Author Archives: SHG

Take My Wife, Please

A Texas attorney was  convictioned of theft for demanding and receiving $100,000 from two men who had affairs with his wife (also an attorney).   Apparently, he demanded the money or threatened that he would sue them.  In civil law, we call that settlement negotiations.  In Texas, always an interesting place for legal happenings, it is apparently a crime to interfere with a person’s right to have sex with your spouse.

Just another silly Texas verdict?  Well, if you’re the wife, you’re thinking “only a hundred thou?”  And if you’re the victims, you’re thinking “I just paid to have sex with a lawyer?”  And if you’re the defendant, you’re thinking “Now if I can only get here to bill for 2500 hours of sex a year at $100,000 per one tenth of an hour…”

Texas always has something fun for the rest of the country. 

“We Have Made Mistakes”

United States Attorney General Alberto Gonzalez has confirmed our worst fears.  The Patriot Act has been abused.  The United States Attorneys offices have been manipulated by Washington for political purposes, upon pain of dismissal.  The FBI is wiretapping whoever it wants.   And when caught in the act, the AG says “We have made mistakes.”

In all fairness to Mr. Gonzalez, it’s not like this comes as a surprise.  The Government is not a single entity, unified in its purpose and intent.  It’s made up of millions of Americans, each of whom thinks he or she knows what’s best for the American people.  To truly oversee these people is impossible.  To truly know the secret intent of these people is even more impossible.  But to understand people is easy.  To err is human.  From the outset, it was impossible to think that there would not be people who would abuse the awsome power they possess.

In the wake of events that drove the emotions of a nation, we acted capriciously.  Sure, we wrapped ourselves in the flag before doing so, but out elected officials were in such a rush to pander to our fears that we allowed them to give away our legacy.  We did it.  They were just the mechanism by which it was done.

I’m not going to belabor the obvious.  There is no time in history, nor set of circumstances, that justifies the suspension of reason.  The words of George Santayan come to mind: “Those who do not remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”

Don’t blame the AG.   But put an end to the abuse.  And remember that the government exists to serve us, not control us.
 

Legal Malpractice and Criminal Defense

Most criminal defense lawyers take comfort in the tacit understanding that the chances of being successfully sued are slim to none.  Absent proof of actual innocence, even abject incompetence causes no harm.  So that gives the defense lawyer a free pass in botching a case, true?

Unfortunately, the answer is, with certain exceptions, true.  This emboldens some lawyers to act with utter indifference to their responsibilities to their clients.  Failing to ask for a hearing, or give proper and timely alibi notice.  Failing to inspect a crime scene or read the discovery.  The dreaded motion to suppress identification when no ID notice was given.  Falling asleep at trial, for god’s sake.  All terrible, but not necessarily actionable.  Why?  Because the defendant cannot prove actual innocence.

So if there’s no gun with a loaded legal malpractice bullet in it pointing at your head, why make the extra effort to do everything within your power to zealously defend your client?  Because they are human beings who deserve, by virtue of nothing more than the fact that they are human beings, to be treated with dignity.  Because we, as lawyers, have self-respect for what we try to do, and we know when we are giving it our all. 

This subject came up recently when a friend of mine, a commercial litigator, asked about my legal malpractice insurance, and why the cost for legal malpractice insurance is so low for criminal litigators.  He said to me, “You have nothing to lose, since you bury your mistakes.”  While it was a flip comment, it was certainly accurate.  My flip riposte, of course, was that it was because I don’t make mistakes.  One good turn deserves another.

But the hard, cold fact is that everyone makes a mistake at some point.  We’re human, and as such as subject to the frailties of humanity.  But that doesn’t mean that through care and sheer, unadulterated effort, we can minimize our potential to make a mistake. 

For most criminal defense lawyers, the fear of legal malpractice provides no motivation whatsoever to do the best job humanly possible for our clients.  It’s certainly true for me.  In its place, I have a much greater motivator than legal malpractice could ever provide:  I have to do my best possible work on every case because each one, each case and each client, reflect my respect for my own abilities, reputation and fellow human beings.  The cost for legal malpractice insurance may be cheap, but maintaining self-respect is priceless. 

