Author Archives: SHG

Nothing To Try

A criminal trial is a platform for the introduction of evidence by the government against an individual who pleads not guilty.  Or so one would think.  Via Grits for Breakfast, this apparently is no longer the case in Texas, where the Texas 5th Court of Appeals held that the prosecution is entitled to a trial even where the defendant has pleaded guilty to all charges against him.  From the Collins County Observer :


“[T]he Court of Criminal Appeals long ago concluded that defendants accused of felony offenses have a constitutional right to trial by jury, but do not have a constitutional protected right to waive trial by jury.” Citing an earlier case opinion that said, ““As a matter of Texas constitutional law, an accused has an absolute right to trial by jury…but neither a historical nor express right to have a felony accusation tried by the court, sitting without a jury can be found.”.

The appeals court then found that, “The trial court abused its discretion when it allowed Blackburn to enter guilty pleas and waive jury trial without the prosecuting attorney’s consent.”

This is a stunning misapprehension of law, even for Texas.  While the notion raised by the prior ruling, that the defendant’s constitutional right to a trial by jury, one expressly stated in the Constitution, compels an equivalent right by the government to demand a jury trial where the defendant has chosen to waive it, is controversial, the decision raises the ante to a level that wholly disconnects the concept from reality. 

The defendant, Robert Lee Blackburn, was charged with four felonies after biting a police officer while being arrested for possession of cocaine.  He offered to plead guilty, and after making inquiry, Visiting Judge John McCraw accepted the plea over the objection of Rolater, the Chief of the District Attorney’s Appellate Division.  Rolater accused Judge McCraw of conducting a bench trial.


The Judge responded saying, “Sir, I’m not conducting a bench trial. I’m accepting his constitutional right to enter a plea before the Court. I would submit the United States Constitution allows a defendant the right to enter a plea based on the Court’s request and to avoid needless four jury trials and have at least a couple of hundred county citizens come forward [as potential jurors, (ed.)] and waive their right to make any type of living that day and costing the county some $5,000 per trial. I don’t understand why the State is refusing to allow the defendant… to enter a plea of guilty.”

By pleading guilty to the charges against him, a defendant does not waive a jury trial, but ends the controversy.  That there is no need for any trial, including a jury trial, is a by-product of there being no controversy to try.  Trials resolve issues of fact.  Once a defendant pleads guilty, there is no issue of fact to resolve.  No issue, no trial.  It’s not a hard concept.

The Texas decision confuses the rights afforded an individual with the authority granted the state, an unfortunately common conceptual error committed by courts that are blinded by a desire to achieve an outcome.  While the defendant has the right to plead not guilty, and thereby place the burden on the state to prove his guilt, the state has no equivalent right to reject a plea to the charge and thereby for the defendant to go to trial.  The idea is absurd.  The state has no right to anything. 

Notably, this case doesn’t involve a plea bargain, but rather a plea to the charge(s).  What that means, for non-criminal defense lawyers, is that the defendant has chosen to plead guilty to the charges levied against him, without any reduction in grade, reduction in number of charges, or agreement as to sentence.  The defendant is fully exposed to whatever sentence the law allows.  He has, in a sense, given up completely.  Whether it’s a good move isn’t the point. It’s the defendant’s choice, and he has chosen to give up.

To my knowledge, this is the first instance of a court telling a defendant that he has no right to end the controversy and plead guilty to the charges, dismissing the defendant’s right to do so in favor of the prosecution’s “right” to a jury trial.  According to Bill Baumbach at the  Collins County Observer, a possible motive behind the prosecution’s shenanigans was judge-shopping, with the locals discontent with the defendant being sentenced by the visiting judge. 

The problem isn’t that the prosecution wasn’t happy with how things transpired, although one might hope that the prosecution’s zeal would be slightly inhibited by the limitations imposed by the Constitution.  The problem is that an appellate court approved.

A minor setback for the Constitution and reason?  Perhaps, but if you’re looking for comfort and a good, well-reasoned reversal from the Court of Criminal Appeals, home to Sharon “Killer” Keller, you may be disappointed. 

Taking a Breather

There are probably no less than a half dozen posts floating about my keyboard this morning, but I’m not going to write them or post them.  I’ve received a few complaints lately from my fellow blawgers that (1) I write too much for them to read and (2) I post about all the good stuff and leave nothing for them to post about.

