable of producing the best results, not necessarily the identical outcome, because your case is never going to be exactly the same as someone else’s case, and you aren’t the same as anyone else.
So when you read between the lines, realize that lawyers who are charging you a fraction of what is required to represent you and achieve the outcome you desire are sending you a message. They want your business. They hope for the best. But they aren’t going to put in the time and effort necessary to win. If circumstances work in their favor, they will look like a hero. But if the DA doesn’t drop the ball, or decide to drop the case, then you’ve just bought a quick plea. Pack your toothbrush, you’re going to jail. If this is okay with you, then you’ve made a wise choice. If this isn’t what you had in mind, then think long and hard about who your retaining and why he’s charging so little. The lawyer doesn’t really love you. The lawyer isn’t giving you a big break on the fee because he likes your smile. The lawyer is telling you that you are one of the herd of criminal defendants that will presumptively fill up the prisons, and that you got what you paid for.
It’s your life. Think about it.
Author Archives: SHG
Fight or Flight?
Many defendants assume that they can’t win anymore, or that the stakes are too high to take the chance. So, they turn to what they believe to be the easy option: cooperation. The assumption is that cooperation is a “get out of jail free” card. This may be one of the worst assumptions that a defendant can make, and he or she may be haunted by this choice for many, many years.
Aside from the obvious issues surrounding cooperation, such as becoming a “rat” against one’s friends and family, risking one’s life and impairing what little integrity you may have, there is a very pragmatic problem. Cooperation is not a free ride. The chance that you will be released to wander the streets as a happy, carefree person is slim to none. That’s just not the outcome. While you may be given a substantial concession in time, it does not mean that you will have worked off any punishment whatsoever.
Oddly, one aspect of cooperation that doesn’t dawn on many people until after it’s too late is that the first thing asked of you is to be debriefed about your own prior criminal conduct. What this means is that you are required to disclose everything you’ve ever done wrong that the government doesn’t know about yet, or can’t prove. But now, with your admission, they DO know about it and they CAN prove it. Very often, the deal with the government will include that you be charged with these additional offenses as well as the offense for which you were arrested. The impact is that while you were facing a charge for one crime initially, you are now facing charges for 10 crimes, with a commensurately greater penalty. So, even with a substantial concession resulting from the cooperation, you end up with as much, if not more, time in prison than you would have had in the first place.
Another ploy is that many defendants think that they can control the government when giving cooperation. They can limit what they say to avoid implicating their friends or avoid admitting to prior criminal conduct. This is one of the most dangerous things that can happen. While there are ocassionally defendants who pull this off, most of the time the government has far more information about the defendant than he realizes, but will hold this information close to the vest. Why? Because the first thing you are told is that you must tell the truth or your cooperation, even though given, will not result in any benefit. By keeping the additional information to themselves, the government tests defendants for truthfulness. After they have sucked whatever they can from the defendant who is trying to play with them, the government will spring this information on the defendant and use their lack of candor to either get whatever they are holding back or deny them the benefit they thought they would receive.
Is this dishonest? To a degree, yes. But it also serves the legitimate purpose of the government being in the position of using a defendant at trial where the defendant’s testimony is protected from impeachment by his dishonesty with the government or failure to be candid. There’s nothing worse for the government than putting a witness on the stand who is subsequently impeached by a good defense lawyer for his failure to disclose prior criminal conduct. It shows the witness is a liar and makes the government look foolish. The government does not like to look foolish, and will take it out on their deceitful cooperator.
Does this mean that cooperation is an inherently bad choice for all defendants. No. But any defendant who is considering cooperation should know the pitfalls as well as the benefits. Just as a defendant should not go to trial without knowing the positives and negatives of the choice, they should not jump blindly into cooperation with realizing that it is not a “get out of jail free” card.
Justice is a funny thing
Most people come to a lawyer claiming that they want justice. Do they? They want to win their case. They want to beat the rap. But winning often has little to do with justice. And that’s okay. As a criminal defense lawyer, it’s my responsibility to represent you, not justice. This point is lost on many clients. More often than not, new potential clients will come to me with a story about their innocence. Perhaps they are indeed innocent (it does happen), but perhaps they are not. Or perhaps they are not as guilty as the police say, but not quite innocent either.
What a new client needs to appreciate is that I do not care whether they are innocent or not. It has no impact whatsoever on my efforts on their behalf, even though they may find that hard to believe. For the purpose of representing a client, I assume that everyone is guilty in order to remove that taint they feel and enable them to speak freely to me about what happened. This is by far the most important thing they can do to aid me in preparing their defense. As I frequently tell clients, I don’t want to be the only person in the room who has no clue what really happened. If a client lies to me to minimize their guilt, they have taken away my most valuable weapon on their behalf: knowledge.
I’m always straight with my clients. As some will happily tell you, there are times when they would appreciate a little more sugar-coating and a little less honesty, though in the end they truly appreciate the fact that their decisions are based on a real appraisal of the situation rather than the old “don’t worry” approach, until (of course) it’s too late. In return, I expect them to be straight with me. It’s not much to ask, and ultimately empowers me to deal with the real situation rather than some pretend set of circumstances that helps neither you nor me.