Booker Changes Everything

In his  White Collar Crime column in the New York Law Journal, Elkan Abramowitz provides the results of a study done by the New York Council of Defense Lawyers as to the reversal rate of post-Booker sentences for “reasonableness”.  He writes:

        The NYCDL surveyed all cases from Jan. 1, 2006 through Nov. 16, 2006 in which a circuit court of appeals engaged in a reasonableness review of a sentence. According to the NYCDL, this data demonstrates how the “unreasonableness review” has functioned in practice, “revealing how courts of appeals have applied Booker’s standard.” Of the 1,515 cases analyzed, approximately 10 percent of these cases involved sentences above the guidelines that were appealed by the defendants. More than 95 percent of those sentences were affirmed (only 7 cases were vacated). In contrast, approximately 85 percent of the below-guidelines sentences appealed by the government were vacated as unreasonable. Of the total 1,515 cases, only 4.7 percent of these were below-guidelines sentences appealed by the government, while 9 percent were below-guidelines sentences appealed by the defendant, none of which were found to be unreasonable. Finally, the remaining 1,152 cases were within-guidelines sentences appealed by defendants. Only 16, or approximately 14 percent, of these cases were vacated. However, all, but one, were vacated for procedural reasons. Therefore, only one within-guideline sentence appealed by a defendant was found to be substantively unreasonable.

To my fellow criminal defense lawyers out there, look hard at these numbers.  It’s too late to wonder about the seizmic changes Booker will bring to the federal sentencing.  The answer is in.  While individual District Court judges may have delighted in the idea that they are once again judges at the time of sentence, empowered to consider the real issues rather than merely announce the outcome of reading the sentencing guidelines grid as if they were the best paid clerk in the courtroom, the Circuit Courts of Appeal will not allow it.  Reasonable is whatever the grid says it is, and they will no more sanction downward departures now then they would before.

The most telling statistic is the reversal rate for upward departures versus downward.  The difference in the statistics is staggering. 

Reversal Reports Redux

Judicial Reports, published by the Institute for Judicial Studies, issues the Reversal Report , one of the most fascinating and useful reads for New York lawyers.  In this weeks Reversal Report, the Appellate Division, First Department reversed Bronx Judge Richard Lee Price for suppressing evidence seized from a fellow who was coming into a “Safe Halls” building, where he kept his marijauna grow house.  The facts are available from the judicial reports link.

The aspect of this appeal that fascinates me is the “Safe Halls” building, or what is more commonly called an “Afffidavit” building.  In the Bronx, landlords give the police an affidavit authorizing them to stop and question anyone entering the building to determine if they have a reason for being there.  So a person goes into an apartment building in the Bronx to see his friend, and by virtue of the landlord having given the police permission to stop anyone entering the building, the individual is now subject to a stop, which is a seizure in constitutional language, and required to explain to the satisfaction of a police officer why he is entering the building.  Welcome to the Bronx!

Since when can one person, the landlord, give away your constitutional right to be free from governmental intrusion?  Since when do you have to explain your purpose to the satisfaction of the police?  One might argue that the landlord, as the owner of the property, has the right to control who enters his premises.  Not exactly, since the landlord has already given away that right to those nice folks who pay him monthly and are allowed to bring in anyone they want without fear that they be subject to the third degree.  If I’m going to visit my mother in the Bronx, and she pays the landlord faithfully for the right to occupy and enjoy her luxurious 9 bedroom duplex (okay, none of this is factually accurate, but it makes the point), then she has the right to have me come to see her every Sunday night for gefilte fish and broost without the landlord giving me a hassle.

And what do the police have to do with this?  These affidavit buildings give the police an unfettered excuse to harrass, annoy and play with people whenever they have a hunch that they can get a good bust out of it.  How often do they get a good bust?  No one knows, because they may stop a hundred people to get one perp.  So 99 people get hassled for no reason while only 1 perp is put under arrest.  Lousy constitutional odds.

I’ve come up against these affidavit buildings many, many times, and I’ve had great success in winning suppression based upon the unconstitutional stop.  So why did Justice Price get reversed?  Can’t say for sure.  Some would argue that it’s the new make-up of the First Department, though I got a reversal out of them recently in
People v. Huertas , I’d be hard-pressed to argue that the court is so antagonistic toward defendants that they can’t bear to let one win once in a while.  What I would really like to see is the quality of the brief filed by the lawyer for the appellant.  My bet is that another bad decision came not from the prosecution, but from the defense. 

Gulag Albany?

Breaking news, Spitzer makes deal on civil confinement.   Man, this is a tough one.  As a parent, not to mention erstwhile human being, there is little that I find more repugnant than sex offenders.  My visceral response, like so many others, is to think that few crimes are more worthy of the death penalty than child molestation.  No, I am not in favor of the death penalty for child molestors, but that is certainly the emotional response which is immediately overcome by the intellectual response, thankfully.

But we now have a deal worked out in Albany to confine civilly those individuals determined by an executive branch agency to be high risk sex offenders after the conclusion of their prison sentence.  There is no one who doubts that public safety is a worthy goal.  It is a primary obligation of government.  There is similarly no one who doubts that some of these offenders are sick people and society needs to be protected from them.  But…

One of the basic premises of our legal system is that people are only imprisoned for crimes that they have committed, not for fear that they will commit future crimes.  Second, people are only imprisoned after being found guilty by a jury via guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, and sentenced by a judge.  Third, once a person has served the sentence imposed by a judge, he has paid his debt to society and is released, not reimprisoned.