I apologize.  I don’t mean to be a burden or to steal your thunder.  I will stand down today and give anyone who wants it a chance to catch up and, if you’re so inclined, get ahead. 

But since I’m not going to post about anything in particular today, I’ll take the opportunity to muse a bit.  One thing I don’t understand is why people who say they don’t care about something still feel compelled to offer a comment about it.  If you don’t care, why bother?  If it doesn’t matter to you, or you’re sick and tired of the subject, or it’s just not interesting, then why not move on?  Yet some people still post a comment to the effect that they don’t care, it doesn’t matter or it’s not interesting.  Why?  I doubt anyone has a gun to your head forcing you to post something. 

It seems to me that posting a comment requires a bit of effort.  There are plenty of posts out there on a wide range of topics and issues.  There must be something out there that’s interesting to you, or meaningful to you.  Post your comment there if nothing here strikes your fancy.  But why bother to exert even that minimum effort to post a comment that says nothing, or expresses your lack of interest or thought, or your having absolutely no position on the matter?

I don’t get it.  Explain?

And as long as I’m musing, and while I really didn’t plan to harp on the subject of the Slackoisie, which has gotten far more attention than I meant to give it lately. Seth Godin posted this today, entitled I don’t feel like it.



Why do you need to feel like something in order to do the work? They call it work because it’s difficult, not because it’s something you need to feel like.

Very few people wake up in the morning and feel like taking big risks or feel like digging deep for something that has eluded them. People don’t usually feel like pushing themselves harder than they’ve pushed before or having conversations that might be uncomfortable.

Maybe I’m not the only “jerk” on the internet who doesn’t think that we only have to serve our clients when it’s convenient, makes us happy or conforms to our personal sense of work/life balance?  Godin is pretty good company.  So good that he doesn’t even know that a poor schlep lawyer named Greenfield has a blawg. 

Glad I decided not to post anything today. 

A Slackoisie Litmus Test

The discussion of the Slackoisie has left some to question its definition; Are you a member of the Slackoisie?  Via Amy Alkon, who has recently invoked their wrath, comes this exchange between NYU Professor Scott Galloway, founder of e-tailer redenvelope, and a potential student.


Sent: Tuesday, February 9, 2010 7:15:11 PM GMT -08:00 US/Canada Pacific Subject: Brand Strategy Feedback

Prof. Galloway,


I would like to discuss a matter with you that bothered me. Yesterday evening I entered your 6pm Brand Strategy class approximately 1 hour late. As I entered the room, you quickly dismissed me, saying that I would need to leave and come back to the next class. After speaking with several students who are taking your class, they explained that you have a policy stating that students who arrive more than 15 minutes late will not be admitted to class.


As of yesterday evening, I was interested in three different Monday night classes that all occurred simultaneously. In order to decide which class to select, my plan for the evening was to sample all three and see which one I like most. Since I had never taken your class, I was unaware of your class policy. I was disappointed that you dismissed me from class considering (1) there is no way I could have been aware of your policy and (2) considering that it was the first day of evening classes and I arrived 1 hour late (not a few minutes), it was more probable that my tardiness was due to my desire to sample different classes rather than sheer complacency.


I have already registered for another class but I just wanted to be open and provide my opinion on the matter.


Regards,
xxxx


—
xxxx
MBA 2010 Candidate
NYU Stern School of Business
xxxx.nyu.edu
xxx-xxx-xxxx


The professor’s reply:


From: To: “xxxx” Sent: Tuesday, February 9, 2010 9:34:02 PM GMT -08:00 US/Canada Pacific Subject: Re: Brand Strategy Feedback

xxxx:


Thanks for the feedback. I, too, would like to offer some feedback.


Just so I’ve got this straight…you started in one class, left 15-20 minutes into it (stood up, walked out mid-lecture), went to another class (walked in 20 minutes late), left that class (again, presumably, in the middle of the lecture), and then came to my class. At that point (walking in an hour late) I asked you to come to the next class which “bothered” you.


Correct?


