It figures that the Supremes would finally actually decide a case, and provide a bright line test, when it serves to burn the defendant. But the decision by Justice Antonin Scalia, the originalist philosopher, makes the line as bright as can be:
Held: Because Shatzer experienced a break in Miranda custody lasting more than two weeks between the first and second attempts at interrogation, Edwards does not mandate suppression of his 2006 statements.
And how did the Justices know that 14 days would be about right? Based on their extensive experience being arrested, perhaps? Presumably not. But no matter. Fourteen days seemed about right, and so the 14-day rule became the law.
As Orin notes, the utility of arriving at a hard and fast rule is clear, given that police in the field (or “on the fly,” as Orin calls it, just in case they had no opportunity to think about their actions in advance of a custodial interrogation) can’t be expected to comport with some complicated balancing act, the new professionalism notwithstanding, is clear. It’s hard to disagree with the need to a clear mandate, even though the Constitution doesn’t include an expiration date on rights. Seriously, if the invocation of rights lasted forever, we would have the anomalous situation of police never being able to coerce confessions. How would we ever convict anyone?
Orin also offers an affirmative reason for Justice Scalia’s opinion containing the 14 day rule, and it’s pretty interesting as well. As he notes, Scalia hates Miranda, it being a wholly judge-made rule, which he called a “prophylaxis built upon prophylaxis, producing a veritable fairyland castle of imagined constitutional restriction upon law enforcement.” So when this opportunity arose to place an arbitrary limit on the duration of the invocation of Miranda rights, Scalia was there.
But if you can’t beat ‘em, join ‘em. Or at least join ‘em if that means you get to write the opinion that substantially limits the effect of the Edwards rule. And if you’re going to write an opinion that you see as merely “prophylactic,” presumably you’re not bound by your usual approach to constitutional interpretation. With apologies to Chief Justice Marshall, it is not a Constitution you are expounding. So explicitly policy-based rulemaking becomes more understandable, even if it’s jarring coming from Justice Scalia.On the bright side of this bright line test, at least we can forewarn defendants that their invocation of right to counsel has a shelf-life of 14 days. After that, rinse and repeat. Or, if they prefer not to keep an eye on the calendar, they can always just follow the prime directive. Say the magic words (I want to speak with my lawyer) and then shut up.