To say that this undermines the basic premise of the independence of the judicial branch of government is an understatement.  We just don’t do this in America.  We don’t lock people up forever, no matter how much they disgust us.  There is a real problem with sex offenders, but this is not the answer.  A thorough discussion of why this is horribly wrong institutionally would be worthy of a doctoral thesis.  America just doesn’t lock people up because we fear them.  Except maybe in Gitmo, but that’s another story.

Having said that, there is a bigger reason not to do this.  Child molestor rapes a child.  Thinks to himself, if I let the child live, there’s a witness to my crime.  But if I kill the child, I go to prison for life.  But if I’m convicted, I go to prison for life anyway, because once I’ve served my sentence, they are going to lock me away forever under this “civil confinement” system.  Result is a dead child.  Don’t do something that will encourage the murder of a child.  Just don’t do it.

Murder in a Martini?

Martin Heidgen, the 25-year-old who was convicted of Murder in the Second Degree for driving drunk the wrong way on the Meadowbrook Parkway in Nassau County, New York, was sentenced to 18 years to life yesterday.  Emotions run high as wrong-way driver gets prison sentence, (Newsday ) His actions resulted in a horrific crash with a limousine driving a wedding party, and resulted in the deaths in the limo driver, Stanley Rabinowitz, 59, and flower girl Katie Flynn, age 7.It is impossible to forget the image of Katie’s mother holding the severed head of her daughter afterwards. Let there be no mistake, this was a tragedy of untold proportions.

Having been convicted of murder, Heidgen was subject to a minimum sentence of 15 years to life, and a maximum of 25 years to life. Why he received 18 years will never be clear. But there is a far bigger issue of law wrapped up in this case. And a uglier problem of jurisprudence that is demonstrated here.

I recently wrote on the subject of bad cases making bad law. The Heidgen case is probably a more significant example of the phenomenon. This was a drunk driving case. Though it ended in a tragedy that dwarfs most, it is still a drunk driving case.Yet it was the first drunk driving case ever in the State of New York to be tried as a murder 2.This was a seismic shift, and one that should give every lawyer, and person, reason to pause.

The rationale for the elevated charge is clearly the horrible outcome of the conduct. Two dead, one a 7-year-old flower girl.There is no living, breathing person who can hear this and not shudder. You would have to be inhuman not to be moved by these deaths.

But the law does not vary by the horrific nature of the outcome, as much as we sometimes wish it would. The law must be dispassionate, as we know that the next case will not have such terrible consequences, but now that the dam has been broken, can be prosecuted as a murder. And murder, any way you turn it, is a different crime from manslaughter or vehicular homicide. It has an intent element, whether under the intentional murder subdivision, or the depraved indifference subdivision, as was used here. And drunk drivers, no matter how bad the result, do not have the intent necessary to commit murder. No matter how bad the result.

We must assume, for the sake of argument, that the Appellate Division, Second Department, will recognize and address this issue on appeal. Right? Perhaps, but there is a very real problem.

When I was chair of the Amicus committee for the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, I began looking for cases that involved important issues of law where the defense attorney was not (how to say this nicely) up to snuff. One critical historical problem with the law is that decisions were largely influenced by the quality of the lawyering, and if a lawyer represented the appellant who was not capable of making the point, we would frequently end up with very bad law that impacted everyone because of one lawyer’s ineffectiveness. Think about this. The ramifications are mind-boggling. And since the lawyer was chosen by the defendant (or his family), and limited by their financial resources or grasp of legal ability, the status of the law in the State of New York was dependent on how good a choice the defendant made.

Turning back to Heidgen, this case presents a fine example of the problem. Heidgen’s lawyer was way over his head on this case, but the opportunity to be the headliner in such a high profile case overwhelmed whatever good judgment he may have had. There are very few lawyers willing to give up the front page because they are not ready for prime time. A big win could make a career. Of course, a big loss could end one too, but nobody ever thinks of that when the TV lights are on them.They are SO important, if only for 15 minutes. Forget about the best interest of the client, it’s SHOWTIME!

This problems seems to be epidemic in Nassau County, New York. Because of its proximity to New York City, there seems to be a wealth of juicy cases. There is also a wealth of lawyers whose expertise runs the gamut of self-promotion to self-aggrandizement. There aren’t too many lawyers, unfortunately, who happen to be very good at practicing law. There are some, but not too many. And it appears that the ones who are solid, quality lawyers are not the ones being hired to do these sensationalistic cases. Uh oh.