You state that, having not taken my class, it would be impossible to know our policy of not allowing people to walk in an hour late. Most risk analysis offers that in the face of substantial uncertainty, you opt for the more conservative path or hedge your bet (e.g., do not show up an hour late until you know the professor has an explicit policy for tolerating disrespectful behavior, check with the TA before class, etc.). I hope the lottery winner that is your recently crowned Monday evening Professor is teaching Judgement and Decision Making or Critical Thinking.


In addition, your logic effectively means you cannot be held accountable for any code of conduct before taking a class. For the record, we also have no stated policy against bursting into show tunes in the middle of class, urinating on desks or taking that revolutionary hair removal system for a spin. However, xxxx, there is a baseline level of decorum (i.e., manners) that we expect of grown men and women who the admissions department have deemed tomorrow’s business leaders.


xxxx, let me be more serious for a moment. I do not know you, will not know you and have no real affinity or animosity for you. You are an anonymous student who is now regretting the send button on his laptop. It’s with this context I hope you register pause…REAL pause xxxx and take to heart what I am about to tell you:


xxxx, get your shit together.


Getting a good job, working long hours, keeping your skills relevant, navigating the politics of an organization, finding a live/work balance…these are all really hard, xxxx. In contrast, respecting institutions, having manners, demonstrating a level of humility…these are all (relatively) easy. Get the easy stuff right xxxx. In and of themselves they will not make you successful. However, not possessing them will hold you back and you will not achieve your potential which, by virtue of you being admitted to Stern, you must have in spades. It’s not too late xxxx…


Again, thanks for the feedback.


Professor Galloway


Who’s right? 

The Vagaries of Cultural Evil

Whenever one has his fill of optimism and hopefulness for mankind, just stop by Crime & Consequences for good, hard slap in the face.  Bill Otis does it again in his preview of the argument over honest services fraud,  18 USC 1346, as the Supremes prepare to hear the case of former Enron CEO, Jeffrey Skilling, this week.

It’s not that anyone speaks well of Skilling, and (as Otis notes) his conviction for honest services fraud is but one of the crimes of which he stands convicted, meaning that he’s unlikely to walk free regardless of the outcome of this case. But the Supremes have already made it abundantly clear, during the arguments in Conrad Black’s and Bruce Wehyrauch’s cases that the statute is so vague as to give no clue what’s conduct falls within its purview. 

Otis proclaims that the big issue isn’t legal, but cultural. We are a culture of liars, cheaters, fraudsters and deceivers.


The subtext of the Court’s questioning in Black and Wehyrauch was that people can’t really know when they’re trying to pull a fast one that could get them in trouble with the law.  But evidence in those cases and even more so in this one proves otherwise.  Indeed, it illustrates the truth the government’s brief seems unwilling to speak, namely, that people know full well when they’re cheating.  Employees by the million may well spend worktime messaging on Facebook or looking at the porn site or the betting odds. 

But that such behavior is widespread scarcely shows, or even suggests, that it’s honest or that anyone thinks it’s honest.   It is precisely because it’s known to be dishonest that the instantaneous mouseclick when the boss shows up at the door has become an American artform.  Thus the Court’s real objection seems to be, not that the statute is too broad for people to know what is forbidden, but that the culture has come largely to accept this “slightly forbidden” behavior, and that a statute making it potentially a federal felony is not so much too vague as it is too sweeping and too harsh, given what in today’s world is accepted as grounds for getting docked a pay’s pay, or at worst getting fired, but by no means going to federal prison.

His first point, that we have lowered the bar of integrity, is hard to dispute.  But do we really know it to be dishonest?  Otis believes so, and that we are either lying to ourselves or to the government as we engage in ” ‘slightly forbidden’ behavior,” knowing that we are cheating but unprepared to accept that it’s wrong enough to warrant serious sanction.

Otis, on the other hand, rejects our cultural excuses.  Cheating is cheating, and in his eyes, we all know it and deserve whatever we get.  Unfortunately, he fears our weak Supreme Court to be a part of this diseased culture of cheaters.


That the Court is inclined to accept the culture of which it is a part is not exactly surprising.  But at a deeper level, it’s ominous.  That’s because the culture the Court is accepting is a culture of deceit.  We are drowning in slick talk and slick dealing.   It’s everywhere from “teaser” rates to liar loans to the razzle-dazzle fine print in your frequent flier statement, your car repair warranty and your credit card bill.  Your e-mail is bulging with offers ranging from half-truth come-on’s to outright swindles.  You can’t watch TV for 20 minutes without hearing some miraculous offer to “fix” your credit, all followed up by some fellow who races through the real terms in a voice so fast and low no human ear could understand it. 

For Otis, it’s the “broken windows” theory of honesty.  He, as is clear, has appointed himself as the arbiter of honesty, as well as the seer of our cultural intent.  He knows what evil lurks in our hearts, and as you click on Youtube at work, he knows of the criminal lust in your heart.


The law is a moral teacher, and for good or ill the Supreme Court, its Constitutional limitations notwithstanding, has become our National Council of Elders.  The Court probably knows that our society could use a lesson in the need for telling the truth.   But even the most powerful instrument of law has little chance of rescuing respect for honesty from a culture that has so thoroughly marginalized it.  The country most in need of an enforceable requirement for honest dealing in everyday life is the country least likely to achieve one.  
Lie, cheat and steal.  When Harvey Silverglate wrote  three felonies a day, he wasn’t just trying to scare us, but to warn us.  That it’s too much even for the Supreme Court to have laws that leave it up to the sour-faced school marms like Bill Otis to provide our moral guidance upon pain of federal imprisonment says a lot. 

Honesty is a cultural problem, and we have become too tolerant of deception, excused as mere puffery in our quest to make a quick buck or have an easy life.  But the solution to banal dishonesty isn’t to criminalize our every dubious move and send everyone to prison.  And while we would do better with a culture that admires, even rewards, integrity, it’s hardly so bad that we’re about to fall into the abyss. 

It may bother Bill Otis far more that someone is “getting away with something” in some cubicle somewhere than that we have a vague law that presumes that we all know when we are cheating, and hence that we deserve whatever we get.  Thankfully, it doesn’t appear that the Supreme Court is ready to hand the government a statute that would enable the prosecution and imprisonment of essentially anyone for failure to live up to Bill Otis’ standards. 

Of course, Congress did pass it, and the President did sign it, so don’t think that Bill Otis’ nasty vision of Americans as criminals all can’t happen again. 

Downfall Meets Law Review

Sorry.  Have no choice. Too funny,  This one is for all the lawprofs out there. You are not alone.



Best line: “It’s OK. He won’t really go back to private practice.” 
Second best line: “Or I could start my own blog.”

H/T Dan Markel at PrawfsBlawg

Can You Hear Me Now? (Plus Bonus Form!)

With barely an opportunity to catch our breaths following the issuance of the Maryland v. Shatzer decision, the 14 days out of thin air shelf life for invocation of the right to counsel, another big Miranda case looms on the horizon.  Oral argument in Berghuis v. Thompkins comes this Monday.

Berkeley Lawprof Chuck Weisselberg wrote a great assessment of Berghuis v. Thompkins for HuffPo.

In the Michigan case, Berghuis v. Thompkins, officers gave Van Chester Thompkins the Miranda warnings. But instead of asking if he would give up his rights and speak, police just began interrogating. Thompkins kept largely silent for close to three hours while officers tried different tactics to get him to talk. He eventually succumbed and made a statement. A federal court threw out the statement, finding that Thompkins did not waive his rights. Michigan has appealed.

 

This is kinda the “don’t ask, don’t tell,” version of Miranda.  The way it was intended to play out, the officer would pause after reading each line off his laminated Miranda card and ask, “do you understand?”  The suspect responds yes, and the officer then, at the end, asks if the suspect wishes to make a statement or if he wants to speak with the police.  Of course, this is the sanitized version, as would be offered in testimony.  It doesn’t include the threats and psychological manipulation designed to thwart free will that is rarely mentioned during the officer’s direct testimony, and is routinely and sincerely denied on cross.

One interesting twist in this case, as Chuck notes, is that the Obama Justice Department had no necessary role in the case, yet made the choice to insert itself on the side of Michigan.

The US Solicitor General is joining Michigan in aggressively attacking Miranda. In 1994, the Court held that if suspects initially waive their rights and agree to talk–but later change their mind and want to see a lawyer–they must say so clearly and affirmatively. The Solicitor General now wants to extend this ruling to the very start of interrogation. Under this approach, there would be no “time out” prior to interrogation for suspects to decide whether to speak. Instead of requiring police to obtain a waiver, suspects would have to stop an interrogation that has already begun. Ironically, people would have to speak in order to claim their right to remain silent.