This bodes ill for the rest of us. This bodes ill for the people of the State of New York, as all of us will be saddled with the outcome of this appeal. Drunk driving is one of those crimes that could happen to pretty much anyone. You may not be willing to say that out loud, but inside your head you know that this is true. And now, the same drunk driver who might make it home without incident could also be convicted of murder if there is a tiny little change in circumstances, resulting in a monumental change in outcome.

Houston, we’ve got a problem.

Bad Facts Make Bad Law

There is no one more idealistic than a criminal defendant.  The words “due process” become their mantra, believing with all their heart and soul that there really is a Santa Claus, and he’s wearing a black robe.  Unfortunately, Virginia, you are more likely to find the grinch sitting on the bench.

A recent decision by the New York Court of Appeals makes clear, yet again, that the state of the law takes a backseat when there is a horrific crime involved.  In
People v Jackson , 2007 NY Slip Op 01424, involving the rape of a minor with essentially no physical evidence to show that a rape occurred, the trial court permitted a witness, the baby sitter, to testify that the defendant had earlier raped her (what we like to call a prior uncharged crime) and while doing so said that the minor victim was lucky because if the baby sitter wasn’t there to be raped, he would have raped the minor.  Wow.  I’m sure he thought carefully before speaking.

And so, the court explained that even if it was wrong to have introduced the prior uncharged crime, it was harmless error.  Harmless error?  Where there’s no physical evidence that a crime occurred?  Harmless?  Do I need to spell this out for you?

In a concurring opinion, Justice George Bundy Smith, whose tenure on the court has come to a close, disagreed that the error would be harmless, but held that there was no error at all.  Per Judge Smith, the statement was admissible under Molineux, a fascinating case that has been the cause of more prosecutorial mischief than any other by providing a back door to introduce enormously prejudicial and untrustworthy evidence under the guise of showing “intent”, etc., and the uncharged rape was admissible as “background” so that the statement would make sense to the jury.  Well, it is certainly more important that a prior uncharged crime be introduced lest the jury hear a statement admitted as proof of future intent than the prosecution be required to actually prove that a crime occurred.  Are you getting the idea that the back door is bigger than the whole house yet?

The shocker of this decision is that Judge Pigott, a midnight appointee by Governor Pataki, dissented.  He alone held that this was sheer, unadulterated “propensity” evidence, intended to do nothing more than show what an evil human being the defendant was and that he was the sort inclined to commit this horrible rape of a minor.  Who would have bet on Judge Pigott being the dissenter?

So are the other judges a bunch of knuckleheads?  Are they disinclined to follow the law?  Are they incapable of even understanding the law?  Don’t be ridiculous.  There was a child raped.  There was no doubt in their minds who raped the child.  And the law had to bend a little to make sure that this defendant ended up where he belonged.  Judges are only human.

Beyond a Reasonable Doubt?

Another law blog, Sui Generis, , asks the reader (kinda like a game show) to define “beyond a reasonable doubt.”  One person defined it as “Not a speculative doubt but an actual doubt that a reasonable person would have based on the evidence or lack of evidence.”  In an effort to be kind, I will not go so far as to say that this definition sucks.

The sad truth is that no one has ever been able to come up with a viable definition of this phrase, probably the most important in criminal law.  Some of my clients, on the other hand, are of the belief that they completely understand what this burden of proof means, and conveniently define it in such a way as to make clear that they cannot possibly be convicted.  I remind them, when they do this, that they aren’t on the jury and don’t get a vote.  Defendants often make the mistaken assumption that they get to pick and choose their reality in a way that best serves their interests.  This presents a problem for the lawyer, who is obligated to bring them back to reality, a place that is often not particularly hospitable to them.

So what is “beyond a reasonable doubt?”  The judge doesn’t really know, though he’s unlikely to admit it.  The jurors may think they know, but they will never have the opportunity to tell us what they think it means before reaching their verdict.  And the lawyers can’t define it, but know that they need to use it to persuade the jury that it wasn’t met. 

Ultimately, it is a meaningless phrase that characterizes a big, wavy line that changes from person to person, case to case, court to court.  It is up to the lawyer to give this fuzzy line meaning, and to convince a jury that wherever that line may be, it has not been crossed.  It is the difference between a happy life with your family, and a very difficult life in prison.  The crux of the matter is that this is just another of those vague things that we create, trial after trial, as part of our arsenal of weapons in the defense of a client.  Law is not a science, but an art.  We paint the picture of doubt, and sell it to the jury as being eminently reasonable.  At the same time, we sell guilt as being wholly unreasonable.  How well we are able to sell our position defines beyond a reasonable doubt.