This position appears more hostile to Miranda than any taken in the Supreme Court by previous Democratic Administrations.

As a fan of the proposition that suspects exercise their right to remain silent, I cannot help but appreciate that this case arises during an administration of hope and change.  Can you imagine how much more awful the Solicitor General’s position would be under a conservative regime.  I can’t.

After sharing a heartfelt laugh over the fact that clients, no matter how many times lawyers tell them, just can’t manage to say the magic words (and Ken at Popehat offers his own variation on this theme, Rule 1: Just Shut Up), Chuck sent over a brilliant form to provide our clients to assist them in this perpetually problematic task.  It’s called the Assertion of Rights form.

ASSERTION OF RIGHTS FORM
TO ALL LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS, AGENTS AND GOVERNMENT PERSONNEL:

I, ________________________________________, am represented by attorney ______________________________________.I hereby assert my right to remain silent.I want to see my lawyer now.I do not wish to answer any questions.

Date:_______________       Signature:_____________________________
ALL LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS, AGENTS AND GOVERNMENT PERSONNEL SHOULD SIGN THE ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF ASSERTION OF RIGHTS, BELOW:

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF ASSERTION OF RIGHTS

            I acknowledge that I have read and understood this Assertion of Rights form, and that _________________________________ wishes to consult with his attorney and does not wish to answer any questions.

Date:_______________        Signature:_____________________________

Agency:_____________        Name (print):__________________________

Chuck tells me that he borrowed the idea for this form from another lawyer, Jodie English he believes, and that she told him that “was once mailed back to her by an officer, ripped up into tiny pieces.”  How much better could it get?  If you don’t love this form, you should immediately start searching for a job practicing transactional law.  And if you do, think about what a wonderful Christmas gift this would make for your clients, with names already filled in so that they can’t screw it up.  Well, at least the names part, anyway.

All of this Miranda squabbling, with the Supremes doing everything in their power to water down, undermine, negate the rule so that they can pretend to maintain its prophylactic purposes while turning it into a minefield for the unwary, one point persists and resolves every issue that has or will arise from each new tweak:  Invoke your right to remain silent and your right to counsel.  Invoke it each and every time a cop tries to question you, whether a few hours later or 14 days later.

Or, if the word “invoke” confuses you, the simpler version will suffice.  Just shut up.

A Lawyer’s Misery For Sale on Craigslist

It’s not the first time. In 2008, David Wold offered his law degree from DePaul for sale on eBay.  Now, another degree, school unknown but for it being “elitist”, is offered on Craigslist for the price of outstanding student loans, $59,250.

The ad shows all the signs of an disgruntled buyer.

After several years of practicing law I have come to the conclusion that my law degree is useless and I don’t want to be a lawyer anymore. Though I spent over $100,000 on it I am willing to sell it for the bargain basement price of $59,250, which is the current value of my remaining student loan balance.

This priceless collectible will permit you to be surrounded by hobby-less assholes whose entire life is dictated by billing by the hour and being anal dickheads. Additionally, this piece of paper has the amazing ability to keep you from doing what you really want to do in life, all in the name of purported prestige and financial success. Finally, girls in the Marina will swoon with retarded thoughts of sugar daddy when they hear you went to XXX prestigious law school and are a lawyer.

Act now as supplies are limited and this crap takes three years to make. DISCLAIMER: this piece of shit isn’t even written in English. It’s in Latin or something, but I have the translation. It says “Haha. We took your tuition money bitch, now suck it. Sincerely, President of the University”

Added Bonus: It’s from one of those elitist BS institutions that accept people like George W. Bush cause their daddy donated $20 million i.e. Cornell, Penn, Harvard, Yale, Columbia, Georgetown, Duke, Tijuana Tech, etc. Instead of donating $20 million you can have it for the low low price of $59,250 or best offer.

This is actually a serious post. I will really sell this piece of shit.


No one, of course, will buy the diploma.  It’s just a piece of paper with someone else’s name on it.  It won’t impress the “girls in the Marina.”   Some will see this as another manifesto of a loser, which, of course, it is.  But it’s more a warning to the unwary, to the law schools and to the mommies and daddies who push their little darlings into the law in the hope that they will become more than they were.

The seller blames the law. His anger is understandable, but misdirected.  He should never have gone to law school, never have become a lawyer.  Being a lawyer is hard work.  Becoming a lawyer doesn’t guarantee anyone wealth and prestige.  He made a very expensive mistake, and now finds himself miserable. 

The seller blames the law schools.  He’s closer to the target now.  Law schools sell the dream, the image that fills their high priced seats with young men and women, that pays for over-priced law professors to indulge their fantasies of writing useless articles and treatises for their own self-aggrandizement.  The take in far more students than can possibly find a viable future in the law, knowing full well that society can’t absorb them all, and couldn’t care less.  They fudge the employment statistics to make the cost appear worth it.  They lie to students, and then to themselves to rationalize their deception.

The seller of this diploma, who I will call Max since he’s neglected to include his name in the Craigslist ad, wants to make a point that he was scammed.  Many will argue that if Max is anywhere near as bright and worthy as he thinks, he should have known what he was getting into.  He should have understood what it meant to be a lawyer.  He should have realized that he was being lied to. 

Whether he should have is one issue; that those entering law school, applying for huge loans, sitting eagerly in class hoping to suck in enough information to make law review and assure themselves of a wonderful life, rarely see their future clearly is a truism.  Even with the stories, the posts, the complaints, the hatred that spews from disaffected young lawyers, they believe that their life will be different, wonderful.  Right or wrong, we know this is how they think.  And if they didn’t, half the seats in the ever-increasing number of law schools would be empty. 

Max is wrong.  His anger is misdirected.  The law is a wonderful profession for those who desire to be lawyers.  For those who enter the law because they want wealth, prestige and work/life balance, it will be a misery. 

Even as Max’s ad runs its course, the American Association of Law Schools is preparing for its 2011 conference by seeking ways to deal with the problem.  It’s put out a call for proposals:




AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF LAW SCHOOLS – 2011 Conference>>

A Joint Program of the Sections on Balance in Legal Education and Academic Support>>

Co-Sponsored by the Section on Student Services>>

>  >

Theme:    “Beyond Humanizing:  Can – and Should – Law Schools Strive to Graduate Happy Students?”>>

>  >

Students often enter law school with goals of helping others, improving peoples’ lives, and making the world a better place.  By the time they graduate, however, other considerations have supplanted students’ pro-social inclinations.  Their aspirations succumb to more extrinsic values, such as prestige and money, and are often faced with the realities of time pressure and the dehumanizing effects of legal education.  Despite the prestige associated with being an attorney, the profession is not ranked in the top ten for job satisfaction or happiness.  In fact, one recent study revealed that a majority of practitioners would not recommend law to a young person.

Nothing shows more clearly how law schools and academics are trying to hide from their massive failings, their deliberate lies, than this charade.  All those very smart people denying that the problem is their sucking in young people who have no business in the law, wholly lacking an understanding of what lawyers do, and selling a sham future at an absurdly inflated price.  Instead, they pretend that it’s all about changing the profession to make students who have no business being in law school “happy”.  Throw them a party.  Give them a trophy.  As long as we keep the seats filled and the tuition checks flowing, so we can spend our time writing articles that will enhance our personal prestige.

Nothing here reflects the slightest recognition of the responsibility of law schools to vet those who apply for people who want to be lawyers.  The fictional paradigm, about those entering with lofty goals and leaving with cynicism, allows them to keep milking the cash cow while shifting the blame elsewhere.

Stop lying to yourselves.  Stop lying to potential law students.  The law is not an easy life, nor clear path to a happy future.  It’s hard work, and not everybody is cut out for it.  The law cannot be reinvented for the benefit of lawyer happiness; We have a job to do and if the purpose of that job ceases to be service to the client so that we can focus on our own happiness, the law ceases to have a reason to exist. 

If you want Max to be happy, don’t throw him an ice cream party or give him a red balloon.  Give him his money back and let him find an occupation for which he is better suited.  Change your law porn to show hard working, financially struggling young lawyers, who can’t get a date with the girls at the Marina, but won’t have time for it even if they could.  Show them fighting for people whose own miserable lives depend on the lawyer doing his job well in a system that satisfies ego and blood lust better than reason, where every once in a while the right result happens.  And if they still want to go to law school, then you’ve got the right person.

Unfortunately, Max is typical of his generation, only brilliant after the fact, and then only when it comes to pointing the finger of blame away from himself.  But narcissism and entitlement are the hallmarks of today’s law students, and that’s not going to change for a while.  At least the Slackoisie can console themselves by knowing that they aren’t totally at fault for being blind pigeons in this scam.  They have good reason to blame law schools and professors. 

The Disappeared: Slackoisie

It was never clear to me how it got there, but somehow it did.  The Urban Dictionary included a definition for a word created by Dan Hull, and one of my favorites:  Slackoisie.

It’s gone.  For reasons that are none of your business, I went to find it yesterday, and it wasn’t there.  Like it never happened.

The cache of the Urban Dictionary remains, and so it lives on in the secret ether for those who know where to look, but for anyone who might cruise the Urban Dictionary in search of a definition, they will come up empty.  Here’s what it used to say:











Slackoisie


(1) Attorney 1, “OMG, like I got a job at (insert name of any law firm) and they expect me to work like a hundred hours a week. I did not go to (insert name of law school) to work all the time.”

Attorney 2, “Stop being such a slackoisie, and appreciate the opportunity you have! There are tons of people graduating law school who would love to have a job doing (insert type of law practiced at Attorney 1’s law firm).”

(2) Anyone who posts on “JD Jive” or “JD Underground”;

or

(3) Those attorneys doing document review work who want to make money, but do not want to work the long hours at low pay found at most small firms. Having a job and making money are more important to a slackoisie than serving clients interests or professional development.
I was never thrilled by the definition, as it failed to attribute its creation to Hull, and called this place the “simplejustice” blog.  It was also a substantially underinclusive definition, as it was never meant to be limited to lawyers, but to a generation of entitled narcissists.  I would have changed it, if I could figure out how, to note that Hull invented it, though I popularized it.  I take credit for that.  I never could figure out how to edit the definition.

But now it’s gone.  Click on it and you’re informed that the word “isn’t defined yet,” with a link to input it again. 

I’m really bummed that it’s gone.  It’s a great word.  It’s a spectacular word.  It makes it’s point, and it’s made the round.  People use the word, besides me and Hull.  It’s working its way into the vernacular.  And it pisses off the Slackoisie to no end, which means that it’s serving its purpose.  What more could one want from a word?

I thought about re-inputting it into the Urban Dictionary, this time with proper attribution, some shameless self-credit, and a more comprehensive definition with better examples.  But it felt wrong.  Being responsible for its popularity, it’s too unseemly for me to promote the legitimacy of Slackoisie as a word. Yes, I know that the Urban Dictionary isn’t Funk & Wagnalls, but it’s better than nothing.  I started the process, then stopped.  If the word is for real, someone else should do it.  Some one else should want to do it.  Some one else did it before.

But why did the Urban Dictionary delete it?  It was there a long time, and then it was gone.  Who killed it?  Why?

Part of my problem, so you know, is that this was a flashback to Wikipedia.  There was a time when I was included in Wikipedia, under trial lawyers, with a short biography.  I don’t know how it got there either, but I was kinda proud that somebody thought enough of me to put it in there.  And then, one day, it was gone.  No clue why, but it was gone.  It’s like I was there, and then I was gone. That hurts.

Wikipedia has an entry for Above the Law.  Simple Justice doesn’t.  Like it never happened.

Bad Boy Lists

Lists.  We love ’em.  No, I mean everybody loves a list.  See a list for the top 10 colors for rocks and you’ll read it. And that’s why it’s worth noting that two lists have come out this week about lawyers.  Since they’re lists, everybody will want to take a look.

The first was put out by American Express, via their small business “Open” wing.  It’s called 16 Things Your Lawyer Won’t Tell You, and it’s all about nasty little lawyer tricks to do less work, get more money, and burn the client.  It’s like a beginners course in how to be a social media consultant, full of obvious ways to put your pocketbook ahead of your integrity.  It starts with the requisite caveat:


While most lawyers are honest professionals, the legal industry does have its share of rotten apples. From overbilling to downright incompetence, our recent interviews with legal experts revealed 16 dirty secrets bad attorneys don’t want you to know.

Nobody cares about the caveat.  It’s not part of the list.  It’s all about the list, and the list is pretty damning.  And pretty good.  And lawyers hate it.  The problem is that lawyers hate the list because it hurts, it exposes tricks that are used.  Maybe not be you or me, but by someone we know. 

The problem is that it makes all lawyers look bad, like thieves stealing from clients in the night.  Yet, our solution isn’t to stop lawyers from engaging in impropriety, but get angry about the list.  The list isn’t the problem.  The problem is that it’s too true.  The problem is that lawyers who use these “dirty little secrets” embarrass the other 1% of honest lawyers (I apologize, but I couldn’t resist the joke).  The problem is that lawyers will shake their head, tsk a few times and sneer.  What you won’t do it call out the lawyer who does wrong.  You won’t do anything to stop it.  You won’t be the mean guy and expose yourself to potential wrath. 

The second list comes via VentureHacks, and is entitled Top 10 Reasons Why Entrepreneurs Hate Lawyers.  Though we may not be part of the start-up, venture capital scene, the complaints apply with full force to all lawyers.  And if you’ve hung around with lawyers for more than about 26 seconds, you know them to be true.  Sure, everyone has their rationale for why they neglect their clients and make every wonderful deal a misery, but this is what it looks like from the other side.  And frankly, with a few minor tweaks, it looks pretty much the same to criminal defendants as well.

A lot of lawyers hate these lists. They hate lawyer jokes too.  And they don’t think much of lawyers who expose the wrongs that lawyers do.  It’s undignified.  It demeans the profession.  It’s embarrassing.  These lawyers are the enablers, if not the perpetrators.  For more than 25 years, I’ve listened to lawyers pontificate about the glory of the profession to obfuscate what’s wrong with it.  It’s all about the appearance of impropriety, as if concealing and denying what lawyers do wrong will make it better.  It hasn’t worked.  It won’t work.  It improves nothing.

One of the most cutting criticisms of lawyers is that, when push comes to shove, we circle the wagons and deny that anybody would engage in the dirty tricks on the list or excuse the failure to respect our clients.  Who do you think you’re kidding?  It’s not enough for a lawyer to truthfully say that he doesn’t do these things.  If we know of others who do and stand mute, we are complicit in their conduct.

Many have been critical of me for breaking the blue pinstripe wall of silence.  Lawyers who have been the “victims” of my criticism curse me.  I am persona non grata to the throng of platitude pontificators, because I won’t embrace the appearance of dignity and ignore the scheming below the surface.  So I’m the outcast. 

What I am not is an enabler, denier, concealer or apologist.  If you despise me for breaking the code of silence, so be it.  Call me a traitor, but the lists are too true to be ignored.

H/T Tannebaum and Hull

Explaining Away The DNA

Johnny Cochran will always be remembered for his line in defense of O.J. Simpson, following the infamous glove demonstration.  If it doesn’t fit, you must acquit.  While it worked for a glove, will it work for DNA?  Not according to Douglas County, Colorado, District Attorney Carol Chambers.

Via Radley Balko, from the Denver Post :

Residents were alarmed last summer by a rash of thefts, trespasses and burglaries in Stonegate, a neighborhood in Douglas County.  Fear turned to panic in July after an intruder reportedly climbed into a second- story window and groped an 8-year-old girl in her bed.

A sicko was on the loose and pressure was on to catch him.

A week later, Sheriff David Weaver announced that his office had made an arrest.

Nobody wants a “sicko” on the loose, and the pressure on the police to “do something about it” can be enormous.  Law enforcement hates to disappoint when the focus is on them.  It makes them look so, well, incompetent.  And so they don’t.

Sheriff David Weaver must have been relieved to tell the locals that they had the “sicko”, a thin 19 year old redhead named Tyler Sanchez.  So what if he looked nothing like the description of the sicko.  So what if he was cognitively impaired.  He confessed, after a 17 hour interrogation, repeating back only the information that was fed him by the police.  Case solved.

Except for one sticky detail.  The 8 year old girl who was molested had semen on her underwear.  Semen has DNA.  The DNA  came from two men, and matched the girl’s father and another unknown male.  What it failed to match is Sanchez.  It didn’t fit.

The Sheriff, however, was not to be denied.  After all, this was the next step in a escalating pattern of criminal conduct for Sanchez.